SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 160
Download to read offline
Performance in Stagflation
                 Lehman Brothers | Title




                             PLEASE SEE ANALYST CERTIFICATION AND IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES, INCLUDING FOREIGN AFFILIATE DISCLOSURES, ON PAGES 157–158




                                               Falling Growth and Rising
                                                         Inflation in Asia
                             The relentless demand for resources is creating a need for large-scale investment
                                                                   in agriculture, water, and alternative energy
                                              Investors confront the reality of rising inflation and slowing growth



                                                                                                                  Regional Research Team

                                                                                                                                           May 2008


                               Lehman Brothers does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports. As a result, investors
                                    should be aware that the firm may have a conflict of interest that could affect the objectivity of this report.

                                          Investors should consider this report as only a single factor in making their investment decision.

                                Customers of Lehman Brothers in the United States can receive independent, third-party research on the company or
                                companies covered in this presentation, at no cost to them, where such research is available. Customers can access
                                 this independent research at www.lehmanlive.com or can call 1-800-2-LEHMAN to request a copy of this research.

                                 This research report has been prepared in whole or in part by research analysts who are not registered/qualified as
                                                                          research analysts with FINRA.
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research


EXECUTIVE SUMMARY

Describing Asian stagflation
Our definition of stagflation in an Asian context can be described as significantly slowing growth and rising inflation. We
have both of these in every single country in Asia, without exception. These stagflationary forces produce: (1) capital
shortages, (2) rising costs, (3) diminishing aggregate demand, (4) margin squeeze and (5) rising taxes. In this environment,
the characteristics of the likely winners, in our view, include (1) low debt, (2) pricing power, (3) captive buyers, (4) control
of input prices, (5) makers of consumer staples and (6) “sin” stocks.

Winners and losers
The countries which are implementing significant price control and/or large subsidy program risk economic destabilization.
These countries include India, China, the Philippines and Indonesia. Countries which allow market forces to determine prices
– and therefore which allow supply and demand to recalibrate effectively and quickly – are the likely winners. These include
Hong Kong, Singapore, Thailand and Taiwan. Countries which should also benefit are those which have large agricultural
sectors. Malaysia wins on this score. Korea stands as an outlier in that it is highly dependent on hard and soft commodities,
is heavily indebted, produces large-scale capital goods and is vulnerable to an economic slowdown in the West.

Sector winners and losers
Sectors which stand to benefit in a world of stagflation are iron ore, plantations, coal, telecom, properties and selected
utilities. Other consumer sectors include tobacco, alcohol, gambling and health care. Sectors which are likely to be affected
poorly by stagflation are lower margin, high-debt businesses, such as container shipping, shipbuilding, low margin
technology businesses, autos, high-end and discretionary consumer goods, basic materials, price-controlled oil & gas, and
selected construction materials.

Currencies
We also highlight countries with large current account surpluses and large budget surpluses which can withstand the
economic pressures from falling growth and rising prices. These include CNY, MYR, SGD and TWD. Countries with
troublesome current account deficits and budget deficits are threatened by excessive subsidies. These include Indonesia,
India and the Philippines.

Stagflation Portfolio
The following portfolio shows stocks which we believe will be winners under a stagflationary environment.
                                                                                                                       EV/
                                                                                 3 Mth Ave
                                                                                                                               P/E     P/B    Div Yield
                                                                                                                     EBITDA
                                                      Lehman Current   Mkt Cap      Liquidity ROE Net Debt/ Altman
Company                  Ticker                        Rating  Price   US$mn       (US$mn) FY08E Assets Z-Score      FY08E    FY08E   FY08E    FY08E
                                      Industry Sector

Cheung Kong Infra        1038 HK      Utilities         1-OW    31.8     9,248         9.0   13      -2%     5.3      55.6    13.9     1.8       3.8
Hong Kong Electric       6 HK         Utilities         1-OW    45.2    12,724        27.5   15       2%     3.5       9.4    12.8     1.9       4.4
China Mobile             941 HK       Telecom           1-OW   132.5   379,182       477.7   28     -27%    10.1      10.8    20.6     5.4       2.1
Sun Hung Kai             16 HK        Property          1-OW   138.0    45,174       178.8   6       10%     NA       27.0    26.3     1.7       1.8
CNOOC                    883 HK       Oil & Gas E&P     2-EW    13.9    94,145       237.9   28     -16%    10.1       9.7    14.3     3.7       2.6
Shenhua                  1088 HK      Energy            1-OW    35.0    14,379       153.4   20       3%     1.9       2.0    20.4     4.0       1.7
Rio Tinto                RIO AU       Mining            0-NR   145.3    64,535       197.2   40      44%     1.4       4.8    15.7     4.9       1.2
IOI                      IOI MK       Palm Oil          0-NR     7.1    13,801        31.3   26       7%     7.5      14.7    21.6     5.0       2.4
EGCO                     EGCO TB      Utilities         2-EW    95.5     1,547         1.8   18       8%     3.4       8.8     6.4     1.1       5.7
HK and Shanghai Hotels   45 HK        Hotels            1-OW    13.5     2,544         1.8   5        5%     2.9      12.0    20.1     0.9       1.5
Ranbaxy                  RBXY IS      Pharmaceuticals   1-OW   466.3     4,355         4.6   24      44%     3.2      18.0    24.7     5.7       2.0
KT&G                     033780 KS Consumer             1-OW 82500.0    11,019        31.2   23      -3%    11.3      10.7    14.8     3.3       NA
Melco                    200 HK Equit Conglomerates     0-NR    11.6     1,891         7.5   4       11%     5.6      82.7    43.5     1.4       0.1
Average                                                                 50,350       104.6   27       6%     8.6      11.9    19.3     4.6       2.1

Source: BES, Worldscope, Lehman Brothers estimates
Prices as of May 7, 2008




Paul Schulte and regional team
Lehman Brothers Asia Limited



May 2008                                                                                                                                               3
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research


COUNTRY SUMMARY

 Country        Lehman Brothers Comments                                                                   In a stagflation scenario
                                                                                                     Top Gainers         Top Losers
 Australia      Australian institutional processes and flexible, yet aggressive, policy settings     Telstra             Bluescope Steel
 (David         are likely to soften inflationary impacts, in our view. The demand side of the
                                                                                                     PrimeAg             Fairfax Media
 Langford)      stagflation equation may prove to be the toughest issue for Australian policy
                makers. As a result, we believe that more attractive investment exposures
                are likely to be provided by those companies which enjoy: (i) limited
                exposure to input cost inflation (e.g., materials and labor); and (ii) product
                sets with a high degree of substitutability for higher priced products in a cost-
                conscious environment.


 China          China is trying to deal with rising inflation by appreciating the currency and       COSL                Guangzhou
 (Cheng Khoo)   keeping rates high. We believe growth is likely to slow down somewhat in                                 R&F
                                                                                                     China Shenhua
                2008 and again in 2009. Inflation risks are to the upside.
                                                                                                                         Minsheng Bank

 Hong Kong      We expect Hong Kong’s internal consumption to slow, unemployment to rise,            HK Electric         Giordano
 (Ivan Lee)     and input cost (in terms of energy, labor, rental, etc.) to rise quickly. This is    Hutchison           Shangri-la Hotel
                not positive, especially for the consumer, hotel, manufacturing, gaming,
                                                                                                     Whampoa
                financial, and export sectors, mainly due to Hong Kong’s fairly open
                economy, close linkage with China’s economy, and because its currency is
                pegged to the US dollar. However, housing prices will likely continue to
                benefit from a negative interest rate environment, in our view. Also, we
                expect regulated utilities, whose earnings are tied to capex instead of tariff
                and fuel cost, and conglomerates with diversified earnings streams to have
                earnings resilient performance.


 India          We do not believe that India will be hit significantly by stagflation and we         Ranbaxy             Larsen and
 (Prabhat       think growth will remain strong in relative terms. In our view, the negative                             Toubro
                                                                                                     Hindustan Lever
 Awasthi)       impact will be felt by interest rate-sensitive stocks or by companies not in a                           Tata Motors
                position to pass on cost pressures to consumers.


 Korea          In Korea, we expect defensive industries such as telco and tobacco to be the         KT                  Hanjin Shipping
 (Zayong Koo)   least affected while other consumer related and export related industries            KT&G                LG Display
                would be adversely affected. However, we believe Samsung Electronics
                although the industry in which it operates is likely to be hurt by stagflation,
                the company is nevertheless well positioned globally to actually benefit from
                the downturn.


 Taiwan         We believe Taiwan’s export-oriented economy is likely to underperform                TSMC                AUO
 (Kent Chan)    compared with its Asian peers owing to its high dependence on technology,
                                                                                                     Taiwan Cement       Nanya Tech
                excessive competition, and its dependence on imported oil. The domestic
                economy (property, telecoms, and insurance) and asset reflation stocks
                would continue to rise, potentially like they did after the inflation shock in the
                1970s, in our view.




May 2008                                                                                                                                    4
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research


SECTOR SUMMARY

 Sector           Comments                                                                      Top Gainers     Top Losers

 Auto             The auto sector could be a likely loser since auto demand is tied to          Denway          Hyundai Motor
 (Zayong Koo)     economic conditions and the level of disposal income that consumers
                  enjoy. In a slower growth environment and with higher inflation, non-
                  essential high-cost items such as cars could face some pressure.
 Banks            Banks are mirrors of the underlying economy. We believe none of the           Nil             Huaxia Bank
 (Lucy Feng)      Chinese banks could survive well in a severe economic downturn.
                  Furthermore, players with weak fundamentals, poor risk management,
                  and less prudent lending procedures will suffer more.
 Conglomerates    Because of their business diversification, the earnings of                    Hutchison       Shanghai Industrial
 (Benjamin Lo)    conglomerates have a higher degree of defensiveness than many                 Whampoa
                  other single-industry-focused companies. All conglomerates are also
                  cash-rich and some are industry leaders in their core businesses. We,
                  therefore, maintain an overall positive stance on conglomerates under
                  a stagflation scenario.
 Consumer         China retail softlines and department stores/broadlines are more              Parkson         People’s Food
 (Phoebe Wong,    resilient in the current high inflationary cycle, while F&B might not fare    KT&G            Lotte Shopping
 Hong Taik        as well because of their high exposure to soft commodities and thin
 Chung)           margins, in our view.
                  In the Korean retail space, we favor discount stores to department
                  stores. Among Korean consumer staple names, we expect top-tier
                  players that can prove strong market leadership and experience
                  steady consumer demand to generate stable earnings.
 Info Tech        Most IT manufacturers are likely to employ a low pricing policy to spur       Samsung         Hon Hai
 (James Kim)      demand and sustain fab utilization rates. However, we believe that a          Electronics
                  rapid rise in material costs and labor expenses will make it very difficult
                  for IT companies to post meaningful profits. With the exception of a
                  few segments, we believe there will be few winners among IT
                  manufacturers when faced withising inflation and slowing growth.
 Media/Internet   The media/Internet sector in Asia-Pacific will weather the stagflation        Focus Media     Fairfax Media
 (Paul Wuh)       storm better than many other industrial sectors. We focus on media
                  companies that: (1) have a subscription model that is unlikely to face
                  lost revenues in an economic downturn and can raise prices if needed
                  to counter inflation (such as, cable TV and satellite TV companies); (2)
                  have relatively low operating costs and are able to easily scale their
                  businesses to meet changing business environments (such as Internet
                  gaming and e-commerce); (3) are relatively low cost to advertisers and
                  are success-based (such as Internet portal/search companies).
 Metal and        We believe inflation-driven upstream sectors (i.e., coal) should remain       China Shenhua   Chalco
 Mining (Oliver   the winners given their strong pricing power, while downstream sectors
 Du)              with relatively weak pricing power, such as aluminum and copper
                  smelters, would be the losers.
 Oil & Gas        We expect the physical oil demand to decline. In the near term, we            Sinopec         Honam
 (Cheng Khoo)     expect the tight supply situation to continue, which could further boost
                  oil prices. However, by the end of 2008 and especially in 2009, as new
                  capacities come into the market, we believe oil prices are likely to
                  decline.
 Property (Paul   Housing and low-end retail, we believe, should prove the most resilient       SHKP            HK Land
 Louie, Min       as they cover basic needs; office and high end-retail are likely to fare
 Chow Sai)        the worst. At the country level, performance should be tied to existing
                  supply levels. Hong Kong with the lowest expected housing supply for
                  the next four years should prove the most defensive, in our view.
 Telecom          In our opinion, the telecom services sector will do much better than          Chunghwa        Bharti
 (Paul Wuh)       other industries in a period of stagflation. However, revenue growth for      Telecom
                  telecom operators in developing markets like China, India, and SE
                  Asia will be affected more than those in developed markets.
 Transportation   We believe the shipping sector would be a likely loser since demand is        Nil             Evergreen
 (Andrew Lee)     driven by global economies and shipping lines bear higher costs
                  because carriers struggle to pass on higher costs to customers.
                  Further, given that shipping is a highly fragmented industry, carriers
                  are mainly price takers.
 Utilities and    In a stagflation environment, defensive and regulated utilities that are      HK Electric     KEPCO
 Renewable        cash rich, have strong cash flow, and have fixed returns tied to a
 Energy (Ivan     regulated asset base tend to outperform, in our view.
 Lee)




May 2008                                                                                                                              5
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research


                                Table of Contents
                                Executive Summary                                                                                                                  3

                                Country Summary                                                                                                                    4

                                Sector Summary                                                                                                                     5

                                Regional Strategy                                                                                                                  9

                                Effects on equities from rising inflation and slower growth.................................................9

                                Country Analysis                                                                                                                 15

                                Australia’s Brief Stagflation                                                                                                    16

                                Tight policies limit local stagflation risk ............................................................................16

                                China Stagflation Scenario                                                                                                       20

                                Can the government tame rising inflation and rescue slowing growth? .....................................20

                                HK Stagflation Scenario                                                                                                          31

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................31

                                India and Stagflation                                                                                                            36

                                Tight policies limit local stagflation risk ............................................................................36

                                Korea Stagflation Scenario                                                                                                       39

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................39

                                Taiwan Stagflation Scenario                                                                                                      45

                                Can politics offset rising inflation and slower growth? ............................................................45

                                Sector Analysis                                                                                                                  53

                                Auto and Auto Parts                                                                                                              54

                                Effects of rising inflation and falling growth .....................................................................54

                                Banks                                                                                                                            57

                                China Banks .......................................................................................................................57
                                India Banks.........................................................................................................................59
                                Taiwan Banks .....................................................................................................................61

                                Cement                                                                                                                           62

                                India Cement ......................................................................................................................62

                                Conglomerates                                                                                                                    64

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................64

                                Consumer                                                                                                                         67

                                India Consumer ..................................................................................................................67
                                China/Hong Kong Consumer .............................................................................................69
                                Korean Consumer...............................................................................................................71


