Jenny gets a new kitten named Timmy and brings him home from the animal shelter. When someone rings their doorbell unexpectedly, Timmy notices it is their neighbor Cinnamon the bunny. Later, Jenny and Timmy find bugs in their dinner and suspect Cinnamon put them there. They hide and catch Cinnamon putting more bugs in their food, but Cinnamon tries to play it cool until he realizes he has been discovered. Cinnamon goes to "bunny jail" while Jenny and Timmy look forward to their next adventure.