SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 5
Download to read offline
1


Information to retrieve the whole reference     What I understood I need to do for thinking/acting(?)          My             My               Temporary answers             Answers taken from
                                                                   ethnographically                      comments        questions


                                              Learn from the people (insiders) what counts as cultural
                                              knowledge (insider meaning)


                                              Ethnographers construct systems to learn what members Members             How        the Creating      data    from     the
                                              of particular groups need to know, understand, produce of groups ethnographe perspective of the different types
                                              and predict as they participate in events of everyday life and            rs can honor or members of the community
                                              within a group.                                            communiti      these
                                                                                                         es do not differences?
                                                                                                         hold roles
                                                                                                         or points of
                                                                                                         views
                                                                                                         evenly.
                                              In education, the key questions:                                          How        the This is a developing process in
                                                       What is happening here?                                         analyst         which the ethnographer is slowly
                                                       What is being accomplished, by and with whom,                   bounds the grasping meaning from the
                                                        how, in what ways, when and where, under what                   events      to community while acknowledging
                                                        conditions, for what purposes, drawing on what                  learn from?     what could be an interesting focus
                                                        historical or current knowledge and resources                                   of analysis, bearing in mind that
                                                        (e.g. artifacts, meanings, tools), with what                                    the goal is to learn from the
                                                        outcomes or consequences for individuals and                                    people (insiders) what counts as
                                                        the group?                                                                      cultural    knowledge     (insider
                                                       To what do individual members of sustaining                                     meaning).
                                                        groups have access, orient and hold each other
2


    accountable?
   What makes someone an insider or outsider of
    particular groups (e.g. class, group within a
    class, peer group or social network)?
   What counts as disciplinary knowledge (i.e.
    mathematics, science, social science or art) in
    this particular group or classroom?
   What roles and relationships, norms and
    expectations, and rights and obligations are
    constructed by and afforded members?
   How does previously constructed cultural
    knowledge support or constrain participation
    in, or create frame clashes with, local knowledge
    being constructed in a particular event (or social
    group)?
   How do decisions beyond the group support
    and/or constrain ways of knowing, being and
    doing afforded members?
3


Information to retrieve the whole reference   What I understood I need to do for thinking/acting(?)     My         My questions            Temporary answers        Answers taken from
                                                                ethnographically                      comments


                                                                                                                                       Ethnographers can redefine
                                                                                                                                       their questions depending
                                                                                                                                       on what they are learning
                                                                                                                                       during the fieldwork




                                                                                                                 Should I define
                                                                                                                 explicitly a theory
                                                                                                                 of culture before
                                                                                                                 starting       my
                                                                                                                 ethnographic
                                                                                                                 study?
4


Information to retrieve the whole reference     What I understood I need to do for thinking/acting(?)      My            My         Temporary answers   Answers taken from
                                                                  ethnographically                       comments    questions


                                                                                                                    What
                                                                                                                    counts     as
                                                                                                                    event? And
                                                                                                                    how many
                                                                                                                    “events”
                                                                                                                    could count
                                                                                                                    as
                                                                                                                    ethnograph
                                                                                                                    y?




                                              Types of questions that I should bear in mind while I am
                                              learning from a community:
                                                   -    What is ordinary and predictable?
                                                   -    What is not ordinary and problematic?
5


Information to retrieve the whole reference   What I understood I need to do for thinking/acting(?)           My comments                 My questions   Temporary   Answers taken from
                                                                ethnographically                                                                          answers




                                                                                                      Ethnography in education is a
                                                                                                      field allowing me to doubt
                                                                                                      upon        common         senses
                                                                                                      regarding              learning,
                                                                                                      knowledge,      success,     and
                                                                                                      effectiveness     in       formal
                                                                                                      educational settings. This
                                                                                                      means, I could problematize
                                                                                                      education. The question I
                                                                                                      should be always bear in
                                                                                                      mind is WHAT COUNTS
                                                                                                      AS…?

