Inclusive Engineering Design
Maggie Delano
Aydelotte Second Tuesday Café
October 8th, 2019
https://health.embs.org/editorial-blog/translational-engineering-health-medicine-glimpse-students-point-view/
Fine dining establishments often have
butter knives shaped like the one
pictured on the left. This type of knife,
while elegant, can be difficult for which
of the following groups of people to
use?
A. Vegans
B. Left-handers
C. The rich and famous
D. Lactose Intolerants
E. Waitstaff
What is wrong with the soap dispenser
shown in the video?
A. The heat sensor was not calibrated
properly for people with cold hands
B. The second person used the
dispenser at a different angle
C. The sensor has a low battery
D. The light sensor was not calibrated
for people with dark skin
E. It’s an illusion
Video from @nke_ise
Apple health is a combination self-
tracking app and aggregator of health
information from third-party apps for
iOS devices. The company received
significant criticism for failing to include
which of the following features when
Apple health was first launched?
A. Period tracking
B. Step counting
C. Blood pressure monitoring
D. Integration with Android devices
E. Exercise tracking
As the technology behind self-driving
cars develops, questions rise about how
cars should be programmed to respond
in a variety of complex scenarios. Which
of the following is most commonly
invoked to guide these discussions?
A. Prisoner’s Dilemma
B. Multi-armed bandit problem
C. Zero sum game
D. Trolley Problem
E. Centipede game
The UK based Babylon health system
developed a “chat bot” that allows
patients to enter a list of symptoms for
a potential diagnosis. A screen shot of
the app for a male user with heart
attack symptoms is shown on the right.
What diagnosis did the chat bot
produce for the equivalent female user?
A. Pericarditis
B. Unstable angina
C. Panic attack
D. Hysteria
E. Gastroenteritis
Devices shown on the right are known
as ankle monitors and are used to
electronically surveil their wearers in
certain circumstances outside of prison.
How much does a wearer in the US have
to pay for the use of their monitor per
day?
A. Free
B. < $ 1
C. < $ 5
D. $5 - $100
E. > $ 100
The graphic on the left and its
variants are commonly used to
illustrate which two concepts?
A. Equality and equity
B. Features and sizing
C. Fairness and unfairness
D. Missed and realized
opportunities
E. Average and normal
Entrepreneur Sam Farber worked with
his wife Betsy Farber to develop the
vegetable peeler shown to the left.
Betsy had mild arthritis that made
conventional peelers difficult to use.
Sam subsequently developed a set of
kitchen tools that became the first
product set for which company?
A. Yeti
B. Williams Sonoma
C. OXO
D. Bed Bath and Beyond
E. Cuisinart
Swarthmore’s Lang Center for Civic and
Social Responsibility focuses primarily
on which of the following design
practices that could be incorporated
into inclusive engineering design?
A. Universal design
B. User centered design
C. Engaged scholarship
D. Critical design

Inclusive Engineering Design Trivia

  • 1.
    Inclusive Engineering Design MaggieDelano Aydelotte Second Tuesday Café October 8th, 2019
  • 2.
  • 4.
    Fine dining establishmentsoften have butter knives shaped like the one pictured on the left. This type of knife, while elegant, can be difficult for which of the following groups of people to use? A. Vegans B. Left-handers C. The rich and famous D. Lactose Intolerants E. Waitstaff
  • 5.
    What is wrongwith the soap dispenser shown in the video? A. The heat sensor was not calibrated properly for people with cold hands B. The second person used the dispenser at a different angle C. The sensor has a low battery D. The light sensor was not calibrated for people with dark skin E. It’s an illusion Video from @nke_ise
  • 6.
    Apple health isa combination self- tracking app and aggregator of health information from third-party apps for iOS devices. The company received significant criticism for failing to include which of the following features when Apple health was first launched? A. Period tracking B. Step counting C. Blood pressure monitoring D. Integration with Android devices E. Exercise tracking
  • 7.
    As the technologybehind self-driving cars develops, questions rise about how cars should be programmed to respond in a variety of complex scenarios. Which of the following is most commonly invoked to guide these discussions? A. Prisoner’s Dilemma B. Multi-armed bandit problem C. Zero sum game D. Trolley Problem E. Centipede game
  • 8.
    The UK basedBabylon health system developed a “chat bot” that allows patients to enter a list of symptoms for a potential diagnosis. A screen shot of the app for a male user with heart attack symptoms is shown on the right. What diagnosis did the chat bot produce for the equivalent female user? A. Pericarditis B. Unstable angina C. Panic attack D. Hysteria E. Gastroenteritis
  • 10.
    Devices shown onthe right are known as ankle monitors and are used to electronically surveil their wearers in certain circumstances outside of prison. How much does a wearer in the US have to pay for the use of their monitor per day? A. Free B. < $ 1 C. < $ 5 D. $5 - $100 E. > $ 100
  • 11.
    The graphic onthe left and its variants are commonly used to illustrate which two concepts? A. Equality and equity B. Features and sizing C. Fairness and unfairness D. Missed and realized opportunities E. Average and normal
  • 12.
    Entrepreneur Sam Farberworked with his wife Betsy Farber to develop the vegetable peeler shown to the left. Betsy had mild arthritis that made conventional peelers difficult to use. Sam subsequently developed a set of kitchen tools that became the first product set for which company? A. Yeti B. Williams Sonoma C. OXO D. Bed Bath and Beyond E. Cuisinart
  • 13.
    Swarthmore’s Lang Centerfor Civic and Social Responsibility focuses primarily on which of the following design practices that could be incorporated into inclusive engineering design? A. Universal design B. User centered design C. Engaged scholarship D. Critical design

Editor's Notes

  • #3 People are motivated most by wanting to help sick people and start companies, but we spend hardly any (if any) time actually talking about the people we are designing technology for. We talk a lot about what we can do, and not what we should do. From my own experience, I started learning about health disparities in CHF, and then realized that this was the tip of the iceberg and there was so much to uncover. I started seeing disparities everywhere, and took courses in WGS to learn more. Lots of important stuff being done in other disciplines, e.g. STS, history, philosophy, english (w/ digital humanities), but this has not penetrated into engineering education. Learning about all these things felt very demotivating, like can I do any good in the world with technology? I almost wanted to quit engineering. But I decided it was important to live with that tension and learn to work through it and help students engage in this same thinking. I think it’s important to bring these lessons directly in a classroom in an accessible way to folks building things, and then work together to grapple with these serious critiques of tech to go build things. Lead in to next slide…
  • #5 Correct answer: B
  • #6 Correct answer: D
  • #7 Correct answer: A
  • #8 Correct answer: A
  • #9 https://twitter.com/DrMurphy11/status/1170774525987971076 Correct answer: C
  • #11 https://equaljusticeunderlaw.org/thejusticereport/2018/6/12/electronic-monitoring#targetText=Indeed%2C%20living%20with%20an%20ankle,its%20own%20brand%20of%20imprisonment.&targetText=Ankle%20monitors%20put%20parolees%20are,ranges%20from%20%245%20to%20%2440. Correct answer: D
  • #12 Correct answer: A
  • #13 Correct answer: C
  • #14 Correct answer: C