SlideShare a Scribd company logo
NagaCorp 3918 HK
The casino operator in Cambodia Nagacorp is a disruptor in the Asian casino market, especially
Macau. The share price is under pressure trading close to its lowest level in March 2020 and -
50% from the top during late 2019 only because the casino is currently closed. Would you like
to go back to March 2020 and buy high-quality assets at bargain prices? Then, this is your
opportunity!
I agree that a casino is a commodity business, however, Nagacorp has competitive advantages
that make it unique:
1. Monopoly license: Nagacorp operates a casino in Phnom Penh with a long-term license that
expires in 2065 and a monopoly within a 200km radius of Phnom Penh that expires in 2045,
with no limits on the amount of gaming space, tables or type of games. Macau has a
limitation on the number of tables and requires a periodic license renewal.
2. Low-cost player: A casino is a labor-intensive business. Wages, building costs, services… the
running cost is much lower in Cambodia. This offers a better value for money than the other
places, e.g., a croupier earns $3.500/month in Macau while the same dealer earns $400-
$500/month in Cambodia.
3. Low-tax country: Macau pays 35% of GGR (Gross Gaming Revenues) + 2-3% variable as
public development and social related contributions. Singapore 5% of VIP Market GGR and
15% of Mass Market. Philippines 17% VIP and 27% Mass and Vietnam 15% VIP and 35%
Mass. On the contrary, Nagacorp only pays 4% VIP and 7% Mass. Moreover, casinos in
Cambodia are exempt from corporate tax rate, while they pay 12% in Macao, 17% in
Singapore, 30% in Philippines and 20% in Vietnam. The low-tax and low-cost on the country
allow outsized returns on invested capital (i.e. 30% ROE)
4. Location: Cambodia is located in southeast Asia and is bordered by Thailand, Laos and
Vietnam. NagaWorld is in the capital, close to the main airport. The population within a one-
hour flight of Phnom Penh is over 165 million. Main Chinese cities are < three-hour flight.
5. Excellent business relation with Junkets: There are two big markets. Mass Market, mostly
driven by tourism and expat, while VIP market, (72% of Gross Gaming Revenue in 2019) is
propelled by “casino junkets”. Junkets are more than travel agents for high rollers. They
provide funding (hard for Chinese to get money out of China), arrange private games (rent
rooms from Nagacorp and share its profits) and other services. Due to Nagacorp’s
competitive advantage from gaming tax and low-cost country, it can pay higher commissions
(1.8% effective VIP commission rate vs 1.2% in Macau - Macao commission is restricted to
regulation) while maintaining the highest margins. (2019 numbers: Nagacorp 32.6% EBIT
Margin, Sands China 25.8% margin, Wynn Macau 17.8% margin)
6. Growth: Nagacorp first opened in 1995 a casino-vessel on the Mekong river. In 2003,
Nagacorp built NagaWorld replacing its maritime vessel with a luxury resort (Naga1) that
has recently been refurbished. In 2017, Nagacorp opened Naga2, which added 900 hotel
rooms to the 700 rooms in Naga 1 and more than doubled the number of gambling tables
to 500. Since the opening, Nagacorp VIP business increased 450% in three years as 4 of the
5 biggest Macao junkets signed with them. Due to the success, Nagacorp is building Naga3
(scheduled to late 2025) which will more than double the current number of gaming tables,
retail space and gross floor area.
7. Corporate governance: Nagacorp’s controlling shareholder, the founder Dr. Chen, owns
67% of the company. Nagacorp’s Chairman is Timothy Patrick and he was a Special Agent of
the Federal Bureau of Investigation (“FBI”) for almost 25 years. He brought the AML (Anti
money laundering) from Las Vegas. Moreover, Nagacorp pays 60% of its annual profit as a
dividend. Since the IPO (2006), $1.5bn were handed out in dividends out of $2.3bn profits
(compared to $3.9bn of current market cap).
8. Risks:
a. Regulatory risk: Low. 70-year-old Dr. Chen has a very good relationship with
Cambodian government and his son is involved too. Nagacorp is the highest labor
provider. In 2018, it represented 23% of local GDP tourism and 1.3% of Cambodia’s
GDP. In 2019, Nagacorp extended its monopolistic license from 2035 to 2045 and
during 2020 Cambodia leased 75 hectare-land near Angkor Wat in Siem Reap (major
Cambodia’s tourism draw) where Nagacorp expects to build a water theme park,
two hotels with a total of 700 5-star rooms, a boating canal system, China Town and
an indoor interactive Hi-Tech Theme Park. (UNESCO has delayed this project