May 2008                                                                                                                                                          6
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research

                                Electrical Equipment                                                                                                           73

                                India Electrical Equipment .................................................................................................73

                                IT Industry                                                                                                                    75

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................75

                                Metal & Mining (China)                                                                                                         78

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................78

                                Materials (Taiwan)                                                                                                             80

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................80

                                Media/Internet                                                                                                                  81

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................81

                                Oil and Gas                                                                                                                    84

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................84

                                Oil Refining                                                                                                                   87

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................87

                                Petrochemicals                                                                                                                  89

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................89

                                Pharmaceuticals                                                                                                                91

                                India Pharmaceuticals.........................................................................................................91

                                Property                                                                                                                       92

                                Reverting to basic needs for shelter....................................................................................92
                                India Real Estate.................................................................................................................98
                                Taiwan Property ...............................................................................................................100

                                Semiconductors – Foundry & SATS                                                                                              101

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................101

                                Semiconductors – Memory                                                                                                      102

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................102

                                Technology – Hardware                                                                                                        104

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................104

                                Technology – Display                                                                                                         105

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................105

                                Technology – IC Design                                                                                                       107

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................107

                                Telecommunications Services                                                                                                  108

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................108




May 2008                                                                                                                                                        7
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research


                                Transportation – Shipping                                                                                     112

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................112

                                Utilities/Power/Renewable Energy                                                                              117

                                Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................117

                                Valuation Methodologies                                                                                       123

                                Asia Research Roster                                                                                          138

                                Coverage Universe                                                                                             140

                                Companies under Coverage in Asia, by Country (as of May 14, 2008) ...........................140
                                Companies under Coverage in Asia, by Sector (as of May 14, 2008)..............................148




May 2008                                                                                                                                         8
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research


REGIONAL STRATEGY

                                    Effects on equities from rising inflation and slower
                  Paul Schulte
                                    growth
            LBAL, Hong Kong
          Tel: (852) 2252 -1409
     paul.schulte@lehman.com
                                    INTRODUCTION: LOWER GROWTH AND HIGHER INFLATION
                    Justin Lau      The world is slowly moving away from a systemic meltdown and toward some
             LBAL, Hong Kong        normalcy. Much of this has been accomplished through the intermediation of central
           Tel: +852 2252 1420      banks. The introduction of a facility on March 20 to lend directly to investment banks for
        justin.lau@lehman.com       the first time in the history of the Federal Reserve helped greatly in calming markets.
                                    These moves by the Fed – and more recently by the Bank of England – have been made
            Chris Leung, CFA        in conjunction with a sharp reduction in interest rates. There have been three
            LBAL, Hong Kong         consequences of this activity.
          Tel: +852 2252 6183
                                    1.   Rising liquidity
   chris.w.leung@lehman.com
                                    There has been a sharp and sudden increase in risk appetite and a sharp rise in liquidity.
                                    As risky or worthless assets are taken out of the market by central bank intervention,
           Shubhankar Das
                                    those assets most at risk often go up the most. So, values of risky assets may go up in
         LBAL, Hong Kong
                                    price. Government bonds would go down in price as investors sell risk-free government
        Tel: +852 2252 1424
                                    bonds and dive back into risky bonds.
shubhankar.das@lehman.com
                                    2.   Lower growth
                                    The above scenario should be great for growth. It makes growth go down less. But the
                                    problem is that much of this liquidity being created is not finding its way back to asset
                                    creation. It is being bottled up on the balance sheet of banks which are themselves
                                    dealing with bad asset liquidation and capital constraints. They are being forced to shed
                                    assets from their balance sheet and write off losses against capital. They are being forced
                                    to find alternative sources of liabilities (deposits). This is because banks must bring
                                    down excessively high loan/deposit ratios at the same time that they are writing off bad
                                    assets. So, the asset base must shrink even while liquidity is replenishing the system.
                                    We present below the base case set forth by our economics team together with the worst
                                    case scenario provided by the strategy team.

Figure 1:      Slower growth/rising inflation – base case and worst case scenarios
                                 GDP (% y-o-y)                                            CPI (%y-o-y)
                        Base Case        Worst Case Scenario                    Base Case          Worst Case Scenario
                  Lehman Economics Team Lehman Stategy Team               Lehman Economics Team Lehman Stategy Team
                        2008        2009      2008      2009                     2008        2009      2008       2009
US                        1.2        0.6       -0.9      -0.4                      na          na         na         na

Australia                     2.5        2.0       1.1          0.9                 3.1           2.2          3.1         3.2
China                         9.8        8.0       6.1          5.9                 5.5           2.8          6.7         6.9
Hong Kong                     4.3        6.2       0.3          0.2                 5.0           5.5          5.0         5.5
India                         7.5        8.5       5.1          4.6                 6.9           4.7          6.9         7.1
Indonesia                     5.2        7.0       2.7          2.3                10.0           8.0          9.0         9.5
Malaysia                      5.0        6.2       2.4          2.2                 3.5           4.5          3.9         4.5
Philippines                   5.0        7.0       2.6          2.4                 7.8           5.5          8.5         8.9
Singapore                     4.2        7.0       2.4          2.1                 6.0           4.8          6.0         6.1
South Korea                   4.1        5.2       2.1          2.0                 4.5           3.5          4.1         4.3
Taiwan                        3.9        5.7       2.9          2.6                 3.8           3.5          3.8         3.9
Thailand                      4.2        6.7       2.6          2.5                 6.5           4.5          6.0         6.2
Asia ex-Japan                 7.3        7.3       4.1          3.8                 5.7           3.8          5.7         5.9
Source Lehman Brothers research


May 2008                                                                                                                      9
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research

                                3.      Higher inflation
                                All this liquidity is not creating more assets. It is supporting the shrinking of assets in an
                                attempt to keep a balance sheet cleansing event from turning into a depression. The cost
                                we are paying for this dynamic is excessive liquidity with low growth. Inflation’s classic
                                definition is too much money chasing too few assets. This is as classic an inflationary
                                phenomenon as it gets. So, liquidity, like lava bursting from a volcano, will roll down the
                                mountain, seeking a path of least resistance to those areas where it is needed most: in the
                                shortages. The greatest shortage of liquidity in the world is in agriculture. The food
                                inflation problem has been brewing since 2004, but was rising right in the midst of the
                                credit crisis. So, this liquidity is creating inflation in an area which had chronic shortages
                                already. This food inflation has spread quickly and has created generally high inflation
                                all over Asia. Oil is part of this as well. Oil shortages are receiving the liquidity as well.
                                We think these price rises are a symptom of inflation, not the other way around.

                                EFFECT ON EBIT: SHRINKING MARGINS?
                                With rising costs in food and energy, the CPIs of many Asian countries are rising
                                quickly. This is because the CPI has a very large proportion of food and energy in the
                                baskets relative to the West. In many cases, it is 30-50%. So, price changes are
                                accelerating quickly. In addition, many governments are responding to sharp increases in
                                food, fertilizers, and oil with price caps and/or subsidies. We believe these policy
                                responses are unhelpful and lead to more inflation. This is because price caps, for
                                instance, lead consumers to consume more, given the perception that prices are unusually
                                low. This also leads to a cutback in production given the perception that producers are
                                not being given a fair price for the goods they sell. So, everyone loses. There are three
                                effects on margins. In the meantime, high fertilizer costs spill into higher food prices.
                                Higher oil spills into high coal prices. The chain reaction goes on.
                                1.      Rising cost of labor
                                As food and energy prices increase, the employees at corporates demand higher wages
                                given that lifestyle costs are rising sharply. So, SG&A expenses rise. We are seeing this
                                all across Asia, as wage growth begins to rise in earnest. Wage rises are a response to
                                rising prices. In many parts of Asia, inflation is rising to multi-decade highs.

                                Figure 2:       Asia CPI

                                    % y-o-y
                                                                                     Headline CPI
                                    8
                                                                                     Core CPI

                                    6


                                    4



                                    2



                                    0
                                    Jan-96       Jan-98        Jan-00   Jan-02       Jan-04       Jan-06       Jan-08
                                Source: Lehman Brothers research




May 2008                                                                                                                   10
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research

                                2.       Rising cost of goods
                                The costs associated with production given rising energy costs are felt throughout the
                                industrial food chain. Cost of energy also goes up dramatically. So, input costs rise.
                                Growth, while falling, is still high in many parts of Asia. As a result, an increasing
                                number of companies have expressed confidence for the first time in many years to pass
                                through price increases to end users. Steel producers are passing prices through to buyers
                                of steel. This is best seen in the rise of the Producer Price Index.

                                Figure 3:        Japan’s domestic corporate goods prices

                                     % y-o-y
                                     5
                                     4
                                     3
                                     2
                                     1
                                     0
                                    -1
                                    -2
                                    -3
                                    -4
                                     Jan-90           Jan-94             Jan-98     Jan-02          Jan-06

                                Source: CEIC, Lehman Brothers research


                                3.       Rising cost of money
                                In the midst of a waning credit crisis, the sharp rise in liquidity is not reaching into the
                                cost of money. The cost of money has actually risen. This is because banks are trying to
                                recapitalize and at the same time shed bad assets. Concentrating on lending is the last
                                thing on their minds. So, while the cost of money is now down to 2% in the US, for
                                instance, the cost of a loan has barely budged. This also reaches into the world of
                                working capital. Working capital is also more expensive although rates are now a lot
                                lower. So, financing costs are higher and new money is harder to come by.
                                There will, of course, be exceptions. For example, we think price makers (monopolies,
                                plantations, oil producers) will make a windfall here. The middle man loses. Lower-end
                                retail wins. Banks which are healthy win big. Unhealthy banks lose altitude and are in
                                danger of crashing. Those banks which try to pick up cheap assets too early can get
                                dragged down.

                                EFFECT ON CASH FLOW: EFFECT ON CAPEX GIVEN FALLING CASH FLOWS
                                AND CAPITAL SHORTAGE?
                                In an environment of restrained lending, rising costs, and increasing wages, corporates
                                may face three hurdles.
                                1.       Working capital is working harder and may turn negative
                                Inflation drives up the cost of doing business. Some corporates will be able to pass on
                                these costs. Others will not. Those with less pricing power or those which sell low-
                                margin goods or middlemen are most at risk for a cash squeeze. (Our stagflation
                                portfolio favours companies that are most decidedly out of this area). Rising working
                                capital tends to be associated with an aversion to corporate activity or high cash levels
                                that have yet to be put to work. On the liabilities side, slowing payments (short-term
                                liabilities rising faster than short-term assets) in a world of liquidity but with hesitant
                                banks is not at all surprising to us.

May 2008                                                                                                                 11
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research

                                2.   Rising cost of funds for capex
                                One of our preferences in our portfolios has been for companies with cash flow sufficient
                                to cover capex. In a world of hesitant banks, the cost of finishing a project will very
                                likely rise. The assumptions for viability in projects included interest costs which were a
                                lot lower a year ago. We estimate that interest costs are up, on average, from Libor +150
                                to Libor +300 to 500. This is a significant increase in interest expense and eats into cash
                                flow.
                                3.   Cutbacks in capex or cancellation of projects
                                The dangerous part of a global slowdown is that companies which are in the middle of
                                major expansion are in danger of not finishing a very expensive project. The anticipation
                                of completion is the source of earnings. In the event of cessation of funding in a half-
                                finished project, the problems are quite serious. With a great deal of money spent, the
                                value of the asset is essentially still zero. Companies in this sort of condition are either
                                forced to sell an impaired asset or are forced into bankruptcy proceedings.

                                WHAT HAPPENED IN THE 1970S?
                                In the early 1970s, the US was in the middle of an unwinnable and increasingly
                                expensive war. It was funding large budget deficits. It was facing high commodity
                                prices. The US – and other countries – imposed price controls to deal with inflation. If
                                this sounds familiar, it is because it is familiar. Many investors agree that analogies to
                                the 1970s are appropriate. As Mark Twain, however, said, “History does not repeat itself.
                                It rhymes.” History will likely play itself out differently, but with many similarities.
                                There are three similarities we see.
                                1.   Inflation hit suddenly and hard
                                Inflation reared its head in a small way from the early 1970s and then hit all of a sudden.
                                When it did, it hit hard and took a long time to go away. Interest rates in 1980 were still
                                21%. Government bond yields peaked at 14%. Gold, oil, agricultural commodities, and
                                general prices soared. These conditions are eerily similar.
                                2.   Growth slowed
                                While nominal growth was quite high given that inflation was in the high single digits,
                                real growth slowed dramatically. Wages can grow with inflation, but pretty soon, they
                                can no longer keep up. As a result, real wages fall and spending drops. Interest rates
                                would soar and the cost of borrowing becomes prohibitive. Tax revenues from slowing
                                economic activity would have to rise and deficits rise. Taxes would rise more. Real take-
                                home income then falls. A vicious cycle is born.
                                3.   Inflation expectations rose
                                The hard part of price increases is that they are born of expectations. As people expect
                                prices to rise, prices rise. We have been living in a world for many years where we have
                                expected prices to go down. So, we delay expenditure and wait for prices to fall further.
                                As inflation grabs hold, we come to expect prices to rise and we rush our purchases. We
                                grab onto those types of investments which are seen as an inflation hedge. We eschew
                                fiat money. We seek out commodities, land, precious metals, and rare jewels. A plethora
                                of books have been written on this subject. Suffice to say that it takes much data (and
                                much time) for people to change their expectations on higher prices once higher prices
                                begin their gallop.




May 2008                                                                                                                 12
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research



                                            HOW CAN THE GOVERNMENT HELP EASE THE PAIN?
                                            Whether we like it or not, governments in the world are now deciding the price of assets
                                            as much as investors are. The decision of the Federal Reserve in March to lend to
                                            investment banks essentially put a ceiling on the price of debt for these banks. We think
                                            governments can do three things to help.
                                            1.    Price controls and subsidies
                                            We are facing a shortage of oil, a shortage of coal, and a shortage of food. Governments
                                            can help by accelerating the development of alternative energy. They can introduce
                                            conservation programs in terms of emissions regulation. They can place price caps on
                                            retail prices or they can introduce subsidy programs which compensate producers and
                                            make the consumer feel less pain at the cash register. While many insist that subsidies
                                            and price controls are destructive in the longer term, they quell social unrest and prevent
                                            riots. The problem is that they almost guarantee inflation as they incentivize consumers
                                            to consume more and cause producers to produce less.
                                            2.    Crash investment programs
                                            One of the results of high prices is the need for governments to pay for investment
                                            programs for products which are price inelastic. Goods with inelastic prices must be
                                            bought independent of price (basic necessities and staples). So, governments have a
                                            responsibility to rush the production of these goods to people and so need to step in and
                                            jump start programs such as oil exploration, cattle production, and farming.
                                            3.    Tax and regulatory relief
                                            Governments are famous for changing rules mid-stream. In an environment of rising
                                            costs, governments can act to reduce costs by turning a blind eye to restrictive
                                            immigration policy. In an environment of bad debt and economic stagnation, they may
                                            turn a blind eye to strict marking to market of that bad debt. They may allow banks to
                                            alter classification. In a coal shortage, some countries may reduce strict safety standards.
                                            In an oil shortage, countries may bend rules on oil drilling in wildlife preserves.
                                            Governments can reduce taxes on corporates which are large employers in a period of
                                            high unemployment. In other words, governments change valuations of companies and,
                                            indeed, cash-flows in the blink of an eye with market-friendly policies which can
                                            improve profitability. Conversely, governments which want to quell civil unrest may
                                            stick it to some corporates which make staples such as food and gasoline. Price controls
                                            can destroy shareholder value in the blink of an eye. We believe we are living in a world
                                            of unprecedented intervention by governments. This is an added risk for markets.

