This document discusses some of the legal challenges posed by e-commerce, including unfair terms, cybercrime, and jurisdictional issues. It outlines how unfair terms in e-commerce contracts can negatively impact consumers and businesses. Specifically, standard form contracts and clickwrap agreements commonly contain unfair terms. The document also examines how cybercrime threatens e-commerce through data theft, hacking, and other illegal online acts. Finally, it notes the jurisdictional problems that can arise when transactions occur across international borders and the applicable laws are unclear. Overall, the document analyzes several significant legal issues presented by the rise of e-commerce and global digital trade.
Legal Framework For E Commerce In Ecowas AfricaDayo Ogunyemi
Presentation summarizing UN Economic Commission for Africa (UN ECA) sponsored project to develop legal framework for E-Commerce for the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS). Delivered in Ouagadougou, 2006.
1) E-commerce has led to legal issues as business and consumers increasingly conduct transactions online. Security concerns make people reluctant to do online business.
2) Laws are needed to provide predictability for online transactions and protect internet users. The UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Commerce establishes rules for forming legally-valid electronic contracts across jurisdictions.
3) The Model Law aims to validate electronic contracts, define electronic writings and signatures, and support the use of computer evidence in legal proceedings. This framework makes online business transactions more consistent and predictable.
This document summarizes a presentation on electronic commerce regulation in Africa. It discusses how countries can benefit from electronic commerce by assessing their policy and legal frameworks. It provides an overview of global electronic commerce trends and regulations, including models from UNCITRAL, the African Union, SADC, ECOWAS, and various countries. The presentation explores issues around developing enabling environments for e-commerce and regulating areas like electronic transactions, data protection, cybercrime, and intellectual property. It also discusses challenges African countries face in developing appropriate ICT policies and legal frameworks to promote regional economic integration and access to the global digital economy.
The document discusses whether there should be governance for e-commerce in India. It outlines the current regulatory framework covering IT acts, contract acts, consumer protection acts, and data privacy laws. It also reviews regulations in other countries like the European Union, South Korea, and the UK. The document concludes by proposing areas that could be covered under a new e-commerce law in India, including recognizing e-commerce as a business sector, limiting liability for third-party goods, and harmonizing laws around logistical services.
The document discusses the various legal regulations surrounding e-commerce in Europe. It outlines directives set in 2000 that establish harmonized rules for electronic commerce to provide legal certainty for businesses and consumers. It also examines specific legal issues regarding taxation, electronic payments, contracts, liability, intellectual property, consumer protection, privacy, and international private law in the context of online transactions and e-commerce websites. Complying with these regulations is important for any business seeking to sell goods or services online within Europe.
This document discusses electronic commerce (e-commerce), including its definition, history, types, processes, advantages, disadvantages, and laws governing it. Some key points:
- E-commerce involves buying and selling of goods/services over electronic networks like the internet. It facilitates online transactions including marketing, sales, delivery, and payments.
- Early forms of e-commerce included EDI in the 1960s. Amazon was one of the first major online retailers in the 1990s.
- The UNCITRAL Model Law on e-commerce from 1997 provides guidelines to regulate e-commerce and promote uniformity across jurisdictions. The Indian IT Act of 2000 was based on this.
- E-
This document provides an overview of e-commerce legislation in the United Kingdom. It discusses:
1) The key legislation governing business on the internet in the UK, including data protection laws, electronic commerce regulations, consumer protection laws, and advertising codes.
2) The government agencies responsible for regulating different aspects of e-commerce, such as the Information Commissioner's Office for data protection and Ofcom for internet access tariffs.
3) The tests applied by UK courts to determine jurisdiction for internet transactions, including applying existing private international law for disputes involving EU businesses and consumers.
The document summarizes a draft UNCITRAL Model Law on identity management (IdM) and trust services. It was prepared by UNCITRAL Working Group IV to provide uniform treatment of IdM systems and a broad range of trust services. The draft law establishes definitions and rules for IdM processes like identity proofing and authentication. It also covers obligations of IdM and trust service providers, and facilitates cross-border recognition of these services to support digital trade. The draft maintains the structure of the EU eIDAS regulation but raises issues around regulating foundational identity versus enabling trust services.
Legal Framework For E Commerce In Ecowas AfricaDayo Ogunyemi
Presentation summarizing UN Economic Commission for Africa (UN ECA) sponsored project to develop legal framework for E-Commerce for the Economic Community of West African States (ECOWAS). Delivered in Ouagadougou, 2006.
1) E-commerce has led to legal issues as business and consumers increasingly conduct transactions online. Security concerns make people reluctant to do online business.
2) Laws are needed to provide predictability for online transactions and protect internet users. The UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Commerce establishes rules for forming legally-valid electronic contracts across jurisdictions.
3) The Model Law aims to validate electronic contracts, define electronic writings and signatures, and support the use of computer evidence in legal proceedings. This framework makes online business transactions more consistent and predictable.
This document summarizes a presentation on electronic commerce regulation in Africa. It discusses how countries can benefit from electronic commerce by assessing their policy and legal frameworks. It provides an overview of global electronic commerce trends and regulations, including models from UNCITRAL, the African Union, SADC, ECOWAS, and various countries. The presentation explores issues around developing enabling environments for e-commerce and regulating areas like electronic transactions, data protection, cybercrime, and intellectual property. It also discusses challenges African countries face in developing appropriate ICT policies and legal frameworks to promote regional economic integration and access to the global digital economy.
The document discusses whether there should be governance for e-commerce in India. It outlines the current regulatory framework covering IT acts, contract acts, consumer protection acts, and data privacy laws. It also reviews regulations in other countries like the European Union, South Korea, and the UK. The document concludes by proposing areas that could be covered under a new e-commerce law in India, including recognizing e-commerce as a business sector, limiting liability for third-party goods, and harmonizing laws around logistical services.
The document discusses the various legal regulations surrounding e-commerce in Europe. It outlines directives set in 2000 that establish harmonized rules for electronic commerce to provide legal certainty for businesses and consumers. It also examines specific legal issues regarding taxation, electronic payments, contracts, liability, intellectual property, consumer protection, privacy, and international private law in the context of online transactions and e-commerce websites. Complying with these regulations is important for any business seeking to sell goods or services online within Europe.
This document discusses electronic commerce (e-commerce), including its definition, history, types, processes, advantages, disadvantages, and laws governing it. Some key points:
- E-commerce involves buying and selling of goods/services over electronic networks like the internet. It facilitates online transactions including marketing, sales, delivery, and payments.
- Early forms of e-commerce included EDI in the 1960s. Amazon was one of the first major online retailers in the 1990s.
- The UNCITRAL Model Law on e-commerce from 1997 provides guidelines to regulate e-commerce and promote uniformity across jurisdictions. The Indian IT Act of 2000 was based on this.
- E-
This document provides an overview of e-commerce legislation in the United Kingdom. It discusses:
1) The key legislation governing business on the internet in the UK, including data protection laws, electronic commerce regulations, consumer protection laws, and advertising codes.