because it does not fit their standards and it is only at 500 meters of the restricted
zone. Nagacorp is seeking some changes in order to go ahead with the project).
Finally, the government of Cambodia draw a draft that will be effective in 2022 and
reaffirmed the monopolistic license by law and a new casino tax-regulation that
ensures Nagacorp low-tax competitive advantage.
b. Country risk: Medium. After a long period of war, the king of Cambodia was
restored. Since then, Cambodia has experienced political stability through a
multiparty democracy under a constitutional monarchy. The Prime Minister Hun
Sen is in charge since 1996 and has consecutively won the elections every five years
(the last being in 2018). Cambodia has raised by >7% CAGR last 25 years being the
sixth highest growing-country in the world thanks to Chinese support (the Belt and
Road Initiative). Cambodia is indeed heavily influenced by China.
c. Company risk: Low. The debt markets were closed for Nagacorp until 2018 when
they issued a bond of $300M 9.375% Senior Notes Due 2021 in order to provide
credit to its VIP Market segment. Last year they issued $350M 7.95% Senior Notes
Due 2024 and they issued additional $200M 2024 maturity at 6.625% a few weeks
ago. I think this reduction in the debt cost implies a lower WACC and a higher
valuation multiple. (Historically, Nagacorp has traded at 8-10x EBITDA vs 15-18x
Macao peers)
d. COVID: Temporary. Cambodia is ranked the second most vaccinated nation among
ASEAN after Singapore. About 99% of Phnom Penh’s adult population is fully
vaccinated being one of the most vaccinated capital in the world. The government
expects to have more than 80% of the people vaccinated before the end of the year.
High vaccination rates are working with new daily infected cases declined to 400 vs
peak of 1130 cases in June 2021. The feedback I’ve got is that government is
planning to reopen the schools by mid/end of September and the Casino will open
during October. It is fair to say that Covid is pressing the business as the casino is
closed since last 2nd
March 2021. In 2020 they were closed for more than 3 months
but Nagacorp reported $102M profit, $45M of FCF and paid 92% of the profit as a
dividend. The VIP market was down 52% because the flights were restricted and
taking into account that their customers 50% from China and the remaining 50%
from Vietnam, Philippines and Thailand, while the Mass segment held on better due
to the expat (people that own business in Cambodia and are regular players). Note
that local people are not allowed to enter in the casino by law.
e. Capital increase: Low Nagacorp has a healthy balance sheet (0.8x 2020 EBITDA and
0.3x taking 2019 EBITDA). Naga 3 project is demand-driven and they might delay or
downsize the project. The project will be financed 50% from Nagacorp cashflow and
50% by the controlling shareholder that will sell his stake to Nagacorp through a
capital increase at 12 HKD (>20% premium on the announcement day and 64% at
today’s prices). Dr. Chen will increase his stake from 66% to 74% by late 2025. On
top of that, Dr. Chen has bought $79M on the secondary market during 2020 and
an extra $10M over the last week which supports our theory that a capital increase
is not needed. Naga3 is a big project, but the largest part of the capex needed
($3.5bn the whole project, $1.75bn Nagacorp stake) can be funded from internal
cashflow from 2022 to 2025 (they can reduce the payout for a couple of years) and
they now have access to cheap debt. Before Covid, Nagacorp expected to grow 10%
its topline and 8% its COGS from 2019 to 2025 generating $1.85bn of excess FCF
showing that they would fund their part only using internal cashflow while paying
60% of their profits as a dividend.
9. Internal estimates: We expect Nagacorp achieving 2019 revenue on 2H 2023. Nagacorp is
trading at less than 9x 2023 PE and less than 7x 2023 EV/EBITDA (assuming -5% EBITDA
growth compared to 2019 and -21% profit growth -new tax regulation effect-, which I agree
is conservative, especially taking as a reference how Nagacorp behaved on 2009 slowdown).
I forecast 60%-80% upside by the end of 2023 and >400% upside by the end of 2027 (28%
CAGR) when I expect Naga3 fully operating.
Nagacorp is a unique business well protected by a monopolistic license until 2045 that benefits
from the Asia growing and gambling structural trend. The company operates in a low-cost and
low-tax country that allows them to attract gamblers and generate outsized returns on invested
capital. The company is trading at Covid lows despite the debt market considers it safer and low-
risky.
Gabriel Castro, CFA

