SlideShare a Scribd company logo
Human beings (and many other animals) are territorial - the
distinction between "mine" and "yours" is not learned or
cultural; it is deeply rooted in our animal instincts. This is what
makes the argument from property rights so powerful.
Supporters of Capitalism (wise-users among them) believe that
all property should be "mine," whereas Socialism (including
most environmentalists, in some form or other) think that most
property should be "ours." This is a very old and fundamental
debate; "Capitalism" and "Socialism" are merely the newest
names for the two sides. Modern socialists and anarchists
usually agree that "I" am entitled to enough private property for
my own personal use (no one wants to share a toothbrush!) but
that all excess property should belong to the community (why
do I need two houses? for example). And the property I
personally need is very little indeed. Any more than that, and I
am usurping what others could use: I am getting rich at someone
else's expense; I am creating two classes of society, the "haves"
and the "have nots." To get to the point: opponents of wise use
believe that it is wrong for me to abuse, pollute, destroy or
otherwise damage property that should benefit everyone. I can
trash my own house, if I like; that's my business; but when I
trash the larger environment, that's everyone's business, even if
the property laws say that environment is "mine." The "wise
use" position is that "mine" is mine, no limits, no restrictions.
When modern capitalism evolved in the eighteenth and
nineteenth centuries, it worked only because new laws defined
"property" in new and inventive ways so that the capitalists
could be certain of keeping the profits they made in the free
market. No entrepreneur would want to start a new business if
he could not be certain that it, and any profit it made, were
really his. (At least, that was what the capitalists and their
partners in the newly centralized governments said.) In earlier
ages, philosophers believed that property is temporary; that it is
ours only so long as we actually use it (this is called "usufruct"
in feudal law). After all, we come into the world with nothing,
and we leave it with nothing, so property cannot be "ours" in
any permanent sense. Medieval cities and kingdoms actually
had laws against charging interest on loans or charging more for
a loaf of bread than the poor could afford - because economic
wealth was seen as belonging to the community, not to the
individual. In fact, the entire Judeao-Christian-Muslim belief
system preaches against the use of interest. They call it usury,
and it is generally agreed to be greedy and potentially evil.
Unfortunately, in the modern era, the Christians (and almost
everyone else) seem to have abandoned this law. The Jewish
and Islamic communities still adhere to it in varying degrees:
the Islamic much more so. These notions of community and
mutual benefit changed when the new market economy began to
encourage greed and acquisitiveness (which are admittedly
natural human traits, but that doesn't mean we have to indulge
them. After all, violence is also a natural human trait). So
property had to be redefined: it is absolute; it is permanent; it
is mine. It can even be abstract (copyrights, interest on
investments). It is this view of property - fairly recent,
historically - on which the wise-users base their claims.
Socialism, which comes in many shapes and sizes, was a
nineteenth-century backlash against this new gospel of greed.
So far, it hasn't worked very well (witness the late unlamented
USSR) but sometimes it does, in smaller places or smaller ways
(Cuba; the British national health care system; American Social
Security). In its more radical forms it has scarcely even been
tried yet. But Karl Marx, who can be thanked for many of the
changes in capitalism itself (they were a response to his
observations, enacted by governments who feared a socialist
revolution if they didn't do something) can also be thanked for
the fact that most of us now believe that, even if private
property is OK, we have a social obligation not to use our
property in ways that are harmful to the community. The wise
users don't agree - they are a minority, but a powerful one.
Click on the following link to learn more about Karl Marx.
· Karl Marx
The term "wise use" first appears in the Reagan era, when the
administration in Washington always supported the big
corporations against the "tree huggers." Essentially the wise-
users want us to believe, "hey, we're environmentalists too, we
just want to conserve natural resources for future generations."
In actuality it amounts to, "hey, we own these damn resources,
and we won't have any eco-radicals telling us how to use what
we own." Anyway, that's the view of most other
environmentalists. Go to the web site of the main wise-use
organization, the Center for the Defense of Free Enterprise,
(link at the bottom of page), and make your own judgment -
then talk about it in the forum this week. There's an old maxim
that is one of the first questions you learn in law school: cui
bono? that is, "who benefits?" Look at who funds organizations
like CDFE, and consider who benefits if they get their way.
Wise use, in all its manifestations, relies on one legal or
constitutional principle: the right to private property. True, this
is one of the foundations of Western civilization, and nearly all
ideologies - liberal or conservative - take it for granted.
(Anarchists and communists do not, nor do many non-Western
cultures.) The wise use movement appeals to patriotism to
support its case: the right to hold property is a basic American
freedom. (Note all the red, white and blue on these websites.)
The argument is this: if private property is truly private, then
the owner has a right to use (or abuse) it in any way s/he
pleases. If the government (or any institution) can interfere,
then the property is not truly "private," and the owner is not
truly "free." The movement strongly opposes the Endangered
Species Act, for example: if the government forbids me to cut
down a forest on my land because an endangered owl lives in
the trees, then I do not have the property rights or freedoms our
ancestors fought and died for.
You need to know two key terms: "eminent
domain" and "takings." The first is the government's power to
take private property for public use (provided that fair
compensation is paid), even if the owner is not willing to sell.
This is often how the state acquires land to build new highways,
for example. Eminent domain is universally accepted, and is
enshrined in the Fifth Amendment: ". . . nor shall private
property be taken for public use without just compensation."
Eminent domain derives from medieval English feudal law, and
no one seriously questions it. "Takings" is another matter
altogether, and the demand that American courts recognize
"takings" as a form of property rights is at the crux of the wise-
use agenda.
Everyone agrees that the government has a right to take some of
my property, in the form of taxes or real estate or whatever. But
does it have the right to take property that is only potential, that
I have not yet acquired? Consider this case: I own a factory, and
the government demands that I install "scrubbers" in my
smokestacks to eliminate air pollutants. I must of course pay for
the installation; this is all right constitutionally (just as the
government may demand that I get and pay for a license if I
want to drive a car). But what if the scrubbers reduce my
factory's efficiency and output, or require more expensive fuels
and upkeep, making it necessary that I raise the price of my
product? Then the government's requirement for scrubbers is
"takings" because it is taking away future profits, on products
not yet manufactured. The wise use movement insists that
"takings" are just as unconstitutional as seizing my property for
a highway and not paying me for it.
So far the courts have not accepted this argument. But what if
they do?
Here's another aspect to think about: The wise use movement is
heavily funded by corporations, especially those involved in
mining and lumbering. Much of the money they donate goes to
"educational materials" for teachers, often given away free. The
goal, of course, is to persuade young students (still
impressionable, and still formulating their world views) that
economic growth and multinational corporations are good for
the environment. Compare the message in "Truax" to the
message suggested by C. Montgomery Burns' friend "Blinky"
(right). "Truax" is a teaching tool for elementary schools
created by an organization of wood-flooring manufacturers. Be
sure to look at these two documents before posting to the forum
(one is the comic book given to kids; the other is the teacher's
guide).