2) The government agencies responsible for regulating different aspects of e-commerce, such as the Information Commissioner's Office for data protection and Ofcom for internet access tariffs.
3) The tests applied by UK courts to determine jurisdiction for internet transactions, including applying existing private international law for disputes involving EU businesses and consumers.
The document summarizes a draft UNCITRAL Model Law on identity management (IdM) and trust services. It was prepared by UNCITRAL Working Group IV to provide uniform treatment of IdM systems and a broad range of trust services. The draft law establishes definitions and rules for IdM processes like identity proofing and authentication. It also covers obligations of IdM and trust service providers, and facilitates cross-border recognition of these services to support digital trade. The draft maintains the structure of the EU eIDAS regulation but raises issues around regulating foundational identity versus enabling trust services.
ICT and the transformation of the legal profession Oluwaseyi K. Oni
ICT is transforming the legal profession in several ways:
1. Technology is being leveraged to deliver legal services more efficiently through tools like video conferencing, online legal communities, e-libraries and case management systems.
2. The rise of e-commerce requires new approaches to legal documentation and dispute resolution, like online dispute resolution and smart contracts on blockchain.
3. Certain routine legal tasks like company formation and basic legal research may become automated, but complex legal work requiring judgment and nuance will still need human lawyers.
The future legal profession is uncertain but will likely see subscription pricing models, an emphasis on technology skills, and changing roles for legal professionals and tools.
Industrial revolution and notions of technology .pptxVishweshSingh16
The document discusses the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law's (UNCITRAL) Model Law on Electronic Commerce (MLEC) from 1996. The MLEC aims to facilitate electronic commerce by establishing principles of non-discrimination of electronic documents, technological neutrality, and functional equivalence of electronic and paper documents. It sets rules for electronic contracting, digital signatures, and attribution of electronic messages. The MLEC has been influential as many states have based domestic e-commerce laws on it, helping unify international standards in the area. It also establishes that electronic documents cannot be denied validity solely due to their electronic form.
The document discusses cyber law and conventions regarding online responsibility. It summarizes key Albanian laws related to electronic communications, electronic commerce, data protection, and other areas of cyber law. It also discusses international sources of cyber law like the UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Signatures and the EU Directive on Electronic Commerce. Decisions by the European Court of Human Rights are analyzed that relate to the responsibility of online news portals for user comments.
E-contracting and Commerce is presented by Pria Chetty and details the South African legal position with regard to electronic contracts and the effect on commerce.
This document discusses several legal, ethical and social issues related to electronic commerce (EC). It covers topics such as privacy and protecting personal information, intellectual property rights, unsolicited electronic ads/spam, free speech vs censorship, taxation of online businesses, and how laws and regulations are still developing to address challenges from EC. The key issues involve balancing consumer protection vs business interests, as well as countries establishing consistent privacy, IP and other legal frameworks for digital/online activities.
This document discusses important issues in global e-commerce. It begins by defining e-commerce and outlining how technological advancements have influenced consumer and business behavior to adopt e-commerce. For businesses, e-commerce allows global operations through websites that can reach customers around the world. However, for e-commerce to be successful there must be trust between parties. The document outlines issues relating to access, trust, and ground rules that impact e-commerce. Specifically, it discusses challenges around infrastructure access, privacy, security, taxation across borders, and regulating online content. Resolving these issues is important for the continued growth and trust in e-commerce globally.
LEGAL REGULATORY ISSUES IN E- COMMERCE.pptxMunazza64
This document provides an overview of legal regulatory issues in e-commerce in India. It begins with definitions of e-commerce and discusses key regulations governing e-commerce in India. It then examines 10 major legal issues in e-commerce including cross-border transactions, jurisdiction, privacy and data protection, taxation, contracts, intellectual property rights, online advertising, consumer protection, liability, and identity management. It concludes by discussing the need for continued development of laws and regulations to facilitate a pleasant customer experience and higher investment in e-commerce.
A Legal Perspective of E-Businesses and E-Marketing for Small and Medium Ente...IJMIT JOURNAL
Electronic businesses are witnessing enormous growth as more and more people are switching to online platforms. The widespread use of Internet has opened new channels to operate trade for many businesses. Also electronic marketing has become a proven channel of passing on the word to the customers. Legal and ethical issues quickly become an area of concern. In this research recommendations are made to harmonize IT and Internet Laws. A novel approach is proposed to promote legal risk management culture in organizations. It begins with revising current state of regulations surrounding e-Businesses and electronic marketing. The proposed approach offers risk management by considering risk mitigation strategy, educating people and use of information technology. Monitoring compliance requirements are met by reviewing the latest changes in regulations and rewarding the employees who ensures the successful implementation of the strategy.
This document discusses intellectual property law challenges in the age of internet and converging technologies. It notes that the balance of rights between copyright owners, internet service providers, consumers, and other stakeholders is difficult to maintain as technology advances faster than legal developments. It also examines issues around regulating converged media and the need for coordinated intellectual property legislation to address digital copyright issues raised by new communication technologies. The document surveys IP laws and regulations globally to analyze challenges and solutions around protecting multimedia content, software, and websites in the internet era.
This document discusses cybercrime in India, including the Information Technology Act 2000 and its amendments. It provides definitions of cybercrime, classifications of offenses like those against individuals, property, organizations and society. Examples of famous cybercrime cases in India are mentioned. Statistics on cybercrime growth are presented. The role of organizations like NASSCOM in combating cybercrime through initiatives focused on engagement, education, enactment and enforcement is summarized. Suggestions for dealing with cybercrime through international cooperation, funding research, upgrading laws and training law enforcement are provided.
Jurisdictional issues of e commerce and consumer protectionAkshay Sharma
This document provides an overview of e-commerce in India. It discusses the growth of e-commerce, e-contracts, jurisdiction issues, the role of international bodies and frameworks, consumer protection, and a case study on Flipkart's Big Billion Sale. The document outlines the classification of e-commerce, essential elements of e-contracts, challenges regarding cross-border transactions and determining applicable law, and issues around intellectual property rights, digital goods/services, contracts with minors, and taxation in e-commerce. It also examines frameworks established by bodies like UNCITRAL and OECD and initiatives in India to regulate e-commerce and protect consumers.
B11: Central IP & IT Court | FinTech: Legal and Regulatory Challenges (7 Aug ...Kullarat Phongsathaporn
"Special seminar on Memorial Day for Thailand's Father of Law" by Central IP & IT Court, Panelist for "FinTech: Legal and Regulatory Challenges" (7 Aug 2019)
Privacy is a fluid concept that is shaped by technology and society. The internet enables vast data collection but also challenges notions of privacy. While governments and companies collect data, there are tensions between privacy, security, and economic interests. Stakeholders should work to strengthen legal frameworks for data access, incentivize business models that respect user consent and ownership, and promote technical standards that enhance privacy and security online. International cooperation is needed to balance an open internet with privacy protections that apply both online and offline.
