ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
Socratic Dialogical Method
A Proposed Formal Model for TITAN
Socratic Methodologies
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
Leonard Nelson (1882 –1927)
Socrates (470–399 B.C.E)
Socratic maieutic
(dialectic philosophy)
1. ignorance (agnoia)
2. questioning (aporia)
3. logical refutation
(elenchus) of
unjustified claims
examination of good
life, true knwoledge
and virtue (arete)
Die Sokratische Methode
(dialogical philosophy)
1. searching for
examples
2. searching for
attributes
3. generalizing the
attributes
critical thinking,
evaluation of different
perspectives
Socratic Method in Education
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
• Not a fixed procedure.
• Systematic, disciplined, challenging, provocative (different
from common questioning and simple conversations).
• An open dialogue between a facilitator and person / group.
• Not a teaching method in the conventional way
("undeniable" facts and truths or "memorization”)
• An open-teaching with shared dialogues between people
where both are responsible for pushing the dialogue
forward through questioning
Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of
Socratic Questioning. The
Foundation for Critical Thinking
Socratic Method in Education
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
• concept
• opinion
Question
• question
• challenge
Method
• defined
• justified
Goal
Content Substratum
Socratic Method in Education
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of
Socratic Questioning. The
Foundation for Critical Thinking
Contextualization
Content
Mechanics
of
Questioning
Human
Subject
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
1. Wonder (pose questions: what is courage, what is
virtue)
2. Hypothesis (answer: opinion or claim, the hypothesis
of the dialogue is defined);
3. Elenchus (hypothesis is challenged, counter-claims,
counter-examples)
4. Accept / Reject (hypothesis accepted or rejected by
the participants themselves)
5. Action (inquiry results and findings)
(Boghossian, 2012)
Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of
Socratic Questioning. The
Foundation for Critical Thinking
Socratic Method in Education
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
Inquiry (doubting,
questioning, clarifying)
Hypothesis (probing
assumptions,
definitions, opinions)
Rationale (examining
reasons, evidences,
facts)
Analysis (recognizing
different perspectives,
viewpoints)
Evaluation (considering
implications and
consequences)
Question on the
Questions (conclusions,
reconsidering the
question)
Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of
Socratic Questioning. The
Foundation for Critical Thinking
Socratic Method in Education
Socratic Method in Educational Technology
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
(1) (quasi-Socratic): encourages participation and promote
intellectual curiosity and the joy of learning. Examples: digital
applications such as "Socrative", "Nearpod" and "ClassDojo"
(Dunn, 2014)
(2) (real-Socratic): encourages critical thinking and intelligent
coaching (probing questions, explore relationships among
concepts and ideas, play devil’s advocate). Examples: Intelligent
Tutoring System (ITS)
Le & Huse, N. (2016)
Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of
Socratic Questioning. The
Foundation for Critical Thinking
Socratic Formal Methods
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
Le & Huse, N. (2016)
“Evaluation of the Formal
Models for the Socratic
Method”
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
Proposed Formal Method
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ
Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος
Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
Proposed Formal Method

IPT Socratic Dialogues.pptx

  • 1.
    ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ &ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr Socratic Dialogical Method A Proposed Formal Model for TITAN
  • 2.
    Socratic Methodologies ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ& ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr Leonard Nelson (1882 –1927) Socrates (470–399 B.C.E) Socratic maieutic (dialectic philosophy) 1. ignorance (agnoia) 2. questioning (aporia) 3. logical refutation (elenchus) of unjustified claims examination of good life, true knwoledge and virtue (arete) Die Sokratische Methode (dialogical philosophy) 1. searching for examples 2. searching for attributes 3. generalizing the attributes critical thinking, evaluation of different perspectives
  • 3.
    Socratic Method inEducation ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr • Not a fixed procedure. • Systematic, disciplined, challenging, provocative (different from common questioning and simple conversations). • An open dialogue between a facilitator and person / group. • Not a teaching method in the conventional way ("undeniable" facts and truths or "memorization”) • An open-teaching with shared dialogues between people where both are responsible for pushing the dialogue forward through questioning Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of Socratic Questioning. The Foundation for Critical Thinking
  • 4.
    Socratic Method inEducation ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr • concept • opinion Question • question • challenge Method • defined • justified Goal Content Substratum
  • 5.
    Socratic Method inEducation ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of Socratic Questioning. The Foundation for Critical Thinking Contextualization Content Mechanics of Questioning Human Subject
  • 6.
    ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ &ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr 1. Wonder (pose questions: what is courage, what is virtue) 2. Hypothesis (answer: opinion or claim, the hypothesis of the dialogue is defined); 3. Elenchus (hypothesis is challenged, counter-claims, counter-examples) 4. Accept / Reject (hypothesis accepted or rejected by the participants themselves) 5. Action (inquiry results and findings) (Boghossian, 2012) Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of Socratic Questioning. The Foundation for Critical Thinking Socratic Method in Education
  • 7.
    ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ &ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr Inquiry (doubting, questioning, clarifying) Hypothesis (probing assumptions, definitions, opinions) Rationale (examining reasons, evidences, facts) Analysis (recognizing different perspectives, viewpoints) Evaluation (considering implications and consequences) Question on the Questions (conclusions, reconsidering the question) Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of Socratic Questioning. The Foundation for Critical Thinking Socratic Method in Education
  • 8.
    Socratic Method inEducational Technology ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr (1) (quasi-Socratic): encourages participation and promote intellectual curiosity and the joy of learning. Examples: digital applications such as "Socrative", "Nearpod" and "ClassDojo" (Dunn, 2014) (2) (real-Socratic): encourages critical thinking and intelligent coaching (probing questions, explore relationships among concepts and ideas, play devil’s advocate). Examples: Intelligent Tutoring System (ITS) Le & Huse, N. (2016) Paul & Edler (2006) The Art of Socratic Questioning. The Foundation for Critical Thinking
  • 9.
    Socratic Formal Methods ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr Le & Huse, N. (2016) “Evaluation of the Formal Models for the Socratic Method”
  • 10.
    ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ &ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
  • 11.
    Proposed Formal Method ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ & ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr
  • 12.
    ΙΝΣΤΙΤΟΥΤΟ ΦΙΛΟΣΟΦΙΑΣ &ΤΕΧΝΟΛΟΓΙΑΣ Λ. Χρονοπούλου 20, 17455, Άλιμος Τ: +30 2109816297 – info@ipt.gr Proposed Formal Method