1. Expansion and Replacement Projects
Expansion project - an independent project which does not
affect the cash flows for the rest of the company.
Replacement project - affects the cash flows of the rest of the
company, therefore it is important to compare the cash flows
from the new investment and the investment being replaced
Formula for a new capital that needs to be invested in an
expansion project
where FCInv is the investment in new fixed capital and NWCInv is the
investment in net working capital
Study Session 8, Reading 25
2. Expansion and Replacement
Projects (cont.)
Formula for the initial capital that needs to be invested in a
replacement project:
Salo is the cash proceeds from the sale of old fixed capital, T is the tax rate
and Bo is the book value of old fixed capital
Formula for the after tax annual cash flows to be derived from
an investment project:
where S is sales, C is cash operating expenses and D is the depreciation
charge
Study Session 8, Reading 25
3. Expansion and Replacement
Projects (cont.)
Formula for the terminal year after tax non-operating cash
flows:
SalT is the terminal cash flows and BT is the book value of the fixed capita
Replacement project cash flows include investment outlays,
after tax operating cash flows over the life of the project and
terminal cash flows.
Study Session 8, Reading 25
4. Effects of Depreciation Method
on Cash Flows
The NPV of the capital project can be improved by the use of
an accelerated depreciation method
An accelerated depreciation method reduces the tax cash out
flow in the early years and increases them in the later years
Study Session 8, Reading 25
5. Effects of Inflation
on Capital Budgeting
Nominal cash flows include the effect of inflation
Real cash flows are adjusted to eliminate the effect of
inflation
Nominal cash flows should be discounted at the nominal rate
Real cash flows should be discounted at the real rate
Formula for converting real discount rate to a nominal discount
rate:
Study Session 8, Reading 25
6. Capital Allocation in Mutually
Exclusive Projects
Replacement chain approach - used to evaluate capital
allocation with mutually exclusive projects with different lives
equivalent annual annuity - the NPV of both projects is
converted into an equivalent annual annuity and the project
with the greater annual positive payments is chosen.
Capital rationing - the process of allocating capital to the best
project when there is limited capital available.
Study Session 8, Reading 25
7. Stand-Alone Risk of Capital Projects
Standalone risk is usually assessed by calculating the dispersion
of NPV or IRR.
Sensitivity analysis - takes into account the change in NPV for a
change in a unit of input.
Scenario analysis - calculates NPV under different scenarios.
Probability distribution - used for important variables in an NPV
calculation.
Study Session 8, Reading 25
8. Determining the Discount Rate
The CAPM can be used to calculate the discount rate for capital
projects.
where: Rf
- risk free rate
β
- risk of the project
Rm
- represents the return of the market
(Rm-Rf)- represents the market premium
Study Session 8, Reading 25
9. Determining the Discount Rate
The CAPM can be used to calculate the discount rate for capital
projects.
where: Rf
- risk free rate
β
- risk of the project
Rm
- represents the return of the market
(Rm-Rf)- represents the market premium
Study Session 8, Reading 25
10. Real Options in Evaluating
a Capital Project
Option - the right but not the obligation to make a decision in
the future
Real options - are options on real assets instead of financial
assets
Real options are a choice to make a decision about a capital
project in the future which may impact the value of the
project.
Real options increase the value of a capital project
Study Session 8, Reading 25
11. Real Options in Evaluating
a Capital Project (cont.)
Different Types of Real Options:
Timing options
Abandonment option
Growth option
Price setting option
Production flexibility option
Study Session 8, Reading 25
12. Common Budgeting Pitfalls
Managers may make errors when valuing capital projects.
Some managers may choose the projects which give good
short term benefits but do not generate value in the long run
Some managers have the tendency to overspend or
underspend the budget allocated.
Sunk costs are often difficult to ignore
Study Session 8, Reading 25
13. Accounting Income
in Capital Budgeting
Accounting income - the income reported on the income
statement from the capital project.
Accounting depreciation is based on the original cost of the
investment.
The after tax cost of debt is subtracted (ie considered) when
calculating net income.