More Related Content

Similar to Human beings (and many other animals) are territorial - the distin.docx

Social contract
Social contractSocial contract
Social contract
Frank Calberg
 
Writing Paper - Differentiated Writing Paper With Rubric
Writing Paper - Differentiated Writing Paper With RubricWriting Paper - Differentiated Writing Paper With Rubric
Writing Paper - Differentiated Writing Paper With Rubric
Nicole Heredia
 
Ana Research - For Linked In Slide Presentation(Without Footnotes)
Ana Research - For Linked In Slide Presentation(Without Footnotes)Ana Research - For Linked In Slide Presentation(Without Footnotes)
Ana Research - For Linked In Slide Presentation(Without Footnotes)
anapenteado
 
Document #1 History of the Economic Systems and TheoriesC
Document #1 History of the Economic Systems and TheoriesCDocument #1 History of the Economic Systems and TheoriesC
Document #1 History of the Economic Systems and TheoriesC
DustiBuckner14
 
Human rights
Human rightsHuman rights
Human rights
sharon monsale
 
The Economic Way of Thinking
The Economic Way of ThinkingThe Economic Way of Thinking
The Economic Way of Thinking
Kolmhofer Martin
 
Independence or interdependence-global_education_in_the_schools-nancy_pearcy-...
Independence or interdependence-global_education_in_the_schools-nancy_pearcy-...Independence or interdependence-global_education_in_the_schools-nancy_pearcy-...
Independence or interdependence-global_education_in_the_schools-nancy_pearcy-...
RareBooksnRecords
 
Decoupling the state and the third sector, rob macmillan
Decoupling the state and the third sector, rob macmillanDecoupling the state and the third sector, rob macmillan
Decoupling the state and the third sector, rob macmillan
Third Sector Research Centre
 
Human Rights (1) (1)
Human Rights (1) (1)Human Rights (1) (1)
Human Rights (1) (1)
Elina Ntalampira
 

Similar to Human beings (and many other animals) are territorial - the distin.docx (9)

Social contract
Social contractSocial contract
Social contract
 
Writing Paper - Differentiated Writing Paper With Rubric
Writing Paper - Differentiated Writing Paper With RubricWriting Paper - Differentiated Writing Paper With Rubric
Writing Paper - Differentiated Writing Paper With Rubric
 