Figure 4:      Stagflation portfolio
                                                                                                                       EV/
                                                                                 3 Mth Ave
                                                                                                                               P/E     P/B    Div Yield
                                                                                                                     EBITDA
                                                      Lehman Current   Mkt Cap      Liquidity ROE Net Debt/ Altman
Company                  Ticker                        Rating  Price   US$mn       (US$mn) FY08E Assets Z-Score       FY08E   FY08E   FY08E    FY08E
                                      Industry Sector

Cheung Kong Infra        1038 HK      Utilities         1-OW    31.8     9,248         9.0   13      -2%     5.3      55.6    13.9     1.8       3.8
Hong Kong Electric       6 HK         Utilities         1-OW    45.2    12,724        27.5   15       2%     3.5       9.4    12.8     1.9       4.4
China Mobile             941 HK       Telecom           1-OW   132.5   379,182       477.7   28     -27%    10.1      10.8    20.6     5.4       2.1
Sun Hung Kai             16 HK        Property          1-OW   138.0    45,174       178.8   6       10%     NA       27.0    26.3     1.7       1.8
CNOOC                    883 HK       Oil & Gas E&P     2-EW    13.9    94,145       237.9   28     -16%    10.1       9.7    14.3     3.7       2.6
Shenhua                  1088 HK      Energy            1-OW    35.0    14,379       153.4   20       3%     1.9       2.0    20.4     4.0       1.7
Rio Tinto                RIO AU       Mining            0-NR   145.3    64,535       197.2   40      44%     1.4       4.8    15.7     4.9       1.2
IOI                      IOI MK       Palm Oil          0-NR     7.1    13,801        31.3   26       7%     7.5      14.7    21.6     5.0       2.4
EGCO                     EGCO TB      Utilities         2-EW    95.5     1,547         1.8   18       8%     3.4       8.8     6.4     1.1       5.7
HK and Shanghai Hotels   45 HK        Hotels            1-OW    13.5     2,544         1.8   5        5%     2.9      12.0    20.1     0.9       1.5
Ranbaxy                  RBXY IS      Pharmaceuticals   1-OW   466.3     4,355         4.6   24      44%     3.2      18.0    24.7     5.7       2.0
KT&G                     033780 KS Consumer             1-OW 82500.0    11,019        31.2   23      -3%    11.3      10.7    14.8     3.3       NA
Melco                    200 HK Equit Conglomerates     0-NR    11.6     1,891         7.5   4       11%     5.6      82.7    43.5     1.4       0.1
Average                                                                 50,350       104.6   27       6%     8.6      11.9    19.3     4.6       2.1

Note: Prices as of May 7, 2008
Source: IBES, Worldscope, Lehman Brothers estimates




May 2008                                                                                                                                           13
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research




                                    This page intentionally left blank




May 2008                                                                 14
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research




                                    COUNTRY ANALYSIS




May 2008                                           15
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research


AUSTRALIA’S BRIEF STAGFLATION

                                Tight policies limit local stagflation risk
              David Langford
             LBAUL, Sydney
          Tel:+612 8062 8440
                                HOW WOULD STAGFLATION IMPACT AUSTRALIA?
 david.langford@lehman.com
                                Lehman Brothers Asia is exploring the risks to Asia Pacific markets in the scenario of
                                falling global growth, resulting in slower Asian growth, but in the face of rising input
            Stephen Roberts
                                costs. In our view, Australia could witness a brief period of stagflation, where inflation is
             LBAUL, Sydney
                                high and relatively sticky and economic growth is weakening. However, we believe a
          Tel:+612 8062 8431
                                lengthy period of stagflation is unlikely because of the Reserve Bank of Australia’s
stephen.roberts@lehman.com
                                (RBA) commitment to deliver sufficiently tight monetary conditions to ensure that
                                domestic spending growth and inflation fall.
   Australia Research Team      Unlike many of its Asian neighbors and major trading partners, Australia benefits from a
         Tel:+612 8062 8000     de-regulated financial system. The characteristics of this system include a freely floating
                                exchange rate and an independent central or reserve bank. The RBA is free to use its
                                cash interest rate to tighten or loosen monetary conditions as it deems necessary. The
                                RBA has a formal 2-3% inflation target that it has agreed (with the Federal Treasurer) to
                                achieve over the course of the economic cycle. Thus, despite the relatively greater
                                acceleration of inflation in most Asian economies when compared with Australia over
                                the past 12 months, the RBA stands almost alone in lifting its cash rate aggressively and
                                allowing its currency to appreciate freely to dampen rising inflation. We consider that
                                Australia is different from Asia in the manner in which policy has responded to rising
                                inflation. In our view, while a consequence of comparatively tighter Australian monetary
                                conditions will be to deliver the “stag” part of stagflation, we expect the “flation” part to
                                recede.
                                The rise of stagflation among Australia’s major Asian trading partners represents a
                                material risk for many Australian companies, in our view. Asia receives around 70% of
                                Australian exports and almost all of Australia’s exports of coal and metal ores.
                                Weakening Asian growth, as a consequence of trying to contain high inflation, could
                                dampen raw material prices significantly, in our view.
                                We believe that attempts to calibrate Australian policy settings at a time when Asian
                                growth may turn in an unpredictable fashion, runs the risk of double trouble for
                                Australian economic growth prospects. Domestic spending is weakening owing to tight
                                monetary policies. We consider that this impact may be further reinforced by an erratic
                                pull-back in Asian demand and commodity prices.




May 2008                                                                                                                  16
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research



                                     WINNERS AND LOSERS

Figure 5:       Winners and losers (Australia)
Winners                    Ticker   Price     TP         Rating   Comments
                                                                  •   Telstra’s large infrastructure/sunk cost base limits exposure
Telstra                    TLS.AX   A$4.52    A$5.40     1-OW
                                                                      to margin squeeze from a rising cost base, in our view.
Telecommunications
                                                                  •   Upgraded IT/customer care systems are likely to reduce its
                                                                      exposure to increasing labor costs.

                                                                  •   Telstra’s products are believed to be attractive substitutes for
                                                                      businesses and consumers when cutting costs (e.g. phone
                                                                      services/video conf replaces travel)

                                                                  •   Inflation-sensitive labor represents ~14% of Austar’s FY08E
Austar                     AUN.AX   A$1.35    A$1.65     1-OW
                                                                      total cost base. Programming costs (~48% of Austar’s
Subscription Television
                                                                      FY08E total costs) are subject to long-term contracts, we
Services
                                                                      believe. We expect the outcome of these factors to be
                                                                      margin strength.

                                                                  •   We consider subscription TV services to be price inelastic and a
                                                                      cheap entertainment alternative for cost-conscious consumers.

                                                                  •   Austar’s set-top box costs (capex) are subject to declining
                                                                      prices, driven by ongoing technology improvements.

                                                                  •   Waste management is an essential/non-discretionary
Transpacific               TPI.AX   A$8.35    A$12.50    1-OW
                                                                      service, we believe.
Waste Management
Services
                                                                  •   We understand that long-term customer contracts (~35% of
                                                                      FY08E revenues) include CPI adjustment clauses. We
                                                                      expect this structure to provide Transpacific a level of
                                                                      immunity from margin squeeze.

                                                                  •   PrimAg owns Australian agricultural land and produces soft
PrimeAg Australia          PAG.AX   A$1.99    A$2.25     1-OW
                                                                      commodities.
Agricultural Commodities
                                                                  •   We expect the company to be a significant beneficiary of food
                                                                      price inflation.

Losers                     Ticker   Price     TP         Rating   Comments
                                                                  •   Project cost inflation already represents a difficulty for future
WorleyParsons              WOR.AX   A$39.50   $40.00     2-EW
                                                                      growth. Cost pressures may intensify particularly in labor- and
Hydrocarbon Engineering
                                                                      commodity-based materials categories.
Services

                                                                  •   Around 85%+ of Bluescope’s EBIT is derived from sales of
Bluescope Steel            BSL.AX   A$10.61   A$9.35*    3-UW
                                                                      commodity-grade flat steel products at international
Flat Steel Products
                                                                      benchmark prices.

                                                                  •   Lower Asian growth may result in reduced steel demand (Asia
                                                                      has been a key driver of global steel demand) and therefore,
                                                                      lower international steel prices.

                                                                  •   Bluescope Steel’s earnings are highly leveraged to falling
                                                                      international steel prices.

                                                                  •   Print advertising and circulation represents ~85% of Fairfax’s
Fairfax Media              FXJ.AX   A$3.34    A$3.80**   2-EW
                                                                      FY08E revenue base. We expect a stagflationary environment to
Newspaper and Online
                                                                      weaken ad growth and accelerate the secular trend to cheaper
Publisher
                                                                      online alternatives.

                                                                  •   Labor costs comprise ~41% of Fairfax’s FY08E total cost
                                                                      base. Accordingly, labor-intensive content requirements and
                                                                      the shift of advertising online are likely to result in margin
                                                                      squeeze, we believe.




May 2008                                                                                                                                  17
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research

                                                                                   •
Babcock & Brown              BNB.AX        A$15.38       A$16.20      2-EW               Infrastructure investments employ significant gearing, which
                                                                                         creates earnings and cash flow risk in a high inflation/interest
Brokers and Asset
Managers                                                                                 rate environment, we believe.

                                                                                   •     We expect principal trading gains to be nominally supported
                                                                                         by inflation. But the after-tax real gain will be much lower, we
                                                                                         believe, because the tax system does not distinguish
                                                                                         between real and nominal gains.

                                                                                   •
Macquarie Group              MQG.AX        A$60.75       A$62.80*** 2-EW                 Infrastructure investments employ significant gearing, which
                                                                                         creates earnings and cash flow risk in a high inflation/interest
Brokers and Asset
Managers                                                                                 rate environment, we believe.

                                                                                   •     We expect principal trading gains to be nominally supported
                                                                                         by inflation. But the after tax real gain will, we believe, be
                                                                                         much lower because the tax system does not distinguish
                                                                                         between real and nominal gains.

Source: Lehman Brothers research. Prices as of May 7, 2008. * The 12-month target price for Fairfax Media was cut to A$3.80 (from A$4.30) on 14 May 2008.
** The 12-month target price for Bluescope Steel was revised to A$9.35 (from A$9.25) on 13 May 2008. *** The 12-month target price for Macquarie Group was
revised to A$62.80 (from A$59.20) on 15 May 2008


                                            DOWNSIZING THE ENGINE ROOM?
                                            Investment spending, in all forms, has been one of the strongest growing segments of the
                                            Australian economy. We believe that strong growth has taken place across the spectrum,
                                            from public sector infrastructure spending to business investment spending. In 2007, the
                                            Australian economy grew 3.9% in real terms, but investment spending was up 8.7%.
                                            We believe that the combination of (1) Asian stagflation resulting in weakening
                                            commodity demand; and (2) tight domestic monetary policy aimed at softening domestic
                                            spending is likely to result in jaundiced growth in investment spending. Apart, from the
                                            negative short-term impact on economic growth, Australia’s longer-term potential
                                            growth rate is also likely to suffer, in our view. Current Australian Federal Treasury
                                            estimates put the country’s long-term potential growth rate at around 3.5% per annum.
                                            However, we estimate that the long-term growth rate could fall to less than 3% per
                                            annum on a material reduction in the pace of growth in investment spending.

                                            WHAT HAPPENED IN THE 1970S?
                                            In our view, Australia’s experience of stagflation in the past was caused by inappropriate
                                            and ineffective monetary and fiscal responses to the oil price shock of the early 1970s.
                                            There are many reasons for why we believe the current run-up in key commodity prices
                                            will not trigger a re-run of the 1970s. First, we believe that it is more difficult for a
                                            commodity price shock to trigger second-round inflation effects in wage claims that help
                                            to develop an upward inflationary spiral. In the 1970s, Australia had near-automatic
                                            wage indexation, which meant that the latest quarterly rise in inflation fed almost directly
                                            into higher wages – i.e., four wage increases a year after each CPI reading. Second,
                                            monetary policy was largely ineffective in the 1970s because of bank lending, deposit
                                            and interest controls, and a fixed exchange rate regime. Third, the exchange rate could
                                            only help to contain inflation periodically – i.e., on occasions when the dollar was
                                            formally re-valued. Finally, fiscal policy was very loose, notwithstanding strong supply-
                                            side pressures on inflation from higher commodity prices.

                                            HOW CAN THE GOVERNMENT HELP EASE THE PAIN?

                                            The government can only ease the pain by ensuring that the period of stagflation is as
                                            brief as possible. Leaving the central bank to deal with inflation and providing it with the
                                            independence and policy armory to do the job is a good start, in our view. We also



May 2008                                                                                                                                                     18
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research

                                believe that prudent fiscal policy (Federal Budget surpluses at or above 1% of GDP)
                                should contain domestic inflationary pressures.

                                CONCLUSION
                                We consider that Asian stagflation represents a material risk to the Australian economy
                                and corporate earnings growth. However, we believe that Australian institutional
                                processes and flexible yet aggressive policy settings are likely to soften inflationary
                                impacts. In our view, the demand side of the stagflation equation may prove to be the
                                toughest issue for Australian policy makers. As a result, we believe that more attractive
                                investment exposures are likely to be provided by those companies which enjoy:
                                (1) limited exposure to input cost inflation (e.g., materials and labor); and (2) product
                                sets with a high degree of substitutability for higher priced products in a cost-conscious
                                environment.




