This study aims to analyze how the designated hitter (DH) rule in Major League Baseball influences optimal player salary allocation for general managers (GMs). The DH rule, which only applies in the American League (AL), allows teams to replace the pitcher with a hitter in the batting lineup. This creates a framework where AL teams should spend a higher proportion of their salary on hitters rather than pitchers compared to National League (NL) teams. The study hypothesizes that AL small market teams that do not follow this framework by spending less on hitters will have improperly constructed teams and lower winning percentages. It also hypothesizes the proportion of salary spent on hitters will have a larger impact on winning percentage in the AL than the
My books- Hacking Digital Learning Strategies http://hackingdls.com & Learning to Go https://gum.co/learn2go
Resources at http://shellyterrell.com/emoji
My books- Hacking Digital Learning Strategies http://hackingdls.com & Learning to Go https://gum.co/learn2go
Resources at http://shellyterrell.com/emoji
Analyzing the Effects of Revenue Sharing on Competitive Balance in Major Leag...elevitt
This paper uses multiple regression models to conclude that revenue-sharing should promote competitive balance, but is hindered by the free agent-draft pick
compensation system and the stadium-building boom.
The focal point of this paper is an attempt to examine the relationship between the percentage-based contractual salaries (log(salary)) [hereto referred throughout as “LSalary”] of qualifying 2013 Major League Baseball players and the following statistics: age, age squared, games, home-runs, slugs, hits, at bats, and on base percentage. As there are many factors that are contributory towards LSalary, those players who are designated as pitchers have been omitted from the data set as they have dissimilar qualities that obscure the intended data set.
With this restricted data set, the sample consists of four hundred forty seven observations across thirty teams within the 2013 season. Utilizing the aforementioned restricted data collection, we have regressed LSalary, age, age squared, games, home-runs, slugs, hits, at bats, on base percentage, strikeouts, times caught stolen, stolen bases and runs. The empirical results suggest that age, age squared, games, home-runs, slugs, hits, at bats, and on base percentage are arguably significant drivers in determining a player’s LSalary.
Revenue Sharing Is Making An ImpactCommon fund is spreading MLBs .docxjoellemurphey
Revenue Sharing Is Making An ImpactCommon fund is spreading MLB's money around
By Maury Brown
March 2, 2010
E-mailPrint
Each year as spring training starts, writers trot out their thread-worn, "hope springs eternal" stories. As the 2010 season approaches, technically every team is on even footing. The Royals or Pirates or Padres have just as many wins and losses as the Yankees or Red Sox or Phillies.
And while that cliché remains true, many fans focus on the word "hope," or the lack of it. After the Yankees signed free agents C.C. Sabathia, Mark Teixeira and A.J. Burnett to the tune of $423.5 million in multi-year contracts before last season, the franchise won its 27th World Series after missing the playoffs entirely the year before.
Aside from the fact that the Yankees actually lowered payroll in 2009 from the year prior, and they hadn't won a World Series since 2000, fans and executives alike carped that they "bought the World Series," and odds are good those calls won't abate any time soon.
The battle of competitive balance in baseball is the game's new holy war. From the barstool to the water cooler, the battle continues to rage. On one side sits the low- to mid-market fan who calls for a salary cap and increased revenue sharing. On the other side are the big-market clubs, headlined by the Yankees and Red Sox, calling for a salary floor, or something in the next labor agreement that forces clubs to spend the revenue-sharing dollars that the big clubs feed them year-in and year-out.
Complicating the argument is that most fans have only a rudimentary understanding of how revenue-sharing even works, and they don't see that baseball does have a salary cap, of sorts. While management and union leaders debate the fine points of both revenue sharing and the luxury tax, fans have a more basic question: Do they promote competitive balance? The answer seems to be yes, and no. You need to spend to go to the postseason with regularity, but if the true barometer for baseball is winning the World Series, then being hot at the right time can get you to the promised land, regardless of where your payroll sits.
Eight different clubs won the 10 World Series in the 2000s, which is the most of any major North American professional sport. In that same period, the NBA saw five different champions, the NFL and NHL saw seven, though the NHL did not have a season in 2004-05. Eight different clubs have won the last nine World Series, dating back to the 2001 Fall Classic, and the Yankees (2000-01) and Phillies (2008-09) are the only clubs in the last decade to go to the World Series in consecutive years. No club has won back-to-back titles.
In that same time period, MLB can boast that 23 of its teams have reached the playoffs. Only the Expos/Nationals, Royals, Pirates, Orioles, Blue Jays, Rangers and Reds missed out. If you tie team payroll ranking to the equation, looking at who is making the postseason and how often, you see that clubs at the low end of ...
1. After watching the attached video by Dan Pink on .docxjeremylockett77
1. After watching the attached video by Dan Pink on the inherent weaknesses of extrinsic motivators, present two salient applications to your role as a leader in athletics. Dan Pink: The puzzle of motivation Ted.com
2. One of the very real truisms about leadership is that it can be lonely at the top and quite stressful. Please describe two specific ways you as a leader manage stress in your life.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Annala, C. N., & Winfree, J. (2011). Salary distribution and team performance in Major League Baseball. Sport Management Review, 14(2), 167-175.
Breunig, R., Garrett-Rumba, B., Jardin, M., & Rocaboy, Y. (2014). Wage dispersion and team performance: a theoretical model and evidence from baseball. Applied Economics, 46(3), 271-281.
