Lawyer in Vietnam Dr. Oliver Massmann THE WORLD BANK IS ASKING DUANE MORRIS O...Dr. Oliver Massmann
The document provides information about public procurement laws and processes in Vietnam. It answers questions from The World Bank about applicable laws and regulations, procurement methods, electronic procurement portals, the procurement process phases from budgeting to contract signing, and other details. Key points include:
- The Ministry of Transport conducts procurement for most roads in Vietnam.
- Applicable laws include the Bidding Law, Construction Law, and decrees regulating bidding and construction contracts.
- Open tendering is commonly used but not always required; exceptions allow other methods.
- A national e-procurement portal allows access to notices, documents, clarifications, and more.
- The process includes budget estimation, public advertisement, bid evaluation and award
The document summarizes reforms to Azerbaijan's public procurement system. The key reforms include establishing a unified internet portal for public procurement, implementing all procurement procedures and information exchange electronically through this portal, increasing transparency and efficiency, reducing bid guarantees and complaint consideration timelines, and signing contracts electronically. The reforms aim to modernize the procurement system and make it more transparent.
Public procurement regularity authority (ppra)TaseerBaloch1
The document discusses the Public Procurement Regularity Authority (PPRA) of Pakistan. It provides background on the need for procurement reforms that led to the establishment of PPRA in 2002. It outlines PPRA's functions of improving governance and transparency in public procurement. It also describes PPRA's legal framework and the public procurement rules and regulations it has established. The document then provides details on the public procurement process and cycle in Pakistan according to PPRA's rules and guidelines.
This document discusses public procurement rules and regulations in Pakistan as outlined by the Punjab Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA). It provides details on the composition and functions of the PPRA board, the definition of a "procuring agency", procurement procedures including acquisition of goods, services and construction work, principles of fair competition and value for money, steps in the procurement process from planning to contract management, and regulations around bidding, blacklisting, and grievance redressal. Key terms discussed include tender, bid, prequalification, direct contracting, and repeat orders. The document also contains sample MCQs to test understanding of public procurement concepts.
This document provides notification of new Public Procurement Rules in Pakistan. Some key points:
- The rules are being made under the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority Ordinance of 2002.
- Definitions are provided for important terms like bid, bidder, contractor, corrupt practices, etc.
- The rules apply to all procurements by Federal Government agencies, whether within or outside Pakistan.
- Procuring agencies must ensure fair and transparent procurements that provide value for money.
The Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) is responsible for prescribing regulations and procedures for public procurement by federal government organizations in Pakistan. Its key functions include improving governance, transparency and quality of procurement.
The Public Procurement Rules 2004 provide the legal framework for procurement and apply to all procurement by federal agencies. Key aspects covered include open competitive bidding as the principal method, advertisement and response time requirements, pre-qualification of bidders, composition and availability of bidding documents, domestic preference policies, bid security, bid validity periods, bid opening and evaluation criteria. The rules aim to ensure fair, transparent and value for money procurement.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS(FAQs) RELATED TO PROCUREMENT Nadeem Khan
The document contains answers to frequently asked questions (FAQs) about public procurement in Pakistan.
1) The minimum response time for procurement advertisements is 15 days for national competitive bidding and 30 days for international competitive bidding, as per Rule 13 of the Public Procurement Rules 2004. Procuring agencies can increase the response time depending on the procurement nature.
2) Response time is calculated from the date of first advertisement publication in a newspaper or on the PPRA website. If advertised in both print and online, the response time is calculated from the newspaper publication date.
3) Procuring agencies may require up to 5% bid security of the bid price as per Rule 25, but cannot fix the
Law No: 4735
Approval Date: 05.01. 2002
Official Journal Date/No: 22.01.2002/ 24648
Law No: 4964
(Law on Amendments on Some Laws)
Approval Date: 30.07. 2003
Official Journal Date/No: 15.08.2003/ 25200
LAW ON PUBLIC PROCUREMENT CONTRACTS
Lawyer in Vietnam Dr. Oliver Massmann THE WORLD BANK IS ASKING DUANE MORRIS O...Dr. Oliver Massmann
The document provides information about public procurement laws and processes in Vietnam. It answers questions from The World Bank about applicable laws and regulations, procurement methods, electronic procurement portals, the procurement process phases from budgeting to contract signing, and other details. Key points include:
- The Ministry of Transport conducts procurement for most roads in Vietnam.
- Applicable laws include the Bidding Law, Construction Law, and decrees regulating bidding and construction contracts.
- Open tendering is commonly used but not always required; exceptions allow other methods.
- A national e-procurement portal allows access to notices, documents, clarifications, and more.
- The process includes budget estimation, public advertisement, bid evaluation and award
The document summarizes reforms to Azerbaijan's public procurement system. The key reforms include establishing a unified internet portal for public procurement, implementing all procurement procedures and information exchange electronically through this portal, increasing transparency and efficiency, reducing bid guarantees and complaint consideration timelines, and signing contracts electronically. The reforms aim to modernize the procurement system and make it more transparent.
Public procurement regularity authority (ppra)TaseerBaloch1
The document discusses the Public Procurement Regularity Authority (PPRA) of Pakistan. It provides background on the need for procurement reforms that led to the establishment of PPRA in 2002. It outlines PPRA's functions of improving governance and transparency in public procurement. It also describes PPRA's legal framework and the public procurement rules and regulations it has established. The document then provides details on the public procurement process and cycle in Pakistan according to PPRA's rules and guidelines.
This document discusses public procurement rules and regulations in Pakistan as outlined by the Punjab Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA). It provides details on the composition and functions of the PPRA board, the definition of a "procuring agency", procurement procedures including acquisition of goods, services and construction work, principles of fair competition and value for money, steps in the procurement process from planning to contract management, and regulations around bidding, blacklisting, and grievance redressal. Key terms discussed include tender, bid, prequalification, direct contracting, and repeat orders. The document also contains sample MCQs to test understanding of public procurement concepts.
This document provides notification of new Public Procurement Rules in Pakistan. Some key points:
- The rules are being made under the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority Ordinance of 2002.
- Definitions are provided for important terms like bid, bidder, contractor, corrupt practices, etc.
- The rules apply to all procurements by Federal Government agencies, whether within or outside Pakistan.
- Procuring agencies must ensure fair and transparent procurements that provide value for money.
The Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) is responsible for prescribing regulations and procedures for public procurement by federal government organizations in Pakistan. Its key functions include improving governance, transparency and quality of procurement.
The Public Procurement Rules 2004 provide the legal framework for procurement and apply to all procurement by federal agencies. Key aspects covered include open competitive bidding as the principal method, advertisement and response time requirements, pre-qualification of bidders, composition and availability of bidding documents, domestic preference policies, bid security, bid validity periods, bid opening and evaluation criteria. The rules aim to ensure fair, transparent and value for money procurement.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS(FAQs) RELATED TO PROCUREMENT Nadeem Khan
The document contains answers to frequently asked questions (FAQs) about public procurement in Pakistan.
1) The minimum response time for procurement advertisements is 15 days for national competitive bidding and 30 days for international competitive bidding, as per Rule 13 of the Public Procurement Rules 2004. Procuring agencies can increase the response time depending on the procurement nature.
2) Response time is calculated from the date of first advertisement publication in a newspaper or on the PPRA website. If advertised in both print and online, the response time is calculated from the newspaper publication date.
3) Procuring agencies may require up to 5% bid security of the bid price as per Rule 25, but cannot fix the
Law No: 4735
Approval Date: 05.01. 2002
Official Journal Date/No: 22.01.2002/ 24648
Law No: 4964
(Law on Amendments on Some Laws)
Approval Date: 30.07. 2003
Official Journal Date/No: 15.08.2003/ 25200
LAW ON PUBLIC PROCUREMENT CONTRACTS
This document outlines the bidding procedures for the procurement of goods by government agencies in the Philippines. It discusses key aspects of the bidding process such as the preparation of bidding documents, requirements for invitation to bid, advertising and posting requirements, eligibility requirements, and procedures for submission and receipt of bids. The overall purpose is to ensure transparency, accountability, and competitiveness in public procurement through a standardized bidding process.