More Related Content

What's hot

Recognition introduction-dec-2010
Recognition introduction-dec-2010Recognition introduction-dec-2010
Recognition introduction-dec-2010awarenessproject
 
Narrative presentation - how we construct our meaning and consciousness
Narrative presentation - how we construct our meaning and consciousnessNarrative presentation - how we construct our meaning and consciousness
Narrative presentation - how we construct our meaning and consciousnessMurray Hunter
 
Experience based Personal Multimedia Content Management System
Experience based Personal Multimedia Content Management SystemExperience based Personal Multimedia Content Management System
Experience based Personal Multimedia Content Management SystemAdrian Hornsby
 
Affective Subject Interacting in the ROODA Virtual Learning Environment
Affective Subject Interacting in the ROODA Virtual Learning EnvironmentAffective Subject Interacting in the ROODA Virtual Learning Environment
Affective Subject Interacting in the ROODA Virtual Learning Environmentpbehar
 
A Powerful Learning Process
A Powerful Learning ProcessA Powerful Learning Process
A Powerful Learning ProcessSarah Martin
 
MDTV Winter Symposium Introduction
MDTV Winter Symposium IntroductionMDTV Winter Symposium Introduction
MDTV Winter Symposium Introductionpeterworthy
 
AAAI08 tutorial: visual object recognition
AAAI08 tutorial: visual object recognitionAAAI08 tutorial: visual object recognition
AAAI08 tutorial: visual object recognitionzukun
 

What's hot (9)

An innovators skills
An innovators skillsAn innovators skills
An innovators skills
 
Recognition introduction-dec-2010
Recognition introduction-dec-2010Recognition introduction-dec-2010
Recognition introduction-dec-2010
 
Narrative presentation - how we construct our meaning and consciousness
Narrative presentation - how we construct our meaning and consciousnessNarrative presentation - how we construct our meaning and consciousness
Narrative presentation - how we construct our meaning and consciousness
 
Experience based Personal Multimedia Content Management System
Experience based Personal Multimedia Content Management SystemExperience based Personal Multimedia Content Management System
Experience based Personal Multimedia Content Management System
 
Affective Subject Interacting in the ROODA Virtual Learning Environment
Affective Subject Interacting in the ROODA Virtual Learning EnvironmentAffective Subject Interacting in the ROODA Virtual Learning Environment
Affective Subject Interacting in the ROODA Virtual Learning Environment
 
A Powerful Learning Process
A Powerful Learning ProcessA Powerful Learning Process
A Powerful Learning Process
 
MDTV Winter Symposium Introduction
MDTV Winter Symposium IntroductionMDTV Winter Symposium Introduction
MDTV Winter Symposium Introduction
 
AAAI08 tutorial: visual object recognition
AAAI08 tutorial: visual object recognitionAAAI08 tutorial: visual object recognition
AAAI08 tutorial: visual object recognition
 
Km
KmKm
Km
 

Viewers also liked

Leo club general meeting jan 22
Leo club general meeting jan 22Leo club general meeting jan 22
Leo club general meeting jan 22byrnecreekleoclub
 
Eden hazard 17, Fotos de su Temporada
Eden hazard 17, Fotos de su TemporadaEden hazard 17, Fotos de su Temporada
Eden hazard 17, Fotos de su TemporadaElJoako
 
Holistic Health Examination Dr Shriniwas Kashalikar
Holistic  Health  Examination  Dr  Shriniwas  KashalikarHolistic  Health  Examination  Dr  Shriniwas  Kashalikar
Holistic Health Examination Dr Shriniwas Kashalikarrajkiran81
 
Dorking Community Orchard
Dorking Community OrchardDorking Community Orchard
Dorking Community Orchardguestc63767
 
Navsarni Bulletin - November 2013
Navsarni Bulletin - November 2013Navsarni Bulletin - November 2013
Navsarni Bulletin - November 2013sindhudurgdiocese
 