Devi R. (2016). Data.world. Baseball Stats. Retrieved September 25, 2019 from https://data.world/deviramanan2016/baseball-stats
Lee, S., & Harris, J. (2012). Managing excellence in USA Major League Soccer: an analysis of the relationship between player performance and salary. Managing Leisure, 17(2-3), 106- 123.
Scully, G. W. (1974). Pay and performance in major league baseball. The American Economic Review, 64(6), 915-930.
Sommers, P. M., & Quinton, N. (1982). Pay and performance in major league baseball: The case of the first family of free agents. The Journal of Human Resources, 17(3), 426-436.
Tao, Y. L., Chuang, H. L., & Lin, E. S. (2016). Compensation and performance in Major League Baseball: Evidence from salary dispersion and team performance. International Review of Economics & Finance, 43, 151-159.
Wiseman, F., & Chatterjee, S. (2003). Team payroll and team performance in major league baseball: 1985–2002. Economics Bulletin, 1(2), 1-10.
Running Head: PAY AND PERFORMANCE IN MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL 1
PAY AND PERFORMANCE IN MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL 5
PAY AND PERFORMANCE IN MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL
RODERICK HOOKS
9-16-2019
Purpose statement and model
This study will try to examine whether there is a relationship between the payment and performance of a team. Performance is the dependent variable measured by wins of a team in the 2010 Major League Baseball (Tao Y. et al, 2016). This is the suitable dependent variable since the wins for a team can be influenced by many factors and the final results are the main target of every team (Scully G., 1974). The primary independent variable is payroll which the totals pay of the team (Wiseman F. & Chatterjee S., 2003). This is suitable in determining whether there is relationship between pay and performance due to the fact that a higher anticipates higher performance since many challenges for the team can be solved by financial stability (Sommers P. & Quinton N., 1982).
The general form of the model will be;
Wins = b0 + b1Payroll + b2Attendance + Error (
Definitions of variables
The variables used in this study are wins, payroll and attendance. Win is the dependent variable measuring the number of games the team wins. I ...
Have you ever wondered how college football teams were ranked amongst each other? A lot of people get angry over the ranking systems, but here are some methods used for ranking the teams!
Netherlands vs Austria Netherlands Face Familiar Foes in Euro Cup Germany Gro...Eticketing.co
The Netherlands are in Group D in Euro Cup Germany - and, unpaid to this, they will be coming up against familiar foes. Remarkably, they have played France, who have fashioned some of the greatest players of all time, 30 times throughout history. Despite France being more effective in major competitions, including captivating the World Cup in 2018, Holland have the greater head-to-head record.
We offer Euro Cup Tickets to admirers who can get Netherlands vs Austria Tickets through our trusted online ticketing marketplace. Eticketing.co is the most reliable source for booking Euro Cup Final Tickets. Sign up for the latest Euro Cup Germany Ticket alert.
UEFA Euro 2024 Tickets | Euro 2024 Tickets | Netherlands vs Austria Tickets
However, in 2023, they played one another twice, with France endearing both matches 4-0 and 2-1 individually. Against Poland and Austria, the Netherlands also have a stout record, winning just under half the matches. They faced Austria at Euro 2020, engaging 2-0, and they haven't lost to Poland since 1979.
The lettering is on the wall for Holland to qualify for the knockouts, but nothing is failsafe. The Netherlands kickstart their Euros campaign against Poland on Sunday, June 16th. In Hamburg, they will have to go up against one of the best strikers in the world, Robert Lewandowski.
Netherlands vs Austria: Tough Challenges Await the Netherlands in Euro Cup Germany
Five days later, they travel south to face France in Leipzig, a side led by Kylian Mbappe - one of the finest players in the world currently and one of the most impressive players in his nation's history. To conclude, they face Austria in Berlin, knowing it could be the end of the road if they don't perform.
Ronald Koeman is widely considered one of the more successful Dutch managers in Premier League history, considering the nation has a reputation for struggling to replicate their talents in England. The former Everton manager went against that script and shone — and now he is back managing his nation.
UEFA Euro 2024 Tickets | Euro 2024 Tickets | Euro Cup Germany Tickets | Netherlands vs Austria Tickets
Euro fans worldwide can book Euro Cup Germany Tickets from our online platform, www.eticketing.co. Fans can book Euro Cup 2024 Tickets on our website at discounted prices.
Netherlands vs Austria: Ronald Koeman's Tactical Approach For UEFA Euro 2024
As well as being the highest-scoring defender in history, Koeman is a man with immense tactical knowledge. He returned to manage Holland at the start of 2023 after it was announced Louis van Gaal would retire. His life back in the dugout with the team wasn't easy, as he lost his first match 4-0 to France after going 3-0 down within 21 minutes.
However, he eventually helped them qualify for Euro Cup Germany. The 61-year-old likes to organize his team with a defensive mindset. Some might call it pragmatic as he defends with minimal space between the lines, but that's often needed for international football.
Croatia vs Italy Can Luka Modrić Lead Croatia to Euro Cup Germany Glory in Hi...Eticketing.co
Euro 2024 fans worldwide can book Croatia vs Italy Tickets from our online platform www.eticketing.co. Fans can book Euro Cup Germany Tickets on our website at discounted prices.
More Related Content
Similar to Hitters vs. Pitchers: The Anomaly of the DH Rule in the MLB
Analyzing the Effects of Revenue Sharing on Competitive Balance in Major Leag...elevitt
This paper uses multiple regression models to conclude that revenue-sharing should promote competitive balance, but is hindered by the free agent-draft pick
compensation system and the stadium-building boom.