The document summarizes key aspects of internet regulation in the UK, focusing on the E-Commerce Regulations and Distance Selling Regulations. It discusses requirements for information that must be provided by online service providers to consumers. This includes general information, terms and conditions, order processes, commercial communications, and cancellation rights. It provides examples of how these regulations apply and consequences for non-compliance, such as enforcement actions and liability.
Microsoft power point comparative study of the main features of unfair comp...sanjeev kumar chaswal
This document discusses unfair competition laws. It begins by explaining that while competition is generally encouraged, competitors may sometimes use unfair means like misleading the public or directly attacking other businesses. International laws like the Paris Convention and TRIPS agreement require countries to prevent unfair competition. The US has no overarching unfair competition law, but addresses aspects of it through tort laws, consumer protection laws, and self-regulation. The Lanham Act also establishes some unfair competition provisions at the federal level regarding false designations of origin.
Law & Emerging Technology - The Model Law on E-Commerce (Unit 2).pptxssuser32bd0c
The document discusses the Model Law on Electronic Commerce (MLEC) adopted by UNCITRAL in 1996. It summarizes the key principles and provisions of the MLEC, including non-discrimination, technological neutrality, functional equivalence. It provides examples of how countries have incorporated the MLEC into their laws governing e-commerce and discusses some relevant case laws. It also discusses electronic contracts and signatures under Indian law, particularly the Information Technology Act, 2000.
This document summarizes a meeting that discussed European legal and privacy updates for data-driven marketing. It included presentations from the CEO of DMA Group and the co-chair of FEDMA on different privacy views in Europe and the need for proportionate and effective regulation through dialogue between industry and policymakers. Other topics discussed were the Data Protection Regulation's impact and how to prepare for the new law, including assessing what constitutes personal data, consent mechanisms, legitimate interest, and profiling activities. The future of marketing and why the industry should care about developments in Europe were also mentioned.
The document discusses concerns about provisions in the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement regarding internet intermediary liability and restrictions on the free flow of online information. It notes that while free flow of information has economic benefits, it is also linked to complex issues of privacy, political considerations, and human rights that may not be best addressed in closed-door trade negotiations. The document advocates for balancing free expression with privacy protections, and ensuring any international framework respects sovereign countries' privacy laws and principles of informed consent.
Lifting the Corporate Veil. Power Point Presentationseri bangash
"Lifting the Corporate Veil" is a legal concept that refers to the judicial act of disregarding the separate legal personality of a corporation or limited liability company (LLC). Normally, a corporation is considered a legal entity separate from its shareholders or members, meaning that the personal assets of shareholders or members are protected from the liabilities of the corporation. However, there are certain situations where courts may decide to "pierce" or "lift" the corporate veil, holding shareholders or members personally liable for the debts or actions of the corporation.
Here are some common scenarios in which courts might lift the corporate veil:
Fraud or Illegality: If shareholders or members use the corporate structure to perpetrate fraud, evade legal obligations, or engage in illegal activities, courts may disregard the corporate entity and hold those individuals personally liable.
Undercapitalization: If a corporation is formed with insufficient capital to conduct its intended business and meet its foreseeable liabilities, and this lack of capitalization results in harm to creditors or other parties, courts may lift the corporate veil to hold shareholders or members liable.
Failure to Observe Corporate Formalities: Corporations and LLCs are required to observe certain formalities, such as holding regular meetings, maintaining separate financial records, and avoiding commingling of personal and corporate assets. If these formalities are not observed and the corporate structure is used as a mere façade, courts may disregard the corporate entity.
Alter Ego: If there is such a unity of interest and ownership between the corporation and its shareholders or members that the separate personalities of the corporation and the individuals no longer exist, courts may treat the corporation as the alter ego of its owners and hold them personally liable.
Group Enterprises: In some cases, where multiple corporations are closely related or form part of a single economic unit, courts may pierce the corporate veil to achieve equity, particularly if one corporation's actions harm creditors or other stakeholders and the corporate structure is being used to shield culpable parties from liability.
ICT and the transformation of the legal profession Oluwaseyi K. Oni
ICT is transforming the legal profession in several ways:
1. Technology is being leveraged to deliver legal services more efficiently through tools like video conferencing, online legal communities, e-libraries and case management systems.
2. The rise of e-commerce requires new approaches to legal documentation and dispute resolution, like online dispute resolution and smart contracts on blockchain.
3. Certain routine legal tasks like company formation and basic legal research may become automated, but complex legal work requiring judgment and nuance will still need human lawyers.
The future legal profession is uncertain but will likely see subscription pricing models, an emphasis on technology skills, and changing roles for legal professionals and tools.
Industrial revolution and notions of technology .pptxVishweshSingh16
The document discusses the United Nations Commission on International Trade Law's (UNCITRAL) Model Law on Electronic Commerce (MLEC) from 1996. The MLEC aims to facilitate electronic commerce by establishing principles of non-discrimination of electronic documents, technological neutrality, and functional equivalence of electronic and paper documents. It sets rules for electronic contracting, digital signatures, and attribution of electronic messages. The MLEC has been influential as many states have based domestic e-commerce laws on it, helping unify international standards in the area. It also establishes that electronic documents cannot be denied validity solely due to their electronic form.
The document discusses cyber law and conventions regarding online responsibility. It summarizes key Albanian laws related to electronic communications, electronic commerce, data protection, and other areas of cyber law. It also discusses international sources of cyber law like the UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Signatures and the EU Directive on Electronic Commerce. Decisions by the European Court of Human Rights are analyzed that relate to the responsibility of online news portals for user comments.
E-contracting and Commerce is presented by Pria Chetty and details the South African legal position with regard to electronic contracts and the effect on commerce.
This document discusses several legal, ethical and social issues related to electronic commerce (EC). It covers topics such as privacy and protecting personal information, intellectual property rights, unsolicited electronic ads/spam, free speech vs censorship, taxation of online businesses, and how laws and regulations are still developing to address challenges from EC. The key issues involve balancing consumer protection vs business interests, as well as countries establishing consistent privacy, IP and other legal frameworks for digital/online activities.
This document discusses important issues in global e-commerce. It begins by defining e-commerce and outlining how technological advancements have influenced consumer and business behavior to adopt e-commerce. For businesses, e-commerce allows global operations through websites that can reach customers around the world. However, for e-commerce to be successful there must be trust between parties. The document outlines issues relating to access, trust, and ground rules that impact e-commerce. Specifically, it discusses challenges around infrastructure access, privacy, security, taxation across borders, and regulating online content. Resolving these issues is important for the continued growth and trust in e-commerce globally.
LEGAL REGULATORY ISSUES IN E- COMMERCE.pptxMunazza64
This document provides an overview of legal regulatory issues in e-commerce in India. It begins with definitions of e-commerce and discusses key regulations governing e-commerce in India. It then examines 10 major legal issues in e-commerce including cross-border transactions, jurisdiction, privacy and data protection, taxation, contracts, intellectual property rights, online advertising, consumer protection, liability, and identity management. It concludes by discussing the need for continued development of laws and regulations to facilitate a pleasant customer experience and higher investment in e-commerce.