Ana Research - For Linked In Slide Presentation(Without Footnotes)
Ana Research - For Linked In Slide Presentation(Without Footnotes)Ana Research - For Linked In Slide Presentation(Without Footnotes)
Ana Research - For Linked In Slide Presentation(Without Footnotes)
 
Document #1 History of the Economic Systems and TheoriesC
Document #1 History of the Economic Systems and TheoriesCDocument #1 History of the Economic Systems and TheoriesC
Document #1 History of the Economic Systems and TheoriesC
 
Human rights
Human rightsHuman rights
Human rights
 
The Economic Way of Thinking
The Economic Way of ThinkingThe Economic Way of Thinking
The Economic Way of Thinking
 
Independence or interdependence-global_education_in_the_schools-nancy_pearcy-...
Independence or interdependence-global_education_in_the_schools-nancy_pearcy-...Independence or interdependence-global_education_in_the_schools-nancy_pearcy-...
Independence or interdependence-global_education_in_the_schools-nancy_pearcy-...
 
Decoupling the state and the third sector, rob macmillan
Decoupling the state and the third sector, rob macmillanDecoupling the state and the third sector, rob macmillan
Decoupling the state and the third sector, rob macmillan
 
Human Rights (1) (1)
Human Rights (1) (1)Human Rights (1) (1)
Human Rights (1) (1)
 

More from wellesleyterresa

Hw059f6dbf-250a-4d74-8f5e-f28f14227edc.jpg__MACOSXHw._059.docx
Hw059f6dbf-250a-4d74-8f5e-f28f14227edc.jpg__MACOSXHw._059.docxHw059f6dbf-250a-4d74-8f5e-f28f14227edc.jpg__MACOSXHw._059.docx
Hw059f6dbf-250a-4d74-8f5e-f28f14227edc.jpg__MACOSXHw._059.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW in teams of 3 studentsAn oil remanufacturing company uses c.docx
HW in teams of 3 studentsAn oil remanufacturing company uses c.docxHW in teams of 3 studentsAn oil remanufacturing company uses c.docx
HW in teams of 3 studentsAn oil remanufacturing company uses c.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW 5.docxAssignment 5 – Currency riskYou may do this assig.docx
HW 5.docxAssignment 5 – Currency riskYou may do this assig.docxHW 5.docxAssignment 5 – Currency riskYou may do this assig.docx
HW 5.docxAssignment 5 – Currency riskYou may do this assig.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW#3 – Spring 20181. Giulia is traveling from Italy to China. .docx
HW#3 – Spring 20181. Giulia is traveling from Italy to China. .docxHW#3 – Spring 20181. Giulia is traveling from Italy to China. .docx
HW#3 – Spring 20181. Giulia is traveling from Italy to China. .docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW 2Due July 1 by 500 PM.docx
HW 2Due July 1 by 500 PM.docxHW 2Due July 1 by 500 PM.docx
HW 2Due July 1 by 500 PM.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW 4 Gung Ho Commentary DUE Thursday, April 20 at 505 PM on.docx
HW 4 Gung Ho Commentary DUE Thursday, April 20 at 505 PM on.docxHW 4 Gung Ho Commentary DUE Thursday, April 20 at 505 PM on.docx
HW 4 Gung Ho Commentary DUE Thursday, April 20 at 505 PM on.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW 5 Math 405. Due beginning of class – Monday, 10 Oct 2016.docx
HW 5 Math 405. Due beginning of class – Monday, 10 Oct 2016.docxHW 5 Math 405. Due beginning of class – Monday, 10 Oct 2016.docx
HW 5 Math 405. Due beginning of class – Monday, 10 Oct 2016.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW 5-RSAascii2str.mfunction str = ascii2str(ascii) .docx
HW 5-RSAascii2str.mfunction str = ascii2str(ascii)        .docxHW 5-RSAascii2str.mfunction str = ascii2str(ascii)        .docx
HW 5-RSAascii2str.mfunction str = ascii2str(ascii) .docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW 3 Project Control• Status meeting agenda – shows time, date .docx
HW 3 Project Control• Status meeting agenda – shows time, date .docxHW 3 Project Control• Status meeting agenda – shows time, date .docx
HW 3 Project Control• Status meeting agenda – shows time, date .docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW 1January 19 2017Due back Jan 26, in class.1. (T.docx
HW 1January 19 2017Due back Jan 26, in class.1. (T.docxHW 1January 19 2017Due back Jan 26, in class.1. (T.docx
HW 1January 19 2017Due back Jan 26, in class.1. (T.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
Hussam Malibari Heckman MAT 242 Spring 2017Assignment Chapte.docx
Hussam Malibari Heckman MAT 242 Spring 2017Assignment Chapte.docxHussam Malibari Heckman MAT 242 Spring 2017Assignment Chapte.docx
Hussam Malibari Heckman MAT 242 Spring 2017Assignment Chapte.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
hw1.docxCS 211 Homework #1Please complete the homework problem.docx
hw1.docxCS 211 Homework #1Please complete the homework problem.docxhw1.docxCS 211 Homework #1Please complete the homework problem.docx
hw1.docxCS 211 Homework #1Please complete the homework problem.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HUS 335 Interpersonal Helping SkillsCase Assessment FormatT.docx
HUS 335 Interpersonal Helping SkillsCase Assessment FormatT.docxHUS 335 Interpersonal Helping SkillsCase Assessment FormatT.docx
HUS 335 Interpersonal Helping SkillsCase Assessment FormatT.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW #1Tech Alert on IT & Strategy (Ch 3-5Ch 3 -5 IT Strategy opt.docx
HW #1Tech Alert on IT & Strategy (Ch 3-5Ch 3 -5 IT Strategy opt.docxHW #1Tech Alert on IT & Strategy (Ch 3-5Ch 3 -5 IT Strategy opt.docx
HW #1Tech Alert on IT & Strategy (Ch 3-5Ch 3 -5 IT Strategy opt.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW 2 (1) Visit Monsanto (httpwww.monsanto.com) again and Goog.docx
HW 2 (1) Visit Monsanto (httpwww.monsanto.com) again and Goog.docxHW 2 (1) Visit Monsanto (httpwww.monsanto.com) again and Goog.docx
HW 2 (1) Visit Monsanto (httpwww.monsanto.com) again and Goog.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
Hunters Son Dialogue Activity1. Please write 1-2 sentences for e.docx
Hunters Son Dialogue Activity1. Please write 1-2 sentences for e.docxHunters Son Dialogue Activity1. Please write 1-2 sentences for e.docx
Hunters Son Dialogue Activity1. Please write 1-2 sentences for e.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HW 2 - SQL The database you will use for this assignme.docx
HW 2 - SQL   The database you will use for this assignme.docxHW 2 - SQL   The database you will use for this assignme.docx
HW 2 - SQL The database you will use for this assignme.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
Humanities Commons Learning Goals1. Write about primary and seco.docx
Humanities Commons Learning Goals1. Write about primary and seco.docxHumanities Commons Learning Goals1. Write about primary and seco.docx
Humanities Commons Learning Goals1. Write about primary and seco.docx
wellesleyterresa
 