The focal point of this paper is an attempt to examine the relationship between the percentage-based contractual salaries (log(salary)) [hereto referred throughout as “LSalary”] of qualifying 2013 Major League Baseball players and the following statistics: age, age squared, games, home-runs, slugs, hits, at bats, and on base percentage. As there are many factors that are contributory towards LSalary, those players who are designated as pitchers have been omitted from the data set as they have dissimilar qualities that obscure the intended data set.
With this restricted data set, the sample consists of four hundred forty seven observations across thirty teams within the 2013 season. Utilizing the aforementioned restricted data collection, we have regressed LSalary, age, age squared, games, home-runs, slugs, hits, at bats, on base percentage, strikeouts, times caught stolen, stolen bases and runs. The empirical results suggest that age, age squared, games, home-runs, slugs, hits, at bats, and on base percentage are arguably significant drivers in determining a player’s LSalary.
Revenue Sharing Is Making An ImpactCommon fund is spreading MLBs .docxjoellemurphey
Revenue Sharing Is Making An ImpactCommon fund is spreading MLB's money around
By Maury Brown
March 2, 2010
E-mailPrint
Each year as spring training starts, writers trot out their thread-worn, "hope springs eternal" stories. As the 2010 season approaches, technically every team is on even footing. The Royals or Pirates or Padres have just as many wins and losses as the Yankees or Red Sox or Phillies.
And while that cliché remains true, many fans focus on the word "hope," or the lack of it. After the Yankees signed free agents C.C. Sabathia, Mark Teixeira and A.J. Burnett to the tune of $423.5 million in multi-year contracts before last season, the franchise won its 27th World Series after missing the playoffs entirely the year before.
Aside from the fact that the Yankees actually lowered payroll in 2009 from the year prior, and they hadn't won a World Series since 2000, fans and executives alike carped that they "bought the World Series," and odds are good those calls won't abate any time soon.
The battle of competitive balance in baseball is the game's new holy war. From the barstool to the water cooler, the battle continues to rage. On one side sits the low- to mid-market fan who calls for a salary cap and increased revenue sharing. On the other side are the big-market clubs, headlined by the Yankees and Red Sox, calling for a salary floor, or something in the next labor agreement that forces clubs to spend the revenue-sharing dollars that the big clubs feed them year-in and year-out.
Complicating the argument is that most fans have only a rudimentary understanding of how revenue-sharing even works, and they don't see that baseball does have a salary cap, of sorts. While management and union leaders debate the fine points of both revenue sharing and the luxury tax, fans have a more basic question: Do they promote competitive balance? The answer seems to be yes, and no. You need to spend to go to the postseason with regularity, but if the true barometer for baseball is winning the World Series, then being hot at the right time can get you to the promised land, regardless of where your payroll sits.
Eight different clubs won the 10 World Series in the 2000s, which is the most of any major North American professional sport. In that same period, the NBA saw five different champions, the NFL and NHL saw seven, though the NHL did not have a season in 2004-05. Eight different clubs have won the last nine World Series, dating back to the 2001 Fall Classic, and the Yankees (2000-01) and Phillies (2008-09) are the only clubs in the last decade to go to the World Series in consecutive years. No club has won back-to-back titles.
In that same time period, MLB can boast that 23 of its teams have reached the playoffs. Only the Expos/Nationals, Royals, Pirates, Orioles, Blue Jays, Rangers and Reds missed out. If you tie team payroll ranking to the equation, looking at who is making the postseason and how often, you see that clubs at the low end of ...
1. After watching the attached video by Dan Pink on .docxjeremylockett77
1. After watching the attached video by Dan Pink on the inherent weaknesses of extrinsic motivators, present two salient applications to your role as a leader in athletics. Dan Pink: The puzzle of motivation Ted.com
2. One of the very real truisms about leadership is that it can be lonely at the top and quite stressful. Please describe two specific ways you as a leader manage stress in your life.
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Annala, C. N., & Winfree, J. (2011). Salary distribution and team performance in Major League Baseball. Sport Management Review, 14(2), 167-175.
Breunig, R., Garrett-Rumba, B., Jardin, M., & Rocaboy, Y. (2014). Wage dispersion and team performance: a theoretical model and evidence from baseball. Applied Economics, 46(3), 271-281.
Devi R. (2016). Data.world. Baseball Stats. Retrieved September 25, 2019 from https://data.world/deviramanan2016/baseball-stats
Lee, S., & Harris, J. (2012). Managing excellence in USA Major League Soccer: an analysis of the relationship between player performance and salary. Managing Leisure, 17(2-3), 106- 123.
Scully, G. W. (1974). Pay and performance in major league baseball. The American Economic Review, 64(6), 915-930.
Sommers, P. M., & Quinton, N. (1982). Pay and performance in major league baseball: The case of the first family of free agents. The Journal of Human Resources, 17(3), 426-436.
Tao, Y. L., Chuang, H. L., & Lin, E. S. (2016). Compensation and performance in Major League Baseball: Evidence from salary dispersion and team performance. International Review of Economics & Finance, 43, 151-159.
Wiseman, F., & Chatterjee, S. (2003). Team payroll and team performance in major league baseball: 1985–2002. Economics Bulletin, 1(2), 1-10.
