The Delhi High Court heard an appeal from the Registrar of the Supreme Court of India regarding an order from the Central Information Commission (CIC). The CIC had directed the Registrar to provide information on cases pending before the Supreme Court where judgments were reserved during 2007-2009. The High Court overturned the CIC's order and the order of the single judge upholding it. The Court found that under the Right to Information Act, a public authority is only required to provide information that is already available with it, and cannot be compelled to collate information in a particular form if it is not maintained that way. As the Supreme Court did not maintain the requested data in the form sought, the direction to provide that information was