A Legal Perspective of E-Businesses and E-Marketing for Small and Medium Ente...IJMIT JOURNAL
Electronic businesses are witnessing enormous growth as more and more people are switching to online platforms. The widespread use of Internet has opened new channels to operate trade for many businesses. Also electronic marketing has become a proven channel of passing on the word to the customers. Legal and ethical issues quickly become an area of concern. In this research recommendations are made to harmonize IT and Internet Laws. A novel approach is proposed to promote legal risk management culture in organizations. It begins with revising current state of regulations surrounding e-Businesses and electronic marketing. The proposed approach offers risk management by considering risk mitigation strategy, educating people and use of information technology. Monitoring compliance requirements are met by reviewing the latest changes in regulations and rewarding the employees who ensures the successful implementation of the strategy.
This document discusses intellectual property law challenges in the age of internet and converging technologies. It notes that the balance of rights between copyright owners, internet service providers, consumers, and other stakeholders is difficult to maintain as technology advances faster than legal developments. It also examines issues around regulating converged media and the need for coordinated intellectual property legislation to address digital copyright issues raised by new communication technologies. The document surveys IP laws and regulations globally to analyze challenges and solutions around protecting multimedia content, software, and websites in the internet era.
This document discusses cybercrime in India, including the Information Technology Act 2000 and its amendments. It provides definitions of cybercrime, classifications of offenses like those against individuals, property, organizations and society. Examples of famous cybercrime cases in India are mentioned. Statistics on cybercrime growth are presented. The role of organizations like NASSCOM in combating cybercrime through initiatives focused on engagement, education, enactment and enforcement is summarized. Suggestions for dealing with cybercrime through international cooperation, funding research, upgrading laws and training law enforcement are provided.
Jurisdictional issues of e commerce and consumer protectionAkshay Sharma
This document provides an overview of e-commerce in India. It discusses the growth of e-commerce, e-contracts, jurisdiction issues, the role of international bodies and frameworks, consumer protection, and a case study on Flipkart's Big Billion Sale. The document outlines the classification of e-commerce, essential elements of e-contracts, challenges regarding cross-border transactions and determining applicable law, and issues around intellectual property rights, digital goods/services, contracts with minors, and taxation in e-commerce. It also examines frameworks established by bodies like UNCITRAL and OECD and initiatives in India to regulate e-commerce and protect consumers.
B11: Central IP & IT Court | FinTech: Legal and Regulatory Challenges (7 Aug ...Kullarat Phongsathaporn
"Special seminar on Memorial Day for Thailand's Father of Law" by Central IP & IT Court, Panelist for "FinTech: Legal and Regulatory Challenges" (7 Aug 2019)
Privacy is a fluid concept that is shaped by technology and society. The internet enables vast data collection but also challenges notions of privacy. While governments and companies collect data, there are tensions between privacy, security, and economic interests. Stakeholders should work to strengthen legal frameworks for data access, incentivize business models that respect user consent and ownership, and promote technical standards that enhance privacy and security online. International cooperation is needed to balance an open internet with privacy protections that apply both online and offline.
The document summarizes key aspects of internet regulation in the UK, focusing on the E-Commerce Regulations and Distance Selling Regulations. It discusses requirements for information that must be provided by online service providers to consumers. This includes general information, terms and conditions, order processes, commercial communications, and cancellation rights. It provides examples of how these regulations apply and consequences for non-compliance, such as enforcement actions and liability.
Microsoft power point comparative study of the main features of unfair comp...sanjeev kumar chaswal
This document discusses unfair competition laws. It begins by explaining that while competition is generally encouraged, competitors may sometimes use unfair means like misleading the public or directly attacking other businesses. International laws like the Paris Convention and TRIPS agreement require countries to prevent unfair competition. The US has no overarching unfair competition law, but addresses aspects of it through tort laws, consumer protection laws, and self-regulation. The Lanham Act also establishes some unfair competition provisions at the federal level regarding false designations of origin.
Law & Emerging Technology - The Model Law on E-Commerce (Unit 2).pptxssuser32bd0c
The document discusses the Model Law on Electronic Commerce (MLEC) adopted by UNCITRAL in 1996. It summarizes the key principles and provisions of the MLEC, including non-discrimination, technological neutrality, functional equivalence. It provides examples of how countries have incorporated the MLEC into their laws governing e-commerce and discusses some relevant case laws. It also discusses electronic contracts and signatures under Indian law, particularly the Information Technology Act, 2000.
This document summarizes a meeting that discussed European legal and privacy updates for data-driven marketing. It included presentations from the CEO of DMA Group and the co-chair of FEDMA on different privacy views in Europe and the need for proportionate and effective regulation through dialogue between industry and policymakers. Other topics discussed were the Data Protection Regulation's impact and how to prepare for the new law, including assessing what constitutes personal data, consent mechanisms, legitimate interest, and profiling activities. The future of marketing and why the industry should care about developments in Europe were also mentioned.
The document discusses concerns about provisions in the Trans-Pacific Partnership Agreement regarding internet intermediary liability and restrictions on the free flow of online information. It notes that while free flow of information has economic benefits, it is also linked to complex issues of privacy, political considerations, and human rights that may not be best addressed in closed-door trade negotiations. The document advocates for balancing free expression with privacy protections, and ensuring any international framework respects sovereign countries' privacy laws and principles of informed consent.
Similar to legalchallengesine-commerceppt-170211074338.pdf (20)
Lifting the Corporate Veil. Power Point Presentationseri bangash
"Lifting the Corporate Veil" is a legal concept that refers to the judicial act of disregarding the separate legal personality of a corporation or limited liability company (LLC). Normally, a corporation is considered a legal entity separate from its shareholders or members, meaning that the personal assets of shareholders or members are protected from the liabilities of the corporation. However, there are certain situations where courts may decide to "pierce" or "lift" the corporate veil, holding shareholders or members personally liable for the debts or actions of the corporation.
Here are some common scenarios in which courts might lift the corporate veil:
Fraud or Illegality: If shareholders or members use the corporate structure to perpetrate fraud, evade legal obligations, or engage in illegal activities, courts may disregard the corporate entity and hold those individuals personally liable.
Undercapitalization: If a corporation is formed with insufficient capital to conduct its intended business and meet its foreseeable liabilities, and this lack of capitalization results in harm to creditors or other parties, courts may lift the corporate veil to hold shareholders or members liable.
Failure to Observe Corporate Formalities: Corporations and LLCs are required to observe certain formalities, such as holding regular meetings, maintaining separate financial records, and avoiding commingling of personal and corporate assets. If these formalities are not observed and the corporate structure is used as a mere façade, courts may disregard the corporate entity.
