Predictive Analytics: the Engine
                    for One-to-One Marketing
February 18, 2011      Ghislaine Duymelings █ Jo De Lange █ Geert Verstraeten
Overtoom International
█   Business-to-Business distance selling
    company (Market leader)

                       •   Penetration rate in Belgium:
                           7% ( 850.000 companies)
                       •   Database customers:
                           85.000 companies / 240.000 contacts
                       •   Database products :
                           40.000 references



        Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 2
Overtoom International
   █   Marketing Channels




Yearly Catalogue:           Yearly Catalogue:               Monthly Leaflet:
 Office Supplies           Warehouse Supplies            Promotional Brochure


               Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 3
Overtoom International
      █   Marketing Channels




Company Website www.overtoom.be                  Email promotions



              Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 4
Overtoom International
      █   Challenges
                                                      By offering the right
                                                         Product(s)

Reaching the right
  Customer



                                           Through the most appropriate
                                              Marketing Channel

                Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 5
Python Predictions

█   Core business: Predictive Analytics


                                                        …in order to
         Using all             …we predict                manage
         available           future customer            one-to-one
         customer               behavior…              relationships.
      information…




        Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 6
Python Predictions

█   Core business: Predictive Analytics
█   Based in Brussels
█   Since 2006
█   Team
█   Customers:




       Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 7
Predictive Analytics
  Benefits




                   Respect           Efficient
                    for the          resource
                   customer          deploymt

Marketing                                                   Marketing
Relevance                                                  Accountability



            Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 8
One-to-one marketing
What it could be…




Minority Report (2002)




          Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 9
One-to-one marketing
       The near future?




New York, November, 2010



                                           Japan, September, 2010


                   Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 10
One-to-one marketing
Well known example: Amazon




     Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 11
One-to-one marketing
     at Overtoom
       █   How it all started…
                                                    By offering the right
                                                       Product(s)

Reaching the right
   Customer


                                         Through the most appropriate
                                            Marketing Channel

              Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 12
Reaching the right customer

  █   Increase targeting efficiency of
      current marketing actions to
      existing clients
      Yearly catalogues
      Monthly leaflets


  █   Increase response and turnover
  █   Segmentation Predictive Analytics



       Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 13
Reaching the right customer

  █   Segmentation is exploratory
  █   Prediction is discriminatory

          Segmentation                      Prediction




                                             Prediction



       Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 14
Reaching the right customer

 █   Turnover during field test
      Short term
        Reduction target size: -10%
        Turnover: +28%
     Long term
        Reduction target size: -10%
        Turnover : +10% (average)




         Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 15
Personalized Targeting
      █   The plot thickens…
                                                 By offering the right
                                                        Product(s)

Reaching the right
  Customer



                                           Through the most appropriate
                                              Marketing Channel

                Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 16
Customized Offers
Motivation: the paradox of choice

                                                   40% stops                        30% purchased

         6 jams




                                                   60% stops                          3% purchased




       24 jams

Source
S. Iyengar & M. Lepper, When Choice is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much of a Good Thing?
Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000, Vol. 79, No. 6, 995-1006


                Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 17
Customized Offers
The Paradox of Choice (Barry Schwartz)

      █   Too much choice and too much information
              • is paralyzing
              • leads to bad decisions
              • leads to dissatisfaction with good
              decisions
      █   Modern technology has helped create this
          problem, but it can also help create the
          solution, by tailoring options and
          information in ways that are relevant to
          individual consumers


      Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 18
Customized Offers
     Motivation: Overtoom facts
         Percentage of Purchases                      Number of Customers
6%                                        40000

5%                                        35000
                                          30000
4%
                                          25000
3%                                        20000
2%                                        15000
                                          10000
1%
                                           5000
0%                                            0
     A B CD E F GH I J K L MNOPQR S T             1    2   3   4   5   6   7   8   9   10
             Product Categories                             Number of Different
                                                           Categories Purchased

                                                  Most customers purchase
     All categories are purchased to                in a limited number
             a certain degree                           of categories


                  Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 19
Customized Offers
  Solutions




Market Basket              Response                        Similarity
  Analysis                 Modeling                        Modeling




           Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 20
Customized Offers
     Response Models
       █     Method

 Product       A        B        C           Company ‘O’ has 3 products


  Model        A        B        C           3 propensity-to-buy models are built


Customer X     A        B        C           Customer X is scored on each of these
                                             models

Best offer               C                   The product with the highest
                                             probability-to-buy/expected return
                                             is offered to the customer


                   Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 21
Customized Offers
Initial format (April 2009)




        Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 22
Customized Offers
Extended Format




     Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 23
Customized Offers
     Similarity Model
       █     Method

Customer X              X                    We compare any customer with all
                                             other customers

