The document discusses various topics related to human rights including the United Nations Human Rights Council, measures for protecting child rights, objectives and features of the Human Rights Act 1993 in India, constitution of the National Human Rights Commission in India, collective rights, and the scope of public interest litigation with respect to human rights in India. It provides answers to several questions related to these topics with details on international conventions, classifications of rights, duties of state institutions, and the role of courts in protecting human rights.
The document analyzes plea bargaining in India. It defines plea bargaining as a prosecutor and defendant negotiating a guilty plea to a lesser charge. The objectives of plea bargaining in India are to provide compensation to victims, reduce pending litigation, decrease trial delays, and reduce the number of under trials. The Law Commission of India advocated for plea bargaining in its 142nd, 154th, and 177th reports to address delays in case disposal. Plea bargaining was incorporated into Indian law to help address overburdened courts and frustration with delays in the justice system. The document discusses provisions, types, judicial pronouncements, advantages, disadvantages, and criticism of plea bargaining in India.
Plea-bargaining allows an accused person to plead guilty in exchange for concessions from the prosecution. It was introduced in India to reduce court backlogs and prison overcrowding. Plea-bargaining involves negotiations between the prosecution and defense on charges, sentences, or facts. While it provides benefits, there are also concerns it may violate rights or result in unfairly lenient sentences. Indian courts have examined plea-bargaining but taken a cautious approach to its implementation and application.
The rule of harmonious construction provides that when two or more statutes or parts of a statute conflict, they should be interpreted in a way that harmonizes them and gives effect to both. The interpretation that avoids inconsistencies or repugnancy between provisions and makes the statute consistent as a whole should be adopted. If provisions cannot be completely reconciled, they must be interpreted to give effect to both as much as possible without reducing any provision to useless or dead letter. The rule aims to avoid head-on clashes and inconsistencies between different parts of a statute.
This document summarizes key aspects of Article 19 of the Indian Constitution, which protects certain fundamental rights of citizens. It discusses the rights to freedom of speech, assembly, association, movement, residence, and occupation as outlined in Article 19(1). It then examines reasonable restrictions that can be imposed on these rights as per Articles 19(2)-19(6) in the interests of sovereignty, public order, morality, etc. Case laws are cited to illustrate how the Supreme Court has interpreted and applied these rights and restrictions over time. The document provides a concise yet comprehensive overview of the fundamental rights protected by Article 19.
The Advocates Act, 1961 is an act to consolidate and amend the law relating to legal practitioners and to provide for the constitution of the Bar Councils and an All-India Bar. It was enacted by the Parliament in the Twelfth Year of the Republic of India.
The Advocates Act,1961 provides for the constitution of two types of councils:
State Bar Council-Section 3
Bar Council of India-Section 4
The Bar Council as well as the State Bar Councils have various functions to perform
This document discusses the definitions and differences between international law and municipal law. It defines international law as the body of rules considered legally binding by states in their relations with each other. Municipal law refers to the laws applicable within a local government entity. The document also discusses the theories of monism and dualism regarding how international law relates to municipal law, and provides criticisms of each approach.
The document discusses the General Clauses Act of 1897. It provides definitions and rules of interpretation for central acts. The act aims to standardize language, provide uniform expression, and make provisions for interpretation. It covers topics like commencement and repeal of enactments, powers and functions, and interpretation of notifications, rules, and bye-laws issued under acts. The act also serves as a model for state general clauses acts and has been applied to interpreting the Indian constitution.
The document analyzes plea bargaining in India. It defines plea bargaining as a prosecutor and defendant negotiating a guilty plea to a lesser charge. The objectives of plea bargaining in India are to provide compensation to victims, reduce pending litigation, decrease trial delays, and reduce the number of under trials. The Law Commission of India advocated for plea bargaining in its 142nd, 154th, and 177th reports to address delays in case disposal. Plea bargaining was incorporated into Indian law to help address overburdened courts and frustration with delays in the justice system. The document discusses provisions, types, judicial pronouncements, advantages, disadvantages, and criticism of plea bargaining in India.
Plea-bargaining allows an accused person to plead guilty in exchange for concessions from the prosecution. It was introduced in India to reduce court backlogs and prison overcrowding. Plea-bargaining involves negotiations between the prosecution and defense on charges, sentences, or facts. While it provides benefits, there are also concerns it may violate rights or result in unfairly lenient sentences. Indian courts have examined plea-bargaining but taken a cautious approach to its implementation and application.
The rule of harmonious construction provides that when two or more statutes or parts of a statute conflict, they should be interpreted in a way that harmonizes them and gives effect to both. The interpretation that avoids inconsistencies or repugnancy between provisions and makes the statute consistent as a whole should be adopted. If provisions cannot be completely reconciled, they must be interpreted to give effect to both as much as possible without reducing any provision to useless or dead letter. The rule aims to avoid head-on clashes and inconsistencies between different parts of a statute.
This document summarizes key aspects of Article 19 of the Indian Constitution, which protects certain fundamental rights of citizens. It discusses the rights to freedom of speech, assembly, association, movement, residence, and occupation as outlined in Article 19(1). It then examines reasonable restrictions that can be imposed on these rights as per Articles 19(2)-19(6) in the interests of sovereignty, public order, morality, etc. Case laws are cited to illustrate how the Supreme Court has interpreted and applied these rights and restrictions over time. The document provides a concise yet comprehensive overview of the fundamental rights protected by Article 19.
The Advocates Act, 1961 is an act to consolidate and amend the law relating to legal practitioners and to provide for the constitution of the Bar Councils and an All-India Bar. It was enacted by the Parliament in the Twelfth Year of the Republic of India.
The Advocates Act,1961 provides for the constitution of two types of councils:
State Bar Council-Section 3
Bar Council of India-Section 4
The Bar Council as well as the State Bar Councils have various functions to perform
This document discusses the definitions and differences between international law and municipal law. It defines international law as the body of rules considered legally binding by states in their relations with each other. Municipal law refers to the laws applicable within a local government entity. The document also discusses the theories of monism and dualism regarding how international law relates to municipal law, and provides criticisms of each approach.
The document discusses the General Clauses Act of 1897. It provides definitions and rules of interpretation for central acts. The act aims to standardize language, provide uniform expression, and make provisions for interpretation. It covers topics like commencement and repeal of enactments, powers and functions, and interpretation of notifications, rules, and bye-laws issued under acts. The act also serves as a model for state general clauses acts and has been applied to interpreting the Indian constitution.
The Supreme Court upheld the High Court's order directing authorities to take action to reduce noise pollution caused by a church. While religious freedom is important, it cannot infringe on the rights of others to not be disturbed. No religion prescribes prayers that create noise nuisances. The guidelines issued by the court previously and laws on noise pollution empower authorities to intervene if religious activities disturb neighbors or the community. The court recognized that all people, including students, children, the elderly and sick, have a right to peace and quiet without unnecessary disturbance.
Asylum provides shelter and protection by a host state to citizens of another state. There are two kinds of asylum: territorial asylum, which is granted within a state's own territory where it has sovereignty, and extra-territorial asylum, which can be granted outside a state's territory in places like embassies, consulates, warships, or international institutions in some cases. Extra-territorial asylum allows states to protect individuals in other states by granting protection in areas considered under the host state's jurisdiction rather than the local state.
This document discusses the immunities granted to trade unions and their members under Indian law. It explains that the Trade Union Act of 1926 granted certain privileges and immunities to trade unions, their office bearers, and members for acts done in furtherance of a labor dispute. Specifically, it provides criminal immunity for concerted worker gatherings and actions during disputes as long as they remain peaceful and lawful. However, criminal immunity is lost if unlawful confinement, trespassing, violence, force, assault, mischief or intimidation occurs. The act also grants civil immunity for actions taken in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute, as long as inducement is through lawful means.
LLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TAXATION
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
This document discusses administrative tribunals in India. It defines tribunals and distinguishes them from courts and executive authorities. Tribunals were established to handle the growing workload of courts due to expanded government functions. While tribunals have some court-like qualities, they are not bound by strict rules of evidence and procedure. The document outlines the constitutional provisions related to tribunals, their powers and limitations, as well as recommendations from committees on improving their structure and functions.
The Bar Council of India is a statutory body that regulates legal education and the legal profession in India. It was established in 1961 under the Advocates Act. The Bar Council sets standards for legal education, grants recognition to law universities, regulates the conduct of advocates, and exercises disciplinary powers over advocates. It consists of 18 members representing the central government and each state's bar council. The Bar Council's key functions are to regulate legal education and the legal profession, safeguard advocates' rights and interests, and promote law reform in India.
Code of civil procedure 1908 reference, review, revisionDr. Vikas Khakare
This explains what is reference, review and revision. when and where it can be made. It also explains difference between reference, review and revision.
The document summarizes the key provisions around temporary injunctions and interlocutory orders under Order 39 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 in India. It discusses the grounds for granting temporary injunctions under Rules 1 and 2 to maintain the status quo during legal proceedings. It also outlines the procedures under Rules 3 and 3A, consequences for disobedience under Rule 2A, discharge or variation of orders under Rule 4, and provisions for interim sale, detention of subject matter, immediate possession, and deposit in court under Rules 6 to 10. The purpose is to provide interim relief and protect suits from becoming infructuous pending final disposal.
Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...sundarsasane
This document discusses principles of constitutional interpretation in India. It begins by explaining that constitutional interpretation should be dynamic, pragmatic and elastic rather than static, pedantic or rigid. It then outlines several key interpretation principles applied to the constitution, including harmonious construction, pith and substance, and colourable legislation. Harmonious construction means provisions should be interpreted together rather than in isolation. Pith and substance examines a law's true nature or essence. Colourable legislation prohibits indirect means of doing what is directly prohibited. The document also discusses occupied field, residuary power, repugnancy, and territorial nexus principles.
The document discusses the legal position and status of women in ancient, medieval, and British India. It provides details on women's rights and roles during these periods. In ancient and Vedic times, women had a relatively high status and equal rights. However, during the medieval period practices like sati, child marriage, and slavery negatively impacted women. Under British rule, social reformers and the British worked to abolish practices like sati and infanticide, and raise the minimum age for marriage. However, patriarchal attitudes persisted and full equality was not achieved even after independence.
This document provides details about The Advocates Act of 1961 in India, which aims to consolidate and amend the laws relating to legal practitioners. Some key points:
1. It establishes the Bar Council of India and State Bar Councils to regulate legal practice and practitioners.
2. The Act implements recommendations from the 1953 All India Bar Committee report and the Law Commission to reform the legal system.
3. It introduces a common roll of advocates to allow practice across courts, establishes qualifications for advocates, and divides advocates into senior and other categories.
4. The Act repeals previous laws on the subject and received assent on May 19, 1961, coming into effect through state-by-state notifications.
There are three main types of delegated legislation: bylaws made by local councils, statutory instruments made by government departments, and Orders in Council made by the Privy Council. Parliament delegates some of its lawmaking power through enabling acts because it does not have time or expertise to pass all necessary laws itself. Delegated legislation is subject to general supervision through the enabling act and requirement for consultation, publication, and parliamentary and court oversight through judicial review. It allows laws to be made more quickly and flexibly by experts but is also criticized as being undemocratic with reduced transparency and scrutiny compared to laws passed by Parliament.
This document discusses the various internal aids to interpretation that can be used when interpreting statutes. It outlines 14 main internal aids: the preamble, title, headings, marginal notes, context, punctuation and brackets, illustrations, definition and interpretation clauses, provisos, exceptions and saving clauses, rules, fictions, explanations, and schedules. For each aid, it provides examples from acts like the IPC and constitutional cases where courts have referred to these aids to resolve ambiguities in statutes.
This document discusses the history and process of codifying international law. It outlines key events and efforts over time to systematically organize international legal rules and principles into written codes and agreements. Some of the major developments mentioned include the Hague Conferences of 1899 and 1907 which resulted in the first international conventions, the work of the League of Nations and United Nations to further codification, and important conventions on topics like the law of the sea, diplomatic relations, and treaties. Both benefits and challenges of the codification process are also reviewed.
LLB LAW NOTES ON ADMINISTRATIVE LAW
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
The document summarizes the Legal Services Authority Act of 1987 in India. It discusses key provisions of the act including establishing legal aid clinics, criteria for providing legal aid based on socioeconomic status, and creating a hierarchy of legal bodies at the national, state, district and local levels. It also describes Lok Adalats, which are specialized courts established under the act to facilitate alternative dispute resolution. Lok Adalats have jurisdiction over pending and new cases up to 10 lakhs rupees and promote speedy and affordable justice through conciliation and settlement.
The document discusses sections of the Advocates Act related to the admission and enrollment of advocates. It notes there are two classes of advocates: senior advocates and other advocates. It outlines the requirements to become an advocate including being a citizen of India over 21, having a law degree from a Bar Council of India recognized university, and paying enrollment fees to the State Bar Council and Bar Council of India. It also mentions a State Bar Council can remove an advocate's name from the state roll if they are deceased or request removal.
The document discusses the key topics of human rights including:
1. Defining human rights as the rights essential to protecting human dignity and allowing individuals to develop their personality.
2. Tracing the history of human rights from ancient origins to modern codification in international agreements like the UN Charter.
3. Outlining the main categories of human rights as civil/political rights and economic/social/cultural rights.
Human Rights are best notes in the world as compare to otherssafdarhussainbhutta4
This document provides an overview of human rights, including:
1) It defines human rights as moral claims inherent in all individuals due to their humanity, regardless of personal attributes. These claims are formulated in international declarations of human rights.
2) It traces the evolution of human rights from theories of natural law proposed by ancient Greek philosophers through landmarks like the Magna Carta and declarations of the French Revolution and UN.
3) It describes nine key characteristics of human rights like their universality and role in limiting state power over individuals.
The Supreme Court upheld the High Court's order directing authorities to take action to reduce noise pollution caused by a church. While religious freedom is important, it cannot infringe on the rights of others to not be disturbed. No religion prescribes prayers that create noise nuisances. The guidelines issued by the court previously and laws on noise pollution empower authorities to intervene if religious activities disturb neighbors or the community. The court recognized that all people, including students, children, the elderly and sick, have a right to peace and quiet without unnecessary disturbance.