This document outlines the Implementing Rules and Regulations of Republic Act No. 9184, otherwise known as the Government Procurement Reform Act. It discusses several key points:
1) It establishes rules and regulations for modernizing, standardizing, and regulating government procurement activities from planning through contract implementation and termination.
2) It declares the policy of the government to conduct competitive and transparent procurement through public bidding, with some exceptions.
3) It establishes principles like transparency, competitiveness, streamlined processes, accountability, and public monitoring to govern procurement.
4) It defines the scope, application, and terms used in the regulation, and mandates the standardization of procurement processes and forms.
The National Complaint Settlement Agency of the Republic of Moldova is an independent administrative authority that settles complaints related to public procurement contract procedures. It has the authority to review complaints, uphold or dismiss them, and decide whether to continue or cancel public procurement procedures. The Agency's staff includes counselors for solving complaints and public servants. Any affected party has the right to appeal a contracting authority's actions within 10 or 5 days, depending on the contract value. Appeals must be in writing and include specific details. The Agency aims to settle complaints within 20 days and makes decisions publicly available on its website. Its decisions are binding but can be challenged in court.
The document discusses public procurement policy and system in the Republic of Moldova. It provides the following key points:
- The system is decentralized, with contracting authorities responsible for planning and executing contracts, while the Ministry of Finance coordinates policies.
- Several public institutions play roles in supervision: the Ministry of Finance develops policies; the Public Procurement Agency implements policies and registers contracts; the Financial Inspection ensures protection of public financial interests; and the Court of Accounts exercises external audit control.
- There is potential for conflict of interest as the Public Procurement Agency registers contracts and also examines disputes, though a new Complaints Settlement Agency is being established to handle disputes.
- Priorities for 2014 include capacity building,
Presentation by Zoran Blazevic, Croatia, on the case law of the High Administrative Court in Croatia against the procurement review bodies' decisions, at the SIGMA 2nd webinar on public procurement reality and challenges of post COVID, held on 9 March 2021. This webinar is the follow-up on the 1st webinar which took place on 26 January 2021 (https://www.slideshare.net/SIGMA2013/tag/ipa260121pup).
Presentation by Marc Steiner, Switzerland, on the practice of the Swiss Federal Administrative Court on public procurement, at the SIGMA 2nd webinar on public procurement reality and challenges of post COVID, held on 9 March 2021. This webinar is the follow-up on the 1st webinar which took place on 26 January 2021 (https://www.slideshare.net/SIGMA2013/tag/ipa260121pup).
PUBLIC PROCUREMENT REGIME & AN OVERVIEW OF PUBLIC PROCUREMENT RULES, 2004 Nadeem Khan
This document provides an overview of Pakistan's public procurement regime, including the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA), applicable laws and regulations, key definitions, procurement principles, and methods. Some of the main points covered include:
- The PPRA was established in 2002 to regulate public procurement and ensure compliance with international standards.
- Procurement rules cover the acquisition of goods, works and services by federal government agencies and organizations.
- Procurement must follow principles of fairness, transparency, efficiency and value for money. Accepted methods include petty purchases, quotations, and open competitive bidding depending on financial limits.
- Detailed requirements address specifications, approval processes, advertising methods, response times
The document provides background information on the historical development of procurement laws in the Philippines and an overview of the key provisions of Republic Act 9184 (R.A. 9184) and its revised Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR). It discusses the enactment of R.A. 9184, also known as the Government Procurement Reform Act (GPRA), in 2003 to consolidate procurement rules and regulations. It also summarizes the functions of important procurement organizations established under the law such as the Government Procurement Policy Board (GPPB) and Bids and Awards Committee (BAC).
class reporting for Government procurement act
Data from this report is taken online i do not claim to be the author
this is a compilation of data gathered for my classroom presentation only
This document provides an introduction to the legal framework of public procurement in Pakistan, including its past and present state. It discusses the findings of the 2000 World Bank Country Procurement Assessment Report which identified outdated rules, inefficiency, poor management, and lack of training as issues. The World Bank recommended enacting a modern procurement law based on international standards and creating an independent regulatory agency. This led to the establishment of the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) in 2002 to regulate procurement processes. The PPRA is responsible for developing rules and regulations to standardize procurement across federal organizations in Pakistan.
Got Problems with Government Procurement? Here's how to do it right.Ninfa Geloryao
The document outlines key provisions of the Philippine Procurement Act, which provides for modernization, regulation and standardization of government procurement activities. It establishes transparency, competitiveness, accountability and public monitoring as core principles. The Act requires all government procurement to be included in an Annual Procurement Plan and carried out by a Bids and Awards Committee, with technical working groups assisting in the process. It specifies roles and responsibilities for procurement planning, budgeting, contract management and imposing penalties for violations.
How to Win a Tender of NNEGC "Energoatom": 17 practical advicesНАЕК «Енергоатом»
1. Pay close attention to the language requirements for tender proposals as specified in the documentation. Proposals must be submitted in the language required, usually Ukrainian, and any foreign language documents may cause rejection.
2. The tender documentation may list technical errors that will not cause rejection, but if not specified, any mistakes can be grounds for rejection. Carefully follow all formatting requirements.
3. Submit all required documents and information as specified in the tender documentation, such as names, numbers, dates, etc. Request clarification if any requirements do not comply with legislation.
This presentation covers the types of audit, its practical implications, tools for conducting audits, how to plan an audit, and what the outcomes of audit planning and finally how to execute an audit.
The document outlines the bidding process for construction projects in the Philippines. It involves:
1. Detailed engineering studies to establish technical viability.
2. Advertising the project and inviting bids. Eligible bidders must meet requirements like licenses, permits, and financial capacity.
3. Bid evaluation involves checking documents, a pre-bid conference, submission of technical and financial proposals in sealed envelopes, and determining the lowest calculated responsive bid through evaluation and post-qualification.
4. The contract is awarded to the winning bidder with the lowest calculated responsive bid if they pass post-qualification.
GUSII MWALIMU SACCO TENDER DOCUMENTS 2015_2016Collo Juma
PROVISION OF ASSET MARKING SERVICES, PROVISION OF CONSULTANCY, TRAINING, AND HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES, PROVISION OF GUARDING SERVICES, PROVISION OF SACCO MOTOR VEHICLE REPAIRS AND MAINTENANCE SERVICES, PROVISION OF WEB DESIGN, HOSTING, EMAIL-INTRANET, SUPPLY, DEPLOYMENT AND MAINTENANCE OF FIRE FIGHTING
This document provides an overview of government contracting procedures in Colombia. It discusses five key things foreign investors should know, including that foreigners may participate in the selection process under the same conditions as Colombians if certain agreements are in place. It also outlines requirements like performance bonds, principles of objectivity and transparency, the need for foreign entities to register in the bidders registry, and permissible contracting modalities like public tenders, abbreviated selection processes, and selection based on qualifications.
The document summarizes 11 cases from the Court of Justice of the EU related to public procurement law. Key issues addressed include:
- Whether a tender of EUR 0.00 can be automatically rejected or requires further assessment.
- Whether subcontractors' exclusions can result in the main contractor's automatic exclusion.
- The conditions under which in-house contracts are permitted.
- Whether software transfers between public authorities fall under cooperation rules.
- Whether modifications can be reviewed ex officio after time limits have expired.
The Court provided interpretations balancing principles like proportionality, equal treatment, and legal certainty.
This document defines key terms and outlines the procurement process and alternative procurement methods for the Philippine government according to Republic Act 9184 or the Government Procurement Reform Act. It defines terms like bidding, blacklisting, performance security, and structures warranties. It also describes the different procurement methods like competitive bidding, limited source bidding, direct contracting, and negotiated procurement.
This document summarizes public procurement laws and processes in Vietnam. It discusses the key laws and regulations governing public procurement, including the bidding process. It outlines the steps involved in bidding for a public tender, including how to access tender documents and opportunities, requirements for bid submission, and processes after contract award. It also provides an overview of Vietnam's regulatory framework and procedures for filing complaints related to the public procurement process. Reforms to improve transparency and compliance with international standards are recommended.
This document outlines the bidding procedures for the procurement of goods by government agencies in the Philippines. It discusses key aspects of the bidding process such as the preparation of bidding documents, requirements for invitation to bid, advertising and posting requirements, eligibility requirements, and procedures for submission and receipt of bids. The overall purpose is to ensure transparency, accountability, and competitiveness in public procurement through a standardized bidding process.
