SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 11
Download to read offline
1
T
FE
ex
th
w
re
su
E
A
w
w
B
be
im
ce
th
a
m
co
20
on
tim
ha
A
Special Repo
Turkey
EBRUARY 2
fter th
about
espec
xternal fron
he hit to the
was therefo
eason beh
ustainable.
Economy
lthough the
with at least
was rather l
ut the fact
een viewe
mproved th
ertainly so
hree quarte
series of f
measures. T
ontribution
017. We w
n the back
me the rec
alf Turkish
A
ort | February 2
– Is it
2018
he July 201
t whether
cially in lig
nt, which m
e Turkish e
ore seen as
hind the s
. We will th
y rebound
e failed co
t some 265
limited. Ad
t that it the
ed by som
hanks, in
me truth to
ers of last y
fiscal (temp
These ser
to growth
will look at
k of these
covery in th
exports ar
2018
Over t
16 failed co
the Turk
ht of the fa
make it hea
economy o
s somethin
sharp rebo
hen look at
ds sharp
oup attemp
5 people ki
dmittedly, t
en rebound
me as a si
large part
o this claim
year, with
porary tax
rved to ba
h stood at
these mea
initiatives,
he internat
re destined
the Wo
oup attemp
kish econo
act that it’s
avily relian
only proved
ng of a sur
ound in gr
t some the
ply in the
t that took
illed accord
he econom
ded to a ro
gn that th
t, to the
m, this reb
GDP grow
cuts) and
ckstop priv
almost 6%
asures in g
domestic
tional econ
d – has he
orst?
pt in Turke
omy could
s faced wit
nt on overs
d fleeting –
rprise. We
rowth rece
challenge
afterma
k place in J
ding some
my contrac
obust 4.2%
he underly
strength o
bound – w
wth expand
quasi-fisca
vate consu
% points o
greater det
demand h
nomy – and
lped to sup
AM
ECO
T: +
E: A
The
A me
ey, some in
d weather
h various v
seas financ
– it only co
will use th
ently and
es which lie
th of the
July 2016 w
e press rep
cted in Q3
% in the su
ing relianc
of domest
hich accel
ding by an
al (credit g
umption a
n average
tail below,
has so far
d in particu
pport net e
Spec
IR KHAN
ONOMIC RE
+44-(0)207-5
Amir.Khan@
Bank of Toky
ember of MUFG
ncluding ou
the dom
vulnerabilit
cing. The
ntracted d
his note to
ask if the
e ahead for
failed co
was costly
orts – its im
of 2016 to
bsequent q
ce of the
ic consum
erated eve
average of
guarantee f
nd investm
during the
but the po
held up w
ular the Eu
exports (se
cial Re
ESEARCH | L
577-2180
@uk.mufg.jp
kyo-Mitsubish
G, a global finan
urselves, w
estic polit
ties, partic
fact that,
uring Q3 o
o examine
e current
r the count
oup atte
in terms o
mpact on t
o the tune
quarter (Q
Turkish ec
mption. Wh
en further
f 7.3% – a
fund loans
ment whos
e initial th
oint to high
well, while
urozone, w
ee Chart 1)
eport
LONDON
hi UFJ, Ltd.
cial group
were worrie
tical turmo
ularly on th
in the even
of last year
some of th
recovery
try.
mpt…
of lives lost
the econom
of 0.8% y/
Q4-2016) ha
conomy h
hile there
into the fir
also reflecte
s) pro-grow
se combine
ree quarte
hlight is tha
at the sam
where almo
).
ed
oil,
he
nt,
r –
he
is
t –
my
/y.
as
as
is
rst
ed
wth
ed
ers
at,
me
ost
Special Report | February 20182
Going forward, if high frequency indicators, such industrial production and retail sales are
anything to go by (see Chart 2), the growth outturn for the final quarter of 2017 should remain
strong, though there is the likelihood that it will start to be adversely affected due to
unfavourable base effects and the expiry of some of the stimulus measures introduced in the
aftermath of the failed coup attempt. Despite this, we envision full year growth in 2017 coming
in at north of 6%, a figure which, if realised, will be well above the previous year’s outturn of
3.2%. For 2018, our sense is that growth is likely to moderate somewhat and come in to the
tune of around 4%. Of note here is that the government will not want growth to fall much less
than the aforementioned figure for fear that it will adversely impact its electoral popularity at the
forthcoming elections in 2019.
…Thanks to a range of initiatives introduced on the part of the authorities…
Mindful of the likely negative impact of the failed military coup on the Turkish economy –
through confidence and related channels – the Turkish authorities sought to backstop growth
through a number of measures:
 On the fiscal side, the government instigated a major reduction of value-added tax on white
goods (kitchen appliances) and on furniture1
. This helped to cushion consumer spending
and private consumption more broadly, as Chart 1 appears to bear out.
 Beyond traditional fiscal measures, the government also took steps to set up a TRY250bn
(~US$65bn) Credit Guarantee Fund (CGF). This, in our mind, was perhaps the most
significant step taken by the government and was set up to encourage local banks to lend
to small and mid-sized businesses by offering partial Treasury guarantees on any non-
performing loans at up to 7% of all loans.
1
Consumption taxes on air conditioners, refrigerators, washing machines, dish washers, vacuum cleaners and some small home appliances
were reduced from 6.7% to zero. Elsewhere, VAT on wood, plastic and office furniture was also decreased to 8%.
(Source) Turkstat, BTMU (Source) Macrobond, BTMU
-6
-4
-2
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
14
Q1-15
Q2-15
Q3-15
Q4-15
Q1-16
Q2-16
Q3-16
Q4-16
Q1-17
Q2-17
Q3-17
Chart 1:CompositionofTurkish GDPgrowth has
broadened...
Private Cons.
GFCF
Gov. Cons.
Net exports
Change in inventory
Headline GDP (%)
(Contribution, percentage points)
-6
-3
0
3
6
9
12
Jan/12
Jan/13
Jan/14
Jan/15
Jan/16
Jan/17
Chart 2:...While highfrequency indicators appearto
suggest that growth will continue to remainrobust
Retail Sales (3m MA,%y/y) IndustialProduction (3mMA, %y/y)
Special Report | February 20183
 On the monetary policy front, while there was little scope to cut rates to support the
economy – thanks a weakening exchange rate and headline inflation running well above
the Central Bank of Turkey’s (CBRT) target of around 5% – this did not prevent the CBRT
from providing unlimited liquidity to the banking system. Additionally, macro-prudential rules
have been relaxed so that, among other things, those borrowing in the form of unsecured
credit have seen their repayment periods extended.
While it’s difficult to disaggregate the impact of these measures on Turkey’s recent growth
performance, it’s fair to say that, taken together, they’ve played a vital role in reviving
confidence in the Turkish economy. Indeed, on the back of such measures, key industrial
activity indicators have rebounded after the failed coup attempt (see Chart 3). Additionally, by
standing behind the banking system through the provision of unlimited liquidity, there was no
run on the Turkish banking system, while at the same time a potential “credit crunch” scenario
was avoided. Indeed, since H2-2016 credit flows to the “real economy” have picked noticeably
and presently stand at 20% plus in annual terms even on a foreign currency-adjusted basis
(see Chart 4). While this is indicative of the buoyancy of Turkey’s current credit-fuelled
recovery, the downside of all this is that by boosting domestic demand – and hence imports – it
will serve to perpetuate the underlying structural imbalances in the Turkish economy,
particularly in terms of its much talked-about current account deficit. Also, of note here is the
fact that the government’s efforts to engineer strong growth has come at the expense of higher
inflation. Indeed, at 11.9%, the latest CPI reading is well above the CBRT’s 5% target and
appears to be driven by higher food and fuel costs. More worryingly, at 11.8%, core CPI –
which strips out volatile items such as food and fuel – has reached the highest point since
2004, suggesting more broad-based inflationary pressures (see Chart 5). This, along with
ongoing downward pressure on the lira, in our minds warrants the need for higher interest
rates which – while they appear to be high on a nominal basis – in inflation-adjusted terms are
barely in positive territory2
. That said, our sense is that with the ongoing pressure on the CBRT
from the governing AKP party – including Mr. Erdogan himself – to, in fact, loosen monetary
this is likely to constrain its room to raise rates much further from current levels.
2
For the sake of simplicity, if we take the CBRT’s weighted average interest rate in nominal terms it stands at 12.25% but in real terms it only
amounts to 0.35%.
Special Report | February 20184
…But questions about sustainability continue to linger…
In essence, the measures taken by the Turkish authorities in the aftermath of the attempted
coup have worked in terms of supporting growth. But, despite this, there are still questions
about both the sustainability and quality of growth. This is based on the following reasoning:
 For one thing, over 85% of the TRY250bn CGF – which was an important driver of growth
through the course of this year – has now been used up. As a result, credit growth,
particularly to the corporate sector is set to slow going forward. This, in turn, is likely to be a
drag on investment spending looking ahead.
 While we welcome the fact that net exports have made a positive contribution to growth
recently, this can perhaps be attributed to temporary factors, such as the declining value of
(Source) Macrobond, BTMU *Adjustment made on the basis that 90% of CGF related lending is in TRY, while 10%
in FX. (Source) Macrobond, BTMU
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
42
44
46
48
50
52
54
56
Jan/12
Jul/12
Jan/13
Jul/13
Jan/14
Jul/14
Jan/15
Jul/15
Jan/16
Jul/16
Jan/17
Jul/17
Chart 3: Industrial activity indicators have rebounded
sharply after the failed coup attempt...
Capacity utilisation rate (RHS, %) PMI (LHS)
(Total loan growth, % y/y)
0
10
20
30
40
50
Jan/12
Jan/13
Jan/14
Jan/15
Jan/16
Jan/17
Chart4: Thanks in large part to the strong creditimpulse
FX denominated Total (FX adjusted)* Total (TRY)
(Loan growth, % y/y)
(Source) Macrobond, BTMU
2
4
6
8
10
12
Jan/12
Jan/13
Jan/14
Jan/15
Jan/16
Jan/17
Chart 5: Inflationary pressure have itensified and not just at the
headline level
CPI Core CPI
(%, y/y)
CBRT target
Special Report | February 20185
the Turkish lira, which is likely to have made the country’s exports more price competitive
abroad. Also, on the external front, our sense is that import growth is likely to accelerate in
H2 on the back of strong domestic demand, so the positive contribution of net exports –
which reached 1.7pp in Q2 – is set to fade. In terms of 2018, our sense is that this negative
bias on net exports may lessen somewhat because of the likely deceleration of domestic
demand, which could crimp demand for imported goods. This is based on two key factors: i)
the expiry of some of the stimulus measures alluded to above; and ii) the lagged impact of
