Experience on System of Root
Intensification in the Sundarbans


             PRASARI
RIVER-BANK
               FAILURE+SEA
                  WATER

  SUNDARBANS




                                     WATERLOG
CROP LOSS




                                     RAINFALL+
 SALINITY




                                       GING
                   DRY SOIL+SALINE
                      SURFACE
Factors contributing …
                        HIGH
                                             WATER SCARCITY
SINGLE                   RAINFALL            +HIGH SALINITY IN
CROP-RICE+              IN JULY              SUMMER (50% MORE)
1 acre av. land         (753mm)

                           SUBMERGENCE
                            LOSS OF ONLY            NOMINAL
       1.91t/ha
                            GROP (as high         SECOND CROP
                                70%)




           FOOD INSECURITY+60% DISTRESSED MIGRATION
PROBLEM STATEMENT…
• WATER LOGGING AND NO DRAINAGE
• MONO-CROPPED (LOW YIELD-RICE)
• HIGHER SALINITY AND LESS SWEET WATER IN
  SUMMER
• SMALL LANDHOLDING
• LACK OF FODDER & ORGANIC MANURE
  (LIVESTOCK DECREASING)
• LACK OF FAITH ON NRM-AGRIL.
• MIGRATION
PRESENTATION SUMMARY….
• SRI EVOLUTIONS
0th Year
Year-1
Year-2
Year-3
• LEARNINGS
• WAY-FORWARD…….
SRI EVOLUTION (0TH YR)…
• PARESH DAS
• LAND-LESS
• LEASED-IN 10 dcml.
  LAND
• SUMMER-07-08
• USED MOC+FYM
  CAKE
• 240 KGS. OF RICE
  OVER TRADITIONAL
  115 KGS.
QUESTIONED ANSWERED(UN)(0TH


?               YR)…..
SRI CAN BE DONE IN THE SUNDARBANS!
CAN IT BE CALLED AS SRI?
HIGHER WATER DEPTH AND STAGNATION VS. ALTERNATE DRY/WET
YOUNG AND SINGLE SEEDLING CAN SURVIVE WATER PRESSURE?
WHAT WOULD BE THE NUTRIENT DOSES?
THE TRADITIONAL VARIETIES WOULD ALSO RESPOND
UNDER SRI?
IF YOU CAN’T SEE THE SOIL UNDER WATER-WHERE TO USE
WEEDER?
WOULD PEOPLE REALY BE READY TO PUT THEIR LAND AT
STAKE?
SRI EVOLUTION (YEAR-1)…..
• RECEIVED SUPPORT
  FROM SDTT
• KHARIF-152 FARMERS IN
  49 ACRE (+80 FARMERS
  IN SUMMER)
• GREEN MANURE+DE-OIL
  CAKE BASED POP
• 11 FARMERS TRIED LOCAL
  VARIETIES
• 15 FARMERS LOST CROP
  IN SUMMER
QUESTIONED ANSWERED(UN)(1ST


?                YR)…..
SRI IS ONLY FEASIBLE FOR THE UPLANDS?
WHAT TO DO WHERE WATER STAGNATION IS VERY HIGH?
WEEDER OPERATION CONTRIBUTES POSITIVELY TO THE YIELD EVEN IF
YOU CAN’T SEE THE SOIL!
ARE THE FARMERS TAKING UP SRI AS THEY ARE PROVIDED WITH THE
INPUTS COST? SOURCE OF ORGANICS?
LOCAL VARIETIES ARE DOING BETTER THAN THAT OF TRADITIONAL
PRACTICES-AROMATIC/MORISHSHAL VARIETY WOULD ASSURE MORE
RETURN UNDER SRI?
DE-OIL CAKES REMAINED ‘CAKES’ EVEN AFTER THE SUMMER
HARVEST!
ALTERNATE DRYING IN SUMMER RISES SALINITY AND CROP LOSSES IN
SUMMER!
SRI EVOLUTION (YEAR-2)….
            • SRI WITH 1010 FARMERS ON
              OVER 470 ACRES (EVEN-AYLA)
            • REGISTRATION FEES VS. 8%
              DROP OUT
            • ALLOWED ORG+CHEMICAL IN
              SUMMER
            • USE OF EM-TECHNOLOGY
            • LOW LAND SRI ENHANCED
              50% YIELD:EARLY
              TRANSPLANTATION
            • 30 TO 40% CROP LOSS IN
              SUMMER
            • 118 FARMERS PRACTICED
              LOCAL VARIETIES (28% in low
              land,22% aromatic)
QUESTIONS ANSWERED(UN)(2ND


