SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Twin Deficit Analysis- Growth perspective
Rahul Chokshi
022-61598021
Hasan Razvi
022-61598049
8th January 2013
Key Pointers
 Deficit- Nature & Issues
 Government Expenditure- Role & Nature
 Revenue Spending- Plan & Non-planp g p
 Capital Expenditure- Plan & Non-plan
 Merchandise trade- Overhang on Current account
 Invisibles Trade Balance- Services dominate
 Role of Government Spending in Economic Growth
 Linkage between GDP and Deficit
STRICTL
 Fiscal Path Committed v/s Expected
 Dealing with the Deficit
LYPRIVATEANDCO
 Risks to Deficit trajectory
 Annexure
2
NFIDENTIAL
Deficit- Nature & Issues
Twin Deficit Trajectoryj y
5
6
7
1
2
3
4
%
Source: RBI and Altius research
0
1
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12
Fiscal Deficit as a % of GDP CAD as a % of GDP
STRICTL
 India has for a long period now been plagued with double-deficit problem, viz., the Current Account Deficit
(CAD) caused by a wedge between exports and imports and the Fiscal Deficit (FD) arising due to
expenditure surpassing the revenue in a given period.
 Deficit is deemed acceptable in an economy that is developing rapidly stoking consumption and investment
Source: RBI and Altius research
LYPRIVATEANDCO
 Deficit is deemed acceptable in an economy that is developing rapidly stoking consumption and investment
demand owing to which mismatches arise in meeting the growth momentum. Nature of deficit on the fiscal
as well as current accounts dictates the sustainability of the growth trajectory.
 For instance, higher fiscal funding on account of recurring revenue expenses leaves out lower room for
3
NFIDENTIAL
capital spending to grow, similarly higher imports for consumption demand instead of manufacturing inputs
eventually weakens the domestic currency substantially.
 The figure alongside attempts to segregate the
Government Expenditure- Role & Nature
Share of Capital-Revenue Expenses
100% The figure alongside attempts to segregate the
overall expenditure into revenue and capital
spending based on their share in the aggregate
expenditure.
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
 The figure thus portrays the share of capital
expenditure at around 11% of the total expenditure
and revenue spending at nearly 89% over the last 5
fiscal years. 10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
 Similarly, the second figure has divided the total
imports broadly into consumption and investment
goods.
100%
Share of Consumption-Investment Imports
0%
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1
Capital Expenditure Revenue Expenditure
STRICTL
 Thus consumption related imports occupy a greater
portion in India’s import basket, at nearly 66%.
Whereas, capital and export related goods that
signify manufacturing demand stands barely at
50%
60%
70%
80%
90%
100%
LYPRIVATEANDCO
around 33%.
 The period under consideration is mainly from FY08
to the current fiscal year (according to availability of
data) primarily due to the various growth cycles, 0%
10%
20%
30%
40%
50%
4
NFIDENTIAL
) p y g y ,
viz., boom, slowdown and revival that were
observed in the short span under consideration.
Source: Bloomberg, RBI and Altius research
0%
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13Q1
Consumption goods Investment goods
Fiscal deficit
Revenue Spending- Plan & Non-plan
Y-o-Y growth of Total Revenue spending
40
25
30
35
40
5
10
15
20
%
Source: India Budget and Altius Research
0
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13
Budgeted Actual Estimated
STRICTL
 The continued divergence of actual revenue spending from budgeted target has been the prime factor to push up
overall expenditure. The above figure also substantiates the proposition that slowing growth translates in a
higher revenue spending by the government.
Source: India Budget and Altius Research
LYPRIVATEANDCO
 The plunge in real GDP growth to 6.72% in FY09 from 9.32% growth seen in FY08 translated into a higher public
spending by the government as the revenue spending rose to INR 7.94 tn from a budgeted target of INR 6.58 tn
and a 34% growth from FY08’s revenue spending of INR 5.89 tn.
 On the other hand immediately in the next fiscal year 2009-2010 as the economy showed signs of recovery
6
NFIDENTIAL
 On the other hand, immediately in the next fiscal year 2009 2010 as the economy showed signs of recovery
posting a real growth rate of 8.39%, the actual revenue spending also posted a minimal slippage at INR 9.06 tn
from a budgeted target of INR 8.97 tn.
Capital Expenditure- Plan & Non-plan
Total Capital spending as a % of GDP4
2
%
0
 The central issue with capital expenses is that it has actually been below the budgeted level for a substantial
b f h l d d hi d h f i l i f h
Source: 12th & 13th Finance Commission Report, India Budget and Altius Research
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13
12th & 13th Finance Commission  Extimates Budgeted Actual Estimated
STRICTL
number of times in the last decade. This undershoot of capital expenses is a matter of concern as the
same highlights the inability to achieve a targeted level of infrastructure that proves to be a
roadblock in paving the path to economic growth recovery.
 The slowdown seen in FY09 owing to the global credit crunch forced the government to support domestic demand
LYPRIVATEANDCO
by heavy revenue expenses as the trade-off by reducing the capital spending; easing from 2.4% of GDP in FY08
to almost 1.6% of GDP in the given year. The targeted 31% Y-o-Y growth of capital expenditure in FY13 is also
set to fall short of the budgeted target given the Y-o-Y growth pattern of merely 17% in Apr-Nov period
 Ironically capital spending that is non recurring and developmental in nature fails to meet its budgeted target as
7
NFIDENTIAL
 Ironically capital spending, that is non-recurring and developmental in nature fails to meet its budgeted target as
the cost of an overshoot in revenue is borne by the haircut in capital spending. This induces a sort of cyclical
characteristic to the deficit making it structural rather than a temporary one.
Current Account Deficit
Merchandise trade- Overhang on Current account
 The slowdown in an economy, where on one hand impacts manufacturing activity stunting investment demand, it
failed to meaningfully dent the domestic consumption demand.
 Thus a drop in manufacturing and investment demand eventually impacts the exports. For instance, credit crunch
of 2008 that resulted in a contraction in export demand from the developed world, thus India’s exports growth
l d t 15 3% FY09 f th t ti t 0 6% i FY10 ( i l h ) f th fi t ti i th l t d dslowed to 15.3% FY09 further contracting to 0.6% in FY10 (revival phase) ,for the first time in the last decade.
 The slowdown in investment demand also impacts the import of bulk import goods and capital goods highlighting
the slowdown in investments and manufacturing activity, however, the issue remains the pace of slowdown, as
merchandise imports exhibit a quicker rebound compared with exports. The contraction in imports lasted to merely
3-quarters whereas, exports witnessed a longer spell of contraction. (Annexure figure 3)
Trade deficit & CAD as % of GDP (INR cr) Foreign Trade trajectory (USD mn)
0
0 5
0
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1
45
STRICTL
‐10
‐5
2 5
‐2
‐1.5
‐1
‐0.5
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1
%
%
25
35
%
LYPRIVATEANDCO
‐20
‐15
‐4.5
‐4
‐3.5
‐3
‐2.5
%
%
5
15
%
9
NFIDENTIAL
Source: RBI and Altius research
‐25‐5
4.5
CAD Trade deficit
‐5
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12
Export Y‐o‐Y Import Y‐o‐Y
Invisibles Trade Balance- Services dominate
 The services trade balance plays an dominant role in influencing the invisible trade portion of the current account,
as the pulse of services balance is imitated by the invisibles balance. The economy has relished a surplus on the
invisibles balance aided by robust services growth, although the external shocks does impact its growth trajectory.
 With the most recent slowdown being triggered by the credit crunch and recession seen in the developed world, the
services exports growth also exhibited a contraction in corresponding quartersservices exports growth also exhibited a contraction in corresponding quarters.
 As the ‘financial crisis’ deepened, the Y-o-Y exports fizzled out to merely 4% growth in Q3 of FY09 compared with
25% growth seen in the same quarter in FY08. This was followed with 4-consecutive quarters of contraction in
exports.
 A similar impact was also seen on the import front, although there is an almost spontaneous rebound in services