More Related Content

What's hot

DealBook of Ukraine: 2022 edition
DealBook of Ukraine: 2022 editionDealBook of Ukraine: 2022 edition
DealBook of Ukraine: 2022 edition
Yevgen Sysoyev
 
China Exit or Co-Investment Opportunities for German PE Investors
China Exit or Co-Investment Opportunities for German PE InvestorsChina Exit or Co-Investment Opportunities for German PE Investors
China Exit or Co-Investment Opportunities for German PE Investors
L.E.K. Consulting
 
Global Challengers 2018: Digital Leapfrogs
Global Challengers 2018: Digital LeapfrogsGlobal Challengers 2018: Digital Leapfrogs
Global Challengers 2018: Digital Leapfrogs
Boston Consulting Group
 
What’s Chipping Away at Automotive Production
What’s Chipping Away at Automotive ProductionWhat’s Chipping Away at Automotive Production
What’s Chipping Away at Automotive Production
Boston Consulting Group
 
EY India Attractiveness Survey 2015 – Reasons to Invest in India & Key Factor...
EY India Attractiveness Survey 2015 – Reasons to Invest in India & Key Factor...EY India Attractiveness Survey 2015 – Reasons to Invest in India & Key Factor...
EY India Attractiveness Survey 2015 – Reasons to Invest in India & Key Factor...
EY
 
Global Capital Confidence Barometer 21st edition
Global Capital Confidence Barometer 21st editionGlobal Capital Confidence Barometer 21st edition
Global Capital Confidence Barometer 21st edition
EY
 
COVID-19 Rapid Response Checklist for Nonprofits
COVID-19 Rapid Response Checklist for NonprofitsCOVID-19 Rapid Response Checklist for Nonprofits
COVID-19 Rapid Response Checklist for Nonprofits
Boston Consulting Group
 
EY's European Banking Barometer – 2015
EY's European Banking Barometer – 2015 EY's European Banking Barometer – 2015
EY's European Banking Barometer – 2015
EY
 
A.T. Kearney 2017 State of Logistics Report: Accelerating into Uncertainty
A.T. Kearney 2017 State of Logistics Report: Accelerating into UncertaintyA.T. Kearney 2017 State of Logistics Report: Accelerating into Uncertainty
A.T. Kearney 2017 State of Logistics Report: Accelerating into Uncertainty
Kearney
 
PwC's Global Technology IPO Review -- Q1 2015
PwC's Global Technology IPO Review -- Q1 2015PwC's Global Technology IPO Review -- Q1 2015
PwC's Global Technology IPO Review -- Q1 2015
PwC
 
EY Germany FinTech Landscape
EY Germany FinTech LandscapeEY Germany FinTech Landscape
EY Germany FinTech Landscape
EY
 
How fit is your capital allocation strategy?
How fit is your capital allocation strategy? How fit is your capital allocation strategy?
How fit is your capital allocation strategy?
EY
 
DealBook of Ukraine: 2021 edition
DealBook of Ukraine: 2021 editionDealBook of Ukraine: 2021 edition
DealBook of Ukraine: 2021 edition
Yevgen Sysoyev
 
A step-by-step overview of a typical cybersecurity attack—and how companies c...
A step-by-step overview of a typical cybersecurity attack—and how companies c...A step-by-step overview of a typical cybersecurity attack—and how companies c...
A step-by-step overview of a typical cybersecurity attack—and how companies c...
McKinsey & Company
 
The Great Mobility Tech Race: Winning the battle for future profits
The Great Mobility Tech Race: Winning the battle for future profitsThe Great Mobility Tech Race: Winning the battle for future profits
The Great Mobility Tech Race: Winning the battle for future profits
Boston Consulting Group
 
Tracxn - Geo Monthly Report - United States Tech - Mar 2022
Tracxn - Geo Monthly Report - United States Tech - Mar 2022Tracxn - Geo Monthly Report - United States Tech - Mar 2022
Tracxn - Geo Monthly Report - United States Tech - Mar 2022
Tracxn
 
True Luxury - 2014/2015 - BCG
True Luxury - 2014/2015 - BCGTrue Luxury - 2014/2015 - BCG
True Luxury - 2014/2015 - BCG
Gabriela Otto
 
Digital Consumers, Emerging Markets, and the $4 Trillion Future
Digital Consumers, Emerging Markets, and the $4 Trillion FutureDigital Consumers, Emerging Markets, and the $4 Trillion Future
Digital Consumers, Emerging Markets, and the $4 Trillion Future
Boston Consulting Group
 
Investors Book 2021
Investors Book 2021Investors Book 2021
AVentures DealBook 2020
AVentures DealBook 2020AVentures DealBook 2020
AVentures DealBook 2020
Yevgen Sysoyev
 

What's hot (20)