This document outlines the Implementing Rules and Regulations of Republic Act No. 9184, otherwise known as the Government Procurement Reform Act. It discusses several key points:
1) It establishes rules and regulations for modernizing, standardizing, and regulating government procurement activities from planning through contract implementation and termination.
2) It declares the policy of the government to conduct competitive and transparent procurement through public bidding, with some exceptions.
3) It establishes principles like transparency, competitiveness, streamlined processes, accountability, and public monitoring to govern procurement.
4) It defines the scope, application, and terms used in the regulation, and mandates the standardization of procurement processes and forms.
The National Complaint Settlement Agency of the Republic of Moldova is an independent administrative authority that settles complaints related to public procurement contract procedures. It has the authority to review complaints, uphold or dismiss them, and decide whether to continue or cancel public procurement procedures. The Agency's staff includes counselors for solving complaints and public servants. Any affected party has the right to appeal a contracting authority's actions within 10 or 5 days, depending on the contract value. Appeals must be in writing and include specific details. The Agency aims to settle complaints within 20 days and makes decisions publicly available on its website. Its decisions are binding but can be challenged in court.
The document discusses public procurement policy and system in the Republic of Moldova. It provides the following key points:
- The system is decentralized, with contracting authorities responsible for planning and executing contracts, while the Ministry of Finance coordinates policies.
- Several public institutions play roles in supervision: the Ministry of Finance develops policies; the Public Procurement Agency implements policies and registers contracts; the Financial Inspection ensures protection of public financial interests; and the Court of Accounts exercises external audit control.
- There is potential for conflict of interest as the Public Procurement Agency registers contracts and also examines disputes, though a new Complaints Settlement Agency is being established to handle disputes.
- Priorities for 2014 include capacity building,
Presentation by Zoran Blazevic, Croatia, on the case law of the High Administrative Court in Croatia against the procurement review bodies' decisions, at the SIGMA 2nd webinar on public procurement reality and challenges of post COVID, held on 9 March 2021. This webinar is the follow-up on the 1st webinar which took place on 26 January 2021 (https://www.slideshare.net/SIGMA2013/tag/ipa260121pup).
Presentation by Marc Steiner, Switzerland, on the practice of the Swiss Federal Administrative Court on public procurement, at the SIGMA 2nd webinar on public procurement reality and challenges of post COVID, held on 9 March 2021. This webinar is the follow-up on the 1st webinar which took place on 26 January 2021 (https://www.slideshare.net/SIGMA2013/tag/ipa260121pup).
PUBLIC PROCUREMENT REGIME & AN OVERVIEW OF PUBLIC PROCUREMENT RULES, 2004 Nadeem Khan
This document provides an overview of Pakistan's public procurement regime, including the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA), applicable laws and regulations, key definitions, procurement principles, and methods. Some of the main points covered include:
- The PPRA was established in 2002 to regulate public procurement and ensure compliance with international standards.
- Procurement rules cover the acquisition of goods, works and services by federal government agencies and organizations.
- Procurement must follow principles of fairness, transparency, efficiency and value for money. Accepted methods include petty purchases, quotations, and open competitive bidding depending on financial limits.
- Detailed requirements address specifications, approval processes, advertising methods, response times
The document provides background information on the historical development of procurement laws in the Philippines and an overview of the key provisions of Republic Act 9184 (R.A. 9184) and its revised Implementing Rules and Regulations (IRR). It discusses the enactment of R.A. 9184, also known as the Government Procurement Reform Act (GPRA), in 2003 to consolidate procurement rules and regulations. It also summarizes the functions of important procurement organizations established under the law such as the Government Procurement Policy Board (GPPB) and Bids and Awards Committee (BAC).
class reporting for Government procurement act
Data from this report is taken online i do not claim to be the author
this is a compilation of data gathered for my classroom presentation only
This document provides an introduction to the legal framework of public procurement in Pakistan, including its past and present state. It discusses the findings of the 2000 World Bank Country Procurement Assessment Report which identified outdated rules, inefficiency, poor management, and lack of training as issues. The World Bank recommended enacting a modern procurement law based on international standards and creating an independent regulatory agency. This led to the establishment of the Public Procurement Regulatory Authority (PPRA) in 2002 to regulate procurement processes. The PPRA is responsible for developing rules and regulations to standardize procurement across federal organizations in Pakistan.
Got Problems with Government Procurement? Here's how to do it right.Ninfa Geloryao
The document outlines key provisions of the Philippine Procurement Act, which provides for modernization, regulation and standardization of government procurement activities. It establishes transparency, competitiveness, accountability and public monitoring as core principles. The Act requires all government procurement to be included in an Annual Procurement Plan and carried out by a Bids and Awards Committee, with technical working groups assisting in the process. It specifies roles and responsibilities for procurement planning, budgeting, contract management and imposing penalties for violations.
How to Win a Tender of NNEGC "Energoatom": 17 practical advicesНАЕК «Енергоатом»
1. Pay close attention to the language requirements for tender proposals as specified in the documentation. Proposals must be submitted in the language required, usually Ukrainian, and any foreign language documents may cause rejection.
2. The tender documentation may list technical errors that will not cause rejection, but if not specified, any mistakes can be grounds for rejection. Carefully follow all formatting requirements.
3. Submit all required documents and information as specified in the tender documentation, such as names, numbers, dates, etc. Request clarification if any requirements do not comply with legislation.
This presentation covers the types of audit, its practical implications, tools for conducting audits, how to plan an audit, and what the outcomes of audit planning and finally how to execute an audit.
The document outlines the bidding process for construction projects in the Philippines. It involves:
1. Detailed engineering studies to establish technical viability.
2. Advertising the project and inviting bids. Eligible bidders must meet requirements like licenses, permits, and financial capacity.
3. Bid evaluation involves checking documents, a pre-bid conference, submission of technical and financial proposals in sealed envelopes, and determining the lowest calculated responsive bid through evaluation and post-qualification.
4. The contract is awarded to the winning bidder with the lowest calculated responsive bid if they pass post-qualification.
GUSII MWALIMU SACCO TENDER DOCUMENTS 2015_2016Collo Juma
PROVISION OF ASSET MARKING SERVICES, PROVISION OF CONSULTANCY, TRAINING, AND HUMAN RESOURCE DEVELOPMENT SERVICES, PROVISION OF GUARDING SERVICES, PROVISION OF SACCO MOTOR VEHICLE REPAIRS AND MAINTENANCE SERVICES, PROVISION OF WEB DESIGN, HOSTING, EMAIL-INTRANET, SUPPLY, DEPLOYMENT AND MAINTENANCE OF FIRE FIGHTING
This document provides an overview of government contracting procedures in Colombia. It discusses five key things foreign investors should know, including that foreigners may participate in the selection process under the same conditions as Colombians if certain agreements are in place. It also outlines requirements like performance bonds, principles of objectivity and transparency, the need for foreign entities to register in the bidders registry, and permissible contracting modalities like public tenders, abbreviated selection processes, and selection based on qualifications.
The document summarizes 11 cases from the Court of Justice of the EU related to public procurement law. Key issues addressed include:
- Whether a tender of EUR 0.00 can be automatically rejected or requires further assessment.
- Whether subcontractors' exclusions can result in the main contractor's automatic exclusion.
- The conditions under which in-house contracts are permitted.
- Whether software transfers between public authorities fall under cooperation rules.
- Whether modifications can be reviewed ex officio after time limits have expired.
The Court provided interpretations balancing principles like proportionality, equal treatment, and legal certainty.
This document defines key terms and outlines the procurement process and alternative procurement methods for the Philippine government according to Republic Act 9184 or the Government Procurement Reform Act. It defines terms like bidding, blacklisting, performance security, and structures warranties. It also describes the different procurement methods like competitive bidding, limited source bidding, direct contracting, and negotiated procurement.
This document summarizes public procurement laws and processes in Vietnam. It discusses the key laws and regulations governing public procurement, including the bidding process. It outlines the steps involved in bidding for a public tender, including how to access tender documents and opportunities, requirements for bid submission, and processes after contract award. It also provides an overview of Vietnam's regulatory framework and procedures for filing complaints related to the public procurement process. Reforms to improve transparency and compliance with international standards are recommended.