?                 YR)…..
WOULD THE DROP OUT RATE INCREASES IF THE INPUTS SUPPORT IS
MINIMUM?
WOULD THE FARMERS GO BACK TO PREVIOUS CHEMICAL N-P-K ONLY
AS THERE IS NO FYM/ORG. SUPPORT?
HOW TO PLAN FOR HIGH WATER ZONES IN ADVANCE?
HOW LONG TO EXPERIMENT WITH THE SUMMER RICE LOSSES?
IS THERE ANY ALTERNATIVE CROP FOR THE SALINE DELTA IN
SUMMER?
IS THIS ENOUGH TO ‘SEE’ THE FAMILIES ONLY IN THE KHARIF AND
FORGETING FOR 6 MONTHS?
HOW TO RESTRICT MIGRATION AND GETTING PEOPLE’S
NRM FAITH BACK WHEN HIGH SALINITY & NO SWEET
WATER?
SRI EVOLUTION (YEAR-3)…..
•   MAPPING THE WATER LEVELS FOR
    ALL VILLAGES
•   SRI WITH 1430 FARMERS
•   221 FARMERS WITH LOCAL VARIETY
    (54% IN THE LOW LAND, 17%
    AROMATIC)
•   SRI IN MUSTARD WITH THREE
    VARIETIES (B9,RP-09,RAIJATA) AS
    SUMMER ALTERNATIVE
•   NOMINAL DROP OUT DUE TO
    MIGRATION THOUGH MAJOR INPUTS
    CONTRIBUTION FROM FARMERS
•   SRI POCKETS HAVE BEEN DEVELOVED
•   THREE LOCAL SHOPS WITH CLEANED
    GODOWN OF DE-OIL CAKES AT THE
    END OF KHARIF…
QUESTIONS ANSWERED(UN)(3RD


?                YR)…..
 WOULD VILLAGERS TAKE UP THE MUSTARD CROP TO
REPLACE SUMMER RICE?
CAN SRI BE ALIGNED AS THE YEAR THE ROUND ACTIVITY?
LET’S EXPLORE HOW THE OVERALL SUPPORT COST
VARRIES OVER TIME!
WHAT IS THE “SRI INTERNALIZATION”
LEVEL OF THE COMMUNITY?
SRI EVOLUTION-4….


              •RICE WITH (929+1211)
              •FAMILIES
              •LIVELIHOODS PLAN
               WITH 50 SHGS-600 FAM
              •RICE-FISH-MUSTARD
              AS YEAR THE ROUND
               ACTIVITY
              •MUSTARD WITH-230
              FAMILES,RAIJATA
              VARIETY
GLANCING THROUGH THE EXTERNAL
       INVESTMENTS…..
SRI INTERNALIZATION-A CASE STUDY
          •   Transplanting:5/7/11
          •   Un-interrupted rain: 03/08/11 to 20/8/11
          •   Complete submergence:9/8/11
          •   Drained out:27/8/11
          •   Lost: 90% of hills
          •   Fertilization to survived hills: 29/08/11
          •   Re-transplanting the panicles: 04/09/11
          •   Weeding: 11/09 and 18/09/11
          •   Date of harvest: 13/12/12
          •   Average Ht.: 122.2 cm
          •   Panicle length: 27.5 cm
          •   Effective tillers: 16
          •   Grain/panicle(av.):271
          •   Chaffy/panicle:23
          •   1000 grain wt.:25 gm
          •   25 sq. mtr grain:13.5 kg.
              OVER 700 FARMERS FOLLOWED THIS METHOD
              AND HARVESTED GOOD RETURN IN THE DELTA
              in-spite of submergence loss
UNADDRESSED ISSUE OF SALINITY,SWEET
       WATER AND MIGRATION…..
                     PROBLEMS
                     • SUMMER SALINITY
                     • NO DRAINAGE
                     • NON AVAILABLE SWEET
                       WATER IN SUMMER
                     • LESS RETURN FROM NRM
                       LEADING TO MIGRATION
                     SOLUTION
                     • FAO OF UN RECOMENDS
SUNDARBANS             WATER HARVESTING
                       STRUCTURES (EX-SITU)
                       AS A SOLUTION
PRASARI HAS BEEN NEGOTIATING
WITH 3 GPs on FIVE SQUARE MODEL…