Study Session 8, Reading 25
14. Economic Income
in Capital Budgeting
Economic income - the profit realized from an investment
Interest is ignored in the economic income as it is included in
the discount rate.
Economic depreciation is based on the change in the market
value of the investment.
Study Session 8, Reading 25
15. Economic Profit
Economic profit - reflects the income earned by all the capital
holders, discounted to its present value at WACC.
Formula:
Where: NOPAT - net operating profit after tax or after tax EBIT
$WACC - the dollar cost of capital which is equal to capital
multiplied by the WACC
Study Session 8, Reading 25
16. Residual Income
The residual income method focuses on the return on equity
Formula:
Where: RIt - the residual income during time t
NIt - the net income during time t
rtBt-1 -the equity charge for period t
Study Session 8, Reading 25
17. Claims Valuation Models
In the claims model, the present value of each cash flow is
added to get the value of the firm
It values liabilities and equity which are the claims against the
assets. The value of the assets should be equal to the value of
the claims
Study Session 8, Reading 25
18. Proposition I & II Without Taxes
from Modigliani-Miller
Modigliani and Miller assumed that the investors have
homogenous expectations about returns and risks of stocks
and bonds.
Proposition I governs the basic capital structure decision
VL=VU
Study Session 8, Reading 25
19. Proposition I & II Without Taxes
from Modigliani-Miller (cont.)
Proposition 2 suggests that the cost of equity is the linear
function of the firm’s debt to equity ratio.
Study Session 8, Reading 25
20. Proposition I & II With Taxes
from Modigliani-Miller
Proposition I - the value of the firm is maximized when the
capital structure contains 100% debt
Study Session 8, Reading 25
21. Proposition I & II With Taxes
from Modigliani-Miller (cont.)
Proposition 2 argues that the 100% debt minimizes the WACC
Study Session 8, Reading 25
22. Target Capital Structure vs
Actual Capital Structure
Target capital structure - the funding mix that a firm wants to
achieve.
Optimal capital structure - the point where the value of the
company is maximized.
Study Session 8, Reading 26
23. Debt Ratings in Capital Structure Policy
Companies need to consider the impact of their capital
structure decisions on credit ratings.
Rising leverage may tempt the ratings agencies to lower the
ratings.
Rising leverage increases the risk is for both equity and debt
providers.
Study Session 8, Reading 26
24. Factors when assessing
Firm’s Capital Structure
Ability of the company to handle the financial obligations
Business risk
Agency costs
Volatility of company’s cash flows and its need for financial
flexibility
Regulatory environment
Study Session 8, Reading 26
25. International Differences in Financial
Leverage
Factors:
Institutional legal and taxation differences
Micro economic factors
Macroeconomic factors
Financial market factors
Banking system factors
General business environment of the country
Differences exist between developed and developing
countries
Study Session 8, Reading 26
26. Theories of Dividend Policy
1. The first group believes that only the investment in fixed
capital and working capital affects shareholder wealth.
2. Second group argues that the dividends are more important
to the investors than the uncertain capital gains.
Study Session 8, Reading 26
27. Dividend Signaling
A company that announces an increase in dividend payouts
may be indicating strong future prospects.
Dividends can be used to signal to investors how the company
is really doing.
A company’s decision to initiate a dividend sends stronger
signals than the words of the management.
Study Session 8, Reading 27
28. Factors Affecting Dividend Policy
Companies with many investment opportunities tend to pay
lower dividends
volatility of future earnings
target payout ratios on future earnings
Financial flexibility
Tax consideration
Shareholder’s preference
Contractual and legal obligations
Study Session 8, Reading 27
29. Dividend Tax Regimes
Double Taxation system - earnings taxed at two levels (at the
company level and at the investor level).
Tax Imputation system - earnings are ultimately taxed at the
shareholder’s specific rate.
Split Rate system - earnings are taxed at two different rates.
Study Session 8, Reading 27
30. Dividend Payout Policies
Stable policy - dividends increase at a constant rate every year
Target payout - the company sets aside a proportion of earnings
which the company wants to disburse as dividends.
Residual dividend policy - the cash flow remaining after capital
budgeting is paid out as dividends.