Running Head: PAY AND PERFORMANCE IN MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL 1
PAY AND PERFORMANCE IN MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL 5
PAY AND PERFORMANCE IN MAJOR LEAGUE BASEBALL
RODERICK HOOKS
9-16-2019
Purpose statement and model
This study will try to examine whether there is a relationship between the payment and performance of a team. Performance is the dependent variable measured by wins of a team in the 2010 Major League Baseball (Tao Y. et al, 2016). This is the suitable dependent variable since the wins for a team can be influenced by many factors and the final results are the main target of every team (Scully G., 1974). The primary independent variable is payroll which the totals pay of the team (Wiseman F. & Chatterjee S., 2003). This is suitable in determining whether there is relationship between pay and performance due to the fact that a higher anticipates higher performance since many challenges for the team can be solved by financial stability (Sommers P. & Quinton N., 1982).
The general form of the model will be;
Wins = b0 + b1Payroll + b2Attendance + Error (
Definitions of variables
The variables used in this study are wins, payroll and attendance. Win is the dependent variable measuring the number of games the team wins. I ...
Have you ever wondered how college football teams were ranked amongst each other? A lot of people get angry over the ranking systems, but here are some methods used for ranking the teams!
Similar to Hitters vs. Pitchers: The Anomaly of the DH Rule in the MLB (20)
Netherlands vs Austria Netherlands Face Familiar Foes in Euro Cup Germany Gro...Eticketing.co
The Netherlands are in Group D in Euro Cup Germany - and, unpaid to this, they will be coming up against familiar foes. Remarkably, they have played France, who have fashioned some of the greatest players of all time, 30 times throughout history. Despite France being more effective in major competitions, including captivating the World Cup in 2018, Holland have the greater head-to-head record.
We offer Euro Cup Tickets to admirers who can get Netherlands vs Austria Tickets through our trusted online ticketing marketplace. Eticketing.co is the most reliable source for booking Euro Cup Final Tickets. Sign up for the latest Euro Cup Germany Ticket alert.
UEFA Euro 2024 Tickets | Euro 2024 Tickets | Netherlands vs Austria Tickets
However, in 2023, they played one another twice, with France endearing both matches 4-0 and 2-1 individually. Against Poland and Austria, the Netherlands also have a stout record, winning just under half the matches. They faced Austria at Euro 2020, engaging 2-0, and they haven't lost to Poland since 1979.
The lettering is on the wall for Holland to qualify for the knockouts, but nothing is failsafe. The Netherlands kickstart their Euros campaign against Poland on Sunday, June 16th. In Hamburg, they will have to go up against one of the best strikers in the world, Robert Lewandowski.
Netherlands vs Austria: Tough Challenges Await the Netherlands in Euro Cup Germany
Five days later, they travel south to face France in Leipzig, a side led by Kylian Mbappe - one of the finest players in the world currently and one of the most impressive players in his nation's history. To conclude, they face Austria in Berlin, knowing it could be the end of the road if they don't perform.
Ronald Koeman is widely considered one of the more successful Dutch managers in Premier League history, considering the nation has a reputation for struggling to replicate their talents in England. The former Everton manager went against that script and shone — and now he is back managing his nation.
UEFA Euro 2024 Tickets | Euro 2024 Tickets | Euro Cup Germany Tickets | Netherlands vs Austria Tickets
Euro fans worldwide can book Euro Cup Germany Tickets from our online platform, www.eticketing.co. Fans can book Euro Cup 2024 Tickets on our website at discounted prices.
Netherlands vs Austria: Ronald Koeman's Tactical Approach For UEFA Euro 2024
As well as being the highest-scoring defender in history, Koeman is a man with immense tactical knowledge. He returned to manage Holland at the start of 2023 after it was announced Louis van Gaal would retire. His life back in the dugout with the team wasn't easy, as he lost his first match 4-0 to France after going 3-0 down within 21 minutes.
However, he eventually helped them qualify for Euro Cup Germany. The 61-year-old likes to organize his team with a defensive mindset. Some might call it pragmatic as he defends with minimal space between the lines, but that's often needed for international football.
Croatia vs Italy Can Luka Modrić Lead Croatia to Euro Cup Germany Glory in Hi...Eticketing.co
Euro 2024 fans worldwide can book Croatia vs Italy Tickets from our online platform www.eticketing.co. Fans can book Euro Cup Germany Tickets on our website at discounted prices.
According to the report, the consumption of video content related to IPL 2024 has seen significant growth, nearly 3 times more than the previous season, reflecting an increasing interest of fans.
Spain vs Croatia Spain aims to put aside the RFEF crisis as they chase Euro C...Eticketing.co
We offer UEFA Euro 2024 Tickets to admirers who can get Spain vs Croatia Tickets through our trusted online ticketing marketplace. Eticketing. co is the most reliable source for booking Euro Cup Final Tickets. Sign up for the latest Euro Cup Germany Ticket alert.
Croatia vs Italy Modric's Last Dance Croatia's UEFA Euro 2024 Journey and Ita...Eticketing.co
UEFA Euro 2024 fans worldwide can book Croatia vs Italy Tickets from our online platform www.eticketing.co. Fans can book Euro Cup Germany Tickets on our website at discounted prices.
Turkey vs Georgia Turkey's Road to Redemption and Euro 2024 Prospects.pdfEticketing.co
Euro Cup Germany fans worldwide can book Euro 2024 Tickets from our online platform www.eticketing.co.Fans can book Euro Cup 2024 Tickets on our website at discounted prices.