Asylum provides shelter and protection by a host state to citizens of another state. There are two kinds of asylum: territorial asylum, which is granted within a state's own territory where it has sovereignty, and extra-territorial asylum, which can be granted outside a state's territory in places like embassies, consulates, warships, or international institutions in some cases. Extra-territorial asylum allows states to protect individuals in other states by granting protection in areas considered under the host state's jurisdiction rather than the local state.
This document discusses the immunities granted to trade unions and their members under Indian law. It explains that the Trade Union Act of 1926 granted certain privileges and immunities to trade unions, their office bearers, and members for acts done in furtherance of a labor dispute. Specifically, it provides criminal immunity for concerted worker gatherings and actions during disputes as long as they remain peaceful and lawful. However, criminal immunity is lost if unlawful confinement, trespassing, violence, force, assault, mischief or intimidation occurs. The act also grants civil immunity for actions taken in contemplation or furtherance of a trade dispute, as long as inducement is through lawful means.
LLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF TAXATION
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
This document discusses administrative tribunals in India. It defines tribunals and distinguishes them from courts and executive authorities. Tribunals were established to handle the growing workload of courts due to expanded government functions. While tribunals have some court-like qualities, they are not bound by strict rules of evidence and procedure. The document outlines the constitutional provisions related to tribunals, their powers and limitations, as well as recommendations from committees on improving their structure and functions.
The Bar Council of India is a statutory body that regulates legal education and the legal profession in India. It was established in 1961 under the Advocates Act. The Bar Council sets standards for legal education, grants recognition to law universities, regulates the conduct of advocates, and exercises disciplinary powers over advocates. It consists of 18 members representing the central government and each state's bar council. The Bar Council's key functions are to regulate legal education and the legal profession, safeguard advocates' rights and interests, and promote law reform in India.
Code of civil procedure 1908 reference, review, revisionDr. Vikas Khakare
This explains what is reference, review and revision. when and where it can be made. It also explains difference between reference, review and revision.
The document summarizes the key provisions around temporary injunctions and interlocutory orders under Order 39 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 in India. It discusses the grounds for granting temporary injunctions under Rules 1 and 2 to maintain the status quo during legal proceedings. It also outlines the procedures under Rules 3 and 3A, consequences for disobedience under Rule 2A, discharge or variation of orders under Rule 4, and provisions for interim sale, detention of subject matter, immediate possession, and deposit in court under Rules 6 to 10. The purpose is to provide interim relief and protect suits from becoming infructuous pending final disposal.
Principles of constitutional interpretation of list prepared by Rajashree J J...sundarsasane
This document discusses principles of constitutional interpretation in India. It begins by explaining that constitutional interpretation should be dynamic, pragmatic and elastic rather than static, pedantic or rigid. It then outlines several key interpretation principles applied to the constitution, including harmonious construction, pith and substance, and colourable legislation. Harmonious construction means provisions should be interpreted together rather than in isolation. Pith and substance examines a law's true nature or essence. Colourable legislation prohibits indirect means of doing what is directly prohibited. The document also discusses occupied field, residuary power, repugnancy, and territorial nexus principles.
The document discusses the legal position and status of women in ancient, medieval, and British India. It provides details on women's rights and roles during these periods. In ancient and Vedic times, women had a relatively high status and equal rights. However, during the medieval period practices like sati, child marriage, and slavery negatively impacted women. Under British rule, social reformers and the British worked to abolish practices like sati and infanticide, and raise the minimum age for marriage. However, patriarchal attitudes persisted and full equality was not achieved even after independence.
This document provides details about The Advocates Act of 1961 in India, which aims to consolidate and amend the laws relating to legal practitioners. Some key points:
1. It establishes the Bar Council of India and State Bar Councils to regulate legal practice and practitioners.
2. The Act implements recommendations from the 1953 All India Bar Committee report and the Law Commission to reform the legal system.
3. It introduces a common roll of advocates to allow practice across courts, establishes qualifications for advocates, and divides advocates into senior and other categories.
4. The Act repeals previous laws on the subject and received assent on May 19, 1961, coming into effect through state-by-state notifications.
There are three main types of delegated legislation: bylaws made by local councils, statutory instruments made by government departments, and Orders in Council made by the Privy Council. Parliament delegates some of its lawmaking power through enabling acts because it does not have time or expertise to pass all necessary laws itself. Delegated legislation is subject to general supervision through the enabling act and requirement for consultation, publication, and parliamentary and court oversight through judicial review. It allows laws to be made more quickly and flexibly by experts but is also criticized as being undemocratic with reduced transparency and scrutiny compared to laws passed by Parliament.
This document discusses the various internal aids to interpretation that can be used when interpreting statutes. It outlines 14 main internal aids: the preamble, title, headings, marginal notes, context, punctuation and brackets, illustrations, definition and interpretation clauses, provisos, exceptions and saving clauses, rules, fictions, explanations, and schedules. For each aid, it provides examples from acts like the IPC and constitutional cases where courts have referred to these aids to resolve ambiguities in statutes.
This document discusses the history and process of codifying international law. It outlines key events and efforts over time to systematically organize international legal rules and principles into written codes and agreements. Some of the major developments mentioned include the Hague Conferences of 1899 and 1907 which resulted in the first international conventions, the work of the League of Nations and United Nations to further codification, and important conventions on topics like the law of the sea, diplomatic relations, and treaties. Both benefits and challenges of the codification process are also reviewed.
LLB LAW NOTES ON ADMINISTRATIVE LAW
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
The document summarizes the Legal Services Authority Act of 1987 in India. It discusses key provisions of the act including establishing legal aid clinics, criteria for providing legal aid based on socioeconomic status, and creating a hierarchy of legal bodies at the national, state, district and local levels. It also describes Lok Adalats, which are specialized courts established under the act to facilitate alternative dispute resolution. Lok Adalats have jurisdiction over pending and new cases up to 10 lakhs rupees and promote speedy and affordable justice through conciliation and settlement.
The document discusses sections of the Advocates Act related to the admission and enrollment of advocates. It notes there are two classes of advocates: senior advocates and other advocates. It outlines the requirements to become an advocate including being a citizen of India over 21, having a law degree from a Bar Council of India recognized university, and paying enrollment fees to the State Bar Council and Bar Council of India. It also mentions a State Bar Council can remove an advocate's name from the state roll if they are deceased or request removal.
The document discusses the key topics of human rights including:
1. Defining human rights as the rights essential to protecting human dignity and allowing individuals to develop their personality.
2. Tracing the history of human rights from ancient origins to modern codification in international agreements like the UN Charter.
3. Outlining the main categories of human rights as civil/political rights and economic/social/cultural rights.
Human Rights are best notes in the world as compare to otherssafdarhussainbhutta4
This document provides an overview of human rights, including:
1) It defines human rights as moral claims inherent in all individuals due to their humanity, regardless of personal attributes. These claims are formulated in international declarations of human rights.
2) It traces the evolution of human rights from theories of natural law proposed by ancient Greek philosophers through landmarks like the Magna Carta and declarations of the French Revolution and UN.
3) It describes nine key characteristics of human rights like their universality and role in limiting state power over individuals.
The document outlines a course on human rights education. It covers 10 topics including fundamental concepts of human rights, the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, and human rights legal frameworks in the Philippines and internationally. It also discusses the classification of human rights according to source, aspect of life, derogability, and generations proposed by Karel Vasak. The three principles of human rights - universality, indivisibility, and interdependence - are explained.
The document discusses the history and key concepts of human rights, including:
1) It defines human rights as inherent to all humans regardless of attributes and outlines their universality and inalienability under international law.
2) It describes the main classifications of human rights such as natural rights, constitutional rights, and political, civil, social, economic, and statutory rights.
3) It provides a brief history of important documents and developments in human rights such as the Magna Carta, US Bill of Rights, UN Charter, and Universal Declaration of Human Rights.
Human rights are inherent entitlements that belong to all people equally by virtue of their humanity. They include civil/political rights like the rights to life, liberty, and free expression, as well as economic/social/cultural rights like the rights to education, health, and an adequate standard of living. Human rights are universal and apply to all people everywhere regardless of characteristics. They are also indivisible and interdependent, meaning the protection of one right depends on protecting others. While cultures vary, human rights uphold the universal value of human dignity.
Introduction to Civil and Political Rights Slides for the Foundation Course o...ASHUTOSHKUMARPANDEY40
The document provides an introduction to civil and political rights as outlined in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). It discusses key provisions of the ICCPR including state responsibility to protect rights, and specific rights such as the right to life, freedom from torture, and right to participate in elections. It also summarizes the role of the Human Rights Committee in monitoring state compliance with the ICCPR and individuals' ability to file complaints regarding rights violations.
1. The document provides an introduction to civil and political rights as outlined in the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights (ICCPR). It discusses key concepts like state responsibility to respect, protect, and fulfill human rights, and important rights like the right to life and freedom from torture.
2. The ICCPR establishes standards for states to implement civil and political rights like fair trial, privacy, freedom of religion and expression. State parties must submit reports to the Human Rights Committee on their implementation.
3. The document outlines debates around civil and political rights, such as whether they require positive or negative state action, and discusses how rights are interrelated and interdependent with economic and social rights.
Human rights are inherent to all human beings by virtue of their humanity. They include civil/political rights like the right to life and liberty, as well as economic/social/cultural rights to necessities of life. The UN Universal Declaration of 1948 codified five basic human rights that countries have agreed to uphold: equality, life, freedom from slavery, fair trial, and freedom of expression. Human rights are important because they establish minimum standards to protect human dignity and require countries to respect, protect, and fulfill these rights through domestic laws and international obligations. Upholding human rights is essential because all people deserve them equally by virtue of their shared humanity.
Freedom of conscience and free profession, practice and propagation of religion - Article 25
This article guarantees freedom of conscience and the right freely to profess, practice and propagate religion to every citizen of India. However, this right is subject to public order, morality and health.
b. Freedom to manage religious affairs - Article 26
This article guarantees every religious denomination or any section thereof the right to establish and maintain institutions for religious and charitable purposes, manage its own affairs in matters of religion, own and acquire movable and immovable property and administer such property.
c. Freedom as to payment of taxes for promotion of any particular religion - Article 27
No person shall be compelled to pay any taxes
This document provides an overview of human rights and their classification. It defines human rights as the inherent rights of all people by virtue of being human, as derived from human dignity. Human rights are categorized into civil/political rights and economic/social/cultural rights. It also describes Karel Vasak's three generations of human rights: first generation as civil/political, second as economic/social/cultural, and third as collective rights. The document outlines the core provisions of the two main international human rights covenants and discusses various UN human rights bodies and instruments.
Introduction to human rights pdf.pdf Indian constitutionnagpurepriyanka437
Human rights are norms that establish standards of treatment for individuals and groups. They include rights like the right to life, freedom from torture, and freedom of speech. Human rights are universal, inalienable, and indivisible. Governments have primary responsibility for upholding human rights, but organizations, businesses, and individuals also play a role. Over time, human rights have evolved from an ideal to established legal protections at both the international and domestic levels through treaties, constitutions, and courts. Key legal sources of human rights in Poland include international covenants as well as the Polish constitution. Human rights are protected through both universal UN systems and regional courts and commissions.
The document discusses human rights in India, including:
1) India's constitution enshrines fundamental rights for all citizens regardless of attributes and the country recognizes universal human rights.
2) However, violations of human rights continue in many parts of India, including extrajudicial killings, communal violence, conflicts involving Maoist insurgents, and restrictions on freedom of expression and civil society.
3) While India has established institutions like the National Human Rights Commission to protect rights, effective implementation and accountability remain challenges as impunity persists for abuses committed by state security forces and non-state actors.
This document discusses human rights, rule of law, and governance in Nigeria. It notes that while Nigeria's constitution aims to protect human rights, in practice governance has been hindered by dysfunctional relationships between branches of government that erode judicial autonomy and rule of law. Military regimes have also damaged governance. As a result, Nigeria has consistently witnessed abuse of human rights and lacked fundamental protections for its citizens, despite being a signatory to international agreements on human rights.
This document discusses the importance of human rights and social work. It defines human rights as those inherent to all humans without distinction. Social work aims to enhance well-being and meet basic needs. While human rights and law can align, rights sometimes conflict with cultural norms or established laws. The document outlines five principles of universal, inalienable, interconnected, indivisible, and non-discriminatory human rights. Governments have primary responsibility to uphold rights through international treaties, but individuals and organizations also play a role. The United Nations and its Human Rights Council promote and protect rights globally.
Sources of Human Rights in Islam and WesternEHSAN KHAN
Human rights are a special sort of inalienable moral entitlement. They attach to all persons equally, by virtue of their humanity, irrespective of race, nationality, or membership of any particular social group. Human rights belong to an individual as a consequence of being human. The term came into wide use after World War II, replacing the earlier phrase "natural rights," which had been associated with the Greco-Roman concept of natural law since the end of the Middle Ages. As understood today, human rights refer to a wide variety of values and capabilities reflecting the diversity of human circumstances and history. They are conceived of as universal Universality of human rights is controutrsial, applying to all human beings everywhere, and as fundamental, referring to essential or basic human needs.
The concept of human rights is based on the belief that every human being is entitled to enjoy her/his rights without discrimination. Human rights differ from other rights in two respects. Firstly, they are characterized by being:
Human Rights are those basic standards without which people cannot Human rights could be generally defined as those rights which are inherent in outs which we cannot live as human beings.
A brief discussion about human rights especially those that can be found in the Universal Declaration of Human Rights. Nonetheless, this can also be a great help in order for us to be equipped with knowledge about our rights as human.
The document discusses the nature and origins of human rights and their relation to international law and the United Nations. It notes that the Universal Declaration of Human Rights (UDHR) enshrines fundamental rights and freedoms that are inherent to all human beings. The UDHR was adopted by the UN General Assembly in 1948 and established the basis for international human rights standards. It outlines civil, political, social, economic, and cultural rights in 30 articles that are legally binding and have become part of customary international law.