Alter Ego: If there is such a unity of interest and ownership between the corporation and its shareholders or members that the separate personalities of the corporation and the individuals no longer exist, courts may treat the corporation as the alter ego of its owners and hold them personally liable.
Group Enterprises: In some cases, where multiple corporations are closely related or form part of a single economic unit, courts may pierce the corporate veil to achieve equity, particularly if one corporation's actions harm creditors or other stakeholders and the corporate structure is being used to shield culpable parties from liability.
What are the common challenges faced by women lawyers working in the legal pr...lawyersonia
The legal profession, which has historically been male-dominated, has experienced a significant increase in the number of women entering the field over the past few decades. Despite this progress, women lawyers continue to encounter various challenges as they strive for top positions.
Synopsis On Annual General Meeting/Extra Ordinary General Meeting With Ordinary And Special Businesses And Ordinary And Special Resolutions with Companies (Postal Ballot) Regulations, 2018
सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने यह भी माना था कि मजिस्ट्रेट का यह कर्तव्य है कि वह सुनिश्चित करे कि अधिकारी पीएमएलए के तहत निर्धारित प्रक्रिया के साथ-साथ संवैधानिक सुरक्षा उपायों का भी उचित रूप से पालन करें।
Guide on the use of Artificial Intelligence-based tools by lawyers and law fi...Massimo Talia
This guide aims to provide information on how lawyers will be able to use the opportunities provided by AI tools and how such tools could help the business processes of small firms. Its objective is to provide lawyers with some background to understand what they can and cannot realistically expect from these products. This guide aims to give a reference point for small law practices in the EU
against which they can evaluate those classes of AI applications that are probably the most relevant for them.
Genocide in International Criminal Law.pptxMasoudZamani13
Excited to share insights from my recent presentation on genocide! 💡 In light of ongoing debates, it's crucial to delve into the nuances of this grave crime.
Business law for the students of undergraduate level. The presentation contains the summary of all the chapters under the syllabus of State University, Contract Act, Sale of Goods Act, Negotiable Instrument Act, Partnership Act, Limited Liability Act, Consumer Protection Act.
Matthew Professional CV experienced Government LiaisonMattGardner52
As an experienced Government Liaison, I have demonstrated expertise in Corporate Governance. My skill set includes senior-level management in Contract Management, Legal Support, and Diplomatic Relations. I have also gained proficiency as a Corporate Liaison, utilizing my strong background in accounting, finance, and legal, with a Bachelor's degree (B.A.) from California State University. My Administrative Skills further strengthen my ability to contribute to the growth and success of any organization.
This document briefly explains the June compliance calendar 2024 with income tax returns, PF, ESI, and important due dates, forms to be filled out, periods, and who should file them?.
The Future of Criminal Defense Lawyer in India.pdfveteranlegal
https://veteranlegal.in/defense-lawyer-in-india/ | Criminal defense Lawyer in India has always been a vital aspect of the country's legal system. As defenders of justice, criminal Defense Lawyer play a critical role in ensuring that individuals accused of crimes receive a fair trial and that their constitutional rights are protected. As India evolves socially, economically, and technologically, the role and future of criminal Defense Lawyer are also undergoing significant changes. This comprehensive blog explores the current landscape, challenges, technological advancements, and prospects for criminal Defense Lawyer in India.
Sangyun Lee, 'Why Korea's Merger Control Occasionally Fails: A Public Choice ...Sangyun Lee
Presentation slides for a session held on June 4, 2024, at Kyoto University. This presentation is based on the presenter’s recent paper, coauthored with Hwang Lee, Professor, Korea University, with the same title, published in the Journal of Business Administration & Law, Volume 34, No. 2 (April 2024). The paper, written in Korean, is available at <https://shorturl.at/GCWcI>.
2. Outline
• Introduction
• Unfair Terms in E-Commerce
• Cybercrime as a Challenge to E-Commerce
• Jurisdictional Issues in E-commerce
3. Introduction
• What is e-commerce?
– The sale of physical or digital goods or services via a digital channel
• Interesting Fact:
– 11th November 2016, The Star Online reported that Chinese e-
commerce giant Alibaba Group Holding Ltd said it racked up more
than US$5bil in transactions in the first hour of its annual 'Singles' Day'
sales blitz
– In Malaysia, revenue in the e-commerce market amounting to USD
1,199.8 million in 2016
• The high volume of e-commerce transactions creates multiple
challenges to all parties
4. Challenges
• consumer protection issues/unfair terms in
e-commerce;
• data and network security issues;
• Intellectual Property rights issues;
• Privacy issues;
• jurisdiction/choice of law issues;
• admissibility/evidence issues;
• Cybercrime to e-payment & etc.
5. The Main Legislation
• Electronic Commerce Act 2006
– “electronic” means the technology of utilizing electrical, optical,
magnetic, electromagnetic, biometric, photonic or other similar
technology
– “commercial transaction” means single communication or multiple
communications of a commercial nature, whether contractual or not,
which includes any matters relating to the supply or exchange of
goods or services, agency, investments, financing, banking and
insurance
• UNCITRAL Model Law on Electronic Commerce
– Part I which covers e-commerce in general
– Part II which covers E-commerce in specific areas such as carriage of
goods
6. UNFAIR TERMS IN E-COMMERCE
• E-commerce transactions are categorised in four
ways being;
– (a) consumer to consumer transactions;
– (b) business to consumer transactions;
– (c) business to business transactions; and
– (d) many to many transactions (e-marketsor exchanges).
• The Star Online reported that:
– ‘Between 80% and 85% of e-commerce is the business-to-
business (B2B) market. The business-to-consumer (B2C)
market takes up only a small portion.’
7. Challenge
• Standard form contract
• A common contract where unfair contract
terms can be expected to be found.
• Consumer Protection Act only governs
consumer contracts
– Not specifically on e-commerce
– Not the business-to business market
8. Unfair Terms in Malaysian Law
• Consumer Protection Act
– Section 24A defines “unfair term” as a term in a consumer contract
which, with regard to all the circumstances, causes a significant
imbalance in the rights and obligations of the parties arising under the
contract to the detriment of the consumer
– Procedural Unfairness (knowledge and understanding, bargaining
strength, reasonably practicable for the consumer to negotiate for the
alternation, independent legal or other expert evidence, accurately
explained) – These are not suitable for e-commerce, click-wrap
agreement? Air Asia auto-added system?
– Substantive Unfairness (unreasonably difficult to comply with, not
reasonably necessary for the protection of the legitimate interests of
the supplier) – No list of example of substantive unfair terms, e-
commerce will not know which term is allowed and which term is not
allowed.
– A breach of any circumstances is a not breach of the law, it is not a
mandatory requirement, merely a list of circumstances for a court or
the Tribunal to take in account.
9. Business-to-business market (business contracts)
• Contract Law
– a contract caused by coercion, undue influence, misrepresentation
and fraud all of which are concerned with the procedural aspects of
contractual fairness
– Consider the burden of proof
– Consider the substantive unfairness
• Common Law
– Doctrine of Unconscionability
– The applicability of the doctrine of inequality of bargaining power or
unconscionable contract under the common law of Malaysia is still
doubted.