DealBook of Ukraine: 2022 edition
DealBook of Ukraine: 2022 editionDealBook of Ukraine: 2022 edition
DealBook of Ukraine: 2022 edition
 
China Exit or Co-Investment Opportunities for German PE Investors
China Exit or Co-Investment Opportunities for German PE InvestorsChina Exit or Co-Investment Opportunities for German PE Investors
China Exit or Co-Investment Opportunities for German PE Investors
 
Global Challengers 2018: Digital Leapfrogs
Global Challengers 2018: Digital LeapfrogsGlobal Challengers 2018: Digital Leapfrogs
Global Challengers 2018: Digital Leapfrogs
 
What’s Chipping Away at Automotive Production
What’s Chipping Away at Automotive ProductionWhat’s Chipping Away at Automotive Production
What’s Chipping Away at Automotive Production
 
EY India Attractiveness Survey 2015 – Reasons to Invest in India & Key Factor...
EY India Attractiveness Survey 2015 – Reasons to Invest in India & Key Factor...EY India Attractiveness Survey 2015 – Reasons to Invest in India & Key Factor...
EY India Attractiveness Survey 2015 – Reasons to Invest in India & Key Factor...
 
Global Capital Confidence Barometer 21st edition
Global Capital Confidence Barometer 21st editionGlobal Capital Confidence Barometer 21st edition
Global Capital Confidence Barometer 21st edition
 
COVID-19 Rapid Response Checklist for Nonprofits
COVID-19 Rapid Response Checklist for NonprofitsCOVID-19 Rapid Response Checklist for Nonprofits
COVID-19 Rapid Response Checklist for Nonprofits
 
EY's European Banking Barometer – 2015
EY's European Banking Barometer – 2015 EY's European Banking Barometer – 2015
EY's European Banking Barometer – 2015
 
A.T. Kearney 2017 State of Logistics Report: Accelerating into Uncertainty
A.T. Kearney 2017 State of Logistics Report: Accelerating into UncertaintyA.T. Kearney 2017 State of Logistics Report: Accelerating into Uncertainty
A.T. Kearney 2017 State of Logistics Report: Accelerating into Uncertainty
 
PwC's Global Technology IPO Review -- Q1 2015
PwC's Global Technology IPO Review -- Q1 2015PwC's Global Technology IPO Review -- Q1 2015
PwC's Global Technology IPO Review -- Q1 2015
 
EY Germany FinTech Landscape
EY Germany FinTech LandscapeEY Germany FinTech Landscape
EY Germany FinTech Landscape
 
How fit is your capital allocation strategy?
How fit is your capital allocation strategy? How fit is your capital allocation strategy?
How fit is your capital allocation strategy?
 
DealBook of Ukraine: 2021 edition
DealBook of Ukraine: 2021 editionDealBook of Ukraine: 2021 edition
DealBook of Ukraine: 2021 edition
 
A step-by-step overview of a typical cybersecurity attack—and how companies c...
A step-by-step overview of a typical cybersecurity attack—and how companies c...A step-by-step overview of a typical cybersecurity attack—and how companies c...
A step-by-step overview of a typical cybersecurity attack—and how companies c...
 
The Great Mobility Tech Race: Winning the battle for future profits
The Great Mobility Tech Race: Winning the battle for future profitsThe Great Mobility Tech Race: Winning the battle for future profits
The Great Mobility Tech Race: Winning the battle for future profits
 
Tracxn - Geo Monthly Report - United States Tech - Mar 2022
Tracxn - Geo Monthly Report - United States Tech - Mar 2022Tracxn - Geo Monthly Report - United States Tech - Mar 2022
Tracxn - Geo Monthly Report - United States Tech - Mar 2022
 
True Luxury - 2014/2015 - BCG
True Luxury - 2014/2015 - BCGTrue Luxury - 2014/2015 - BCG
True Luxury - 2014/2015 - BCG
 
Digital Consumers, Emerging Markets, and the $4 Trillion Future
Digital Consumers, Emerging Markets, and the $4 Trillion FutureDigital Consumers, Emerging Markets, and the $4 Trillion Future
Digital Consumers, Emerging Markets, and the $4 Trillion Future
 
Investors Book 2021
Investors Book 2021Investors Book 2021
Investors Book 2021
 
AVentures DealBook 2020
AVentures DealBook 2020AVentures DealBook 2020
AVentures DealBook 2020
 

Similar to Naga corp 3918 hk

Global Telecom - Re-Intitation of coverage December, 2016
Global Telecom - Re-Intitation of coverage December, 2016Global Telecom - Re-Intitation of coverage December, 2016
Global Telecom - Re-Intitation of coverage December, 2016Taher Seif, CFA
 
