We have observed for at least a few years now that about 80% of S&P 500 stock market valuation is driven by factors that are not accurately captured and valued on financial statements – like people (human capital), natural resources (ecological capital) and trust (social capital). In a breakthrough new research project, HIP Investor shows how sustainability considerations can lower risk and enhance potential financial returns for investment portfolios, all while creating net benefit for society. Join Paul Herman as he reveals how sustainability-driven investment portfolios can outperform Wall Street, and what the implications of that may be for Modern Portfolio Theory.
15. 15
MIT Sloan Review and BCG:
New Metrics Drive Shareholder Value
A study by Boston Consulting Group and MIT Sloan Management Review discusses how sustainability is
changing the competitive landscape and reshaping the opportunities and threats that companies face.
32. Health
Wealth
Earth
Equality
Trust
…and Connect Directly to
Cash Flow, Profit and Shareholder Value
Products
& Services
Operating
Metrics
Mgmt
Practices
I
M
P
A
C
T
“How HIP Is This Investment?”
HIP = Human Impact + Profit
Strategic
Innovation &
Risk
Mitigation
Higher
Revenue
potential
Lower
Cost
potential
However, it was through an experience in my own family foundation that I became aware of another risk – the risk of unsustainable businesses lurking in my endowment portfolio. One of the charitable missions of our foundation is rural economic development through low carbon solutions, When I found we were invested in coal stocks through a manager that had an increasing-dividend strategy, I was more than dismayed, having been a vocal critic of a utility with carbon-heavy power production. Fortunately, my traditional merrill Lynch account manager was willing to look at substitutions which fit their profiles and which were rated more sustainable by Paul Herman’s HIP analysis. Coal stocks since Aug 2011 have been under pressure, especially now with China needed to reduce their reliance on coal because their population literally can not breathe. A sustainable lens I believe added to a better financial decision.
Measure and assess risk factors beyond traditional financial risk factors, which are historical.
HIP weight vs. Market cap weight and underweight fossil producing companies as part of 5 year plan to sell fossil companies
HIP investor Ratings:The 21st Century GPS for Your Portfolio
16
Credit Suisse analyzed more than 2,500 companies and found that companies with more than one woman on the board have outperformed those with no women on the board by 26 percent since 2005.
Companies with at least one woman on the board over the past six years show better average growth, with an average of 14 percent over the past six years compared to 10 percent for those with no female board representation. They also have a 4 percent higher return on equity, according to the research.
“Most of that performance comes from the post-credit crisis period: introducing women to the board gives better decision making and better vigilance in terms of what’s going on the in company," .
In other words, stocks with greater gender diversity on their boards generally look defensive: they tend to perform best when markets are falling, deliver higher average ROEs through the cycle, exhibit less volatility in earnings and typically have lower gearing ratios.
Although the proportion of women at board level generally remains very low, it is changing. On our numbers, only 41 percent of MSCI ACWI stocks had any women on the board at the end of 2005, but this had increased to 59 percent by the end of 2011.
Source: https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:4ad0j-WDCxwJ:https://infocus.credit-suisse.com/data/_product_documents/_articles/360157/cs_women_in_leading_positions_FINAL.PDF+&hl=en&gl=us&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEEShAQs7Fy1jP-S3HU7ctAKKJXiUelVYXLHh3x_rg6k0_MKDTmTU8zUW_OkvXOVPWcWnB4WFGXUJ6HN3jzcvk24f0aknhoLYZkNsigKVfqsj2PaoaYUVjsGqm9I3wCKgg9LsovIjA&sig=AHIEtbSg4DlRUgDUYW8qDlE6dIirprPI3Q
Credit Suisse analyzed more than 2,500 companies and found that companies with more than one woman on the board have outperformed those with no women on the board by 26 percent since 2005.
Companies with at least one woman on the board over the past six years show better average growth, with an average of 14 percent over the past six years compared to 10 percent for those with no female board representation. They also have a 4 percent higher return on equity, according to the research.
“Most of that performance comes from the post-credit crisis period: introducing women to the board gives better decision making and better vigilance in terms of what’s going on the in company," .
In other words, stocks with greater gender diversity on their boards generally look defensive: they tend to perform best when markets are falling, deliver higher average ROEs through the cycle, exhibit less volatility in earnings and typically have lower gearing ratios.
Although the proportion of women at board level generally remains very low, it is changing. On our numbers, only 41 percent of MSCI ACWI stocks had any women on the board at the end of 2005, but this had increased to 59 percent by the end of 2011.
Source: https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&q=cache:4ad0j-WDCxwJ:https://infocus.credit-suisse.com/data/_product_documents/_articles/360157/cs_women_in_leading_positions_FINAL.PDF+&hl=en&gl=us&pid=bl&srcid=ADGEEShAQs7Fy1jP-S3HU7ctAKKJXiUelVYXLHh3x_rg6k0_MKDTmTU8zUW_OkvXOVPWcWnB4WFGXUJ6HN3jzcvk24f0aknhoLYZkNsigKVfqsj2PaoaYUVjsGqm9I3wCKgg9LsovIjA&sig=AHIEtbSg4DlRUgDUYW8qDlE6dIirprPI3Q
Looking beyond a fossil-free portfolio to a carbon efficient portfolio – companies using fossil resources innovatively and efficiently – I encourage you to compare the S&P U.S. Carbon Efficient Index against the S&P 500. The Carbon Efficient Index is listed as SPGRCUUT in Google Finance, and at its 3 year track record and has cumulatively outperformed the S&P 500 by 12 percent.
Study by Carbon Disclosure Project says carbon efficient firms can beat market. This is only an index, not investable yet
HIP investor Ratings:The 21st Century GPS for Your Portfolio
1952 was a memorable year: Cadillac roadster….
…singing in the rain; and High Noon;
… and the invention of Modern Portfolio Theory
To get to your destination in years past, the state of the art was the paper-based TripTik
But you wouldn’t use 1952 or 1990s technology today to drive forward to your destination,
You would use a tech-enabled, dynamic, interactive tool like Google Maps
HIP can be applied across all asset classes
Over the past year, while the S&P 500 has risen over 20 percent, the Blackrock Global Energy Sector ETF declined 8 percent and the Coal Sector ETF declined 27 percent.
Measure and assess risk factors beyond traditional financial risk factors, which are historical.
HIP weight vs. Market cap weight and underweight fossil producing companies as part of 5 year plan to sell fossil companies
HIP investor Ratings:The 21st Century GPS for Your Portfolio
And describe the team – including previous exits (2 Acq’s – Paul’s venture and Keith’s venture)
HIP investor Ratings:The 21st Century GPS for Your Portfolio