– Malaysian courts have yet to deal with the issue of unconscionability
and unequal bargaining power in e-commerce transactions.
10. A regional movement
• European Union Council Directive 93/13/ECC on Unfair
Terms in Consumer Contracts
• UK enacted the Consumer Rights Act 2015 (CRA) in order to
give effect to the Directive
– ‘Contract and Notices’ vs ‘A Contract or a Term of the Contract’
• A notice that relates to rights and obligations between a trader and a
consumer or a notice which appears to exclude or restrict a trader’s
liability to a consumer
• Contractual or non-contractual consumer notices
• Notices can be found on an e-commerce website (e.g incorrect price,
incorrectly states the offer's end date, late delivery, etc)
– The Fairness Requirement
• A term or a notice is unfair if, contrary to the requirement of good
faith, it causes a significant imbalance in the parties’ rights and
obligations under the contract to the detriment of the consumer.
– The Transparency Requirement
• A term which is ambiguous will be interpreted in the meaning that is
most favorable to the consumer
• The transparency requirement may be enforced by public bodies
11. Conclusion on Unfair Terms in
E-Commerce
• No Model Law, Convention or Treaty
• No specific provision
• No regulation on business contracts
• No mandatory requirement on transparency
• The current law is inadequate for dealing with unfair
terms in e-commerce
12. Recommendations
• Insert the provisions on unfair terms in
Electronic Commerce Act 2005—applicable to
business contracts and consumer contracts
• Set up a commission or regulator to govern the
unfair terms in e-commerce
• Insert a transparency requirement
• Importance: to foster a more conducive
environment for e-commerce activities
14. CYBER CRIME !!
The term ‘Crime’ is defined as “an intentional act in violation of the
criminal law (statutory and case law), committed without defence or
excuse, and penalized by the state as a felony or misdemeanour.
Cybercrime is a term used to broadly describe criminal activity in which
computers or computer networks are a tool, a target or a place of
criminal activity. It include everything from electronic cracking to denial
of service attacks.
It is also used to include traditional crimes in which computers or
networks are used to enable the illegal activity.
15. Categories of Cybercrime
Saturday, 11 February 2017
Cybercrime can generally be divided into two categories;
• Crimes that target computer networks or devises directly,
example; Malware and malicious code, denial of service attacks,
computer viruses, industrial espionage, software piracy and
hacking.
• Crimes facilitated by computer networks or devices, example;
cyber stalking, fraud and identity theft, phishing scams and
information warfare.
20. International efforts to combat Cybercrime
• International Criminal Police Organization (Interpol)
– As an international law-enforcement organization with 184
members, Interpol started to tackle computer crime very
early, by coordinating law-enforcement agencies and
legislations, in regard to which Interpol made efforts to
improve counter-cybercrime capacity at the international
level
– Interpol has provided a technical guidance in cybercrime
detection, investigation and evidence collection. The
Interpol Information Technology Crime Investigation
Manual was compiled by the European Working Party on
Information Technology Crime.
– Compared with the substantive and procedural law
harmonization of today's Convention on Cybercrime, the
Manual developed a technological law-enforcement model
to improve the efficiency of combating cybercrime
Saturday, 11 February 2017
21. Regional efforts to combat Cybercrime;
• The Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation (APEC)
• In 2005, The sixth APEC Ministerial Meeting on the
Telecommunications and Information Industry passed the
Lima Declaration,
• "encouraging all economies to study the Convention on
Cybercrime (2001) and to endeavour to enact a
comprehensive set of laws relating to cyber security and
cybercrime that are consistent with international legal
instruments, including UN General Assembly Resolution
55/63 (2000) and the Convention on Cybercrime (2001)."
• Nevertheless, due to the great difference between member
economies within the APEC, the development toward unified
legal instruments has not been too satisfactory.
Saturday, 11 February 2017
22. Regional efforts to combat Cybercrime cont.….
Saturday, 11 February 2017
• COUNCIL OF EUROPE
• In 1981, the Council of Europe implemented “the Convention for the
Protection of Individuals with Regard to Automatic Processing of
Personal Data”,
• The Convention recognized the desirability
– "to extend the safeguards for everyone's rights and fundamental
freedoms, and in particular the right to the respect for privacy,
taking account of the increasing flow across frontiers of personal
data undergoing automatic processing," and the necessity "to
reconcile the fundamental values of the respect to privacy and the
free flow of information between peoples" (Preamble).
• The Convention covers the protection of personal data in both the
public and private sectors.
23. COUNCIL OF EUROPE cont.…
Saturday, 11 February 2017
• In 1997, the Council of Europe began drafting the Convention on
Cybercrime, which was open for signature in 2001 and took
effect in 2004.
• In 2003, the Additional Protocol to the Convention on
Cybercrime Concerning the Criminalization of Acts of a Racist
and Xenophobic Nature Committed Through Computer System
(ETS NO. 189) was implemented.
• The Convention is a historic landmark in the combat against
cybercrime.
• The Council of Europe in 2006 launched a Project against
Cybercrime, envisioned to assist the development of national
legislation in line with the provision of the Convention, training
of judges, prosecutors and law-enforcement officers, and
training of criminal justice officials and 24/5 contact points in
international cooperation.
24. The European Union
• In 1995, the European Parliament and the Council (EPC) endorsed Directive
95/46/EC of 24 October 1995 on the protection of Individuals with regard to the
Processing of Personal Data and on the Movement of Such Data.
• In 1997, the EPC endorsed Directive 97/66/EC of 15 December 1997 concerning
the Processing of Personal Data and the Protection of Privacy in the
Telecommunications Sector.
• In April 2002, the Commission of the European Communities presented a proposal
for a Council Framework Decision on Attacks against information systems, and this
proposal constitutes the case of the Decision of 24 February 2005.
• The Framework Decision only dealt with attacks through unauthorized access to
or interference with information systems or data. It does not specify penalties for
illegal access to information systems and instigation, aiding and abetting and
attempting of these offences, but requires member states to take the necessary
measures to ensure that they are punishable by effective, proportional and
dissuasive criminal penalties.
• It is worth noting that the matters mentioned in the Framework Decision can also
be found in the Convention on Cybercrime.
25. Multi-national Organizations;
• The Common Wealth Nations
• The Commonwealth of Nations’ Secretariat prepared the "Model Law on Computer
and Computer Related Crime" in October 2002
• The Model Law expanded criminal liability - so as to include reckless liability- for the
offences of interfering with data, interfering with computer systems, and using illegal
devices.
• The Model Law also covered the problem of dual criminality by stating that the act
applied to an act done or an omission made by a national of a state outside its
territory, if the person's conduct would also constitute an offence under a law of the
country where the offence was committed. This may lead to prosecution or extradition
based on dual criminality.
• Another focus of the Commonwealth is on mutual assistance in law enforcement
between Commonwealth member states and non-commonwealth States.
