Consumer Health Information
         www.fda.gov/consumer




FDA 101: Product Recalls
   From First Alert to Effectiveness Checks




           First Alert                         Alerting the Public                     Effectiveness Checks
FDA hears about product problems           FDA posts regular updates about            FDA reviews all of a company’s
  through company notification,             recalls to its Web site, and all         corrective actions to determine
 agency inspections and adverse             recalls appear in the agency’s              when a recall is complete.
 event reports, and through CDC.             weekly Enforcement Reports.




O
      nce a product is in widespread use, unforeseen problems                     recall. But in every case, FDA’s role is
      can sometimes lead to a recall. Contaminated spinach,                       to oversee a company’s strategy and
                                                                                  assess the adequacy of the recall.
      for example, led to the recent recall of spinach products
under multiple brand names. Contaminated peanut butter led to                     First Alert
the recall of thousands of jars of two popular brands. In both                    FDA first hears about a problem
cases, FDA responded immediately to minimize harm.                                product in several ways:
                                                                                  • A company discovers a problem
                                                                                    and contacts FDA.
   When an FDA-regulated product is      rather than from an intentional dis-     • FDA inspects a manufacturing
either defective or potentially harm-    regard for the law.                        facility and determines the
ful, recalling that product—removing       Recalls are almost always volun-         potential for a recall.
it from the market or correcting the     tary. Sometimes a company discovers      • FDA receives reports of health
problem—is the most effective means      a problem and recalls a product on its     problems through various
for protecting the public. In most       own. Other times a company recalls         reporting systems.
cases, a recall results from an unin-    a product after FDA raises concerns.     • The Centers for Disease Control and
tentional mistake by the company,        Only in rare cases will FDA request a      Prevention (CDC) contacts FDA.
                                                                                                       Illustrations: FDA/Michael Ermarth


1 / FDA Consumer Health Information / U.S. Food and Drug Administration                                         OC TOBER 2009
Consumer Health Information
          www.fda.gov/consumer




           RECAll ClASSIFICATIOnS These guidelines categorize all recalls into one of three classes,
           according to the level of hazard involved:
           Class I       Dangerous or defective products that predictably could cause serious health problems or death.
                         Examples include: food found to contain botulinum toxin, food with undeclared allergens, a label
                         mix-up on a lifesaving drug, or a defective artificial heart valve.

           Class II      Products that might cause a temporary health problem, or pose only a slight threat of a serious
                         nature. Example: a drug that is under-strength but that is not used to treat life-threatening
                         situations.

           Class III     Products that are unlikely to cause any adverse health reaction, but that violate FDA labeling or
                         manufacturing laws. Examples include: a minor container defect and lack of English labeling in a
                         retail food.




  When it comes to illnesses associ-                                                    complete after all of the company’s cor-
ated with food products, Dorothy J.                                                     rective actions are reviewed by FDA
Miller, Director of FDA’s Office of
                                               FDA-regulated Products                   and deemed appropriate. After a recall
Emergency Operations, says that FDA            Subject to Recall                        is completed, FDA makes sure that the
generally first hears of these kinds of        • human drugs                            product is destroyed or suitably recondi-
problems from CDC.                                                                      tioned, and investigates why the product
  “CDC hears about such problems               • animal drugs                           was defective in the first place.
from state health departments that
                                               • medical devices
have received and submitted illness
reports,” she says. “An ongoing out-           • radiation-emitting products            This article appears on FDA’s
break means that we have an emer-                                                       Consumer Updates page (www.fda.
                                               • vaccines
gency, and when there’s a public                                                        gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates),
health crisis like this, you need to tell      • blood and blood products               which features the latest on all FDA-
the public immediately.”                                                                regulated products.
                                               • transplantable human tissue
Alerting the Public                            • animal feed                            For More Information
FDA seeks publicity about a recall only                                                 FDA 101: Product Recalls (video)
when it believes the public needs to           • cosmetics                              www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/
be alerted to a serious hazard. When           • about 80 percent of the                ConsumerUpdates/ucm182929.htm
a recalled product has been widely               foods eaten in the United
distributed, the news media is a very                                                   Protect Your Health Joint FDA/
effective way to reach large numbers
                                                 States                                 WebMD resource
of people. FDA can hold press confer-                                                   www.webmd.com/fda/default.htm
ences, issue press releases, and post
updates to its Web site regularly, to         Not all recalls are announced in the      Archive for Recalls, Market
alert people.                               media. But all recalls go into FDA’s        Withdrawals & Safety Alerts
  “It’s about being as transparent as       weekly Enforcement Report. This             www.fda.gov/Safety/Recalls/
possible,” says Catherine McDermott,        document lists each recall according        ArchiveRecalls/default.htm
public affairs manager in the Division      to classification (see “Recall Classifi-
of Federal-State Relations in FDA’s         cations” box), with the specific action     Food Safety Alerts and Tips Widget
Office of Regulatory Affairs. “If we        taken by the recalling firm.                www.foodsafety.gov/widgets/index.html
feel there is that much of a health
risk, we will offer media updates           Effectiveness Checks                        FoodSafety.gov: Your Gateway to
every day to give new information,          FDA evaluates whether all reasonable        Federal Food Safety Information
and all that we know gets posted to         efforts have been made to remove or         www.foodsafety.gov/
FDA’s Web site.”                            correct a product. A recall is considered
                                                                                                              Illustrations: FDA/Michael Ermarth