May 2008                                                                                                               19
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research


CHINA STAGFLATION SCENARIO

                                Can the government tame rising inflation and rescue
              Cheng Khoo
                                slowing growth?
         LBAL, Hong Kong
       Tel: +852 2252 6180
   cheng.khoo@lehman.com
                                HOW WOULD STAGFLATION IMPACT CHINA?
                Paul Schulte    During a high inflationary period that coupled with slowing global and domestic
          LBAL, Hong Kong       economic growth, we think Chinese companies and the stock market would not be
         Tel: +852 2252 1409    shielded from a downturn. The Chinese government is in a difficult position. It seems the
   paul.schulte@lehman.com      most logical course of action is to allow the currency to appreciate. In doing so, it: (1)
                                imports deflationary pressures; (2) reduces trade surplus; and (3) reduces the enormous
                                reserves. In essence, importing deflationary pressures and reducing inflationary domestic
      China Research Team       liquidity is just about the only thing China can do, in our view. Interest rates could be
                                raised further, but we believe that would be using the wrong tool. In our view, China’s
                                problems are due to insufficient upstream raw material supply and an excess capacity in
                                selected downstream manufacturing industries, in our view.
                                Ironically, we have to ask whether there has been sufficient investment in China. With
                                fixed capital investment running at 25% per year, we also expect nominal growth at
                                about 19%–20%. Is one way out of the supply-driven inflationary burst an even higher
                                level of capital investment, especially in water and agriculture? The government recently
                                increased its investment in agriculture by 30%, to around US$43 billion. It is also
                                running up large subsidy bills as it keeps consumers from feeling the full brunt of
                                international price increases of most commodities. Our favourite theme for the next few
                                years is agricultural investment. China needs to revolutionize its agricultural sector,
                                including its water supply. When it targets to achieve something, its policies tends to
                                succeed. This, we believe, represents the most promising sector for investors over the
                                coming years. Biofuels, genetically modified (GM) seeds, irrigation, and new labor in
                                rural areas are vital for China to get to the next level.
                                Earnings and margins outlook. We are already seeing the effects on margins in many
                                forms. (1) Many exporters’ margins are eroded by the appreciating renminbi. Other
                                companies are under severe pressure due to price caps on products. The renminbi has
                                appreciated by more than 9% against the dollar in the past few months, eliminating any
                                profits for low-margin businesses. (2) These price caps – actually, for most products in
                                the HSCEI – decimate margins as international prices rise. Consider the case of the
                                biggest oil refining company Sinopec – were it not for a subsidized check, many of them
                                would have already been in the red in 1Q08. Ironically, these price caps themselves are
                                inflationary as they discourage future expansion in plant and equipment, and, therefore,
                                are likely to produce lower installed capacity over time. This is a concern for us. (3) The
                                normal margin pressure comes from input prices going up while wages are also rising.
                                So, we can see many companies with rising land costs, rising energy costs, rising labor
                                costs, and rising capital costs.
                                Market performance. In January, we downgraded China from an overweight because
                                we saw inflationary pressures spilling out all over. We also saw China’s inflation-free
                                growth beginning to show wear and tear. The costs of land, labor, and capital are all
                                moving up dramatically. This is a phenomenon that we strongly believe is a reflection of
                                shortages and, hence, we are sceptical about the issue of overcapacity. So, China is
                                seeing its liquidity seep out of the economy as the government becomes reinvigorated by
                                the need to control inflation. We also think there is a need for a vast “Green Revolution”
                                or “New Deal” to deal with chronic food shortages and water shortages, among others.
                                This necessary, but very expensive, bonanza of spending is, in itself, also inflationary.
                                Hence, we expect a pause in growth as large capital investments are implemented, which
                                do not yield strong results.

May 2008                                                                                                                20
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research

                                       We would consider upgrading China if we saw signs of inflation peaking. However, we
                                       do not see that any time soon.
                                       Our sector and company selections follow.

                                       WINNERS AND LOSERS

Figure 6:      Winners and losers (China)
Winners                Ticker       Price           Target price     Rating         Comments
                                                                                    •
COSL                   2883.HK      HK$15.56        HK$21.0          1-OW               Low earnings risk
                                                                                    •
China Shenhua          1088.HK      HK$34.95        HK$57.0          1-OW               Extremely tight supply and asset injections
                                                                                    •   Price controls a risk
                                                                                    •
Hutchison Whampoa 0013.HK           HK$78.00        HK$93.8          1-OW               Cash rich; industry leader; diversified
Losers – Company Ticker             Price           Target price     Rating         Comments
                                                                                    •
Guangzhou R&F          2777.HK      HK$21.00        HK$31.04         2-EW               High gearing of 265%.
                                                                                    •   A-share listing not assured in current unfriendly
                                                                                        environment.
                                                                                    •
Minsheng Bank          600016.SS    RMB8.22         RMB9.85          2-EW               Relatively weaker management; insufficient risk
                                                                                        management during a downturn.
                                                                                    •
CSCL                   2866.HK      HK$3.49         HK$2.9           3-UW               Leveraged to changes in inflation and costs
Prices as of May 7, 2008
Source: Lehman Brothers estimates


                                       LOWER GDP GROWTH WITH HIGHER INFLATION
                                       Lehman Brothers’ China economist Mingchun Sun currently forecasts single-digit GDP
                                       growth of 9.8% in 2008 for China, which indicates a decline from a growth rate of
                                       11.6% in 2006 and 11.9% in 2007. Expecting deteriorating conditions exacerbated by
                                       overinvestment, which is resulting in overcapacity situation in many sectors, he recently
                                       downgraded the 2009 GDP forecast from 8.5% to 8%.
                                       In terms of inflation, Sun forecasts a full-year 2008 CPI to reach 5.5%, up from 4.8% in
                                       2007, but much lower than the 1Q08’s level of 8%, indicating that 2H08 inflation will
                                       likely ease from a high base effect in 2H07. The easing trend then continues into 2009
                                       with a FY09E CPI of 2.8%.

                                       Figure 7:        China real GDP growth vs CPI

                                                              China Real GDP Growth vs CPI (YoY % Change)
                                            16                                                                                            30
                                            14                                                                                            25
                                                                                                Real GDP growth
                                            12                                                  CPI (RHS)                                 20
                                            10
                                                                                                                                          15
                                            8
                                                                                                                                          10
                                            6
                                                                                                                                          5
                                            4
                                                                                                                                          0
                                            2
                                            0                                                                                             -5
                                                 1985    1988      1991          1994   1997      2000          2003     2006     2009E
                                       Source: CEIC, Lehman Brothers estimates




May 2008                                                                                                                                  21
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research

                                However, in this report, the equity strategy team explores the impact of equities in light
                                of a more negative scenario of a GDP growth rate of only 6.1% in 2008 and 5.9% in
                                2009 and escalating inflationary environment with a CPI of 6.7% in 2008 and rising
                                further to 6.9% in 2009. By applying higher inflation assumptions, we are exploring the
                                negative impact of real GDP growth. We analyze the risks to revenue growth and profit
                                margins in combination with higher input cost in the various sectors.

                                IMPACT ON REVENUE
                                The market is currently debating whether a slowdown in the US/developed economies
                                would impact the Asian and Chinese economies. Irrespective of the global economic
                                slowdown, Chinese exporters have already started to feel the pinch of rising costs and
                                competitive pressures. These include an appreciating currency, reduced VAT export
                                rebates (and in some cases an increase in export tariffs), removal of favourable policies for
                                processing trade; increasing cost pressure from rising prices of land, labour, energy and
                                raw materials; and tighter standard on product quality, labour conditions, and
                                environmental protection. In terms of trend, export growth has already slowed, especially
                                in volume terms. As global demand weakens, export growth is very likely to be hit further.
                                We think domestic consumption is unlikely to be strong enough to offset weakness in exports.
                                Furthermore, as export growth slows, we expect income growth to decline while high inflation
                                stands to erode the purchasing power of households and be a drag on real spending.
                                During a period of slowing GDP growth, demand normally enters a downward trend, and
                                excess capacity becomes a problem as operating rates decline. This is especially true in
                                sectors that are experiencing an overcapacity situation. Producers have to lower prices in
                                light of the heightened competition. With the global economy expected to slowdown
                                considerably more in 2H08, we expect exports to decline in 2H08, intensifying through
                                2009. About one quarter of China’s total industrial production is exported, even though
                                some sectors are more dependent on exports than others, such as mobile phones and
                                color TVs.

                                EFFECT ON EBIT: MARGIN SHRINKAGE?
                                As external demand weakens, we think inventories are likely to pile up as soon as in
                                3Q08, after the Olympics. A strong inventory is being built up in some areas such as fuel
                                and consumer products in anticipation of high demand during the Olympics. We believe
                                firms will probably compete on price despite rising cost, which will likely depress
                                margins. Profit margins are still trending around their highest levels since 1999, but seem
                                to have reached a plateau. The number of loss-making enterprises is currently rising at
                                8.5%, up from 0.3% in 2007.

                                Figure 8:      China net profit margin

                                                                   China Net Profit Margin (%)
                                    12

                                    10

                                    8

                                    6

                                    4

                                    2

                                    0
                                         1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007
                                Source: Worldscope, Lehman Brothers research


May 2008                                                                                                                  22
Lehman Brothers | Equity Research

                                With significantly lower economic growth and a rising cost base, we expect corporate
                                earnings to come under pressure. According to consensus (IBES) estimates for Chinese
                                corporations, analysts are projecting slowing EPS growth of 17.6% for 2008 and 16.6%
                                for 2009, down from 32% in 2006. However, only four sectors (capital goods, retailing,
                                diversified financials, and insurance) have negative earnings growth projections for
                                2008, while only one sector (diversified financials) has negative earning growth estimate
                                in 2009(–10%). In our worst-case scenario, we expect potential downside to this set of
                                earnings estimates. Instead of a majority of the sectors showing earnings growth, we
                                expect the reverse to happen especially for those that are export focused and are facing
                                overcapacity.

                                Figure 9:        China EPS growth estimates
                                                                                              EPS growth (%)
                                                                                           2007       2008E        2009E
                                China                                                      32.3         17.6         16.6
                                Energy                                                      7.6         18.7          9.6
                                Materials                                                   4.8         24.9         14.2
                                Capital goods                                              38.6          -3.7        22.7
                                Transportation                                            155.2         12.7          9.7
                                Auto & components                                          38.4         19.2         16.1
                                Consumer durables                                          23.2         11.5         20.5
                                Consumer services                                          34.9         34.6         25.8
                                Retailing                                                  52.0         -22.5        23.7
                                Food bev & tobacco                                         26.2         24.5         24.2
                                Household products                                         42.9         19.0         25.7
                                Banks                                                      47.0         39.8         19.2
                                Diversified financials                                    360.6         -41.7       -10.0
                                Insurance                                                 103.3         -17.2        17.3
                                Real estate                                                53.0         26.0         37.3
                                Software & services                                        24.1         17.1         30.7
                                Technology hardware & equip                                61.0         15.5         15.3
                                Telecom                                                    19.0         25.1         15.7
                                Utilities                                                  10.0          1.3         18.2
                                Source: IBES


                                We believe weaker corporate earnings and rising bankruptcies will increase
                                unemployment and undermine the ability of the firms to repay loans. While bank non-
                                performing loans (NPLs) have declined in recent years, they rose slightly in 4Q07. In
                                addition, we are concerned that a credit cycle may kick in, and Chinese banks could face
                                increased new NPL formation, particularly in risky sectors such as property,
                                manufacturing, and exporters.

                                We think that the weakening earnings will likely be reflected in the stock market as P/E
                                ratios climb. Despite falling by about 30% this year, the Shanghai Stock Exchange A-
                                share Index at a P/E of 27.3 is still expensive compared to the other market index P/Es.




May 2008                                                                                                               23
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia
Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia

More Related Content

What's hot

SANTANDER MEXICO-SANTANDER INVESTOR DAY 2011
SANTANDER MEXICO-SANTANDER INVESTOR DAY 2011SANTANDER MEXICO-SANTANDER INVESTOR DAY 2011
SANTANDER MEXICO-SANTANDER INVESTOR DAY 2011BANCO SANTANDER
 
Daily report 2 dec 2019
Daily report 2 dec 2019Daily report 2 dec 2019
Daily report 2 dec 2019AnkitDubey174
 
Korea Fund, Inc. Second Quarter 2012
Korea Fund, Inc. Second Quarter 2012Korea Fund, Inc. Second Quarter 2012
Korea Fund, Inc. Second Quarter 2012Company Spotlight
 
Carfinco investor presentation
Carfinco investor presentationCarfinco investor presentation
Carfinco investor presentationCompany Spotlight
 
Carfinco Investor Presentation June 2012
Carfinco Investor Presentation June 2012Carfinco Investor Presentation June 2012
Carfinco Investor Presentation June 2012Company Spotlight
 
csx Dahlman Rose Conference 09.11.08
csx  Dahlman Rose Conference 09.11.08csx  Dahlman Rose Conference 09.11.08
csx Dahlman Rose Conference 09.11.08finance27
 
CSX_Corp_-_Citi_Conf_11.14.06-REF23362
CSX_Corp_-_Citi_Conf_11.14.06-REF23362CSX_Corp_-_Citi_Conf_11.14.06-REF23362
CSX_Corp_-_Citi_Conf_11.14.06-REF23362finance27
 
Accountants (Big 4s) Professional Liability (audit analytics 2009)
Accountants (Big 4s) Professional Liability (audit analytics 2009)Accountants (Big 4s) Professional Liability (audit analytics 2009)
Accountants (Big 4s) Professional Liability (audit analytics 2009)Andres Baytelman
 
Keynote capitals india morning note aug 18-'11
Keynote capitals india morning note aug 18-'11Keynote capitals india morning note aug 18-'11
Keynote capitals india morning note aug 18-'11Keynote Capitals Ltd.
 
