SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Investment Management Fees:
Who Pays Them and Why
• Public pension funds often use external Wall
Street firms to manage their investments.
• Wall Street firms charge fees that are arbitrary,
opaque, and expensive. Lack of accountability
allows this extraction of wealth from communities.
Investment Management Fees:
How are They Charged and Reported?
• Fees charged as a percentage of investment funds
or (“assets”) under management, independent of
whether or not the managers increase the value of
the funds.
• Only those investment management fees that are
directly invoiced are required to be publicly
reported.
Other Investment Fees/Expenses
 Financial consultant fees
 Securities lending fees
 Performance fees
 Transaction fees
 Hidden fees
Finding Investment Management Fees
• Pension Fund Los Angeles City Employees’
Retirement System (LACERS) CAFR
 Visit pension fund Web site, look for annual reports
that often contain a “Schedule of Investment
Expenses”
 LACERS CAFR FY13
 Attend Board of Investments meeting at pension
fund—open to public
 Request fee information from pension fund staff
Finding Investment Management Fees
• City of Los Angeles CAFR 2013
• Search term “investment expense”
Developing Quantitative Metrics for Fees Negotiation
AUM = $1,206,895,000
Investment Management Fees = $18,050,000
IMF/AUM=.0149 (1.5%)
AUM Fees
Calculating Fees as a Percentage of Assets Under Management (AUM)
Exercise: Calculate fees as a percentage of AUM
1. Find fees as a percentage of AUM for Securities
Lending in the LACERS Retirement Plan
2. Find fees as a percentage of AUM for Total Real
Estate Managers
AUM Fees
Group Exercise 1
• Pension Fund California Public Employees’ Retirement System
(CalPERS), FY 2013
• HINT: Use Table of Contents, Find “Total Investment Management
Expenses Summary”
 What did CalPERS pay in external management fees?
 What did CalPERS pay in external performance fees?
 CalPERS total assets under management as of June 30, 2013 was
$287 billion.
 Using this total, find the total fees paid as a percentage of AUM.
Group Exercise 2
• Los Angeles Fire and Police Pensions (LAFPP),
FY 2013
 Find the investment expenses reported for this
pension fund in the City of Los Angeles CAFR
2013.
 How does the total investment listed in the City’s
CAFR compare to the total listed in this LAFPP
Budget FY 2013?
 What might account for the large discrepancy
between the total investment expenses listed in
the City’s CAFR and LAFPP’s budget
document?
How Fee Research Fits into Your Campaign
• Remember pension funds are pools of capital of workers’ money—
current and future.
• Use fee research to challenge Wall Street’s control of the
resources of our cities and communities
• If we achieve cost savings, that money can be reinvested in local
communities
• For example, what would $1 million in fee savings provide:
• At 6% annual return
• A $50,000 annual pension
• With a 3% annual COLA
• For 30 years!

More Related Content

Similar to Investment Mngt Fees Presentation Final

Costs of Issuance Presentation Final
Costs of Issuance Presentation FinalCosts of Issuance Presentation Final
Costs of Issuance Presentation FinalLisa E. Cody
 
2015 inspire tour: Fixed asset management
2015 inspire tour: Fixed asset management2015 inspire tour: Fixed asset management
2015 inspire tour: Fixed asset management
Jeremy Ploessel
 
Mutual fund market in australia vis a’-vis india
Mutual fund market in australia vis a’-vis indiaMutual fund market in australia vis a’-vis india
Mutual fund market in australia vis a’-vis india
AabhasKshetapal
 
slides cash flow of law firm session 5 forecash
slides cash flow of law firm session 5 forecashslides cash flow of law firm session 5 forecash
slides cash flow of law firm session 5 forecash
z z
 
032119 -als--best practices prsn
032119 -als--best practices prsn032119 -als--best practices prsn
032119 -als--best practices prsn
Carol Buckmann
 
Loan Fund Program Informational Meeting
Loan Fund Program Informational MeetingLoan Fund Program Informational Meeting
Loan Fund Program Informational Meeting
tiffanycfslc
 
407_ISFs & EFs.pptx
407_ISFs & EFs.pptx407_ISFs & EFs.pptx
407_ISFs & EFs.pptx
RakibulIslam622598
 
Financial Services from Hawksley Consulting
Financial Services from Hawksley ConsultingFinancial Services from Hawksley Consulting
Financial Services from Hawksley Consulting
JGMumm
 
chapter- 1 inroduction to advanced financial accounting.pptx
chapter- 1 inroduction to advanced financial accounting.pptxchapter- 1 inroduction to advanced financial accounting.pptx
chapter- 1 inroduction to advanced financial accounting.pptx
MohamedAbdi347025
 