• In the 2005 Meeting of Commonwealth Law Ministers and Senior Officials, the Expert
Working Group proposed 10 recommendations for member states to adopt suitable
measures for improving domestic law enforcement and trans-national assistance.
• It also encouraged member states to sign, ratify, accede to and implement the
Convention on Cybercrime as a basis for mutual legal assistance between
Commonwealth member states and Non-commonwealth States.
26. The Group of Eight (G8)
• In 1995 at the Halifax Summit, the Group of Seven recognized
– "that ultimate success requires all governments to provide for effective
measures to prevent the laundering of proceeds from serious crimes, and to
implement commitments in the fight against trans-national organized crime."
• The group released 40-point set of "recommendations to combat Trans-
national Organized Crime efficiently" at the G7/P8 Lyon Summit. The
recommendations urged the states to increase the level of criminalization,
prosecution, investigation, and international cooperation, while
acknowledging in their entirety human-rights protection.
• The Group of Eight Meeting of the Justice and Interior Ministers indicated, in
a Statement of Principles Concerning Electronic Crime, that,
– ‘although criminal legislation was a national responsibility, the character of the
information networks obstructed countries from operating traditional power over
this problem. National legislations have to be supplemented by international
cooperation to criminalize the exploitation of the networks and harmonize the
investigative action.’
• The Group of Eight agreed on principles and approaches for the protection of
privacy, the free flow of information, and the security of transactions.
27. The Organization for Economic Corporation and Development
(OECD)
• In 1983, an expert committee was appointed by the OECD
to discuss computer crime phenomena and criminal-law
reform.
• In December 1999, the OECD officially approved the
Guidelines for Consumer Protection in the Context of
Electronic Commerce,
• In 2002 the OECD adopted Guidelines for the Security of
Information Systems and Networks, calling on member
governments to
– "establish a heightened priority for security planning and
management", and to "promote a culture of security among
all participants as a means of protecting information systems
and networks"
• The guidelines established nine principles, including
awareness, responsibility, response, ethics, democracy,
risk assessment, security design and implementation,
security management, and re-assessment.
28. Major themes of the Organizations
The promotion of security awareness at both
the international and national levels,
Global harmonization of laws and procedure,
Coordination and Cooperation in law
enforcement, and
Direct anti-cybercrime actions.
Saturday, 11 February 2017
29. Efforts to combat cybercrime in Malaysia
• Numerous legislations have been enacted in
1997 to 1998. They are: -
– 1. Multimedia and Communications Act 1998
– 2. Multimedia Commission Act 1998
– 3. Digital Signature Act 1997
– 4. Computer Crimes Act 1997
– 5. Telemedicine Act 1997
– 6. Copyright (Amendment) Act 1997
Saturday, 11 February 2017
30. Malaysia cont.….
• Computer Crimes Act 1997 is the main Act use to combat
cybercrime in Malaysia.
• However, the offences are only described in sections 3, 4, 5,
6, 7 and 8 in Part II of the Act.
• The Computer Crimes Act 1997 does not cover many areas of
computer-related activities.
• The criminal laws of Malaysia, in particular the Penal Code,
do not specifically provide for any computer-related crimes.
• The legal standing of these cybercrime protections must be
determined in the context of the existing laws.
• The existing laws were not drafted with computer technology
in mind and in most cases, is not sufficiently broad enough to
encompass the various types of computer-related activities.
• Consequently, no matter how repulsive or evil such activities
may be in the perception of the policymakers and the public,
they may not constitute unlawful or prohibited behaviour.
Saturday, 11 February 2017
31. FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
Cybercrime’s definition; no comprehensive definition of the term “cybercrime”
yet. Cybercrime covers diverse types of offences which includes; offences against
the confidentiality, integrity and availability of data and information systems.
There is need for a harmonized definition of the term cybercrime in an
international instruments either binding or non-binding.
ICT is complex and often unfamiliar to the traditional criminal justice world. It
requires well-trained personnel to deal with crimes involving these devices
throughout the investigation phase, during prosecution, and in courts. States
need to invest in constant training and education of its operators
Sovereignty and the territoriality principle issue; cybercrimes
frequently occur in different places, which may be under the
jurisdictions of different countries. There is a strong need for clear
norms setting the priorities and competences of each country
involved.
Crimes occur in a fraction of a second and evidence of cybercrime
frequently consists of digital information, which is momentary by
nature and can be altered or deleted. Law enforcement agencies
must therefore take rapid action and be able to collect and preserve
digital evidence for use in criminal proceedings
Saturday, 11 February 2017
32. How to Tackle Such Activities?
An important question that arises is how can these crimes be prevented. A
number of techniques and solutions have been presented but the problems still
exists and are increasing day by day.
Antivirus And Anti Spyware Software:
Antivirus software consists of computer programs that attempt to identify,
thwart and eliminate computer viruses and other malicious software. Anti spy
wares are used to restrict backdoor program, trojans and other spy wares to be
installed on the computer.
Firewalls:
A firewall protects a computer network from unauthorized access. Network
firewalls may be hardware devices, software programs, or a combination of the
two. A network firewall typically guards an internal computer network against
malicious access from outside the network.
Saturday, 11 February 2017
33. Cryptography:
Cryptography is the science of encrypting and decrypting information.
Encryption is like sending a postal mail to another party with a lock code
on the envelope which is known only to the sender and the recipient. A
number of cryptographic methods have been developed and some of
them are still not cracked.
Cyber Ethics and Laws:
Cyber ethics and cyber laws are also being formulated to stop cyber
crimes. It is a responsibility of every individual to follow cyber ethics and
cyber laws so that the increasing cyber crimes shall reduce. Security
Software like Anti Viruses and Anti Spy Wares should be installed on all
computers, in order to remain secure from Cyber Crimes. Internet Service
Providers should also provide high level of security at their servers in order
to keep their clients secure from all types of viruses and malicious
programs.
34. The Future of Cyber-Crimes in Malaysia
• Continued Website Hacks and
Defacements
• Data and Information theft
• Increasing phishing attacks on
Ecommerce and Financial Websites
• Cybercriminals targeting Social and
Professional Networks
• Threats directed at the Mobile Platform:
Smartphones and Tablets
35. Conclusion…
"As internet technology advances so does the
threat of cyber crime. In times like these we must
protect ourselves from cyber crime. Anti-virus
software, firewalls and security patches are just
the beginning. Never open suspicious e-mails and
only navigate to trusted sites.”
36. 36
JURISDICTIONAL ISSUES IN E - COMMERCE
INTRODUCTION
• “As long as different countries have different laws and cultures,
there are no good principles for jurisdiction….Every nation wants
unity, but no nation wants to give up any of its traditions.”
• When something goes wrong with contracts between parties in
different countries, there is often confusion as to where a court
action should be brought.
Should it be in the country of the purchaser?
Or that of the seller or service provider?
And how can you enforce a court ruling when each party is in a
different country?