the Turkish lira’s recent depreciation, which will make the cost of imported goods coming
into the country more expensive.
 Even though Turkey’s public debt stock is low, at under 30% of GDP, the current pace of
fiscal stimulus – which pushed the budget deficit from 1.1% of GDP in December 2016 to
2.1% of GDP in August (see Chart 6) – needs to be closely monitored. Adding to these
worries is the fact that investors in Turkish debt have become unnerved recently as result of
the country’s deteriorating relations with its key allies, namely the US and EU. This, in turn,
has had the effect of putting pressure on the lira, while yields on the country’s benchmark
10-year government bonds have risen by more than 100bps since early October, to a post-
crises high of over 12% (see Chart 7). If sustained, this could likely add to country’s
borrowing costs and, ultimately, undermine its fiscal flexibility, at least, at the margin.
…As a myriad of challenges still confront the country
External vulnerability
The most obvious challenge that Turkey faces today is its gapping current account deficit.
While this has fallen from a peak of around 10% of GDP at the start of this decade to a figure
in the region of 4% today, it still remains an area of concern. This is especially true given the
fact that it is largely being financed by volatile portfolio flows rather than foreign direct
investment (FDI), which tends to be more durable in nature. Central to this problem is the fact
that Turkey’s saving rate is too low relative to its investment outlays (see Chart 8). Thus, to
(Source) Macrobond, BTMU (Source) Macrobond, BTMU
-1.1
-2.1
-6
-5
-4
-3
-2
-1
0
0
10
20
30
40
50
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
2017/08
Chart 6:Turkey's fiscal metrics remain respectable...
Public debt(% of GDP, LHS) Budget balance (% of GDP, RHS)
4
6
8
10
12
14
Jan/13
Jul/13
Jan/14
Jul/14
Jan/15
Jul/15
Jan/16
Jul/16
Jan/17
Jul/17
Chart 7:...But the uptick in bond yields suggest that the
markets remain wary
(10-year govt. bond yields, %)
Special Report | February 20186
plug this gap, the country resorts to borrowing from abroad. While in principle this should not
be a problem, the point to note is that such borrowing makes the country vulnerable to the
vagaries of changing market sentiment. Indeed, when the US Fed signalled in 2013 that it was
looking to pare down its quantitative easing or asset purchase programme, bond yields in the
US rose sharply and portfolio capital started to flow out of emerging markets. The currencies of
most EMs came under downward pressure at the time, but the lira came under particular line
of fire due to the country’s outsized current account deficit. Between May 2013 – when this so-
called “taper tantrum” saga started – to the end of 2015, the currency lost around 40% of its
value vis-a-vis the US dollar. The lira came in for another bout of punishment after the failed
coup attempt last July and is down some 50% or so since May 2013.
Against this backdrop, our sense is that Turkey needs to do a number of things to reduce its
external vulnerability:
 The country needs to reduce its reliance on imported fuel and energy, which accounts for
something like two thirds of the country’s current account deficit. To this end, it needs to
instigate measures that would aid the development of alternative or renewable energy
sources, including nuclear and solar power projects. While there’s a lot of interest on the
part of the Turkish authorities in such projects, it is important to highlight they’re very
capital-intensive in nature and, for this reason, have been rather slow to take-off.
Notwithstanding this, the role of alternative energy as a whole is set to rise in Turkey over
time – and if the consultation document entitled “National Renewable Energy Action Plan
for Turkey”3
is any guide it’s expected to jump from around 17% presently to around 20% in
2020. Also, of note here is that with economic growth – which is one of the key drivers of
energy demand – set to continue at a decent pace over the next three years (3.5% on
average according to the IMF) energy consumption is expected to closely following suit.
Indeed, we are of the view that on this assumption Turkey’s energy demand is expected to
jump from an estimated figure of 100.6m tonnes of oil equivalent (toe) presently to ~112m
toe in 2020.
3
This was published in December 2014.
(Source) World Bank, BTMU
0
2
4
6
8
10
20
24
28
32
2007
2008
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
Chart 8: The mismatch between Turkey's investment &
savings position is central to it's external vulnerabilities
Gap (RHS) Gross investment Gross savings
(% of GDP)(% of GDP)
Special Report | February 20187
 Second, Turkey needs to improve the quality of the financing of its current account deficit.
In this regard, the country needs to improve its business environment as well as its
infrastructure base, both of which are often cited as vital in helping the country to attract
greater FDI inflows. In fact, the country has made reasonable strides in terms of the former,
with its latest ranking with respect to the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business Index
climbing some nine places. However, at 60 (out of total of 190 countries), the country’s
current ranking still lags that of comparable EMs within Central and Eastern Europe, such
as, Poland and the Czech Republic, which rank 27 and 30 respectively.
 Third, the country needs to boost its savings rate which, at under 25% of GDP, is rather low
by EM standards4
. We expected this figure to remain broadly the same through to 2020 in
part thanks to Turkey’s young and growing population and its high propensity to consume.
While measures to encourage private individuals to save more is perhaps the most obvious
way to deal with this problem, another would be for the Turkish government to run a smaller
budget deficit, if not, a surplus. However, we don’t see this happening, for the time being at
least, given the fact that in the run-up to the 2019 presidential election the government will
be under pressure to ensure that growth remains robust. Elsewhere, measures could also
be taken to, for example, further develop the country’s capital markets which, over time,
would make it more attractive for Turkish companies borrow domestically rather than from
abroad.
While the priority areas we have identified above are not exactly new and – if anything –
amount to long-standing challenges, markets will be expecting to see much greater focus on
implementing such reforms, especially now that the political uncertainty associated with
constitutional referendum vote that was held earlier this April is out of the way. Additionally, it is
also worth pointing out that given the above measures are essentially structural in nature and
are accorded a high weighting by the rating agencies, some progress would need to be seen in
these areas for the country’s sovereign rating – which was downgraded to “junk” status in the
aftermath of attempted coup – to be upgraded back to investment grade territory (See Table 1).
Banking/Corporate sector risk
The Turkish banking system remains sound, as banks are liquid and well capitalised (see
Chart 9), while non-performing loans are generally low (about 3%). However, as noted above,
government policy aimed at stimulating credit growth is somewhat worrying, as there has been
a reversal of tighter regulations, which were originally put in place to prevent run-away credit
4
The top tier EMs, i.e. BRIC economies, average closer to 30% of GDP.
Current rating Previous rating Date of downgrade Current outlook
S&P BB BBB- 20-Jul-16 Negative
Moody's Ba1 Baa3 23-Sep-16 Negative
Fitch BB+ BBB- 27-Jan-17 Stable
(Source) Bloomberg, BTMU
Table 1: Turkey's recent sovereign rating action
Special Report | February 20188
growth. The loan to value ratio has been relaxed from 75% to 80% and government applies
suasion on banks to keep mortgage rates low despite rising funding costs. Against such a
backdrop, credit growth has exceeded the 15% ceiling previously considered by the CBRT to
healthy. The danger is that with loan growth as a whole currently running in excess of 20% it
could push up NPLs of the Turkish banking system going forward.
Also, of note here is the fact by lending to the corporate sector in the form of foreign currency
debt, banks are also indirectly vulnerable to currency risk. Total corporate debt at the end of
2016 stood at over 65% of GDP, a more than two-fold increase on the level seen in 2007 (see
Chart 10). This is particularly worrying given the fact that about 45% of this debt is
denominated in foreign currency. Turkish companies – particularly in the energy, construction
materials, steel, transport (airlines) and chemicals sectors – have extensively borrowed in
foreign currency from local banks. While there are mitigating factors at play, such as the fact
that two thirds of the loans are in sectors with natural hedges (e.g. via export revenues), the
point to note is that as foreign exchange assets only cover 40% of liabilities corporates run a
substantial currency risk. Most at risk are smaller firms with earnings mostly in local currency
that are not sufficiently hedged.
Labour market challenges
Elsewhere on the domestic front, productivity growth – which averaged 5% over the 2000-2007
period – slowed sharply to 1.4% over 2008-2015 according to OECD data. There have been
no meaningful education or labour market reforms in recent years. As result, Turkey continues
to register one of the highest youth unemployment rates among Central and Eastern European
countries, while in terms of female participation rates it does not fare much better either (see
Chart 11). While the latter issue is, in part, influenced by cultural factors, it is also important to
*This is indicative of whether banks have adequate high quality liquid assets (Source) BIS, BTMU
(HQLA) to survive stressed liquidity conditions over a 30-day period. This ratio
is calculated as follows: LCR = HQLAs/ Net cash outflows.**This is the
amount of ownership an individual or company has in an asset. Formula:
Total assets - total liabilities. (Source) BRSA, BTMU
0
5
10
15
20
25
0
30
60
90
120
150
180
2009
2010
2011
2012
2013
2014
2015
2016
Sep-17
Chart 9: Key fundamentals of the Turkish banking
system remain sound...
Liquidity Coverage Ratio (%, LHS)* Owners Equity (US$bn,LHS)**
CAR(%,RHS)
11.3 18.2 17.7
29.9
44.8
67.9
39.9
35.8
28.6
0
20
40
60
80
100
120
2007 2012 2016
Chart 10:...But growing exposure to the
corporate sector could be troublesome going
forward
Credit to Govt. Credit to Firms Credit to Houselholds
(% of GDP)
Special Report | February 20189