VIETNAM – THE WORLD BANK GROUP IS ASKING DUANE MORRIS ABOUT PUBLIC PROCUREMENTDr. Oliver Massmann
The document provides information about a case study involving a public road resurfacing project in Vietnam. It describes the project, assumptions about the bidding company BidCo, and phases of the procurement process. The World Bank Group is asking Duane Morris for information about Vietnam's public procurement laws and practices as they relate to this case study.
LAWYER IN VIETNAM DR. OLIVER MASSMANN – PUBLIC PROCUREMENT – THE WORLD BANK I...Dr. Oliver Massmann
LAWYER IN VIETNAM DR. OLIVER MASSMANN – PUBLIC PROCUREMENT – THE WORLD BANK IS ASKING DUANE MORRIS VIETNAM ON THE RELEVANT REGULATIONS ON PUBLIC PROCUREMENT – HERE ARE OUR ANSWERS:
LAWYER IN VIETNAM DR. OLIVER MASSMANN – PUBLIC PROCUREMENT – THE WORLD BANK I...Dr. Oliver Massmann
LAWYER IN VIETNAM DR. OLIVER MASSMANN – PUBLIC PROCUREMENT – THE WORLD BANK IS ASKING DUANE MORRIS VIETNAM ON THE RELEVANT REGULATIONS ON PUBLIC PROCUREMENT – HERE ARE OUR ANSWERS:
Understanding Pre Qualification QuestionnairesLloyd Sewell
Tendering for contracts training offers a comprehensive training programme provided by small enterprise support specialists and public sector support specialists for small firms who wish to develop new revenue streams by tendering for public sector contracts.
The document summarizes key aspects of the Government Procurement Act (RA 9184) in the Philippines. It outlines the scope, transparency requirements, competitive bidding process, roles of the Bids and Awards Committee and Technical Working Group in procurement. It also discusses the importance of the Annual Procurement Plan, Procurement Project Management Plans, and penalties for offenses committed in the procurement process. The goal of the Act is to standardize and regulate government procurement through transparency, competitiveness, and accountability.
This document is a bidding document for the procurement of construction works for a building project in Ethiopia. It provides instructions to bidders on the bidding process, including eligibility requirements, submission of bids, bid evaluation and contract award. The works involve the construction of the AGORA building one project. Bidders are required to submit their bids by the deadline of June 2014 and the bidding process will be conducted according to the procurement laws and regulations of Ethiopia.
The document summarizes key aspects of the Philippine Government Procurement Act (RA 9184), including:
- It defines government procurement and mandates its use for all government entities.
- It establishes principles of transparency, competitiveness, and accountability in procurement.
- It outlines the roles and responsibilities of the Bids and Awards Committee, Technical Working Group, and Head of Procuring Entity in procurement processes.
- It discusses requirements for procurement planning including the Annual Procurement Plan and Procurement Project Management Plans.
- It describes penalties for offenses committed in violation of the Act.
The document is a bidding document from the Federal Democratic Republic of Ethiopia for the procurement of construction works for a residential building. It contains instructions to bidders, general bidding procedures and requirements, evaluation criteria, standard contract forms, and details of the scope of work. The project involves the construction of a G+1 residential building, with a procurement reference number of G/03/10/2014. The bidding document was issued on June 11, 2022 in Addis Ababa.
This document provides guidelines and procedures for competitive bidding for procurement of goods by the Philippine government. It outlines the bidding process, including eligibility requirements, bid preparation and submission, bid opening, and evaluation. The guidelines are intended to promote transparency and fairness in public procurement. Key points include:
- The bidding process will follow Philippine procurement laws and regulations.
- Eligible bidders must meet track record and nationality requirements.
- Bids must include technical and financial components with sufficient detail on specifications, delivery, etc.
- Bid prices must remain valid for a specified period. Late bids will not be accepted.
- The procuring entity will evaluate bids based on completeness of documents and pass/fail
Indonesia’s Model Document for Sustainable Procurement Selection for Construc...AHRP Law Firm
In an effort to achieve significant benefits and reduce negative impacts on the environment throughout the entire work cycle, the Deputy for Strategic Development and Policy of the National Public Procurement Agency (LKPP) issued NPPA Deputy Decree Number 3 of 2024 concerning the Sustainable Procurement Document Model for Construction Works (NPPA Deputy Decree 3/2024), which has been in effect since 19 February 2024. Find out more about our insights related to this topic in our Legal Brief publication.
This document outlines the Tamil Nadu Transparency in Tenders Act and Rules which provide transparency in public procurement in Tamil Nadu. It defines procuring entities, categories and types of procurement contracts. It describes the roles of Tender Inviting and Accepting Authorities and the tendering process including notice, evaluation, acceptance and special provisions. The objective is to regulate procedures for inviting and accepting tenders in a transparent manner.
The document summarizes Montenegro's public procurement legislative framework and plans for further development. It provides an overview of the key laws and regulations governing public procurement procedures in Montenegro. It also outlines the principles, timelines, exemptions, reporting requirements, and assessment of alignment with the EU public procurement directives. There are plans to further harmonize procurement laws with EU standards and introduce more flexible procedures and electronic procurement tools to enhance the public procurement system.
Article: The Power of a Stamp or On the Confidentiality of Documents Submitte...Țuca Zbârcea & Asociații
Lately, there have been increasing talks about the confidentiality of documents submitted by economic operators in procedures of awarding public procurement contracts, about the need to specifically and efficiently ensure the confidentiality of these documents, but also about the obligation of contracting authorities to ensure the transparency of the public procurement process.
Terms of reference CLPE auction Nº3 - 2021ProColombia
1) The document outlines the terms of reference for auction CLPE 03-2021, which aims to promote long-term electricity generation contracts through a competitive bidding process.
2) Interested parties can register to participate as buyers or sellers between August 17-27, and must submit prequalification documents by September 6 to meet technical, financial, and legal requirements.
3) Prequalified participants will submit binding offers by September 29. Contracts will be awarded based on competition criteria and price caps, with the goal of meeting the target demand for electricity. Winning bidders must then sign electricity supply contracts and post compliance guarantees.
The document provides an overview of procurement procedures in Nandi County, Kenya. It discusses the legal framework established by the Public Procurement and Disposal Act of 2005. It also outlines the key steps in the procurement cycle, including preparation of procurement plans and specifications, prequalification of bidders, advertisement of tenders, bid opening and evaluation, contract award, and contract administration. Maintaining transparency and fairness throughout the procurement process is emphasized.
Public procurement regularity authority (ppra)TaseerBaloch1
The document discusses the Public Procurement Regularity Authority (PPRA) of Pakistan. It provides background on the need for procurement reforms that led to the establishment of PPRA in 2002. It outlines PPRA's functions of improving governance and transparency in public procurement. It also describes PPRA's legal framework and the public procurement rules and regulations it has established. The document then provides details on the public procurement process and cycle in Pakistan according to PPRA's rules and guidelines.
Similar to Lawyer in Vietnam - Dr. Oliver Massmann THE WORLD BANK IS ASKING DUANE MORRIS ON GOVERNMENT AND PUBLIC PROCUREMENT HERE ARE OUR ANSWERS: (20)
VIETNAM — Anwalt in Vietnam Dr. Oliver Massmann Corporate Sustainability Due ...Dr. Oliver Massmann
VIETNAM — Anwalt in Vietnam Dr. Oliver Massmann Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD oder das EU-Lieferkettengesetz): Umfassende Analyse und Ausblick auf die Auswirkungen auf Unternehmen in Vietnam
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...Dr. Oliver Massmann
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chain Law): A Comprehensive Analysis and Review of its Implications on Vietnam-based Companies
Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to enco...Dr. Oliver Massmann
Legal Alert - Vietnam - First draft Decree on mechanisms and policies to encourage the development of rooftop solar power systems for self-consumption purpose
OMassmann - Investment into the grid and transmission system in Vietnam (2024...Dr. Oliver Massmann
The document summarizes Vietnam's Power Development Plan 8 (PDP8), which aims to ensure national energy security by 2050 through increasing renewable energy and developing the transmission grid system. Key points include: (1) PDP8 sets renewable energy targets of 47% by 2030 and 67.5-71.5% by 2050; (2) $134.7 billion will be invested in power generation and transmission from 2021-2030; (3) the plan encourages private investment and development of the transmission grid system.