                               18
Investment and expected return from the 'five square model’
                                                            Rate
                                             Cft.           (Rs.)/cft      Amount(rs.)
                     Length (ft.)       55
                     width (ft)         55
Layer-1              depth (ft)          3           9075           1.56        14144.51
Layer-2              depth (ft)          3           6627           1.67        11080.20
Layer-3              depth (ft)          3           5043           1.76         8860.52
Leaching trench                                       300           1.56          467.59
  available water                                   23770
     total (Rs.)                                                                34552.81
 Rounded off (Rs.)                                                                35000
     Loss 30%                                        7131
   Net available-
      WATER                                         16639
      RETURN
                                                          WATER                        AVAILABLE
                 1RAIN-SEASON                AREA(SQ.FT) REQD.            RETURN(RS.) WATER
A                 RICE -SRI(SQ.FT)                   5724               0     2759.504        16639
B                 BUND-VEG (OKHRA)                   1452               0         9600        16639
                  HIGH-LAND VEG
C                 (OKHRA)                            2800             0           19200      16639
                 2FISH (MIX CULTURE)                 3025          5043            5000      11596
                 3POST-KHARIF                                                                11596
A                 MUSTARD-SRI                        5724          5724          6181.92      5872
                  BUND-VEG (bitter
B                 gourd)                             1452          1452             5120      4420
                  HIGH-LAND VEG (cue-
C                 cumber)                            2800          2800         4977.778      1620
                 4SUMMER                                                                      1620
                  BUND-VEG (RIDGE
A                 GOURD)                             1452          1452             3840       168
 TOTAL RETURN                                                                                         19
     (Rs.)                                                                      56679.2
WE ARE OPTIMISTIC, THIS MODEL
WOULD ADDRESS THE STATED ISSUES…..
KHARIF WATER STAGNATION & RESOURCE
    MAP PREPARED BY VILLAGERS…




                        BACK
RESEARCH WITH BCKV
ON STATION &ON FARM

1.NUTRIENT MANAGEMENT
2. WEED MANAGEMENT
3. WATER MANAGEMENT

ON FARM PARTNERS WITH BCKV
PRASARI
AMBUJA CEMENT FOUNDATION
!!!