Center for Enterprise Innovation (CEI) Summary for HREDA, 9-25-14
Center for Enterprise Innovation (CEI) Summary for HREDA, 9-25-14Center for Enterprise Innovation (CEI) Summary for HREDA, 9-25-14
Center for Enterprise Innovation (CEI) Summary for HREDA, 9-25-14
Marty Kaszubowski
 
Building Federal Budgets
Building Federal BudgetsBuilding Federal Budgets
Building Federal Budgets
Illinois ResourceNet
 
Not-for-Profit Financial Reporting: How to Convert Your Financial Statements ...
Not-for-Profit Financial Reporting: How to Convert Your Financial Statements ...Not-for-Profit Financial Reporting: How to Convert Your Financial Statements ...
Not-for-Profit Financial Reporting: How to Convert Your Financial Statements ...
McKonly & Asbury, LLP
 
2013 Callan Cost of Doing Business Survey: U.S. Funds and Trusts
2013 Callan Cost of Doing Business Survey: U.S. Funds and Trusts2013 Callan Cost of Doing Business Survey: U.S. Funds and Trusts
2013 Callan Cost of Doing Business Survey: U.S. Funds and Trusts
Callan
 
Performance Evaluation Parameters for Non-Profit Organisations
Performance Evaluation Parameters for Non-Profit OrganisationsPerformance Evaluation Parameters for Non-Profit Organisations
Performance Evaluation Parameters for Non-Profit Organisations
Sheetal Wagh
 
Mercer Capital | Valuation Insight | Capital Structure in 30 Minutes
Mercer Capital | Valuation Insight | Capital Structure in 30 MinutesMercer Capital | Valuation Insight | Capital Structure in 30 Minutes
Mercer Capital | Valuation Insight | Capital Structure in 30 Minutes
Mercer Capital
 
Ngo financial management guide pwc
Ngo financial management guide pwcNgo financial management guide pwc
Ngo financial management guide pwc
Tariq
 
accouting types.pdf
accouting types.pdfaccouting types.pdf
accouting types.pdf
AkankshaPendharkar1
 
Philly public bank and cafr presentation
Philly public bank and cafr presentationPhilly public bank and cafr presentation
Philly public bank and cafr presentation
Scott Baker - Senior Advisor to Public Banking Institute
 

Similar to Investment Mngt Fees Presentation Final (20)

Costs of Issuance Presentation Final
Costs of Issuance Presentation FinalCosts of Issuance Presentation Final
Costs of Issuance Presentation Final
 
2015 inspire tour: Fixed asset management
2015 inspire tour: Fixed asset management2015 inspire tour: Fixed asset management
2015 inspire tour: Fixed asset management
 
Mutual fund market in australia vis a’-vis india
Mutual fund market in australia vis a’-vis indiaMutual fund market in australia vis a’-vis india
Mutual fund market in australia vis a’-vis india
 
slides cash flow of law firm session 5 forecash
slides cash flow of law firm session 5 forecashslides cash flow of law firm session 5 forecash
slides cash flow of law firm session 5 forecash
 
032119 -als--best practices prsn
032119 -als--best practices prsn032119 -als--best practices prsn
032119 -als--best practices prsn
 
Loan Fund Program Informational Meeting
Loan Fund Program Informational MeetingLoan Fund Program Informational Meeting
Loan Fund Program Informational Meeting
 
407_ISFs & EFs.pptx
407_ISFs & EFs.pptx407_ISFs & EFs.pptx
407_ISFs & EFs.pptx
 
Charity Reach April 2015
Charity Reach  April 2015Charity Reach  April 2015
Charity Reach April 2015
 
Financial Services from Hawksley Consulting
Financial Services from Hawksley ConsultingFinancial Services from Hawksley Consulting
Financial Services from Hawksley Consulting
 
chapter- 1 inroduction to advanced financial accounting.pptx
chapter- 1 inroduction to advanced financial accounting.pptxchapter- 1 inroduction to advanced financial accounting.pptx
chapter- 1 inroduction to advanced financial accounting.pptx
 
Center for Enterprise Innovation (CEI) Summary for HREDA, 9-25-14
Center for Enterprise Innovation (CEI) Summary for HREDA, 9-25-14Center for Enterprise Innovation (CEI) Summary for HREDA, 9-25-14
Center for Enterprise Innovation (CEI) Summary for HREDA, 9-25-14
 
Building Federal Budgets
Building Federal BudgetsBuilding Federal Budgets
Building Federal Budgets
 
Not-for-Profit Financial Reporting: How to Convert Your Financial Statements ...
Not-for-Profit Financial Reporting: How to Convert Your Financial Statements ...Not-for-Profit Financial Reporting: How to Convert Your Financial Statements ...
Not-for-Profit Financial Reporting: How to Convert Your Financial Statements ...
 