Belgium vs Slovakia Belgium Euro 2024 Golden Generation Faces Euro Cup Final ...Eticketing.co
We offer Euro Cup Tickets to admirers who can get Belgium vs Slovakia Tickets through our trusted online ticketing marketplace. Eticketing.co is the most reliable source for booking Euro Cup Final Tickets. Sign up for the latest Euro Cup Germany Ticket alert.
The Split_ Hardik Pandya and Natasa Stankovic Part Ways News by Betkaro247 (3...bet k247
Betting ID
we like to introduce to our Cricket Betting ID platform, which help people to earn lot of money just by doing little-little predictions on games and events.
Indian cricketer Hardik Pandya and Serbian actress Natasha Stankovic have decided to part ways, ending a relationship that captivated fans and followers worldwide. The news of their split has been making headlines, stirring a mixture of shock, sadness, and speculation among their supporters.
Gabriel Kalembo A Rising Star in the World of Football Coachinggabrielkalembous
Gabriel Kalembo is a player's coach who connects with his teams on a deep level. With a strong background in sports science and a passion for the game, Kalembo has developed a unique coaching philosophy that emphasizes player development and tactical flexibility. His ability to connect with players and create a positive team culture has led to success at every level he has coached.
Hesan Soufi's Legacy: Inspiring the Next GenerationHesan Soufi
Hesan Soufi's impact on the game extends far beyond his on-field exploits. With his humility, sportsmanship, and unwavering commitment to excellence, Soufi has become a role model for aspiring footballers worldwide. His legacy lies not only in his achievements but also in the inspiration he provides to the next generation of talented players.
Italy vs Albania Soul and sacrifice' are the keys to success for Albania at E...Eticketing.co
We offer UEFA Euro 2024 Tickets to admirers who can get Italy vs Albania Tickets through our trusted online ticketing marketplace. Eticketing. co is the most reliable source for booking Euro Cup Final Tickets. Sign up for the latest Euro Cup Germany Ticket alert.
Turkey vs Georgia Tickets: Turkey's Provisional Squad for UEFA Euro 2024, Key...Eticketing.co
Euro Cup Germany fans worldwide can book Euro 2024 Tickets from our online platform www.eticketing.co.Fans can book Euro Cup 2024 Tickets on our website at discounted prices.
Belgium vs Romania Ultimate Guide to Euro Cup 2024 Tactics, Ticketing, and Qu...Eticketing.co
Euro Cup 2024 fans worldwide can book Belgium vs Romania Tickets from our online platform www.eticketing.co. Fans can book Euro Cup Germany Tickets on our website at discounted prices.
Belgium vs Romania Ultimate Guide to Euro Cup 2024 Tactics, Ticketing, and Qu...
Hitters vs. Pitchers: The Anomaly of the DH Rule in the MLB
1. Hitters vs. Pitchers: The Anomaly of the DH Rule
Max Miller
max@uoguelph.ca
0629437
Abstract:
This study aims to determine how rules in the MLB (Major League Baseball) influence the framework of
the game – and in turn determine the optimal player pricing actions for GM’s. This paper will focus
specifically on the DH rule, and the inherent differences that it creates between the American League
(AL) and National League (NL). Just as Billy Beane, GM of the Oakland Athletics, understood the
framework of a league without a salary cap, and changed the dynamics of the game – this paper will try
to bring a better understanding to the framework created by the DH rule. By doing so, this analysis will
prove that GM’s need not only to find undervalued talent in the market (à laMoneyball), but also need
to focus on proper allocation of the available talent.
2. Introduction –
Baseball, like all sports, has a fundamental characteristic of uncertainty, which dominate the possible
outcomes of the game. Although this uncertainty has been found to lead to an increase in gate-receipts
(El-Hodiri and Quirk, 1971), in order to be successful – a team’s general manager (GM) should focus on
decreasing uncertainty in outcome – in order to build a roster that maximizes total wins, even when at
the expense of forgone revenue. This relates to the fact that a GM’s compensation, and legacy for that
matter, is based on how well their team performed, and not how much money the team earned during
their tenure. By focusing on decreasing uncertainty and maximizing winning percentage, all involved
parties should be better off, and owners should still earn a fair return.
The rules of the game, which govern how the players act, lead to the creation of a general framework
that influences how outcomes are determined. Therefore by gaining an in-depth understanding of the
framework these rules create, a GM can produce strategies that effectively decrease uncertainty of
outcome and in turn increase their team’s chances of winning.
Similar to a mutual fund manager, GM’s are constantly managing a portfolio of players (equity), in a
market full of uncertainty, looking to maximize total return (wins). Therefore, a vital question constantly
on the mind of professional sports GM’s should be – What is the most efficient way to allocate salary in
order to maximize total return? To answer this important question – GM’s must take an objective, rules-
based approach – allowing them to properly allocate salary in a way that reduces uncertainty of team
outcomes, stacking the odds in their favor.
I hypothesize that due to the DH rule, a framework is created, in which teams in the AL should
consistently spend a higher proportion of their salary on offense (non-pitchers), when compared to NL
teams, and that teams that don’t distribute salary in accordance to this framework, will be improperly
constructed, and thus will lead to a lower winning percentage. I also hypothesize that the proportion of
salary spent on offense (non-pitchers) will have a larger effect on the winning percentage in the AL
compared to the NL.
Literature Review –
An interesting review of how rules in the MLB can impact the pricing decisions of GM’s can be found in
the 2003 bestseller, “Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game”, by Michael Lewis. This book
chronicled the perennial success of the Oakland Athletics and their GM Billy Beane – despite having one
of the lowest payrolls, in a league that lacks a salary cap.