Alba Taboada Dels telers als canons
Alba Taboada Dels telers als canonsAlba Taboada Dels telers als canons
Alba Taboada Dels telers als canonsllgenesca
 
Music magazine analysis
Music magazine analysisMusic magazine analysis
Music magazine analysisabdul_8282
 
Perlindungan Lingkungan
Perlindungan LingkunganPerlindungan Lingkungan
Perlindungan Lingkunganthu conghua
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Leo club general meeting jan 22
Leo club general meeting jan 22Leo club general meeting jan 22
Leo club general meeting jan 22
 
Van Winkle 1
Van Winkle 1Van Winkle 1
Van Winkle 1
 
Eden hazard 17, Fotos de su Temporada
Eden hazard 17, Fotos de su TemporadaEden hazard 17, Fotos de su Temporada
Eden hazard 17, Fotos de su Temporada
 
Outstanding AfL
Outstanding AfL Outstanding AfL
Outstanding AfL
 
10 Words To Spell Right
10 Words To Spell Right10 Words To Spell Right
10 Words To Spell Right
 
Ap ch10
Ap ch10Ap ch10
Ap ch10
 
Holistic Health Examination Dr Shriniwas Kashalikar
Holistic  Health  Examination  Dr  Shriniwas  KashalikarHolistic  Health  Examination  Dr  Shriniwas  Kashalikar
Holistic Health Examination Dr Shriniwas Kashalikar
 
Lenguas integradas
Lenguas integradasLenguas integradas
Lenguas integradas
 
Español para el blog
Español para el blogEspañol para el blog
Español para el blog
 
Fall leaves
Fall leavesFall leaves
Fall leaves
 
Dorking Community Orchard
Dorking Community OrchardDorking Community Orchard
Dorking Community Orchard
 
Navsarni Bulletin - November 2013
Navsarni Bulletin - November 2013Navsarni Bulletin - November 2013
Navsarni Bulletin - November 2013
 
Alba Taboada Dels telers als canons
Alba Taboada Dels telers als canonsAlba Taboada Dels telers als canons
Alba Taboada Dels telers als canons
 
Neveléstörténet
NeveléstörténetNeveléstörténet
Neveléstörténet
 
Music magazine analysis
Music magazine analysisMusic magazine analysis
Music magazine analysis
 
Sept 27 meeting_powerpoint
Sept 27 meeting_powerpointSept 27 meeting_powerpoint
Sept 27 meeting_powerpoint
 
CURSO DE ATUALIDADES INICIO
CURSO DE ATUALIDADES INICIOCURSO DE ATUALIDADES INICIO
CURSO DE ATUALIDADES INICIO
 
Etyarth 3
Etyarth 3Etyarth 3
Etyarth 3
 
Bashgram part7
Bashgram part7Bashgram part7
Bashgram part7
 
Perlindungan Lingkungan
Perlindungan LingkunganPerlindungan Lingkungan
Perlindungan Lingkungan
 

Similar to Step back to readings

Ask Questions - Full Documentation
Ask Questions - Full DocumentationAsk Questions - Full Documentation
Ask Questions - Full DocumentationAlexandria Jarvis
 
Education prototype
Education prototypeEducation prototype
Education prototypecurlybecca
 
cognition and intelligence
cognition and intelligencecognition and intelligence
cognition and intelligencevida-dehnad
 
Soc comp slides_march_2012
Soc comp slides_march_2012Soc comp slides_march_2012
Soc comp slides_march_2012perspegrity5
 
Wwaipt unit overview (Mike)
Wwaipt unit overview (Mike)Wwaipt unit overview (Mike)
Wwaipt unit overview (Mike)5Ddaredevil
 
Fostering Inclusive Leadership Development Among College and High School Stud...
Fostering Inclusive Leadership Development Among College and High School Stud...Fostering Inclusive Leadership Development Among College and High School Stud...
Fostering Inclusive Leadership Development Among College and High School Stud...National Partnership for Educational Access
 