highlight that it’s reflective of the failure of the education system to perhaps adequately equip
new entrants into the labour market with the requisite skills to succeed. Also, of note here is
the fact that labour market rigidities – for example in the form of strictness of employment
protectionism – remain at elevated levels in Turkey (see Chart 12).
Finally, Turkey’s slide in a number of governance indicators compiled by the World Bank
recently (including in the areas of voice and accountability, political instability, government
effectiveness, rule of law and control of corruption) suggest that the pace of institutional
reforms has also slowed.
Political concerns
Turkey has had to navigate many political challenges over the past year or so, not least the
failed coup attempt and the constitutional referendum vote on the creation of an executive
presidency. Notwithstanding this, political risk in the country still remains at an elevated level
thanks to following factors:
 For one thing, the purge Mr. Erdogan instigated in the aftermath of the coup attempt
against the followers of the exiled religious cleric Fethullah Gulen – who he and his
supporters claim were behind the putsch – continues to this day, leading some, to rightly
question, whether this may have gone too far.
 Related to the above point, Mr. Erdogan retains the power to rule by decree, which he
initially amassed following the aborted coup attempt. While such emergency powers served
a useful purpose in stemming the immediate crisis, their continuation leads us to the
inevitable conclusion that the checks and balances within the Turkish political system are
being eroded.
(Source) HDI, World Bank, BTMU *0-6 scale where 6 is the most restrictive. (Source) OECD, BTMU
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
Bulgaria Hungary Poland Czech
Rep.
Romania Turkey
Chart 11: Turkey's labour market indicators compare
poorly with its CEE peers...
Female participation rate (%) Youth unemployment (%)
0
0.5
1
1.5
2
2.5
3
3.5
Turkey Czech Rep. Poland Hungary
Chart 12:...Whilethe strictnessofits employment
protectionlegislation isalsomoreworrisome
(0‐6 scale)*
Special Report | February 201810
 Although the political noise associated with the constitutional referendum vote held this
Spring has abated, this by no means the end of the story as far as the proposed
constitutional changes are concerned. Indeed, the country is due to hold presidential
elections in 2019 which Mr. Erdogan will need to convincingly win in order to push ahead
with his aim to move towards an executive presidency. This, in turn, is likely to add to
continuing political uncertainty up to 2019 and perhaps even beyond if the outcome of this
election proves to be inconclusive. Aside from the political uncertainty associated with the
aforementioned presidential election, the fact that Turkey’s fragile Kurdish peace process
has broken down recently – with the separatist PKK declaring an end to its unilateral
ceasefire – will continue make the security situation in Turkey rather precarious as we
approach the end of this decade. This – along with Turkish army’s recent incursion into
northern parts of Syria that border Turkey to attack Kurdish separatist strongholds there –
we feel will also make the prospect of reprisal attacks on Turkish soil a potential likelihood
over this period.
 Finally, on the external front, the country also needs to reset relations with the EU and the
US, which have suffered a serious setback recently. With respect to the former group,
failure to do so could mean it could lose a vital anchor which, until recently, has helped the
country to benchmark its policies against EU member states. US-Turkish relations
meanwhile appear to have worsened since the arrival of Donald Trump at the helm of the
US presidency and we expect this tendency to persist going forward as the two countries
appear to be taking a differing stance on regional issues including Syria.
Concluding thoughts/look ahead
Turkey finds itself at a key juncture at the moment. While the economy has rebounded sharply
in the aftermath of the failed coup attempt, it’s not fully out of the woods yet. For one thing,
there are still lingering doubts about the sustainability of the current recovery, which has been
propped up by the government’s various stimulus measures, some of which are set to expire
as the year-end approaches. Elsewhere, measures to address the country’s external
vulnerabilities are still pending while, on the political front, a key event risk in the form of the
2019 presidential election still looms large. Against this backdrop, while we welcome the fact
that Turkey’s economy didn’t tank in the aftermath of the attempted coup, going forward our –
and – indeed the market’s – focus will very much be on whether the Turkish authorities will be
able to push through some of the key macro and structural reforms, which we’ve highlighted in
this report including, for example, boosting human capital, strengthening the business
environment, and improving the functioning of the labour market. Such measures, despite
being seen as of vital importance in helping the country to transition towards a more value-
added growth model over time, will in our minds struggle to gain traction thanks, in large part,
to the fact that forthcoming presidential elections are due to take place in Turkey in 2019 and
in the run-up to this event it’s highly unlikely that Mr. Erdogan will be willing to embrace painful
structural reforms which in the short-term at least are likely to temper growth and hence his
electoral popularity.
Set against this rather bleak backdrop for structural reforms and an economy which is currently
running beyond its current growth potential5
, while we expect Turkey to continue to “muddle
5
IMF’s estimate of Turkey potential GDP growth stands at slightly above 3%.
Special Report | February 201811
through”, our sense is that there will be a number of implications for the country looking ahead
over the short to medium-term:
 Current account implications – Turkey’s current deficit, which is viewed as its main Achilles
heel, will remain at an elevated levels of greater than 3% of GDP over the next couple of
years. While, in theory, this gap should improve somewhat through the course of next year
and, perhaps, beyond on the back of the predicted moderation in domestic demand, this in
our minds will be offset by the recent rebound in international oil and energy prices whose
imports, as we’ve alluded to above, account for around two-thirds of the country’s total
current account deficit. Going forward, our sense is that with oil prices expected to remain
within the US$60-70/barrel range or beyond in the period to 2020 this will not be helpful in
aiding the Turkish authorities desire to bring down the country’s underlying current account
deficit.
 Sovereign rating implications – Concerns over the financing of Turkey’s sizeable external
deficit, coupled with the reluctance on the part of the authorities there to tighten fiscal policy
in the run-up to the 2019 presidential election, will continue to weigh on Turkey’s sovereign
rating. Indeed, we expect its rating to remain in “junk” territory for the time being at least.
While our central view is that this rating will not be downgraded further, in the event that it
does it could certainly have the potential to negatively affect the value of its local currency
unit and/or bonds. This in turn could make the task of financing its current account deficit
even more difficult than it already is.
 Political developments & their likely implications – A final point worth noting here is that we
expect the recent political uncertainty in Turkey to persist going forward over the next two
years or so not only because of domestic political factors, such the forthcoming presidential
elections, but also due to the country’s strained relations with its key western allies, such as
the US. This, in our mind, will have a negative bearing on the country’s financial markets
and will, in particular, continue to undermine the performance of its local currency unit over
the short to medium-term. Also, should Mr. Erdogan win the 2019 presidential election with
a landslide majority – an outcome which will allow him to continue to go down the road of
an executive presidency with little checks and balances – there is a danger that this could
further undermine the quality as well as investors’ perception of Turkey’s institutional
strength.
The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd. (“BTMU”) is a limited liability stock company incorporated in Japan and registered in the Tokyo
Legal Affairs Bureau (company no. 0100-01-008846). BTMU’s head office is at 7-1 Marunouchi 2-Chome, Chiyoda-Ku, Tokyo 100-8388,
Japan. BTMU’s London branch is registered as a UK establishment in the UK register of companies (registered no. BR002013). BTMU is
authorised and regulated by the Japanese Financial Services Agency. BTMU’s London branch is authorised by the Prudential Regulation
Authority (FCA/PRA no. 139189) and subject to regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority and limited regulation by the Prudential
Regulation Authority. Details about the extent of BTMU London branch’s regulation by the Prudential Regulation Authority are available
from us on request.
This report shall not be construed as solicitation to take any action such as purchasing/selling/investing in financial market products. In
taking any action, each reader is requested to act on the basis of his or her own judgment. This report is based on information believed to
be reliable, but we do not guarantee, and do not accept any liability whatsoever for, its accuracy and we accept no liability whatsoever for
any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of all or any part of this report. The contents of the report may be revised without
advance notice. Also, this report is a literary work protected by copyright. No part of this report may be reproduced in any form without
express statement of its source.
The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd. retains copyright to this report and no part of this report may be reproduced or re-distributed
without the written permission of The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd. The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd. expressly prohibits the
re-distribution of this report to Retail Customers, via the internet or otherwise and The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd., its subsidiaries
or affiliates accept no liability whatsoever to any third parties resulting from such re-distribution.