ETX Capital -From The Floor is a daily briefing and global market report to k...
ETX Capital -From The Floor is a daily briefing and global market report to k...ETX Capital -From The Floor is a daily briefing and global market report to k...
ETX Capital -From The Floor is a daily briefing and global market report to k...ETX_Capital
 
GNW Raymond%20James%203-5-08
GNW Raymond%20James%203-5-08GNW Raymond%20James%203-5-08
GNW Raymond%20James%203-5-08finance24
 

What's hot (16)

SANTANDER MEXICO-SANTANDER INVESTOR DAY 2011
SANTANDER MEXICO-SANTANDER INVESTOR DAY 2011SANTANDER MEXICO-SANTANDER INVESTOR DAY 2011
SANTANDER MEXICO-SANTANDER INVESTOR DAY 2011
 
Daily report 2 dec 2019
Daily report 2 dec 2019Daily report 2 dec 2019
Daily report 2 dec 2019
 
Daily report 11 dec
Daily report 11 decDaily report 11 dec
Daily report 11 dec
 
Korea Fund, Inc. Second Quarter 2012
Korea Fund, Inc. Second Quarter 2012Korea Fund, Inc. Second Quarter 2012
Korea Fund, Inc. Second Quarter 2012
 
Munjal show ltd
Munjal show ltdMunjal show ltd
Munjal show ltd
 
Carfinco investor presentation
Carfinco investor presentationCarfinco investor presentation
Carfinco investor presentation
 
Carfinco Investor Presentation June 2012
Carfinco Investor Presentation June 2012Carfinco Investor Presentation June 2012
Carfinco Investor Presentation June 2012
 
cmi_051109
cmi_051109cmi_051109
cmi_051109
 
csx Dahlman Rose Conference 09.11.08
csx  Dahlman Rose Conference 09.11.08csx  Dahlman Rose Conference 09.11.08
csx Dahlman Rose Conference 09.11.08
 
CSX_Corp_-_Citi_Conf_11.14.06-REF23362
CSX_Corp_-_Citi_Conf_11.14.06-REF23362CSX_Corp_-_Citi_Conf_11.14.06-REF23362
CSX_Corp_-_Citi_Conf_11.14.06-REF23362
 
Accountants (Big 4s) Professional Liability (audit analytics 2009)
Accountants (Big 4s) Professional Liability (audit analytics 2009)Accountants (Big 4s) Professional Liability (audit analytics 2009)
Accountants (Big 4s) Professional Liability (audit analytics 2009)
 
Jpm china view 121018
Jpm china view 121018Jpm china view 121018
Jpm china view 121018
 
Keynote capitals india morning note aug 18-'11
Keynote capitals india morning note aug 18-'11Keynote capitals india morning note aug 18-'11
Keynote capitals india morning note aug 18-'11
 
Korea Supplement
Korea SupplementKorea Supplement
Korea Supplement
 
ETX Capital -From The Floor is a daily briefing and global market report to k...
ETX Capital -From The Floor is a daily briefing and global market report to k...ETX Capital -From The Floor is a daily briefing and global market report to k...
ETX Capital -From The Floor is a daily briefing and global market report to k...
 
GNW Raymond%20James%203-5-08
GNW Raymond%20James%203-5-08GNW Raymond%20James%203-5-08
GNW Raymond%20James%203-5-08
 

Viewers also liked

Lehman Brothers Bankruptcy
Lehman Brothers BankruptcyLehman Brothers Bankruptcy
Lehman Brothers BankruptcyHassaan13
 
Fall of lehman brothers
Fall of lehman brothers Fall of lehman brothers
Fall of lehman brothers Vishal Gavandar
 
Lehman brothers Alternatives
Lehman brothers AlternativesLehman brothers Alternatives
Lehman brothers Alternativesvvraviteja
 
Lehman Brothers - Collapse and Bankruptcy
Lehman Brothers - Collapse and BankruptcyLehman Brothers - Collapse and Bankruptcy
Lehman Brothers - Collapse and BankruptcyFatih Aydogdu
 
Lehman brothers
Lehman brothersLehman brothers
Lehman brothersasadswati1
 
lehman brothers
lehman brotherslehman brothers
lehman brothersagggari
 
Lehman Brothers Collapse
Lehman Brothers CollapseLehman Brothers Collapse
Lehman Brothers Collapsekktv
 
Political parties of india
Political parties of indiaPolitical parties of india
Political parties of indiaNikhil Gupta
 

Viewers also liked (11)

Emerging key-recovery-service
Emerging key-recovery-serviceEmerging key-recovery-service
Emerging key-recovery-service
 
Lehman Brothers Bankruptcy
Lehman Brothers BankruptcyLehman Brothers Bankruptcy
Lehman Brothers Bankruptcy
 
Fall of lehman brothers
Fall of lehman brothers Fall of lehman brothers
Fall of lehman brothers
 
Lehman brothers Alternatives
Lehman brothers AlternativesLehman brothers Alternatives
Lehman brothers Alternatives
 
Lehman Brothers
Lehman BrothersLehman Brothers
Lehman Brothers
 
Lehman Brothers - Collapse and Bankruptcy
Lehman Brothers - Collapse and BankruptcyLehman Brothers - Collapse and Bankruptcy
Lehman Brothers - Collapse and Bankruptcy
 
Lehman brothers
Lehman brothersLehman brothers
Lehman brothers
 
Fall Of Lehman Brother
Fall Of Lehman BrotherFall Of Lehman Brother
Fall Of Lehman Brother
 
lehman brothers
lehman brotherslehman brothers
lehman brothers
 
Lehman Brothers Collapse
Lehman Brothers CollapseLehman Brothers Collapse
Lehman Brothers Collapse
 
Political parties of india
Political parties of indiaPolitical parties of india
Political parties of india
 

Similar to Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia

2011 - Q1 - Commentary
2011 - Q1 - Commentary2011 - Q1 - Commentary
2011 - Q1 - CommentaryDrew Beja
 
el paso 11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
el paso  11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)el paso  11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
el paso 11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)finance49
 
el paso 11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
el paso  11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)el paso  11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
el paso 11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)finance49
 
.integrysgroup 02/05/09_money show
.integrysgroup 02/05/09_money show.integrysgroup 02/05/09_money show
.integrysgroup 02/05/09_money showfinance26
 
Mining%20bill %20 impact%20analysis-eu-080711
Mining%20bill %20 impact%20analysis-eu-080711Mining%20bill %20 impact%20analysis-eu-080711
Mining%20bill %20 impact%20analysis-eu-080711Angel Broking
 
Nap investor presentation_feb._2012
Nap investor presentation_feb._2012Nap investor presentation_feb._2012
Nap investor presentation_feb._2012FirstQuantum
 
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierUnderstanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierrollerballrohit8
 
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierUnderstanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierrollerballrohit8
 

Similar to Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia (20)

LCC Weekly Sector Report Edition 501.pdf
LCC Weekly Sector Report Edition 501.pdfLCC Weekly Sector Report Edition 501.pdf
LCC Weekly Sector Report Edition 501.pdf
 
Nap investor presentation apr. 2012
Nap investor presentation apr. 2012Nap investor presentation apr. 2012
Nap investor presentation apr. 2012
 
2011 - Q1 - Commentary
2011 - Q1 - Commentary2011 - Q1 - Commentary
2011 - Q1 - Commentary
 
Nap investor presentation_may_2012
Nap investor presentation_may_2012Nap investor presentation_may_2012
Nap investor presentation_may_2012
 
el paso 11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
el paso  11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)el paso  11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
el paso 11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
 
el paso 11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
el paso  11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)el paso  11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
el paso 11_20_Hopper_BofACreditConferenceFINALv2(Web)
 
Jpm china view 121018
Jpm china view 121018Jpm china view 121018
Jpm china view 121018
 
ENERGY CALL JAN 2015
ENERGY CALL JAN 2015ENERGY CALL JAN 2015
ENERGY CALL JAN 2015
 
.integrysgroup 02/05/09_money show
.integrysgroup 02/05/09_money show.integrysgroup 02/05/09_money show
.integrysgroup 02/05/09_money show
 
Mining%20bill %20 impact%20analysis-eu-080711
Mining%20bill %20 impact%20analysis-eu-080711Mining%20bill %20 impact%20analysis-eu-080711
Mining%20bill %20 impact%20analysis-eu-080711
 
Nap investor presentation_feb._2012
Nap investor presentation_feb._2012Nap investor presentation_feb._2012
Nap investor presentation_feb._2012
 
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierUnderstanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
 
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplierUnderstanding the-health-of-your-supplier
Understanding the-health-of-your-supplier
 
Nap investor presentation feb. 2012
Nap investor presentation feb. 2012Nap investor presentation feb. 2012
Nap investor presentation feb. 2012
 
Nap investor presentation feb. 2012
Nap investor presentation feb. 2012Nap investor presentation feb. 2012
Nap investor presentation feb. 2012
 
XEL_110306
XEL_110306XEL_110306
XEL_110306
 
XEL_110306
XEL_110306XEL_110306
XEL_110306
 
XEL_110306
XEL_110306XEL_110306
XEL_110306
 
Nap investor presentation august 2012
Nap investor presentation august 2012Nap investor presentation august 2012
Nap investor presentation august 2012
 
Stock analysis l&t special report by capital height
Stock analysis l&t special report by capital heightStock analysis l&t special report by capital height
Stock analysis l&t special report by capital height
 

Recently uploaded

Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation SlidesKeppelCorporation
 
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756dollysharma2066
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
Call Girls in Mehrauli Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Mehrauli Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝Call Girls in Mehrauli Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Mehrauli Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝soniya singh
 
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT .pdf
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT      .pdfCatalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT      .pdf
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT .pdfOrient Homes
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurSuhani Kapoor
 
CATALOG cáp điện Goldcup (bảng giá) 1.4.2024.PDF
CATALOG cáp điện Goldcup (bảng giá) 1.4.2024.PDFCATALOG cáp điện Goldcup (bảng giá) 1.4.2024.PDF
CATALOG cáp điện Goldcup (bảng giá) 1.4.2024.PDFOrient Homes
 
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...lizamodels9
 
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailCase study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailAriel592675
 
BEST Call Girls In BELLMONT HOTEL ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In BELLMONT HOTEL ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In BELLMONT HOTEL ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In BELLMONT HOTEL ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,noida100girls
 
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service DewasVip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewasmakika9823
 
Investment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio managementInvestment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio managementJunaidKhan750825
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...lizamodels9
 
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet CreationsMarketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creationsnakalysalcedo61
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...lizamodels9
 
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdfCatalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdfOrient Homes
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation SlidesKeppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update  Presentation Slides
Keppel Ltd. 1Q 2024 Business Update Presentation Slides
 
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Greater Noida ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
Call Girls In ⇛⇛Chhatarpur⇚⇚. Brings Offer Delhi Contact Us 8377877756
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Howrah 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
Call Girls in Mehrauli Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Mehrauli Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝Call Girls in Mehrauli Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
Call Girls in Mehrauli Delhi 💯Call Us 🔝8264348440🔝
 
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT .pdf
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT      .pdfCatalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT      .pdf
Catalogue ONG NUOC PPR DE NHAT .pdf
 
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting PartnershipBest Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
Best Practices for Implementing an External Recruiting Partnership
 
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In Old Faridabad ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service JamshedpurVIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
VIP Call Girl Jamshedpur Aashi 8250192130 Independent Escort Service Jamshedpur
 
CATALOG cáp điện Goldcup (bảng giá) 1.4.2024.PDF
CATALOG cáp điện Goldcup (bảng giá) 1.4.2024.PDFCATALOG cáp điện Goldcup (bảng giá) 1.4.2024.PDF
CATALOG cáp điện Goldcup (bảng giá) 1.4.2024.PDF
 
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
Call Girls In Connaught Place Delhi ❤️88604**77959_Russian 100% Genuine Escor...
 
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detailCase study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
Case study on tata clothing brand zudio in detail
 
BEST Call Girls In BELLMONT HOTEL ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In BELLMONT HOTEL ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,BEST Call Girls In BELLMONT HOTEL ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
BEST Call Girls In BELLMONT HOTEL ✨ 9773824855 ✨ Escorts Service In Delhi Ncr,
 
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service DewasVip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
Vip Dewas Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Dewas
 
Investment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio managementInvestment analysis and portfolio management
Investment analysis and portfolio management
 
KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)
KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)
KestrelPro Flyer Japan IT Week 2024 (English)
 
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
Call Girls In Sikandarpur Gurgaon ❤️8860477959_Russian 100% Genuine Escorts I...
 
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet CreationsMarketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
Marketing Management Business Plan_My Sweet Creations
 
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
Lowrate Call Girls In Laxmi Nagar Delhi ❤️8860477959 Escorts 100% Genuine Ser...
 
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdfCatalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
Catalogue ONG NƯỚC uPVC - HDPE DE NHAT.pdf
 