The document defines and discusses the concept of rights. It begins by defining rights as fundamental norms or claims that are allowed or owed to people. It then discusses the characteristics and classifications of rights, distinguishing between natural rights, moral rights, and legal rights. Legal rights are further divided into civil rights, political rights, and economic rights. Civil rights include the right to life, liberty, privacy and property. Political rights enable participation in government. Economic rights provide basic economic security and opportunity.
Similar to LLB LAW NOTES ON LAW OF HUMAN RIGHTS (20)
CA NOTES ON TRANSFER PRICING
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON THEORY OF PRODUCTION AND COST IN BUSINESS ECONOMICS
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
1) The document provides information on the theory of production and cost, including definitions and concepts related to production, factors of production, and capital formation.
2) It defines production as the transformation of inputs or resources into finished goods and services, and outlines the different types of utility created through production.
3) The main factors of production are identified as land, labor, capital, and entrepreneurship, and their key features are described.
4) Capital formation is defined as the increased production of capital goods like machinery and infrastructure that are used for further production.
CA NOTES ON THEORY OF DEMAND AND SUPPLY
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
This document discusses the theory of demand and supply, specifically the law of demand and elasticity of demand. It defines demand as the quantity of a good consumers are willing and able to purchase at various prices. The law of demand states that, all else equal, quantity demanded varies inversely with price - as price increases, quantity demanded decreases, and vice versa. This is shown through individual and market demand schedules and curves. The document discusses factors influencing demand and provides rationales for the downward sloping demand curve. It also notes some exceptions to the law of demand and defines expansion and contraction of demand.
CA NOTES ON THE SALES OF GOODS ACT 1930
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON THE LIMITED LIABILITY PARTNERSHIP ACT 2008
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON THE INDIAN PARTNERSHIP ACT 1932
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON THE INDIAN CONTRACT ACT 1872
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
This document provides information about CA coaching classes and study materials offered by AVJ Institute in Delhi, India. It includes contact details for the institute, names and subjects of various CA course instructors like CA Sanchit Grover and CA Sahil Grover, along with fees and contents of pen drive classes and online video lectures/notes on YouTube and Telegram. The last pages contain teaching materials on Chapter 4 (The Companies Act, 2013) of the CA Foundation syllabus, covering topics like nature, definition, characteristics and features of a company, as well as the concept of separate legal entity.
CA NOTES ON RISK, RETURN AND PORTFOLIO PRACTICALS OF STRATEGIC FINANCIAL MODE...Kanoon Ke Rakhwale India
CA NOTES ON RISK, RETURN AND PORTFOLIO PRACTICALS OF STRATEGIC FINANCIAL MODELING
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON PRINCIPLES AND PRACTICES OF ACCOUNTING
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON PRICING DECISION
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON PRICE DETERMINATION
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON PARTNERSHIP ACCOUNTS
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
Business economics helps managers make decisions by applying economic principles and analysis tools. It draws from microeconomics, using concepts like demand analysis, production and cost analysis, and inventory management to address operational issues. It also considers macroeconomic factors and how they influence the business environment. Business economics aims to provide practical recommendations, making it a normative rather than purely positive discipline. It has a wide scope, covering issues from choosing a business and products to setting prices, managing costs and investments, and forecasting demand.
Business Economics concerns the application of economic theory and tools to business decision making. It helps managers address issues like choosing optimal production levels and input mixes, determining appropriate pricing strategies given market conditions, managing inventories, assessing risks and uncertainties, and allocating scarce resources. While based largely in microeconomics, Business Economics also incorporates some macroeconomic analysis to help understand the broader economic environment. Its scope encompasses using economic theories and analysis to address both internal operational issues for businesses, as well as external environmental factors that impact firms.
CA NOTES ON MARKETS IN BUSINESS ECONOMICS
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON LEVY OF CUSTOMS
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
CA NOTES ON INVENTORIES
FREE AFFIDAVITS AND NOTICES FORMATS
FREE AGREEMENTS AND CONTRACTS FORMATS
FREE LLB LAW NOTES
FREE CA ICWA NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIRST SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SECOND SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW THIRD SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FOURTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW FIFTH SEM NOTES
FREE LLB LAW SIXTH SEM NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FOUNDATION NOTES
FREE CA ICWA INTERMEDIATE NOTES
FREE CA ICWA FINAL NOTES
KANOON KE RAKHWALE INDIA
HIRE LAWYER ONLINE
LAW FIRMS IN DELHI
CA FIRM DELHI
VISIT : https://www.kanoonkerakhwale.com/
VISIT : https://hirelawyeronline.com/
What are the common challenges faced by women lawyers working in the legal pr...lawyersonia
The legal profession, which has historically been male-dominated, has experienced a significant increase in the number of women entering the field over the past few decades. Despite this progress, women lawyers continue to encounter various challenges as they strive for top positions.
Receivership and liquidation Accounts
Being a Paper Presented at Business Recovery and Insolvency Practitioners Association of Nigeria (BRIPAN) on Friday, August 18, 2023.
Corporate Governance : Scope and Legal Frameworkdevaki57
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
MEANING
Corporate Governance refers to the way in which companies are governed and to what purpose. It identifies who has power and accountability, and who makes decisions. It is, in essence, a toolkit that enables management and the board to deal more effectively with the challenges of running a company.
Business law for the students of undergraduate level. The presentation contains the summary of all the chapters under the syllabus of State University, Contract Act, Sale of Goods Act, Negotiable Instrument Act, Partnership Act, Limited Liability Act, Consumer Protection Act.
Genocide in International Criminal Law.pptxMasoudZamani13
Excited to share insights from my recent presentation on genocide! 💡 In light of ongoing debates, it's crucial to delve into the nuances of this grave crime.
Guide on the use of Artificial Intelligence-based tools by lawyers and law fi...Massimo Talia
This guide aims to provide information on how lawyers will be able to use the opportunities provided by AI tools and how such tools could help the business processes of small firms. Its objective is to provide lawyers with some background to understand what they can and cannot realistically expect from these products. This guide aims to give a reference point for small law practices in the EU
against which they can evaluate those classes of AI applications that are probably the most relevant for them.
Sangyun Lee, 'Why Korea's Merger Control Occasionally Fails: A Public Choice ...Sangyun Lee
Presentation slides for a session held on June 4, 2024, at Kyoto University. This presentation is based on the presenter’s recent paper, coauthored with Hwang Lee, Professor, Korea University, with the same title, published in the Journal of Business Administration & Law, Volume 34, No. 2 (April 2024). The paper, written in Korean, is available at <https://shorturl.at/GCWcI>.
Lifting the Corporate Veil. Power Point Presentationseri bangash
"Lifting the Corporate Veil" is a legal concept that refers to the judicial act of disregarding the separate legal personality of a corporation or limited liability company (LLC). Normally, a corporation is considered a legal entity separate from its shareholders or members, meaning that the personal assets of shareholders or members are protected from the liabilities of the corporation. However, there are certain situations where courts may decide to "pierce" or "lift" the corporate veil, holding shareholders or members personally liable for the debts or actions of the corporation.
Here are some common scenarios in which courts might lift the corporate veil:
Fraud or Illegality: If shareholders or members use the corporate structure to perpetrate fraud, evade legal obligations, or engage in illegal activities, courts may disregard the corporate entity and hold those individuals personally liable.
Undercapitalization: If a corporation is formed with insufficient capital to conduct its intended business and meet its foreseeable liabilities, and this lack of capitalization results in harm to creditors or other parties, courts may lift the corporate veil to hold shareholders or members liable.
Failure to Observe Corporate Formalities: Corporations and LLCs are required to observe certain formalities, such as holding regular meetings, maintaining separate financial records, and avoiding commingling of personal and corporate assets. If these formalities are not observed and the corporate structure is used as a mere façade, courts may disregard the corporate entity.
Alter Ego: If there is such a unity of interest and ownership between the corporation and its shareholders or members that the separate personalities of the corporation and the individuals no longer exist, courts may treat the corporation as the alter ego of its owners and hold them personally liable.
Group Enterprises: In some cases, where multiple corporations are closely related or form part of a single economic unit, courts may pierce the corporate veil to achieve equity, particularly if one corporation's actions harm creditors or other stakeholders and the corporate structure is being used to shield culpable parties from liability.
सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने यह भी माना था कि मजिस्ट्रेट का यह कर्तव्य है कि वह सुनिश्चित करे कि अधिकारी पीएमएलए के तहत निर्धारित प्रक्रिया के साथ-साथ संवैधानिक सुरक्षा उपायों का भी उचित रूप से पालन करें।
Integrating Advocacy and Legal Tactics to Tackle Online Consumer Complaintsseoglobal20
Our company bridges the gap between registered users and experienced advocates, offering a user-friendly online platform for seamless interaction. This platform empowers users to voice their grievances, particularly regarding online consumer issues. We streamline support by utilizing our team of expert advocates to provide consultancy services and initiate appropriate legal actions.
Our Online Consumer Legal Forum offers comprehensive guidance to individuals and businesses facing consumer complaints. With a dedicated team, round-the-clock support, and efficient complaint management, we are the preferred solution for addressing consumer grievances.
Our intuitive online interface allows individuals to register complaints, seek legal advice, and pursue justice conveniently. Users can submit complaints via mobile devices and send legal notices to companies directly through our portal.
1. SUBJECT- HUMAN RIGHTS
COURSE- LL.B., VI-SEM
NOTES PREPARED BY- DINESH KUMAR (ASSISTANT PROFESSOR)
QUESTION AND ANSWERS
Q.1 WRITE ABOUT UNITED NATIONS HUMAN RIGHTS COUNCIL.
A. The Human Rights Council is the main inter-governmental body within the United
Nations system responsible for addressing situations of human rights violations. The
Council also receives thematic and country-specific reports from a series of independent
expert mechanisms, including special procedures, as well as from the Office of the High
Commissioner for Human Rights. Since the Council’s inception in 2006, Human Rights
Watch has been involved in strengthening its capacity to promote and protect human
rights worldwide and be more responsive to the needs of victims of rights violations. We
work to cast a light on the activities of the Council, hold its members accountable for
their actions and advance compliance with its objective of addressing “situations of
violations of human rights, including gross and systematic violations” around the world.
Q.2 WRITE MEASURES FOR PROTECTING CHILD RIGHTS.
A. Human rights apply to all age groups; children have the same general human rights as
adults. In 1989, however, world leaders decided that children needed a special convention
just for them because people under 18 years old often need special care and protection
that adults do not. The leaders also wanted to make sure that the world recognized that
children have human rights too. The Convention on the Rights of the Child (CRC) is the
first legally binding international instrument to incorporate the full range of human
rights—including civil, cultural, economic, political and social rights.
The Convention on the Rights of the Child sets out the rights that must be realized for
children to develop their full potential, free from hunger and want, neglect and abuse. It
reflects a new vision of the child. Children are neither the property of their parents nor
are they helpless objects of charity. They are human beings and are the subject of their
own rights. The Convention offers a vision of the child as an individual and as a member
of a family and community, with rights and responsibilities appropriate to his or her age
2. and stage of development. By recognizing children's rights in this way, the Convention
firmly sets the focus on the whole child.
These rights encompass freedom of children and their civil rights, family environment,
necessary healthcare and welfare, education, leisure and cultural activities and special
protection measures. The UNCRC outlines the fundamental human rights that should be
afforded to children in four broad classifications that suitably cover all civil, political,
social, economic and cultural rights of every child:
Right to Survival:
• Right to be born
• Right to minimum standards of food, shelter and clothing
• Right to live with dignity
• Right to health care, to safe drinking water, nutritious food, a clean and safe
environment, and information to help them stay healthy
Right to Protection:
• Right to be protected from all sorts of violence
• Right to be protected from neglect
• Right to be protected from physical and sexual abuse
• Right to be protected from dangerous drugs
Right to Participation:
S• Right to freedom of opinion
• Right to freedom of expression
• Right to freedom of association
• Right to information
• Right to participate in any decision making that involves him/her directly or indirectly
Right to Development:
• Right to education
• Right to learn
3. • Right to relax and play
• Right to all forms of development – emotional, mental and physical
Q3. WRITE TWO OBJECTS AND TWO SALIENT FEATURES OF THE HUMAN
RIGHTS ACT, 1993.
A. The main objective of protection of Human Rights Act 1993 is protecting human beings
from violations. Without Human rights there would be either no if or a meaning less life.
The rights relating to life, liberty equality and dignity of the individual as guaranteed by
the constitution are also included in the category of “Human Rights”. Human Rights are
the rights and freedoms of all human beings.
The purpose of securing human rights as such is to provide protection to these rights
against the abuse of power committed by the organs of state to establish institution for the
promotion of living condition beings and for the development of their personality and at
the same time to provide effective remedial measures for obtaining redress in the event of
those rights are violated. The act provides for establishment of National Human Rights
Commission, State Human right Commission and Human Rights Courts which seeks to
prevent and punish any gross violation of human rights.
Two salient features:
The human rights that everyone has and everyone equally by virtue of their very
humanity. They are grounded in our appeal to human nature. As such, their main
implications and characteristic features may be enumerated as under:-
It means in the first place, that everybody has them. The subject of human rights are not
the members of this or that society but of the community of humankind. There is no
question about full membership in this community for example, for children or the
insane. and there is some doubt as to whatever gouts can count as members in the sense
of themselves being subjects of Human Rights. But the basic justification, for holding
human rights is belong to the human race.
The objects of human rights, like those of plain rights, are of great importance. But just
as rights may be said to override other considerations, human rights may be said to
override mere rights. The human rights to life may be judged to out rank in a situation
where there is a contest between them, a right under a particular civil law, say, to the use
4. of land among trumps, it may be side, human rights are the coloured cards. And this is
what is meant by reference to human rights as absolute rights. It does not mean that
human rights are indivisible. Even the ace of trumps may be topped by a joker (the right
not to be tortured for example) against the need to know where the nuclear bomb has
been planted in the underground of by decision to play another game (the transition for
example from place to war). It means only that they are in general of the greatest
importance.
The exercise of human rights might have a more restricted range that that of civil rights.
We referred earlier to claiming, asserting demanding enjoying protecting and enforcing a
right. In the case of human rights the assertive and of this spectrum is the most
prominent. For very often human rights are appealed to when the claim they encompass
are not locally acknowledge in positive law.