AsiaGaming300415e210559
AsiaGaming300415e210559AsiaGaming300415e210559
AsiaGaming300415e210559Jamie Zhou
 
Northcourt H1 2019 Nigerian Real Estate Market Review report
Northcourt H1 2019 Nigerian Real Estate Market Review reportNorthcourt H1 2019 Nigerian Real Estate Market Review report
Northcourt H1 2019 Nigerian Real Estate Market Review report
Ayo Ibaru
 
I Bytes Business Services Industry
I Bytes Business Services IndustryI Bytes Business Services Industry
I Bytes Business Services Industry
EGBG Services
 
58284. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT_ND-2022_Question.pdf
58284. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT_ND-2022_Question.pdf58284. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT_ND-2022_Question.pdf
58284. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT_ND-2022_Question.pdf
Sazzad Hossain, ITP, MBA, CSCA™
 
Marina Bay Sands, Singapore
Marina Bay Sands, SingaporeMarina Bay Sands, Singapore
Marina Bay Sands, Singapore
Razvan Julian Petrescu
 
Travel & transportation
Travel & transportation Travel & transportation
Travel & transportation
EGBG Services
 
I Bytes Telecommunication & Media Industry
I Bytes Telecommunication & Media IndustryI Bytes Telecommunication & Media Industry
I Bytes Telecommunication & Media Industry
EGBG Services
 
Mnhd valuation update - april 2017
Mnhd   valuation update - april 2017Mnhd   valuation update - april 2017
Mnhd valuation update - april 2017
Mohamed Marei
 
Fin 515-week-3-problem-set
Fin 515-week-3-problem-setFin 515-week-3-problem-set
Fin 515-week-3-problem-set
aagnaa
 
IMAN pitch deck
IMAN pitch deckIMAN pitch deck
IMAN pitch deck
Tech in Asia
 
Platforms & Applications
Platforms & ApplicationsPlatforms & Applications
Platforms & Applications
EGBG Services
 
APEX_FinancialReportFinal
APEX_FinancialReportFinalAPEX_FinancialReportFinal
APEX_FinancialReportFinalHazel Sy
 
I Bytes business service industry
I Bytes business service industryI Bytes business service industry
I Bytes business service industry
EGBG Services
 
Ch 3 Problem Solving Quiz
Ch 3 Problem Solving QuizCh 3 Problem Solving Quiz
Ch 3 Problem Solving Quiz
Mikee Bylss
 
I Bytes Travel & Transportation industry
I Bytes Travel & Transportation industryI Bytes Travel & Transportation industry
I Bytes Travel & Transportation industry
EGBG Services
 
QNBFS Weekly Market Report July 26, 2018.
QNBFS Weekly Market Report July 26, 2018. QNBFS Weekly Market Report July 26, 2018.
QNBFS Weekly Market Report July 26, 2018.
QNB Group
 
Emperor Entertainment Hotel (296 HK): A Weighted Coin
Emperor Entertainment Hotel (296 HK): A Weighted CoinEmperor Entertainment Hotel (296 HK): A Weighted Coin
Emperor Entertainment Hotel (296 HK): A Weighted Coin
Brian Grosso
 

Similar to Naga corp 3918 hk (20)

Global Telecom - Re-Intitation of coverage December, 2016
Global Telecom - Re-Intitation of coverage December, 2016Global Telecom - Re-Intitation of coverage December, 2016
Global Telecom - Re-Intitation of coverage December, 2016
 
AsiaGaming300415e210559
AsiaGaming300415e210559AsiaGaming300415e210559
AsiaGaming300415e210559
 
Northcourt H1 2019 Nigerian Real Estate Market Review report
Northcourt H1 2019 Nigerian Real Estate Market Review reportNorthcourt H1 2019 Nigerian Real Estate Market Review report
Northcourt H1 2019 Nigerian Real Estate Market Review report
 
I Bytes Business Services Industry
I Bytes Business Services IndustryI Bytes Business Services Industry
I Bytes Business Services Industry
 
58284. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT_ND-2022_Question.pdf
58284. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT_ND-2022_Question.pdf58284. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT_ND-2022_Question.pdf
58284. FINANCIAL MANAGEMENT_ND-2022_Question.pdf
 
Marina Bay Sands, Singapore
Marina Bay Sands, SingaporeMarina Bay Sands, Singapore
Marina Bay Sands, Singapore
 
Travel & transportation
Travel & transportation Travel & transportation
Travel & transportation
 