Performance in Stagflation: Winners and Losers in Asia

  • 1. Performance in Stagflation Lehman Brothers | Title PLEASE SEE ANALYST CERTIFICATION AND IMPORTANT DISCLOSURES, INCLUDING FOREIGN AFFILIATE DISCLOSURES, ON PAGES 157–158 Falling Growth and Rising Inflation in Asia The relentless demand for resources is creating a need for large-scale investment in agriculture, water, and alternative energy Investors confront the reality of rising inflation and slowing growth Regional Research Team May 2008 Lehman Brothers does and seeks to do business with companies covered in its research reports. As a result, investors should be aware that the firm may have a conflict of interest that could affect the objectivity of this report. Investors should consider this report as only a single factor in making their investment decision. Customers of Lehman Brothers in the United States can receive independent, third-party research on the company or companies covered in this presentation, at no cost to them, where such research is available. Customers can access this independent research at www.lehmanlive.com or can call 1-800-2-LEHMAN to request a copy of this research. This research report has been prepared in whole or in part by research analysts who are not registered/qualified as research analysts with FINRA.
  • 2.
  • 3. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research EXECUTIVE SUMMARY Describing Asian stagflation Our definition of stagflation in an Asian context can be described as significantly slowing growth and rising inflation. We have both of these in every single country in Asia, without exception. These stagflationary forces produce: (1) capital shortages, (2) rising costs, (3) diminishing aggregate demand, (4) margin squeeze and (5) rising taxes. In this environment, the characteristics of the likely winners, in our view, include (1) low debt, (2) pricing power, (3) captive buyers, (4) control of input prices, (5) makers of consumer staples and (6) “sin” stocks. Winners and losers The countries which are implementing significant price control and/or large subsidy program risk economic destabilization. These countries include India, China, the Philippines and Indonesia. Countries which allow market forces to determine prices – and therefore which allow supply and demand to recalibrate effectively and quickly – are the likely winners. These include Hong Kong, Singapore, Thailand and Taiwan. Countries which should also benefit are those which have large agricultural sectors. Malaysia wins on this score. Korea stands as an outlier in that it is highly dependent on hard and soft commodities, is heavily indebted, produces large-scale capital goods and is vulnerable to an economic slowdown in the West. Sector winners and losers Sectors which stand to benefit in a world of stagflation are iron ore, plantations, coal, telecom, properties and selected utilities. Other consumer sectors include tobacco, alcohol, gambling and health care. Sectors which are likely to be affected poorly by stagflation are lower margin, high-debt businesses, such as container shipping, shipbuilding, low margin technology businesses, autos, high-end and discretionary consumer goods, basic materials, price-controlled oil & gas, and selected construction materials. Currencies We also highlight countries with large current account surpluses and large budget surpluses which can withstand the economic pressures from falling growth and rising prices. These include CNY, MYR, SGD and TWD. Countries with troublesome current account deficits and budget deficits are threatened by excessive subsidies. These include Indonesia, India and the Philippines. Stagflation Portfolio The following portfolio shows stocks which we believe will be winners under a stagflationary environment. EV/ 3 Mth Ave P/E P/B Div Yield EBITDA Lehman Current Mkt Cap Liquidity ROE Net Debt/ Altman Company Ticker Rating Price US$mn (US$mn) FY08E Assets Z-Score FY08E FY08E FY08E FY08E Industry Sector Cheung Kong Infra 1038 HK Utilities 1-OW 31.8 9,248 9.0 13 -2% 5.3 55.6 13.9 1.8 3.8 Hong Kong Electric 6 HK Utilities 1-OW 45.2 12,724 27.5 15 2% 3.5 9.4 12.8 1.9 4.4 China Mobile 941 HK Telecom 1-OW 132.5 379,182 477.7 28 -27% 10.1 10.8 20.6 5.4 2.1 Sun Hung Kai 16 HK Property 1-OW 138.0 45,174 178.8 6 10% NA 27.0 26.3 1.7 1.8 CNOOC 883 HK Oil & Gas E&P 2-EW 13.9 94,145 237.9 28 -16% 10.1 9.7 14.3 3.7 2.6 Shenhua 1088 HK Energy 1-OW 35.0 14,379 153.4 20 3% 1.9 2.0 20.4 4.0 1.7 Rio Tinto RIO AU Mining 0-NR 145.3 64,535 197.2 40 44% 1.4 4.8 15.7 4.9 1.2 IOI IOI MK Palm Oil 0-NR 7.1 13,801 31.3 26 7% 7.5 14.7 21.6 5.0 2.4 EGCO EGCO TB Utilities 2-EW 95.5 1,547 1.8 18 8% 3.4 8.8 6.4 1.1 5.7 HK and Shanghai Hotels 45 HK Hotels 1-OW 13.5 2,544 1.8 5 5% 2.9 12.0 20.1 0.9 1.5 Ranbaxy RBXY IS Pharmaceuticals 1-OW 466.3 4,355 4.6 24 44% 3.2 18.0 24.7 5.7 2.0 KT&G 033780 KS Consumer 1-OW 82500.0 11,019 31.2 23 -3% 11.3 10.7 14.8 3.3 NA Melco 200 HK Equit Conglomerates 0-NR 11.6 1,891 7.5 4 11% 5.6 82.7 43.5 1.4 0.1 Average 50,350 104.6 27 6% 8.6 11.9 19.3 4.6 2.1 Source: BES, Worldscope, Lehman Brothers estimates Prices as of May 7, 2008 Paul Schulte and regional team Lehman Brothers Asia Limited May 2008 3
  • 4. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research COUNTRY SUMMARY Country Lehman Brothers Comments In a stagflation scenario Top Gainers Top Losers Australia Australian institutional processes and flexible, yet aggressive, policy settings Telstra Bluescope Steel (David are likely to soften inflationary impacts, in our view. The demand side of the PrimeAg Fairfax Media Langford) stagflation equation may prove to be the toughest issue for Australian policy makers. As a result, we believe that more attractive investment exposures are likely to be provided by those companies which enjoy: (i) limited exposure to input cost inflation (e.g., materials and labor); and (ii) product sets with a high degree of substitutability for higher priced products in a cost- conscious environment. China China is trying to deal with rising inflation by appreciating the currency and COSL Guangzhou (Cheng Khoo) keeping rates high. We believe growth is likely to slow down somewhat in R&F China Shenhua 2008 and again in 2009. Inflation risks are to the upside. Minsheng Bank Hong Kong We expect Hong Kong’s internal consumption to slow, unemployment to rise, HK Electric Giordano (Ivan Lee) and input cost (in terms of energy, labor, rental, etc.) to rise quickly. This is Hutchison Shangri-la Hotel not positive, especially for the consumer, hotel, manufacturing, gaming, Whampoa financial, and export sectors, mainly due to Hong Kong’s fairly open economy, close linkage with China’s economy, and because its currency is pegged to the US dollar. However, housing prices will likely continue to benefit from a negative interest rate environment, in our view. Also, we expect regulated utilities, whose earnings are tied to capex instead of tariff and fuel cost, and conglomerates with diversified earnings streams to have earnings resilient performance. India We do not believe that India will be hit significantly by stagflation and we Ranbaxy Larsen and (Prabhat think growth will remain strong in relative terms. In our view, the negative Toubro Hindustan Lever Awasthi) impact will be felt by interest rate-sensitive stocks or by companies not in a Tata Motors position to pass on cost pressures to consumers. Korea In Korea, we expect defensive industries such as telco and tobacco to be the KT Hanjin Shipping (Zayong Koo) least affected while other consumer related and export related industries KT&G LG Display would be adversely affected. However, we believe Samsung Electronics although the industry in which it operates is likely to be hurt by stagflation, the company is nevertheless well positioned globally to actually benefit from the downturn. Taiwan We believe Taiwan’s export-oriented economy is likely to underperform TSMC AUO (Kent Chan) compared with its Asian peers owing to its high dependence on technology, Taiwan Cement Nanya Tech excessive competition, and its dependence on imported oil. The domestic economy (property, telecoms, and insurance) and asset reflation stocks would continue to rise, potentially like they did after the inflation shock in the 1970s, in our view. May 2008 4
  • 5. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research SECTOR SUMMARY Sector Comments Top Gainers Top Losers Auto The auto sector could be a likely loser since auto demand is tied to Denway Hyundai Motor (Zayong Koo) economic conditions and the level of disposal income that consumers enjoy. In a slower growth environment and with higher inflation, non- essential high-cost items such as cars could face some pressure. Banks Banks are mirrors of the underlying economy. We believe none of the Nil Huaxia Bank (Lucy Feng) Chinese banks could survive well in a severe economic downturn. Furthermore, players with weak fundamentals, poor risk management, and less prudent lending procedures will suffer more. Conglomerates Because of their business diversification, the earnings of Hutchison Shanghai Industrial (Benjamin Lo) conglomerates have a higher degree of defensiveness than many Whampoa other single-industry-focused companies. All conglomerates are also cash-rich and some are industry leaders in their core businesses. We, therefore, maintain an overall positive stance on conglomerates under a stagflation scenario. Consumer China retail softlines and department stores/broadlines are more Parkson People’s Food (Phoebe Wong, resilient in the current high inflationary cycle, while F&B might not fare KT&G Lotte Shopping Hong Taik as well because of their high exposure to soft commodities and thin Chung) margins, in our view. In the Korean retail space, we favor discount stores to department stores. Among Korean consumer staple names, we expect top-tier players that can prove strong market leadership and experience steady consumer demand to generate stable earnings. Info Tech Most IT manufacturers are likely to employ a low pricing policy to spur Samsung Hon Hai (James Kim) demand and sustain fab utilization rates. However, we believe that a Electronics rapid rise in material costs and labor expenses will make it very difficult for IT companies to post meaningful profits. With the exception of a few segments, we believe there will be few winners among IT manufacturers when faced withising inflation and slowing growth. Media/Internet The media/Internet sector in Asia-Pacific will weather the stagflation Focus Media Fairfax Media (Paul Wuh) storm better than many other industrial sectors. We focus on media companies that: (1) have a subscription model that is unlikely to face lost revenues in an economic downturn and can raise prices if needed to counter inflation (such as, cable TV and satellite TV companies); (2) have relatively low operating costs and are able to easily scale their businesses to meet changing business environments (such as Internet gaming and e-commerce); (3) are relatively low cost to advertisers and are success-based (such as Internet portal/search companies). Metal and We believe inflation-driven upstream sectors (i.e., coal) should remain China Shenhua Chalco Mining (Oliver the winners given their strong pricing power, while downstream sectors Du) with relatively weak pricing power, such as aluminum and copper smelters, would be the losers. Oil & Gas We expect the physical oil demand to decline. In the near term, we Sinopec Honam (Cheng Khoo) expect the tight supply situation to continue, which could further boost oil prices. However, by the end of 2008 and especially in 2009, as new capacities come into the market, we believe oil prices are likely to decline. Property (Paul Housing and low-end retail, we believe, should prove the most resilient SHKP HK Land Louie, Min as they cover basic needs; office and high end-retail are likely to fare Chow Sai) the worst. At the country level, performance should be tied to existing supply levels. Hong Kong with the lowest expected housing supply for the next four years should prove the most defensive, in our view. Telecom In our opinion, the telecom services sector will do much better than Chunghwa Bharti (Paul Wuh) other industries in a period of stagflation. However, revenue growth for Telecom telecom operators in developing markets like China, India, and SE Asia will be affected more than those in developed markets. Transportation We believe the shipping sector would be a likely loser since demand is Nil Evergreen (Andrew Lee) driven by global economies and shipping lines bear higher costs because carriers struggle to pass on higher costs to customers. Further, given that shipping is a highly fragmented industry, carriers are mainly price takers. Utilities and In a stagflation environment, defensive and regulated utilities that are HK Electric KEPCO Renewable cash rich, have strong cash flow, and have fixed returns tied to a Energy (Ivan regulated asset base tend to outperform, in our view. Lee) May 2008 5
  • 6. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research Table of Contents Executive Summary 3 Country Summary 4 Sector Summary 5 Regional Strategy 9 Effects on equities from rising inflation and slower growth.................................................9 Country Analysis 15 Australia’s Brief Stagflation 16 Tight policies limit local stagflation risk ............................................................................16 China Stagflation Scenario 20 Can the government tame rising inflation and rescue slowing growth? .....................................20 HK Stagflation Scenario 31 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................31 India and Stagflation 36 Tight policies limit local stagflation risk ............................................................................36 Korea Stagflation Scenario 39 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................39 Taiwan Stagflation Scenario 45 Can politics offset rising inflation and slower growth? ............................................................45 Sector Analysis 53 Auto and Auto Parts 54 Effects of rising inflation and falling growth .....................................................................54 Banks 57 China Banks .......................................................................................................................57 India Banks.........................................................................................................................59 Taiwan Banks .....................................................................................................................61 Cement 62 India Cement ......................................................................................................................62 Conglomerates 64 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................64 Consumer 67 India Consumer ..................................................................................................................67 China/Hong Kong Consumer .............................................................................................69 Korean Consumer...............................................................................................................71 May 2008 6
  • 7. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research Electrical Equipment 73 India Electrical Equipment .................................................................................................73 IT Industry 75 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................75 Metal & Mining (China) 78 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................78 Materials (Taiwan) 80 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................80 Media/Internet 81 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................81 Oil and Gas 84 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................84 Oil Refining 87 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................87 Petrochemicals 89 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth .....................................................................89 Pharmaceuticals 91 India Pharmaceuticals.........................................................................................................91 Property 92 Reverting to basic needs for shelter....................................................................................92 India Real Estate.................................................................................................................98 Taiwan Property ...............................................................................................................100 Semiconductors – Foundry & SATS 101 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................101 Semiconductors – Memory 102 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................102 Technology – Hardware 104 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................104 Technology – Display 105 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................105 Technology – IC Design 107 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................107 Telecommunications Services 108 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................108 May 2008 7
  • 8. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research Transportation – Shipping 112 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................112 Utilities/Power/Renewable Energy 117 Effects of rising inflation and slower growth ...................................................................117 Valuation Methodologies 123 Asia Research Roster 138 Coverage Universe 140 Companies under Coverage in Asia, by Country (as of May 14, 2008) ...........................140 Companies under Coverage in Asia, by Sector (as of May 14, 2008)..............................148 May 2008 8