Study Session 8, Reading 27
31. Global Trends in Corporate Dividend
Policies
Companies adapt their dividend policies according to changes
in investor preferences which differ globally.
The portion of dividend paying companies have been on the
decline in developed economies
Fama and French stated the decline in dividend payout over
time was due to the weaker related companies in the same
industry.
Study Session 8, Reading 27
32. Dividend Coverage Ratio
Dividend coverage ratios - a way of assessing dividend safety
Free cash flows - the earnings available for shareholders after
working capital and fixed capital expenditures.
Formula to Calculate Free Cash Flow coverage ratios :
Study Session 8, Reading 27
33. Characteristics of Companies that
Cannot Sustain Cash Dividends
If the market is pessimistic about the dividends of the
company
Companies with extremely high dividend yields
Past record of the company’s dividends
Investors predicting a dividend cut
Study Session 8, Reading 27
34. Major Business Forms
and Associated Conflicts of Interest
Sole Proprietorship
A business run and owned by single person
Have difficulty in raising capital
Issues in the transferability of ownership
Have unlimited liability
No agency risk is present
Creditors and suppliers are in a better position to ask for the
quality information
Study Session 8, Reading 28
35. Major Business Forms
and Associated Conflicts of Interest (cont.)
Partnership
Similar to a Sole Proprietor, except that it has more than one
owner
The financial capital of the partners is pooled together.
Partners share the business risk.
Partnership contracts are devised
Study Session 8, Reading 28
36. Major Business Forms
and Associated Conflicts of Interest (cont.)
Corporations
A legal entity that has similar rights to a person
Managers act as the agents of the firm
Corporations can raise large capital
Shareholders are the owners of the corporation and receive
profits
Owners do not need to be experts in the business
Ownership is easily transferable
Corporations have limited liability
Study Session 8, Reading 28
37. Manager- Shareholder Conflicts
agency relationship - relationship between managers and
shareholders
Management have control of undistributed income
Managers may spend company money on lavish perquisites
Managers may make risky investment decisions for their own
benefits
Study Session 8, Reading 28
38. Director-Shareholder Conflicts
board of directors - act as an intermediary between the
shareholders and managers
Directors start to protect the interests of the managers
The board is not independent
The directors have personal relations with the managers or
consulting agreements
Generous payments to the directors
Study Session 8, Reading 28
39. Board of Directors: Qualifications
Expertise in the relevant field, operations and the
technologies used by the company.
Should have the knowledge of accounting and legal practices.
Ethical soundness
Experience in risk management and strategic planning.
Board experience with other companies
Commitment and dedication to serving the cause of the
shareholders.
There should be an absence of conflicts of interest.
Study Session 8, Reading 28
40. Board of Directors: Competencies
and Responsibilities
Should establish corporate values and governance
Should ensure that legal and regulatory requirements are met
Should establish the long term strategic objectives for the
company
Should establish strong accountability measures and clear line
of responsibilities.
Determine the compensation package and hire the chief
executive officer.
Adequate training should be given to members.
Board elections should be held annually.
Directors should serve only on two or three boards
Study Session 8, Reading 28
41. Effective Corporate Governance
The CEO and chairman should be separate positions.
Independent and outside counsel should be used by the
board.
Board members should be knowledgeable and experienced.
Board should be annually evaluated and assessed.
Board members should meet without the presence of the
management.
Study Session 8, Reading 28
42. Statement of Corporate Governance
Policies
Contain a clear code of ethics
Define the measures for self assessment
Contain measures for the monitoring and review
responsibilities of the directors
Contain a statement underlining the responsibilities of the
management
Contain reports of directors
Study Session 8, Reading 28
43. Valuation Implications of Corporate
Governance
Accounting risk
Asset risk
Liability risk
Risk taking
Short term objectives
Study Session 8, Reading 28
44. Classification Based on Integration
and Mergers
Acquisition - the purchase of some part of one company by another
Merger - the adoption of one company by another where the target
ceases to exist
Statutory merger - when one company’s assets and liabilities are
transferred to another company and the company ceases to exist
Subsidiary merger - the company becomes the subsidiary of the
buying company.
