A new study in the Journal of Marketing shows that the design of websites used for buying health insurance combined with high-quality big data can produce big savings for consumers. When health insurance products are ordered such that the best options for the consumer appear first in the presented list, this strongly improves consumers' decisions. If the list is also partitioned to show a small number of options first (with an easy option to click through to see all options), this further improves consumers' decisions. However, importantly, if the best options are not at the top of the list, partitioning can harm consumer decision quality.