More Related Content

What's hot

BTMU Economic Brief - macro themes 2017
BTMU Economic Brief - macro themes 2017BTMU Economic Brief - macro themes 2017
BTMU Economic Brief - macro themes 2017Amir Khan
 
Presentation 2017 macro themes
Presentation   2017 macro themesPresentation   2017 macro themes
Presentation 2017 macro themesAmir Khan
 
Monetary Policy
Monetary PolicyMonetary Policy
Monetary Policytutor2u
 
Assumptions may 2017 mpc meeting
Assumptions may 2017 mpc meetingAssumptions may 2017 mpc meeting
Assumptions may 2017 mpc meetingSABC News
 
MPC Statement 19 July 2018
MPC Statement 19 July 2018 MPC Statement 19 July 2018
MPC Statement 19 July 2018 SABC News
 
The US Market Overview - 2Q14 (FINAL)
The US Market Overview - 2Q14 (FINAL)The US Market Overview - 2Q14 (FINAL)
The US Market Overview - 2Q14 (FINAL)Greg Meier
 
Oecd interim economic ocde outlook march 2017 embargo (3)
Oecd interim economic ocde outlook march 2017   embargo (3)Oecd interim economic ocde outlook march 2017   embargo (3)
Oecd interim economic ocde outlook march 2017 embargo (3)Daniel BASTIEN
 
Ivo Pezzuto - FEDERAL RESERVE'S RATE RISE. COMING SOON? The Global Analyst Se...
Ivo Pezzuto - FEDERAL RESERVE'S RATE RISE. COMING SOON? The Global Analyst Se...Ivo Pezzuto - FEDERAL RESERVE'S RATE RISE. COMING SOON? The Global Analyst Se...
Ivo Pezzuto - FEDERAL RESERVE'S RATE RISE. COMING SOON? The Global Analyst Se...Dr. Ivo Pezzuto
 
Economic forecast-summary-russia-oecd-economic-outlook-november-2016
Economic forecast-summary-russia-oecd-economic-outlook-november-2016Economic forecast-summary-russia-oecd-economic-outlook-november-2016
Economic forecast-summary-russia-oecd-economic-outlook-november-2016Bankir_Ru
 
Statement of the monetary policy committee 25 may 2017
Statement of the monetary policy committee   25 may 2017Statement of the monetary policy committee   25 may 2017
Statement of the monetary policy committee 25 may 2017SABC News
 
Economy and equity markets: are they disconnected?
Economy and equity markets: are they disconnected?Economy and equity markets: are they disconnected?
Economy and equity markets: are they disconnected?Markets Beyond
 
OECD Global Interim Economic Outlook February 2016 presentation
OECD Global Interim Economic Outlook February 2016 presentationOECD Global Interim Economic Outlook February 2016 presentation
OECD Global Interim Economic Outlook February 2016 presentationOECD, Economics Department
 
How strong a comeback for inflation?
How strong a comeback for inflation?How strong a comeback for inflation?
How strong a comeback for inflation?Jurgen Vluijmans
 
Economic and Government Policy Analysis - Vietnam - June 2016
Economic and Government Policy Analysis - Vietnam - June 2016Economic and Government Policy Analysis - Vietnam - June 2016
Economic and Government Policy Analysis - Vietnam - June 2016paul young cpa, cga
 
The Latvian Economy - 2010, June
The Latvian Economy - 2010, JuneThe Latvian Economy - 2010, June
The Latvian Economy - 2010, JuneSwedbank
 
Quarterly Update - June 2009
Quarterly Update - June 2009Quarterly Update - June 2009
Quarterly Update - June 2009Peter Ho
 

What's hot (20)

BTMU Economic Brief - macro themes 2017
BTMU Economic Brief - macro themes 2017BTMU Economic Brief - macro themes 2017
BTMU Economic Brief - macro themes 2017
 
Presentation 2017 macro themes
Presentation   2017 macro themesPresentation   2017 macro themes
Presentation 2017 macro themes
 
Monetary Policy
Monetary PolicyMonetary Policy
Monetary Policy
 
Assumptions may 2017 mpc meeting
Assumptions may 2017 mpc meetingAssumptions may 2017 mpc meeting
Assumptions may 2017 mpc meeting
 
Economy Matters: November - December Issue
Economy Matters: November - December IssueEconomy Matters: November - December Issue
Economy Matters: November - December Issue
 
MPC Statement 19 July 2018
MPC Statement 19 July 2018 MPC Statement 19 July 2018
MPC Statement 19 July 2018
 
The US Market Overview - 2Q14 (FINAL)
The US Market Overview - 2Q14 (FINAL)The US Market Overview - 2Q14 (FINAL)
The US Market Overview - 2Q14 (FINAL)
 
201812-FOMC
201812-FOMC201812-FOMC
201812-FOMC
 
Oecd interim economic ocde outlook march 2017 embargo (3)
Oecd interim economic ocde outlook march 2017   embargo (3)Oecd interim economic ocde outlook march 2017   embargo (3)
Oecd interim economic ocde outlook march 2017 embargo (3)
 
Ivo Pezzuto - FEDERAL RESERVE'S RATE RISE. COMING SOON? The Global Analyst Se...
Ivo Pezzuto - FEDERAL RESERVE'S RATE RISE. COMING SOON? The Global Analyst Se...Ivo Pezzuto - FEDERAL RESERVE'S RATE RISE. COMING SOON? The Global Analyst Se...
Ivo Pezzuto - FEDERAL RESERVE'S RATE RISE. COMING SOON? The Global Analyst Se...
 
Polish Economic Outlook 01/2010
Polish Economic Outlook 01/2010Polish Economic Outlook 01/2010
Polish Economic Outlook 01/2010
 
Economic forecast-summary-russia-oecd-economic-outlook-november-2016
Economic forecast-summary-russia-oecd-economic-outlook-november-2016Economic forecast-summary-russia-oecd-economic-outlook-november-2016
Economic forecast-summary-russia-oecd-economic-outlook-november-2016
 
Statement of the monetary policy committee 25 may 2017
Statement of the monetary policy committee   25 may 2017Statement of the monetary policy committee   25 may 2017
Statement of the monetary policy committee 25 may 2017
 
Economy and equity markets: are they disconnected?
Economy and equity markets: are they disconnected?Economy and equity markets: are they disconnected?
Economy and equity markets: are they disconnected?
 
OECD Global Interim Economic Outlook February 2016 presentation
OECD Global Interim Economic Outlook February 2016 presentationOECD Global Interim Economic Outlook February 2016 presentation
OECD Global Interim Economic Outlook February 2016 presentation
 
Singapore Residential Property Outlook 2015
Singapore Residential Property Outlook 2015Singapore Residential Property Outlook 2015
Singapore Residential Property Outlook 2015
 
How strong a comeback for inflation?
How strong a comeback for inflation?How strong a comeback for inflation?
How strong a comeback for inflation?
 
Economic and Government Policy Analysis - Vietnam - June 2016
Economic and Government Policy Analysis - Vietnam - June 2016Economic and Government Policy Analysis - Vietnam - June 2016
Economic and Government Policy Analysis - Vietnam - June 2016
 
The Latvian Economy - 2010, June
The Latvian Economy - 2010, JuneThe Latvian Economy - 2010, June
The Latvian Economy - 2010, June
 
Quarterly Update - June 2009
Quarterly Update - June 2009Quarterly Update - June 2009
Quarterly Update - June 2009
 

Similar to Turkey 2018

Egypt Economic Outlook
Egypt Economic OutlookEgypt Economic Outlook
Egypt Economic OutlookMoheb Malak
 
Pakistan Day Conference_2011_Strategy
Pakistan Day Conference_2011_StrategyPakistan Day Conference_2011_Strategy
Pakistan Day Conference_2011_StrategyFaraz Farooq
 
Budget FY17 - Reforms set to persist_ recovery in agri to lift 06-06-2016
Budget FY17 - Reforms set to persist_ recovery in agri to lift 06-06-2016Budget FY17 - Reforms set to persist_ recovery in agri to lift 06-06-2016
Budget FY17 - Reforms set to persist_ recovery in agri to lift 06-06-2016Aijaz Siddique
 
Joining Dots- Twin Defict Analysis
Joining Dots- Twin Defict AnalysisJoining Dots- Twin Defict Analysis
Joining Dots- Twin Defict AnalysisHasan Razvi
 
Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014
Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014
Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014ilfattoquotidiano.it
 
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]Gary Crosbie
 
Greek Equity Market update Sept2015
Greek Equity Market update Sept2015Greek Equity Market update Sept2015
Greek Equity Market update Sept2015George Doukas
 
DA is calling for a "resilience budget"
DA is calling for a "resilience budget"DA is calling for a "resilience budget"
DA is calling for a "resilience budget"SABC News
 
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]Gary Crosbie
 
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]Gary Crosbie
 
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]Gary Crosbie
 
Btmu Economic Brief - Nigeria: Making Sense of the Naira's Devaluation
Btmu Economic Brief  -  Nigeria: Making Sense of the Naira's DevaluationBtmu Economic Brief  -  Nigeria: Making Sense of the Naira's Devaluation
Btmu Economic Brief - Nigeria: Making Sense of the Naira's DevaluationAmir Khan
 
Monetary Policy 1st quarter 2023
Monetary Policy 1st quarter 2023Monetary Policy 1st quarter 2023
Monetary Policy 1st quarter 2023SyedaAfraFatima
 
Long or Short Mauritius_ Final (7) (1)
Long or Short Mauritius_ Final (7) (1)Long or Short Mauritius_ Final (7) (1)
Long or Short Mauritius_ Final (7) (1)Davin Appanah
 
Foreign Currency Crisis - EG
Foreign Currency Crisis - EGForeign Currency Crisis - EG
Foreign Currency Crisis - EGsamehanani
 
Prelude to Budget 2017-18
Prelude to Budget 2017-18Prelude to Budget 2017-18
Prelude to Budget 2017-18Inves Trekk
 
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014Joannes Mongardini
 

Similar to Turkey 2018 (20)

Egypt Economic Outlook
Egypt Economic OutlookEgypt Economic Outlook
Egypt Economic Outlook
 
Economy Matters September- October 2014
Economy Matters September- October 2014 Economy Matters September- October 2014
Economy Matters September- October 2014
 
Pakistan Day Conference_2011_Strategy
Pakistan Day Conference_2011_StrategyPakistan Day Conference_2011_Strategy
Pakistan Day Conference_2011_Strategy
 