import growth.
Exports- Invisibles: Services (USD mn) Imports- Invisibles : Services (USD mn)
80
STRICTL
Prolonged export contraction Spontaneous rebound in imports
30
40
50
60
70
80
30
40
50
60
70
LYPRIVATEANDCO
20
‐10
0
10
20
30
Y08Q1
Y08Q2
Y08Q3
Y08Q4
Y09Q1
Y09Q2
Y09Q3
Y09Q4
Y10Q1
Y10Q2
Y10Q3
Y10Q4
Y11Q1
Y11Q2
Y11Q3
Y11Q4
Y12Q1
Y12Q2
Y12Q3
Y12Q4
Y13Q1
Y13Q2
%
20
‐10
0
10
20
Y08Q1
Y08Q2
Y08Q3
Y08Q4
Y09Q1
Y09Q2
Y09Q3
Y09Q4
Y10Q1
Y10Q2
Y10Q3
Y10Q4
Y11Q1
Y11Q2
Y11Q3
Y11Q4
Y12Q1
Y12Q2
Y12Q3
Y12Q4
Y13Q1
Y13Q2
%
10
NFIDENTIAL
Source: RBI and Altius research
‐30
‐20
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
Invisibles Import growth Y‐o‐Y Services Import growth Y‐o‐Y
‐30
‐20
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
Invisibles Export growth Y‐o‐Y Services Export growth Y‐o‐Y
Growth Implications of Twin Deficit
Role of Government Spending in Economic Growth
 The table given below attempts to substantiate the impact of slowing growth on changing composition of GDP The table given below attempts to substantiate the impact of slowing growth on changing composition of GDP
contributed by government, consumption and investment expenditure over the past economic cycle.
 The Y-o-Y growth rate of investment expenditure was slashed to nearly half, growing merely at 11% in FY09 owing
to the credit crunch in the developed world, compared with over 20% growth seen in the previous 3 fiscal years.
 Government expenditure on the other hand spiked to 20% in FY09 and the upward trend in also maintained in
revival phase in order to support the economy and put the economic growth back on track.
 The catch here remains the consumption expenditure and recurring revenue expenses (as exhibited on page 6)
h d i l i l fl i i f h h l h h i i h h Thithat tends to remain relatively flat irrespective of the growth cycle that the economy is going through. This
stickiness or inelasticity in consumption demand and revenue expenses explains the widening twin deficits.
Growth rate of GDP components in varied growth cycles
FY11 FY12FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10
STRICTL
GDP 
Components
Amount 
(INR tn)
Y‐o‐Y 
growth
Amount 
(INR tn)
Y‐o‐Y 
growth
Amount 
(INR tn)
Y‐o‐Y 
growth
Amount 
(INR tn)
Y‐o‐Y 
growth
Amount 
(INR tn)
Y‐o‐Y 
growth
Amount 
(INR tn)
Y‐o‐Y 
growth
Amount 
(INR tn)
Y‐o‐Y 
growth
Amount 
(INR tn)
Y‐o‐Y 
growth
Consumption 
Expenditure 19.18 8% 21.53 12% 24.77 15% 28.41 15% 32.49 14% 37.08 14% 43.38 17% 49.62 14%
G t
FY11 FY12FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10
LYPRIVATEANDCO
Government 
Expenditure 3.55 9% 4.02 13% 4.43 10% 5.13 16% 6.15 20% 7.74 26% 9.11 18% 10.36 14%
Investment 
Expenditure 9.31 33% 11.20 20% 13.44 20% 16.42 22% 18.21 11% 20.42 12% 23.31 14% 26.15 12%
12
NFIDENTIAL
Source: RBI and Altius research
Stable Increasing Decreasing
Changing share of GDP components in different Growth cycles
 Similarly the pie charts given below attempt to highlight the changing share of various components in differing Similarly, the pie charts given below attempt to highlight the changing share of various components in differing
growth cycles. The share of investment spending in the overall GDP also contracts from 37% in a boom period to
nearly 35.5% in a slowdown phase. Consumption spending also exhibits a similar trend.
 The boom phase components are an average of FY07 and FY08 owing to a real growth rate of over 9% recorded
in these years.
 Similarly, the slowdown phase considers FY09 and FY12 owing to the impact of credit crunch seen in the former
and the spill-over of European debt issues bogging down growth in the latter,
 FY10 d FY11 k d h i l h i l h i h i b d d 8% i h FY10 and FY11 are marked as the revival phase since real growth in the given years rebounded over 8% with
most components seeing a correction from the slowdown phase.
Foreign Trade
3 59%
Foreign Trade
‐5%
Foreign Trade
4 76%
Slowing exports widening Current
Account Deficit
Slow export, rebound in
imports widening CAD
STRICTL
Investment 
Expenditure
‐3.59%
Investment 
Expenditure
‐5%
Investment 
Expenditure
‐4.76%imports widening CAD
LYPRIVATEANDCO
Boom Slowdown Revival
Consumption 
Expenditure
57.31%
Expenditure
36.95%
Consumption 
Expenditure
56.86%
Expenditure
35.52%
Consumption 
Expenditure
56.98%
Expenditure
35.97%
13
NFIDENTIAL
Source: RBI and Altius research
Government 
expenditure
10.31%
Government 
expenditure
11.31%
Government 
expenditure
11.93%
Public spending pickup impacting
Fiscal Deficit
Widening Fiscal Deficit
Linkage between GDP and Deficits
 The slowdown in growth that triggers high expenses by Inverse relationship between GDP & Fiscal Deficit The slowdown in growth that triggers high expenses by
the government to support the faltering economic
activity also impacts the deficit. The figure highlight
the correlation between GDP and Fiscal deficit, this
also shows FD curve a the mirror image of GDP 4
5
6
7
12
14
16
18
20
also shows FD curve a the mirror image of GDP
trajectory.
 Since the slowdown is a function of a drop in
manufacturing and investment activity, thus the
0
1
2
3
0
2
4
6
8
10
%
Direct relationship between Fiscal deficit & CAD
revenue mop-up drops as chunk of the capital flow
funds the revenue expense to maintain the
consumption momentum.
 Subsidised domestic consumption changes the DNA of
00
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12
GDP at Market Price Fiscal Deficit as a % of GDP
STRICTL
 Subsidised domestic consumption changes the DNA of
imports as demand for capital spending takes the
backseat. Stronger revival capability of imports
compared to exports, reeling under global crisis, adds
pressure to the current account balance
2.5
3
3.5
4
4.5
4
5
6
7
%
LYPRIVATEANDCO
pressure to the current account balance.
 Hence, the figure alongside establishes the direct
correlation between fiscal deficit and current account
deficit owing to identical trajectory of the two curves. 0
0.5
1
1.5
2
0
1
2
3
%
14
NFIDENTIAL
Source: RBI and Altius research
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12
Fiscal Deficit as a % of GDP CAD as a % of GDP
Fiscal Path  Committed v/s Expected
At a Glance FY12 (RE) FY13 (BE) (%) Nov-12 YTD (%) FY13 (AE) Change
Revenue Receipts 7,670 9,357 22 4,458 9,129
-Tax Revenue (net to Centre) 6,423 7,711 20 3,696 15 7,483 16.5%
1. Direct Tax 4,996 5,690 14 2,683 15 5,795 16.0%
2. Indirect Tax* 4,021 5,086 26 2,704 15 4,745 18.0%
-Non-tax Revenue$ 1,247 1,646 32 762 1,646
Capital Receipts 5,517 5,552 1 4,218 5,680
-Recoveries of Loans 143 117 -18 67 117
-Disinvestment 155 300 94 22 200 INR 100 bn (-)
-Borrowings and other Liabilities 5,220 5,136 -2 4,129 5,364
1. Market Loan 5,525 4,880 -12 4,205 5,108
D t d S iti 4 364 4 790 4 790a. Dated Securities 4,364 4,790 4,790
b. Bills and Others 1,161 90 318
2. Others -305 256 -184 -75 256
Total Receipts 13,187 14,909 13 8,676 14 14,810
Non-plan Expenditure 8,921 9,699 9 6,243 16 10,273 15.2%
-On Revenue Account of which 8 157 8 656 6 5 663 17 9 433 15 6%
STRICTL
On Revenue Account of which 8,157 8,656 6 5,663 17 9,433 15.6%
1. Interest Payments 2,756 3,198 16 1,829 10 3,198 16.0%
2. Fertiliser Subsidy 672 610 -9 553 656
3. Petroleum Subsidy 685 436 -36 403 723 H1 UR INR 855 bn
4. Food Subsidy 728 750 3 728 750
-On Capital Account 764 1,043 37 580 7 840 10.0%
LYPRIVATEANDCO
p ,
Plan Expenditure 4,266 5,210 22 2,434 10 4,778 12.0%
Total Expenditure 13,187 14,909 13 8,676 14 15,051 14.1%
Fiscal Deficit 5,220 5,136 4,129 5,605
FD as a % of GDP 5.86 5.06 3.32 5.54
GDP 89,122 101,599 101,153
15
NFIDENTIAL
INR bn Source: Finmin.nic.in, Indiabudget.nic.in and Altius research
AE: Total Expenses is BE + Supplementary grant of INR 308 bn; YTD (%) is cumilative Y‐o‐Y for 8 month ended Nov 12 over Nov 11 Numbers in INR bn
Incremental T‐bill issuance of INR 318 bn as on December 14; * Indirect Tax = Sum of Excise, Custom and Service; $ Expected spectrum sale to meet BE by March
Diffrential of Total Expenses over Total Receipts is the incremental issuance that can come though any of the two marked source
Key Takeaway
 Gold and Petroleum products cumulatively occupy nearly 40% of the total imports Thus reigning in the duo can
Dealing with Deficit
 Gold and Petroleum products cumulatively occupy nearly 40% of the total imports. Thus reigning in the duo can
improve the merchandise trade balance substantially. Addressing the non-planned revenue spending would also
improve the fiscal balance by capping subsidy bill to 2% of GDP in medium term, helping to inch towards the
committed consolidation of Fiscal deficit at 3% of GDP by 2017.