The salary cap, which puts a ceiling on the amount each team is allowed to spend on its players, is a rule
that is generally used to level the competitive playing field for small market teams in professional sports.
Instead of a salary cap, the MLB utilizes a form of luxury tax, in which teams whose total salary exceeds
a certain figure are taxed on the excess amount. In the past, this luxury tax system has been ineffective
at stopping large market team’s form spending high amounts of salary. For example, the New York
Yankees who have paid approximately 92% of all luxury tax collected by MLB have also participated in 40
of the past 109 World Series (MLB, 2012).
3. Although the luxury tax has been ineffective at maintaining equality in MLB team payrolls, as the world
learned with the release of “Moneyball” – spending doesn’t always equate to a higher winning
percentage.
For many years, Billy Beane had dealt with the issues of competing with large market teams that could
afford to maintain high salaries. In doing so, he was able to gain a total understanding of the framework
created by the lack of salary cap, coming to the realization that he couldn’t compete in the market for
conventional talent. Therefore Billy and his assistant Paul Depodesta created a new strategy, which
valued empirical gauges of player performance over the traditional, subjective wisdom of baseball
scouts (Lewis, 2003). This strategy allowed the Oakland Athletics to solve a serious issue which had
plagued the MLB: competing by obtaining first rate talent without a large payroll.
The success of this Billy Beane’s strategy is clearly evident in the data. Since Beane took over as GM of
the Oakland Athletics in 1998, the team has won approximately 55% of their games – good for the 5th
highest winning percentage of all 30 MLB teams, behind only the New York Yankees, the Atlanta Braves,
the Boston Red Sox and the St. Louis Cardinals (Regan, 2012).
However, like all great strategies, once the secrets have been exposed, the potential opportunity to
exploit for gains greatly decreases. As the Moneyball method became more widely used, and more
popular throughout the MLB, it inherently became harder to take advantage of undervalued assets in
both the free agent and trade market. According to Hakes and Sauer (2006), a year after the publication
of Moneyball, the strategy had been completely diffused throughout the MLB. This became an even
larger issue when large market teams, such as the Boston Red Sox, started adopting these Moneyball
techniques on top of their vast payrolls.
In order to re-gain a competitive advantage over the big spenders, small market GM’s must gain a
deeper understanding of the rules in the game. This study will focus specifically on the DH rule and its
effects on the optimal salary distribution in the MLB.
While a large amount of literature has been published on the effects of salary dispersion in the MLB, a
majority of these studies focus on dispersion inequality, rather than determining an optimal distribution
based on the available constraints. Jewell and Molina (2004) and DeBrock et al. (2004) found a negative
relationship between the intra-team salary dispersion and team performance in MLB. The findings from
these studies are due to the large nature of MLB rosters – by concentrating a high proportion of salary in
a small number of players, GM’s are unable to build well-balanced teams.
The next section of this paper will try to understand how the DH rule influences the framework of the
game – and in turn determine the optimal player pricing actions for GMs.
Research Question:
How does the DH rule effect the optimal player pricing actions of GMs in the MLB?
4. Hypotheses:
1) The DH rule creates a framework, in which, AL teams should spend a higher proportion of salary
on offense (non-pitchers), and small-market teams (teams with a salary below the league
average) that don’t spend according to this framework, will have improperly constructed teams,
and therefore will lead to a lower winning percentage.
2) The proportion of salary spent on offense (non-pitchers) will have a larger impact on the
winning percentage in the AL, compared to the NL.
Data
The data for this section consists of MLB team salary figures for the past six years (2007-2012). This data
was taken from USATODAY (http://content.usatoday.com/sportsdata/baseball/mlb/salaries/team),
which lists a collection of professional sports salary data. The baseball salary database contains year-by-
year listings of salaries for MLB opening day rosters, including players on the disabled lists. This data is
based on documents obtained from the MLB Players Association (MLBPA), club officials and Major
League Baseball’s central office.
Hitters vs. Pitchers: The Anomaly of the DH Rule
The DH Rule – which only applies to the AL – allows a designated hitter (DH) to replace the pitcher in the
batting lineup. This means that the batting lineup in the AL consists of nine full-time batters, whereas an
NL batting lineup consists of eight full-time batters and one pitcher. In theory, due to the added hitter in
the lineup, thisrule creates league-wide dynamic that causes the structure of AL teams to be more
offensively oriented. According to this framework, AL teams should consistently spend a higher portion
of salary on hitters (non-pitchers), than their counterparts in the NL. This analysis will try to first
establish the fact that AL teams spend a higher proportion of salary on offense, followed by measuring
the performance of teams that didn’t follow the DH rule framework.
Hypothesis 1:
2012 AL NL Change in % 2009 AL NL Change in %
% Non-Pitcher 57.62% 50.64% 6.98% % Non-Pitcher 58.43% 53.86% 4.57%
% Pitcher 42.38% 49.36% % Pitcher 41.57% 46.14%
2011 AL NL 2008 AL NL
% Non-Pitcher 60.76% 53.79% 6.97% % Non-Pitcher 58.86% 53.05% 5.81%
% Pitcher 39.24% 46.21% % Pitcher 41.14% 46.95%
2010 AL NL 2007 AL NL
% Non-Pitcher 57.78% 50.55% 7.23% % Non-Pitcher 57.96% 53.07% 4.89%
% Pitcher 42.22% 49.45% % Pitcher 42.04% 46.93%
58.57%
52.49%
6.08%Total Change in % Non-Pitcher:
Average % Non-Pitcher NL
Average % Non-Pitcher AL
5. As hypothesized, the above figure proves that over the past six years, AL teams spent approximately
6.08% more on hitters (non-pitchers), when compared to NL teams. This figure accounts for the fact that
designated hitters in the AL are generally well-paid, middle of the lineup power bats – whereas when NL
teams play under AL rules they have to resort to using a backup player to fill the DH role.
