SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Mock ups Feedback:
After completing the mock ups for my Front cover, contents page and double page spread, I
gathered the opinions of my target demographic. I did this to find which one was the most
effective layout to use in my final design.
1st front cover: they found it had good complexity, well laid out and liked that it had a
balance like having a puff in each corner and the coverlines surrounding the image on both
sides. 2nd Front Cover: unconventional, good use of space, including creative ideas. 3rd front
cover: unconventional movement of the main image, different shapes, it was different and
unique. I agree with them and that they prefer the 3rd layout because in unconventional and
therefore unique, I will use this layout in the final design.
1st Contents page: they thought it was a little crammed but neatly laid out and also the use
of mini advertisements. 2nd contents page: they thought it was very informative and a lot to
take in but a good idea of presentation. 3rd contents page: again they thought it was
compact but neat. I will take their ideas for ways to improve it but I will take some good
parts from each design and incorporate them into the final piece.
1st Double page spread: they thought that the idea was too simplistic and that it leaves little
room to fit in the entire article. 2nd double page spread: they though it was complex and had
a lot going on but it was cleverly laid out, another thing was that they thought that there
should be a main image rather than just a collection. 3rd double page spread: they especially
liked how all the conventions surrounded the main image, ‘clever’, ‘unique’, and the links to
social networking sites. I agree and think that the final design is the best but I may
incorporate some elements of the second to add into the final design to make it better.
Their opinions and advice were very helpful in creating the final layouts; I will take their
advice and incorporate them into my final design.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Bitacora 5
Bitacora 5Bitacora 5
Bitacora 5
milita Ramirez
 
Maestria en tecnologia educativa
Maestria en tecnologia educativaMaestria en tecnologia educativa
Maestria en tecnologia educativa
anabelleonneri
 
Cuoh mte 513 la alimentación como parte de la nutrición
Cuoh mte 513 la alimentación como parte de la nutriciónCuoh mte 513 la alimentación como parte de la nutrición
Cuoh mte 513 la alimentación como parte de la nutrición
Yuri9999
 
Moving Stress Infographic
Moving Stress InfographicMoving Stress Infographic
Moving Stress Infographic
Movers.com
 
Calendar
CalendarCalendar
Calendar
martipt10
 
Call Sheet 2
Call Sheet 2Call Sheet 2
Call Sheet 2
charlottepage94
 

Viewers also liked (8)

Asserpe
AsserpeAsserpe
Asserpe
 
Bitacora 5
Bitacora 5Bitacora 5
Bitacora 5
 
Maestria en tecnologia educativa
Maestria en tecnologia educativaMaestria en tecnologia educativa
Maestria en tecnologia educativa
 
Cuoh mte 513 la alimentación como parte de la nutrición
Cuoh mte 513 la alimentación como parte de la nutriciónCuoh mte 513 la alimentación como parte de la nutrición
Cuoh mte 513 la alimentación como parte de la nutrición
 
Moving Stress Infographic
Moving Stress InfographicMoving Stress Infographic
Moving Stress Infographic
 
Calendar
CalendarCalendar
Calendar
 
Call Sheet 2
Call Sheet 2Call Sheet 2
Call Sheet 2
 
Therewasa country
Therewasa countryTherewasa country
Therewasa country
 

Similar to Mock ups feedback

Production reflection
Production reflectionProduction reflection
Production reflection
Abbie Nicholls
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentation
jeffohsoj
 
Proposal
ProposalProposal
Proposal
Josh Brownsword
 
Task2 brainstorms and mindmaps
Task2  brainstorms and mindmapsTask2  brainstorms and mindmaps
Task2 brainstorms and mindmaps
paige moorby
 
Task 10
Task 10Task 10
Evaluation pdf
Evaluation pdfEvaluation pdf
Evaluation pdf
gdiane
 
Evaluation
Evaluation Evaluation
Evaluation
BenDix4
 
Task 10
Task 10Task 10
Evaluation
EvaluationEvaluation
Evaluation
KateSutton04
 
Task2 brainstorms and mindmaps
Task2  brainstorms and mindmapsTask2  brainstorms and mindmaps
Task2 brainstorms and mindmaps
paige moorby
 