 The revival of investment activity may also play a major role in boosting economic growth. The same has been
attempted via approval of big-ticket reforms that is aimed at facilitating domestic manufacturing and investment.
 A major factor to revive the economic activity remains the interest rate environment. Thus a likely cut in interest
rate by the monetary authority may help in buoying business sentiment taking the pressure off the government’srate by the monetary authority may help in buoying business sentiment taking the pressure off the government s
shoulders to support economic growth.
Committed Fiscal pathTrade Balance as a % of GDP
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1
STRICTL
4
5
6
7
6
‐4
‐2
0
FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1
%
LYPRIVATEANDCO
0
1
2
3
%
‐12
‐10
‐8
‐6
%
17
NFIDENTIAL
Source: PIB, RBI and Altius research
0
FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17
Actual Fiscal Deficit Targeted Fiscal Deficit
Trade balance Trade Balance ex‐gold
Trade Balance ex‐ Net Oil Trade Balance ex‐Net Oil & Gold
Risks to Deficit trajectory
 Recession in developed world With the European Union reeling under the textbook definition of a recession Recession in developed world- With the European Union reeling under the textbook definition of a recession,
the impact of the same has derailed the growth in some of the fastest growing Asian economies, viz., China and
India. Although, the Indian economy on back of government’s spending spree managed a revival in FY10 and FY11,
but the ability to sustain and grow when fiscal consolidation take center stage over next 5-years amid the
p e ailing t moil in de eloped economies ill be a da nting task (Anne e fig es 1 and 2)prevailing turmoil in developed economies will be a daunting task. (Annexure figures 1 and 2)
 Domestic macros- Food security bill scheduled to be passed and applicable since next fiscal, the upcoming
budget remaining populous in view of the 2014 elections, domestic monetary policy will continue to influence the
fiscal and trade balance.
 Global fiscal policy enigma- As global central banker strive to pull back their respective economies from slump
through the means of monetary easing, the translating impact on global commodity prices will percolate in
imported inflation for India. This can harness the domestic central banker willingness to ease monetary policy in
next financial year
STRICTL
next financial year.
 The Double edged sword- The ability of Indian government to completely deregulate petroleum products seems
like a never ending fight owing to the threat the same bears on economic an geo-political factors, however,
regulation of petroleum products poses as a major roadblock to its targeted fiscal consolidation aim.
LYPRIVATEANDCO
 Global crude oil prices- The geo-political issues in middle-east that has constantly pushed global crude oil prices
well above USD 100/bbl coupled with rupee weakness may continue to exert pressure as far as the subsidy bill is
concerned.
18
NFIDENTIAL
Annexure
Division of India’s export destinations (Fig 2.)Share of OECD nations in India’s export destination (Fig 1.)
60
70
80
90
100
60
70
80
90
100
10
20
30
40
50
60
%
0
10
20
30
40
50
%
0
10
FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12
Total OECD % Total OPEC %
0
FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12
All EU countries % All North American countries %
All Asian & Oceania countries % Other OECD countries %
Merchandise trade trajectory growth (in USD mn) (Fig 3.)
60
STRICTL
j y g ( ) ( g )
30
40
50
60
LYPRIVATEANDCO
‐10
0
10
20
Y08Q1
Y08Q2
Y08Q3
Y08Q4
Y09Q1
Y09Q2
Y09Q3
Y09Q4
Y10Q1
Y10Q2
Y10Q3
Y10Q4
Y11Q1
Y11Q2
Y11Q3
Y11Q4
Y12Q1
Y12Q2
Y12Q3
Y12Q4
Y13Q1
%
19
NFIDENTIAL
Source: RBI and Altius Research
‐30
‐20
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
FY
Export Y‐o‐Y Import Y‐o‐Y
Thank You
This report has been prepared by Altius Fincap Markets Limited to provide information about the company (ies) and sector(s) covered in the report and may be
distributed by it and/or its affiliated companies solely for the purpose of information of the select recipient of this report. This report and/or any part thereof may
not be duplicated in any form and/or reproduced or redistributed without the prior written consent of Altius Fincap Markets Limited.
Altius Fincap Markets Limited and/or its affiliated company (ies) might have managed corporate finance, other advisory services for the company (ies) covered
herein in the preceding twelve months and might have received compensation for the same during this period for the services in a specific transaction. Altius
Fincap Markets Limited and/or its affiliated company(ies) may receive compensation from the company(ies) mentioned in this report within a period of three to
six months' time following the date of publication of this research report for rendering any of the above services While reasonable care has been taken in thesix months' time following the date of publication of this research report for rendering any of the above services. While reasonable care has been taken in the
preparation of this report including but not limited to current or historical information, it does not purport to be a complete description of the securities, markets
or developments referred to herein, and Altius Fincap Markets Limited does not warrant/guarantee its accuracy or completeness. Altius Fincap Markets Limited or
any person connected with it may not be in any way responsible for any loss or damage that may arise to any person from any inadvertent error in the
information contained in this report. This report is provided for information only and is not intended to be and must not alone be taken as the basis for an
investment decision. The investment discussed or views expressed herein may not be suitable for all investors. The user assumes the entire risk of any use made
of this information. No person associated with Altius Fincap Markets Limited is obligated to call or initiate contact with you for the purposes of elaborating or
following up on the information contained in this report. Opinions expressed are Altius Fincap Markets Limited’s Current opinions as of the date appearing on this
report only
STRICTL
report only.
While Altius Fincap Markets Limited endeavour to update on a reasonable basis the information discussed in this material, there may be regulatory, compliance,
or other reasons that prevent it from doing so. The information contained herein may be changed without notice and Altius Fincap Markets Limited reserves the
right to make modifications and alterations to this statement as they may deem fit from time to time. The user is cautioned that any forward-looking statements
are not predictions and may be subject to change without notice. Altius Fincap Markets Limited and its affiliated company(ies), their directors and employees
may; (a) from time to time, have a long or short position in, and buy or sell the securities of the company(ies) mentioned herein or (b) be engaged in any other
transaction involving such securities and earn brokerage or other compensation or act as a market maker in the financial instruments of the company(ies)
discussed herein or seek to perform investment banking services for such company(ies) or act as an advisor or associated to such company(ies) or may have
LYPRIVATEANDCO
discussed herein or seek to perform investment banking services for such company(ies) or act as an advisor or associated to such company(ies) or may have
other potential conflict of interests with respect to any recommendation and other related information and opinions. This report is neither an offer nor solicitation
of an offer to buy and/or sell any securities mentioned herein and/or not an official confirmation of any transaction. This report is not directed or intended for
distribution to, or use by any person or entity who is a citizen or resident of or located in any locality, state, country or other jurisdiction, where such distribution,
publication, availability or use would be contrary to law, regulation or which would subject Altius Fincap Markets Limited and/or its affiliated company (ies) to any
registration or licensing requirement within such jurisdiction. The securities described herein may or may not be eligible for sale in all jurisdictions or to a certain
category of investors. Persons in whose possession this report may come are required to inform them of and to observe such restrictions
20
NFIDENTIAL
Visit us on www.altiusfin.co.in
Bloomberg: ALTS <Go>
Disclaimer: http://altiusfin.co.in/privacy-policy.html