HURRICANE KATRINA A NATION STILL UNPREPARED .docx
HURRICANE KATRINA  A NATION STILL UNPREPARED   .docxHURRICANE KATRINA  A NATION STILL UNPREPARED   .docx
HURRICANE KATRINA A NATION STILL UNPREPARED .docx
wellesleyterresa
 
Humanities 115Short Essay Grading CriteriaExcellentPassing.docx
Humanities 115Short Essay Grading CriteriaExcellentPassing.docxHumanities 115Short Essay Grading CriteriaExcellentPassing.docx
Humanities 115Short Essay Grading CriteriaExcellentPassing.docx
wellesleyterresa
 

More from wellesleyterresa (20)

Hw059f6dbf-250a-4d74-8f5e-f28f14227edc.jpg__MACOSXHw._059.docx
Hw059f6dbf-250a-4d74-8f5e-f28f14227edc.jpg__MACOSXHw._059.docxHw059f6dbf-250a-4d74-8f5e-f28f14227edc.jpg__MACOSXHw._059.docx
Hw059f6dbf-250a-4d74-8f5e-f28f14227edc.jpg__MACOSXHw._059.docx
 
HW in teams of 3 studentsAn oil remanufacturing company uses c.docx
HW in teams of 3 studentsAn oil remanufacturing company uses c.docxHW in teams of 3 studentsAn oil remanufacturing company uses c.docx
HW in teams of 3 studentsAn oil remanufacturing company uses c.docx
 
HW 5.docxAssignment 5 – Currency riskYou may do this assig.docx
HW 5.docxAssignment 5 – Currency riskYou may do this assig.docxHW 5.docxAssignment 5 – Currency riskYou may do this assig.docx
HW 5.docxAssignment 5 – Currency riskYou may do this assig.docx
 
HW#3 – Spring 20181. Giulia is traveling from Italy to China. .docx
HW#3 – Spring 20181. Giulia is traveling from Italy to China. .docxHW#3 – Spring 20181. Giulia is traveling from Italy to China. .docx
HW#3 – Spring 20181. Giulia is traveling from Italy to China. .docx
 