FMP Proposal
FMP ProposalFMP Proposal
FMP Proposal
Leticia Pozze
 
Interaction Design Method - Contextual Inquiry
Interaction Design Method - Contextual InquiryInteraction Design Method - Contextual Inquiry
Interaction Design Method - Contextual Inquiry
Melissa Tang
 
Second Part of powerpoint
Second Part of powerpointSecond Part of powerpoint
Second Part of powerpoint
abankow1
 
Fl evaluation
Fl evaluationFl evaluation
Fl evaluation
Nicola Kilgallon
 
Year 12 Personal Study Task 1.ppt
Year 12 Personal Study Task 1.pptYear 12 Personal Study Task 1.ppt
Year 12 Personal Study Task 1.ppt
missfcmay
 
Fmp proposal
Fmp proposalFmp proposal
Fmp proposal
jackedwardsz
 
Magazine planning
Magazine planningMagazine planning
Magazine planning
Kiya Cussans
 
Magazine plan
Magazine planMagazine plan
Magazine plan
Kiya Cussans
 
Question 1 part a presentation
Question 1 part a presentationQuestion 1 part a presentation
Question 1 part a presentation
medialauren
 
Design for Advertising: The design Pro Forma Improved
Design for Advertising: The design Pro Forma ImprovedDesign for Advertising: The design Pro Forma Improved
Design for Advertising: The design Pro Forma Improved
TheJellehKed
 

Similar to Mock ups feedback (20)

Production reflection
Production reflectionProduction reflection
Production reflection
 
Presentation
PresentationPresentation
Presentation
 
Proposal
ProposalProposal
Proposal
 
Task2 brainstorms and mindmaps
Task2  brainstorms and mindmapsTask2  brainstorms and mindmaps
Task2 brainstorms and mindmaps
 
Task 10
Task 10Task 10
Task 10
 
Evaluation pdf
Evaluation pdfEvaluation pdf
Evaluation pdf
 
Evaluation
Evaluation Evaluation
Evaluation
 
Task 10
Task 10Task 10
Task 10
 
Evaluation
EvaluationEvaluation
Evaluation
 
Task2 brainstorms and mindmaps
Task2  brainstorms and mindmapsTask2  brainstorms and mindmaps
Task2 brainstorms and mindmaps
 
FMP Proposal
FMP ProposalFMP Proposal
FMP Proposal
 
Interaction Design Method - Contextual Inquiry
Interaction Design Method - Contextual InquiryInteraction Design Method - Contextual Inquiry
Interaction Design Method - Contextual Inquiry
 
Second Part of powerpoint
Second Part of powerpointSecond Part of powerpoint
Second Part of powerpoint
 
Fl evaluation
Fl evaluationFl evaluation
Fl evaluation
 
Year 12 Personal Study Task 1.ppt
Year 12 Personal Study Task 1.pptYear 12 Personal Study Task 1.ppt
Year 12 Personal Study Task 1.ppt
 
Fmp proposal
Fmp proposalFmp proposal
Fmp proposal
 
Magazine planning
Magazine planningMagazine planning
Magazine planning
 
Magazine plan
Magazine planMagazine plan
Magazine plan
 
Question 1 part a presentation
Question 1 part a presentationQuestion 1 part a presentation
Question 1 part a presentation
 
Design for Advertising: The design Pro Forma Improved
Design for Advertising: The design Pro Forma ImprovedDesign for Advertising: The design Pro Forma Improved
Design for Advertising: The design Pro Forma Improved
 

More from 960940

Reflection on research
Reflection on researchReflection on research
Reflection on research
960940
 
Props list
Props listProps list
Props list
960940
 
Audience Research
Audience ResearchAudience Research
Audience Research
960940
 
Audience research
Audience researchAudience research
Audience research
960940
 
Evaluation Question 1
Evaluation Question 1Evaluation Question 1
Evaluation Question 1
960940
 
Magazine production drafts
Magazine production draftsMagazine production drafts
Magazine production drafts
960940
 