More Related Content

What's hot

Current Austrlian Economic Trends and 2015 Predictions
Current Austrlian Economic Trends and 2015 PredictionsCurrent Austrlian Economic Trends and 2015 Predictions
Current Austrlian Economic Trends and 2015 PredictionsMatthew Pearce
 
Weekly media update 18. 05. 2015
Weekly media update 18. 05. 2015Weekly media update 18. 05. 2015
Weekly media update 18. 05. 2015BalmerLawrie
 
Economic Survey 2014-15
Economic Survey 2014-15Economic Survey 2014-15
Economic Survey 2014-15
Daily 10 Minutes
 
Economic Condition of Bangladesh
Economic Condition of BangladeshEconomic Condition of Bangladesh
Economic Condition of Bangladesh
Ataus Salam Shourav
 
Economy Matters: July-August 2015
Economy Matters: July-August 2015Economy Matters: July-August 2015
Economy Matters: July-August 2015
Confederation of Indian Industry
 
Weekly media update 17.08.2015
Weekly media update 17.08.2015Weekly media update 17.08.2015
Weekly media update 17.08.2015
BalmerLawrie
 
Fdi in bangladesh problems & prospects
Fdi in bangladesh problems & prospectsFdi in bangladesh problems & prospects
Fdi in bangladesh problems & prospects
Mushfiq Rayan
 
Challenges and Threats Faced by India Economy
Challenges and Threats Faced by India Economy Challenges and Threats Faced by India Economy
Challenges and Threats Faced by India Economy
Mervin Felix Caleb
 
Economic condition analysis of bangladesh......niloy.....
Economic condition analysis of bangladesh......niloy.....Economic condition analysis of bangladesh......niloy.....
Economic condition analysis of bangladesh......niloy.....
Niloy Saha
 
Major economic indicators of Banladesh in mid 2015
Major economic indicators of Banladesh in mid 2015Major economic indicators of Banladesh in mid 2015
Major economic indicators of Banladesh in mid 2015
Zahidul Islam
 
IJSRED-V2I3P101
IJSRED-V2I3P101IJSRED-V2I3P101
IJSRED-V2I3P101
IJSRED
 
effect of inflation on indian economy ppt
effect of inflation on indian economy ppteffect of inflation on indian economy ppt
effect of inflation on indian economy ppt
Babasab Patil
 
The overall economic condition of bangladesh
The overall economic condition of bangladeshThe overall economic condition of bangladesh
The overall economic condition of bangladeshTanvir777
 
Currency At Crisis
Currency At CrisisCurrency At Crisis
Currency At Crisis
Tarapada Ghosh
 
Import Trends of India
Import Trends of IndiaImport Trends of India
Import Trends of India
Kaivalya Shah
 
Fdi in bangladesh
Fdi in bangladeshFdi in bangladesh
Fdi in bangladesh
Biplob Hossain
 
Macroeconomic situation in Sri Lanka
Macroeconomic situation in Sri LankaMacroeconomic situation in Sri Lanka
Macroeconomic situation in Sri LankaThushan Dharmawardana
 
FDI in Bangladesh
FDI in BangladeshFDI in Bangladesh
FDI in BangladeshRifat Jamal
 
Vietnam Research Forecast Report 2Q2013 EN
Vietnam Research Forecast Report 2Q2013 ENVietnam Research Forecast Report 2Q2013 EN
Vietnam Research Forecast Report 2Q2013 EN
KyNam Doan
 
Weekly media update 23.11.2015
Weekly media update 23.11.2015Weekly media update 23.11.2015
Weekly media update 23.11.2015
BalmerLawrie
 

What's hot (20)

Current Austrlian Economic Trends and 2015 Predictions
Current Austrlian Economic Trends and 2015 PredictionsCurrent Austrlian Economic Trends and 2015 Predictions
Current Austrlian Economic Trends and 2015 Predictions
 
Weekly media update 18. 05. 2015
Weekly media update 18. 05. 2015Weekly media update 18. 05. 2015
Weekly media update 18. 05. 2015
 
Economic Survey 2014-15
Economic Survey 2014-15Economic Survey 2014-15
Economic Survey 2014-15
 
Economic Condition of Bangladesh
Economic Condition of BangladeshEconomic Condition of Bangladesh
Economic Condition of Bangladesh
 
Economy Matters: July-August 2015
Economy Matters: July-August 2015Economy Matters: July-August 2015
Economy Matters: July-August 2015
 
Weekly media update 17.08.2015
Weekly media update 17.08.2015Weekly media update 17.08.2015
Weekly media update 17.08.2015
 
Fdi in bangladesh problems & prospects
Fdi in bangladesh problems & prospectsFdi in bangladesh problems & prospects
Fdi in bangladesh problems & prospects
 
Challenges and Threats Faced by India Economy
Challenges and Threats Faced by India Economy Challenges and Threats Faced by India Economy
Challenges and Threats Faced by India Economy
 
Economic condition analysis of bangladesh......niloy.....
Economic condition analysis of bangladesh......niloy.....Economic condition analysis of bangladesh......niloy.....
Economic condition analysis of bangladesh......niloy.....
 
Major economic indicators of Banladesh in mid 2015
Major economic indicators of Banladesh in mid 2015Major economic indicators of Banladesh in mid 2015
Major economic indicators of Banladesh in mid 2015
 
IJSRED-V2I3P101
IJSRED-V2I3P101IJSRED-V2I3P101
IJSRED-V2I3P101
 
effect of inflation on indian economy ppt
effect of inflation on indian economy ppteffect of inflation on indian economy ppt
effect of inflation on indian economy ppt
 
The overall economic condition of bangladesh
The overall economic condition of bangladeshThe overall economic condition of bangladesh
The overall economic condition of bangladesh
 
Currency At Crisis
Currency At CrisisCurrency At Crisis
Currency At Crisis
 
Import Trends of India
Import Trends of IndiaImport Trends of India
Import Trends of India
 
Fdi in bangladesh
Fdi in bangladeshFdi in bangladesh
Fdi in bangladesh
 
Macroeconomic situation in Sri Lanka
Macroeconomic situation in Sri LankaMacroeconomic situation in Sri Lanka
Macroeconomic situation in Sri Lanka
 
FDI in Bangladesh
FDI in BangladeshFDI in Bangladesh
FDI in Bangladesh
 
Vietnam Research Forecast Report 2Q2013 EN
Vietnam Research Forecast Report 2Q2013 ENVietnam Research Forecast Report 2Q2013 EN
Vietnam Research Forecast Report 2Q2013 EN
 
Weekly media update 23.11.2015
Weekly media update 23.11.2015Weekly media update 23.11.2015
Weekly media update 23.11.2015
 

Viewers also liked

Module 6 5 fdi
Module 6 5 fdiModule 6 5 fdi
Module 6 5 fdi
Independent
 
Module 6 1 - efm - industrial policies and structure
Module 6 1 - efm - industrial policies and structureModule 6 1 - efm - industrial policies and structure
Module 6 1 - efm - industrial policies and structure
Independent
 
Balance of payment
Balance of paymentBalance of payment
Balance of payment
Shashank Singh
 
Role and purpose of FDI
Role and purpose of FDIRole and purpose of FDI
Role and purpose of FDI
Kartik Parashar
 
Understanding the Determinants and Impacts of FDI Inflows - An Indian Perspec...
Understanding the Determinants and Impacts of FDI Inflows - An Indian Perspec...Understanding the Determinants and Impacts of FDI Inflows - An Indian Perspec...
Understanding the Determinants and Impacts of FDI Inflows - An Indian Perspec...Jitender Barna
 
Balance of payment concept, components and trends
Balance of payment concept, components and trends Balance of payment concept, components and trends
Balance of payment concept, components and trends
shivakumar patil
 
Fdi in india
Fdi in indiaFdi in india
Fdi in india
Gauhar Khurshid
 
Twin deficit of indian economy
Twin deficit of indian economyTwin deficit of indian economy
Twin deficit of indian economy
identity684
 
FDI IN INDIA
FDI IN INDIAFDI IN INDIA
FDI IN INDIA
ROUSHAN RAJ KUMAR
 
FDI
FDIFDI
Increasing Your Share of FDI in 2016
Increasing Your Share of FDI in 2016Increasing Your Share of FDI in 2016
Increasing Your Share of FDI in 2016
Development Counsellors International
 
Fdi in india
Fdi in indiaFdi in india
Fdi in india
Joseph Kinattukara
 
Fdi policy and its impact on India
Fdi policy and its impact on IndiaFdi policy and its impact on India
Fdi policy and its impact on India
92_neil
 
Balance of payment
Balance of paymentBalance of payment
Balance of payment
Suresh Thengumpallil
 
Recent changes in FDI and ECB Norms
Recent changes in FDI and ECB NormsRecent changes in FDI and ECB Norms
Recent changes in FDI and ECB Norms
Dhruv Dua
 
Balance of Payments Basics - 2015 (India)
Balance of Payments Basics - 2015 (India)Balance of Payments Basics - 2015 (India)
Balance of Payments Basics - 2015 (India)
Suryansh Bansal
 
Foreign Direct Investment in India (FDI)
Foreign Direct Investment in India (FDI)Foreign Direct Investment in India (FDI)
Foreign Direct Investment in India (FDI)
Ameya Gandhi
 
foreign direct investment
foreign direct investmentforeign direct investment
foreign direct investment
Thunder Vinith
 
ECN 820 Thesis Final Version (Tariq Khan - 500543727) 02-05-2016
ECN 820 Thesis Final Version (Tariq Khan - 500543727) 02-05-2016ECN 820 Thesis Final Version (Tariq Khan - 500543727) 02-05-2016
ECN 820 Thesis Final Version (Tariq Khan - 500543727) 02-05-2016Tariq Khan
 
SEO: Getting Personal
SEO: Getting PersonalSEO: Getting Personal
SEO: Getting Personal
Kirsty Hulse
 

Viewers also liked (20)

Module 6 5 fdi
Module 6 5 fdiModule 6 5 fdi
Module 6 5 fdi
 
Module 6 1 - efm - industrial policies and structure
Module 6 1 - efm - industrial policies and structureModule 6 1 - efm - industrial policies and structure
Module 6 1 - efm - industrial policies and structure
 
Balance of payment
Balance of paymentBalance of payment
Balance of payment
 
Role and purpose of FDI
Role and purpose of FDIRole and purpose of FDI
Role and purpose of FDI
 
Understanding the Determinants and Impacts of FDI Inflows - An Indian Perspec...
Understanding the Determinants and Impacts of FDI Inflows - An Indian Perspec...Understanding the Determinants and Impacts of FDI Inflows - An Indian Perspec...
Understanding the Determinants and Impacts of FDI Inflows - An Indian Perspec...
 