Prasari west bengal

  • 1.
    Experience on Systemof Root Intensification in the Sundarbans PRASARI
  • 2.
    RIVER-BANK FAILURE+SEA WATER SUNDARBANS WATERLOG CROP LOSS RAINFALL+ SALINITY GING DRY SOIL+SALINE SURFACE
  • 3.
    Factors contributing … HIGH WATER SCARCITY SINGLE RAINFALL +HIGH SALINITY IN CROP-RICE+ IN JULY SUMMER (50% MORE) 1 acre av. land (753mm) SUBMERGENCE LOSS OF ONLY NOMINAL 1.91t/ha GROP (as high SECOND CROP 70%) FOOD INSECURITY+60% DISTRESSED MIGRATION
  • 4.
    PROBLEM STATEMENT… • WATERLOGGING AND NO DRAINAGE • MONO-CROPPED (LOW YIELD-RICE) • HIGHER SALINITY AND LESS SWEET WATER IN SUMMER • SMALL LANDHOLDING • LACK OF FODDER & ORGANIC MANURE (LIVESTOCK DECREASING) • LACK OF FAITH ON NRM-AGRIL. • MIGRATION
  • 5.
    PRESENTATION SUMMARY…. • SRIEVOLUTIONS 0th Year Year-1 Year-2 Year-3 • LEARNINGS • WAY-FORWARD…….
  • 6.
    SRI EVOLUTION (0THYR)… • PARESH DAS • LAND-LESS • LEASED-IN 10 dcml. LAND • SUMMER-07-08 • USED MOC+FYM CAKE • 240 KGS. OF RICE OVER TRADITIONAL 115 KGS.
  • 7.
    QUESTIONED ANSWERED(UN)(0TH ? YR)….. SRI CAN BE DONE IN THE SUNDARBANS! CAN IT BE CALLED AS SRI? HIGHER WATER DEPTH AND STAGNATION VS. ALTERNATE DRY/WET YOUNG AND SINGLE SEEDLING CAN SURVIVE WATER PRESSURE? WHAT WOULD BE THE NUTRIENT DOSES? THE TRADITIONAL VARIETIES WOULD ALSO RESPOND UNDER SRI? IF YOU CAN’T SEE THE SOIL UNDER WATER-WHERE TO USE WEEDER? WOULD PEOPLE REALY BE READY TO PUT THEIR LAND AT STAKE?
  • 8.
    SRI EVOLUTION (YEAR-1)….. •RECEIVED SUPPORT FROM SDTT • KHARIF-152 FARMERS IN 49 ACRE (+80 FARMERS IN SUMMER) • GREEN MANURE+DE-OIL CAKE BASED POP • 11 FARMERS TRIED LOCAL VARIETIES • 15 FARMERS LOST CROP IN SUMMER
  • 9.
    QUESTIONED ANSWERED(UN)(1ST ? YR)….. SRI IS ONLY FEASIBLE FOR THE UPLANDS? WHAT TO DO WHERE WATER STAGNATION IS VERY HIGH? WEEDER OPERATION CONTRIBUTES POSITIVELY TO THE YIELD EVEN IF YOU CAN’T SEE THE SOIL! ARE THE FARMERS TAKING UP SRI AS THEY ARE PROVIDED WITH THE INPUTS COST? SOURCE OF ORGANICS? LOCAL VARIETIES ARE DOING BETTER THAN THAT OF TRADITIONAL PRACTICES-AROMATIC/MORISHSHAL VARIETY WOULD ASSURE MORE RETURN UNDER SRI? DE-OIL CAKES REMAINED ‘CAKES’ EVEN AFTER THE SUMMER HARVEST! ALTERNATE DRYING IN SUMMER RISES SALINITY AND CROP LOSSES IN SUMMER!
  • 10.
    SRI EVOLUTION (YEAR-2)…. • SRI WITH 1010 FARMERS ON OVER 470 ACRES (EVEN-AYLA) • REGISTRATION FEES VS. 8% DROP OUT • ALLOWED ORG+CHEMICAL IN SUMMER • USE OF EM-TECHNOLOGY • LOW LAND SRI ENHANCED 50% YIELD:EARLY TRANSPLANTATION • 30 TO 40% CROP LOSS IN SUMMER • 118 FARMERS PRACTICED LOCAL VARIETIES (28% in low land,22% aromatic)
  • 11.
    QUESTIONS ANSWERED(UN)(2ND ? YR)….. WOULD THE DROP OUT RATE INCREASES IF THE INPUTS SUPPORT IS MINIMUM? WOULD THE FARMERS GO BACK TO PREVIOUS CHEMICAL N-P-K ONLY AS THERE IS NO FYM/ORG. SUPPORT? HOW TO PLAN FOR HIGH WATER ZONES IN ADVANCE? HOW LONG TO EXPERIMENT WITH THE SUMMER RICE LOSSES? IS THERE ANY ALTERNATIVE CROP FOR THE SALINE DELTA IN SUMMER? IS THIS ENOUGH TO ‘SEE’ THE FAMILIES ONLY IN THE KHARIF AND FORGETING FOR 6 MONTHS? HOW TO RESTRICT MIGRATION AND GETTING PEOPLE’S NRM FAITH BACK WHEN HIGH SALINITY & NO SWEET WATER?
  • 12.