Task 7- Analysis of Film Posters
Task 7- Analysis of Film PostersTask 7- Analysis of Film Posters
Task 7- Analysis of Film Posters
960940
 
Media horror research
Media horror researchMedia horror research
Media horror research
960940
 
Sample recce
Sample recceSample recce
Sample recce
960940
 
Call sheet
Call sheetCall sheet
Call sheet
960940
 
Thirst script
Thirst scriptThirst script
Thirst script
960940
 
Stalker script
Stalker scriptStalker script
Stalker script
960940
 
Purple man script
Purple man scriptPurple man script
Purple man script
960940
 
Asylum script
Asylum scriptAsylum script
Asylum script
960940
 
Task 7
Task 7Task 7
Task 7
960940
 
Task 2 media
Task 2 mediaTask 2 media
Task 2 media
960940
 
Institutions
InstitutionsInstitutions
Institutions
960940
 
Mood board
Mood boardMood board
Mood board960940
 
Music magazine research
Music magazine researchMusic magazine research
Music magazine research
960940
 
Uses and gratifications theory
Uses and gratifications theoryUses and gratifications theory
Uses and gratifications theory
960940
 

More from 960940 (20)

Reflection on research
Reflection on researchReflection on research
Reflection on research
 
Props list
Props listProps list
Props list
 
Audience Research
Audience ResearchAudience Research
Audience Research
 
Audience research
Audience researchAudience research
Audience research
 
Evaluation Question 1
Evaluation Question 1Evaluation Question 1
Evaluation Question 1
 
Magazine production drafts
Magazine production draftsMagazine production drafts
Magazine production drafts
 
Task 7- Analysis of Film Posters
Task 7- Analysis of Film PostersTask 7- Analysis of Film Posters
Task 7- Analysis of Film Posters
 
Media horror research
Media horror researchMedia horror research
Media horror research
 
Sample recce
Sample recceSample recce
Sample recce
 
Call sheet
Call sheetCall sheet
Call sheet
 
Thirst script
Thirst scriptThirst script
Thirst script
 
Stalker script
Stalker scriptStalker script
Stalker script
 
Purple man script
Purple man scriptPurple man script
Purple man script
 
Asylum script
Asylum scriptAsylum script
Asylum script
 
Task 7
Task 7Task 7
Task 7
 
Task 2 media
Task 2 mediaTask 2 media
Task 2 media
 
Institutions
InstitutionsInstitutions
Institutions
 
Mood board
Mood boardMood board
Mood board
 
Music magazine research
Music magazine researchMusic magazine research
Music magazine research
 
Uses and gratifications theory
Uses and gratifications theoryUses and gratifications theory
Uses and gratifications theory
 

Mock ups feedback

  • 1. Mock ups Feedback: After completing the mock ups for my Front cover, contents page and double page spread, I gathered the opinions of my target demographic. I did this to find which one was the most effective layout to use in my final design. 1st front cover: they found it had good complexity, well laid out and liked that it had a balance like having a puff in each corner and the coverlines surrounding the image on both sides. 2nd Front Cover: unconventional, good use of space, including creative ideas. 3rd front cover: unconventional movement of the main image, different shapes, it was different and unique. I agree with them and that they prefer the 3rd layout because in unconventional and therefore unique, I will use this layout in the final design. 1st Contents page: they thought it was a little crammed but neatly laid out and also the use of mini advertisements. 2nd contents page: they thought it was very informative and a lot to take in but a good idea of presentation. 3rd contents page: again they thought it was compact but neat. I will take their ideas for ways to improve it but I will take some good parts from each design and incorporate them into the final piece. 1st Double page spread: they thought that the idea was too simplistic and that it leaves little room to fit in the entire article. 2nd double page spread: they though it was complex and had a lot going on but it was cleverly laid out, another thing was that they thought that there should be a main image rather than just a collection. 3rd double page spread: they especially liked how all the conventions surrounded the main image, ‘clever’, ‘unique’, and the links to social networking sites. I agree and think that the final design is the best but I may incorporate some elements of the second to add into the final design to make it better. Their opinions and advice were very helpful in creating the final layouts; I will take their advice and incorporate them into my final design.