Balance of payment concept, components and trends
Balance of payment concept, components and trends Balance of payment concept, components and trends
Balance of payment concept, components and trends
 
Fdi in india
Fdi in indiaFdi in india
Fdi in india
 
Twin deficit of indian economy
Twin deficit of indian economyTwin deficit of indian economy
Twin deficit of indian economy
 
FDI IN INDIA
FDI IN INDIAFDI IN INDIA
FDI IN INDIA
 
FDI
FDIFDI
FDI
 
Increasing Your Share of FDI in 2016
Increasing Your Share of FDI in 2016Increasing Your Share of FDI in 2016
Increasing Your Share of FDI in 2016
 
Fdi in india
Fdi in indiaFdi in india
Fdi in india
 
Fdi policy and its impact on India
Fdi policy and its impact on IndiaFdi policy and its impact on India
Fdi policy and its impact on India
 
Balance of payment
Balance of paymentBalance of payment
Balance of payment
 
Recent changes in FDI and ECB Norms
Recent changes in FDI and ECB NormsRecent changes in FDI and ECB Norms
Recent changes in FDI and ECB Norms
 
Balance of Payments Basics - 2015 (India)
Balance of Payments Basics - 2015 (India)Balance of Payments Basics - 2015 (India)
Balance of Payments Basics - 2015 (India)
 
Foreign Direct Investment in India (FDI)
Foreign Direct Investment in India (FDI)Foreign Direct Investment in India (FDI)
Foreign Direct Investment in India (FDI)
 
foreign direct investment
foreign direct investmentforeign direct investment
foreign direct investment
 
ECN 820 Thesis Final Version (Tariq Khan - 500543727) 02-05-2016
ECN 820 Thesis Final Version (Tariq Khan - 500543727) 02-05-2016ECN 820 Thesis Final Version (Tariq Khan - 500543727) 02-05-2016
ECN 820 Thesis Final Version (Tariq Khan - 500543727) 02-05-2016
 
SEO: Getting Personal
SEO: Getting PersonalSEO: Getting Personal
SEO: Getting Personal
 

Similar to Joining Dots- Twin Defict Analysis

India Budget Synthesis -2014
India Budget Synthesis -2014 India Budget Synthesis -2014
India Budget Synthesis -2014
Akshay KENKRE
 
India budget synthesis - 2014 - An Impact on Your Pocket
India budget synthesis - 2014 - An Impact on Your PocketIndia budget synthesis - 2014 - An Impact on Your Pocket
India budget synthesis - 2014 - An Impact on Your Pocket
ConTeTra Universal LLP
 
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
Joannes Mongardini
 
Turkey 2018
Turkey 2018Turkey 2018
Turkey 2018
Amir Khan
 
FICCI paper on Mega Plans
FICCI paper on Mega PlansFICCI paper on Mega Plans
Griffon quarterly report - Iran's Macro Economics dashboard - March 2017
Griffon quarterly report - Iran's Macro Economics dashboard - March 2017Griffon quarterly report - Iran's Macro Economics dashboard - March 2017
Griffon quarterly report - Iran's Macro Economics dashboard - March 2017
Griffon Capital
 
Pakistan: Finance Bill 2016/17
Pakistan: Finance Bill 2016/17Pakistan: Finance Bill 2016/17
Pakistan: Finance Bill 2016/17
Alex Baulf
 
Market Outlook Post Union Budget 2017-18
Market Outlook Post Union Budget 2017-18Market Outlook Post Union Budget 2017-18
Market Outlook Post Union Budget 2017-18
SBI Mutual Fund
 
Centrum wealth india investment strategy - 24 august 2013
Centrum wealth   india investment strategy - 24 august 2013Centrum wealth   india investment strategy - 24 august 2013
Centrum wealth india investment strategy - 24 august 2013umeshnihalani
 
Economic Outlook- Nov'15
Economic Outlook- Nov'15Economic Outlook- Nov'15
Economic Outlook- Nov'15
choice broking
 
Budget 2016-17: Implications for Trade and Investment
Budget 2016-17: Implications for Trade and InvestmentBudget 2016-17: Implications for Trade and Investment
Budget 2016-17: Implications for Trade and Investment
NIPFP Publications
 
Study on widening of tax base and tackling black money
Study on widening of tax base and tackling black moneyStudy on widening of tax base and tackling black money
Study on widening of tax base and tackling black money
Federation of Indian Chambers of Commerce & Industry (FICCI)
 
Union Budget 2015
Union Budget 2015 Union Budget 2015
Union Budget 2015
Akshay KENKRE
 
Economics Project
Economics ProjectEconomics Project
Economics Projectguest2c5fd0
 
India : Economic growth slows
India : Economic growth slowsIndia : Economic growth slows
India : Economic growth slows
Finalytiks Analytics
 
State of the Economy in 2018-19: A Macro View
State of the Economy in 2018-19: A Macro ViewState of the Economy in 2018-19: A Macro View
State of the Economy in 2018-19: A Macro View
DVSResearchFoundatio
 
2016 06 01_weekly_export_risk_outlook-n21
2016 06 01_weekly_export_risk_outlook-n212016 06 01_weekly_export_risk_outlook-n21
2016 06 01_weekly_export_risk_outlook-n21
Ethos Media S.A.
 
Budget in reference to growth of gdp
Budget in reference to growth of gdpBudget in reference to growth of gdp
Budget in reference to growth of gdp
M S Siddiqui
 
Weekly Media Update_05_02_2024. This document comprises news clips from vario...
Weekly Media Update_05_02_2024. This document comprises news clips from vario...Weekly Media Update_05_02_2024. This document comprises news clips from vario...
Weekly Media Update_05_02_2024. This document comprises news clips from vario...
BalmerLawrie
 

Similar to Joining Dots- Twin Defict Analysis (20)

IOC Zimbabwe 19052015
IOC Zimbabwe 19052015IOC Zimbabwe 19052015
IOC Zimbabwe 19052015
 
India Budget Synthesis -2014
India Budget Synthesis -2014 India Budget Synthesis -2014
India Budget Synthesis -2014
 
India budget synthesis - 2014 - An Impact on Your Pocket
India budget synthesis - 2014 - An Impact on Your PocketIndia budget synthesis - 2014 - An Impact on Your Pocket
India budget synthesis - 2014 - An Impact on Your Pocket
 
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
 
Turkey 2018
Turkey 2018Turkey 2018
Turkey 2018
 
FICCI paper on Mega Plans
FICCI paper on Mega PlansFICCI paper on Mega Plans
FICCI paper on Mega Plans
 
Griffon quarterly report - Iran's Macro Economics dashboard - March 2017
Griffon quarterly report - Iran's Macro Economics dashboard - March 2017Griffon quarterly report - Iran's Macro Economics dashboard - March 2017
Griffon quarterly report - Iran's Macro Economics dashboard - March 2017
 
Pakistan: Finance Bill 2016/17
Pakistan: Finance Bill 2016/17Pakistan: Finance Bill 2016/17
Pakistan: Finance Bill 2016/17
 
Market Outlook Post Union Budget 2017-18
Market Outlook Post Union Budget 2017-18Market Outlook Post Union Budget 2017-18
Market Outlook Post Union Budget 2017-18
 
Centrum wealth india investment strategy - 24 august 2013
Centrum wealth   india investment strategy - 24 august 2013Centrum wealth   india investment strategy - 24 august 2013
Centrum wealth india investment strategy - 24 august 2013
 
Economic Outlook- Nov'15
Economic Outlook- Nov'15Economic Outlook- Nov'15
Economic Outlook- Nov'15
 