Vietnam's Plan for Implementation of PDP8 – Key HighlightsDr. Oliver Massmann
The Prime Minister of Vietnam approved the Plan for Implementation of the National Power Development Plan to 2030 (PDP8) on April 1, 2024. The Implementation Plan sets specific tasks and timelines for government ministries to execute PDP8 through 2025. It maintains planned capacity targets for power generation projects such as gas, coal, and hydropower. However, it does not provide guidelines to address issues like project bankability and feed-in tariffs. The Implementation Plan also lists onshore wind and solar power projects and targets, while prioritizing the development of relevant legal frameworks through 2025 to fully implement PDP8 by 2030.
VIETNAM - THE NEW LAW ON CREDIT INSTITUTIONS - WHAT YOU MUST KNOW:Dr. Oliver Massmann
The National Assembly of Vietnam passed a new Law on Credit Institutions that takes effect on July 1, 2024. The objectives of the new law are to strengthen the resilience of the banking system, increase the independence and accountability of credit institutions, and improve oversight of the banking industry. Key changes include new rules around cross-ownership in commercial banks, managing bad debts, and providing a legal framework for digital banking. These regulations are intended to further develop Vietnam's market infrastructure and move the country closer to emerging market status. However, Vietnam remains a frontier market, and guidance on the new law could focus more on ensuring availability of information and streamlined processes to set up investment accounts to help Vietnam achieve emerging market status sooner. The new law
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...Dr. Oliver Massmann
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chain Law): A Comprehensive Analysis and Review of its Implications on Vietnam-based Companies
Vietnam's National Energy Development Strategy – Key HighlightsDr. Oliver Massmann
The Prime Minister of Vietnam approved the National Energy Development Strategy to 2030 and vision to 2045 to ensure national energy security and sustainable development. The strategy aims to meet domestic energy demand through 2030 by supplying 150-170 million tons of oil equivalent primarily through renewable sources comprising 15-20% of supply by 2030 and 65-70% by 2045. It also seeks to reduce greenhouse gas emissions from energy by 15-35% by 2030 and 70-80% by 2045. The Ministry of Industry and Trade will implement policies and proposed legislation to develop an interconnected energy market, encourage private investment in renewable projects, and establish a framework for direct power purchase agreements between renewable producers and customers.
Anwalt in Vietnam Dr. Oliver Massmann Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence ...Dr. Oliver Massmann
Anwalt in Vietnam Dr. Oliver Massmann Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD oder das EU-Lieferkettengesetz): Umfassende Analyse und Ausblick auf die Auswirkungen auf Unternehmen in Vietnam
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chai...Dr. Oliver Massmann
Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence Directive (CSDDD or the EU Supply Chain Law): A Comprehensive Analysis and Review of its Implications on Vietnam-based Companies
Sangyun Lee, 'Why Korea's Merger Control Occasionally Fails: A Public Choice ...Sangyun Lee
Presentation slides for a session held on June 4, 2024, at Kyoto University. This presentation is based on the presenter’s recent paper, coauthored with Hwang Lee, Professor, Korea University, with the same title, published in the Journal of Business Administration & Law, Volume 34, No. 2 (April 2024). The paper, written in Korean, is available at <https://shorturl.at/GCWcI>.
सुप्रीम कोर्ट ने यह भी माना था कि मजिस्ट्रेट का यह कर्तव्य है कि वह सुनिश्चित करे कि अधिकारी पीएमएलए के तहत निर्धारित प्रक्रिया के साथ-साथ संवैधानिक सुरक्षा उपायों का भी उचित रूप से पालन करें।
Business law for the students of undergraduate level. The presentation contains the summary of all the chapters under the syllabus of State University, Contract Act, Sale of Goods Act, Negotiable Instrument Act, Partnership Act, Limited Liability Act, Consumer Protection Act.
Receivership and liquidation Accounts
Being a Paper Presented at Business Recovery and Insolvency Practitioners Association of Nigeria (BRIPAN) on Friday, August 18, 2023.
What are the common challenges faced by women lawyers working in the legal pr...lawyersonia
The legal profession, which has historically been male-dominated, has experienced a significant increase in the number of women entering the field over the past few decades. Despite this progress, women lawyers continue to encounter various challenges as they strive for top positions.
Corporate Governance : Scope and Legal Frameworkdevaki57
CORPORATE GOVERNANCE
MEANING
Corporate Governance refers to the way in which companies are governed and to what purpose. It identifies who has power and accountability, and who makes decisions. It is, in essence, a toolkit that enables management and the board to deal more effectively with the challenges of running a company.
The Future of Criminal Defense Lawyer in India.pdfveteranlegal
https://veteranlegal.in/defense-lawyer-in-india/ | Criminal defense Lawyer in India has always been a vital aspect of the country's legal system. As defenders of justice, criminal Defense Lawyer play a critical role in ensuring that individuals accused of crimes receive a fair trial and that their constitutional rights are protected. As India evolves socially, economically, and technologically, the role and future of criminal Defense Lawyer are also undergoing significant changes. This comprehensive blog explores the current landscape, challenges, technological advancements, and prospects for criminal Defense Lawyer in India.
Guide on the use of Artificial Intelligence-based tools by lawyers and law fi...Massimo Talia
This guide aims to provide information on how lawyers will be able to use the opportunities provided by AI tools and how such tools could help the business processes of small firms. Its objective is to provide lawyers with some background to understand what they can and cannot realistically expect from these products. This guide aims to give a reference point for small law practices in the EU
against which they can evaluate those classes of AI applications that are probably the most relevant for them.
Genocide in International Criminal Law.pptxMasoudZamani13
Excited to share insights from my recent presentation on genocide! 💡 In light of ongoing debates, it's crucial to delve into the nuances of this grave crime.
The Work Permit for Self-Employed Persons in Italy
Lawyer in Vietnam - Dr. Oliver Massmann THE WORLD BANK IS ASKING DUANE MORRIS ON GOVERNMENT AND PUBLIC PROCUREMENT HERE ARE OUR ANSWERS:
1. Lawyer in Vietnam - Dr. Oliver Massmann
THE WORLD BANK IS ASKING DUANE MORRIS
ON GOVERNMENT AND PUBLIC PROCUREMENT
HERE ARE OUR ANSWERS:
1. Legal framework and reform update
1. Which is the entity that conducts procurement for the authority that owns the majority of roads
in Vietnam ?
Ho Chi Minh City's People Committee
2. Are you aware of any change (in practice or in laws/regulations/procedures) related to public
procurement between June 1, 2017 and May 1, 2018? For example: amendments to applicable public
procurement laws, enactment and/or implementation of new regulations, implementation or improvement
of e-procurement platforms, changes to the bid security and performance guarantee framework, etc.
No
3. Please provide a list of the laws, regulations and other binding materials (including mandatory
standard procurement documents and contracts) that regulate public procurement in Vietnam.
Please include legislation or other binding materials promulgated at the national/federal level as well as
any additional legislation that is applicable to the procuring entity described in Section 1.
The Civil Code of Vietnam No. 91/2015/QH13 by the National Assembly of Vietnam dated 24 November
2015 ("Civil Code");
Construction Law No. 50/2014/QH13 by the National Assembly dated 18 June 2014 ("Construction
Law");
Law on Bidding No. 43/2013/QH13 by National Assembly dated 26 November 2013 ("Bidding Law");
Law on Public Investment No. 49/2014/QH13 of the National Assembly dated 18 June 2014 ("Law on
Public Investment");
Commercial Law No. 36/2005/Qh11 by the National Assembly dated 14 June 2005 ("Commercial Law");
Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP by the Government dated 26 June 2014 guiding Law on Bidding ("Decree
No.63/2014/ND-CP");
Decree No. 37/2015/ND-CP by the Government dated 22 April 2015 on detailing construction contracts
("Decree No. 37/2015/ND-CP");
Decree No. 46/2015/ND-CP by the Government dated on 12 May 2015 on managing the quality and
maintenance of construction works ("Decree No. 46/2015/ND-CP");
Decree No. 30/2015/ND-CP by the Government dated 17 March 2015 on detailing certain provisions of
the Law on Bidding on selection of bidders ("Decree No. 30/2015/ND-CP");
Decree No. 15/2015/ND-CP by the Government dated 14 February 2015 on public-private partnership
investment ("Decree No. 15/2015/ND-CP");
2. Circular No. 04/2017/TT-BKHDT by the Ministry of Planning and Investment dated 15 November 2017
on detailing the selection of bidders via the national biding portal ("Circular No. 04/2017/TT-BKHDT");
Circular No. 26/2016/TT-BXD by the Ministry of Construction dated 26 October 2016 on detailing
certain provisions on management of quality and maintenance of construction works ("Circular No.