Tencent
TencentTencent
Tencent
 
I Bytes Telecommunication & Media Industry
I Bytes Telecommunication & Media IndustryI Bytes Telecommunication & Media Industry
I Bytes Telecommunication & Media Industry
 
2016 TMT-MSFT
2016 TMT-MSFT2016 TMT-MSFT
2016 TMT-MSFT
 
Mnhd valuation update - april 2017
Mnhd   valuation update - april 2017Mnhd   valuation update - april 2017
Mnhd valuation update - april 2017
 
Fin 515-week-3-problem-set
Fin 515-week-3-problem-setFin 515-week-3-problem-set
Fin 515-week-3-problem-set
 
IMAN pitch deck
IMAN pitch deckIMAN pitch deck
IMAN pitch deck
 
Platforms & Applications
Platforms & ApplicationsPlatforms & Applications
Platforms & Applications
 
APEX_FinancialReportFinal
APEX_FinancialReportFinalAPEX_FinancialReportFinal
APEX_FinancialReportFinal
 
I Bytes business service industry
I Bytes business service industryI Bytes business service industry
I Bytes business service industry
 
Ch 3 Problem Solving Quiz
Ch 3 Problem Solving QuizCh 3 Problem Solving Quiz
Ch 3 Problem Solving Quiz
 
I Bytes Travel & Transportation industry
I Bytes Travel & Transportation industryI Bytes Travel & Transportation industry
I Bytes Travel & Transportation industry
 
QNBFS Weekly Market Report July 26, 2018.
QNBFS Weekly Market Report July 26, 2018. QNBFS Weekly Market Report July 26, 2018.
QNBFS Weekly Market Report July 26, 2018.
 
Emperor Entertainment Hotel (296 HK): A Weighted Coin
Emperor Entertainment Hotel (296 HK): A Weighted CoinEmperor Entertainment Hotel (296 HK): A Weighted Coin
Emperor Entertainment Hotel (296 HK): A Weighted Coin
 

Recently uploaded

Investor Day 2024 Presentation Sysco 2024
Investor Day 2024 Presentation Sysco 2024Investor Day 2024 Presentation Sysco 2024
Investor Day 2024 Presentation Sysco 2024
Sysco_Investors
 
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
CollectiveMining1
 
Snam 2023-27 Industrial Plan - Financial Presentation
Snam 2023-27 Industrial Plan - Financial PresentationSnam 2023-27 Industrial Plan - Financial Presentation
Snam 2023-27 Industrial Plan - Financial Presentation
Valentina Ottini
 
New Tax Regime User Guide Flexi Plan Revised (1).pptx
New Tax Regime User Guide Flexi Plan Revised (1).pptxNew Tax Regime User Guide Flexi Plan Revised (1).pptx
New Tax Regime User Guide Flexi Plan Revised (1).pptx
RajkumarRajamanikam
 
Corporate Presentation Probe June 2024.pdf
Corporate Presentation Probe June 2024.pdfCorporate Presentation Probe June 2024.pdf
Corporate Presentation Probe June 2024.pdf
Probe Gold
 
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
CollectiveMining1
 
cyberagent_For New Investors_EN_240424.pdf
cyberagent_For New Investors_EN_240424.pdfcyberagent_For New Investors_EN_240424.pdf
cyberagent_For New Investors_EN_240424.pdf
CyberAgent, Inc.
 
Osisko Development - Investor Presentation - June 24
Osisko Development - Investor Presentation - June 24Osisko Development - Investor Presentation - June 24
Osisko Development - Investor Presentation - June 24
Philip Rabenok
 

Recently uploaded (8)

Investor Day 2024 Presentation Sysco 2024
Investor Day 2024 Presentation Sysco 2024Investor Day 2024 Presentation Sysco 2024
Investor Day 2024 Presentation Sysco 2024
 
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
 
Snam 2023-27 Industrial Plan - Financial Presentation
Snam 2023-27 Industrial Plan - Financial PresentationSnam 2023-27 Industrial Plan - Financial Presentation
Snam 2023-27 Industrial Plan - Financial Presentation
 
New Tax Regime User Guide Flexi Plan Revised (1).pptx
New Tax Regime User Guide Flexi Plan Revised (1).pptxNew Tax Regime User Guide Flexi Plan Revised (1).pptx
New Tax Regime User Guide Flexi Plan Revised (1).pptx
 
Corporate Presentation Probe June 2024.pdf
Corporate Presentation Probe June 2024.pdfCorporate Presentation Probe June 2024.pdf
Corporate Presentation Probe June 2024.pdf
 