Budget 2016-17: Implications for Trade and Investment
Budget 2016-17: Implications for Trade and InvestmentBudget 2016-17: Implications for Trade and Investment
Budget 2016-17: Implications for Trade and Investment
 
Study on widening of tax base and tackling black money
Study on widening of tax base and tackling black moneyStudy on widening of tax base and tackling black money
Study on widening of tax base and tackling black money
 
Union Budget 2015
Union Budget 2015 Union Budget 2015
Union Budget 2015
 
Economics Project
Economics ProjectEconomics Project
Economics Project
 
India : Economic growth slows
India : Economic growth slowsIndia : Economic growth slows
India : Economic growth slows
 
State of the Economy in 2018-19: A Macro View
State of the Economy in 2018-19: A Macro ViewState of the Economy in 2018-19: A Macro View
State of the Economy in 2018-19: A Macro View
 
2016 06 01_weekly_export_risk_outlook-n21
2016 06 01_weekly_export_risk_outlook-n212016 06 01_weekly_export_risk_outlook-n21
2016 06 01_weekly_export_risk_outlook-n21
 
Budget in reference to growth of gdp
Budget in reference to growth of gdpBudget in reference to growth of gdp
Budget in reference to growth of gdp
 
Weekly Media Update_05_02_2024. This document comprises news clips from vario...
Weekly Media Update_05_02_2024. This document comprises news clips from vario...Weekly Media Update_05_02_2024. This document comprises news clips from vario...
Weekly Media Update_05_02_2024. This document comprises news clips from vario...
 