26/2016/TTBXD");
Circular No. 10/2016/TT-BKHDT of the Ministry of Planning and Investment on detailing the
supervision, following up and examination of bidding activities ("Circular No. 10/2016/TT-BKHDT");
Circular No. 23/2015/TT_BKHDT by the Ministry of Planning and Investment dated 21 December 2015
on detailing the making the evaluation report on bidding documents ("Circular No.
23/2015/TTBKHDT");
Circular No. 10/2015/TT-BKHDT of the Ministry of Planning and Investment dated 26 October 2015 on
detailing the plan for bidder selection ("Circular No. 10/2015/TT-BKHDT");
Circular No. 01/2015/TT-BKHDT by the Ministry of Planning and Investment dated 14 February 2015
on detailing the preparation of Invitation dossier for Concern, Invitation Dossier for Bidding, and Request
dossider for consultancy services ("Circular No. 01/2015/TT-BKHDT");
Circular No. 17/2010/TT-BKH by the Ministry of Planning and Investment dated 22 July 2010 detailing
a pilot online bidding program ("Circular No. 17/2010/TT-BKH");
Official Letter No. 5356/BKHDT-QLDT by the Ministry of Planning and Investment dated 18 August
2014 on registration of bidder's information on national bidding network system;
Official Letter No. 4962/BKHDT-QLDT by the Ministry of Planning and Investment dated 31 July 2014
on the implementation of Law on Bidding No. 43/2013/QH13 regarding investors selection;
Official Letter No. 4054/BKHDT-QLDT by the Ministry of Planning and Investment dated 7 June 2014
on implementation of Law on Bidding No. 43/2013/QH13 and Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP;
Official Letter No. 5186/BKHDT-QLDT by the Ministry of Planning and Investment dated 11 August
2014 guiding to carry out to provide and publish bidding information in the transitional period.
4. Please list any mandatory standard tender documents and/or standard contract terms that the
Procuring Entity must use for a contract like the one described in Section 1.
3. p/ Other contents.
5. Are you aware of any change (in practice or in laws/regulations/procedures) related to public
procurement between May 2, 2019 and May 1, 2020? For example: amendments to applicable public
procurement laws, enactment and/or implementation of new regulations, implementation or improvement
of e-procurement platforms, changes to the bid security and performance guarantee framework, etc.
No
2. E-procurement Platforms and Statistics
6. If one or several electronic procurement portal(s) (i.e., an official website(s) specifically and
exclusively dedicated to public procurement) are in operation, please mark which platform would
most commonly be used by the Procuring Entity.
National level - Link: www.muasamcong.mpi.gov.vn
7. If a procurement portal is used by the procuring entity, how many works contracts are procured
through the portal?
More than 75%
8. If electronic procurement portals are available, please indicate which of the following actions can
be performed through each portal:
Accessing notices on procurement opportunities: Procuring entity and bidders
Accessing tender documentation: Procuring entity and bidders
Accessing tender documentation: Procuring entity and bidders
Asking the procuring entity for clarifications: Bidders
Submitting tenders: Bidders
Submitting bid security: Bidders
Opening bids: Procuring entity
Notifying decisions (clarification, award,etc.): Procuring entity
Accessing award decisions: Procuring entity and bidders
Accessing explanations of award decisions: Procuring entity and bidders
Submitting performance guarantees: Bidders
Signing the contract: Procuring entity and bidders
Contract terms must specify:
a/ Applied legal bases;
b/ Language used in the contract,
c/ Content and volume of work;
d/ Quality, technical requirements of work; pre-acceptance test and handover;
dd/ Contract performance duration and schedule;
e/ Contract price, advance payment, currency used in payment, and payment for the contract;
g/ Contract performance security, contract advance guarantee;
h/ Adjustment of the construction contract;
i/ Rights and obligations of the parties to the construction contract;
k/ Liability for violations of the contract, rewards and fines for violations of the contract;
l/ Suspension and termination of the contract;
m/ Settlement of disputes over the contract;
n/ Risks and force majeure events;
o/ Settlement and liquidation of the contract;
4. 9. Which of the following information about road works contracts procured by the Procuring
Entity is made publicly available?
Phases of the Procurement Process
This section of the questionnaire follows the chronological evolution of a procurement cycle, starting with
the process the Procuring Entity undertakes to assess its needs and secure the budget. Section 4 also
explores the steps that a local company would have to undertake in order to: (i) secure a government
contract; (ii) deliver the agreed-upon works; and (iii) obtain payment.
Phase 1: Budgeting and Needs Assessment
For the definition of “procuring entity”, please refer to Section 1.
10. According to the legal framework, when the Procuring Entity prepares to advertise a new
procurement opportunity for a contract like the one described in Section 1, what are used to
estimate the contract value and projected length of works?
Market analysis, Standardized unit cost, Project-specific technical drawings, Similar projects from
previous years, price evaluation result by authorized state agency or price evaluation enterprise for assets,
goods and services subject to price evaluation under the Law on Price.
11. In practice, is the estimated contract value/budget published in the tender notice/tender
documents?
Yes, contract value
12. Is the Procuring Entity required to have already allocated budget to a specific project before
tendering?
Yes, there is a specific budget allocatior Comment:
13. How often does the Procuring Entity award a contract without having all the necessary funds?
Rarely (between 10-25%)
Phrase 2: from Advertisement to Bid Submission
The following questions relate to the initial phase of the procurement process, focusing on how the
procurement method is chosen, how the tender is advertised, and how bids are collected from the private
sector.
14.According to the legal framework, would open tendering (i.e., the process in which any business
can submit a bid) be the default method of procurement in Vietnam for a contract like the one
Cost Duration
(days)
Web link
for
resourceEstimated cost/length/completion time - as calculated
by the Procuring Entity at the time of advertising the
procurement opportunity.
Contract cost/length/completion time - as agreed upon
in the contract signed by the Procuring Entity and the
contractor.
□ □
Actual cost/length/completion time - as measured at
project completion.
□ □
5. described in Section 1?
No, Section 1, Chapter 2 of the Bidding Law
15. According to the legal framework, can the Procuring Entity require bidders to participate in a
prequalification process specific to that contract before being able to submit their economic offer?
Yes. Article 22 and 24 of Decree 63/2014/ND-CP
16. In practice, what is the most common method of procurement for a contract like the one
described in Section 1?
Open tendering is not the default, but remains the most common for a case comparable to the case study.
17. Does the legal framework define the situations in which open tendering must be used (including
thresholds)? If the legal framework regulates exceptions to open tendering, please list them.
Yes. Article 20 of the Bidding Law. Exceptions to open tendering are cases under restrictive tendering,
direct award, competitive dialogue, direct procurement, self-implementation, community's and
participation selection of bidders in some special cases (Articles 21-27 of the Bidding Law)
18. Does the legal framework prohibit dividing contracts to circumvent thresholds for open
tendering?
Yes. Article 89.6 (k) of the Bidding Law
In practice, how often does this happen?
Very rarely (< 10% of cases)
19. Which of the following materials need to be made publicly available by the procuring entity?
By law and Publicly available in practice
Procurement plans: Article 8.1 of the Bidding Law
Tender notices: Article 8.1 of the Bidding Law
Tender documents and technical specifications: Article 8.1 of the Bidding Law
Notices of award / bidding results: Article 8.1 of the Bidding Law
Tender Notices & Tender Documents
20. According to the legal framework, is there a minimum time limit between the advertisement of
the tender notice and the submission deadline for an open tendering procedure like the one
described in Section 1?
Yes. Article 12.1.e of the Bidding Law
In practice, how many days would pass between the advertisement of the tender notice and the
submission deadline for a case like the one described in Section 1?