There is the question of the location of the duties that correlate with human rights. In this
regard it has been argued that there are universal human rights in a strong and a weak
sense.
Rights in the strong sense are held against every body else. Rights in a weak sense are held
against a particular Section of humanity. Everyone has a right to life against everyone else. There
is general duty to respect it. But if every body holds, say economic and social rights, it is against
a particular government: duties are laid only on the responsible authorities. Thus, all basic human
rights are said to have three correlative duties-duties to avoid depriving duties to protect from
deprivation and duties to aid the deprived.
According to circumstances the duty bearers may be different (individuals, responsible nations,
exploitative companies) and the particular duty varied by aid in a natural disaster, avoidance of
deprivation in a monopolistic Market. But basic rights trigger all these kinds of duty.
What is characteristic of the justification of human rights? It is not an appeal to this statute or
that contract, for if the rights in question were written into the statutes or contracts, those
provisions under municipal law would by themselves be a sufficient justification. The
justification of human sright moves up one level to regional international law (e.g. the European
convention on Human Rights) or two levels to global international law (e.g. International
covenant on civil and political Rights and International covenant on Economic, Social and
5. Cultural Rights), so that the appeal is that standards internationally recognized should be met by
domestic practice. And there is a level above these which is the ultimate justification of human
rights. It is the level at which what is appealed to is not any kind of positive law, but is what
ought by some rational calculation to prevail.
Q 4. HOW DOES NATIONAL HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION CONSTITUTE?
A. Constitution of a National Human Rights Commission.-
(1) The Central Government shall constitute a body to be known as the National Human
Rights Commission to exercise the powers conferred upon, and to perform the functions
assigned to, it under this Act.
(2) the commission shall consist of-
(a) a Chairperson who has been a Chief Justice of the Supreme Court;
(b) one Member who is, or has been, a Judge of the Supreme e Court;
(c) one Member who is, or has been, the chief Justice of a High Court;
(d) two Members to be appointed from amongst persons having knowledge of, or
practical experience in, matters relating to human rights.
(3) The Chairperson of the National commission for Minorities, the National Commission
for the Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes and the National Commission for Women
shall be deemed to the Members of the Commission for the discharge of functions
specified in clauses (b) to (j) of section 12.
(4) There shall be a Secretary-General who shall be the chief Executive Office of the
Commission and shall exercise such powers and discharge such functions of the
Commission as it may delegate to him.
(5) The headquarters of the Commission shall be at Delhi and the Commission may, with
the previous approval of the Central Government, establish offices at other places in
India.
Q.5 COLLECTIVE RIGHTS
ANS. Collective Rights are a type of Human Rights, which unlike traditional rights, are
not vested in a single individual but belongs to all people so that all of them can
6. collective enjoyed. i.e they are enjoyed jointly rather than severally. Collective Rights are
also called Third Generation Rights, Solidarity Rights or New Rights.
Collective rights are held by a group, rather than any one individual. They have typically
been a focus of indigenous peoples and other groups whose rights are threatened by an
individualistic, capitalist system. For example, much of the "Third World" (now Global
South) organizing in the 1980s and 1990s focused on collective rights and finding ways
to enforce those rights in addition to the more widely-recognized individual rights. Some
examples include:
The right to speak one's native language and educate children in that language; the
right to cultural preservation
The rights of indigenous peoples to land and resources held collectively, and the
right to pass land and resources down through the generations
Environmental rights to clean air, water, and land
The right to national self-determination
The right to development
The right to autonomous self-government for minority groups
The right to restitution for lands stolen from the collective
These rights generally revolve around the rights of distinct groups to maintain a distinct identity
and be free from harm at the hands of a more powerful government, though there is also an
argument for collective rights held by the human race as a whole, such environmental rights or
the right to peace. Generally, the larger the group in question, the more controversial the idea of
a commonly held right.
Q. 6 EXPLAIN THE SCOPE OF PIL WITH RESPECT TO THE HUMAN RIGHTS
IN INDIA.
ANS. In Indian law, means litigation for the protection of public interest. It is litigation
introduced in a court of law, not by the aggrieved party but by the court itself or by any other
private party. It is not necessary, for the exercise of the court's jurisdiction, that the person
who is the victim of the violation of his or her right should personally approach the court.
Public Interest Litigation is the power given to the public by courts through judicial activism.
7. Public interest Litigation,
In simple words, means, litigation filed in a court of law, for the protection of Public Interest,
such as pollution, Terrorism, Road safety, constructional hazards etc.
Public interest litigation is not defined in any statute or in any act. It has been interpreted by
judges to consider the intent of public at large. Although, the main and only focus of such
litigation is only Public Interest there are various areas where a Public interest litigation can be
filed. For e.g.
- Violation of basic human rights of the poor
- Content or conduct of government policy
- Compel municipal authorities to perform a public duty.
- Violation of religious rights or other basic fundamental rights
Through the mechanism of PIL, the courts seek to protect human rights in the following
ways:
1) By creating a new regime of human rights by expanding the meaning of fundamental right to
equality, life and personal liberty. In this process, the right to speedy trial, free legal aid, dignity,
means and livelihood, education, housing, medical care, clean environment, right against torture,
sexual harassment, solitary confinement, bondage and servitude, exploitation and so on emerge
as human rights. These new reconceptualised rights provide legal resources to activate the courts
for their enforcement through PIL.
2) By democratization of access of justice. This is done by relaxing the traditional rule of locus
standi. Any public spirited citizen or social action group can approach the court on behalf of the
oppressed classes. Courts attention can be drawn even by writing a letter or sending a telegram.
This has been called epistolary jurisdiction.
3) By fashioning new kinds of reliefs under the court’s writ jurisdiction. For example, the court
can award interim compensation to the victims of governmental lawlessness. This stands in sharp
contrast to the Anglo-Saxon model of adjudication where interim relief is limited to preserving
the status quo pending final decision. The grant of compensation in PIL matters does not
8. preclude the aggrieved person from bringing a civil suit for damages. In PIL cases the court can
fashion any relief to the victims.
4) By judicial monitoring of state institutions such as jails, women’s protective homes, juvenile
homes, mental asylums, and the like. Through judicial invigilation, the court seeks gradual
improvement in their management and administration. This has been characterized as creeping
jurisdiction in which the court takes over the administration of these institutions for protecting
human rights.
5) By devising new techniques of fact-finding. In most of the cases the court has appointed its
own socio-legal commissions of inquiry or has deputed its own official for investigation.
Sometimes it has taken the help of National Human Rights Commission or Central Bureau of
Investigation (CBI) or experts to inquire into human rights violations. This may be called
investigative litigation.
10 ARKS QUESTIONS
Q.7 CONCEPT OF HUMAN RIGHTS AND FUNDAMENTAAL RIGHTS.
ANS. Human rights are the basic rights and freedoms that belong to every person in the
world, from birth until death. They apply regardless of where you are from, what you believe
or how you choose to live your life. They can never be taken away, although they can
sometimes be restricted – for example if a person breaks the law, or in the interests of
national security. These basic rights are based on shared values like dignity, fairness,
equality, respect and independence. These values are defined and protected by law.
Human rights are fundamental rights, commonly understood, as inalienable fundamental
rights to which a person is inherently entitled simply because she or he is a human being."
Human rights are therefore conceived as universal. These rights may exist as natural rights or
as legal rights in law. Thus, we can say they are basic rights or freedom to which all human
being are entitled no matter what their status, gender, religion etc. is. As John F. Kennedy
states; “The rights of every man are diminished when the rights of one man are threatened.”
The value is mirrored as the idea of human rights states, "if the public discourse of peacetime
global society can be said to have a common moral language, it is that of human rights."
9. Although ideas of rights and liberty have existed in some form for much of human history,
they do not resemble the modern conception of human rights.
Many of the basic ideas that founded the Human Rights legislation was a result of the
aftermath of World War II, and thus consequently the adoption of the Universal Declaration
of Human Rights (UDHR) occurred. The doctrine of human rights in international practice
has been a cornerstone of public policy around the world. Despite this, the strong claims
made by the doctrine of human rights continue to provoke considerable scepticism and
debates about the content, nature and justifications of human rights to this day. This even
includes the idea of 'what is a right?' and this has lead to many controversies and is the
subject of many debates.
The Rights and Fundamental Rights are sections of the Constitution of India that provides
people with their rights. These Fundamental Rights are considered as basic human rights of
all citizens, irrespective of their gender, caste, religion or creed. etc. These sections are the
vital elements of the constitution, which was developed between 1947 and 1949 by the
Constitution of India. There are six fundamental rights in India. They are Right to Equality,
Right to Freedom, Right against Exploitation, Right to Freedom of Religion, Cultural and
Educational Rights, and Right to Constitutional Remedies.
Right to Equality ensures equal rights for all the citizens. The Right to Equality
prohibits inequality on the basis of caste, religion, place of birth, race, or gender. It
also ensures equality of opportunity in matters of public employment and prevents the
State from discriminating against anyone in matters of employment on the grounds
only of religion, race, caste, sex, descent, place of birth, place of residence or any of
them.
Right to freedom provides us with various rights. These rights are freedom of
speech, freedom of expression, freedom of assembly without arms, freedom of
movement throughout the territory of our country, freedom of association, freedom to
practice any profession, freedom to reside in any part of the country. However, these
rights have their own restrictions.
Right against Exploitation condemns human trafficking, child labor, forced labor
making it an offense punishable by law, and also prohibit any act of compelling a
10. person to work without wages where he was legally entitled not to work or to receive
remuneration for it. Unless it is for the public purpose, like community services or
NGO work.
Right to Freedom of Religion guarantees religious freedom and ensures secular
states in India. The Constitutions says that the States should treat all religions equally
and impartially and that no state has an official religion. It also guarantees all people
the freedom of conscience and the right to preach, practice and propagate any religion
of their choice.
Cultural and Educational Rights protects the rights of cultural, religious and
linguistic minorities by enabling them to conserve their heritage and protecting them
against discrimination. Educational rights ensure education for everyone irrespective
of their caste, gender, religion, etc.
Right to Constitutional Remedies ensures citizens to go to the supreme court of
India to ask for enforcement or protection against violation of their fundamental
rights. The Supreme Court has the jurisdiction to enforce the Fundamental Rights
even against private bodies, and in case of any violation, award compensation as well
to the affected individual.
The Supreme Court recently added Right To Privacy in the fundamental rights.
Q. 8 EXPLAIN THE PROVISIONS RELATING TO THE INVESTIGATION BY
THE NATION HUMAN RIGHTS COMMISSION(NHRC).
ANS. Introduction
“Human rights” means the rights relating to life, liberty, equality and dignity of the
individual guaranteed under the Constitution or embodied in the International Covenants and
enforced by courts in India.” All human beings are born with some unalienable rights like
life, liberty and pursuit of happiness. The importance of these natural rights can be found in
the fact that these are fundamental for their proper existence and no other rights can be
enjoyed without the presence of rights to life and liberty.
The complaints against the human rights offences can be divided into three categories: (a)
complaint to the National Human Rights Commission, (b) complaint to the State Human
11. Rights Commission and (c) complaint to the police authorities or private complaint at District
Human Rights Courts. The investigation and prosecutions procedures are different in these
categories. Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993, has not defined the term "complaint" and
"offence". The Section 12 of the Act deals with the various functions of the National Human
Rights Commission. This section is applicable to the State Human Rights Commissions also.
The first codified function is as follows; Inquire, suo motu or on a petition presented to it by
a victim or any person on his behalf [or on a direction or order of any court, into complaint
of:- (i) Violation of human rights or abetment thereof; or (ii) Negligence in the prevention of
such violation, by a public servantii ; The Section 17 of the Act deals with the inquiry into
complaints. Accordingly, sections 12 and 17 of the Act uses the term "complaint".
The section 30 of the Act says that for the purpose of providing for speedy trial of offences
arising out of violation of human rights, the state government may, with the concurrence of
chief justice of the High Court, by notification, specify for each district a Court of Sessions to
be a human rights court to try the said offences; The section 37 of the Act says about the
constitution of special investigation teams to investigate the human rights offences.
Accordingly, sections 30 and 37 of the Act uses the word "offence".
Criminal Procedure Code, 1973, is applicable for the Human Rights Courts. High Court of
Madras clearly mentioned in its judgment that it is legally permissible for the relevant
provisions of the Criminal Procedure Code to be swing into operation for the trial of „Human
Rights‟ expecting matters in respect of specific provisions has been made in the Protection of
Human Rights Act. Hence, it is very clear that the definition of the complaint and offence are
applicable for the cases before the human rights courts.
There is no specific provision in PHR Act as to locus standi in the matter of approaching
Human Rights Courts for redressal of grievances in relation to violation of human rights,
amounting to offences whether cognizable or non- cognizable. In the absence of such a
provision, Human Rights Court being a criminal court have to necessarily follow the
procedure laid down in the Criminal Procedure Code.
Investigation It is noteworthy to know the investigation process in criminal cases before examining
the investigation process in the human rights cases. In criminal cases, on receipt of the complaint,
the police officer registers the First Information Report under section 154 of the Criminal Procedure
12. Code. A police officer is competent to investigate only cognizable offences. Non cognizable offences
cannot be investigated by the police without obtaining prior orders from the courts. The
investigation of the complaint begins from the First Information Report. A police officer can examine
witnesses under section 161. However, the statements are not to be signed by the witnesses.
Confessions of accused persons and statements of witnesses are recorded under section 164 of the
Code. A police officer has the power to conduct searches in emergent situations without a warrant
from the court under section 165. A police officer is competent to arrest an accused suspected to be
involved in a cognizable offence without an order from the court in circumstances specified in
section 41 of the Code. He is required to maintain a day to day account of the investigation
conducted by him under section 172. After completion of investigation, a police officer is required to
submit a final report to the court under section 173. If a prima facie case is made out, this final
report is filed in the shape of a charge-sheet. The accused has, thereafter, to face trial. If no cogent
evidence comes on record, a closure report is filed in the Courtvi . In criminal cases, on receipt of the
complaint, if the police officer refuses to register the First Information Report, the complainant has
right to file private complaint before the concern court. The procedure is given in Section 200 and
203 of the Criminal Procedure Code. There is no investigation proceedings in the private complaint.
