Presentation by Louise Shepherd, Alder Hey Children's NHS Foundation Trust: How to embed research in NHS Trusts to improve patient care event at How to embed research in NHS Trusts to improve patient care event at The Foresight Centre, Liverpool on 28 November 2019
Louise Shepherd - How to embed research in NHS trusts to improve patient care
1. Inspired by ChildrenInspired by Children
Embedding Research in NHS Trusts:
The Alder Hey Experience
Louise Shepherd
Chief Executive
Alder Hey Children’s NHS Foundation Trust
2. Inspired by ChildrenInspired by Children
Background
• Specialist Children’s Trust
• Serves a population of 8 million people
• Provides secondary, tertiary and quaternary
services, including community
• Largest recruiter to NIHR CRN Children studies
(>45,000 since 2009)
4. Limited time for research in paediatrician’s jobs plans
Source: RCPCH Participation in Child Health Research Survey 2015
Novel, multi-sector approaches needed to address imbalance
5. Inspired by ChildrenInspired by Children
• Trust Boards required to balance the needs
of multiple external drivers (including RCP)
• Many competing demands on consultant SPA
time (research, education, QI, etc)
• Creative solutions involving multiple partners
needed (Charities, commercial sector, etc)
• Sharing knowledge, experience and best
practice
Protecting research time in a time poor environment
7. Inspired by Children
CQC NHS trust-wide well-led inspection framework
The 2019 update of the well led framework includes research
questions (Section W8)
https://www.cqc.org.uk/sites/default/files/20190412_Trust_
wide_well_led_inspection_framework_v6.pdf used by NHS
trusts to plan to meet the requirements
8. Inspired by Children
A whole system for ‘well-led’ research in NHS trusts
Equity
Facilitation
Strategic
Leaders
Patients
Divisional Managers
and Staff
9. Inspired by ChildrenInspired by Children
• Strategic use of NIHR Research Capability
Funding (RCF)
• Rheumatology:
– 7 Research PAs across four consultants
– Research income generated enables research
PAs to be self funding
– RCF recycled – virtuous circle
Supporting Research Intensive Departments
10. Inspired by ChildrenInspired by Children
• Income directly supports junior medical
salaries releasing PI time to deliver research
tasks
• Income distribution model being piloted to
enable reinvestment into wider clinical
services
Commercial Research
11. Inspired by ChildrenInspired by Children
• Secured £340k to support protected time for
healthcare professionals
• Pump-priming investment from national DMD
and CF charities for commercial research
capacity
– Enabled research infrastructure posts to become
self-sufficient
– Includes medical time
• Alder Hey ‘approach’ to Patient Recruitment
Centre
Working with Charities
12. Inspired by ChildrenInspired by Children
• Not always possible to include research time in
consultant job plans
• ‘Indirect’ mechanisms to reduce research burden
and increase capacity for PI time in existing job
plan
– Providing administrative support (for DCC or research
activities)
– Research nurse allocation
– Data administration support (e.g. case report
completion, data quality checks)
• Personalising the supportive resource to the needs
of the consultant/clinical team
Supporting Infrastructure
13. Inspired by ChildrenInspired by Children
• Trust Boards have to prioritise and balance
competing demands on the medical
workforce
• No single approach to increasing medical
research capacity
• Case studies are informative, but not always
scalable
• Joint working between NHS and other sectors
needed
• Sharing best practice and NHS wide
collaboration with RCP essential, e.g. through
UKRD
Summary
Editor's Notes
1311 or 81.6% did not have PAs for research in their job plan and 875 or 54.5% do no research work
8.1% have less than 1 PA for research in their job plan, although 25% of respondents spend this amount of time on research
Average PAs in job plan for research per respondent was 0.37 and the average PAs actually worked for research per respondent was 0.66.
In early October 2018 the CQC published the 2018 Well Led Framework (Trusts) and this included the new clinical research prompts:
https://www.cqc.org.uk/sites/default/files/20180921_9001100_trust-wide_well-led_inspection_framework_v5.pdf
The new research prompts are:
Are divisional staff aware of research undertaken in and through the Trust, how it contributes to improvement and the service level needed across departments to support it?
How do senior leaders support internal investigators initiating and managing clinical studies?
Does the Vision and Strategy incorporate plans for supporting clinical research activity as a key contributor to best patient care?
Does the Trust have clear internal reporting systems for its research range, volume, activity, safety and performance?
How are patients and carers given the opportunity to participate in or become actively involved in clinical research studies in the trust?
The work on research is focussed on CQC’s Well Led category. For research this concerns how a Trust as a whole incorporates clinical research into its healthcare governance and delivery and makes it available to patients as an option.
The 3 Levels:
Research equity – how does the organisation support the research programme across the breadth of its services?
Research facilitation – how does the organisation proactively support the delivery of research from board level to the clinical setting(s)?
Research awareness – how does the organisation make research opportunity known to patients, the public and healthcare professionals?