Budget FY17 - Reforms set to persist_ recovery in agri to lift 06-06-2016
Budget FY17 - Reforms set to persist_ recovery in agri to lift 06-06-2016Budget FY17 - Reforms set to persist_ recovery in agri to lift 06-06-2016
Budget FY17 - Reforms set to persist_ recovery in agri to lift 06-06-2016
 
Joining Dots- Twin Defict Analysis
Joining Dots- Twin Defict AnalysisJoining Dots- Twin Defict Analysis
Joining Dots- Twin Defict Analysis
 
Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014
Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014
Lettera Padoan Ue 21 novembre 2014
 
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
 
Greek Equity Market update Sept2015
Greek Equity Market update Sept2015Greek Equity Market update Sept2015
Greek Equity Market update Sept2015
 
DA is calling for a "resilience budget"
DA is calling for a "resilience budget"DA is calling for a "resilience budget"
DA is calling for a "resilience budget"
 
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
 
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
 
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic  Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
4th Qtr Year End 2011 Economic Review Feb 15 [Autosaved] [Autosaved]
 
Btmu Economic Brief - Nigeria: Making Sense of the Naira's Devaluation
Btmu Economic Brief  -  Nigeria: Making Sense of the Naira's DevaluationBtmu Economic Brief  -  Nigeria: Making Sense of the Naira's Devaluation
Btmu Economic Brief - Nigeria: Making Sense of the Naira's Devaluation
 
Monetary Policy 1st quarter 2023
Monetary Policy 1st quarter 2023Monetary Policy 1st quarter 2023
Monetary Policy 1st quarter 2023
 
The Pros And Cons Of Interest Rates
The Pros And Cons Of Interest RatesThe Pros And Cons Of Interest Rates
The Pros And Cons Of Interest Rates
 
Long or Short Mauritius_ Final (7) (1)
Long or Short Mauritius_ Final (7) (1)Long or Short Mauritius_ Final (7) (1)
Long or Short Mauritius_ Final (7) (1)
 
Gov sppech
Gov sppechGov sppech
Gov sppech
 
Foreign Currency Crisis - EG
Foreign Currency Crisis - EGForeign Currency Crisis - EG
Foreign Currency Crisis - EG
 
Prelude to Budget 2017-18
Prelude to Budget 2017-18Prelude to Budget 2017-18
Prelude to Budget 2017-18
 
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
QNB Group China Economic Insight 2014
 

More from Amir Khan

Macro Themes 2021
Macro Themes 2021Macro Themes 2021
Macro Themes 2021Amir Khan
 
Macro themes 2020
Macro themes 2020Macro themes 2020
Macro themes 2020Amir Khan
 
Mid-year Market Review 2019
Mid-year Market Review 2019Mid-year Market Review 2019
Mid-year Market Review 2019Amir Khan
 
MENA - Adjusting to the New Normal
MENA - Adjusting to the New NormalMENA - Adjusting to the New Normal
MENA - Adjusting to the New NormalAmir Khan
 
Germany – How Worrisome is the Country’s Recent Slowdown?*
Germany – How Worrisome is the Country’s Recent Slowdown?*Germany – How Worrisome is the Country’s Recent Slowdown?*
Germany – How Worrisome is the Country’s Recent Slowdown?*Amir Khan
 
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current WoesBahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current WoesAmir Khan
 
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current WoesBahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current WoesAmir Khan
 
"Emerging Markets in the Aftermath of the Commodity Price Crash – Onwards & U...
"Emerging Markets in the Aftermath of the Commodity Price Crash – Onwards & U..."Emerging Markets in the Aftermath of the Commodity Price Crash – Onwards & U...
"Emerging Markets in the Aftermath of the Commodity Price Crash – Onwards & U...Amir Khan
 
Euro Area & Global Economy - Getting its Mojo Back
Euro Area & Global Economy - Getting its Mojo BackEuro Area & Global Economy - Getting its Mojo Back
Euro Area & Global Economy - Getting its Mojo BackAmir Khan
 
Special Report - Aferthoughts on the OPEC agreement
Special Report  - Aferthoughts on the OPEC agreementSpecial Report  - Aferthoughts on the OPEC agreement
Special Report - Aferthoughts on the OPEC agreementAmir Khan
 
Presentation - Populism & the Politics of Rage - the Case of the UK & US
Presentation - Populism & the Politics of Rage - the Case of the UK & US Presentation - Populism & the Politics of Rage - the Case of the UK & US
Presentation - Populism & the Politics of Rage - the Case of the UK & US Amir Khan
 
South Africa - Stuck in the Slow Lane
South Africa -  Stuck in the Slow LaneSouth Africa -  Stuck in the Slow Lane
South Africa - Stuck in the Slow LaneAmir Khan
 
Special Report - Is the OPEC Agreement a Game Changer?
Special Report  - Is the OPEC Agreement a Game Changer?Special Report  - Is the OPEC Agreement a Game Changer?
Special Report - Is the OPEC Agreement a Game Changer?Amir Khan
 
Special Report - Spain - Election Aftermath
Special Report - Spain - Election AftermathSpecial Report - Spain - Election Aftermath
Special Report - Spain - Election AftermathAmir Khan
 
Germany - Towards a New Growth Model?
Germany - Towards a New Growth Model?Germany - Towards a New Growth Model?
Germany - Towards a New Growth Model?Amir Khan
 

More from Amir Khan (15)

Macro Themes 2021
Macro Themes 2021Macro Themes 2021
Macro Themes 2021
 
Macro themes 2020
Macro themes 2020Macro themes 2020
Macro themes 2020
 
Mid-year Market Review 2019
Mid-year Market Review 2019Mid-year Market Review 2019
Mid-year Market Review 2019
 
MENA - Adjusting to the New Normal
MENA - Adjusting to the New NormalMENA - Adjusting to the New Normal
MENA - Adjusting to the New Normal
 
Germany – How Worrisome is the Country’s Recent Slowdown?*
Germany – How Worrisome is the Country’s Recent Slowdown?*Germany – How Worrisome is the Country’s Recent Slowdown?*
Germany – How Worrisome is the Country’s Recent Slowdown?*
 
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current WoesBahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
 
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current WoesBahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
Bahrain - Making Sense of the Country's Current Woes
 
"Emerging Markets in the Aftermath of the Commodity Price Crash – Onwards & U...
"Emerging Markets in the Aftermath of the Commodity Price Crash – Onwards & U..."Emerging Markets in the Aftermath of the Commodity Price Crash – Onwards & U...
"Emerging Markets in the Aftermath of the Commodity Price Crash – Onwards & U...
 
Euro Area & Global Economy - Getting its Mojo Back
Euro Area & Global Economy - Getting its Mojo BackEuro Area & Global Economy - Getting its Mojo Back
Euro Area & Global Economy - Getting its Mojo Back
 
Special Report - Aferthoughts on the OPEC agreement
Special Report  - Aferthoughts on the OPEC agreementSpecial Report  - Aferthoughts on the OPEC agreement
Special Report - Aferthoughts on the OPEC agreement
 
Presentation - Populism & the Politics of Rage - the Case of the UK & US
Presentation - Populism & the Politics of Rage - the Case of the UK & US Presentation - Populism & the Politics of Rage - the Case of the UK & US
Presentation - Populism & the Politics of Rage - the Case of the UK & US
 
South Africa - Stuck in the Slow Lane
South Africa -  Stuck in the Slow LaneSouth Africa -  Stuck in the Slow Lane
South Africa - Stuck in the Slow Lane
 
Special Report - Is the OPEC Agreement a Game Changer?
Special Report  - Is the OPEC Agreement a Game Changer?Special Report  - Is the OPEC Agreement a Game Changer?
Special Report - Is the OPEC Agreement a Game Changer?
 
Special Report - Spain - Election Aftermath
Special Report - Spain - Election AftermathSpecial Report - Spain - Election Aftermath
Special Report - Spain - Election Aftermath
 
Germany - Towards a New Growth Model?
Germany - Towards a New Growth Model?Germany - Towards a New Growth Model?
Germany - Towards a New Growth Model?
 

Recently uploaded

Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast SlidesQ3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast SlidesMarketing847413
 
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdfLundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdfAdnet Communications
 
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptxFinTech Belgium
 
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure serviceCall US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure servicePooja Nehwal
 
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignLog your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignHenry Tapper
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfGale Pooley
 
VIP Call Girls Thane Sia 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Thane
VIP Call Girls Thane Sia 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ThaneVIP Call Girls Thane Sia 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Thane
VIP Call Girls Thane Sia 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ThaneCall girls in Ahmedabad High profile
 
Stock Market Brief Deck for 4/24/24 .pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 4/24/24 .pdfStock Market Brief Deck for 4/24/24 .pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 4/24/24 .pdfMichael Silva
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School DesignsInstant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School Designsegoetzinger
 
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptxDividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptxanshikagoel52
 
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free DeliveryMalad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free DeliveryPooja Nehwal
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779Delhi Call girls
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escortsranjana rawat
 
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance CompanyInterimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance CompanyTyöeläkeyhtiö Elo
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130 Available With Roomdivyansh0kumar0
 
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...shivangimorya083
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot ModelsAndheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Modelshematsharma006
 
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...Pooja Nehwal
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast SlidesQ3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
Q3 2024 Earnings Conference Call and Webcast Slides
 
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdfLundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
Lundin Gold April 2024 Corporate Presentation v4.pdf
 
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
00_Main ppt_MeetupDORA&CyberSecurity.pptx
 
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure serviceCall US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
Call US 📞 9892124323 ✅ Kurla Call Girls In Kurla ( Mumbai ) secure service
 
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaignLog your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
Log your LOA pain with Pension Lab's brilliant campaign
 