Consolidation - both companies finish the legal structure and become
a new company
Target company or “target” - The company which is being acquired
Acquirer - the acquiring company that acquires the target
Takeovers - mergers
Study Session 8, Reading 29
45. Classification Based on Integration
and Mergers (cont.)
Hostile takeover - when a company is being acquired against the
wishes of the management and board of directors
Friendly transaction - a potential business combination backed by
management and the board
Horizontal merger - when the merging companies operate in the same
type of business
Vertical merger - when the acquirer acquires a company in the same
production chain
Backward integration - a company acquires suppliers
Forward integration - company acquires distributors
Conglomerate merger - when a company in an unrelated business is
acquired
Study Session 8, Reading 29
46. Common Motivations
Behind M&A Activity
Economies of scale
Increasing market share
Cost saving through vertical integration
Synergies
Growth
To acquire unique opportunities and resources
Diversification
For personal benefits
Tax benefits
Taking the business global
Study Session 8, Reading 29
47. Bootstrapping and Post Merger EPS
bootstrapping effect - Companies typically generate higher EPS
following a merger
Total earnings of the combined firms are unchanged.
However, the number of total shares outstanding is
decreased.
There may be no economic gains of the process
Study Session 8, Reading 29
48. Pioneer Stage and Merger Motivations
pioneer stage – companies have low profit margins and large
capital requirements.
Newer companies may want to merge with the bigger and
more experienced players in the industry to benefit from their
expertise.
Horizontal and conglomerate mergers occur at this stage
Study Session 8, Reading 29
49. Rapid Growth and Merger Motivations
rapid growth stage - firms have few participants in the market
and high profit margins.
Larger capital
To meet sales demand and increase the production capacity
Conglomerate and horizontal mergers are the choices
Study Session 8, Reading 29
50. Mature Growth and Merger Motivations
mature growth stage- firms still have growth present in the
industry, but competition stops entering the market.
Operational efficiency, savings and economies of scale
Horizontal and vertical mergers are preferred
Study Session 8, Reading 29
51. Stabilization and Merger Motivations
stabilisation phase - firms suffer from increased competition
and capacity constraints
To improve management
Economies of scale and reduce the costs
Horizontal mergers are done at this stage
Study Session 8, Reading 29
52. Decline and Merger Motivations
decline phase – business is characterized by declining profit
margins and over capacity.
To acquire new growth opportunities, survival and operational
efficiencies
Horizontal vertical and conglomerate mergers occur
Study Session 8, Reading 29
53. Merger Transactions: Acquisition
Stock purchase - the most convenient form of acquisition
the acquirer gives the shareholders of the target company some
cash and securities.
it must be approved by more than 50% of the shareholders
asset purchase - the target company’s assets are purchased and
payment is made to the target company
Shareholder’s approval is needed if a substantial amount of
assets are being sold
Liabilities of the target company are assumed by the acquirer in
stock purchase, but liabilities are avoided under the assets
purchased.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
54. Merger Transactions: Method of Payment
cash offering method of payment - cash can come from the
existing assets of the company or a debt issue.
securities offering - the shareholders of the target company may
receive the shares of the acquiring company
Each shareholder gets the shares of the acquirer based on the
number of shares of the target company held multiplied by the
exchange ratio.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
55. Merger Transactions: Target Management
friendly merger - acquirer and target work together and sign the
agreement before presenting it to the shareholders of the target
company.
If the bear hug fails, approval from the shareholders of the
company can be received in two ways:
1. Tender offer is given to the shareholders of the target
company, every shareholder decides to sell or not sell the shares.
2. In a proxy battle the acquirer tries to control the target by
getting an acquirer approved board.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
56. Pre-Offer Defense Mechanisms
shark repellents - defence mechanisms
poison pills - allow the company the option to offer shares of the
target company at a discounted price
flip-in pill - an option to buy the target company’s shares at
discount
flip-over pill - if the shareholders of the target company have the
option to buy the shares of the acquiring company at a discount
• Reincorporation can be undertaken to avoid hostile takeovers.
• Staggered board elections can also be undertaken.