Customers      1         2       3           Company ‘O’ has 3 customers

                                             Customers have bought products
 Products      A        B        C           Company ‘O’ has 3 products


Best offer               C                   Based on the purchases of the most
                                             similar customers, we offer the best
                                             possible suggestion to each customer


                   Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 24
Customized Offers
     Similarity Model
       █     Method
                                         Advantages
Customer X              X
                                         █   Client-based vs product-based
                                         █   1 model, simple data structure
Customers      1         2       3
                                         █   Inclusion of all products, categories
                                         █   Development time
 Products      A        B        C       █   Comparison with existing models
                                             possible
Best offer               C                     Performance
                                               Variety



                   Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 25
Results

█   Evaluation:
     Conversion rate
       Percentage of buyers who purchased the specific offer

     Success Rate
       Percentage of buyers who purchased at least 1 of the offers

     Variety index
       Indicator of the global variety of the offers across all customers




        Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 26
Results - development
█    Summary
                                            Success Rate
    0.7
              +14.6%       +8.6%
    0.6

    0.5

    0.4

    0.3

    0.2

    0.1

     0
          1     2      3     4          5    6      7    8       9   10    11    12    13      14

                    Customized Offers         Benchmark LogReg       Benchmark
          Similarity Modeling                    Response Modeling              Most Popular
                                                                     Most Popular Product      Product




               Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 27
Results - infield
     █   Conversion rate based on rank of the offer:
            Extended format (14 customized offers)

                                     Conversion Rate
             7%
                                                      Customized Offers
300 %        6%
             5%
                                                      Folder

 more
                                                      Baseline
             4%

relevant     3%
             2%
             1%
             0%
                   1   2   3    4     5   6   7   8     9      10   11   12 13 14
                                    Number of Recommendations


               Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 28
Implementation
█   Stakeholders

      General Management           Inventory Management


  Marketing                                          Communication
 Management                                             Partner


    Purchasing                                       Digital Printing
                                                         Partner
                           Analytical
                           Partners


         Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 29
Personalized Targeting
      █   The future…
                                                      By offering the right
                                                         Product(s)

Reaching the right
  Customer



                                   Through the most appropriate
                                          Marketing Channel
                Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 30
Analytics & the Customer Lifecycle


    Acquisition


Suspect    Prospect        New          Active         Customer     Inactive
                         Customer      Customer         At Risk     Customer


Suspect     Prospect    Segmenting     Segmenting        Churn      Reactivation
Purchase   Conversion   & Targeting    & Targeting     Prevention

           Customized   Customized     Customized
             Offers       Offers         Offers

                                       Profit / Long
                                        Term Value

                                         Loyalty

             Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 31
█ SAS Success Story

█ Visit our websites:
      www.overtoom.be
      www.pythonpredictions.com

█ Contact information:
     ghislaine.duymelings@overtoom.be
     jo.delange@overtoom.be
     geert.verstraeten@pythonpredictions.com

    Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 32

Predictive Analytics: the Engine for One-to-One Marketing

  • 1.
    Predictive Analytics: theEngine for One-to-One Marketing February 18, 2011 Ghislaine Duymelings █ Jo De Lange █ Geert Verstraeten
  • 2.
    Overtoom International █ Business-to-Business distance selling company (Market leader) • Penetration rate in Belgium: 7% ( 850.000 companies) • Database customers: 85.000 companies / 240.000 contacts • Database products : 40.000 references Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 2
  • 3.
    Overtoom International █ Marketing Channels Yearly Catalogue: Yearly Catalogue: Monthly Leaflet: Office Supplies Warehouse Supplies Promotional Brochure Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 3
  • 4.
    Overtoom International █ Marketing Channels Company Website www.overtoom.be Email promotions Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 4
  • 5.
    Overtoom International █ Challenges By offering the right Product(s) Reaching the right Customer Through the most appropriate Marketing Channel Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 5
  • 6.
    Python Predictions █ Core business: Predictive Analytics …in order to Using all …we predict manage available future customer one-to-one customer behavior… relationships. information… Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 6
  • 7.
    Python Predictions █ Core business: Predictive Analytics █ Based in Brussels █ Since 2006 █ Team █ Customers: Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 7
  • 8.
    Predictive Analytics Benefits Respect Efficient for the resource customer deploymt Marketing Marketing Relevance Accountability Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 8
  • 9.
    One-to-one marketing What itcould be… Minority Report (2002) Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 9
  • 10.
    One-to-one marketing The near future? New York, November, 2010 Japan, September, 2010 Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 10
  • 11.
    One-to-one marketing Well knownexample: Amazon Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 11
  • 12.
    One-to-one marketing at Overtoom █ How it all started… By offering the right Product(s) Reaching the right Customer Through the most appropriate Marketing Channel Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 12
  • 13.
    Reaching the rightcustomer █ Increase targeting efficiency of current marketing actions to existing clients Yearly catalogues Monthly leaflets █ Increase response and turnover █ Segmentation Predictive Analytics Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 13
  • 14.
    Reaching the rightcustomer █ Segmentation is exploratory █ Prediction is discriminatory Segmentation Prediction Prediction Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 14
  • 15.
    Reaching the rightcustomer █ Turnover during field test Short term Reduction target size: -10% Turnover: +28% Long term Reduction target size: -10% Turnover : +10% (average) Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 15
  • 16.
    Personalized Targeting █ The plot thickens… By offering the right Product(s) Reaching the right Customer Through the most appropriate Marketing Channel Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 16
  • 17.
    Customized Offers Motivation: theparadox of choice 40% stops 30% purchased 6 jams 60% stops 3% purchased 24 jams Source S. Iyengar & M. Lepper, When Choice is Demotivating: Can One Desire Too Much of a Good Thing? Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 2000, Vol. 79, No. 6, 995-1006 Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 17
  • 18.
    Customized Offers The Paradoxof Choice (Barry Schwartz) █ Too much choice and too much information • is paralyzing • leads to bad decisions • leads to dissatisfaction with good decisions █ Modern technology has helped create this problem, but it can also help create the solution, by tailoring options and information in ways that are relevant to individual consumers Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 18
  • 19.
    Customized Offers Motivation: Overtoom facts Percentage of Purchases Number of Customers 6% 40000 5% 35000 30000 4% 25000 3% 20000 2% 15000 10000 1% 5000 0% 0 A B CD E F GH I J K L MNOPQR S T 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 Product Categories Number of Different Categories Purchased Most customers purchase All categories are purchased to in a limited number a certain degree of categories Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 19
  • 20.
    Customized Offers Solutions Market Basket Response Similarity Analysis Modeling Modeling Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 20
  • 21.
    Customized Offers Response Models █ Method Product A B C Company ‘O’ has 3 products Model A B C 3 propensity-to-buy models are built Customer X A B C Customer X is scored on each of these models Best offer C The product with the highest probability-to-buy/expected return is offered to the customer Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 21
  • 22.
    Customized Offers Initial format(April 2009) Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 22
  • 23.
    Customized Offers Extended Format Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 23
  • 24.
    Customized Offers Similarity Model █ Method Customer X X We compare any customer with all other customers Customers 1 2 3 Company ‘O’ has 3 customers Customers have bought products Products A B C Company ‘O’ has 3 products Best offer C Based on the purchases of the most similar customers, we offer the best possible suggestion to each customer Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 24
  • 25.
    Customized Offers Similarity Model █ Method Advantages Customer X X █ Client-based vs product-based █ 1 model, simple data structure Customers 1 2 3 █ Inclusion of all products, categories █ Development time Products A B C █ Comparison with existing models possible Best offer C  Performance  Variety Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 25
  • 26.
    Results █ Evaluation:  Conversion rate Percentage of buyers who purchased the specific offer  Success Rate Percentage of buyers who purchased at least 1 of the offers  Variety index Indicator of the global variety of the offers across all customers Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 26
  • 27.
    Results - development █ Summary Success Rate 0.7 +14.6% +8.6% 0.6 0.5 0.4 0.3 0.2 0.1 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Customized Offers Benchmark LogReg Benchmark Similarity Modeling Response Modeling Most Popular Most Popular Product Product Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 27
  • 28.
    Results - infield █ Conversion rate based on rank of the offer:  Extended format (14 customized offers) Conversion Rate 7% Customized Offers 300 % 6% 5% Folder more Baseline 4% relevant 3% 2% 1% 0% 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 Number of Recommendations Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 28
  • 29.
    Implementation █ Stakeholders General Management Inventory Management Marketing Communication Management Partner Purchasing Digital Printing Partner Analytical Partners Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 29
  • 30.
    Personalized Targeting █ The future… By offering the right Product(s) Reaching the right Customer Through the most appropriate Marketing Channel Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 30
  • 31.
    Analytics & theCustomer Lifecycle Acquisition Suspect Prospect New Active Customer Inactive Customer Customer At Risk Customer Suspect Prospect Segmenting Segmenting Churn Reactivation Purchase Conversion & Targeting & Targeting Prevention Customized Customized Customized Offers Offers Offers Profit / Long Term Value Loyalty Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 31
  • 32.
    █ SAS SuccessStory █ Visit our websites: www.overtoom.be www.pythonpredictions.com █ Contact information: ghislaine.duymelings@overtoom.be jo.delange@overtoom.be geert.verstraeten@pythonpredictions.com Predictive Analytics - February 18, 2011 █ 32