Investigation in human rights cases are differ from the criminal cases.
Section 14 of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 deals with investigation, which as follows;
(1) The Commission may, for the purpose of conducting any investigation pertaining to the inquiry,
utilize the services of any officer or investigation agency of the Central Government or any State
Government with the concurrence of the Central Government, or the State Government as case
may be. (2) For the purpose of instigating into any matter pertaining to the inquiry, any officer or
agency whose services are utilized under sub-section (1) may, subject to the direction and control of
the Commission, - (a) Summon and enforce the attendance of any person and examine him; (b)
Require the discovery and production of document; and (c) Requisition any public record or copy
thereof from any office. (3) The provisions of section 15 shall apply in relation to any statement
made by a person before any officer or agency whose service are utilized under sub-section (1) as
they apply in relation to any statement made by a person in the course of giving evidence before the
Commission. (4) The officer or agency whose services are utilized under sub-section (1) shall
investigate into any matter pertaining to the inquiry and submit a report thereon to the Commission
within such period as may be specified by the Commission in this behalf. (5) The Commission shall
satisfy itself about the correctness of the facts stated and the conclusion, if any, arrived at in the
13. court submitted to it under sub-section (4) and for this purpose the Commission may make such
inquiry (including the examination of the person or person who conducted to assisted in the
investigation) as it thinks fitvii . This provision is applicable to the National and State Human Rights
Commissions. According to the National Human Rights Commission's regulation (8) 6, on admission
of a complaint, the Chairperson/Commission shall direct whether the matter would be set down for
inquiry by it or should be investigatedviii. The regulation 17 provides the investigation team for the
Commission. The State Human Rights Commission's regulation 21 provides power to issue order for
investigation on the complaints and regulation 4 provides the investigation division for the
Commission. Generally, on receipt of human rights complaints, the human rights commissions shall
call for reports from the concern Government or authority and proceeds with same. Directing for
investigation on the complaints of human rights violations is discretionary power of the human
rights commissions. According to the human rights commission's sources, in less than ten
percentages of complaints only commissions directed for the investigation.
The Section 37 of the Protection of Human Rights Act, 1993 provides constitution of special
investigation teams. The provision as follows; Notwithstanding anything contained in any other law
for the time being in force, where the Government considers, it necessary so to do, it may constitute
one or more special investigation teams, consisting of such police officers as it thinks necessary for
purposes of investigation and prosecution of offences arising out of violations of human rightsix .
But, Central or State governments have not yet constituted such special investigation teams from
1993 to till date. No first information report was registered in human rights cases by station house
officer of the police station under the Protection of Human Rights Act. Private complaints were filed
and taken on the file of Human Rights Courts in Tamil Nadu from 1996 to 2011. To avoid this defect,
a special investigation team for human rights should be appointed under section 37 of the
Protection of Human Rights Act in the districts. If the special investigation team for human rights
refuses or drops the proceedings, victims of human rights violations have right to file private
complaint before the Human Rights Courtsx . On receipt of direct complaints, the district special
investigation team has to register First Information Report and proceed the investigation in
accordance with the Criminal Procedure Code and file the report to the district human rights court
for trial, which was explained earlier. The complaints of human rights violations will be against the
public servants. Hence, these teams have to under the control of existing Inspector General of
Police, investigation division of State Human Rights Commissions. The investigation division of the
State Human Rights Commissions shall come under the control of existing Director-General of
14. Police, investigation agency of the National Human Rights Commissions. Thus, National Human
Rights Investigation Agency (NHRIA) has to established independently like Central Bureau of
Investigation. On receipt of complaints, the human rights commissions shall call for investigation
report from the concern district special investigation team and proceed to the inquiry. Hence, the
proposed system shall provide the investigation in each and every complaint.
Q.9 EXPLAIN THE CONSTITUTION AND SALIENT FEATURES OF
NATIONAL COMMISSION FOR WOMEN.
Ans. The National Commission for Women Act was passed in the year 1990 by the
notification of Central Government in the Official Gazette. As there was lack of
constitutional, economical and social interest to protect the women in India they faced many
problems and injustices caused to them. Government considered as handicapped as they
lacked policies to face the problem of women, need for certain Commission to look in to the
grievances of women. The National Commission for Women established in January 1992
under the Indian Constitution as defined in National Commission for Women Act, 1990.
Central Government laid the structure for formation of Commission by passing the bill in
Lok Sabha in May 1990, the bill was passed and received the president assent on 30th
August 1990. The first Commission was constituted on January 31 1992 as Jayanti patnaik as
the chairperson to assist the women in redressal of their grievances.
Salient features
National Commission for Women is also one of the significant statutory bodies established
by the Government of India. It was established in 1992 under the provisions of the National
Commission for Women Act, 1990.
The Central Government took the initiative to establish this Commission by keeping in view
the provisions of India’s constitution to strengthen the women in country through addressing
plights, suppressions and other types of violence they use to face. National Commission for
Women also takes the initiatives for overall development of women community in whole
country. Main aim of National Commission for Women is to raise the concern for the women
15. and to represent itself for their rights. This Commission takes into account the issues and
concerns of women community and advises for the authentic solution of all the problems
they face.
Composition of National Commission for Women
The Commission shall consist of
(a) A Chairperson, committed to the cause of women, to be nominated by the Central
Government.
(b) five Members to be nominated by the Central Government from amongst persons of
ability, integrity and standing who have had experience in law or legislation, trade unionism,
management of an industry potential of women, women’s voluntary organizations ( including
women activist ), administration, economic development, health, education or social welfare;
Provided that at least one Member each shall be from amongst persons belonging to the
Scheduled Castes and Scheduled Tribes respectively;
Functions of National Commission for Women
Work as the coordinating agency to receive and process all the complaints related to
Indian Women deserted by their Overseas Indian husbands.
Shall render all possible assistance to the complaints including conciliation,
mediation between the parties and advising the complainant on related issues.
Associating, networking with NGOs, community organizations in India and overseas
and State women Commissions for wider area coverage, so as to assist easy access
and provide support services.
Shall endeavour towards a coordinated response amongst various Government
agencies/organizations such as State Governments, The National Human Rights
Commission, Indian Embassies and Mission, concerned Ministries etc.
Provide assistance to the distressed woman in litigation and other issues pertaining to
the complainant/case.
Shall maintain a data bank record of cases registered.
16. Seek reports from the State Government and other authorities on the complaints filed
and action taken thereon.
Shall advice and recommend the government on any policy or issue relating to the
NRI marriages.
Investigate various legal treaties on the issue and advice the Government on the
subject, wherever required.
Shall constitute an advisory committee panel of reputed advocates/NGOs, both in
India as well as abroad, which shall intermittently review the functioning of the cell,
cases filed and policy issues.
Shall constitute a panel of experts (All India) to support the aggrieved wife and
rendering legal services and other assistance, including mediation and conciliation
Planning of training modules and conducting training on sensitisation on the subject
to the various agencies entrusted with the task of providing justice, vig. Judiciary,
police, administration, etc.
Shall organize awareness campaigns for the masses on the issue.
This commission has responsibility to encourage /support research and study in the
related field like issues of grievances associated with dual citizenship, enactment of
new legislation or signing of international treaties, marriage laws of other countries,
etc.
NCW must look into complaints and take suo-moto notice on any issue brought to the
notice of the NRI Cell in accordance with Section 10 (1)(f) of the National
Commission for Women Act , 1990 read with sub-section 4 of Section 10 and Section
8 of the Act.
The cell shall control its own procedures in accordance with the National
Commission for Women Act 1990.
NCW must perform any other function as assigned to it by the Commission/Central
Government.
Q. 10 EXPLAIN THE MINORITY RIGHTS AND SCOPE OF THEIR PROTECTION
IN INDIA.
ANS. INTRODUCTION
17. Minority rights are the normal individual rights as applied to members of racial, ethnic,
class, religious, linguistic or gender and sexual minorities; and also the
collective rights accorded to minority groups.Minority rights may also apply simply to
individualrights of anyone who is not part of a majority decision.
The expression “minority” has been derived from the Latin word “minor” and the suffix ‘ity’, which
means “small in number”. According to Encyclopedia Britannica minorities means “group held
together by ties of common descent, language or religious faith and feeling different in these
respects from the inhabitants of a given political entity”.
The United Nations Commission on Human Rights in 1950 had defined minorities as below:
Only those communities other than the ruling national community can be termed as minorities, who
want to have a language, religion or race different from the language, religion and race of the
national community. It is essential for being recognized as minorities that they should be sufficient
in number and their constituents should be faithful to the nation in which they live.”
Minority as per the Constitution of India
The architects of the Indian Constitution guaranteed to minorities all necessary rights and freedoms
but have no where defined the expression “Minority”. There is no parliamentary legislation either
defining a ‘minority.’ The Motilal Nehru Report (1928) showed a prominent desire to afford
protection to minorities, but did not define the expression. The Sapru Report (1945) also proposed,
inter alia, a Minorities Commission but did not define Minority.
The Constitution of India strives to achieve a harmony between all the communities by
ensuring “justice, social, economic or political” to all citizens and declaring itself to be a
secular state. While certain laws are applicable to all Indian citizens, there are personal laws
that apply to certain communities only, preserving their customs and beliefs. Minority rights
protection in India has always been in limelight with political parties garnering votes of
various communities through triggering their emotions upon their minority status.
Under the Constitution of India, there are various provisions to safeguard the rights of
minorities. Preamble of the Constitution declares India to be a secular state. Article 15
prohibits any sort of discrimination on the grounds of race, religion, caste, sex, descent, place
of birth or residence. Article 16 also prohibits any sort of discrimination when it comes to
18. public employment, on the basis of religion, caste, language, race and so on. This guarantees
equal employment opportunities to all the Indian citizens in case of government offices.
The right to profess, practice and propagate any religion has been guaranteed to every person
as a fundamental right under Article 25 of the Indian Constitution. This article allows the
minority communities to follow their beliefs and practices without any hindrance as long as it
does not hamper public order, morality and health of any person.
Article 29 of the Constitution provides the citizens with the right to conserve their language,
script and culture; as well as guarantees that they would not be denied admission into any
educational institution based on their race, language, religion or caste. This right is provided
to any section of the society, whether it has been recognised as a minority by the State or not.
Article 30 is pivotal to the protection of minority rights in India. It provides the minorities the
right to establish and administer educational institutions and the State has been prohibited
from any discrimination in matters of granting aids to such institutions. But these educational
institutions can be regulated by the State. Although this article uses the term “minorities”, it
has not been given any definition by the Indian Constitution. The judiciary has tried to dwell
upon this matter in various cases.
In the judgment of In re Kerala Education Bill[20], the Supreme Court held that the meaning
of the term minority can be construed to a “community which is less than 50% of the total
population” in a defined area.[21] In D.A.V. College v. State of Punjab[22], it was held that
Hindus even though they are majority in the nation, can be treated as a minority in State of
Punjab for the purpose of conserving their language under Article 29 of the Constitution.
Hence, religious or linguistic minority status should be construed in relation to the legislation
which is sought to be impugned, in case of state legislature, according to the state
population.[23] In A.S.E. Trust v. Director, Education, Delhi Administration, it was held that
only those religions such as Muslims, Christians, Jains, Buddhists, Sikhs etc., which have
kept their identities separated from the majority, i.e., Hindus, can only be considered to be
“minority” based on religion.[24] Not every section of the Hindu religion can be considered
to be minority.
19. TMA Pai foundation Case also upheld that the minority status of any community has to be
decided based on state population.[25] It also established that Article 30(1) confers both
linguistic and religious minorities the right to establish and administer educational institutions of
their choice, albeit the right to administer is not absolute. The Judges also held that aided
minority institutions need to admit a certain number of non-minority students so as to maintain a
balance between minorities’ right under Article 30(1) and citizen’s rights against discrimination
under Article 29(2).
The National Commission for Minority Educational Institution Act, 2004, amended in 2006 and
2010, was promulgated with an objective to safeguard the minorities’ educational rights as
mentioned in Article 30(1).
Minority Protection Through Enforcement Of Personal Laws
Before the colonial rule in India, Personal laws were widely applied in India, including
Hindu laws, Muslim Laws, and Jewish Laws. The British also used the policy of non-
interference with these personal laws. In the contemporary India also, the matters related to
marriage, divorce, succession and family affairs are mostly governed by the personal laws
specific to the certain communities.
National Commission for Minorities
The National Commission for Minorities was established by the National Commission for
Minorities Act, 1992 to protect minority rights in the country. The commission consists of
one chairperson and six members representing the six minor communities – Muslims, Sikhs,
Buddhists, Christians, Parsis and Jains. The Commission performs various functions
including evaluating the development of minority communities under Union and States,
ensuring the safeguard of minority rights as per the Constitutional laws and other legislations,
conducting studies and researches on the matters related to minorities and suggesting
measures to Government on these aspects.
Conclusion
Though minorities are those whose are numerically less based on their language and culture,
it is evident from the above arguments that the Indian Constitution provides certain rights to
20. the minorities residing in several parts of Indian territories. The Constitution of India has not
defined the term ‘minority’, but had provided them with all the opportunities needed for their
survival in the form of fundamental rights. Since India is a secular country, it is important to
maintain the integrity of nation by maintaining a status of equality as because of its rich
cultural values and tolerance. Besides this, there are also certain fundamental duties under
Article 51A given in Part IV-A of the Constitution of India for every citizen.
The main focus of the law is to create confidence in the mind of such minorities that they are
protected by the law of the Constitution and also they are treated equally on par with the majority
so that there would be no any kind of discrimination among the citizens.
Q. 11 WHAT HUMAN RIGHTS ARE INCLUDED IN RIGHT TO LIVE UNDER
ARTICLE 21.
ANS. INTRODUCTION
The Constitution of India guarantees the right to life and personal liberty in Part III under the
category of Right to Freedom (Articles 19-22). The right to life and personal liberty in
accordance with the procedure established by law is guarantee by Article 21 of the Indian
Constitution. The right is available to both citizens and non-citizens.