ISFIRE 14 Feb 2013 Red dirt thinking on power, pedagogy and paradigms: Sam Os...
ISFIRE 14 Feb 2013 Red dirt thinking on power, pedagogy and paradigms: Sam Os...ISFIRE 14 Feb 2013 Red dirt thinking on power, pedagogy and paradigms: Sam Os...
ISFIRE 14 Feb 2013 Red dirt thinking on power, pedagogy and paradigms: Sam Os...Ninti_One
 
Local Knowledge in Pre-Service Education
Local Knowledge in Pre-Service EducationLocal Knowledge in Pre-Service Education
Local Knowledge in Pre-Service EducationSheila Dingcong
 
Integration in the 21st Century Classroom
Integration in the 21st Century ClassroomIntegration in the 21st Century Classroom
Integration in the 21st Century Classroombgalloway
 
Project: Ana & Paloma
Project: Ana & PalomaProject: Ana & Paloma
Project: Ana & Palomaanapaloma94
 
Internationalisation in post-secondary education
Internationalisation in post-secondary educationInternationalisation in post-secondary education
Internationalisation in post-secondary educationNick Brieger
 
Ethnography primer
Ethnography primerEthnography primer
Ethnography primerJAYCIKEITH
 
Ethnography Primer
Ethnography PrimerEthnography Primer
Ethnography Primermanero
 

Similar to Step back to readings (20)

Ask Questions - Full Documentation
Ask Questions - Full DocumentationAsk Questions - Full Documentation
Ask Questions - Full Documentation
 
Education prototype
Education prototypeEducation prototype
Education prototype
 
2 w.methods
2 w.methods2 w.methods
2 w.methods
 
Unit Letter
Unit LetterUnit Letter
Unit Letter
 
cognition and intelligence
cognition and intelligencecognition and intelligence
cognition and intelligence
 
Soc comp slides_march_2012
Soc comp slides_march_2012Soc comp slides_march_2012
Soc comp slides_march_2012
 
Intro to Unit & Lesson Plan Writing
Intro to Unit & Lesson Plan WritingIntro to Unit & Lesson Plan Writing
Intro to Unit & Lesson Plan Writing
 
Wwaipt unit overview (Mike)
Wwaipt unit overview (Mike)Wwaipt unit overview (Mike)
Wwaipt unit overview (Mike)
 
Fostering Inclusive Leadership Development Among College and High School Stud...
Fostering Inclusive Leadership Development Among College and High School Stud...Fostering Inclusive Leadership Development Among College and High School Stud...
Fostering Inclusive Leadership Development Among College and High School Stud...
 
March 4
March 4March 4
March 4
 
ISFIRE 14 Feb 2013 Red dirt thinking on power, pedagogy and paradigms: Sam Os...
ISFIRE 14 Feb 2013 Red dirt thinking on power, pedagogy and paradigms: Sam Os...ISFIRE 14 Feb 2013 Red dirt thinking on power, pedagogy and paradigms: Sam Os...
ISFIRE 14 Feb 2013 Red dirt thinking on power, pedagogy and paradigms: Sam Os...
 
Field book 2010
Field book 2010Field book 2010
Field book 2010
 
Local Knowledge in Pre-Service Education
Local Knowledge in Pre-Service EducationLocal Knowledge in Pre-Service Education
Local Knowledge in Pre-Service Education
 
Integration in the 21st Century Classroom
Integration in the 21st Century ClassroomIntegration in the 21st Century Classroom
Integration in the 21st Century Classroom
 
NFE
NFE NFE
NFE
 
Local knowledge
Local knowledgeLocal knowledge
Local knowledge
 
Project: Ana & Paloma
Project: Ana & PalomaProject: Ana & Paloma
Project: Ana & Paloma
 
