The document discusses Boulder, Colorado's 2011 ballot initiative to municipalize its electric utility. It passed, allowing the city to condemn Xcel Energy's local distribution assets. However, the city faces challenges as many of the critical transmission assets are outside city limits. There are also concerns that the criteria being used to evaluate municipalization do not adequately address reliability, rates and costs. If the city proceeds, it could face years of litigation and take on hundreds of millions in debt to operate its own utility, potentially raising rates and losing businesses. Alternatives like renewable programs partnered with Xcel may better meet energy goals at lower risk and cost.
'Review: Community Media Association Conference & Annual General Meeting: 2 N...Grant Goddard
Notes from the Conference and Annual General Meeting of the Community Media Association held in London, UK on 2 November 2002, written by Grant Goddard in November 2002.
PLTC 2013: Electronic Filing in BC: What’s New and How to Use Client-Centric...Dye and Durham Corporation
eFiling is today’s norm. This session examines efiling in our registries, courts and boards and how best to configure your office technology to achieve the best results.
'Review: Community Media Association Conference & Annual General Meeting: 2 N...Grant Goddard
Notes from the Conference and Annual General Meeting of the Community Media Association held in London, UK on 2 November 2002, written by Grant Goddard in November 2002.
PLTC 2013: Electronic Filing in BC: What’s New and How to Use Client-Centric...Dye and Durham Corporation
eFiling is today’s norm. This session examines efiling in our registries, courts and boards and how best to configure your office technology to achieve the best results.
Interesting study "Smarter Neighborhoods, Smarter City" contains detailed recommendations on how to help America's largest urban area - the City of New York - plan for more sustainable growth.
Hoosier Environmental Council Green Drinks Presentation219GreenConnect
HEC Executive Director, Jesse Kharbanda, and Water/Agricultural Policy Director, Kim Ferraro, offered an informative presentation at Green Drinks in Valparaiso, Indiana on 5/21/12.
Learn about the City of Boulder's municipalization effort. This presentation covers background on the project, the city's climate and energy goals and the 2017 PUC process.
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation's (CMHC) Municipal Infrastructure Len...MaRS Discovery District
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation's (CMHC) Municipal Infrastructure Lending Program
Speaker: Mark Salerno, National Sales Team Leader, Municipal Infrastructure Lending Program, CMHC
Part of the 2010 Community Power Finance Forum at MaRS:
http://www.marsdd.com/communitypower
Benicia Industrial Gigabit Broadband Project Assessment and PlanStephen Blum
A fiber to the premise plan for the Benicia Industrial Park is kicked off. Steve Blum, president of Tellus Venture Associates, presents an analysis and strategic plan to the Benicia City Council on 2 July 2013.
UNDERSTANDING THE DEBATE OVER GOVERNMENT-OWNED BROADBAND NETWORKSEd Dodds
Context, Lessons Learned, and a Way Forward for Policy Makers Cedar Falls Case Study Charles M. Davidson Director, ACLP at New York Law School Michael J. Santorelli Director, ACLP at New York Law School From JUNE 2014
Community Choice Energy for Policymakers organized by Business for Clean Energy, Joint Venture Silicon Valley, and the Cities Association of Santa Clara County. Hosted by Microsoft.
Genevieve Cullen, President of the Electric Drive Transportation Association, gave this presentation at Drive Oregon's event on December 1, 2016. In her presentation, Genevieve gave a recap of the election results and outlined how clean car policy may be influenced.
Learn more about us and our events at www.driveoregon.org.
Interesting study "Smarter Neighborhoods, Smarter City" contains detailed recommendations on how to help America's largest urban area - the City of New York - plan for more sustainable growth.
Hoosier Environmental Council Green Drinks Presentation219GreenConnect
HEC Executive Director, Jesse Kharbanda, and Water/Agricultural Policy Director, Kim Ferraro, offered an informative presentation at Green Drinks in Valparaiso, Indiana on 5/21/12.
Learn about the City of Boulder's municipalization effort. This presentation covers background on the project, the city's climate and energy goals and the 2017 PUC process.
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation's (CMHC) Municipal Infrastructure Len...MaRS Discovery District
Canada Mortgage and Housing Corporation's (CMHC) Municipal Infrastructure Lending Program
Speaker: Mark Salerno, National Sales Team Leader, Municipal Infrastructure Lending Program, CMHC
Part of the 2010 Community Power Finance Forum at MaRS:
http://www.marsdd.com/communitypower
Benicia Industrial Gigabit Broadband Project Assessment and PlanStephen Blum
A fiber to the premise plan for the Benicia Industrial Park is kicked off. Steve Blum, president of Tellus Venture Associates, presents an analysis and strategic plan to the Benicia City Council on 2 July 2013.