Chart 1 (Appendix 1) represents a scatter plot diagram of all the small-market AL teams over the past six
years and their proportion of salary spent on offense (non-hitters). This chart focuses specifically on
small market teams (teams with salary below the league average) due to the fact that large market
teams, who can afford to have high salaries, can spend a smaller proportion of their salary on offense,
but still be spending an higher actual dollar value. For example, although the Boston Red Sox spent
below the average non-pitcher percentage in 2011, they still spent just under 85 million on hitters alone,
which is almost as high as the average MLB team salary.
When considering the discussed framework created by the DH rule, teams in quadrant 1 should have
more optimal allocation of salary when compared to teams in quadrant 2 – and therefore should lead to
a higher winning percentage.
When comparing the winning percentage of the data points from the above chart (Appendix 2),
hypothesis 1 is confirmed. Only 20% of the teams in quadrant 2 finished with a record above .500,
whereas 40% of the teams in quadrant 1 finished above .500. Also the average winning percentage in
quadrant 2 (46.75%), is less than the average winning percentage in quadrant 1 (48.84%). This results in
a 2.09% winning percentage differential, which is approximately a 3.40 difference in total wins (# of wins
= winning % * 162).
Hypothesis 2:
This section will try to measure the effect of increasing the proportion of salary invested in hitters on AL
teams versus NL teams. To do so, I ran the simple regression model below for both the AL and NL:
Average NL Non-
Pitcher %: 0.525
Average AL Salary:
$97,107,964
0.38
0.43
0.48
0.53
0.58
0.63
0.68
0.73
0.78
20000000 40000000 60000000 80000000
Non-Pitcher%
Total Salary
I
II
6. Win % = β0 + β1*Salary +β2*Non-Pitcher %
In the above regression, the dependent variable (Y variable), is the winning percentage – whereas the
independent variables (X variables) are total salary and non-pitcher percentage. Therefore, the results
from these regressions should be able to distinguish whether the proportion of salary invested in
offense (non-pitchers) has a greater effect on winning in the AL over the NL. These results would
confirm that the DH rule does in fact create a framework, in which AL teams are more offensively
oriented and therefore should devote a higher proportion of their salary to offense (non-pitchers).
When looking at theresults from this study (Appendix 3 and 4), as expected, we see that salary (β1) has a
definite positive effect on winning % in both leagues. More importantly, when looking at these results,
we see that non-pitcher % (β2) has a slightly positive effect on winning percentage in the AL (coefficient
= .02858), whereas, the same coefficient has a negative effect in the NL (coefficient = -.1191). This
verifies the second hypothesize that the proportion of non-pitchers has a larger effect on the winning
percentage in the AL.
It’s easy to dismiss the above models due to a low R2, only explaining around 15%(11% = salary, 4% =
non-pitching %) of the variation in winning percentage. However, if one considers all variables in
baseball that affect winning percentage – total salary and non-pitcher expense cannot be
consideredperfect predictors. Baseball games are intensely competitive in nature and outcomes are
based upon many competing variables, including opponent, starting pitcher, umpires, injuries,
attendance and even weather.
Conclusion
The main conclusion derived from the analysis of this study is that due to the DH rule, a framework is
created in the MLB, which affects the optimal salary distribution– increasing the importance of offense
in the AL. This conclusion was a result of evidence demonstrating lower winning percentages amongAL
teams that deviated from this framework. This conclusion was also strengthened by the use of
regression analysis, which proved that the proportion of salary allocated to non-pitchers has hada
positive impact on the winning percentage in the AL, and a slightly negative effect on the winning
percentage in the NL.
Overall, this analysis proves that due to the DH rule, a reliable relationship exists between salary
allocation and winning percentage in the MLB. This relationship should be properly understood by GM’s
– allowing them to allocate salary in a way that decreases uncertainty of outcome, and maximizestheir
team’s potentialwinning percentage.
Coefficients R Square
Intercept 0.426737591
Total Salary 6.39008E-10
Non-Pitching % 0.028577299
0.159356798
AL LEAGUE SUMMARY OUTPUT
Coefficients R Square
Intercept 0.498486503
Total Salary 6.98652E-10
Non-Pitching % -0.119099243
NL LEAUGE SUMMARY OUTPUT
0.141025583
7. Work Cited List
Debrock, Larry. "Pay and Performance: The Impact of Salary Distribution on Firm--Level Outcomes in
Baseball." Journal of Sports Economics 5 (2004): 243-61. Sage Journals.Web. 27 Feb. 2013.
El-Hodiri, Mohamed, and Quirk, James."An Economic Model of a Professional Sports League." Journal of
Political Economiy 79.6 (1971): 1302-319. JSTOR.Web. 22 Feb. 2013.
Hakes, Jahn K., and Raymond D. Sauer."An Economic Evaluation of the Moneyball Hypothesis." Journal
of Economic Perspectives 20.3 (2006): 173-85. JSTOR.Web. 25 Feb. 2013.