Joining Dots- Twin Defict Analysis

  • 1. Twin Deficit Analysis- Growth perspective Rahul Chokshi 022-61598021 Hasan Razvi 022-61598049 8th January 2013
  • 2. Key Pointers  Deficit- Nature & Issues  Government Expenditure- Role & Nature  Revenue Spending- Plan & Non-planp g p  Capital Expenditure- Plan & Non-plan  Merchandise trade- Overhang on Current account  Invisibles Trade Balance- Services dominate  Role of Government Spending in Economic Growth  Linkage between GDP and Deficit STRICTL  Fiscal Path Committed v/s Expected  Dealing with the Deficit LYPRIVATEANDCO  Risks to Deficit trajectory  Annexure 2 NFIDENTIAL
  • 3. Deficit- Nature & Issues Twin Deficit Trajectoryj y 5 6 7 1 2 3 4 % Source: RBI and Altius research 0 1 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 Fiscal Deficit as a % of GDP CAD as a % of GDP STRICTL  India has for a long period now been plagued with double-deficit problem, viz., the Current Account Deficit (CAD) caused by a wedge between exports and imports and the Fiscal Deficit (FD) arising due to expenditure surpassing the revenue in a given period.  Deficit is deemed acceptable in an economy that is developing rapidly stoking consumption and investment Source: RBI and Altius research LYPRIVATEANDCO  Deficit is deemed acceptable in an economy that is developing rapidly stoking consumption and investment demand owing to which mismatches arise in meeting the growth momentum. Nature of deficit on the fiscal as well as current accounts dictates the sustainability of the growth trajectory.  For instance, higher fiscal funding on account of recurring revenue expenses leaves out lower room for 3 NFIDENTIAL capital spending to grow, similarly higher imports for consumption demand instead of manufacturing inputs eventually weakens the domestic currency substantially.
  • 4.  The figure alongside attempts to segregate the Government Expenditure- Role & Nature Share of Capital-Revenue Expenses 100% The figure alongside attempts to segregate the overall expenditure into revenue and capital spending based on their share in the aggregate expenditure. 60% 70% 80% 90% 100%  The figure thus portrays the share of capital expenditure at around 11% of the total expenditure and revenue spending at nearly 89% over the last 5 fiscal years. 10% 20% 30% 40% 50%  Similarly, the second figure has divided the total imports broadly into consumption and investment goods. 100% Share of Consumption-Investment Imports 0% FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1 Capital Expenditure Revenue Expenditure STRICTL  Thus consumption related imports occupy a greater portion in India’s import basket, at nearly 66%. Whereas, capital and export related goods that signify manufacturing demand stands barely at 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% LYPRIVATEANDCO around 33%.  The period under consideration is mainly from FY08 to the current fiscal year (according to availability of data) primarily due to the various growth cycles, 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 4 NFIDENTIAL ) p y g y , viz., boom, slowdown and revival that were observed in the short span under consideration. Source: Bloomberg, RBI and Altius research 0% FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13Q1 Consumption goods Investment goods
  • 6. Revenue Spending- Plan & Non-plan Y-o-Y growth of Total Revenue spending 40 25 30 35 40 5 10 15 20 % Source: India Budget and Altius Research 0 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 Budgeted Actual Estimated STRICTL  The continued divergence of actual revenue spending from budgeted target has been the prime factor to push up overall expenditure. The above figure also substantiates the proposition that slowing growth translates in a higher revenue spending by the government. Source: India Budget and Altius Research LYPRIVATEANDCO  The plunge in real GDP growth to 6.72% in FY09 from 9.32% growth seen in FY08 translated into a higher public spending by the government as the revenue spending rose to INR 7.94 tn from a budgeted target of INR 6.58 tn and a 34% growth from FY08’s revenue spending of INR 5.89 tn.  On the other hand immediately in the next fiscal year 2009-2010 as the economy showed signs of recovery 6 NFIDENTIAL  On the other hand, immediately in the next fiscal year 2009 2010 as the economy showed signs of recovery posting a real growth rate of 8.39%, the actual revenue spending also posted a minimal slippage at INR 9.06 tn from a budgeted target of INR 8.97 tn.
  • 7. Capital Expenditure- Plan & Non-plan Total Capital spending as a % of GDP4 2 % 0  The central issue with capital expenses is that it has actually been below the budgeted level for a substantial b f h l d d hi d h f i l i f h Source: 12th & 13th Finance Commission Report, India Budget and Altius Research FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 12th & 13th Finance Commission  Extimates Budgeted Actual Estimated STRICTL number of times in the last decade. This undershoot of capital expenses is a matter of concern as the same highlights the inability to achieve a targeted level of infrastructure that proves to be a roadblock in paving the path to economic growth recovery.  The slowdown seen in FY09 owing to the global credit crunch forced the government to support domestic demand LYPRIVATEANDCO by heavy revenue expenses as the trade-off by reducing the capital spending; easing from 2.4% of GDP in FY08 to almost 1.6% of GDP in the given year. The targeted 31% Y-o-Y growth of capital expenditure in FY13 is also set to fall short of the budgeted target given the Y-o-Y growth pattern of merely 17% in Apr-Nov period  Ironically capital spending that is non recurring and developmental in nature fails to meet its budgeted target as 7 NFIDENTIAL  Ironically capital spending, that is non-recurring and developmental in nature fails to meet its budgeted target as the cost of an overshoot in revenue is borne by the haircut in capital spending. This induces a sort of cyclical characteristic to the deficit making it structural rather than a temporary one.
  • 9. Merchandise trade- Overhang on Current account  The slowdown in an economy, where on one hand impacts manufacturing activity stunting investment demand, it failed to meaningfully dent the domestic consumption demand.  Thus a drop in manufacturing and investment demand eventually impacts the exports. For instance, credit crunch of 2008 that resulted in a contraction in export demand from the developed world, thus India’s exports growth l d t 15 3% FY09 f th t ti t 0 6% i FY10 ( i l h ) f th fi t ti i th l t d dslowed to 15.3% FY09 further contracting to 0.6% in FY10 (revival phase) ,for the first time in the last decade.  The slowdown in investment demand also impacts the import of bulk import goods and capital goods highlighting the slowdown in investments and manufacturing activity, however, the issue remains the pace of slowdown, as merchandise imports exhibit a quicker rebound compared with exports. The contraction in imports lasted to merely 3-quarters whereas, exports witnessed a longer spell of contraction. (Annexure figure 3) Trade deficit & CAD as % of GDP (INR cr) Foreign Trade trajectory (USD mn) 0 0 5 0 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1 45 STRICTL ‐10 ‐5 2 5 ‐2 ‐1.5 ‐1 ‐0.5 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1 % % 25 35 % LYPRIVATEANDCO ‐20 ‐15 ‐4.5 ‐4 ‐3.5 ‐3 ‐2.5 % % 5 15 % 9 NFIDENTIAL Source: RBI and Altius research ‐25‐5 4.5 CAD Trade deficit ‐5 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 Export Y‐o‐Y Import Y‐o‐Y
  • 10. Invisibles Trade Balance- Services dominate  The services trade balance plays an dominant role in influencing the invisible trade portion of the current account, as the pulse of services balance is imitated by the invisibles balance. The economy has relished a surplus on the invisibles balance aided by robust services growth, although the external shocks does impact its growth trajectory.  With the most recent slowdown being triggered by the credit crunch and recession seen in the developed world, the services exports growth also exhibited a contraction in corresponding quartersservices exports growth also exhibited a contraction in corresponding quarters.  As the ‘financial crisis’ deepened, the Y-o-Y exports fizzled out to merely 4% growth in Q3 of FY09 compared with 25% growth seen in the same quarter in FY08. This was followed with 4-consecutive quarters of contraction in exports.  A similar impact was also seen on the import front, although there is an almost spontaneous rebound in services import growth. Exports- Invisibles: Services (USD mn) Imports- Invisibles : Services (USD mn) 80 STRICTL Prolonged export contraction Spontaneous rebound in imports 30 40 50 60 70 80 30 40 50 60 70 LYPRIVATEANDCO 20 ‐10 0 10 20 30 Y08Q1 Y08Q2 Y08Q3 Y08Q4 Y09Q1 Y09Q2 Y09Q3 Y09Q4 Y10Q1 Y10Q2 Y10Q3 Y10Q4 Y11Q1 Y11Q2 Y11Q3 Y11Q4 Y12Q1 Y12Q2 Y12Q3 Y12Q4 Y13Q1 Y13Q2 % 20 ‐10 0 10 20 Y08Q1 Y08Q2 Y08Q3 Y08Q4 Y09Q1 Y09Q2 Y09Q3 Y09Q4 Y10Q1 Y10Q2 Y10Q3 Y10Q4 Y11Q1 Y11Q2 Y11Q3 Y11Q4 Y12Q1 Y12Q2 Y12Q3 Y12Q4 Y13Q1 Y13Q2 % 10 NFIDENTIAL Source: RBI and Altius research ‐30 ‐20 FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY Invisibles Import growth Y‐o‐Y Services Import growth Y‐o‐Y ‐30 ‐20 FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY Invisibles Export growth Y‐o‐Y Services Export growth Y‐o‐Y
  • 11. Growth Implications of Twin Deficit
  • 12. Role of Government Spending in Economic Growth  The table given below attempts to substantiate the impact of slowing growth on changing composition of GDP The table given below attempts to substantiate the impact of slowing growth on changing composition of GDP contributed by government, consumption and investment expenditure over the past economic cycle.  The Y-o-Y growth rate of investment expenditure was slashed to nearly half, growing merely at 11% in FY09 owing to the credit crunch in the developed world, compared with over 20% growth seen in the previous 3 fiscal years.  Government expenditure on the other hand spiked to 20% in FY09 and the upward trend in also maintained in revival phase in order to support the economy and put the economic growth back on track.  The catch here remains the consumption expenditure and recurring revenue expenses (as exhibited on page 6) h d i l i l fl i i f h h l h h i i h h Thithat tends to remain relatively flat irrespective of the growth cycle that the economy is going through. This stickiness or inelasticity in consumption demand and revenue expenses explains the widening twin deficits. Growth rate of GDP components in varied growth cycles FY11 FY12FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 STRICTL GDP  Components Amount  (INR tn) Y‐o‐Y  growth Amount  (INR tn) Y‐o‐Y  growth Amount  (INR tn) Y‐o‐Y  growth Amount  (INR tn) Y‐o‐Y  growth Amount  (INR tn) Y‐o‐Y  growth Amount  (INR tn) Y‐o‐Y  growth Amount  (INR tn) Y‐o‐Y  growth Amount  (INR tn) Y‐o‐Y  growth Consumption  Expenditure 19.18 8% 21.53 12% 24.77 15% 28.41 15% 32.49 14% 37.08 14% 43.38 17% 49.62 14% G t FY11 FY12FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 LYPRIVATEANDCO Government  Expenditure 3.55 9% 4.02 13% 4.43 10% 5.13 16% 6.15 20% 7.74 26% 9.11 18% 10.36 14% Investment  Expenditure 9.31 33% 11.20 20% 13.44 20% 16.42 22% 18.21 11% 20.42 12% 23.31 14% 26.15 12% 12 NFIDENTIAL Source: RBI and Altius research Stable Increasing Decreasing
  • 13. Changing share of GDP components in different Growth cycles  Similarly the pie charts given below attempt to highlight the changing share of various components in differing Similarly, the pie charts given below attempt to highlight the changing share of various components in differing growth cycles. The share of investment spending in the overall GDP also contracts from 37% in a boom period to nearly 35.5% in a slowdown phase. Consumption spending also exhibits a similar trend.  The boom phase components are an average of FY07 and FY08 owing to a real growth rate of over 9% recorded in these years.  Similarly, the slowdown phase considers FY09 and FY12 owing to the impact of credit crunch seen in the former and the spill-over of European debt issues bogging down growth in the latter,  FY10 d FY11 k d h i l h i l h i h i b d d 8% i h FY10 and FY11 are marked as the revival phase since real growth in the given years rebounded over 8% with most components seeing a correction from the slowdown phase. Foreign Trade 3 59% Foreign Trade ‐5% Foreign Trade 4 76% Slowing exports widening Current Account Deficit Slow export, rebound in imports widening CAD STRICTL Investment  Expenditure ‐3.59% Investment  Expenditure ‐5% Investment  Expenditure ‐4.76%imports widening CAD LYPRIVATEANDCO Boom Slowdown Revival Consumption  Expenditure 57.31% Expenditure 36.95% Consumption  Expenditure 56.86% Expenditure 35.52% Consumption  Expenditure 56.98% Expenditure 35.97% 13 NFIDENTIAL Source: RBI and Altius research Government  expenditure 10.31% Government  expenditure 11.31% Government  expenditure 11.93% Public spending pickup impacting Fiscal Deficit Widening Fiscal Deficit