Internationalisation in post-secondary education
Internationalisation in post-secondary educationInternationalisation in post-secondary education
Internationalisation in post-secondary education
 
Ethnography primer
Ethnography primerEthnography primer
Ethnography primer
 
Ethnography Primer
Ethnography PrimerEthnography Primer
Ethnography Primer
 

More from enarvaez2009

Teaching writing in colombian higher education elizabeth narvaez cardona
Teaching writing in colombian higher education elizabeth narvaez cardonaTeaching writing in colombian higher education elizabeth narvaez cardona
Teaching writing in colombian higher education elizabeth narvaez cardonaenarvaez2009
 
Presentation Elizabeth Narváez
Presentation Elizabeth NarváezPresentation Elizabeth Narváez
Presentation Elizabeth Narváezenarvaez2009
 
Presentación puebla 2013
Presentación puebla 2013Presentación puebla 2013
Presentación puebla 2013enarvaez2009
 
Boletin enredate ve 19
Boletin enredate ve 19Boletin enredate ve 19
Boletin enredate ve 19enarvaez2009
 
Ponencia definitiva cali agosto 10
Ponencia definitiva cali agosto 10Ponencia definitiva cali agosto 10
Ponencia definitiva cali agosto 10enarvaez2009
 
Handout august 7th
Handout august 7thHandout august 7th
Handout august 7thenarvaez2009
 
Presentación lasa
Presentación lasaPresentación lasa
Presentación lasaenarvaez2009
 
Lasa conference final paper march 28th
Lasa conference final paper march 28thLasa conference final paper march 28th
Lasa conference final paper march 28thenarvaez2009
 
Publicizing research data june 2nd
Publicizing research data june 2ndPublicizing research data june 2nd
Publicizing research data june 2ndenarvaez2009
 
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy III
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy IIIRehash dichotomous pedagogy III
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy IIIenarvaez2009
 
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy ii
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy iiRehash dichotomous pedagogy ii
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy iienarvaez2009
 
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy II
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy IIRehash dichotomous pedagogy II
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy IIenarvaez2009
 
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy
Rehash dichotomous pedagogyRehash dichotomous pedagogy
Rehash dichotomous pedagogyenarvaez2009
 
Final ethnography elizabeth narváez cardona march 20th
Final ethnography elizabeth narváez cardona march 20thFinal ethnography elizabeth narváez cardona march 20th
Final ethnography elizabeth narváez cardona march 20thenarvaez2009
 
Final paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardona
Final paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardonaFinal paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardona
Final paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardonaenarvaez2009
 
Theoretical orientations
Theoretical orientationsTheoretical orientations
Theoretical orientationsenarvaez2009
 
Graphic of analysis ii
Graphic of analysis iiGraphic of analysis ii
Graphic of analysis iienarvaez2009
 

More from enarvaez2009 (20)

Teaching writing in colombian higher education elizabeth narvaez cardona
Teaching writing in colombian higher education elizabeth narvaez cardonaTeaching writing in colombian higher education elizabeth narvaez cardona
Teaching writing in colombian higher education elizabeth narvaez cardona
 
Presentation Elizabeth Narváez
Presentation Elizabeth NarváezPresentation Elizabeth Narváez
Presentation Elizabeth Narváez
 
Presentación puebla 2013
Presentación puebla 2013Presentación puebla 2013
Presentación puebla 2013
 
Boletin enredate ve 19
Boletin enredate ve 19Boletin enredate ve 19
Boletin enredate ve 19
 
Ponencia definitiva cali agosto 10
Ponencia definitiva cali agosto 10Ponencia definitiva cali agosto 10
Ponencia definitiva cali agosto 10
 
Handout august 7th
Handout august 7thHandout august 7th
Handout august 7th
 
Presentación lasa
Presentación lasaPresentación lasa
Presentación lasa
 
Lasa conference final paper march 28th
Lasa conference final paper march 28thLasa conference final paper march 28th
Lasa conference final paper march 28th
 