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdfThe Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
The Economic History of the U.S. Lecture 19.pdf
 
Veritas Interim Report 1 January–31 March 2024
Veritas Interim Report 1 January–31 March 2024Veritas Interim Report 1 January–31 March 2024
Veritas Interim Report 1 January–31 March 2024
 
VIP Call Girls Thane Sia 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Thane
VIP Call Girls Thane Sia 8617697112 Independent Escort Service ThaneVIP Call Girls Thane Sia 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Thane
VIP Call Girls Thane Sia 8617697112 Independent Escort Service Thane
 
Stock Market Brief Deck for 4/24/24 .pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 4/24/24 .pdfStock Market Brief Deck for 4/24/24 .pdf
Stock Market Brief Deck for 4/24/24 .pdf
 
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School DesignsInstant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
Instant Issue Debit Cards - School Designs
 
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptxDividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
Dividend Policy and Dividend Decision Theories.pptx
 
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free DeliveryMalad Call Girl in Services  9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
Malad Call Girl in Services 9892124323 | ₹,4500 With Room Free Delivery
 
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
Best VIP Call Girls Noida Sector 18 Call Me: 8448380779
 
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur EscortsCall Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
Call Girls Service Nagpur Maya Call 7001035870 Meet With Nagpur Escorts
 
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance CompanyInterimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
Interimreport1 January–31 March2024 Elo Mutual Pension Insurance Company
 
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130  Available With RoomVIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130  Available With Room
VIP Kolkata Call Girl Serampore 👉 8250192130 Available With Room
 
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
Russian Call Girls In Gtb Nagar (Delhi) 9711199012 💋✔💕😘 Naughty Call Girls Se...
 
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane  6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
Booking open Available Pune Call Girls Shivane 6297143586 Call Hot Indian Gi...
 
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot ModelsAndheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
Andheri Call Girls In 9825968104 Mumbai Hot Models
 
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
Independent Call Girl Number in Kurla Mumbai📲 Pooja Nehwal 9892124323 💞 Full ...
 