30 -40 days
21. Does the legal framework establish the minimum content of the tender notice and tender
documents? If "Yes", please list the requirements.
Yes.
Articles 8 of Bidding Law:
a) The plan on selection of contractors, investors;
6. b) Notice of invitation for expression of interest, notice of invitation for pre-qualification;
c) Notice of invitation for quotation, notice of bid invitation;
d) Short list;
dd) Results of selection of contractors, investors;
e) Results of bid opening for bidding via network;
g) Information on handling of violations of law on bidding;
h) Legal documents on bidding;
i) List of investment projects in the form of public-private partnership, projects with land use;
k) The database of bidders, investors, bidding experts, lecturers of bidding, and establishments of training
on bidding;
l) Other relevant information.
Subcontracting
22. Does the legal framework regulate subcontracting?
Yes. Article 128.2 of Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP
23. According to the legal framework, if the intent to subcontract was not disclosed in the bid, what
is the contractor who decides to subcontract after the contract is signed required to do?
The matter is not regulated.
Clarifications
24. When a potential bidder seeks clarifications on the tender documents from the procuring entity,
what is the most common way of addressing them?
The procuring entity addresses all clarifications in a public meeting.
The procuring entity will answer, and it is always required to communicate the answer to all other bidders
too - Legal basis: Article 14.2 (c) of Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP
Bid Security
25. Does the legal framework require BidCo to provide a form of bid guarantee?
Yes. Article 11.1 of the Bidding Law
7. 26. If BidCo is required, what is the most common instrument of bid security deposit?
Cash/Bank guarantee / letter of credit
Phase 3: from Bid Opening to Contract Signing
The following questions relate to bid opening, bid evaluation, exclusions and contract signing. When
answering these questions, please continue to refer to the case study assumptions outlined in Section 1.
For the definition of “procuring entity", please refer to Section 1.
27. Does the legal framework establish a timeframe for the procuring entity to proceed to bid
opening once the deadline for bid submission has been reached?
Yes. Article 14.3(b) of Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP
In practice, how many days after the deadline for bid submission does the Procuring Entity proceed
to bid opening? If bid opening is carried out in multiple sessions, please answer this question
considering the first session. If bid opening happens immediately, please indicate 0 days.
0 days
28. In practice, in a case comparable to the case study scenario, how many days would pass between
bid opening and public notice of award (i.e., the moment in which all tenderers, participants and
relevant parties are notified of the award decision), considering that no complaint/challenges/protests
have been filed? In this estimate, please include the time to evaluate the bids, notify all bidders of the
decision and notify the winner of the award. If there is no public notice, please indicate the time until
notification of BidCo.
Time: 45 – 60 days. Main reasons for delay: The bidder selection result must be verified or there needs
some amendments to the bidding dossiers/ documents.
29. Is there a standstill (or pause) period between public notice of award and contract signing to
allow unsuccessful bidders to challenge the award decision?
No
30. In practice, in a case comparable to the case study scenario, how many days would pass on
average between public notice of award and contract signing? Please include the time for the winner
to submit relevant documents and the time to sign the contract.
Time: 20 – 25 days
31. In practice, how many days would pass on average between contract signing and receipt of a
notice to proceed with the works?
Time: 0 days or upon receipt of the performance security by the procuring entity.
Main reasons for delay: No receipt of the performance security
Does BidCo need to obtain work permits or other administrative authorizations between public
notice of award and contract signing? Please include environmental permits, occupancy permits,
activity permits, etc. as applicable.
No
Evaluation & Award
8. 32. Does the legal framework regulate how members of the selection committee are chosen?
Yes. Article 116, Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP
33. Are employees of the procuring entity required to follow a mandatory code of conduct or ethics
that includes topics like screening procedures, conflict of interest, training requirements, etc.?
No. Not mentioned in the laws
34. According to the legal framework, what would be the award criterion considering a case like the
one described in Section 1?
Price - Legal basis: Article 39.1 of the Bidding Law
Price and other qualitative elements (i.e., best value for money or the most advantageous combination of
cost, time to completion, quality and sustainability, or the most economically advantageous tender) -
Legal
basis: Article 39.2 of the Bidding Law
Other, please explain: Combination of technical and price assessment (Article 39.3 of the Bidding Law)
35. In practice, how often is the award decision based solely on price and not on best value for
money?
Very rarely (<10% of cases)
36. Does the legal framework establish criteria to identify abnormally low bids?
No
37. Does the legal framework define what constitutes a non-substantial error?
Yes, Article 17, Decree 63/2014/ND-CP
In practice, how often does the Procuring Entity require bidders to amend their offers (because of
mistakes, arithmetic errors, etc.)?
Occasionally (between 25-50%)
In practice, in these cases would the bidder be given the opportunity to rectify such error before
dis-qualification?
Yes, Article 17, Decree no. 63/2014/ND-CP
Exclusion & Loss
38. When a bidder is unsuccessful (either because of exclusion or loss), is it provided with an
explanation of the reasons for the exclusion/loss in writing?
Yes, by law the bidder must always be provided with an explanation in writing, according to Article 20.6
(b) of Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP; within 5 workings days from the time the bidding result is approved.
If “Yes”, is the bidder usually told early enough so that it can challenge the exclusion/loss in a
timely manner?
Yes
39. When a bidder loses, is it provided with an explanation of the reasons for the loss in writing?
9. Yes, the bidder must always be provided with an explanation in writing, according to Article 20.6(b)
Decree no.63/2014/ND-CP
Phase 4: Contract Management
Performance Guarantee
40. According to the legal framework, is BidCo required to provide a performance guarantee
deposit that ensures a source of compensation in case of failure to perform its contractual
obligations?
Yes. Amount: 2%- 10% of the bid winning price.
Articles 66 & 72 of the Bidding Law.
41. If BidCo is required, what is the most common instrument of performance guarantee?
Certificate of deposit
Bank Guarantee / Letter of Credit
Payment retention until satisfactory completion of the contract
42. In practice, how long does it usually take for the procuring entity to return the performance
guarantee in full once the certificate of completion of works is issued?
5-10 days
Contract Renegotiations / Amendments
43. Does the legal framework regulate contract renegotiation? If "Yes", please indicate the relevant
provisions.
Yes. Article 67 of the Bidding Law and Article 93 of Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP
44. How often would a contract like the one described in Section 1 be renegotiated?
Occasionally (between 25-50%)
45. If the contract described in Section 1 were more complex (i.e., lengthier and/or more costly
execution, more complex scope or object, etc.), how often would it be renegotiated?
Often (between 50-90%)
46. According to the legal framework, is there a percentage of price increase below which the
procuring entity is not required to provide a reason for the renegotiation? If "Yes", please provide
the percentage and the relevant legal basis.
No.
47. According to the legal framework, is there a percentage of price increase above which the
procuring entity is not allowed to renegotiate and is always required to re-tender? If"Yes", please
provide the percentage and the relevant legal basis.
No.
48. In practice, are the results of contract renegotiations made publicly available?
No. Not addressed by law but practically No
10. 49. In practice, how many days would pass on average from the moment one of the parties requests/
initiates a renegotiation of the contract until a new contract amendment is signed?
It varies upon the negociation
50. How often do bidders submit unrealistically low bids to win the contract, confident of having a
possibility to renegotiate at a later stage?
Occasionally (25-50%)
51. How often are "emergencies" used as a reason to renegotiate?
Very rarely (<10% of cases)
52. How often would a changing (variation) order/price adjustment (i.e. a modification below a
certain threshold or clearly defined in the terms of the contract) take place in a contract like the
one described in Section 1?
Occasionally (25-50%)
In practice, how many days would pass on average from the moment that the modification becomes
necessary until a changing (variation) order/price adjustment is issued?
20-30 days
53. How often would additional works related to the initial contract (i.e. works by the original
contractor that have become necessary and that were not included in the initial procurement) be
awarded to the same contractor through direct award?
Occasionally (25-50%)
In practice, how many days would pass on average from the moment additional works become
necessary until they are awarded to the same original contractor?
30 days
Phase 5: Payment, Delays and Quality Assessment
The following questions relate to payment and inspections.
Payment
54. According to the legal framework, is there a limit to how much the procuring entity can pay
upfront for the contractor to hire workers, buy materials, and start operations, in a contract like
the one described in Section 1?
No.