HW 2Due July 1 by 500 PM.docx
HW 2Due July 1 by 500 PM.docxHW 2Due July 1 by 500 PM.docx
HW 2Due July 1 by 500 PM.docx
 
HW 4 Gung Ho Commentary DUE Thursday, April 20 at 505 PM on.docx
HW 4 Gung Ho Commentary DUE Thursday, April 20 at 505 PM on.docxHW 4 Gung Ho Commentary DUE Thursday, April 20 at 505 PM on.docx
HW 4 Gung Ho Commentary DUE Thursday, April 20 at 505 PM on.docx
 
HW 5 Math 405. Due beginning of class – Monday, 10 Oct 2016.docx
HW 5 Math 405. Due beginning of class – Monday, 10 Oct 2016.docxHW 5 Math 405. Due beginning of class – Monday, 10 Oct 2016.docx
HW 5 Math 405. Due beginning of class – Monday, 10 Oct 2016.docx
 
HW 5-RSAascii2str.mfunction str = ascii2str(ascii) .docx
HW 5-RSAascii2str.mfunction str = ascii2str(ascii)        .docxHW 5-RSAascii2str.mfunction str = ascii2str(ascii)        .docx
HW 5-RSAascii2str.mfunction str = ascii2str(ascii) .docx
 
HW 3 Project Control• Status meeting agenda – shows time, date .docx
HW 3 Project Control• Status meeting agenda – shows time, date .docxHW 3 Project Control• Status meeting agenda – shows time, date .docx
HW 3 Project Control• Status meeting agenda – shows time, date .docx
 
HW 1January 19 2017Due back Jan 26, in class.1. (T.docx
HW 1January 19 2017Due back Jan 26, in class.1. (T.docxHW 1January 19 2017Due back Jan 26, in class.1. (T.docx
HW 1January 19 2017Due back Jan 26, in class.1. (T.docx
 
Hussam Malibari Heckman MAT 242 Spring 2017Assignment Chapte.docx
Hussam Malibari Heckman MAT 242 Spring 2017Assignment Chapte.docxHussam Malibari Heckman MAT 242 Spring 2017Assignment Chapte.docx
Hussam Malibari Heckman MAT 242 Spring 2017Assignment Chapte.docx
 
hw1.docxCS 211 Homework #1Please complete the homework problem.docx
hw1.docxCS 211 Homework #1Please complete the homework problem.docxhw1.docxCS 211 Homework #1Please complete the homework problem.docx
hw1.docxCS 211 Homework #1Please complete the homework problem.docx
 
HUS 335 Interpersonal Helping SkillsCase Assessment FormatT.docx
HUS 335 Interpersonal Helping SkillsCase Assessment FormatT.docxHUS 335 Interpersonal Helping SkillsCase Assessment FormatT.docx
HUS 335 Interpersonal Helping SkillsCase Assessment FormatT.docx
 
HW #1Tech Alert on IT & Strategy (Ch 3-5Ch 3 -5 IT Strategy opt.docx
HW #1Tech Alert on IT & Strategy (Ch 3-5Ch 3 -5 IT Strategy opt.docxHW #1Tech Alert on IT & Strategy (Ch 3-5Ch 3 -5 IT Strategy opt.docx
HW #1Tech Alert on IT & Strategy (Ch 3-5Ch 3 -5 IT Strategy opt.docx
 
HW 2 (1) Visit Monsanto (httpwww.monsanto.com) again and Goog.docx
HW 2 (1) Visit Monsanto (httpwww.monsanto.com) again and Goog.docxHW 2 (1) Visit Monsanto (httpwww.monsanto.com) again and Goog.docx
HW 2 (1) Visit Monsanto (httpwww.monsanto.com) again and Goog.docx
 
Hunters Son Dialogue Activity1. Please write 1-2 sentences for e.docx
Hunters Son Dialogue Activity1. Please write 1-2 sentences for e.docxHunters Son Dialogue Activity1. Please write 1-2 sentences for e.docx
Hunters Son Dialogue Activity1. Please write 1-2 sentences for e.docx
 
HW 2 - SQL The database you will use for this assignme.docx
HW 2 - SQL   The database you will use for this assignme.docxHW 2 - SQL   The database you will use for this assignme.docx
HW 2 - SQL The database you will use for this assignme.docx
 
Humanities Commons Learning Goals1. Write about primary and seco.docx
Humanities Commons Learning Goals1. Write about primary and seco.docxHumanities Commons Learning Goals1. Write about primary and seco.docx
Humanities Commons Learning Goals1. Write about primary and seco.docx
 
HURRICANE KATRINA A NATION STILL UNPREPARED .docx
HURRICANE KATRINA  A NATION STILL UNPREPARED   .docxHURRICANE KATRINA  A NATION STILL UNPREPARED   .docx
HURRICANE KATRINA A NATION STILL UNPREPARED .docx
 