The ambit of Article 21 have expanded over the years through judicial precedents. According
to article 21, a person can be deprived of his life and personal liberty according to a
procedure established by law. To have a proper understanding of article 21, we are required
to travel a journey from A K Gopalan (1950 SC) case to Maneka Gandhi (1978 SC) case,
which reflect two opposite dimensions and scope of this article.
In Maneka Gandhi case, Personal liberty has been given an expansive meaning. It was held
that articles 21, 14 & 19 are not mutually exclusive. In the words of justice VR Krishna Iyer,
“no article in the constitution relating to fundamental rights is an island in itself. They are
group of Islands connected with each other, i.e. not separate Islands”. On personal liberty,
Justice Iyer said, “the spirit of the man is at root of article 21. Personal liberty makes the
worth of human person and travel makes Liberty worthwhile.”
21. The most significant and creative aspect of Maneka Gandhi case is the reinterpretation of
procedure established by law. According to it the procedure established by law must be fair,
reasonable and non-arbitrary. The court reached this conclusion I holding that article 21, 9 and
14th are not mutually exclusive but they are interlinked. It brought in the requirement of
visibility of article 19 into article 21. Justice Krishna Iyer said, “Procedure in article 21 means
fair and not formal procedure and law is a reasonable law and not any enacted piece.”
Thus, the ambit of article 21 also includes right to travel abroad and principles of natural justice
must be applied while exercising this right.
Different Aspects Of Article 21
The expanded scope of Article 21 has been explained further in the case of Unni
Krishnan v. State of A.P In the case the court provided the list of some of the
rights covered under Article 21. Some of them are listed below:
The right to go abroad
The right to privacy
The right to education
The right against solitary confinement
The right against hand cuffing
The right against delayed execution
The right to shelter
Right to livelihood
Right to health and medical aid
The right against custodial death
The right against public hanging
Doctors assistance
Through various judgments the Court also included many of the non-justifiable
Directive Principles embodied under part IV of the Constitution. Some of them
are:
Right to pollution free water and air
22. Protection of under-trial
Right of every child to a full development
Protection of cultural heritage.
Right to Live with Dignity
Supreme Court has given a broad and liberal interpretation to the term life as used in Article 21.
In Munn Vs. Illinois (94 U.S. 113), J.Field spoke of the right to live as follows, “by the term
‘life’ as here used, something more is meant than sheer animal existence”. Supporting this view,
Justice Bhagwati, in Francis Coralie Vs. U.T. of Delhi (1981 SC), had observed, “we think that
right to life includes the right to live with human dignity and all that grows along with it namely,
the bare necessities of life such as the adequate nutrition, clothing and shelter over the head and
facilities for reading, writing and expressing oneself. The protection extends to all those limbs of
body by which the life is enjoyed”.
In Bandhua Mukti Morcha Vs. Union of India (1984 SC), Justice Bhagwati reiterated his view
and held that it is the fundamental right of every person in this country to live with human
dignity which is free from exploitation. This right to live with human dignity is enshrined under
article 21 drives its life breath from the DPSP.
Right to Die
Right to life includes right to lead dignified life. The question arises hair that
does it also confer I write not to live if a person chooses to end his life?
P.Ratinam Vs. Union of India,1994 SC, The two judge bench rule that right
to life under article 21 also embodies within itself a right not to live forced life to
his detriment hand held that section 309 of IPC is void. But Ratinam case was
overruled by full bench in Gian Kaur vs State of Punjab, 1996 SC. In this
case it was held that section 309 of IPC is not unconstitutional and also section
306 is Constitutional. Supreme Court further said that the right to life is a
natural right which is embodied in article 21, but suicide is an unnatural
23. termination or extinction of life. Therefore it is incompatible and inconsistent
with the concept of right to life and so both are constitutional.
In Common Cause (A Regd. Society) Vs. Union of India (2018 SC), a five-
judge Constitution Bench, judgment delivered by Chief Justice Dipak Mishra,
gave legal sanction to passive euthanasia, permitting ‘living will’ by patients on
withdrawing medical support if they slip into irreversible state of coma. The SC
held that the right to die with dignity is a fundamental right.
Right To Life Extends To Livelihood
In 1960, the Hon’ble Supreme Court was of the view that Article 21 of Indian
Constitution does not guarantee right to livelihood.
Re Sant Ram (1960 SC), a case which came up before Maneka Gandhi in
which the Apex Court ruled that the right to livelihood would not fall within the
expression “life” in Article 21.
In Olga Tellis Vs. Bombay Municipal Corporation (1986 SC), a case which
was brought by pavement dwellers to resist eviction of their habitat by the
Bombay Municipal Corporation, the right to livelihood is born out of the right to
life, as no person can live without the means of living, that is, the means of
livelihood. The Court has observed in this connection:
“….the question which we have to consider is whether the right to life includes
the right to livelihood. We see only one answer to that question, namely, that it
does. The sweep of the right to life conferred by Article 21 is wide and far-
reaching. It does not mean, merely that life cannot be extinguished or taken
away as, for example, by the imposition and execution of the death sentence,
except according to procedure established by law. That is but one aspect of the
right to life an equally important facet of that right is the right to livelihood
24. because, no person can live without the means of living, that is, the means of
livelihood.”
If the right to livelihood is not treated as part and parcel of the constitutional
right to life, the easiest way of depriving a person of his right to life would be to
deprive him of his means of livelihood to the point of abrogation.
Right to Education
Right to education is one of the most important aspect human beings without
which no one can lead good, decent and dignified life. Earlier, it was the part of
Directive Principles of State Policy. However as per the changing needs of the
society Supreme Court in Mohini Jain Vs. State of Karnataka (1992
SC) and Unni Krishna Vs. state of Andhra Pradesh (1993 SC) ruled that
right to education is a fundamental right as it directly flows from right to life.
Earlier the Court interpreted right to education under article 21 but in the year
2002, by constitutional amendment, article 21-A was inserted to the Indian
Constitution and right to education was expressly made as a fundamental right.
Right to Privacy
Kharak Singh vs State of Tamilnadu (1963 SC), this issue was raised for
the first time. Justice Subba Rao it is Minority judgement said that the right to
privacy flows from the expression personal liberty. This minority judgement
paved path for the development.
In PUCL vs Union of India (1997 SC), Telephonic conversation, the court
said, was a part of modern man’s life and and important faces of a man’s
private life. Therefore, the Court ruled that telephone tapping would attract
article 21, unless it was permitted under the procedure established by law.
25. In Selvi vs State of Karnataka, it was held that in involuntary subjection of
person to test such as narco analysis, polygraph examination also violates the
right to privacy.
In Ramlila Maidan case (2012 SC), the Honourable Supreme Court has said
that citizens/persons have right to laser, to sleep, not to here and to remain
silent. The Knock at the door weather by day or by night as a prelude to a
search without authority of law amounts to police incursion into privacy and
violation of fundamental right of a citizen. Right to privacy has been held to be a
fundamental right of a citizen being an integral part of article 21 of the Indian
Constitution. It was also said that the right to life and personal liberty also
includes right to sleep.
Justice KS Puttaswamy (Retd.) Vs. Union of India (2018 SC), has been
proven to be a landmark judgement in deciding the issue whether right to
privacy is constitutionally protected. The nine Judges bench has held that:
The right to privacy is protected as an intrinsic part of the right to life and personal liberty
under article 21 and as a part of the freedoms guaranteed by part III of the constitution.
The decision in MP Sharma case which held that right to privacy is not protected by the
constitution was overruled.
The decision in Khadak Singh case to the extent that it held that right to privacy is not
protected by the constitution was overruled.
Decisions subsequent to Khadak Singh case which had enunciated the position in (i)
above lay down the correct position in law.
Navtej Singh Johar Vs. Union of India (2018 SC), proved to be another
milestone in the development of right to privacy and an important precedent
delivered by five-judge Bench. The Section 377 of the Indian Penal Code has
been partially struck down by decriminalizing same-sex relations between
consenting adults. Now, the LGBT individuals are legally allowed to engage in
consensual intercourse. The Apex Court has upheld provisions in Section 377,
IPC, that criminalize non-consensual acts or sexual acts performed on animals.
26. Right against Illegal Detention
The Supreme Court in the case of Joginder Kumar v. State of Uttar
Pradesh[xvii] laid down the guidelines governing arrest of a person during
investigation:
An arrested person being held in custody is entitled, if he so requests, to have a friend,
relative or other person told as far as is practicable that he has been arrested and where he
is being detained.
The police officer shall inform the arrested person, when he is brought to the police
station, of this right.
An entry shall be required to be made in the diary as to who was informed of the arrest.
Further in D.K. Basu v. State of West Bengal,[xviii] the Supreme Court laid
down detailed guidelines to be followed by the central and state investigating
agencies in all cases of arrest and detention till legal provisions are made in that
behalf as preventive measures. The court also held that any form of torture,
cruel, inhuman or degrading treatment, whether it occurs during interrogation,
investigation or otherwise, falls within the ambit of Article 21.
Right to Medical Care
In Parmananda Katara v. Union of India[xlvii], the Supreme Court has very specifically clarified
that preservation of life is of paramount importance. The Apex Court stated that ‘once life is lost,
status quo ante cannot be restored[xlviii].’ It was held that it is the professional obligation of all
doctors (government or private) to extent medical aid to the injured immediately to preserve life
without legal formalities to be complied with the police. Article21 casts the obligation on the
state to preserve life. It is the obligation of those who are in charge of the health of the
community to preserve life so that the innocent may be protected and the guilty may be
punished. No law or state action can intervene to delay and discharge this paramount obligation
of the members of the medical profession.
Right to get Pollution Free Water and Air
27. In Subhas Kumar v. State of Bihar[lxi], it has held that a Public Interest Litigation is
maintainable for insuring enjoyment of pollution free water and air which is included in ‘right to
live’ under Art.21 of the constitution. The court observed:
“Right to live is a fundamental right under Art 21 of the Constitution and it includes the right of
enjoyment of pollution free water and air for full enjoyment of life. If anything endangers or
impairs that quality of life in derogation of laws, a citizen has right to have recourse to Art.32 of
the Constitution for removing the pollution of water or air which may be detrimental to the
quality of life.”
Right to Clean Environment
The “Right to Life” under Article 21 means a life of dignity to live in a proper environment free
from the dangers of diseases and infection. Maintenance of health, preservation of the sanitation
and environment have been held to fall within the purview of Article 21 as it adversely affects
the life of the citizens and it amounts to slow poisoning and reducing the life of the citizens
because of the hazards created if not checked.
The following are some of the well-known cases on environment under Article 21:
In M.C. Mehta v. Union of India(1988)[lxii], the Supreme Court ordered closure of tanneries that
were polluting water.
In M.C. Mehta v. Union of India(1997)[lxiii], the Supreme Court issued several guideline and
directions for the protection of the Taj Mahal, an ancient monument, from environmental
degradation.
In Vellore Citizens Welfare Forum v. Union of India[lxiv], the Court took cognizance of the
environmental problems being caused by tanneries that were polluting the water resources,
rivers, canals, underground water and agricultural land. The Court issued several directions to
deal with the problem.
In Milk Men Colony Vikas Samiti v. State Of Rajasthan[lxv], the Supreme Court held that the
„right to life‟ means clean surrounding which lead to healthy body and mind. It includes right to
freedom from stray cattle and animals in urban areas.
28. In M.C. Mehta v. Union of India (2006)[lxvi], the Court held that the blatant and large-scale
misuse of residential premises for commercial use in Delhi, violated the right to salubrious sand
decent environment. Taking note of the problem the Court issued directives to the Government
on the same.
In Murli S. Deora v. Union of India[lxvii], the persons not indulging in smoking cannot be
compelled to or subjected to passive smoking on account of act of smokers. Right to Life under
Article 21 is affected as a non-smoker may become a victim of someone smoking in a public
place. Right Against Noise Pollution
In Re: Noise Pollution[lxviii], the case was regarding noise pollution caused by obnoxious levels
of noise due to bursting of crackers during Diwali. The Apex Court suggested to desist from
bursting and making use of such noise making crackers.
Right to Know or Right to Be Informed
Holding that the right to life has reached new dimensions and urgency the Supreme Court in R.P.
Ltd. v. Proprietors Indian Express Newspapers, Bombay Pvt. Ltd., observed that if democracy
had to function effectively, people must have the right to know and to obtain the conduct of
affairs of the State.
In Essar Oil Ltd. v. Halar Utkarsh Samiti, the Supreme Court said that there was a strong link
between Art.21 and Right to know, particularly where “secret government decisions may affect
health, life and livelihood.
Reiterating the above observations made in the instant case, the Apex Court in Reliance
Petrochemicals Ltd. v. Proprietors of Indian Express Newspapers, ruled that the citizens who had
been made responsible to protect the environment had a right to know the government proposal.
Right to Speedy Trial
In Hussainara Khatoon v. Home Secretary, State of Bihar[lxxxiv], it was brought to the notice of
the Supreme Court that an alarming number of men, women and children were kept in prisons
for years awaiting trial in courts of law. The Court took a serious note of the situation and
observed that it was carrying a shame on the judicial system that permitted incarceration of men
and women for such long periods of time without trials.
29. The Court held that detention of under-trial prisoners, in jail for period longer than what they
would have been sentenced if convicted, was illegal as being in violation of Article of 21. The
Court, thus, ordered the release from jail of all those under-trial prisoners, who had been in jail
for longer period than what they could have been sentenced had they been convicted.
Conclusion
Article 21 is a live provision in the constitution of India which constantly evolves
like an organism and inherits the traits of dynamism that caters the needs of
the society. The Ambit of right to life and personal liberty keeps on expanding
and will evolve further in future through various judicial pronouncements and
legislative enactment. It is serves as an under-stream that touches every
fundamental right in part III of the Indian Constitution.