Turkey 2018

  • 1. 1 T FE ex th w re su E A w w B be im ce th a m co 20 on tim ha A Special Repo Turkey EBRUARY 2 fter th about espec xternal fron he hit to the was therefo eason beh ustainable. Economy lthough the with at least was rather l ut the fact een viewe mproved th ertainly so hree quarte series of f measures. T ontribution 017. We w n the back me the rec alf Turkish A ort | February 2 – Is it 2018 he July 201 t whether cially in lig nt, which m e Turkish e ore seen as hind the s . We will th y rebound e failed co t some 265 limited. Ad t that it the ed by som hanks, in me truth to ers of last y fiscal (temp These ser to growth will look at k of these covery in th exports ar 2018 Over t 16 failed co the Turk ht of the fa make it hea economy o s somethin sharp rebo hen look at ds sharp oup attemp 5 people ki dmittedly, t en rebound me as a si large part o this claim year, with porary tax rved to ba h stood at these mea initiatives, he internat re destined the Wo oup attemp kish econo act that it’s avily relian only proved ng of a sur ound in gr t some the ply in the t that took illed accord he econom ded to a ro gn that th t, to the m, this reb GDP grow cuts) and ckstop priv almost 6% asures in g domestic tional econ d – has he orst? pt in Turke omy could s faced wit nt on overs d fleeting – rprise. We rowth rece challenge afterma k place in J ding some my contrac obust 4.2% he underly strength o bound – w wth expand quasi-fisca vate consu % points o greater det demand h nomy – and lped to sup AM ECO T: + E: A The A me ey, some in d weather h various v seas financ – it only co will use th ently and es which lie th of the July 2016 w e press rep cted in Q3 % in the su ing relianc of domest hich accel ding by an al (credit g umption a n average tail below, has so far d in particu pport net e Spec IR KHAN ONOMIC RE +44-(0)207-5 Amir.Khan@ Bank of Toky ember of MUFG ncluding ou the dom vulnerabilit cing. The ntracted d his note to ask if the e ahead for failed co was costly orts – its im of 2016 to bsequent q ce of the ic consum erated eve average of guarantee f nd investm during the but the po held up w ular the Eu exports (se cial Re ESEARCH | L 577-2180 @uk.mufg.jp kyo-Mitsubish G, a global finan urselves, w estic polit ties, partic fact that, uring Q3 o o examine e current r the count oup atte in terms o mpact on t o the tune quarter (Q Turkish ec mption. Wh en further f 7.3% – a fund loans ment whos e initial th oint to high well, while urozone, w ee Chart 1) eport LONDON hi UFJ, Ltd. cial group were worrie tical turmo ularly on th in the even of last year some of th recovery try. mpt… of lives lost the econom of 0.8% y/ Q4-2016) ha conomy h hile there into the fir also reflecte s) pro-grow se combine ree quarte hlight is tha at the sam where almo ). ed oil, he nt, r – he is t – my /y. as as is rst ed wth ed ers at, me ost
  • 2. Special Report | February 20182 Going forward, if high frequency indicators, such industrial production and retail sales are anything to go by (see Chart 2), the growth outturn for the final quarter of 2017 should remain strong, though there is the likelihood that it will start to be adversely affected due to unfavourable base effects and the expiry of some of the stimulus measures introduced in the aftermath of the failed coup attempt. Despite this, we envision full year growth in 2017 coming in at north of 6%, a figure which, if realised, will be well above the previous year’s outturn of 3.2%. For 2018, our sense is that growth is likely to moderate somewhat and come in to the tune of around 4%. Of note here is that the government will not want growth to fall much less than the aforementioned figure for fear that it will adversely impact its electoral popularity at the forthcoming elections in 2019. …Thanks to a range of initiatives introduced on the part of the authorities… Mindful of the likely negative impact of the failed military coup on the Turkish economy – through confidence and related channels – the Turkish authorities sought to backstop growth through a number of measures:  On the fiscal side, the government instigated a major reduction of value-added tax on white goods (kitchen appliances) and on furniture1 . This helped to cushion consumer spending and private consumption more broadly, as Chart 1 appears to bear out.  Beyond traditional fiscal measures, the government also took steps to set up a TRY250bn (~US$65bn) Credit Guarantee Fund (CGF). This, in our mind, was perhaps the most significant step taken by the government and was set up to encourage local banks to lend to small and mid-sized businesses by offering partial Treasury guarantees on any non- performing loans at up to 7% of all loans. 1 Consumption taxes on air conditioners, refrigerators, washing machines, dish washers, vacuum cleaners and some small home appliances were reduced from 6.7% to zero. Elsewhere, VAT on wood, plastic and office furniture was also decreased to 8%. (Source) Turkstat, BTMU (Source) Macrobond, BTMU -6 -4 -2 0 2 4 6 8 10 12 14 Q1-15 Q2-15 Q3-15 Q4-15 Q1-16 Q2-16 Q3-16 Q4-16 Q1-17 Q2-17 Q3-17 Chart 1:CompositionofTurkish GDPgrowth has broadened... Private Cons. GFCF Gov. Cons. Net exports Change in inventory Headline GDP (%) (Contribution, percentage points) -6 -3 0 3 6 9 12 Jan/12 Jan/13 Jan/14 Jan/15 Jan/16 Jan/17 Chart 2:...While highfrequency indicators appearto suggest that growth will continue to remainrobust Retail Sales (3m MA,%y/y) IndustialProduction (3mMA, %y/y)
  • 3. Special Report | February 20183  On the monetary policy front, while there was little scope to cut rates to support the economy – thanks a weakening exchange rate and headline inflation running well above the Central Bank of Turkey’s (CBRT) target of around 5% – this did not prevent the CBRT from providing unlimited liquidity to the banking system. Additionally, macro-prudential rules have been relaxed so that, among other things, those borrowing in the form of unsecured credit have seen their repayment periods extended. While it’s difficult to disaggregate the impact of these measures on Turkey’s recent growth performance, it’s fair to say that, taken together, they’ve played a vital role in reviving confidence in the Turkish economy. Indeed, on the back of such measures, key industrial activity indicators have rebounded after the failed coup attempt (see Chart 3). Additionally, by standing behind the banking system through the provision of unlimited liquidity, there was no run on the Turkish banking system, while at the same time a potential “credit crunch” scenario was avoided. Indeed, since H2-2016 credit flows to the “real economy” have picked noticeably and presently stand at 20% plus in annual terms even on a foreign currency-adjusted basis (see Chart 4). While this is indicative of the buoyancy of Turkey’s current credit-fuelled recovery, the downside of all this is that by boosting domestic demand – and hence imports – it will serve to perpetuate the underlying structural imbalances in the Turkish economy, particularly in terms of its much talked-about current account deficit. Also, of note here is the fact that the government’s efforts to engineer strong growth has come at the expense of higher inflation. Indeed, at 11.9%, the latest CPI reading is well above the CBRT’s 5% target and appears to be driven by higher food and fuel costs. More worryingly, at 11.8%, core CPI – which strips out volatile items such as food and fuel – has reached the highest point since 2004, suggesting more broad-based inflationary pressures (see Chart 5). This, along with ongoing downward pressure on the lira, in our minds warrants the need for higher interest rates which – while they appear to be high on a nominal basis – in inflation-adjusted terms are barely in positive territory2 . That said, our sense is that with the ongoing pressure on the CBRT from the governing AKP party – including Mr. Erdogan himself – to, in fact, loosen monetary this is likely to constrain its room to raise rates much further from current levels. 2 For the sake of simplicity, if we take the CBRT’s weighted average interest rate in nominal terms it stands at 12.25% but in real terms it only amounts to 0.35%.
  • 4. Special Report | February 20184 …But questions about sustainability continue to linger… In essence, the measures taken by the Turkish authorities in the aftermath of the attempted coup have worked in terms of supporting growth. But, despite this, there are still questions about both the sustainability and quality of growth. This is based on the following reasoning:  For one thing, over 85% of the TRY250bn CGF – which was an important driver of growth through the course of this year – has now been used up. As a result, credit growth, particularly to the corporate sector is set to slow going forward. This, in turn, is likely to be a drag on investment spending looking ahead.  While we welcome the fact that net exports have made a positive contribution to growth recently, this can perhaps be attributed to temporary factors, such as the declining value of (Source) Macrobond, BTMU *Adjustment made on the basis that 90% of CGF related lending is in TRY, while 10% in FX. (Source) Macrobond, BTMU 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 42 44 46 48 50 52 54 56 Jan/12 Jul/12 Jan/13 Jul/13 Jan/14 Jul/14 Jan/15 Jul/15 Jan/16 Jul/16 Jan/17 Jul/17 Chart 3: Industrial activity indicators have rebounded sharply after the failed coup attempt... Capacity utilisation rate (RHS, %) PMI (LHS) (Total loan growth, % y/y) 0 10 20 30 40 50 Jan/12 Jan/13 Jan/14 Jan/15 Jan/16 Jan/17 Chart4: Thanks in large part to the strong creditimpulse FX denominated Total (FX adjusted)* Total (TRY) (Loan growth, % y/y) (Source) Macrobond, BTMU 2 4 6 8 10 12 Jan/12 Jan/13 Jan/14 Jan/15 Jan/16 Jan/17 Chart 5: Inflationary pressure have itensified and not just at the headline level CPI Core CPI (%, y/y) CBRT target
  • 5. Special Report | February 20185 the Turkish lira, which is likely to have made the country’s exports more price competitive abroad. Also, on the external front, our sense is that import growth is likely to accelerate in H2 on the back of strong domestic demand, so the positive contribution of net exports – which reached 1.7pp in Q2 – is set to fade. In terms of 2018, our sense is that this negative bias on net exports may lessen somewhat because of the likely deceleration of domestic demand, which could crimp demand for imported goods. This is based on two key factors: i) the expiry of some of the stimulus measures alluded to above; and ii) the lagged impact of the Turkish lira’s recent depreciation, which will make the cost of imported goods coming into the country more expensive.  Even though Turkey’s public debt stock is low, at under 30% of GDP, the current pace of fiscal stimulus – which pushed the budget deficit from 1.1% of GDP in December 2016 to 2.1% of GDP in August (see Chart 6) – needs to be closely monitored. Adding to these worries is the fact that investors in Turkish debt have become unnerved recently as result of the country’s deteriorating relations with its key allies, namely the US and EU. This, in turn, has had the effect of putting pressure on the lira, while yields on the country’s benchmark 10-year government bonds have risen by more than 100bps since early October, to a post- crises high of over 12% (see Chart 7). If sustained, this could likely add to country’s borrowing costs and, ultimately, undermine its fiscal flexibility, at least, at the margin. …As a myriad of challenges still confront the country External vulnerability The most obvious challenge that Turkey faces today is its gapping current account deficit. While this has fallen from a peak of around 10% of GDP at the start of this decade to a figure in the region of 4% today, it still remains an area of concern. This is especially true given the fact that it is largely being financed by volatile portfolio flows rather than foreign direct investment (FDI), which tends to be more durable in nature. Central to this problem is the fact that Turkey’s saving rate is too low relative to its investment outlays (see Chart 8). Thus, to (Source) Macrobond, BTMU (Source) Macrobond, BTMU -1.1 -2.1 -6 -5 -4 -3 -2 -1 0 0 10 20 30 40 50 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 2017/08 Chart 6:Turkey's fiscal metrics remain respectable... Public debt(% of GDP, LHS) Budget balance (% of GDP, RHS) 4 6 8 10 12 14 Jan/13 Jul/13 Jan/14 Jul/14 Jan/15 Jul/15 Jan/16 Jul/16 Jan/17 Jul/17 Chart 7:...But the uptick in bond yields suggest that the markets remain wary (10-year govt. bond yields, %)
  • 6. Special Report | February 20186 plug this gap, the country resorts to borrowing from abroad. While in principle this should not be a problem, the point to note is that such borrowing makes the country vulnerable to the vagaries of changing market sentiment. Indeed, when the US Fed signalled in 2013 that it was looking to pare down its quantitative easing or asset purchase programme, bond yields in the US rose sharply and portfolio capital started to flow out of emerging markets. The currencies of most EMs came under downward pressure at the time, but the lira came under particular line of fire due to the country’s outsized current account deficit. Between May 2013 – when this so- called “taper tantrum” saga started – to the end of 2015, the currency lost around 40% of its value vis-a-vis the US dollar. The lira came in for another bout of punishment after the failed coup attempt last July and is down some 50% or so since May 2013. Against this backdrop, our sense is that Turkey needs to do a number of things to reduce its external vulnerability:  The country needs to reduce its reliance on imported fuel and energy, which accounts for something like two thirds of the country’s current account deficit. To this end, it needs to instigate measures that would aid the development of alternative or renewable energy sources, including nuclear and solar power projects. While there’s a lot of interest on the part of the Turkish authorities in such projects, it is important to highlight they’re very capital-intensive in nature and, for this reason, have been rather slow to take-off. Notwithstanding this, the role of alternative energy as a whole is set to rise in Turkey over time – and if the consultation document entitled “National Renewable Energy Action Plan for Turkey”3 is any guide it’s expected to jump from around 17% presently to around 20% in 2020. Also, of note here is that with economic growth – which is one of the key drivers of energy demand – set to continue at a decent pace over the next three years (3.5% on average according to the IMF) energy consumption is expected to closely following suit. Indeed, we are of the view that on this assumption Turkey’s energy demand is expected to jump from an estimated figure of 100.6m tonnes of oil equivalent (toe) presently to ~112m toe in 2020. 3 This was published in December 2014. (Source) World Bank, BTMU 0 2 4 6 8 10 20 24 28 32 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Chart 8: The mismatch between Turkey's investment & savings position is central to it's external vulnerabilities Gap (RHS) Gross investment Gross savings (% of GDP)(% of GDP)