  • 9. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research REGIONAL STRATEGY Effects on equities from rising inflation and slower Paul Schulte growth LBAL, Hong Kong Tel: (852) 2252 -1409 paul.schulte@lehman.com INTRODUCTION: LOWER GROWTH AND HIGHER INFLATION Justin Lau The world is slowly moving away from a systemic meltdown and toward some LBAL, Hong Kong normalcy. Much of this has been accomplished through the intermediation of central Tel: +852 2252 1420 banks. The introduction of a facility on March 20 to lend directly to investment banks for justin.lau@lehman.com the first time in the history of the Federal Reserve helped greatly in calming markets. These moves by the Fed – and more recently by the Bank of England – have been made Chris Leung, CFA in conjunction with a sharp reduction in interest rates. There have been three LBAL, Hong Kong consequences of this activity. Tel: +852 2252 6183 1. Rising liquidity chris.w.leung@lehman.com There has been a sharp and sudden increase in risk appetite and a sharp rise in liquidity. As risky or worthless assets are taken out of the market by central bank intervention, Shubhankar Das those assets most at risk often go up the most. So, values of risky assets may go up in LBAL, Hong Kong price. Government bonds would go down in price as investors sell risk-free government Tel: +852 2252 1424 bonds and dive back into risky bonds. shubhankar.das@lehman.com 2. Lower growth The above scenario should be great for growth. It makes growth go down less. But the problem is that much of this liquidity being created is not finding its way back to asset creation. It is being bottled up on the balance sheet of banks which are themselves dealing with bad asset liquidation and capital constraints. They are being forced to shed assets from their balance sheet and write off losses against capital. They are being forced to find alternative sources of liabilities (deposits). This is because banks must bring down excessively high loan/deposit ratios at the same time that they are writing off bad assets. So, the asset base must shrink even while liquidity is replenishing the system. We present below the base case set forth by our economics team together with the worst case scenario provided by the strategy team. Figure 1: Slower growth/rising inflation – base case and worst case scenarios GDP (% y-o-y) CPI (%y-o-y) Base Case Worst Case Scenario Base Case Worst Case Scenario Lehman Economics Team Lehman Stategy Team Lehman Economics Team Lehman Stategy Team 2008 2009 2008 2009 2008 2009 2008 2009 US 1.2 0.6 -0.9 -0.4 na na na na Australia 2.5 2.0 1.1 0.9 3.1 2.2 3.1 3.2 China 9.8 8.0 6.1 5.9 5.5 2.8 6.7 6.9 Hong Kong 4.3 6.2 0.3 0.2 5.0 5.5 5.0 5.5 India 7.5 8.5 5.1 4.6 6.9 4.7 6.9 7.1 Indonesia 5.2 7.0 2.7 2.3 10.0 8.0 9.0 9.5 Malaysia 5.0 6.2 2.4 2.2 3.5 4.5 3.9 4.5 Philippines 5.0 7.0 2.6 2.4 7.8 5.5 8.5 8.9 Singapore 4.2 7.0 2.4 2.1 6.0 4.8 6.0 6.1 South Korea 4.1 5.2 2.1 2.0 4.5 3.5 4.1 4.3 Taiwan 3.9 5.7 2.9 2.6 3.8 3.5 3.8 3.9 Thailand 4.2 6.7 2.6 2.5 6.5 4.5 6.0 6.2 Asia ex-Japan 7.3 7.3 4.1 3.8 5.7 3.8 5.7 5.9 Source Lehman Brothers research May 2008 9
  • 10. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research 3. Higher inflation All this liquidity is not creating more assets. It is supporting the shrinking of assets in an attempt to keep a balance sheet cleansing event from turning into a depression. The cost we are paying for this dynamic is excessive liquidity with low growth. Inflation’s classic definition is too much money chasing too few assets. This is as classic an inflationary phenomenon as it gets. So, liquidity, like lava bursting from a volcano, will roll down the mountain, seeking a path of least resistance to those areas where it is needed most: in the shortages. The greatest shortage of liquidity in the world is in agriculture. The food inflation problem has been brewing since 2004, but was rising right in the midst of the credit crisis. So, this liquidity is creating inflation in an area which had chronic shortages already. This food inflation has spread quickly and has created generally high inflation all over Asia. Oil is part of this as well. Oil shortages are receiving the liquidity as well. We think these price rises are a symptom of inflation, not the other way around. EFFECT ON EBIT: SHRINKING MARGINS? With rising costs in food and energy, the CPIs of many Asian countries are rising quickly. This is because the CPI has a very large proportion of food and energy in the baskets relative to the West. In many cases, it is 30-50%. So, price changes are accelerating quickly. In addition, many governments are responding to sharp increases in food, fertilizers, and oil with price caps and/or subsidies. We believe these policy responses are unhelpful and lead to more inflation. This is because price caps, for instance, lead consumers to consume more, given the perception that prices are unusually low. This also leads to a cutback in production given the perception that producers are not being given a fair price for the goods they sell. So, everyone loses. There are three effects on margins. In the meantime, high fertilizer costs spill into higher food prices. Higher oil spills into high coal prices. The chain reaction goes on. 1. Rising cost of labor As food and energy prices increase, the employees at corporates demand higher wages given that lifestyle costs are rising sharply. So, SG&A expenses rise. We are seeing this all across Asia, as wage growth begins to rise in earnest. Wage rises are a response to rising prices. In many parts of Asia, inflation is rising to multi-decade highs. Figure 2: Asia CPI % y-o-y Headline CPI 8 Core CPI 6 4 2 0 Jan-96 Jan-98 Jan-00 Jan-02 Jan-04 Jan-06 Jan-08 Source: Lehman Brothers research May 2008 10
  • 11. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research 2. Rising cost of goods The costs associated with production given rising energy costs are felt throughout the industrial food chain. Cost of energy also goes up dramatically. So, input costs rise. Growth, while falling, is still high in many parts of Asia. As a result, an increasing number of companies have expressed confidence for the first time in many years to pass through price increases to end users. Steel producers are passing prices through to buyers of steel. This is best seen in the rise of the Producer Price Index. Figure 3: Japan’s domestic corporate goods prices % y-o-y 5 4 3 2 1 0 -1 -2 -3 -4 Jan-90 Jan-94 Jan-98 Jan-02 Jan-06 Source: CEIC, Lehman Brothers research 3. Rising cost of money In the midst of a waning credit crisis, the sharp rise in liquidity is not reaching into the cost of money. The cost of money has actually risen. This is because banks are trying to recapitalize and at the same time shed bad assets. Concentrating on lending is the last thing on their minds. So, while the cost of money is now down to 2% in the US, for instance, the cost of a loan has barely budged. This also reaches into the world of working capital. Working capital is also more expensive although rates are now a lot lower. So, financing costs are higher and new money is harder to come by. There will, of course, be exceptions. For example, we think price makers (monopolies, plantations, oil producers) will make a windfall here. The middle man loses. Lower-end retail wins. Banks which are healthy win big. Unhealthy banks lose altitude and are in danger of crashing. Those banks which try to pick up cheap assets too early can get dragged down. EFFECT ON CASH FLOW: EFFECT ON CAPEX GIVEN FALLING CASH FLOWS AND CAPITAL SHORTAGE? In an environment of restrained lending, rising costs, and increasing wages, corporates may face three hurdles. 1. Working capital is working harder and may turn negative Inflation drives up the cost of doing business. Some corporates will be able to pass on these costs. Others will not. Those with less pricing power or those which sell low- margin goods or middlemen are most at risk for a cash squeeze. (Our stagflation portfolio favours companies that are most decidedly out of this area). Rising working capital tends to be associated with an aversion to corporate activity or high cash levels that have yet to be put to work. On the liabilities side, slowing payments (short-term liabilities rising faster than short-term assets) in a world of liquidity but with hesitant banks is not at all surprising to us. May 2008 11
  • 12. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research 2. Rising cost of funds for capex One of our preferences in our portfolios has been for companies with cash flow sufficient to cover capex. In a world of hesitant banks, the cost of finishing a project will very likely rise. The assumptions for viability in projects included interest costs which were a lot lower a year ago. We estimate that interest costs are up, on average, from Libor +150 to Libor +300 to 500. This is a significant increase in interest expense and eats into cash flow. 3. Cutbacks in capex or cancellation of projects The dangerous part of a global slowdown is that companies which are in the middle of major expansion are in danger of not finishing a very expensive project. The anticipation of completion is the source of earnings. In the event of cessation of funding in a half- finished project, the problems are quite serious. With a great deal of money spent, the value of the asset is essentially still zero. Companies in this sort of condition are either forced to sell an impaired asset or are forced into bankruptcy proceedings. WHAT HAPPENED IN THE 1970S? In the early 1970s, the US was in the middle of an unwinnable and increasingly expensive war. It was funding large budget deficits. It was facing high commodity prices. The US – and other countries – imposed price controls to deal with inflation. If this sounds familiar, it is because it is familiar. Many investors agree that analogies to the 1970s are appropriate. As Mark Twain, however, said, “History does not repeat itself. It rhymes.” History will likely play itself out differently, but with many similarities. There are three similarities we see. 1. Inflation hit suddenly and hard Inflation reared its head in a small way from the early 1970s and then hit all of a sudden. When it did, it hit hard and took a long time to go away. Interest rates in 1980 were still 21%. Government bond yields peaked at 14%. Gold, oil, agricultural commodities, and general prices soared. These conditions are eerily similar. 2. Growth slowed While nominal growth was quite high given that inflation was in the high single digits, real growth slowed dramatically. Wages can grow with inflation, but pretty soon, they can no longer keep up. As a result, real wages fall and spending drops. Interest rates would soar and the cost of borrowing becomes prohibitive. Tax revenues from slowing economic activity would have to rise and deficits rise. Taxes would rise more. Real take- home income then falls. A vicious cycle is born. 3. Inflation expectations rose The hard part of price increases is that they are born of expectations. As people expect prices to rise, prices rise. We have been living in a world for many years where we have expected prices to go down. So, we delay expenditure and wait for prices to fall further. As inflation grabs hold, we come to expect prices to rise and we rush our purchases. We grab onto those types of investments which are seen as an inflation hedge. We eschew fiat money. We seek out commodities, land, precious metals, and rare jewels. A plethora of books have been written on this subject. Suffice to say that it takes much data (and much time) for people to change their expectations on higher prices once higher prices begin their gallop. May 2008 12
  • 13. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research HOW CAN THE GOVERNMENT HELP EASE THE PAIN? Whether we like it or not, governments in the world are now deciding the price of assets as much as investors are. The decision of the Federal Reserve in March to lend to investment banks essentially put a ceiling on the price of debt for these banks. We think governments can do three things to help. 1. Price controls and subsidies We are facing a shortage of oil, a shortage of coal, and a shortage of food. Governments can help by accelerating the development of alternative energy. They can introduce conservation programs in terms of emissions regulation. They can place price caps on retail prices or they can introduce subsidy programs which compensate producers and make the consumer feel less pain at the cash register. While many insist that subsidies and price controls are destructive in the longer term, they quell social unrest and prevent riots. The problem is that they almost guarantee inflation as they incentivize consumers to consume more and cause producers to produce less. 2. Crash investment programs One of the results of high prices is the need for governments to pay for investment programs for products which are price inelastic. Goods with inelastic prices must be bought independent of price (basic necessities and staples). So, governments have a responsibility to rush the production of these goods to people and so need to step in and jump start programs such as oil exploration, cattle production, and farming. 3. Tax and regulatory relief Governments are famous for changing rules mid-stream. In an environment of rising costs, governments can act to reduce costs by turning a blind eye to restrictive immigration policy. In an environment of bad debt and economic stagnation, they may turn a blind eye to strict marking to market of that bad debt. They may allow banks to alter classification. In a coal shortage, some countries may reduce strict safety standards. In an oil shortage, countries may bend rules on oil drilling in wildlife preserves. Governments can reduce taxes on corporates which are large employers in a period of high unemployment. In other words, governments change valuations of companies and, indeed, cash-flows in the blink of an eye with market-friendly policies which can improve profitability. Conversely, governments which want to quell civil unrest may stick it to some corporates which make staples such as food and gasoline. Price controls can destroy shareholder value in the blink of an eye. We believe we are living in a world of unprecedented intervention by governments. This is an added risk for markets. Figure 4: Stagflation portfolio EV/ 3 Mth Ave P/E P/B Div Yield EBITDA Lehman Current Mkt Cap Liquidity ROE Net Debt/ Altman Company Ticker Rating Price US$mn (US$mn) FY08E Assets Z-Score FY08E FY08E FY08E FY08E Industry Sector Cheung Kong Infra 1038 HK Utilities 1-OW 31.8 9,248 9.0 13 -2% 5.3 55.6 13.9 1.8 3.8 Hong Kong Electric 6 HK Utilities 1-OW 45.2 12,724 27.5 15 2% 3.5 9.4 12.8 1.9 4.4 China Mobile 941 HK Telecom 1-OW 132.5 379,182 477.7 28 -27% 10.1 10.8 20.6 5.4 2.1 Sun Hung Kai 16 HK Property 1-OW 138.0 45,174 178.8 6 10% NA 27.0 26.3 1.7 1.8 CNOOC 883 HK Oil & Gas E&P 2-EW 13.9 94,145 237.9 28 -16% 10.1 9.7 14.3 3.7 2.6 Shenhua 1088 HK Energy 1-OW 35.0 14,379 153.4 20 3% 1.9 2.0 20.4 4.0 1.7 Rio Tinto RIO AU Mining 0-NR 145.3 64,535 197.2 40 44% 1.4 4.8 15.7 4.9 1.2 IOI IOI MK Palm Oil 0-NR 7.1 13,801 31.3 26 7% 7.5 14.7 21.6 5.0 2.4 EGCO EGCO TB Utilities 2-EW 95.5 1,547 1.8 18 8% 3.4 8.8 6.4 1.1 5.7 HK and Shanghai Hotels 45 HK Hotels 1-OW 13.5 2,544 1.8 5 5% 2.9 12.0 20.1 0.9 1.5 Ranbaxy RBXY IS Pharmaceuticals 1-OW 466.3 4,355 4.6 24 44% 3.2 18.0 24.7 5.7 2.0 KT&G 033780 KS Consumer 1-OW 82500.0 11,019 31.2 23 -3% 11.3 10.7 14.8 3.3 NA Melco 200 HK Equit Conglomerates 0-NR 11.6 1,891 7.5 4 11% 5.6 82.7 43.5 1.4 0.1 Average 50,350 104.6 27 6% 8.6 11.9 19.3 4.6 2.1 Note: Prices as of May 7, 2008 Source: IBES, Worldscope, Lehman Brothers estimates May 2008 13
  • 14. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research This page intentionally left blank May 2008 14
  • 15. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research COUNTRY ANALYSIS May 2008 15
  • 16. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research AUSTRALIA’S BRIEF STAGFLATION Tight policies limit local stagflation risk David Langford LBAUL, Sydney Tel:+612 8062 8440 HOW WOULD STAGFLATION IMPACT AUSTRALIA? david.langford@lehman.com Lehman Brothers Asia is exploring the risks to Asia Pacific markets in the scenario of falling global growth, resulting in slower Asian growth, but in the face of rising input Stephen Roberts costs. In our view, Australia could witness a brief period of stagflation, where inflation is LBAUL, Sydney high and relatively sticky and economic growth is weakening. However, we believe a Tel:+612 8062 8431 lengthy period of stagflation is unlikely because of the Reserve Bank of Australia’s stephen.roberts@lehman.com (RBA) commitment to deliver sufficiently tight monetary conditions to ensure that domestic spending growth and inflation fall. Australia Research Team Unlike many of its Asian neighbors and major trading partners, Australia benefits from a Tel:+612 8062 8000 de-regulated financial system. The characteristics of this system include a freely floating exchange rate and an independent central or reserve bank. The RBA is free to use its cash interest rate to tighten or loosen monetary conditions as it deems necessary. The RBA has a formal 2-3% inflation target that it has agreed (with the Federal Treasurer) to achieve over the course of the economic cycle. Thus, despite the relatively greater acceleration of inflation in most Asian economies when compared with Australia over the past 12 months, the RBA stands almost alone in lifting its cash rate aggressively and allowing its currency to appreciate freely to dampen rising inflation. We consider that Australia is different from Asia in the manner in which policy has responded to rising inflation. In our view, while a consequence of comparatively tighter Australian monetary conditions will be to deliver the “stag” part of stagflation, we expect the “flation” part to recede. The rise of stagflation among Australia’s major Asian trading partners represents a material risk for many Australian companies, in our view. Asia receives around 70% of Australian exports and almost all of Australia’s exports of coal and metal ores. Weakening Asian growth, as a consequence of trying to contain high inflation, could dampen raw material prices significantly, in our view. We believe that attempts to calibrate Australian policy settings at a time when Asian growth may turn in an unpredictable fashion, runs the risk of double trouble for Australian economic growth prospects. Domestic spending is weakening owing to tight monetary policies. We consider that this impact may be further reinforced by an erratic pull-back in Asian demand and commodity prices. May 2008 16