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
Collective Mining | Corporate Presentation - May 2024
 
cyberagent_For New Investors_EN_240424.pdf
cyberagent_For New Investors_EN_240424.pdfcyberagent_For New Investors_EN_240424.pdf
cyberagent_For New Investors_EN_240424.pdf
 
Osisko Development - Investor Presentation - June 24
Osisko Development - Investor Presentation - June 24Osisko Development - Investor Presentation - June 24
Osisko Development - Investor Presentation - June 24
 

Naga corp 3918 hk

  • 1. NagaCorp 3918 HK The casino operator in Cambodia Nagacorp is a disruptor in the Asian casino market, especially Macau. The share price is under pressure trading close to its lowest level in March 2020 and - 50% from the top during late 2019 only because the casino is currently closed. Would you like to go back to March 2020 and buy high-quality assets at bargain prices? Then, this is your opportunity! I agree that a casino is a commodity business, however, Nagacorp has competitive advantages that make it unique: 1. Monopoly license: Nagacorp operates a casino in Phnom Penh with a long-term license that expires in 2065 and a monopoly within a 200km radius of Phnom Penh that expires in 2045, with no limits on the amount of gaming space, tables or type of games. Macau has a limitation on the number of tables and requires a periodic license renewal. 2. Low-cost player: A casino is a labor-intensive business. Wages, building costs, services… the running cost is much lower in Cambodia. This offers a better value for money than the other places, e.g., a croupier earns $3.500/month in Macau while the same dealer earns $400- $500/month in Cambodia. 3. Low-tax country: Macau pays 35% of GGR (Gross Gaming Revenues) + 2-3% variable as public development and social related contributions. Singapore 5% of VIP Market GGR and 15% of Mass Market. Philippines 17% VIP and 27% Mass and Vietnam 15% VIP and 35% Mass. On the contrary, Nagacorp only pays 4% VIP and 7% Mass. Moreover, casinos in Cambodia are exempt from corporate tax rate, while they pay 12% in Macao, 17% in Singapore, 30% in Philippines and 20% in Vietnam. The low-tax and low-cost on the country allow outsized returns on invested capital (i.e. 30% ROE) 4. Location: Cambodia is located in southeast Asia and is bordered by Thailand, Laos and Vietnam. NagaWorld is in the capital, close to the main airport. The population within a one- hour flight of Phnom Penh is over 165 million. Main Chinese cities are < three-hour flight. 5. Excellent business relation with Junkets: There are two big markets. Mass Market, mostly driven by tourism and expat, while VIP market, (72% of Gross Gaming Revenue in 2019) is propelled by “casino junkets”. Junkets are more than travel agents for high rollers. They provide funding (hard for Chinese to get money out of China), arrange private games (rent rooms from Nagacorp and share its profits) and other services. Due to Nagacorp’s competitive advantage from gaming tax and low-cost country, it can pay higher commissions (1.8% effective VIP commission rate vs 1.2% in Macau - Macao commission is restricted to regulation) while maintaining the highest margins. (2019 numbers: Nagacorp 32.6% EBIT Margin, Sands China 25.8% margin, Wynn Macau 17.8% margin) 6. Growth: Nagacorp first opened in 1995 a casino-vessel on the Mekong river. In 2003, Nagacorp built NagaWorld replacing its maritime vessel with a luxury resort (Naga1) that has recently been refurbished. In 2017, Nagacorp opened Naga2, which added 900 hotel rooms to the 700 rooms in Naga 1 and more than doubled the number of gambling tables to 500. Since the opening, Nagacorp VIP business increased 450% in three years as 4 of the 5 biggest Macao junkets signed with them. Due to the success, Nagacorp is building Naga3 (scheduled to late 2025) which will more than double the current number of gaming tables, retail space and gross floor area. 7. Corporate governance: Nagacorp’s controlling shareholder, the founder Dr. Chen, owns 67% of the company. Nagacorp’s Chairman is Timothy Patrick and he was a Special Agent of the Federal Bureau of Investigation (“FBI”) for almost 25 years. He brought the AML (Anti
