The story describes two children, Ann and Arthur, who live across from an abandoned house said to be haunted. They hear screams coming from the house one night and try to warn their parents, but their parents don't believe them. That night, while their parents are gone, the children see a ghostly boy in the other house who brings them there. They learn he is the spirit of Jack Morton who was killed by his father in that house long ago. Jack now takes the spirits of anyone who lives in that house as punishment for what was done to him. He tells the children they will be next.