  • 17. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research WINNERS AND LOSERS Figure 5: Winners and losers (Australia) Winners Ticker Price TP Rating Comments • Telstra’s large infrastructure/sunk cost base limits exposure Telstra TLS.AX A$4.52 A$5.40 1-OW to margin squeeze from a rising cost base, in our view. Telecommunications • Upgraded IT/customer care systems are likely to reduce its exposure to increasing labor costs. • Telstra’s products are believed to be attractive substitutes for businesses and consumers when cutting costs (e.g. phone services/video conf replaces travel) • Inflation-sensitive labor represents ~14% of Austar’s FY08E Austar AUN.AX A$1.35 A$1.65 1-OW total cost base. Programming costs (~48% of Austar’s Subscription Television FY08E total costs) are subject to long-term contracts, we Services believe. We expect the outcome of these factors to be margin strength. • We consider subscription TV services to be price inelastic and a cheap entertainment alternative for cost-conscious consumers. • Austar’s set-top box costs (capex) are subject to declining prices, driven by ongoing technology improvements. • Waste management is an essential/non-discretionary Transpacific TPI.AX A$8.35 A$12.50 1-OW service, we believe. Waste Management Services • We understand that long-term customer contracts (~35% of FY08E revenues) include CPI adjustment clauses. We expect this structure to provide Transpacific a level of immunity from margin squeeze. • PrimAg owns Australian agricultural land and produces soft PrimeAg Australia PAG.AX A$1.99 A$2.25 1-OW commodities. Agricultural Commodities • We expect the company to be a significant beneficiary of food price inflation. Losers Ticker Price TP Rating Comments • Project cost inflation already represents a difficulty for future WorleyParsons WOR.AX A$39.50 $40.00 2-EW growth. Cost pressures may intensify particularly in labor- and Hydrocarbon Engineering commodity-based materials categories. Services • Around 85%+ of Bluescope’s EBIT is derived from sales of Bluescope Steel BSL.AX A$10.61 A$9.35* 3-UW commodity-grade flat steel products at international Flat Steel Products benchmark prices. • Lower Asian growth may result in reduced steel demand (Asia has been a key driver of global steel demand) and therefore, lower international steel prices. • Bluescope Steel’s earnings are highly leveraged to falling international steel prices. • Print advertising and circulation represents ~85% of Fairfax’s Fairfax Media FXJ.AX A$3.34 A$3.80** 2-EW FY08E revenue base. We expect a stagflationary environment to Newspaper and Online weaken ad growth and accelerate the secular trend to cheaper Publisher online alternatives. • Labor costs comprise ~41% of Fairfax’s FY08E total cost base. Accordingly, labor-intensive content requirements and the shift of advertising online are likely to result in margin squeeze, we believe. May 2008 17
  • 18. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research • Babcock & Brown BNB.AX A$15.38 A$16.20 2-EW Infrastructure investments employ significant gearing, which creates earnings and cash flow risk in a high inflation/interest Brokers and Asset Managers rate environment, we believe. • We expect principal trading gains to be nominally supported by inflation. But the after-tax real gain will be much lower, we believe, because the tax system does not distinguish between real and nominal gains. • Macquarie Group MQG.AX A$60.75 A$62.80*** 2-EW Infrastructure investments employ significant gearing, which creates earnings and cash flow risk in a high inflation/interest Brokers and Asset Managers rate environment, we believe. • We expect principal trading gains to be nominally supported by inflation. But the after tax real gain will, we believe, be much lower because the tax system does not distinguish between real and nominal gains. Source: Lehman Brothers research. Prices as of May 7, 2008. * The 12-month target price for Fairfax Media was cut to A$3.80 (from A$4.30) on 14 May 2008. ** The 12-month target price for Bluescope Steel was revised to A$9.35 (from A$9.25) on 13 May 2008. *** The 12-month target price for Macquarie Group was revised to A$62.80 (from A$59.20) on 15 May 2008 DOWNSIZING THE ENGINE ROOM? Investment spending, in all forms, has been one of the strongest growing segments of the Australian economy. We believe that strong growth has taken place across the spectrum, from public sector infrastructure spending to business investment spending. In 2007, the Australian economy grew 3.9% in real terms, but investment spending was up 8.7%. We believe that the combination of (1) Asian stagflation resulting in weakening commodity demand; and (2) tight domestic monetary policy aimed at softening domestic spending is likely to result in jaundiced growth in investment spending. Apart, from the negative short-term impact on economic growth, Australia’s longer-term potential growth rate is also likely to suffer, in our view. Current Australian Federal Treasury estimates put the country’s long-term potential growth rate at around 3.5% per annum. However, we estimate that the long-term growth rate could fall to less than 3% per annum on a material reduction in the pace of growth in investment spending. WHAT HAPPENED IN THE 1970S? In our view, Australia’s experience of stagflation in the past was caused by inappropriate and ineffective monetary and fiscal responses to the oil price shock of the early 1970s. There are many reasons for why we believe the current run-up in key commodity prices will not trigger a re-run of the 1970s. First, we believe that it is more difficult for a commodity price shock to trigger second-round inflation effects in wage claims that help to develop an upward inflationary spiral. In the 1970s, Australia had near-automatic wage indexation, which meant that the latest quarterly rise in inflation fed almost directly into higher wages – i.e., four wage increases a year after each CPI reading. Second, monetary policy was largely ineffective in the 1970s because of bank lending, deposit and interest controls, and a fixed exchange rate regime. Third, the exchange rate could only help to contain inflation periodically – i.e., on occasions when the dollar was formally re-valued. Finally, fiscal policy was very loose, notwithstanding strong supply- side pressures on inflation from higher commodity prices. HOW CAN THE GOVERNMENT HELP EASE THE PAIN? The government can only ease the pain by ensuring that the period of stagflation is as brief as possible. Leaving the central bank to deal with inflation and providing it with the independence and policy armory to do the job is a good start, in our view. We also May 2008 18
  • 19. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research believe that prudent fiscal policy (Federal Budget surpluses at or above 1% of GDP) should contain domestic inflationary pressures. CONCLUSION We consider that Asian stagflation represents a material risk to the Australian economy and corporate earnings growth. However, we believe that Australian institutional processes and flexible yet aggressive policy settings are likely to soften inflationary impacts. In our view, the demand side of the stagflation equation may prove to be the toughest issue for Australian policy makers. As a result, we believe that more attractive investment exposures are likely to be provided by those companies which enjoy: (1) limited exposure to input cost inflation (e.g., materials and labor); and (2) product sets with a high degree of substitutability for higher priced products in a cost-conscious environment. May 2008 19
  • 20. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research CHINA STAGFLATION SCENARIO Can the government tame rising inflation and rescue Cheng Khoo slowing growth? LBAL, Hong Kong Tel: +852 2252 6180 cheng.khoo@lehman.com HOW WOULD STAGFLATION IMPACT CHINA? Paul Schulte During a high inflationary period that coupled with slowing global and domestic LBAL, Hong Kong economic growth, we think Chinese companies and the stock market would not be Tel: +852 2252 1409 shielded from a downturn. The Chinese government is in a difficult position. It seems the paul.schulte@lehman.com most logical course of action is to allow the currency to appreciate. In doing so, it: (1) imports deflationary pressures; (2) reduces trade surplus; and (3) reduces the enormous reserves. In essence, importing deflationary pressures and reducing inflationary domestic China Research Team liquidity is just about the only thing China can do, in our view. Interest rates could be raised further, but we believe that would be using the wrong tool. In our view, China’s problems are due to insufficient upstream raw material supply and an excess capacity in selected downstream manufacturing industries, in our view. Ironically, we have to ask whether there has been sufficient investment in China. With fixed capital investment running at 25% per year, we also expect nominal growth at about 19%–20%. Is one way out of the supply-driven inflationary burst an even higher level of capital investment, especially in water and agriculture? The government recently increased its investment in agriculture by 30%, to around US$43 billion. It is also running up large subsidy bills as it keeps consumers from feeling the full brunt of international price increases of most commodities. Our favourite theme for the next few years is agricultural investment. China needs to revolutionize its agricultural sector, including its water supply. When it targets to achieve something, its policies tends to succeed. This, we believe, represents the most promising sector for investors over the coming years. Biofuels, genetically modified (GM) seeds, irrigation, and new labor in rural areas are vital for China to get to the next level. Earnings and margins outlook. We are already seeing the effects on margins in many forms. (1) Many exporters’ margins are eroded by the appreciating renminbi. Other companies are under severe pressure due to price caps on products. The renminbi has appreciated by more than 9% against the dollar in the past few months, eliminating any profits for low-margin businesses. (2) These price caps – actually, for most products in the HSCEI – decimate margins as international prices rise. Consider the case of the biggest oil refining company Sinopec – were it not for a subsidized check, many of them would have already been in the red in 1Q08. Ironically, these price caps themselves are inflationary as they discourage future expansion in plant and equipment, and, therefore, are likely to produce lower installed capacity over time. This is a concern for us. (3) The normal margin pressure comes from input prices going up while wages are also rising. So, we can see many companies with rising land costs, rising energy costs, rising labor costs, and rising capital costs. Market performance. In January, we downgraded China from an overweight because we saw inflationary pressures spilling out all over. We also saw China’s inflation-free growth beginning to show wear and tear. The costs of land, labor, and capital are all moving up dramatically. This is a phenomenon that we strongly believe is a reflection of shortages and, hence, we are sceptical about the issue of overcapacity. So, China is seeing its liquidity seep out of the economy as the government becomes reinvigorated by the need to control inflation. We also think there is a need for a vast “Green Revolution” or “New Deal” to deal with chronic food shortages and water shortages, among others. This necessary, but very expensive, bonanza of spending is, in itself, also inflationary. Hence, we expect a pause in growth as large capital investments are implemented, which do not yield strong results. May 2008 20
  • 21. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research We would consider upgrading China if we saw signs of inflation peaking. However, we do not see that any time soon. Our sector and company selections follow. WINNERS AND LOSERS Figure 6: Winners and losers (China) Winners Ticker Price Target price Rating Comments • COSL 2883.HK HK$15.56 HK$21.0 1-OW Low earnings risk • China Shenhua 1088.HK HK$34.95 HK$57.0 1-OW Extremely tight supply and asset injections • Price controls a risk • Hutchison Whampoa 0013.HK HK$78.00 HK$93.8 1-OW Cash rich; industry leader; diversified Losers – Company Ticker Price Target price Rating Comments • Guangzhou R&F 2777.HK HK$21.00 HK$31.04 2-EW High gearing of 265%. • A-share listing not assured in current unfriendly environment. • Minsheng Bank 600016.SS RMB8.22 RMB9.85 2-EW Relatively weaker management; insufficient risk management during a downturn. • CSCL 2866.HK HK$3.49 HK$2.9 3-UW Leveraged to changes in inflation and costs Prices as of May 7, 2008 Source: Lehman Brothers estimates LOWER GDP GROWTH WITH HIGHER INFLATION Lehman Brothers’ China economist Mingchun Sun currently forecasts single-digit GDP growth of 9.8% in 2008 for China, which indicates a decline from a growth rate of 11.6% in 2006 and 11.9% in 2007. Expecting deteriorating conditions exacerbated by overinvestment, which is resulting in overcapacity situation in many sectors, he recently downgraded the 2009 GDP forecast from 8.5% to 8%. In terms of inflation, Sun forecasts a full-year 2008 CPI to reach 5.5%, up from 4.8% in 2007, but much lower than the 1Q08’s level of 8%, indicating that 2H08 inflation will likely ease from a high base effect in 2H07. The easing trend then continues into 2009 with a FY09E CPI of 2.8%. Figure 7: China real GDP growth vs CPI China Real GDP Growth vs CPI (YoY % Change) 16 30 14 25 Real GDP growth 12 CPI (RHS) 20 10 15 8 10 6 5 4 0 2 0 -5 1985 1988 1991 1994 1997 2000 2003 2006 2009E Source: CEIC, Lehman Brothers estimates May 2008 21
  • 22. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research However, in this report, the equity strategy team explores the impact of equities in light of a more negative scenario of a GDP growth rate of only 6.1% in 2008 and 5.9% in 2009 and escalating inflationary environment with a CPI of 6.7% in 2008 and rising further to 6.9% in 2009. By applying higher inflation assumptions, we are exploring the negative impact of real GDP growth. We analyze the risks to revenue growth and profit margins in combination with higher input cost in the various sectors. IMPACT ON REVENUE The market is currently debating whether a slowdown in the US/developed economies would impact the Asian and Chinese economies. Irrespective of the global economic slowdown, Chinese exporters have already started to feel the pinch of rising costs and competitive pressures. These include an appreciating currency, reduced VAT export rebates (and in some cases an increase in export tariffs), removal of favourable policies for processing trade; increasing cost pressure from rising prices of land, labour, energy and raw materials; and tighter standard on product quality, labour conditions, and environmental protection. In terms of trend, export growth has already slowed, especially in volume terms. As global demand weakens, export growth is very likely to be hit further. We think domestic consumption is unlikely to be strong enough to offset weakness in exports. Furthermore, as export growth slows, we expect income growth to decline while high inflation stands to erode the purchasing power of households and be a drag on real spending. During a period of slowing GDP growth, demand normally enters a downward trend, and excess capacity becomes a problem as operating rates decline. This is especially true in sectors that are experiencing an overcapacity situation. Producers have to lower prices in light of the heightened competition. With the global economy expected to slowdown considerably more in 2H08, we expect exports to decline in 2H08, intensifying through 2009. About one quarter of China’s total industrial production is exported, even though some sectors are more dependent on exports than others, such as mobile phones and color TVs. EFFECT ON EBIT: MARGIN SHRINKAGE? As external demand weakens, we think inventories are likely to pile up as soon as in 3Q08, after the Olympics. A strong inventory is being built up in some areas such as fuel and consumer products in anticipation of high demand during the Olympics. We believe firms will probably compete on price despite rising cost, which will likely depress margins. Profit margins are still trending around their highest levels since 1999, but seem to have reached a plateau. The number of loss-making enterprises is currently rising at 8.5%, up from 0.3% in 2007. Figure 8: China net profit margin China Net Profit Margin (%) 12 10 8 6 4 2 0 1996 1997 1998 1999 2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 Source: Worldscope, Lehman Brothers research May 2008 22
  • 23. Lehman Brothers | Equity Research With significantly lower economic growth and a rising cost base, we expect corporate earnings to come under pressure. According to consensus (IBES) estimates for Chinese corporations, analysts are projecting slowing EPS growth of 17.6% for 2008 and 16.6% for 2009, down from 32% in 2006. However, only four sectors (capital goods, retailing, diversified financials, and insurance) have negative earnings growth projections for 2008, while only one sector (diversified financials) has negative earning growth estimate in 2009(–10%). In our worst-case scenario, we expect potential downside to this set of earnings estimates. Instead of a majority of the sectors showing earnings growth, we expect the reverse to happen especially for those that are export focused and are facing overcapacity. Figure 9: China EPS growth estimates EPS growth (%) 2007 2008E 2009E China 32.3 17.6 16.6 Energy 7.6 18.7 9.6 Materials 4.8 24.9 14.2 Capital goods 38.6 -3.7 22.7 Transportation 155.2 12.7 9.7 Auto & components 38.4 19.2 16.1 Consumer durables 23.2 11.5 20.5 Consumer services 34.9 34.6 25.8 Retailing 52.0 -22.5 23.7 Food bev & tobacco 26.2 24.5 24.2 Household products 42.9 19.0 25.7 Banks 47.0 39.8 19.2 Diversified financials 360.6 -41.7 -10.0 Insurance 103.3 -17.2 17.3 Real estate 53.0 26.0 37.3 Software & services 24.1 17.1 30.7 Technology hardware & equip 61.0 15.5 15.3 Telecom 19.0 25.1 15.7 Utilities 10.0 1.3 18.2 Source: IBES We believe weaker corporate earnings and rising bankruptcies will increase unemployment and undermine the ability of the firms to repay loans. While bank non- performing loans (NPLs) have declined in recent years, they rose slightly in 4Q07. In addition, we are concerned that a credit cycle may kick in, and Chinese banks could face increased new NPL formation, particularly in risky sectors such as property, manufacturing, and exporters. We think that the weakening earnings will likely be reflected in the stock market as P/E ratios climb. Despite falling by about 30% this year, the Shanghai Stock Exchange A- share Index at a P/E of 27.3 is still expensive compared to the other market index P/Es. May 2008 23