2013 Callan Cost of Doing Business Survey: U.S. Funds and Trusts
2013 Callan Cost of Doing Business Survey: U.S. Funds and Trusts2013 Callan Cost of Doing Business Survey: U.S. Funds and Trusts
2013 Callan Cost of Doing Business Survey: U.S. Funds and Trusts
 
Performance Evaluation Parameters for Non-Profit Organisations
Performance Evaluation Parameters for Non-Profit OrganisationsPerformance Evaluation Parameters for Non-Profit Organisations
Performance Evaluation Parameters for Non-Profit Organisations
 
Mercer Capital | Valuation Insight | Capital Structure in 30 Minutes
Mercer Capital | Valuation Insight | Capital Structure in 30 MinutesMercer Capital | Valuation Insight | Capital Structure in 30 Minutes
Mercer Capital | Valuation Insight | Capital Structure in 30 Minutes
 
Ipsas training part i overview
Ipsas training part i   overviewIpsas training part i   overview
Ipsas training part i overview
 
Ngo financial management guide pwc
Ngo financial management guide pwcNgo financial management guide pwc
Ngo financial management guide pwc
 
accouting types.pdf
accouting types.pdfaccouting types.pdf
accouting types.pdf
 
Philly public bank and cafr presentation
Philly public bank and cafr presentationPhilly public bank and cafr presentation
Philly public bank and cafr presentation
 

Investment Mngt Fees Presentation Final

  • 1. Investment Management Fees: Who Pays Them and Why • Public pension funds often use external Wall Street firms to manage their investments. • Wall Street firms charge fees that are arbitrary, opaque, and expensive. Lack of accountability allows this extraction of wealth from communities.
  • 2. Investment Management Fees: How are They Charged and Reported? • Fees charged as a percentage of investment funds or (“assets”) under management, independent of whether or not the managers increase the value of the funds. • Only those investment management fees that are directly invoiced are required to be publicly reported.
  • 3. Other Investment Fees/Expenses  Financial consultant fees  Securities lending fees  Performance fees  Transaction fees  Hidden fees
  • 4. Finding Investment Management Fees • Pension Fund Los Angeles City Employees’ Retirement System (LACERS) CAFR  Visit pension fund Web site, look for annual reports that often contain a “Schedule of Investment Expenses”  LACERS CAFR FY13  Attend Board of Investments meeting at pension fund—open to public  Request fee information from pension fund staff
  • 5. Finding Investment Management Fees • City of Los Angeles CAFR 2013 • Search term “investment expense”
  • 6. Developing Quantitative Metrics for Fees Negotiation AUM = $1,206,895,000 Investment Management Fees = $18,050,000 IMF/AUM=.0149 (1.5%) AUM Fees Calculating Fees as a Percentage of Assets Under Management (AUM)
  • 7. Exercise: Calculate fees as a percentage of AUM 1. Find fees as a percentage of AUM for Securities Lending in the LACERS Retirement Plan 2. Find fees as a percentage of AUM for Total Real Estate Managers AUM Fees
  • 8. Group Exercise 1 • Pension Fund California Public Employees’ Retirement System (CalPERS), FY 2013 • HINT: Use Table of Contents, Find “Total Investment Management Expenses Summary”  What did CalPERS pay in external management fees?  What did CalPERS pay in external performance fees?  CalPERS total assets under management as of June 30, 2013 was $287 billion.  Using this total, find the total fees paid as a percentage of AUM.
  • 9. Group Exercise 2 • Los Angeles Fire and Police Pensions (LAFPP), FY 2013  Find the investment expenses reported for this pension fund in the City of Los Angeles CAFR 2013.  How does the total investment listed in the City’s CAFR compare to the total listed in this LAFPP Budget FY 2013?  What might account for the large discrepancy between the total investment expenses listed in the City’s CAFR and LAFPP’s budget document?
  • 10. How Fee Research Fits into Your Campaign • Remember pension funds are pools of capital of workers’ money— current and future. • Use fee research to challenge Wall Street’s control of the resources of our cities and communities • If we achieve cost savings, that money can be reinvested in local communities • For example, what would $1 million in fee savings provide: • At 6% annual return • A $50,000 annual pension • With a 3% annual COLA • For 30 years!

Editor's Notes

  1. Exotic products, lack of transparency, high-risk, overly complex
  2. Mention an example Bain Capital Bastion of 1% ness, a lot of wealth from pension funds as clients for pe investments, companies did not survive, investors and communities take a hit.
  3. Note that retirement plans invest but also health plans