2 / FDA Consumer Health Information / U.S. Food and Drug Administration                                               OC TOBER 2009

Recall fda

  • 1.
    Consumer Health Information www.fda.gov/consumer FDA 101: Product Recalls From First Alert to Effectiveness Checks First Alert Alerting the Public Effectiveness Checks FDA hears about product problems FDA posts regular updates about FDA reviews all of a company’s through company notification, recalls to its Web site, and all corrective actions to determine agency inspections and adverse recalls appear in the agency’s when a recall is complete. event reports, and through CDC. weekly Enforcement Reports. O nce a product is in widespread use, unforeseen problems recall. But in every case, FDA’s role is can sometimes lead to a recall. Contaminated spinach, to oversee a company’s strategy and assess the adequacy of the recall. for example, led to the recent recall of spinach products under multiple brand names. Contaminated peanut butter led to First Alert the recall of thousands of jars of two popular brands. In both FDA first hears about a problem cases, FDA responded immediately to minimize harm. product in several ways: • A company discovers a problem and contacts FDA. When an FDA-regulated product is rather than from an intentional dis- • FDA inspects a manufacturing either defective or potentially harm- regard for the law. facility and determines the ful, recalling that product—removing Recalls are almost always volun- potential for a recall. it from the market or correcting the tary. Sometimes a company discovers • FDA receives reports of health problem—is the most effective means a problem and recalls a product on its problems through various for protecting the public. In most own. Other times a company recalls reporting systems. cases, a recall results from an unin- a product after FDA raises concerns. • The Centers for Disease Control and tentional mistake by the company, Only in rare cases will FDA request a Prevention (CDC) contacts FDA. Illustrations: FDA/Michael Ermarth 1 / FDA Consumer Health Information / U.S. Food and Drug Administration OC TOBER 2009
  • 2.
    Consumer Health Information www.fda.gov/consumer RECAll ClASSIFICATIOnS These guidelines categorize all recalls into one of three classes, according to the level of hazard involved: Class I Dangerous or defective products that predictably could cause serious health problems or death. Examples include: food found to contain botulinum toxin, food with undeclared allergens, a label mix-up on a lifesaving drug, or a defective artificial heart valve. Class II Products that might cause a temporary health problem, or pose only a slight threat of a serious nature. Example: a drug that is under-strength but that is not used to treat life-threatening situations. Class III Products that are unlikely to cause any adverse health reaction, but that violate FDA labeling or manufacturing laws. Examples include: a minor container defect and lack of English labeling in a retail food. When it comes to illnesses associ- complete after all of the company’s cor- ated with food products, Dorothy J. rective actions are reviewed by FDA Miller, Director of FDA’s Office of FDA-regulated Products and deemed appropriate. After a recall Emergency Operations, says that FDA Subject to Recall is completed, FDA makes sure that the generally first hears of these kinds of • human drugs product is destroyed or suitably recondi- problems from CDC. tioned, and investigates why the product “CDC hears about such problems • animal drugs was defective in the first place. from state health departments that • medical devices have received and submitted illness reports,” she says. “An ongoing out- • radiation-emitting products This article appears on FDA’s break means that we have an emer- Consumer Updates page (www.fda. • vaccines gency, and when there’s a public gov/ForConsumers/ConsumerUpdates), health crisis like this, you need to tell • blood and blood products which features the latest on all FDA- the public immediately.” regulated products. • transplantable human tissue Alerting the Public • animal feed For More Information FDA seeks publicity about a recall only FDA 101: Product Recalls (video) when it believes the public needs to • cosmetics www.fda.gov/ForConsumers/ be alerted to a serious hazard. When • about 80 percent of the ConsumerUpdates/ucm182929.htm a recalled product has been widely foods eaten in the United distributed, the news media is a very Protect Your Health Joint FDA/ effective way to reach large numbers States WebMD resource of people. FDA can hold press confer- www.webmd.com/fda/default.htm ences, issue press releases, and post updates to its Web site regularly, to Not all recalls are announced in the Archive for Recalls, Market alert people. media. But all recalls go into FDA’s Withdrawals & Safety Alerts “It’s about being as transparent as weekly Enforcement Report. This www.fda.gov/Safety/Recalls/ possible,” says Catherine McDermott, document lists each recall according ArchiveRecalls/default.htm public affairs manager in the Division to classification (see “Recall Classifi- of Federal-State Relations in FDA’s cations” box), with the specific action Food Safety Alerts and Tips Widget Office of Regulatory Affairs. “If we taken by the recalling firm. www.foodsafety.gov/widgets/index.html feel there is that much of a health risk, we will offer media updates Effectiveness Checks FoodSafety.gov: Your Gateway to every day to give new information, FDA evaluates whether all reasonable Federal Food Safety Information and all that we know gets posted to efforts have been made to remove or www.foodsafety.gov/ FDA’s Web site.” correct a product. A recall is considered Illustrations: FDA/Michael Ermarth 2 / FDA Consumer Health Information / U.S. Food and Drug Administration OC TOBER 2009