On the basis of reasonability and non-arbitrariness and the principles of natural
justice which are enshrined within the Ambit of article 21, many rights have
been evolved till date through Hon’ble Supreme Court’s interpretations in its
judgements. Some other rights within the ambit of Article 21, which have been
evolved through various precedents of Apex Court, but have not been covered
in detail in this write-up are: right to environment, Right of prisoners, right to
speedy and fair trial, right against sexual harassment, right against handcuffing,
right to medical care, Right to food and right against malnutrition, right against
custodial violence, right not to be subjected to bonded labour, right to Legal
Aid, right against solitary confinement, right against bar fetters, right to pure
drinking water, right to reputation, etc.
Thus, to meet the new challenges in the society and to fulfil the dynamic needs
of the society the judicial system or the legislature will come up with new facets
of article 21.
Q.12 DISCUSS THE VARIOUS RIGHTS ENSHRINED IN AMERICAN CONVENTION
OF HUMAN RIGHTS.
ANS. The American Convention on Human Rights is an international human rights instrument
aimed at establishing a system of personal liberty and social justice based on respect for the
30. essential rights of man. The convention emphasizes on respecting the recognized rights and
freedoms guaranteed to all persons. It further provides that every individual must be given the
full freedom to exercise their rights and freedoms without any discrimination on the basis of
race, color, sex, language, religion, political or other opinion, national or social origin, economic
status, birth, or any other social condition. It generally lays down the standards on human rights
that must be observed in all the states of America.
The American Convention on Human Rights was adopted in the year 1969 at the meeting of the
states of America in San José, Costa Rica. It came into force in the year 1978. The Inter-
American Commission on Human Rights and the Inter-American Court of Human Rights are the
principal bodies that are responsible for the observance of the provisions laid down in the
convention. The American Convention on Human Rights is also known as the Pact of San José.
The was concluded at San Jose, Costa Rica on 22 Nov 1969 and entered into force in July 1978,
ratified by 25 member states. The United State signed the convention and President Jimmy
Carter referred it to Senate for advice and consent to ratification.
The two additional protocols Economic, Cultural, Social rights and other Abolition of Death
penalty have not as yet entered into force. The convention consists of dozens of civil and
political rights. These are right to life, right to personal liberty, rights to free trial, right to human
treatment, right to nationality, right to property, rights of children right to juridical personality,
freedom from slavery, freedom of religion, freedom of speech, thoughts, expression, conscience,
freedom of association, rights of family, freedom of movement and residence, freedom from ex
post facto laws, rights to privacy, right to name, right to compensation for miscarriage of justice,
right of reply, right of assembly, right to participate in government, right to equal protection of
law, right to judicial protection.
The state parties take progressive social, economic, educational measures for full realization of
rights and supplemented by board non-discrimination clauses.
The Convention provides for the establishment of Inter-American Commission of Human Rights
and Inter Court of human Rights and confers with competence respect to matter blasting to
fulfillment of the commitment made by state parties.
31. Implementation of procedure of American convention on Human rights by commission
appointed and elected by all OAS members. Article I of convention states. “The state parties to
the convention have an obligation not only to respect the ensure their three and full exercise.
They have both positive and negative duties that are they have the obligation not to violate the
rights which the convention guarantees and are required to adopt the measures may be necessary
and reasonable circumstances to ensure full enjoyment.
The extensive interpretation of obligation under Article 1 of convention. Article 27 of
Convention allows state parties to derogate from their obligations in time of war, danger,
emergency, security. The American Convention declares that judicial remedies essential for
protection of non-derivable rights may not suspended.
Article 28 of convention deal with federal clause which enable federal state to assume more
limited obligations by binding itself only in relation to matter over which it exercise legislative
and judicial jurisdiction. The function of commission is spelled out in the Article 41 of
convention.
The Inter-American Commission on Human rights and Inter- American Court of human rights
are main organs of Convention.
Inter-American Court of Human Rights
The Inter-American Court of Human Rights (the ‘Court’) is the judicial organ of the Inter-
American system for the protection of human rights. Based in San José, Costa Rica, it was
established by the American Convention on Human Rights in 1978. The Court is composed of
seven jurists who are elected by the General Assembly and serve 6-year terms, once renewable.
The Court meets five times per year, with one of these meetings taking place outside of Costa
Rica in order to increase awareness of its work.
The Inter-American Court of Human Rights serves two primary functions (Chapter VIII,
American Convention on Human Rights):
Adjudicatory function: the Court may issue judgments on cases referred to it by the Inter-
American Commission on Human Rights
32. Advisory function: the Court may issue advisory opinions on the application of human
rights treaties at the request of member states or bodies within the OAS.
Unlike the European Court of Human Rights, individual may not access the Court directly. All
individual complaints must first go through the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights,
which may then decide to refer the case to the Court.
Inter-American Commission on Human Rights
The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights (the “Commission”) was established in 1959
at the 5th Meeting of Consultation of Ministers of Foreign Affairs and is one of the primary
institutions that make up the Inter-American system for the protection of human rights. It is a
quasi-judicial body that now receives 1,500 individual complaints per year. Based in Washington
D.C. (USA) the Commission consists of seven independent human rights experts serving four-
year terms, once renewable. Each experts is nominated by his/her member state and elected by
the OAS General Assembly. These experts contribute to the general work of the Commission
and are individually designated as a Rapporteur on specific OAS states and thematic areas of
concern. Thematic rapporteurships include:
In 1976, the American Convention on Human Rights entered into force and the OAS Charter has
been amended to include the Commission as the primary human rights body of the OAS. The
work of the Commission is built on three main pillars:
Individual complaints
Monitoring human rights in member states
Focus on thematic areas on concern
The Commission has an Executive Secretariat of professional and administrative staff to help
Commissioners carry out their work, managing correspondence with petitioners and states and
preparing cases and petitions for Commissioners’ decisions.
The Inter-American Commission on Human Rights is responsible for (Article 41, American
Convention on Human Rights):
Developing an awareness of human rights among the peoples of America;
33. Making recommendations to the governments of the member states, when it considers
such action advisable, for the adoption of progressive measures in favour of human rights
within the framework of their domestic law and constitutional provisions as well as
appropriate measures to further the observance of those rights;
Preparing studies or reports as it considers advisable in the performance of its duties;
Requesting the governments of the member states to supply it with information on the
measures adopted by them in matters of human rights;
Responding, through the General Secretariat of the Organization of American States, to
inquiries made by the member states on matters related to human rights and, within the
limits of its possibilities, to provide those states with the advisory services they request;
Taking action on individual complaints and other communications
Submitting an annual report to the General Assembly.
Q.13 GIVE AN ACCOUNT OF JUDICIAL ACTIVISM IN INDIA WITH UPHOLDING
HUMAN RIGHTS.
ANS. INTRODUCTION
Judicial review means overseeing by the judiciary of the exercise of power by other co- ordinate
organs of government with a view to ensuring that they remain confined to the limits drawn upon
their powers by the Constitution. Britain extended the practice of judicial review of legislation to
colonies such as India whose constituent acts enacted by British Parliament laid down the limits
of the legislative power vested in the colonial legislatures. India therefore experienced judicial
review of legislations as well as executive acts since the days of British rule. Since there was no
bill of rights in the constituent acts, the scope of judicial review was limited. The courts in India
followed the policy of maximum judicial restraint. The judicial attitude in countries ruled by
Britain was to interfere with legislative acts only if they clearly transgressed the limits drawn
upon their powers. This attitude was influenced by the theory of parliamentary supremacy and
the courts denied that they had anything to do with policy or principles beyond what was clearly
laid down by the words. The judges in India were brought up in the British tradition of
parliamentary supremacy and therefore rarely questioned the validity of the legislative action
except on the ground of its being ultra vires.
34. The Indians demanded that their constitution should contain a declaration of fundamental rights
but that demand was not conceded by the British government till the passing of Government of
India Act, 1935. The traditional British distrust of such declarations was behind the rejection of
such a demand. On the other hand, the Indians saw in a bill of rights an assurance to the
minorities of their rights, and a safeguard against arbitrary rule. The Constitution of India of
1950 contained a bill of rights in Part III under the caption ‘Fundamental rights’ and declared
that any law that takes away or abridges any of the fundamental rights shall be void. However,
while vesting such power of judicial review in the High Courts and Supreme Court, maximum
care was taken to prevent the courts in India from being more than auditors of legality. The rights
were defined and restrictions upon them were also defined with precision so as to leave the least
discretion with the courts.
JUDICIAL ACTIVISM
Black’s Law Dictionary defined judicial activism as a “philosophy of judicial decision-making
whereby judges allow their personal views about public policy, among other factors, to guide
their decisions…” The flipside of judicial activism is Judicial Restraint, which is defined as “the
philosophy of judicial decision-making whereby judges base their decisions on the doctrine of
‘stare decisis’ (relying on precedents) to maintain the status quo.
Judicial activism can be positive as well as negative. A court engaged in altering the power
relations to make them more equitable is said to be positively activist and a court using its
ingenuity to maintain the status quo in power relations is said to be negatively activist.
Judicial review is an essential component of the rule of law, which is a basic feature
of the Indian Constitution. Every State action has to be tested on the anvil of rule of
law and that exercise is performed, when occasion arises by the reason of a doubt
raised in that behalf, by the courts. This well-established constitutional principle of
the existence of the power of judicial review and its need was indicated by Chief
Justice Marshall in Marbury v. Madison1 . He said: "It is emphatically the province and
duty of the judicial department to say what the law is." At that time, it appeared to
be an innovation or an act which is now being termed as "judicial activism".
35. However, no one since then has doubted the correctness of this constitutional
imperative in the scheme of separation of powers. Over a period of 47 years,
beginning from 1950 when the Constitution conferred on the High Courts, the power
to issue prerogative orders and writs, the judiciary in India has come to control by
judicial review every aspect of governmental and public functions. Every legislation is
amenable to judicial review, be it momentous amendments to the Constitution or
drawing up of schemes and bye-laws of municipal bodies which affect the life of a
citizen. Judicial review extends to every governmental or executive action - from high
policy matters like the President's power to issue a proclamation on failure of
constitutional machinery in the States like in Bommai case2 , to the highly
discretionary exercise of the prerogative of pardon like in Kehar Singh case3 or the
right to go abroad as in Satwant Singh case4 . Judicial review knows no bounds except
the restraint of the judges themselves regarding justiciability of an issue in a
particular case.
In Nilabati Behera v. State of Orissa5 the Supreme Court while considering the
question of grant of relief in a case of custodial death of the son of the petitioner
opined that the old doctrine of only relegating the aggrieved to the remedies
available in civil law limits the role of the courts too much as the "protector and
guarantor of the indefeasible human rights of the citizens" and went on to say that
the courts have an obligation to satisfy the social aspirations of the citizens because
the courts and the law are for the people and expected to respond to their
aspirations. The Court, therefore, in that case moulded the relief by granting
compensation by way of penalizing the wrongdoer and fixing the liability for the
public wrong on the State which failed in its public duty to protect human rights of
the citizen. It was stressed that a public body or officials should not act unlawfully
and should perform their public duties in accordance with law. This was done by the
36. Court in exercise of its public law jurisdiction. The Court explained the purpose of
public law and said "that the purpose of public law is not only to civilize public
power" but also to assure to the citizen that they live under a legal system which
aims to protect and preserve the rule of law. Thus, new "tools" were invented to give
redress to the citizen.
The Supreme Court has been consistently expanding the dimensions of Article 21 (Right to Life
and Personal Liberty) within the bounds of law by purposeful interpretations. More than fifteen
years ago in Francis Coralie Mullin v. Administrator, Union Territory of Delhi14 Justice
Bhagwati observed: (SCC pp. 618-19, para 8)
"The right to life includes the right to live with human dignity and all that goes along with it,
namely, the bare necessaries of life such as adequate nutrition, clothing and shelter and facilities
for reading, writing and expressing oneself in diverse forms, freely moving about and mixing and
commingling with fellow human beings. The magnitude and content of the components of this
right would depend upon the extent of the economic development of the country, but it must, in
any view of the matter, include the right to the basic necessities of life and also the right to carry
on such functions and activities as constitute the bare minimum expression of the human self.
Every act which offends against or impairs human dignity would constitute deprivation pro tanto
of this right to live and it would have to be in accordance with reasonable, fair and just procedure
established by law which stands the test of other fundamental rights."
In Bandhua Mukti Morcha case15 the Supreme Court reiterated once again that right to life
guaranteed by Article 21 included the right to live with human dignity, free from exploitation. In
Mohini Jain case16 the Court held the right to free education to the children until they complete
the age of 14 years also to be a fundamental right by taking note of Article 45 of the
Constitution. The concern of the courts for the underprivileged and the poor sections of the
society was reflected a decade ago in Bihar Legal Support Society v. Chief Justice of India17
when the Court said: (SCC p. 768, para 2)
"... that the weaker sections of Indian humanity have been deprived of justice for long, long
years: they have had no access to justice on account of their poverty, ignorance and illiteracy.
They are not aware of the rights and benefits conferred upon them by the Constitution and the
37. law. On account of their socially and economically disadvantaged position they lack the capacity
to assert their rights and they do not have the material resources with which to enforce their
social and economic entitlements and combat exploitation and injustice."
In M.H. Hoskot case18 , the Supreme Court recognised the right of an indigent person to have
legal aid.
The courts have been making judicial intervention in cases concerning violation of human rights
as an ongoing judicial process. Decisions on such matters as the right to protection against
solitary confinement as in Sunil Batra19 the right not to be held in fetters as in Sobraj case20
the right against handcuffing as in T. Vatheeswaran case21 the right against custodial violence
as in Nilabati Behera case5 or the rights of the arrestee as in D.K. Basu case22 or right of the
female employees not to be sexually harassed at the place of work as in the case of Vishaka v.
State of Rajasthan23 are just a few pointers in that directions. I need not multiply illustrations.
It would, therefore, be wrong to call it as an act of "judicial activism" when the judiciary in
discharge of its constitutional powers seeks to protect the human rights of the citizens in case
after case where a citizen has been deprived of his life or liberty otherwise than in accordance
with the procedure prescribed by law or when the courts insist upon "transparency and
accountability" in respect of the orders made or action taken by public servants. The requirement
that every State action must satisfy the test of fairness and non-arbitrariness are judicially
evolved principles which now form part of the constitutional law.
There is of late some criticism also of the judiciary in respect of its role in cases involving
environment. It is said that courts have started acting as "environmentalists" without "any
expertise" in that field and that the courts earlier on did not venture into this field.
