The document discusses the concept of open access as part of a new value system within digital environments, emphasizing the importance of knowledge as a commons and advocating for unrestricted access to knowledge for all. It critiques current commercial publishing models and copyright regulations, proposing more sustainable and inclusive frameworks for knowledge dissemination. The conclusion urges a transformation in understanding intellectual property rights and the institutionalization of knowledge to ensure it remains accessible and usable for everyone.

1. A commons-based foundation of
open access and other open
models
Rainer Kuhlen
Department of Computer and Information Science
University of Konstanz, Germany
CC
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010

2. A commons-based foundation
of open access
or
knowledge is the water
of the mind
CC
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010

3. Content - Topics
➢ Open Access part of a new value system in electronic
environments
➢ Open Access – part of knowledge ecology
➢ Towards an understanding of knowledge as a commons
➢ Models for the institutionalization of knowledge
➢ What needs to be done? Transformation processes
➢ Conclusion
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 3

4. Open Access as a new value system in electronic environments
A different view on open access
Open Access is not only a model for organizing the
production, distribution, and usage of knowledge but is also part
of a new value system which is being developed in electronic
environments.
information
ethics
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 4

5. Open Access part of a new value system in electronic environments
Information ethics aims at finding out which
beliefs, rules and values guide people at any given
time in history in producing, exchanging, sharing and
using knowledge and information.
Information ethics is based on the concept of knowledge as a
commons.
Commons not only the base for information ethics
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010

6. Open Access part of a new value system in electronic environment
Information ethics
Regulation of
knowledge and
information
Information
copyright
markets
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010

7. Open Access part of a new value system in electronic environments
Commons not only the base for information ethics
Commons is also the central concept of
knowledge ecology
and in time to come for
markets
and law
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010

8. Open Access – part of knowledge ecology
Ecology in general is concerned with the sustainability of
natural resources (for instance water, air/climate, forests) by
protecting these resources from overuse.
Knowledge ecology is also concerned with sustainability
but sustainability of immaterial goods such as knowledge can
only be achieved by making it open and free open access and
unrestricted use.
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 8

9. Open Access – part of knowledge ecology
The concept of knowledge ecology and in its context the idea of
open access provides an alternative both
to existing commercial publishing models on the international
information markets and
to international copyright regulations,
which, in the last 20 years, have mainly emphasized the economic
impact of knowledge and information
and thus have made knowledge a scarce resource
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 9

10. Open Access – part of knowledge ecology
economy ecology
knowledge
economy
? knowledge
ecology
Thesis
Knowledge ecology does not object to the commercial use of
knowledge,
but suggests that publishing models are only acceptable when
they acknowledge the status of knowledge as a commons,
allowing free and open access for everyone
not reclaiming exclusive propert rights.
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 10

11. Towards an under-
standing of knowledge
as a commons
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 11

12. An understanding of knowledge as a commons
common heritage
of What are commons?
nature
common heritage
of
social life
common heritage
of
cultural
creativity
Aus: Peter Barnes: Capitalism 3.0
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 12

13. An understanding of knowledge as a commons
What are commons?
Commons
access to water is a fundamental
➢water human right
➢natural resources
➢public spaces
➢air/sky knowledge is the water of
➢knowledge the mind
….
access to knowledge is a
fundamental human right
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 13

14. An understanding of knowledge as a commons
res nullius What is the
res privatae status of
res publicae
knowledge?
res communes
Justinian I., Mosaikdetail aus der Kirche San
Vitale in Ravenna
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 14

15. An understanding of knowledge as a commons
Who owns knowledge?
producers/authors?
exploiters/content providers/publishers?
users/those who need it for their work?
knowledge is part of the commons – of the res
communes
nobody should own knowledge exclusively
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 15

16. An understanding of knowledge as a commons
Who owns knowledge?
is it the right question?
knowledge itself, ideas, facts, theories, …data(??)
is not protected by copyright laws
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 16

17. An understanding of knowledge as a commons
knowledge is a commons
but only usable when accessible
Who has access to knowledge?
Who controls the access to knowledge?
The question is not one of knowledge but that of information
Who has access to information – who controls
information?
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 17

18. Access is the challenge
making it a scarce resource
exploiter
author
exploiter
balance author
In balance
copyright In
copyright
user
user
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 18

19. Access is the challenge
knowledge is a commons
but only usable when accessible
knowledge needs to be institutionalized appropriately
In order to become a common property
Open access is a form of institutionalization of
knowledge as a commons
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 19

20. Institutionalizing knowledge as a commons
sharing
justice, fairness
inclusion
sustainabilty
principles
Common
institution-
Pool
alization Commons
Resources
procedures
communication (reaching a consensus)
rules
commitments
contracts
control mechanisms
sanctions
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 20

21. Institutionalizung the access to information
privatization sharing
enclosure of the mind It´s our justice, fairness
profitability choice open
scarce resource inclusion
sustainabilty
principles
access to
Knowledge institution- information
products
Resources alization
Services
procedures systems
rules
commitments
contracts
control mechanisms
sanctions
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 21