    SRI EVOLUTION (YEAR-3)….. • MAPPING THE WATER LEVELS FOR ALL VILLAGES • SRI WITH 1430 FARMERS • 221 FARMERS WITH LOCAL VARIETY (54% IN THE LOW LAND, 17% AROMATIC) • SRI IN MUSTARD WITH THREE VARIETIES (B9,RP-09,RAIJATA) AS SUMMER ALTERNATIVE • NOMINAL DROP OUT DUE TO MIGRATION THOUGH MAJOR INPUTS CONTRIBUTION FROM FARMERS • SRI POCKETS HAVE BEEN DEVELOVED • THREE LOCAL SHOPS WITH CLEANED GODOWN OF DE-OIL CAKES AT THE END OF KHARIF…
  • 13.
    QUESTIONS ANSWERED(UN)(3RD ? YR)…..  WOULD VILLAGERS TAKE UP THE MUSTARD CROP TO REPLACE SUMMER RICE? CAN SRI BE ALIGNED AS THE YEAR THE ROUND ACTIVITY? LET’S EXPLORE HOW THE OVERALL SUPPORT COST VARRIES OVER TIME! WHAT IS THE “SRI INTERNALIZATION” LEVEL OF THE COMMUNITY?
  • 14.
    SRI EVOLUTION-4…. •RICE WITH (929+1211) •FAMILIES •LIVELIHOODS PLAN WITH 50 SHGS-600 FAM •RICE-FISH-MUSTARD AS YEAR THE ROUND ACTIVITY •MUSTARD WITH-230 FAMILES,RAIJATA VARIETY
  • 15.
    GLANCING THROUGH THEEXTERNAL INVESTMENTS…..
  • 16.
    SRI INTERNALIZATION-A CASESTUDY • Transplanting:5/7/11 • Un-interrupted rain: 03/08/11 to 20/8/11 • Complete submergence:9/8/11 • Drained out:27/8/11 • Lost: 90% of hills • Fertilization to survived hills: 29/08/11 • Re-transplanting the panicles: 04/09/11 • Weeding: 11/09 and 18/09/11 • Date of harvest: 13/12/12 • Average Ht.: 122.2 cm • Panicle length: 27.5 cm • Effective tillers: 16 • Grain/panicle(av.):271 • Chaffy/panicle:23 • 1000 grain wt.:25 gm • 25 sq. mtr grain:13.5 kg. OVER 700 FARMERS FOLLOWED THIS METHOD AND HARVESTED GOOD RETURN IN THE DELTA in-spite of submergence loss
  • 17.
    UNADDRESSED ISSUE OFSALINITY,SWEET WATER AND MIGRATION….. PROBLEMS • SUMMER SALINITY • NO DRAINAGE • NON AVAILABLE SWEET WATER IN SUMMER • LESS RETURN FROM NRM LEADING TO MIGRATION SOLUTION • FAO OF UN RECOMENDS SUNDARBANS WATER HARVESTING STRUCTURES (EX-SITU) AS A SOLUTION
  • 18.
    PRASARI HAS BEENNEGOTIATING WITH 3 GPs on FIVE SQUARE MODEL… 18
  • 19.
    Investment and expectedreturn from the 'five square model’ Rate Cft. (Rs.)/cft Amount(rs.) Length (ft.) 55 width (ft) 55 Layer-1 depth (ft) 3 9075 1.56 14144.51 Layer-2 depth (ft) 3 6627 1.67 11080.20 Layer-3 depth (ft) 3 5043 1.76 8860.52 Leaching trench 300 1.56 467.59 available water 23770 total (Rs.) 34552.81 Rounded off (Rs.) 35000 Loss 30% 7131 Net available- WATER 16639 RETURN WATER AVAILABLE 1RAIN-SEASON AREA(SQ.FT) REQD. RETURN(RS.) WATER A RICE -SRI(SQ.FT) 5724 0 2759.504 16639 B BUND-VEG (OKHRA) 1452 0 9600 16639 HIGH-LAND VEG C (OKHRA) 2800 0 19200 16639 2FISH (MIX CULTURE) 3025 5043 5000 11596 3POST-KHARIF 11596 A MUSTARD-SRI 5724 5724 6181.92 5872 BUND-VEG (bitter B gourd) 1452 1452 5120 4420 HIGH-LAND VEG (cue- C cumber) 2800 2800 4977.778 1620 4SUMMER 1620 BUND-VEG (RIDGE A GOURD) 1452 1452 3840 168 TOTAL RETURN 19 (Rs.) 56679.2
  • 20.
    WE ARE OPTIMISTIC,THIS MODEL WOULD ADDRESS THE STATED ISSUES…..
  • 21.
    KHARIF WATER STAGNATION& RESOURCE MAP PREPARED BY VILLAGERS… BACK
  • 22.
    RESEARCH WITH BCKV ONSTATION &ON FARM 1.NUTRIENT MANAGEMENT 2. WEED MANAGEMENT 3. WATER MANAGEMENT ON FARM PARTNERS WITH BCKV PRASARI AMBUJA CEMENT FOUNDATION
  • 23.

Editor's Notes

  • #4 Weak root system is due to less aeration. Delayed transplantation results in less panicle due to fall in temperature.