UNDERSTANDING THE DEBATE OVER GOVERNMENT-OWNED BROADBAND NETWORKSEd Dodds
Context, Lessons Learned, and a Way Forward for Policy Makers Cedar Falls Case Study Charles M. Davidson Director, ACLP at New York Law School Michael J. Santorelli Director, ACLP at New York Law School From JUNE 2014
Community Choice Energy for Policymakers organized by Business for Clean Energy, Joint Venture Silicon Valley, and the Cities Association of Santa Clara County. Hosted by Microsoft.
Genevieve Cullen, President of the Electric Drive Transportation Association, gave this presentation at Drive Oregon's event on December 1, 2016. In her presentation, Genevieve gave a recap of the election results and outlined how clean car policy may be influenced.
Learn more about us and our events at www.driveoregon.org.
2. Why is this an issue today?
Question 2C
(allowing the formation of a municipal utility)
Yes: 13,784, 51.93%
No: 12,757, 48.07%
The ballot language allows the city to sell unlimited
revenue bonds to condemn assets and pay separation
costs plus stranded asset settlements to Xcel Energy.
3. 2011 Ballot Question No. 2C
Light and Power Utility
Shall the City of Boulder have the authority to establish, acquire, erect, maintain, and
operate, by any lawful means, a municipal light and power utility with programs and
improvements that include without limitation generation plants, renewable energy, energy
conservation, and distribution systems, with all necessary powers appurtenant thereto if the
city council determines that it can acquire the electrical distribution system in Boulder and
charge rates that do not exceed those rates charged by Xcel Energy at the time of acquisition
and that such rates will produce revenues sufficient to pay for operating expenses and debt
payments, plus an amount equal to twenty-five percent (25%) of the debt payments; and with
the reliability comparable to Xcel Energy
Shall the City, acting through the utility, issue enterprise revenue bonds payable solely from
the net revenues of the utility, to finance the costs of acquiring from Xcel Energy and any
affiliate thereof, and constructing, relocating, installing, improving, completing or expanding
the equipment, facilities and other assets comprising an existing electric distribution system
within or outside the City’s boundaries, and paying all necessary or incidental costs related
thereto, and shall the City have the authority to adopt all means necessary or appropriate to
carry out the requirements, purpose and intent of this measure?
To date, City Council has allocated an additional $300,000 from the city's general
fund to cover municipalization cost overruns. Already in violation of the ballot charter?
4. Summary Take-Away
The municipalization decision criteria measurements, as designed by Heather Bailey and
staff, are rigged. If they pass City Council vote approval November 15, Bailey will have
little trouble in avoiding a Council municipalization “off-ramp decision” and subsequent
vote to proceed to condemnation court in March 2013. The rest of the process is
mostly for show. Bailey is staffing up now for starting a Municipal Power Company.
After condemnation filing, we pay for a multi-year legal battle with Xcel Energy, the
Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, and many other electric power users in
Colorado. Legal costs are estimated near $10 million and will need taxpayer funding.
Businesses will avoid expansion or location in Boulder while this power battle rages.
How can we protect Boulder?
1. Write and call 6 members of City Council before Thursday, November 15
Vote NO on Heather Bailey's "off-ramp avoidance" criteria.
Vote YES on Ken Wilson's "municipalization decision addenda" at Council on
November 15.
2. Fight the city’s annexation of the East Boulder periphery properties in the interest
of the public and property owners – and all Boulder residents. If the city doesn’t have
jurisdiction over some critical Xcel assets, they can’t seize them through
condemnation. Who wants the 1923 Valmont power plant anyway?
6. Is a Boulder City seizure, settlement and separation of
Xcel’s distribution assets in Boulder a solution to
greenhouse gas emissions? NO!
7. Boulder City Government
Heather Bailey
Executive Director of Energy Strategy and
Electric Utility Development
Compensation exceeds $250K per year
Consists of the Mayor,
Deputy Mayor and City Council
seven council members
In Charge of City Manager Jane
Boards, Commissions,
implementing initiatives Brautigam appointed by
Divisions
approved by the Council City Council
Boulder Energy
17 staff members also Future Project City Manager’s 17 City Staff
listed to aid the project Directed by Directors members
Heather Bailey
Source: www.bouldercolorado.com
8. Boulder Energy Future Project Resources
Events leading to an increase in funding:
• Voter-approved Measure 2B instituted a tax to provide $1.9
million to the project annually during the initial phases to cover
study expenditures.
• The City Manager recommended that the council allocate
$300,000 from the city’s general fund to cover staff member
costs.
• Some of the unnamed consultants included in staff member
costs receive rates of $900 per hour.
