IN   THE HIGH   COURT OFKERALA       AT ERNNCUL1IM
                                       Pre:sent :
                THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANTONY DOMINIC
            Monday ~he 27th day of September 2010/5TH                     ASWINA 1932
                                     WP(C);No.     29745/2010        {PI



      HI S. f'lJNET· GROUP (HOTEL PALACE INN.)   ANGAMALLY               I    E~.lKUI.JM,       REP.   BY
      ITS MANAGING PARTNER,       SRI. SHAJAN AN~ONY.

                                                   "' ~J
     RESPONDENT I

1.    STATE OF KERALA,  REP. BY ITS~TARY                    TO GOVERNMENT,              DEPARTMENT
      OF TAXES, THIRUVANANTHAI'URAM ••.

2.    THE EXCISE ~~MMrSSIONER, COMMISSIONER OF EXCISE,
      THIRUVANANTHAPURAM.

3.    THE DEPUTY      COMMISSIONER    OF EXCISE,     ERNAKULAM.

4•    ANGAMALY TOWN BRETHREN ASS EMBLY HALL,               REP.     BY E. M. POULOSE,
      EDACHERIL HOUSE, ANGAMALY, ERNAKtJLAM.

      K. V. VARGHESE,    KOORANPLANKUDY,     KALIUPALAM           ROAD,       ANGAM;ALY,
      ERNAKULAM.

     Writ Petition praying in~er alia that in the circ~~ance8   stated
in the affidavit filed along with the WP(C) the Hi9h Court be pleased
~o stay all further proceedings in pursuant to Ext.P9 pending disposal
of this writ petition.             .
      This petition coming on for orders upon perusing the petition
and the affidavit filed in support of the WP(C) and upon hearing the
argU11len2_~~_:?R:.
                  BENNlr ANTONY PAREL Advocate for the petitioner and                          I

of Mr. S~HAVAN,           Advocate for     R4 and R5, the court                 passed the
following
;,t:

         Sri. S~thuRladhavantakes     nob.:i&e [c,r R4 and RS.           Notice to oth.~:!t.
         PurS1lant to the direction       in:'txtP7 jUdgment, Ext. PB ord~J.: Has.
  passed by the first      r~.sP'=>ndent ~V612010, holding that ~
                                        on                                     t>lll

  res}-'Ondent is not a church as defiijed und~r the FpreVJn Liquor Rules.
  On that basJ.s atter cOfItpleting all 'formalities,            F~-j licenc'3> is~ued tc·
  the petitioner    was ren.wed ,on 3Dl,~,l2uIO.          Ho~ver,~ without. issuing even
  a m:tice to'the P?'tititner,      the.l'iEence is,,n7uspen.'<:ied by Ext. P'9 _order,
  act:wg upon certa~n r"presentatJ.onlt que='t~g the correctnes~ ?t, the
, findings in ~x~.P,8 andY,?fi t,he 9~dU.-~.d    t,hat:"...  vi:w.take~ il.1 Ext,.P8 bas
  hurt the re11.9J.ou5sentJJllents or some pepp e.              Pruua     tac1e,,I     anl
  inclined to thihk that'Ext.P9       iSu!)susUiinable.           The,f:etore £Kt.P9 will
  stand stay.d for a ~.r:ioo of 2 mont;:hs. ,..••    ,:                (
  .      P.espt:>ndents t.. file
                          O       Gount~r ~,f.'avit.         P03t. iIrl1'ltediat.;:>lyaft""!
  service is completed.                     A       '




                                                                 ANTONY j)()MINIC
                                                                 JUDGE




                                                                         ~k
                                                                ASSlSTANT~'R
                                                                 V
 Ext.Ph    Tru~ copy of the      Judgment   29167/09 dt . .23IL,' 10
 Ext-FB:   True copy of the      order GO(Rt!No.542/2010/TD       dt.24/6/l1J.
 Ext.P9: True copy of tne        order C,o(Rt)No.801;2D10JTD dt.2Si9/10.

Latest stay order issued

  • 1.
    IN THE HIGH COURT OFKERALA AT ERNNCUL1IM Pre:sent : THE HON'BLE MR. JUSTICE ANTONY DOMINIC Monday ~he 27th day of September 2010/5TH ASWINA 1932 WP(C);No. 29745/2010 {PI HI S. f'lJNET· GROUP (HOTEL PALACE INN.) ANGAMALLY I E~.lKUI.JM, REP. BY ITS MANAGING PARTNER, SRI. SHAJAN AN~ONY. "' ~J RESPONDENT I 1. STATE OF KERALA, REP. BY ITS~TARY TO GOVERNMENT, DEPARTMENT OF TAXES, THIRUVANANTHAI'URAM ••. 2. THE EXCISE ~~MMrSSIONER, COMMISSIONER OF EXCISE, THIRUVANANTHAPURAM. 3. THE DEPUTY COMMISSIONER OF EXCISE, ERNAKULAM. 4• ANGAMALY TOWN BRETHREN ASS EMBLY HALL, REP. BY E. M. POULOSE, EDACHERIL HOUSE, ANGAMALY, ERNAKtJLAM. K. V. VARGHESE, KOORANPLANKUDY, KALIUPALAM ROAD, ANGAM;ALY, ERNAKULAM. Writ Petition praying in~er alia that in the circ~~ance8 stated in the affidavit filed along with the WP(C) the Hi9h Court be pleased ~o stay all further proceedings in pursuant to Ext.P9 pending disposal of this writ petition. . This petition coming on for orders upon perusing the petition and the affidavit filed in support of the WP(C) and upon hearing the argU11len2_~~_:?R:. BENNlr ANTONY PAREL Advocate for the petitioner and I of Mr. S~HAVAN, Advocate for R4 and R5, the court passed the following
  • 2.
    ;,t: Sri. S~thuRladhavantakes nob.:i&e [c,r R4 and RS. Notice to oth.~:!t. PurS1lant to the direction in:'txtP7 jUdgment, Ext. PB ord~J.: Has. passed by the first r~.sP'=>ndent ~V612010, holding that ~ on t>lll res}-'Ondent is not a church as defiijed und~r the FpreVJn Liquor Rules. On that basJ.s atter cOfItpleting all 'formalities, F~-j licenc'3> is~ued tc· the petitioner was ren.wed ,on 3Dl,~,l2uIO. Ho~ver,~ without. issuing even a m:tice to'the P?'tititner, the.l'iEence is,,n7uspen.'<:ied by Ext. P'9 _order, act:wg upon certa~n r"presentatJ.onlt que='t~g the correctnes~ ?t, the , findings in ~x~.P,8 andY,?fi t,he 9~dU.-~.d t,hat:"... vi:w.take~ il.1 Ext,.P8 bas hurt the re11.9J.ou5sentJJllents or some pepp e. Pruua tac1e,,I anl inclined to thihk that'Ext.P9 iSu!)susUiinable. The,f:etore £Kt.P9 will stand stay.d for a ~.r:ioo of 2 mont;:hs. ,..•• ,: ( . P.espt:>ndents t.. file O Gount~r ~,f.'avit. P03t. iIrl1'ltediat.;:>lyaft""! service is completed. A ' ANTONY j)()MINIC JUDGE ~k ASSlSTANT~'R V Ext.Ph Tru~ copy of the Judgment 29167/09 dt . .23IL,' 10 Ext-FB: True copy of the order GO(Rt!No.542/2010/TD dt.24/6/l1J. Ext.P9: True copy of tne order C,o(Rt)No.801;2D10JTD dt.2Si9/10.