Humanities 115Short Essay Grading CriteriaExcellentPassing.docx
Humanities 115Short Essay Grading CriteriaExcellentPassing.docxHumanities 115Short Essay Grading CriteriaExcellentPassing.docx
Humanities 115Short Essay Grading CriteriaExcellentPassing.docx
 

Recently uploaded

A Survey of Techniques for Maximizing LLM Performance.pptx
A Survey of Techniques for Maximizing LLM Performance.pptxA Survey of Techniques for Maximizing LLM Performance.pptx
A Survey of Techniques for Maximizing LLM Performance.pptx
thanhdowork
 
Digital Artifact 1 - 10VCD Environments Unit
Digital Artifact 1 - 10VCD Environments UnitDigital Artifact 1 - 10VCD Environments Unit
Digital Artifact 1 - 10VCD Environments Unit
chanes7
 
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp NetworkIntroduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
TechSoup
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
Nguyen Thanh Tu Collection
 
বাংলাদেশ অর্থনৈতিক সমীক্ষা (Economic Review) ২০২৪ UJS App.pdf
বাংলাদেশ অর্থনৈতিক সমীক্ষা (Economic Review) ২০২৪ UJS App.pdfবাংলাদেশ অর্থনৈতিক সমীক্ষা (Economic Review) ২০২৪ UJS App.pdf
বাংলাদেশ অর্থনৈতিক সমীক্ষা (Economic Review) ২০২৪ UJS App.pdf
eBook.com.bd (প্রয়োজনীয় বাংলা বই)
 
Top five deadliest dog breeds in America
Top five deadliest dog breeds in AmericaTop five deadliest dog breeds in America
Top five deadliest dog breeds in America
Bisnar Chase Personal Injury Attorneys
 
Film vocab for eal 3 students: Australia the movie
Film vocab for eal 3 students: Australia the movieFilm vocab for eal 3 students: Australia the movie
Film vocab for eal 3 students: Australia the movie
Nicholas Montgomery
 
Assessment and Planning in Educational technology.pptx
Assessment and Planning in Educational technology.pptxAssessment and Planning in Educational technology.pptx
Assessment and Planning in Educational technology.pptx
Kavitha Krishnan
 
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP ModuleHow to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
Celine George
 
clinical examination of hip joint (1).pdf
clinical examination of hip joint (1).pdfclinical examination of hip joint (1).pdf
clinical examination of hip joint (1).pdf
Priyankaranawat4
 
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdfLiberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
WaniBasim
 
Azure Interview Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Azure Interview Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHatAzure Interview Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Azure Interview Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Scholarhat
 
Hindi varnamala | hindi alphabet PPT.pdf
Hindi varnamala | hindi alphabet PPT.pdfHindi varnamala | hindi alphabet PPT.pdf
Hindi varnamala | hindi alphabet PPT.pdf
Dr. Mulla Adam Ali
 
Executive Directors Chat Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Executive Directors Chat  Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and InclusionExecutive Directors Chat  Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Executive Directors Chat Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
TechSoup
 
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
Celine George
 
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective UpskillingYour Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Excellence Foundation for South Sudan
 
CACJapan - GROUP Presentation 1- Wk 4.pdf
CACJapan - GROUP Presentation 1- Wk 4.pdfCACJapan - GROUP Presentation 1- Wk 4.pdf
CACJapan - GROUP Presentation 1- Wk 4.pdf
camakaiclarkmusic
 
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docxAdvanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
adhitya5119
 
The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...
The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...
The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...
RitikBhardwaj56
 
World environment day ppt For 5 June 2024
World environment day ppt For 5 June 2024World environment day ppt For 5 June 2024
World environment day ppt For 5 June 2024
ak6969907
 

Recently uploaded (20)

A Survey of Techniques for Maximizing LLM Performance.pptx
A Survey of Techniques for Maximizing LLM Performance.pptxA Survey of Techniques for Maximizing LLM Performance.pptx
A Survey of Techniques for Maximizing LLM Performance.pptx
 
Digital Artifact 1 - 10VCD Environments Unit
Digital Artifact 1 - 10VCD Environments UnitDigital Artifact 1 - 10VCD Environments Unit
Digital Artifact 1 - 10VCD Environments Unit
 
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp NetworkIntroduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
Introduction to AI for Nonprofits with Tapp Network
 
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
BÀI TẬP BỔ TRỢ TIẾNG ANH 8 CẢ NĂM - GLOBAL SUCCESS - NĂM HỌC 2023-2024 (CÓ FI...
 