  • 14. Linkage between GDP and Deficits  The slowdown in growth that triggers high expenses by Inverse relationship between GDP & Fiscal Deficit The slowdown in growth that triggers high expenses by the government to support the faltering economic activity also impacts the deficit. The figure highlight the correlation between GDP and Fiscal deficit, this also shows FD curve a the mirror image of GDP 4 5 6 7 12 14 16 18 20 also shows FD curve a the mirror image of GDP trajectory.  Since the slowdown is a function of a drop in manufacturing and investment activity, thus the 0 1 2 3 0 2 4 6 8 10 % Direct relationship between Fiscal deficit & CAD revenue mop-up drops as chunk of the capital flow funds the revenue expense to maintain the consumption momentum.  Subsidised domestic consumption changes the DNA of 00 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 GDP at Market Price Fiscal Deficit as a % of GDP STRICTL  Subsidised domestic consumption changes the DNA of imports as demand for capital spending takes the backseat. Stronger revival capability of imports compared to exports, reeling under global crisis, adds pressure to the current account balance 2.5 3 3.5 4 4.5 4 5 6 7 % LYPRIVATEANDCO pressure to the current account balance.  Hence, the figure alongside establishes the direct correlation between fiscal deficit and current account deficit owing to identical trajectory of the two curves. 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 0 1 2 3 % 14 NFIDENTIAL Source: RBI and Altius research FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 Fiscal Deficit as a % of GDP CAD as a % of GDP
  • 15. Fiscal Path  Committed v/s Expected At a Glance FY12 (RE) FY13 (BE) (%) Nov-12 YTD (%) FY13 (AE) Change Revenue Receipts 7,670 9,357 22 4,458 9,129 -Tax Revenue (net to Centre) 6,423 7,711 20 3,696 15 7,483 16.5% 1. Direct Tax 4,996 5,690 14 2,683 15 5,795 16.0% 2. Indirect Tax* 4,021 5,086 26 2,704 15 4,745 18.0% -Non-tax Revenue$ 1,247 1,646 32 762 1,646 Capital Receipts 5,517 5,552 1 4,218 5,680 -Recoveries of Loans 143 117 -18 67 117 -Disinvestment 155 300 94 22 200 INR 100 bn (-) -Borrowings and other Liabilities 5,220 5,136 -2 4,129 5,364 1. Market Loan 5,525 4,880 -12 4,205 5,108 D t d S iti 4 364 4 790 4 790a. Dated Securities 4,364 4,790 4,790 b. Bills and Others 1,161 90 318 2. Others -305 256 -184 -75 256 Total Receipts 13,187 14,909 13 8,676 14 14,810 Non-plan Expenditure 8,921 9,699 9 6,243 16 10,273 15.2% -On Revenue Account of which 8 157 8 656 6 5 663 17 9 433 15 6% STRICTL On Revenue Account of which 8,157 8,656 6 5,663 17 9,433 15.6% 1. Interest Payments 2,756 3,198 16 1,829 10 3,198 16.0% 2. Fertiliser Subsidy 672 610 -9 553 656 3. Petroleum Subsidy 685 436 -36 403 723 H1 UR INR 855 bn 4. Food Subsidy 728 750 3 728 750 -On Capital Account 764 1,043 37 580 7 840 10.0% LYPRIVATEANDCO p , Plan Expenditure 4,266 5,210 22 2,434 10 4,778 12.0% Total Expenditure 13,187 14,909 13 8,676 14 15,051 14.1% Fiscal Deficit 5,220 5,136 4,129 5,605 FD as a % of GDP 5.86 5.06 3.32 5.54 GDP 89,122 101,599 101,153 15 NFIDENTIAL INR bn Source: Finmin.nic.in, Indiabudget.nic.in and Altius research AE: Total Expenses is BE + Supplementary grant of INR 308 bn; YTD (%) is cumilative Y‐o‐Y for 8 month ended Nov 12 over Nov 11 Numbers in INR bn Incremental T‐bill issuance of INR 318 bn as on December 14; * Indirect Tax = Sum of Excise, Custom and Service; $ Expected spectrum sale to meet BE by March Diffrential of Total Expenses over Total Receipts is the incremental issuance that can come though any of the two marked source
  • 17.  Gold and Petroleum products cumulatively occupy nearly 40% of the total imports Thus reigning in the duo can Dealing with Deficit  Gold and Petroleum products cumulatively occupy nearly 40% of the total imports. Thus reigning in the duo can improve the merchandise trade balance substantially. Addressing the non-planned revenue spending would also improve the fiscal balance by capping subsidy bill to 2% of GDP in medium term, helping to inch towards the committed consolidation of Fiscal deficit at 3% of GDP by 2017.  The revival of investment activity may also play a major role in boosting economic growth. The same has been attempted via approval of big-ticket reforms that is aimed at facilitating domestic manufacturing and investment.  A major factor to revive the economic activity remains the interest rate environment. Thus a likely cut in interest rate by the monetary authority may help in buoying business sentiment taking the pressure off the government’srate by the monetary authority may help in buoying business sentiment taking the pressure off the government s shoulders to support economic growth. Committed Fiscal pathTrade Balance as a % of GDP FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1 STRICTL 4 5 6 7 6 ‐4 ‐2 0 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13H1 % LYPRIVATEANDCO 0 1 2 3 % ‐12 ‐10 ‐8 ‐6 % 17 NFIDENTIAL Source: PIB, RBI and Altius research 0 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 FY13 FY14 FY15 FY16 FY17 Actual Fiscal Deficit Targeted Fiscal Deficit Trade balance Trade Balance ex‐gold Trade Balance ex‐ Net Oil Trade Balance ex‐Net Oil & Gold
  • 18. Risks to Deficit trajectory  Recession in developed world With the European Union reeling under the textbook definition of a recession Recession in developed world- With the European Union reeling under the textbook definition of a recession, the impact of the same has derailed the growth in some of the fastest growing Asian economies, viz., China and India. Although, the Indian economy on back of government’s spending spree managed a revival in FY10 and FY11, but the ability to sustain and grow when fiscal consolidation take center stage over next 5-years amid the p e ailing t moil in de eloped economies ill be a da nting task (Anne e fig es 1 and 2)prevailing turmoil in developed economies will be a daunting task. (Annexure figures 1 and 2)  Domestic macros- Food security bill scheduled to be passed and applicable since next fiscal, the upcoming budget remaining populous in view of the 2014 elections, domestic monetary policy will continue to influence the fiscal and trade balance.  Global fiscal policy enigma- As global central banker strive to pull back their respective economies from slump through the means of monetary easing, the translating impact on global commodity prices will percolate in imported inflation for India. This can harness the domestic central banker willingness to ease monetary policy in next financial year STRICTL next financial year.  The Double edged sword- The ability of Indian government to completely deregulate petroleum products seems like a never ending fight owing to the threat the same bears on economic an geo-political factors, however, regulation of petroleum products poses as a major roadblock to its targeted fiscal consolidation aim. LYPRIVATEANDCO  Global crude oil prices- The geo-political issues in middle-east that has constantly pushed global crude oil prices well above USD 100/bbl coupled with rupee weakness may continue to exert pressure as far as the subsidy bill is concerned. 18 NFIDENTIAL
  • 19. Annexure Division of India’s export destinations (Fig 2.)Share of OECD nations in India’s export destination (Fig 1.) 60 70 80 90 100 60 70 80 90 100 10 20 30 40 50 60 % 0 10 20 30 40 50 % 0 10 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 Total OECD % Total OPEC % 0 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07 FY08 FY09 FY10 FY11 FY12 All EU countries % All North American countries % All Asian & Oceania countries % Other OECD countries % Merchandise trade trajectory growth (in USD mn) (Fig 3.) 60 STRICTL j y g ( ) ( g ) 30 40 50 60 LYPRIVATEANDCO ‐10 0 10 20 Y08Q1 Y08Q2 Y08Q3 Y08Q4 Y09Q1 Y09Q2 Y09Q3 Y09Q4 Y10Q1 Y10Q2 Y10Q3 Y10Q4 Y11Q1 Y11Q2 Y11Q3 Y11Q4 Y12Q1 Y12Q2 Y12Q3 Y12Q4 Y13Q1 % 19 NFIDENTIAL Source: RBI and Altius Research ‐30 ‐20 FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY FY Export Y‐o‐Y Import Y‐o‐Y
  • 20. Thank You This report has been prepared by Altius Fincap Markets Limited to provide information about the company (ies) and sector(s) covered in the report and may be distributed by it and/or its affiliated companies solely for the purpose of information of the select recipient of this report. This report and/or any part thereof may not be duplicated in any form and/or reproduced or redistributed without the prior written consent of Altius Fincap Markets Limited. Altius Fincap Markets Limited and/or its affiliated company (ies) might have managed corporate finance, other advisory services for the company (ies) covered herein in the preceding twelve months and might have received compensation for the same during this period for the services in a specific transaction. Altius Fincap Markets Limited and/or its affiliated company(ies) may receive compensation from the company(ies) mentioned in this report within a period of three to six months' time following the date of publication of this research report for rendering any of the above services While reasonable care has been taken in thesix months' time following the date of publication of this research report for rendering any of the above services. While reasonable care has been taken in the preparation of this report including but not limited to current or historical information, it does not purport to be a complete description of the securities, markets or developments referred to herein, and Altius Fincap Markets Limited does not warrant/guarantee its accuracy or completeness. Altius Fincap Markets Limited or any person connected with it may not be in any way responsible for any loss or damage that may arise to any person from any inadvertent error in the information contained in this report. This report is provided for information only and is not intended to be and must not alone be taken as the basis for an investment decision. The investment discussed or views expressed herein may not be suitable for all investors. The user assumes the entire risk of any use made of this information. No person associated with Altius Fincap Markets Limited is obligated to call or initiate contact with you for the purposes of elaborating or following up on the information contained in this report. Opinions expressed are Altius Fincap Markets Limited’s Current opinions as of the date appearing on this report only STRICTL report only. While Altius Fincap Markets Limited endeavour to update on a reasonable basis the information discussed in this material, there may be regulatory, compliance, or other reasons that prevent it from doing so. The information contained herein may be changed without notice and Altius Fincap Markets Limited reserves the right to make modifications and alterations to this statement as they may deem fit from time to time. The user is cautioned that any forward-looking statements are not predictions and may be subject to change without notice. Altius Fincap Markets Limited and its affiliated company(ies), their directors and employees may; (a) from time to time, have a long or short position in, and buy or sell the securities of the company(ies) mentioned herein or (b) be engaged in any other transaction involving such securities and earn brokerage or other compensation or act as a market maker in the financial instruments of the company(ies) discussed herein or seek to perform investment banking services for such company(ies) or act as an advisor or associated to such company(ies) or may have LYPRIVATEANDCO discussed herein or seek to perform investment banking services for such company(ies) or act as an advisor or associated to such company(ies) or may have other potential conflict of interests with respect to any recommendation and other related information and opinions. This report is neither an offer nor solicitation of an offer to buy and/or sell any securities mentioned herein and/or not an official confirmation of any transaction. This report is not directed or intended for distribution to, or use by any person or entity who is a citizen or resident of or located in any locality, state, country or other jurisdiction, where such distribution, publication, availability or use would be contrary to law, regulation or which would subject Altius Fincap Markets Limited and/or its affiliated company (ies) to any registration or licensing requirement within such jurisdiction. The securities described herein may or may not be eligible for sale in all jurisdictions or to a certain category of investors. Persons in whose possession this report may come are required to inform them of and to observe such restrictions 20 NFIDENTIAL Visit us on www.altiusfin.co.in Bloomberg: ALTS <Go> Disclaimer: http://altiusfin.co.in/privacy-policy.html