  • 7. Special Report | February 20187  Second, Turkey needs to improve the quality of the financing of its current account deficit. In this regard, the country needs to improve its business environment as well as its infrastructure base, both of which are often cited as vital in helping the country to attract greater FDI inflows. In fact, the country has made reasonable strides in terms of the former, with its latest ranking with respect to the World Bank’s Ease of Doing Business Index climbing some nine places. However, at 60 (out of total of 190 countries), the country’s current ranking still lags that of comparable EMs within Central and Eastern Europe, such as, Poland and the Czech Republic, which rank 27 and 30 respectively.  Third, the country needs to boost its savings rate which, at under 25% of GDP, is rather low by EM standards4 . We expected this figure to remain broadly the same through to 2020 in part thanks to Turkey’s young and growing population and its high propensity to consume. While measures to encourage private individuals to save more is perhaps the most obvious way to deal with this problem, another would be for the Turkish government to run a smaller budget deficit, if not, a surplus. However, we don’t see this happening, for the time being at least, given the fact that in the run-up to the 2019 presidential election the government will be under pressure to ensure that growth remains robust. Elsewhere, measures could also be taken to, for example, further develop the country’s capital markets which, over time, would make it more attractive for Turkish companies borrow domestically rather than from abroad. While the priority areas we have identified above are not exactly new and – if anything – amount to long-standing challenges, markets will be expecting to see much greater focus on implementing such reforms, especially now that the political uncertainty associated with constitutional referendum vote that was held earlier this April is out of the way. Additionally, it is also worth pointing out that given the above measures are essentially structural in nature and are accorded a high weighting by the rating agencies, some progress would need to be seen in these areas for the country’s sovereign rating – which was downgraded to “junk” status in the aftermath of attempted coup – to be upgraded back to investment grade territory (See Table 1). Banking/Corporate sector risk The Turkish banking system remains sound, as banks are liquid and well capitalised (see Chart 9), while non-performing loans are generally low (about 3%). However, as noted above, government policy aimed at stimulating credit growth is somewhat worrying, as there has been a reversal of tighter regulations, which were originally put in place to prevent run-away credit 4 The top tier EMs, i.e. BRIC economies, average closer to 30% of GDP. Current rating Previous rating Date of downgrade Current outlook S&P BB BBB- 20-Jul-16 Negative Moody's Ba1 Baa3 23-Sep-16 Negative Fitch BB+ BBB- 27-Jan-17 Stable (Source) Bloomberg, BTMU Table 1: Turkey's recent sovereign rating action
  • 8. Special Report | February 20188 growth. The loan to value ratio has been relaxed from 75% to 80% and government applies suasion on banks to keep mortgage rates low despite rising funding costs. Against such a backdrop, credit growth has exceeded the 15% ceiling previously considered by the CBRT to healthy. The danger is that with loan growth as a whole currently running in excess of 20% it could push up NPLs of the Turkish banking system going forward. Also, of note here is the fact by lending to the corporate sector in the form of foreign currency debt, banks are also indirectly vulnerable to currency risk. Total corporate debt at the end of 2016 stood at over 65% of GDP, a more than two-fold increase on the level seen in 2007 (see Chart 10). This is particularly worrying given the fact that about 45% of this debt is denominated in foreign currency. Turkish companies – particularly in the energy, construction materials, steel, transport (airlines) and chemicals sectors – have extensively borrowed in foreign currency from local banks. While there are mitigating factors at play, such as the fact that two thirds of the loans are in sectors with natural hedges (e.g. via export revenues), the point to note is that as foreign exchange assets only cover 40% of liabilities corporates run a substantial currency risk. Most at risk are smaller firms with earnings mostly in local currency that are not sufficiently hedged. Labour market challenges Elsewhere on the domestic front, productivity growth – which averaged 5% over the 2000-2007 period – slowed sharply to 1.4% over 2008-2015 according to OECD data. There have been no meaningful education or labour market reforms in recent years. As result, Turkey continues to register one of the highest youth unemployment rates among Central and Eastern European countries, while in terms of female participation rates it does not fare much better either (see Chart 11). While the latter issue is, in part, influenced by cultural factors, it is also important to *This is indicative of whether banks have adequate high quality liquid assets (Source) BIS, BTMU (HQLA) to survive stressed liquidity conditions over a 30-day period. This ratio is calculated as follows: LCR = HQLAs/ Net cash outflows.**This is the amount of ownership an individual or company has in an asset. Formula: Total assets - total liabilities. (Source) BRSA, BTMU 0 5 10 15 20 25 0 30 60 90 120 150 180 2009 2010 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 2016 Sep-17 Chart 9: Key fundamentals of the Turkish banking system remain sound... Liquidity Coverage Ratio (%, LHS)* Owners Equity (US$bn,LHS)** CAR(%,RHS) 11.3 18.2 17.7 29.9 44.8 67.9 39.9 35.8 28.6 0 20 40 60 80 100 120 2007 2012 2016 Chart 10:...But growing exposure to the corporate sector could be troublesome going forward Credit to Govt. Credit to Firms Credit to Houselholds (% of GDP)
  • 9. Special Report | February 20189 highlight that it’s reflective of the failure of the education system to perhaps adequately equip new entrants into the labour market with the requisite skills to succeed. Also, of note here is the fact that labour market rigidities – for example in the form of strictness of employment protectionism – remain at elevated levels in Turkey (see Chart 12). Finally, Turkey’s slide in a number of governance indicators compiled by the World Bank recently (including in the areas of voice and accountability, political instability, government effectiveness, rule of law and control of corruption) suggest that the pace of institutional reforms has also slowed. Political concerns Turkey has had to navigate many political challenges over the past year or so, not least the failed coup attempt and the constitutional referendum vote on the creation of an executive presidency. Notwithstanding this, political risk in the country still remains at an elevated level thanks to following factors:  For one thing, the purge Mr. Erdogan instigated in the aftermath of the coup attempt against the followers of the exiled religious cleric Fethullah Gulen – who he and his supporters claim were behind the putsch – continues to this day, leading some, to rightly question, whether this may have gone too far.  Related to the above point, Mr. Erdogan retains the power to rule by decree, which he initially amassed following the aborted coup attempt. While such emergency powers served a useful purpose in stemming the immediate crisis, their continuation leads us to the inevitable conclusion that the checks and balances within the Turkish political system are being eroded. (Source) HDI, World Bank, BTMU *0-6 scale where 6 is the most restrictive. (Source) OECD, BTMU 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 Bulgaria Hungary Poland Czech Rep. Romania Turkey Chart 11: Turkey's labour market indicators compare poorly with its CEE peers... Female participation rate (%) Youth unemployment (%) 0 0.5 1 1.5 2 2.5 3 3.5 Turkey Czech Rep. Poland Hungary Chart 12:...Whilethe strictnessofits employment protectionlegislation isalsomoreworrisome (0‐6 scale)*
  • 10. Special Report | February 201810  Although the political noise associated with the constitutional referendum vote held this Spring has abated, this by no means the end of the story as far as the proposed constitutional changes are concerned. Indeed, the country is due to hold presidential elections in 2019 which Mr. Erdogan will need to convincingly win in order to push ahead with his aim to move towards an executive presidency. This, in turn, is likely to add to continuing political uncertainty up to 2019 and perhaps even beyond if the outcome of this election proves to be inconclusive. Aside from the political uncertainty associated with the aforementioned presidential election, the fact that Turkey’s fragile Kurdish peace process has broken down recently – with the separatist PKK declaring an end to its unilateral ceasefire – will continue make the security situation in Turkey rather precarious as we approach the end of this decade. This – along with Turkish army’s recent incursion into northern parts of Syria that border Turkey to attack Kurdish separatist strongholds there – we feel will also make the prospect of reprisal attacks on Turkish soil a potential likelihood over this period.  Finally, on the external front, the country also needs to reset relations with the EU and the US, which have suffered a serious setback recently. With respect to the former group, failure to do so could mean it could lose a vital anchor which, until recently, has helped the country to benchmark its policies against EU member states. US-Turkish relations meanwhile appear to have worsened since the arrival of Donald Trump at the helm of the US presidency and we expect this tendency to persist going forward as the two countries appear to be taking a differing stance on regional issues including Syria. Concluding thoughts/look ahead Turkey finds itself at a key juncture at the moment. While the economy has rebounded sharply in the aftermath of the failed coup attempt, it’s not fully out of the woods yet. For one thing, there are still lingering doubts about the sustainability of the current recovery, which has been propped up by the government’s various stimulus measures, some of which are set to expire as the year-end approaches. Elsewhere, measures to address the country’s external vulnerabilities are still pending while, on the political front, a key event risk in the form of the 2019 presidential election still looms large. Against this backdrop, while we welcome the fact that Turkey’s economy didn’t tank in the aftermath of the attempted coup, going forward our – and – indeed the market’s – focus will very much be on whether the Turkish authorities will be able to push through some of the key macro and structural reforms, which we’ve highlighted in this report including, for example, boosting human capital, strengthening the business environment, and improving the functioning of the labour market. Such measures, despite being seen as of vital importance in helping the country to transition towards a more value- added growth model over time, will in our minds struggle to gain traction thanks, in large part, to the fact that forthcoming presidential elections are due to take place in Turkey in 2019 and in the run-up to this event it’s highly unlikely that Mr. Erdogan will be willing to embrace painful structural reforms which in the short-term at least are likely to temper growth and hence his electoral popularity. Set against this rather bleak backdrop for structural reforms and an economy which is currently running beyond its current growth potential5 , while we expect Turkey to continue to “muddle 5 IMF’s estimate of Turkey potential GDP growth stands at slightly above 3%.
  • 11. Special Report | February 201811 through”, our sense is that there will be a number of implications for the country looking ahead over the short to medium-term:  Current account implications – Turkey’s current deficit, which is viewed as its main Achilles heel, will remain at an elevated levels of greater than 3% of GDP over the next couple of years. While, in theory, this gap should improve somewhat through the course of next year and, perhaps, beyond on the back of the predicted moderation in domestic demand, this in our minds will be offset by the recent rebound in international oil and energy prices whose imports, as we’ve alluded to above, account for around two-thirds of the country’s total current account deficit. Going forward, our sense is that with oil prices expected to remain within the US$60-70/barrel range or beyond in the period to 2020 this will not be helpful in aiding the Turkish authorities desire to bring down the country’s underlying current account deficit.  Sovereign rating implications – Concerns over the financing of Turkey’s sizeable external deficit, coupled with the reluctance on the part of the authorities there to tighten fiscal policy in the run-up to the 2019 presidential election, will continue to weigh on Turkey’s sovereign rating. Indeed, we expect its rating to remain in “junk” territory for the time being at least. While our central view is that this rating will not be downgraded further, in the event that it does it could certainly have the potential to negatively affect the value of its local currency unit and/or bonds. This in turn could make the task of financing its current account deficit even more difficult than it already is.  Political developments & their likely implications – A final point worth noting here is that we expect the recent political uncertainty in Turkey to persist going forward over the next two years or so not only because of domestic political factors, such the forthcoming presidential elections, but also due to the country’s strained relations with its key western allies, such as the US. This, in our mind, will have a negative bearing on the country’s financial markets and will, in particular, continue to undermine the performance of its local currency unit over the short to medium-term. Also, should Mr. Erdogan win the 2019 presidential election with a landslide majority – an outcome which will allow him to continue to go down the road of an executive presidency with little checks and balances – there is a danger that this could further undermine the quality as well as investors’ perception of Turkey’s institutional strength. The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd. (“BTMU”) is a limited liability stock company incorporated in Japan and registered in the Tokyo Legal Affairs Bureau (company no. 0100-01-008846). BTMU’s head office is at 7-1 Marunouchi 2-Chome, Chiyoda-Ku, Tokyo 100-8388, Japan. BTMU’s London branch is registered as a UK establishment in the UK register of companies (registered no. BR002013). BTMU is authorised and regulated by the Japanese Financial Services Agency. BTMU’s London branch is authorised by the Prudential Regulation Authority (FCA/PRA no. 139189) and subject to regulation by the Financial Conduct Authority and limited regulation by the Prudential Regulation Authority. Details about the extent of BTMU London branch’s regulation by the Prudential Regulation Authority are available from us on request. This report shall not be construed as solicitation to take any action such as purchasing/selling/investing in financial market products. In taking any action, each reader is requested to act on the basis of his or her own judgment. This report is based on information believed to be reliable, but we do not guarantee, and do not accept any liability whatsoever for, its accuracy and we accept no liability whatsoever for any loss or damage of any kind arising out of the use of all or any part of this report. The contents of the report may be revised without advance notice. Also, this report is a literary work protected by copyright. No part of this report may be reproduced in any form without express statement of its source. The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd. retains copyright to this report and no part of this report may be reproduced or re-distributed without the written permission of The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd. The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd. expressly prohibits the re-distribution of this report to Retail Customers, via the internet or otherwise and The Bank of Tokyo-Mitsubishi UFJ, Ltd., its subsidiaries or affiliates accept no liability whatsoever to any third parties resulting from such re-distribution.