The right to pollution-free environment has to be conceived of as a human right being a facet of
right to life guaranteed by Article 21. Let us not forget that while human rights are necessary to
promote the personality development of human beings, healthy environment is necessary to
safeguard conditions conducive to such a personality development. There is a natural link
between environment, development and human rights. It ought to be remembered that human
rights are based on mankind's increasing demand for a decent, civilised life in which the inherent
dignity of each human being must receive respect and protection. Human rights are fundamental
38. to human nature and therefore the relationship between environment and human rights becomes
much too obvious. In other words, human rights and environment are interdependent. As such it
can be legitimately argued that the right to an adequate environment is a human right because
human species cannot exist on this planet without proper environment. The Supreme Court has
ruled that right to pollution-free air falls under Article 21 in Subhash Kumar v. State of Bihar24 .
In the Doon Valley case, Article 21 was invoked by the Court to prevent the degradation of
Mussoorie Hills due to the mining operations there, which was becoming a health hazard. The
Court held that Article 21 included in its sweep a right to clean environment and that the
permanent assets of mankind cannot be allowed to be exhausted in our generation. Again, in
M.C. Mehta v. Union of India26 the Supreme Court reiterated the fundamental right to a clean
environment for healthy living and held that pollution treatment plant is a fore-condition of the
existence and continuation of an industry. It observed: (SCC p. 478, para 14)
"Just like an industry which cannot pay minimum wages to its workers, cannot be allowed to
exist, a tannery which cannot set up a primary treatment plant cannot be permitted to continue..."
as otherwise it would pose a threat to the health and well-being of the citizens residing in the
surrounding areas.
In the Oleum Gas Leak case27 the rule of strict liability was applied without exception to a
polluting undertaking employing hazardous process of manufacture. Bhagwati, C.J. observed in
this case:
"An enterprise engaged in hazardous or inherently dangerous industrial activity posing a
potential threat to the health and safety of persons working in the factory and residing in the
surrounding area was under an obligation to pay compensation for the injury caused."
Article 48-A of the Constitution provides:
"48-A. Protection and improvement of environment and safeguarding of forests and wild life.-
The State shall endeavour to protect and improve the environment and to safeguard the forests
and wild life of the country."
Indeed, this article is a part of the Directive Principles of the State Policy and not of the Chapter
on Fundamental Rights. But the Directive Principles of State Policy are complementary to the
39. fundamental rights guaranteed under the Constitution of India as they spell out the obligation of
the State towards the citizens in the discharge of its functions. Resort had by the judiciary to the
directive principles for interpreting the content of the fundamental rights is therefore logical. A
reference to Article 51-A(g) detailing the fundamental duties of the citizens, which reads, "to
protect and improve the natural environment including forests, lakes, rivers and wild life, and to
have compassion for living creatures", is also interesting in this context.
It also needs to be stated that the courts when they deal with cases concerning "environment" do
not by themselves act as experts. They rely upon expert bodies like National Environment
Engineering Research Institute (NEERI) which are requested by the courts to examine the
grievance relating to environmental pollution and submit their report. The courts also call upon
the Pollution Control Boards of the Union or the State, as the case may be, to submit their reports
and then base their judgments on expert opinion. The argument that courts were hithertofore not
entering into this domain, does not mean that courts should not act when called upon by the
citizens to protect the environment so as to make it possible for the citizens to enjoy the right of
healthy and decent life guaranteed by Article 21 of the Constitution. The argument that since it
has not been done before therefore it should not be done now is illogical. If courts do not
interpret the law in a manner consistent with the mandate of Article 21, only because it had not
been done before, then while the society would move, the law would remain static and that
would be bad both for law and the society. Law must move with the society so as to respond to
its hopes and aspirations.
It must, however, be remembered that the Judges in exercise of their power of judicial review,
are not expected to decide a dispute or controversy which is purely theoretical or for which there
are no judicially manageable standards available with them. The courts do not generally speaking
interfere with the policy matters of the executive unless the policy is either against the
Constitution or some statute or is actuated by mala fides. Policy matters, fiscal or otherwise, are
thus best left to the judgment of the executive. However, once it is conceded that right to life
guaranteed by Article 21 includes the right to live decently, the interference by the courts to
ensure the same by making attempts to prevent pollution of environment cannot but be
considered as a legitimate exercise in discharge of the constitutional obligation by the judiciary.
40. Having talked about human rights and the constitutional obligations of the courts to protect the
same, there is one important aspect which needs to be dealt with by me and that is the need of
"self-restraint" by the Judges while expanding and expounding the law in response to the call and
need of the society in exercise of their power of judicial review.
It is in fact stating the obvious to say that courts must while exercising the power of judicial
review exercise restraint and base their decisions on the recognised doctrines or principles of
law. Judicial activism and judicial restraint are two sides of the same coin. It is therefore
essential to remember that judicial restraint in the exercise of its functions is of equal importance
for the judiciary while discharging its judicial obligations under the Constitution. With a view to
see that judicial activism does not become "judicial adventurism" and lead a Judge going in
pursuits of his own notions of justice and beauty, ignoring the limits of law, the bounds of his
jurisdiction and the binding precedents, it is necessary and essential that "public interest
litigation" which is taken recourse to for reaching justice to those who are for variety of reasons
unable to approach the court to protect their fundamental rights should develop on a consistent
and firm path. The courts must be careful to see that by their overzealousness they do not cause
any uncertainty or confusion either through their observations during the hearing of a case or
through their written verdicts. If unmindful of the expected restraint, the courts make
observations orally or through written decisions, one way or the other, under the cover of judicial
activism, they may consciously or unconsciously cause uncertainty and confusion in the law. In
that event, the law will not only develop along uncertain lines instead of straight and consistent
path but the judiciary's image may also in the bargain get tarnished and its respectability eroded.
That would be a sad day. Judicial authoritarianism cannot be permitted under any circumstances.
The courts, therefore, have to be very careful to see that their exercise of judicial creativity for
attaining social change is not allowed to run amuck and every court functions within the bounds
of its own prescribed jurisdiction. The courts have the duty of implementing the constitutional
safeguards that protect individual rights but they cannot push back the limits of the Constitution
to accommodate the challenged violation. All it means is that Judges are expected to be
circumspect and self-disciplined in the discharge of their judicial functions.
The virtue of humility in the Judges, a constant awareness that the investment of power in them
is meant for use in public interest and to uphold the majesty of rule of law and the realisation that
41. Judges are not infallible even if final, would ensure the requisite self-restraint in discharge of all
judicial functions because all actions of a Judge must be judicious in character. As Justice
Michael Kirby of the High Court of Australia rightly said, not too long ago, while addressing
Bangalore Advocates Association on 13-1-1997, "of Judges, the community expects honesty,
integrity and learning".
Olga Tellis v. Bombay Municipal Corporation, the Court admitted at the abstract level that
everyone had the right to shelter as part of his right to live. But the court was faced with persons
who were living on footpaths and they had to be removed in order to clear footpaths for
pedestrians. Therefore, the court said that the Bombay Municipal Corporation could evict them
by issuing a notice and following the procedure laid down under the Bombay Municipal
Corporation Act. So the right to shelter, as a fundamental right, turned out to be a platitude when
it could be dispensed with by the corporation after following proper procedure.
Mohini Jain v Karnataka[33]: In this case, the Supreme Court held that the right to education was
included within right to life. The court realizing the impracticability of such a proposition, tried
to narrow down the dictum in Unni Krishnan v. A.P.[34], where it said that the right to live
included the right to primary education. Here again, we find that the court has verged on
populism. The Constitution in one of the directive principles of state policy specifically enjoins
on the state to provide within a period of ten years free and compulsory primary education for all
children below the age of fourteen years[35]. It is not for the Court to convert a directive
principle of State policy into a fundamental right. Where the literacy rate has been around fifty
percent, to say that all Indian people have a fundamental right to primary education is an exercise
of romanticism. These are second generation human rights, which consist of social and economic
rights of a positive nature and have to be backed up by political action. The rights such as right to
education or right to livelihood can be a reality only when the state allocates resources for
providing education or jobs to people. This will depend on the economic policies the State
pursues.
Justice P.B. Sawant speaking in Delhi Development Horticulture Employees’ Union v. Delhi
Administration[36] observed: “This country has so far not found it feasible to incorporate the
right to livelihood as a fundamental right in the Constitution. This is because the country has so
far not attained the capacity to guarantee it and not because it considers it any the less
42. fundamental to life. Advisedly, therefore, it has been placed in the chapter on Directive
Principles”.
Right to electricity is right to life: In K. Aacharya v C.M.D.W.B.S.E. Distribution Co. Ltd.[37],
the Court held that the right to electricity is right to life and liberty in terms of art.21 of the
Constitution. In modern days no one can survive without electricity. This is another example of
judicial populism. How can the Court provide electricity to people? Providing electricity depends
on the policies and measures taken by the State. It depends on the state policies and development
in the area where such demand arises.
Right to Sleep: In Ram Lila Maidan Case[38], Justice B.S. Chauhan in his opinion wrote that
when police disturbed the crowd in night at 1:00 AM their right to sleep was violated. He holds
that right to sleep forms an essential part of Article 21 which guarantees personal liberty and life
to all. It was observed: “Sleep is essential for a human being to maintain the delicate balance of
health necessary for its very existence and survival. Sleep is, therefore, a fundamental and basic
requirement without which the existence of life itself would be in peril.” Undoubtedly, sleep is
absolutely necessary; it is an essential requirement. But granting it the status of a right at par with
right to food is stretching the concept of right to a preposterous level. Such a judgment can lead
to Diwali revelers being jailed for infringing upon the right to sleep when they burst firecrackers
closer to the midnight hour. It will have factory workers on night shift manufacture excuses like
lack of sleep as reason for inefficient performance. As a society, we shall begin to discourage
most nocturnal activities because those might interfere with our sleeping habit.
CONCLUSION
Judicial activism is not an aberration. It is an essential aspect of the dynamics of a constitutional
court. It is a counter-majoritarian check on democracy. Judicial activism, however, does not
mean governance by the judiciary. It also must function within the limits of the judicial process.
Within those limits, it performs the function of legitimizing or, more rarely, stigmatizing the
actions of the other organs of government. The judiciary is the weakest organ of the State. It
becomes strong only when people repose faith in it. Such faith of the people constitutes the
legitimacy of the Court and of judicial activism. Courts have to continuously strive to sustain
their legitimacy. They do not have to bow to public pressure, rather they have to stand firm
against any pressure.
43. While it is imperative to exercise justifiable restraint and caution to ensure that judicial activism
does not become judicial adventurism or tyranny, this power should be exercised only in
exceptional circumstances and that too, only in public interest. Truly, judicial activism “is the
oxygen of the rule of law”. The constitutional revolution, which was the vision of the Founding
Fathers, was entrusted to the judiciary, giving it powers to enforce, through “writ power”, the
socio economic liberation implicit in the fundamental rights and other avant-garde provisions of
the Indian Constitution- the oasis of our democracy. “It is the courts, which have stood the test of
time and served the cause of social-economic justice only to preserve the fundamental rights and
duties of the citizen. When the executive violates these rights, the court cannot abdicate its
responsibility or jurisdiction, oath bound as it is, to uphold the Constitution.”
Q.14 EXPLAIN THE VARIOUS MODES FOR THE IMPLEMENTATION OF HUMAN
RIGHTS UNDER COVENANT ON ECONOMIC AND SOCIAL AND CULTURAL
RIGHTS.
ANS. INTRODUCTION
Economic, social, and cultural rights are the freedoms, privileges, and entitlements that
individuals and communities require to live a life of dignity. These human rights include the
rights to food, housing, health, education, cultural identity, and more. Although some economic,
social, and cultural rights cannot be immediately implemented, States that have ratified the
relevant treaties nonetheless have the obligation to guarantee these rights.
Specifically, States have an obligation to respect, protect, and fulfill economic, social, and
cultural rights. The obligation to respect means States cannot interfere with enjoyment of the
right. The obligation to protect requires the State to reasonably prevent other actors from
interfering with enjoyment of the right. The obligation to fulfill mandates that the State actively
take steps to create the conditions necessary for individuals’ full enjoyment of the right.
Legal Protections
The extent to which individuals can claim legal protection of their economic, social, and cultural
rights (ESCR) depends on which treaties have been ratified by their governments, given that the
protections for ESCR vary significantly among the universal and regional human rights
instruments. However, the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights
44. (ICESCR) is the most comprehensive international treaty addressing this area of human rights
law, and is also the most widely-applicable. As of May 2018, 168 of the 193 United Nations
Member States have ratified the ICESCR, implementation of which is monitored by the UN
Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR).
International human rights law recognizes that the “full realization of all economic, social and
cultural rights will generally not be able to be achieved in a short period of time.”
States parties to the ICESCR have the obligation “to take steps, individually and through
international assistance and co-operation,” to the “maximum of available resources, with a view
to achieving progressively the full realization of the rights recognized.”
States must initiate such steps within a reasonably short time. In the understanding of the
CESCR, these steps should be “deliberate, concrete, and targeted as clearly as possible” toward
meeting the obligations. See id. States should use legislative measures to progressively realize
the rights; however, doing so will not automatically fulfill the obligations under the ICESCR if
other “appropriate” measures are still available. Those may include judicial, administrative,
financial, educational, and social measures.
Immediate Implementation
While many ESC rights are subject to progressive realization, the UN Committee on Economic,
Social and Cultural Rights (CESCR) has identified certain rights and obligations that the State
should immediately implement, including:
undertaking to ensure the equal right of men and women in their enjoyment of economic,
social, and cultural rights (art. 3);
providing all workers with fair wages and equal remuneration for work of equal value
without any distinction, particularly guaranteeing that women’s conditions of work are
not inferior to men’s work conditions (art. 7(a)(1));
ensuring the right to form and join trade unions, and to go on strike (art. 8);
protecting children from economic and social exploitation, including enacting legislation
that provides a minimum age for employment and punishes dangerous working
conditions for children (art. 10(3));
providing free and compulsory primary education (art. 13(2)(a));