• Supermajority of voting provisions
• Golden parachutes
Study Session 8, Reading 29
57. Post-Offer Defense Mechanisms
the “just say no” defence
file a law suit
Greenmail option
buy shares in the open
leveraged recapitalization
crown jewel defence
Pac Man defence
white knight defence
white squire defence
Study Session 8, Reading 29
58. The HHI and Likelihood of Antitrust
Challenge
Antitrust laws have been devised to stop takeovers which are not
healthy for competition.
The HHI is used to judge whether the antitrust challenge is
qualified or not
Study Session 8, Reading 29
59. Valuing a Target Company
discounted cash flows approach - the company’s expected future
cash flows are discounted to their present value.
comparable company approach - the value of a comparable
company plus a premium is used. A set of comparable companies
is assessed
transaction multiple approach - a set of relevant and recent
sample transaction are evaluated.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
60. Calculating Free Cash Flow
Free cash flow - cash flows which are available for shareholders
after capital expenditures.
Net income
+ Net interest after tax
= Unlevered Net income
+ Change in deferred taxes
= Net operating profit less adjusted taxes (NOPLAT)
+ Net noncash charges
- Change in net working capital
- Capital expenditures (Capex)
= Free Cash Flow (FCF)
Study Session 8, Reading 29
61. Evaluating Merger Bids
pre-merger value of the target company - the absolute
minimum bid that target shareholders should accept.
The acquirer’s shareholders would not want to pay more than
pre-merger value plus any value of the expected synergies.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
62. Estimated Post-Merger Value
Post merger value - a function of the pre merger value of both
companies.
Synergies - created as a result of merger and any cash paid to
the target’s shareholders.
Formula to Calculate Post Merger Value:
VA*=VA+VT+S-C
Where: VA* - the post merger value of the companies
VA - the pre-merger value of the acquirer
C - the cash paid to the target shareholders.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
63. Gains of Target
Definition:
TP= PT-VT
Where: PT - the price paid to the target
VT - the pre-merger value of the target
cash offer - the target’s shareholders will benefit by the amount paid
above the market value. But the gain is capped at that amount.
stock offer- the gain can be determined by the value of the post
merger firm, because the shareholders do not receive cash they still
have the ownership.
Gains to the Target is defined as: PT=(N× PA×T)
Study Session 8, Reading 29
64. Gains of Acquirer Shareholders
To Calculate Synergies:
S-TP=S-(PT-VT)
Where: S -represents the synergies created
Acquirer pays the premium in order to realise the synergies.
The gains to the acquirer are derived from the synergies.
The gains to the acquirer can include a combination of cost
reductions and revenue enhancements.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
65. Effects of Price and Payment Method
in a Merger Transaction
The acquirer wants to get the best deal by paying the lowest
possible amount.
The target wants to get the best deal by getting the highest
amount.
The acquirer receives the potential rewards of the merger.
The gain to the target is the premium paid by the acquirer.
The premium does not change for the target.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
66. Empirical evidence in distribution of
benefits
Shareholders of the target gain in the short run.
Target shareholders receive a 30% premium, on average.
Acquirer’s stock price falls as a result.
Acquirer and target see a higher stock return in cash offers
than the stock offers.
Hubris can also result in higher bids in excess of the real value.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
67. Reasons for Divestiture
divestiture - when a company decides to sell, spin-off or
liquidate a division
when a company decides to sell, spin-off or liquidate a division
company decides that the division is a poor fit
reverse synergies
financial and cash flow needs
Study Session 8, Reading 29
68. Equity Carve-Outs
Create a new independent by giving a proportionate equity
interest in a subsidiary
A new legal entity is created
Shares are sold to the outsiders
Study Session 8, Reading 29
69. Spin-Offs
Creates a new company by giving shares to the shareholders
of the parent company.
Proportional number of shares are offered.
A spin-off gives the shareholders shares in the both
companies.
Split-Offs
Parent company shares are exchanged by the existing
shareholders to get a share in the new company.
Study Session 8, Reading 29
70. Liquidation
A firm is broken and sold piece by piece.
Usually happens as a result of bankruptcy.
A subsidiary of a division can also be liquidated.
Study Session 8, Reading 29