বাংলাদেশ অর্থনৈতিক সমীক্ষা (Economic Review) ২০২৪ UJS App.pdf
বাংলাদেশ অর্থনৈতিক সমীক্ষা (Economic Review) ২০২৪ UJS App.pdfবাংলাদেশ অর্থনৈতিক সমীক্ষা (Economic Review) ২০২৪ UJS App.pdf
বাংলাদেশ অর্থনৈতিক সমীক্ষা (Economic Review) ২০২৪ UJS App.pdf
 
Top five deadliest dog breeds in America
Top five deadliest dog breeds in AmericaTop five deadliest dog breeds in America
Top five deadliest dog breeds in America
 
Film vocab for eal 3 students: Australia the movie
Film vocab for eal 3 students: Australia the movieFilm vocab for eal 3 students: Australia the movie
Film vocab for eal 3 students: Australia the movie
 
Assessment and Planning in Educational technology.pptx
Assessment and Planning in Educational technology.pptxAssessment and Planning in Educational technology.pptx
Assessment and Planning in Educational technology.pptx
 
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP ModuleHow to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
How to Add Chatter in the odoo 17 ERP Module
 
clinical examination of hip joint (1).pdf
clinical examination of hip joint (1).pdfclinical examination of hip joint (1).pdf
clinical examination of hip joint (1).pdf
 
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdfLiberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
Liberal Approach to the Study of Indian Politics.pdf
 
Azure Interview Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Azure Interview Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHatAzure Interview Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
Azure Interview Questions and Answers PDF By ScholarHat
 
Hindi varnamala | hindi alphabet PPT.pdf
Hindi varnamala | hindi alphabet PPT.pdfHindi varnamala | hindi alphabet PPT.pdf
Hindi varnamala | hindi alphabet PPT.pdf
 
Executive Directors Chat Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Executive Directors Chat  Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and InclusionExecutive Directors Chat  Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
Executive Directors Chat Leveraging AI for Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion
 
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17
 
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective UpskillingYour Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
Your Skill Boost Masterclass: Strategies for Effective Upskilling
 
CACJapan - GROUP Presentation 1- Wk 4.pdf
CACJapan - GROUP Presentation 1- Wk 4.pdfCACJapan - GROUP Presentation 1- Wk 4.pdf
CACJapan - GROUP Presentation 1- Wk 4.pdf
 
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docxAdvanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
Advanced Java[Extra Concepts, Not Difficult].docx
 
The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...
The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...
The simplified electron and muon model, Oscillating Spacetime: The Foundation...
 
World environment day ppt For 5 June 2024
World environment day ppt For 5 June 2024World environment day ppt For 5 June 2024
World environment day ppt For 5 June 2024
 