Internet Contracts are based largely on the terms and conditions
contained on the web site in question
37. 37
Introduction cont.……
• The terms and conditions often contain a 'choice of law'
clause, which indicates the country in which a dispute will be
decided.
• But most times not brought to the attention of the customer.
• These problems may be solved and/or reduced by an
international treaty
• Unfortunately, there are no specific rules in the model laws
and conventions dealing with Internet jurisdiction yet
• Common law courts around the world have applied different
criteria to determine whether they have jurisdiction over
Internet disputes.
• While some courts have simply applied existent traditional
rules, others have tried to develop new criteria to
accommodate the uniqueness of the electronic commerce.
38. CASE STUDY; BANYAN TREE HOLDING (P) LIMITED VS. A.
MURALI KRISHNA REDDY & ANR.
• The case came up at Delhi India Court
• The Plaintiff’s registered office is at Singapore
• The Defendants 1 and 2 are at Hyderabad. None of the parties is located
within the territorial jurisdiction of the Court.
Brief facts of the case.
• The Plaintiff, since 1994 adopted and used the word mark “Banyan Tree”
and also the banyan tree device.
• Due to long usage the Plaintiff claimed that the said mark have come to be
associated with it and its sister concerns.
• The Plaintiff maintains the websites www.banyantree.com and
www.banayantreespa.com since 1996.
• The said websites are accessible in India.
• In October 2007, the Plaintiff learnt that the Defendants had initiated work on
a project under the name “Banyan Tree Retreat”.
• The Plaintiff contend that the word mark and the device adopted by the
Defendants in relation to their retreat is deceptively similar to that of the
Plaintiff.
38
39. Case study cont.…
The Plaintiff contends that the use of the said mark and device
by the Defendants was calculated to cause confusion and
deception among the public by passing off the services of the
Defendants as that of the Plaintiff.
The Plaintiff filed for an injunction to restrain the Defendants
from the use of the said mark and device.
One of the issues before the court for determination is,
– whether for the purposes of a passing off action, or an
infringement action where the Plaintiff is not carrying on
business within the jurisdiction of a court, in what circumstances
can it be said that the hosting of a universally accessible website
by the Defendants lends jurisdiction to such Court where such
suit is filed ("the forum court")?
39
40. 40
USA Approach
• In the United States, the rules on applicable law and jurisdiction are based on
notions of “reasonableness” and “fundamental fairness” to both plaintiffs and
defendants.
• Case to case basis
1. Purposeful availment test;- the Plaintiff to prove;
o That the defendant has sufficient "minimum contacts" in the forum state. In
other words, the defendant must have purposefully directed its activities
towards the forum state or otherwise "purposefully availed" of the privilege of
conducting activities in the forum state.
o The forum court had to be satisfied that exercising jurisdiction would comport
with the traditional notions of fair play and substantial justice (International
Shoe Co. v. Washington)
2. The “Zippo” sliding scale test:- the plaintiff to prove:
o the defendant must have sufficient "minimum contacts" with the forum state,
(2) the claim asserted against the defendant must arise out of those contacts,
and (3) the exercise of jurisdiction must be reasonable."
o The court in Zippo classified websites as (i) passive, (ii) interactive and (iii)
integral to the defendant’s business. (Zippo Mfg. Co. v. Zippo Dot Com, Inc.)
41. 41
USA Approach
3. Effects test:-
o The courts moved from a “subjective territoriality” test to an
“objective territoriality” or “effects” test in which the forum court
will exercise jurisdiction if it is shown that effects of the Defendant’s
website are felt in the forum state. (Calder v. Jones)
4. Targeting Approach:-
o Currently evolving in the USA courts, a targeting analysis requires
that a defendant specifically aim its online activities at a forum to
come under the jurisdiction of that state.
In addition, US courts have generally held that consumer protection
authorities can assert jurisdiction over foreign businesses harming
American consumers.
42. 42
EUROPEAN UNION APROACH
• Europe has specific rules relating to jurisdictional issues relating to e-
commerce activity.
The Brussels Convention on Jurisdiction and Recognition of Enforcement of
Judgments in Civil and Commercial Matters (known as “the Brussels
Convention”) govern the issue of jurisdiction; and
The EC Convention on the Law Applicable to Contractual Obligations (known
as “the Rome Convention”) govern the issue of applicable law for consumer
contracts concluded over the Internet.
• Under these conventions, jurisdiction and applicable law for consumer
contracts are based on whether consumer is “active” or “passive”.
– Passive;- the consumer is not the initiator of the international contract(has no
intention to enter international market) such contract was preceded by a
specific invitation or by advertising.
– Active:- takes the initiative to enter international market
• The conventions focus more on passive consumer than active consumers
• This protection is not affected by a choice of forum or law clause.
• Art. 17.1( c) Brussels Reg. requires only that the commercial activity was
directed towards the consumer’s state and the specific contract should fall
within the scope of the business area
• It does not provide any basis for a causation requirement
43. BANYAN TREE HOLDING (P) LIMITED CONT….
• The Delhi High Court after thorough examination of different
commonwealth cases and principles of law, applying USA
targeting approach held that;
“………For it to exercise jurisdiction there should be a
prima facie evidence to shown that the nature of the
activity indulged in by the Defendant by the use of the
website was with an intention to conclude a commercial
transaction with the website user and that the specific
targeting of the forum state by the Defendant resulted in an
injury or harm to the Plaintiff within the forum state”.
44. APPROACH IN MALAYSIA
There is no Malaysian decision on the jurisdiction of a
commercial website yet.
• Should a case arise, we assume, the basic law
regarding Court’s jurisdiction would apply i.e.;-
• Thus Malaysian Courts would have jurisdiction only
when;
– The cause of action arose in Malaysia; or
– The defendant resides or is domiciled in Malaysia; or
– The defendant has a business or carrying on a business in
Malaysia
It is suggested that the approach taken by the U.S.A.
courts would be the best way forward, that is the
targeting
45. FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS
The presence of multiple parties in various parts of the world
who have a virtual connection with each other.
Difficulties in determining the appropriate forum court in times
of dispute due to borderless nature of internet.
We recommend that in this kind of situations the court should
apply the USA targeting approach theory.
The challenge of conflict of laws among nations may also arise.
For instance, some websites may be offensive in Malaysia but
legal in Canada.
These issues are of serious concern especially with respect to
enforcement of foreign judgment.
We suggest that there is urgent need for strong and pervasive
laws at the international level to deal with forum jurisdiction in
e-commerce disputes and the recognition and compulsory
enforcement of such forum decisions in other territorial
jurisdiction.
46. Conclusion
• As the number of internet users increases globally and
consumers and vendors gain more familiarity and comfort in
doing business online, internet markets will play an even
more significant role in the economies of nations worldwide.
• Therefore, the subject of jurisdiction in e-commerce
consumer contracts is of great importance in the lives of
online vendors, consumers, policy makers and governments.
Saturday, 11 February 2017