22. Models for the
institutionalization of
knowledge
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 22

23. Models for the institutionalization of knowledge
(1) Proprietary commercial information markets
objects exclusive rights for the
exploitation
trade with information with the consequence
objects that
transformation of knowledge is made a
scarce good
authors´ rights into
exploiters´ rights
copyright contractual
DRM agreement
law
licenses
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 23

24. Models for the institutionalization of knowledge
(2) Freeconomics markets – prototpye Google
profit
objects
Information objects Not by information itself
search engines
but
as
using user search profiles
private property rights
for advertisement
but
merchandizing
free use
cross financing
value-added effects
Will SpringerOpen mutate into a freeconomics model?
Usage open/free, copyright remains by the authors – the public finance the
production costs and the profit of a company on the information market
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 24

25. Models for the institutionalization of knowledge
(3) Open free markets
possible default
Information objects in the copyright
non-exclusive paradigm
given for open access commercial but
exploitation rights as
free open use
claimed as
exploitation a means of
development
personal moral rights
Creative commons
or type 2
type 1
given into the freeconomics
Proprietary Open Access
commons, directly markets
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 25

26. Models for the institutionalization of knowledge
(4) commons-based information markets
Commons A property of mankind
but
air/sky
water private rights for
natural resources exploitation possible and
he public space often necessary
knowledge but only
….
with non-exclusive exploitation rights
with sufficient compensation to the
public
as lang as free access to everyone is
guaranteed
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 26

27. What needs to be done?
Transformation processes
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010

28. What needs to be done? Transformation processes
(1) transforming the understanding of intellectual
property
knowledge as a commons is not to be considered a res
nullius which can be used ad libitum by everyone for
whatever purpose
developing a concept of common property rights
without denying private individual property rights
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 28

29. What needs to be done? Transformation processes
(1) transforming the understanding of intellectual
property
knowledge as a commons is not to be considered an
exclusive private producers´ individual right nor a
commercial exploiters´ right
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 29

30. What needs to be done? Transformation processes
(1) transforming the understanding of intellectual
property
What was feasible with respect to patent right – no longer a
professor´s/inventor´s right but now a right of their
institutions
should be possible with respect to copyright
That means: overcoming the objections against an
institutional mandate
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 30

31. What needs to be done? Transformation processes
(2) developing a new understanding and practice of
copyright
Overcoming the systems of exceptions/limitations in
copyright
for science and education a generic clause is needed
rather then a set of exceptions
right to use published information for any ethically and
justifiably purpose in science and education without
asking permission
(but with reasonable remuneration)
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 31

32. What needs to be done? Transformation processes
Art. 5.2– Uses for the purpose of freedom of
expression and information
(2) The following uses for the purpose of freedom
of expression and information are permitted
without authorisation, but only against
payment of remuneration and to the extent
justified by the purpose of the use:
(a) use of single articles for purposes of
internal reporting within an organisation;
(b) use for purposes of scientific research.
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010

33. What needs to be done? Transformation processes
A generic clause for
science and education
A proposal by the Coalition for
Action
"Copyright for Education and
Research”
2010
Similar:
 The Alliance of German Science Organisations
(AvH, DAAD, DFG, FhG, HGF, HRK, MPG, WGL, WR)
 Standing Conference of the Ministers of Education and Cultural Affairs of the
Länder in the Federal Republic of Germany
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 33

34. What needs to be done? Transformation processes
§ 45b Education and Science
(1) Copying, distributing and making published works available to the
public is permitted for personal use in science and for educational
purposes in schools, institutions of higher education (such as
universities), and other non-commercial institutions dedicated to
education, continuing and professional training.
provided that the source from which the not restricted to publicly
reproduction is made is not an obviously financed science
infringing copy
from a legitimately acquired copy
only, e.g. from a library or bought from a
commercial provider
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 34

35. http://www.urheberrechtsbuen
dnis.de/index.html.en
www.ences.eu
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 35

36. Conclusion
Knowledge is the water of the mind
absolutely necessary for development and cultural survival
as water for the physical survival
Knowledge and its derivative information products cannot
be subject of exclusive private property rights
Production and use of knowledge and its derivative information
products depend on commons-based institutionalization forms
adequate to electronic environments
commons-based information markets do not make the
commercial use of of knowledge and its derivative
information products impossible but rather are the realistic
chance for the information economy to survive successfully
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 36

37. Thank you for your
attention
Slides under a CC-Licence from www.kuhlen.name
Towards a commons-based copyright– IFLA 08/2010
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 37

38. Towards a commons-based copyright– IFLA 08/2010
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010 38

39. Infrastructure Copyright for
Science and Education
Funded by the German Research
Community (DFG)
CC
39
A commons-based foundation of open access and other open models – Open Data Cologne 14.12.2010