Proposal june 2nd
Proposal june 2ndProposal june 2nd
Proposal june 2nd
 
Publicizing research data june 2nd
Publicizing research data june 2ndPublicizing research data june 2nd
Publicizing research data june 2nd
 
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy III
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy IIIRehash dichotomous pedagogy III
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy III
 
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy ii
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy iiRehash dichotomous pedagogy ii
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy ii
 
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy II
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy IIRehash dichotomous pedagogy II
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy II
 
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy
Rehash dichotomous pedagogyRehash dichotomous pedagogy
Rehash dichotomous pedagogy
 
Final ethnography elizabeth narváez cardona march 20th
Final ethnography elizabeth narváez cardona march 20thFinal ethnography elizabeth narváez cardona march 20th
Final ethnography elizabeth narváez cardona march 20th
 
Final paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardona
Final paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardonaFinal paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardona
Final paper textual analysis elizabeth narváez cardona
 
Theoretical orientations
Theoretical orientationsTheoretical orientations
Theoretical orientations
 
Writing centers
Writing centersWriting centers
Writing centers
 
Overview
OverviewOverview
Overview
 
Graphic of analysis ii
Graphic of analysis iiGraphic of analysis ii
Graphic of analysis ii
 

Step back to readings

  • 1. 1 Information to retrieve the whole reference What I understood I need to do for thinking/acting(?) My My Temporary answers Answers taken from ethnographically comments questions Learn from the people (insiders) what counts as cultural knowledge (insider meaning) Ethnographers construct systems to learn what members Members How the Creating data from the of particular groups need to know, understand, produce of groups ethnographe perspective of the different types and predict as they participate in events of everyday life and rs can honor or members of the community within a group. communiti these es do not differences? hold roles or points of views evenly. In education, the key questions: How the This is a developing process in  What is happening here? analyst which the ethnographer is slowly  What is being accomplished, by and with whom, bounds the grasping meaning from the how, in what ways, when and where, under what events to community while acknowledging conditions, for what purposes, drawing on what learn from? what could be an interesting focus historical or current knowledge and resources of analysis, bearing in mind that (e.g. artifacts, meanings, tools), with what the goal is to learn from the outcomes or consequences for individuals and people (insiders) what counts as the group? cultural knowledge (insider  To what do individual members of sustaining meaning). groups have access, orient and hold each other
  • 2. 2 accountable?  What makes someone an insider or outsider of particular groups (e.g. class, group within a class, peer group or social network)?  What counts as disciplinary knowledge (i.e. mathematics, science, social science or art) in this particular group or classroom?  What roles and relationships, norms and expectations, and rights and obligations are constructed by and afforded members?  How does previously constructed cultural knowledge support or constrain participation in, or create frame clashes with, local knowledge being constructed in a particular event (or social group)?  How do decisions beyond the group support and/or constrain ways of knowing, being and doing afforded members?
  • 3. 3 Information to retrieve the whole reference What I understood I need to do for thinking/acting(?) My My questions Temporary answers Answers taken from ethnographically comments Ethnographers can redefine their questions depending on what they are learning during the fieldwork Should I define explicitly a theory of culture before starting my ethnographic study?
  • 4. 4 Information to retrieve the whole reference What I understood I need to do for thinking/acting(?) My My Temporary answers Answers taken from ethnographically comments questions What counts as event? And how many “events” could count as ethnograph y? Types of questions that I should bear in mind while I am learning from a community: - What is ordinary and predictable? - What is not ordinary and problematic?
  • 5. 5 Information to retrieve the whole reference What I understood I need to do for thinking/acting(?) My comments My questions Temporary Answers taken from ethnographically answers Ethnography in education is a field allowing me to doubt upon common senses regarding learning, knowledge, success, and effectiveness in formal educational settings. This means, I could problematize education. The question I should be always bear in mind is WHAT COUNTS AS…?