In practice, how much would usually be paid upfront for a contract like the one described in
Section 1?
Minimum 10% of the contract value, maximum 50% of the contract value.
In practice, if an advance payment is usually issued, does the contractor have to provide a
guarantee for receiving this payment?
Yes
11. In practice, how many calendar days will be necessary for BidCo to receive the advance payment
once the request has been submitted to the Procuring Entity?
10-20 days
55. During the execution of the contract, does the legal framework establish a timeframe within
which the procuring entity must process the payment once an invoice is received?
Yes. Article 19 of Decree No. 37/2015/ND-CP
In practice, how many calendar days will be necessary on average for BidCo to receive
payment once the invoice has been delivered to the relevant authority?
Maximum 14 days
In practice, how many people would need to authorize payment within the procuring entity
before payment is made?
2
In practice, how often will BidCo receive payment within the timeframe established by the
legal framework?
Often (between 50-90%)
According to the legal framework, is the company entitled to claim interest on late payments
if the procuring entity does not pay within the legally - established timeframe?
Yes. Article 94 of Decree No. 63/2014/ND-CP
If so, in practice how often would such interest be paid to the company?
Occationally (between 25-50%)
In practice, for a contract like the one described in Section 1, how many days would pass on
average between the moment BidCo notifies the Procuring Entity that the works are completed and
a formal agreement between them stipulating that the works are indeed finished and comply with
the contract specifications (i.e. a certificate of completion of works)? Please include the time for the
Procuring Entity to conduct a final inspection.
7-14 days
How often do disagreements between the Procuring Entity and BidCo on the completed works
delay the process of reaching a formal agreement that the works are finished?
Occationally (between 25-50%)
In practice, by how many days would the time you indicated in Q.55.f be extended to resolve this
disagreement and obtain a certificate of completion of works from the Procuring Entity?
30 days
56. Assuming that BidCo delivers works complying with the quality standards agreed-upon in the
contract, within budget and on time, what strategies, if any, does the procuring entity use to delay
or avoid payment?
Bureucracy/paperwork inspections
12. In practice, how often does the procuring entity not pay?
Very rarely (< 10% of cases)
In practice, how often is a portion of the payment retained to guarantee the works for a
predetermined amount of time?
Very rarely (< 10% of cases)
Inspections & Warranties
57. Does the procuring entity have guidelines or protocols regulating inspections on the quality of
the works?
Yes. Articles 6, 8, 9 of Circular No. 26/2016/TT- BXD
58. Which of the following is true for a contract like the one described in Section 1? Please select the
most common option only.
Inspections are carried out before every payment
Inspections are carried out before some - but not all - payments
Inspections are carried out routinely, but are not connected with payments
Inspections are carried out randomly
Only one final inspection is conducted
No inspections are conducted Comment
59. Upon completion of the works, does the legal framework require BidCo to guarantee the works
for a certain period of time?
Yes. Articles 35-36 of Decree No. 46/2015/ND-CP
61. If BidCo is required, what is the most common instrument of post-completion guarantee?
Payment retention
62. In practice, how long after completion of the works is BidCo required to maintain the
instrument
that guarantees them?
12- 18 months
Delays & Overruns
63. In practice, how often are the works delivered within the original deadline?
Often (between 50-90%)
64. In practice, if delays are common, what are the main reasons for them?
Burdensome administrative processes within the procuring entity
Capacity of the procuring entity (staff/skills/budgetary constraints)
Capacity of the contractor (technical/financial/managerial/human capital constraints)
Poor planning on the procuring entity's side (poorly designed project specifications, etc.)
Poor planning on the contractor's side
13. 65. In practice, how often are the works delivered within the original budget?
Occasionally (between 25-50%)
66. In practice, if cost overruns are common, what are the main reasons for them?
Market conditions (changes in input prices, fluctuations in exchange rate, etc.)
Burdensome administrative processes within the procuring entity
Capacity of the contractor (technical/financial/managerial/human capital constraints)
Poor planning on the procuring entity's side (poorly designed project specifications, etc.)
Poor planning on the contractor's side
5. Formal Challenges throughout the Procurement Process
In answering, please refer to the Procuring Entity you selected in Q. 1.
Challenging the contract award
In answering the following questions please assume that:
The Procuring Entity you selected in Q.1 has awarded a works contract to BidCo.
Three companies challenge the award on the following grounds:
o Company 1 argues that BidCo submitted a recklessly low bid that shouldhave been excluded.
o Company 2 argues that one of the evaluation criteria was used arbitrarily by the Procuring
Entity to reduce the Company's final score.
o Company 3 argues that the technical project they submitted met the minimum standards
established by the tender documents and should not have been excluded.
Assume all challengers submit their claims within the legal deadlines, free of mistakes, pay the fees
associated with their challenges, and pursue their claims until no further legal remedy is available. Please
include all administrative, judicial and quasi-judicial authorities that may be involved in the process.
67. According to the legal framework, who has legal standing to challenge the contract award?
Bidders
Legal basis:
FIRST
INSTANCE
a. Which authority would hear the challenge? If more
than one is possible, please list all relevant
authorities and specify which one a complaining
party would most commonly choose.
Investor of the project
b. How often would the award of a road works
contract rendered by the Procuring Entity be
challenged?
Between 10-25% of cases
c. Calendar days in practice between the moment a
challenge is filed and the day the complaining
party receives a decision.
30-45 business days
d. Would the challenge suspend the procurement
process?
No, the procurement process would
con
SECOND
INSTANCE
a. To which authority would the first instance decision
be appealed?
Investor of the project
b. How often would the first instance decision be
appealed?
Between 10-25% of cases
c. Calendar days in practice between the moment the
decision is appealed and the day the complaining
party receives a decision.
10-20 days
14. d. Would the appeal suspend the procurement process? No, suspension is discretionary but
NO'
THIRD
INSTANCE
a. To which authority would the second instance
decision be appealed?
Not available
b. How often would the second instance decision be
appealed?
Not available
c. Calendar days in practice between the moment the
decision is appealed and the day the complaining
party receives a decision.
d. Would the appeal suspend the procurement process? Not
available
68. If more than 3 instances of review are available,
please list the authorities and resolution times for all
further tiers of review.
Not available
Research - Criticalities of the Procurement Process
69. How often are the following strategies used by the procuring entity to circumvent public
procurement rules?
Not advertise procurement opportunities long enough to minimize competition: 10-25%
Prioritize projects without sufficient motivation just to benefit a particular bidder. : 10-25%
Prioritize non-competitive tenders to restrict market entry. : 10-25%
Define technical specifications to benefit a specific bidder. : >90%
Hold informal meetings with individual bidders: >90%
Unilaterally change some of the tendering requirements after the bid is opened, but before the contract is
signed: <10% of cases
Biased interpretation of the selection criteria.: 25-50%
Change the award criteria after the bids are opened: <10% of cases
Add specific obligations in the contract that were not previously incorporated in the tender documents,
and by doing so impose unnecessary burdens on the contractor.:<10% of cases
Delay payments to the contractor to request other works not included in the tender documents:<10% of
cases
Delay the certification of completion of the contract to obtain other works/goods/services not previously
included in the tender documents:<10% of cases
Unilaterally and arbitrarily terminate the contract:<10% of cases
70/ How often are the following strategies used by private sector companies to circumvent public
procurement rules?
Collusion between bidders (cover bidding, bid suppression, bid rotation, market allocation). .:<10% of
cases
Collusion with the procuring entity, to negate market entry to other competitors: 50-90%
Submission of recklessly low bids to win the tender. 10-25%
Falsification of documents or failure to disclose essential information in the bidder's offer. 10-25%
Informally paying public officials: 50-90%
Abuse the renegotiation process to increase the price or the scope of the project without another
competitive process. .: 50-90%
Delay the execution of the contract to coerce the procuring entity to award other contracts to the same
company. 10-25%
Execute the contract with less quality or with different technical specifications than were submitted
during the tender process. .: 50-90%
Employ subcontractors that were neither properly selected nor disclosed during the tender process. 10-
25%
15. ***
If you have any question on the above, please do not hesitate to contact Dr. Oliver Massmann under
omassmann@duanemorris.com . Dr. Oliver Massmann is the General Director of Duane Morris Vietnam
LLC.
Thank you very much!