  • 2. money laundering) from Las Vegas. Moreover, Nagacorp pays 60% of its annual profit as a dividend. Since the IPO (2006), $1.5bn were handed out in dividends out of $2.3bn profits (compared to $3.9bn of current market cap). 8. Risks: a. Regulatory risk: Low. 70-year-old Dr. Chen has a very good relationship with Cambodian government and his son is involved too. Nagacorp is the highest labor provider. In 2018, it represented 23% of local GDP tourism and 1.3% of Cambodia’s GDP. In 2019, Nagacorp extended its monopolistic license from 2035 to 2045 and during 2020 Cambodia leased 75 hectare-land near Angkor Wat in Siem Reap (major Cambodia’s tourism draw) where Nagacorp expects to build a water theme park, two hotels with a total of 700 5-star rooms, a boating canal system, China Town and an indoor interactive Hi-Tech Theme Park. (UNESCO has delayed this project because it does not fit their standards and it is only at 500 meters of the restricted zone. Nagacorp is seeking some changes in order to go ahead with the project). Finally, the government of Cambodia draw a draft that will be effective in 2022 and reaffirmed the monopolistic license by law and a new casino tax-regulation that ensures Nagacorp low-tax competitive advantage. b. Country risk: Medium. After a long period of war, the king of Cambodia was restored. Since then, Cambodia has experienced political stability through a multiparty democracy under a constitutional monarchy. The Prime Minister Hun Sen is in charge since 1996 and has consecutively won the elections every five years (the last being in 2018). Cambodia has raised by >7% CAGR last 25 years being the sixth highest growing-country in the world thanks to Chinese support (the Belt and Road Initiative). Cambodia is indeed heavily influenced by China. c. Company risk: Low. The debt markets were closed for Nagacorp until 2018 when they issued a bond of $300M 9.375% Senior Notes Due 2021 in order to provide credit to its VIP Market segment. Last year they issued $350M 7.95% Senior Notes Due 2024 and they issued additional $200M 2024 maturity at 6.625% a few weeks ago. I think this reduction in the debt cost implies a lower WACC and a higher valuation multiple. (Historically, Nagacorp has traded at 8-10x EBITDA vs 15-18x Macao peers) d. COVID: Temporary. Cambodia is ranked the second most vaccinated nation among ASEAN after Singapore. About 99% of Phnom Penh’s adult population is fully vaccinated being one of the most vaccinated capital in the world. The government expects to have more than 80% of the people vaccinated before the end of the year. High vaccination rates are working with new daily infected cases declined to 400 vs peak of 1130 cases in June 2021. The feedback I’ve got is that government is planning to reopen the schools by mid/end of September and the Casino will open during October. It is fair to say that Covid is pressing the business as the casino is closed since last 2nd March 2021. In 2020 they were closed for more than 3 months but Nagacorp reported $102M profit, $45M of FCF and paid 92% of the profit as a dividend. The VIP market was down 52% because the flights were restricted and taking into account that their customers 50% from China and the remaining 50% from Vietnam, Philippines and Thailand, while the Mass segment held on better due to the expat (people that own business in Cambodia and are regular players). Note that local people are not allowed to enter in the casino by law. e. Capital increase: Low Nagacorp has a healthy balance sheet (0.8x 2020 EBITDA and 0.3x taking 2019 EBITDA). Naga 3 project is demand-driven and they might delay or
  • 3. downsize the project. The project will be financed 50% from Nagacorp cashflow and 50% by the controlling shareholder that will sell his stake to Nagacorp through a capital increase at 12 HKD (>20% premium on the announcement day and 64% at today’s prices). Dr. Chen will increase his stake from 66% to 74% by late 2025. On top of that, Dr. Chen has bought $79M on the secondary market during 2020 and an extra $10M over the last week which supports our theory that a capital increase is not needed. Naga3 is a big project, but the largest part of the capex needed ($3.5bn the whole project, $1.75bn Nagacorp stake) can be funded from internal cashflow from 2022 to 2025 (they can reduce the payout for a couple of years) and they now have access to cheap debt. Before Covid, Nagacorp expected to grow 10% its topline and 8% its COGS from 2019 to 2025 generating $1.85bn of excess FCF showing that they would fund their part only using internal cashflow while paying 60% of their profits as a dividend. 9. Internal estimates: We expect Nagacorp achieving 2019 revenue on 2H 2023. Nagacorp is trading at less than 9x 2023 PE and less than 7x 2023 EV/EBITDA (assuming -5% EBITDA growth compared to 2019 and -21% profit growth -new tax regulation effect-, which I agree is conservative, especially taking as a reference how Nagacorp behaved on 2009 slowdown). I forecast 60%-80% upside by the end of 2023 and >400% upside by the end of 2027 (28% CAGR) when I expect Naga3 fully operating. Nagacorp is a unique business well protected by a monopolistic license until 2045 that benefits from the Asia growing and gambling structural trend. The company operates in a low-cost and low-tax country that allows them to attract gamblers and generate outsized returns on invested capital. The company is trading at Covid lows despite the debt market considers it safer and low- risky. Gabriel Castro, CFA