(Source: The Boulder Daily Camera, Rising Costs in Boulder Municipalization Study, October 29, 2012)
• Bouldercolorado.gov discloses that the project has employed
a number of consultants, without providing their identities.
• The project has selected Duncan & Allen as FERC attorneys,
and Duncan, Ostrander & Dingess to represent the city in any
future condemnation proceedings with Xcel Energy.
9. ---------------------------------------- Left Blank! ----------------------------------------------------
City Council will vote November 15, 2012 on the adequacy of the “charter
requirement” proposed metrics as the “off-ramp” decision criteria in fulfillment
of Ballot Measure 2C.
Following this vote, other criteria may not be considered.
Heather Bailey Verbal:
February 25th - Council Study Session to discuss complete strategy options and ask
clarifying questions/request further information. No votes are taken at Study Sessions
March 19th - Council Study Session to vote on complete strategy options.
10. State Control of Power Monopolies?
"Praise Joseph Stalin, the great protector of communism!"
Didn’t work out so well.
11. Likely Outcomes of Boulder City
Council Control of Local Monopoly
• Punitive Commercial
Rate Structures
(80% of total demand)
• Forever lose consumer rate and reliability protection
of Colorado Public Utilities Commission
– No legal recourse with City Council
• Technical and manpower limits to power reliability
13. Xcel assets in Boulder are not a local grid
(they serve the whole area)
Xcel monitoring and dispatch are in remote bunker
facilities near Golden – not Boulder. Not condemnable!
14. Transmission Stations
Boulder City Limits
Louisville/Lafayette/Su
perior City Limits
Transmission lines
Boulder Council cannot condemn Xcel
assets that are not within city borders.
Hence the letters and proceedings
started to annex critical Xcel property
and feeders on the East side of Boulder.
Stop annexation! You have legal rights.
15. Closing the Transmission Loop: South Boulder County on the way to Louisville and Valmont
Separation Problem: Belongs to Xcel Energy. Can’t be condemned since outside of Boulder city.
16. The “Not in Boulder” Electrical Transmission Lariat
Boulder
Valmont Plant
Leggett Terminal
17.
18. Existing Boulder Commercial Rates are like sausage. Don’t know
what is inside. So how can Heather Bailey claim rate equivalence?
Modeling commercial rates on only three category averages creates inflated revenue
expectations for a Boulder Municipal Power Company – plus “sticker shock” for businesses.
19. Big Problem with Bailey’s decision metric! The majority of existing commercial rates
don’t match simple categories. 80% of Boulder power is commercial and industrial.
20. Primary Transmission Customers in Colorado
Will stop investing in Boulder
Will self generate rather than
participate in Boulder municipal
21. Bonding Boulder Municipal Power - by Gaming Debt Service Coverage Ratio
(Interest time deferrals lead to customer power rate increases in later years)
Easy to Game DSCR with Deferred Tranches
22. Boulder Municipal Power Monopoly Decision
$10 million of lawyers and hearings
proceeding 2013 to 2017(?)
followed by:
$300 to $600 million of debt for:
• Xcel asset settlements
• separation engineering
• new dispatch + transmission construction
• start-up costs for service and ops people
• punitive rates that drive business out
Versus
• Incremental renewable generation
programs and incentives with return
on investment for business and gov.
• Demand destruction incentives
where Xcel suffers, not a city power
monopoly suffering
• Negotiate and implement a
broader set of interconnections with
Xcel and the PUC for micro grids
(University of Colorado example)
23. Dear Council Member,
Please vote NO on proceeding with inadequate financial, rate and reliability
decision criteria for Municipalization on November 15. I would like to
continue living or working in Boulder with affordable and reliable power.
There are far less costly and lengthy paths for implementing renewable
generation and energy efficiency goals in our city.
council@bouldercolorado.gov
Call council members who have supported proceeding with Heather Bailey’s
“off-ramp avoidance” criteria, and ask them to support open governance for
Boulder. Publish decision dates, reliability concerns and financial risks.
Matt Appelbaum 303-499-8970 AppelbaumM@bouldercolorado.gov
KC Becker 303-218-8814 beckerk@bouldercolorado.gov
Macon Cowles 303-638-6884 CowlesM@bouldercolorado.gov
Suzanne Jones 720-633-7388 joness@bouldercolorado.gov
Lisa Morzel 303-815-6723 morzell@bouldercolorado.gov
Tim Plass 720-299-4518 plasst@bouldercolorado.gov
24. What else can I do?
E-mail me to receive an invitation to join a new
“PLAN-Rational” 501(c)4 education and issues non-
profit that represents consumer, business, and
taxpayer rights in Boulder.
Thanks for being involved in our local democracy!
RogerKoenig@comcast.net