Human beings (and many other animals) are territorial - the distin.docx

  • 1. Human beings (and many other animals) are territorial - the distinction between "mine" and "yours" is not learned or cultural; it is deeply rooted in our animal instincts. This is what makes the argument from property rights so powerful. Supporters of Capitalism (wise-users among them) believe that all property should be "mine," whereas Socialism (including most environmentalists, in some form or other) think that most property should be "ours." This is a very old and fundamental debate; "Capitalism" and "Socialism" are merely the newest names for the two sides. Modern socialists and anarchists usually agree that "I" am entitled to enough private property for my own personal use (no one wants to share a toothbrush!) but that all excess property should belong to the community (why do I need two houses? for example). And the property I personally need is very little indeed. Any more than that, and I am usurping what others could use: I am getting rich at someone else's expense; I am creating two classes of society, the "haves" and the "have nots." To get to the point: opponents of wise use believe that it is wrong for me to abuse, pollute, destroy or otherwise damage property that should benefit everyone. I can trash my own house, if I like; that's my business; but when I trash the larger environment, that's everyone's business, even if the property laws say that environment is "mine." The "wise use" position is that "mine" is mine, no limits, no restrictions. When modern capitalism evolved in the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries, it worked only because new laws defined "property" in new and inventive ways so that the capitalists could be certain of keeping the profits they made in the free market. No entrepreneur would want to start a new business if he could not be certain that it, and any profit it made, were really his. (At least, that was what the capitalists and their partners in the newly centralized governments said.) In earlier ages, philosophers believed that property is temporary; that it is
  • 2. ours only so long as we actually use it (this is called "usufruct" in feudal law). After all, we come into the world with nothing, and we leave it with nothing, so property cannot be "ours" in any permanent sense. Medieval cities and kingdoms actually had laws against charging interest on loans or charging more for a loaf of bread than the poor could afford - because economic wealth was seen as belonging to the community, not to the individual. In fact, the entire Judeao-Christian-Muslim belief system preaches against the use of interest. They call it usury, and it is generally agreed to be greedy and potentially evil. Unfortunately, in the modern era, the Christians (and almost everyone else) seem to have abandoned this law. The Jewish and Islamic communities still adhere to it in varying degrees: the Islamic much more so. These notions of community and mutual benefit changed when the new market economy began to encourage greed and acquisitiveness (which are admittedly natural human traits, but that doesn't mean we have to indulge them. After all, violence is also a natural human trait). So property had to be redefined: it is absolute; it is permanent; it is mine. It can even be abstract (copyrights, interest on investments). It is this view of property - fairly recent, historically - on which the wise-users base their claims. Socialism, which comes in many shapes and sizes, was a nineteenth-century backlash against this new gospel of greed. So far, it hasn't worked very well (witness the late unlamented USSR) but sometimes it does, in smaller places or smaller ways (Cuba; the British national health care system; American Social Security). In its more radical forms it has scarcely even been tried yet. But Karl Marx, who can be thanked for many of the changes in capitalism itself (they were a response to his observations, enacted by governments who feared a socialist revolution if they didn't do something) can also be thanked for the fact that most of us now believe that, even if private property is OK, we have a social obligation not to use our property in ways that are harmful to the community. The wise users don't agree - they are a minority, but a powerful one.
  • 3. Click on the following link to learn more about Karl Marx. · Karl Marx The term "wise use" first appears in the Reagan era, when the administration in Washington always supported the big corporations against the "tree huggers." Essentially the wise- users want us to believe, "hey, we're environmentalists too, we just want to conserve natural resources for future generations." In actuality it amounts to, "hey, we own these damn resources, and we won't have any eco-radicals telling us how to use what we own." Anyway, that's the view of most other environmentalists. Go to the web site of the main wise-use organization, the Center for the Defense of Free Enterprise, (link at the bottom of page), and make your own judgment - then talk about it in the forum this week. There's an old maxim that is one of the first questions you learn in law school: cui bono? that is, "who benefits?" Look at who funds organizations like CDFE, and consider who benefits if they get their way. Wise use, in all its manifestations, relies on one legal or constitutional principle: the right to private property. True, this is one of the foundations of Western civilization, and nearly all ideologies - liberal or conservative - take it for granted. (Anarchists and communists do not, nor do many non-Western cultures.) The wise use movement appeals to patriotism to support its case: the right to hold property is a basic American freedom. (Note all the red, white and blue on these websites.) The argument is this: if private property is truly private, then the owner has a right to use (or abuse) it in any way s/he pleases. If the government (or any institution) can interfere, then the property is not truly "private," and the owner is not truly "free." The movement strongly opposes the Endangered Species Act, for example: if the government forbids me to cut down a forest on my land because an endangered owl lives in the trees, then I do not have the property rights or freedoms our ancestors fought and died for. You need to know two key terms: "eminent
  • 4. domain" and "takings." The first is the government's power to take private property for public use (provided that fair compensation is paid), even if the owner is not willing to sell. This is often how the state acquires land to build new highways, for example. Eminent domain is universally accepted, and is enshrined in the Fifth Amendment: ". . . nor shall private property be taken for public use without just compensation." Eminent domain derives from medieval English feudal law, and no one seriously questions it. "Takings" is another matter altogether, and the demand that American courts recognize "takings" as a form of property rights is at the crux of the wise- use agenda. Everyone agrees that the government has a right to take some of my property, in the form of taxes or real estate or whatever. But does it have the right to take property that is only potential, that I have not yet acquired? Consider this case: I own a factory, and the government demands that I install "scrubbers" in my smokestacks to eliminate air pollutants. I must of course pay for the installation; this is all right constitutionally (just as the government may demand that I get and pay for a license if I want to drive a car). But what if the scrubbers reduce my factory's efficiency and output, or require more expensive fuels and upkeep, making it necessary that I raise the price of my product? Then the government's requirement for scrubbers is "takings" because it is taking away future profits, on products not yet manufactured. The wise use movement insists that "takings" are just as unconstitutional as seizing my property for a highway and not paying me for it. So far the courts have not accepted this argument. But what if they do? Here's another aspect to think about: The wise use movement is heavily funded by corporations, especially those involved in mining and lumbering. Much of the money they donate goes to "educational materials" for teachers, often given away free. The goal, of course, is to persuade young students (still impressionable, and still formulating their world views) that
  • 5. economic growth and multinational corporations are good for the environment. Compare the message in "Truax" to the message suggested by C. Montgomery Burns' friend "Blinky" (right). "Truax" is a teaching tool for elementary schools created by an organization of wood-flooring manufacturers. Be sure to look at these two documents before posting to the forum (one is the comic book given to kids; the other is the teacher's guide).