Jewell, Todd, and David Molina."Testing the Determinants of Income Distribution in Major League
Baseball." Economic Inquiry 42.3 (2004): 469-82. Scholars Portal.Web. 27 Feb. 2013.
Lewis, Michael. Moneyball: The Art of Winning an Unfair Game. New York: W.W. Norton, 2003. Print.
MLB."Standings | MLB.com " Major League Baseball. 12 Mar. 2012. Web. 25 Feb.
2013.http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/standings/
MLB. "World Series Overview | MLB.com: History." Major League Baseball. 12 Mar. 2013. Web. 25 Feb.
http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/standings/http://mlb.mlb.com/mlb/history/postseason/mlb_ws.jsp?feature=a
l_clubs
Regan, Colin. "The Price of Efficiency: Examining the Effects of Payroll Efficiency on Major League
Baseball Attendance." Applied Economics Letters 19 (2012): 1007-015.Scholars Portal. Web. 25 Feb.
2013.
8. Quadrant 1 Quandrant 2
Team Year Non-Pitcher % Win % Team Year Non-Pitcher % Win %
CLE 2007 0.395757647 0.593 MIN 2007 0.555078073 0.488
TEX 2007 0.440179746 0.463 BAL 2007 0.591630929 0.426
KC 2007 0.440300582 0.426 TB 2007 0.633573072 0.407
TOR 2007 0.449876136 0.512 DET 2007 0.67567725 0.543
CLE 2008 0.456740571 0.5 OAK 2007 0.705497705 0.469
TEX 2008 0.469825207 0.488 OAK 2008 0.541099752 0.466
KC 2008 0.48013406 0.463 TB 2008 0.575541333 0.599
TEX 2009 0.483303504 0.537 BAL 2008 0.620003594 0.422
CLE 2009 0.485735171 0.401 MIN 2008 0.667326896 0.54
CHI 2009 0.490311687 0.488 OAK 2009 0.795056973 0.463
CLE 2010 0.507870643 0.426 TOR 2009 0.53906899 0.463
KC 2010 0.508788 0.414 KC 2009 0.545840855 0.401
KC 2011 0.509743932 0.438 TB 2009 0.575541333 0.519
KC 2012 0.518358646 0.444 BAL 2009 0.628821943 0.395
CLE 2012 0.520357796 0.42 MIN 2009 0.669184643 0.534
0.467533 TEX 2010 0.555881839 0.556
BAL 2010 0.595313218 0.407
OAK 2010 0.609525911 0.5
TB 2010 0.63237076 0.593
SEA 2010 0.662333834 0.377
TOR 2010 0.707383424 0.525
TOR 2011 0.585182794 0.5
TB 2011 0.616833064 0.562
OAK 2011 0.6474266 0.457
TEX 2011 0.674752444 0.593
SEA 2011 0.686030331 0.414
CLE 2011 0.696447892 0.494
BAL 2011 0.704275429 0.426
OAK 2012 0.530678586 0.58
TB 2012 0.55863869 0.556
SEA 2012 0.560271585 0.463
CHI 2012 0.57231001 0.525
TOR 2012 0.592409245 0.451
MIN 2012 0.617686135 0.407
BAL 2012 0.639182596 0.574
0.488429
Appendix
1. American League Scatter Plot
2. American League Small Market Teak Winning % (Highlighted = Win % >.500)
Average NL Non-
Pitcher %: 0.525
Average AL Salary:
$97,107,964
0.38
0.43
0.48
0.53
0.58
0.63
0.68
0.73
0.78
$20,000,000 $70,000,000 $120,000,000 $170,000,000
Non-Pitcher%
Total Salary
9. 3. American League Regression Output
4. National League Regression Output
Regression Statistics
Multiple R 0.399195188
R Square 0.159356798
Adjusted R Square 0.138600176
Standard Error 0.06329462
Observations 84
ANOVA
df SS MS F Significance F
Regression 2 0.061514501 0.03075725 7.677395497 0.000884655
Residual 81 0.324502924 0.004006209
Total 83 0.386017425
Coefficients t Stat P-value Lower 95% Upper 95%
Intercept 0.426737591 0.054357126 7.850628259 1.47823E-11 0.31858396 0.534891221
Total Salary 6.39008E-10 1.68275E-10 3.797414223 0.00028134 3.04195E-10 9.73822E-10
Non-Pitching % 0.028577299 0.092586936 0.308653689 0.758377418 -0.15564166 0.212796259
AL LEAGUE SUMMARY OUTPUT
Regression Statistics
Multiple R 0.37553373
R Square 0.141025583
Adjusted R Square 0.122553015
Standard Error 0.062130905
Observations 96
ANOVA
df SS MS F Significance F
Regression 2 0.058940795 0.029470397 7.634324684 0.000851296
Residual 93 0.359003195 0.003860249
Total 95 0.41794399
Coefficients Standard Error t Stat P-value Lower 95% Upper 95%
Intercept 0.498486503 0.04099418 12.1599336 6.33462E-21 0.417080186 0.579892819
Total Salary 6.98652E-10 2.10367E-10 3.321106244 0.001282299 2.80904E-10 1.1164E-09
Non-Pitching % -0.119099243 0.066623156 -1.787655376 0.077088886 -0.251399627 0.013201141
NL LEAUGE SUMMARY OUTPUT
NL LEAUGE SUMMARY OUTPUT