This document discusses the challenges of transforming university campuses to be more environmentally sustainable on a systemic level. It argues that past efforts have led to many successful projects but few examples of full institutional transformation. Universities are complex organizations with characteristics like goal ambiguity, limited rational decision-making, and competing priorities that inhibit systemic change. The document outlines approaches used by successful green campus initiatives, such as securing management support and building partnerships. It also discusses the mental models and "absurd consensus" that can prevent recognizing environmental issues and the need for change. Overall, the document argues that transforming universities requires understanding their systemic nature and developing new ways to engage a critical mass of the organization in change efforts.
This document summarizes a Master's thesis project that explored pro-environmental lifestyles and values in Canada. The author conducted a survey of over 1,200 Canadians to answer three research questions: 1) What is a green lifestyle and how does it compare to other lifestyle types? 2) What are the different types of green lifestyles among Canadians? 3) How do environmental values influence engagement in green lifestyles? The author used factor analysis to identify general lifestyle types and different pro-environmental lifestyle sectors. Regression analysis was then used to examine the relationship between environmental values and engagement in the various pro-environmental lifestyles. The results provide insight into lifestyle behaviors among Canadians and how values are linked to participation
This document summarizes a re-review of a systematic review on the impacts of water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) interventions on diarrhea. The re-review found that in over 45% of studies, impacts were more complex than just diarrhea reduction. Many interventions unintentionally impacted other health and development factors like nutrition, education, and gender relations. It also found that in over 50% of studies, individual and community actions influenced the benefits and harms experienced from the interventions in ways not considered. The re-review calls for WASH interventions and evaluations to better account for these complexities and interactions to maximize impacts.
State of Environmental Clearance in India: Procedures, timelines and delays a...vaibhavenv
Trade-off between economic development and environmental protection becomes critical for any country aspiring for high growth for achieving development objectives. Within India, “Green clearances”, an instrument to balance this trade-off, has been subjected to severe criticism for deterring the industrial development process and impacting economic growth. How much truth is there to such perceptions? Which aspects of the process of securing environmental and forest clearance need attention and how can these be addressed? Are there particular states or industries where the challenges are more acute? This study was undertaken to comprehend these contours of development.
This document describes the rationale and design of the CAPABLE randomized controlled trial. The trial aims to test whether an interdisciplinary intervention including a nurse, occupational therapist, and handyman can reduce disability among low-income older adults compared to an attention control group. The intervention addresses both personal and environmental risk factors for disability over 10 home visits in 4 months. The primary outcome is decreased disability in self-care activities. Secondary outcomes include sustained decreases in disability and improvements in mobility, health-related quality of life, and healthcare utilization. The trial plans to enroll 300 participants and follow them for 52 weeks to assess short and long-term impacts.
Green infrastructure (GI) solutions were investigated as part of a joint-industry program to increase business resilience. GI solutions utilize natural and semi-natural systems to provide benefits like traditional gray infrastructure. The study evaluated case studies where GI increased resilience to stressors through reduced costs, environmental impacts, and socio-political risks compared to gray infrastructure. Both green and gray infrastructure resist shocks in different ways, so hybrid approaches may provide optimal resilience.
C:\Documents And Settings\Prashant1\My Documents\Study Material\Publication\P...Prashant Mehta
Energy and Sustainable Development are dynamically interlinked. This paper highlights industail process and product change can bring requirements of energy to minimum
This document summarizes a Master's thesis project that explored pro-environmental lifestyles and values in Canada. The author conducted a survey of over 1,200 Canadians to answer three research questions: 1) What is a green lifestyle and how does it compare to other lifestyle types? 2) What are the different types of green lifestyles among Canadians? 3) How do environmental values influence engagement in green lifestyles? The author used factor analysis to identify general lifestyle types and different pro-environmental lifestyle sectors. Regression analysis was then used to examine the relationship between environmental values and engagement in the various pro-environmental lifestyles. The results provide insight into lifestyle behaviors among Canadians and how values are linked to participation
This document summarizes a re-review of a systematic review on the impacts of water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) interventions on diarrhea. The re-review found that in over 45% of studies, impacts were more complex than just diarrhea reduction. Many interventions unintentionally impacted other health and development factors like nutrition, education, and gender relations. It also found that in over 50% of studies, individual and community actions influenced the benefits and harms experienced from the interventions in ways not considered. The re-review calls for WASH interventions and evaluations to better account for these complexities and interactions to maximize impacts.
State of Environmental Clearance in India: Procedures, timelines and delays a...vaibhavenv
Trade-off between economic development and environmental protection becomes critical for any country aspiring for high growth for achieving development objectives. Within India, “Green clearances”, an instrument to balance this trade-off, has been subjected to severe criticism for deterring the industrial development process and impacting economic growth. How much truth is there to such perceptions? Which aspects of the process of securing environmental and forest clearance need attention and how can these be addressed? Are there particular states or industries where the challenges are more acute? This study was undertaken to comprehend these contours of development.
This document describes the rationale and design of the CAPABLE randomized controlled trial. The trial aims to test whether an interdisciplinary intervention including a nurse, occupational therapist, and handyman can reduce disability among low-income older adults compared to an attention control group. The intervention addresses both personal and environmental risk factors for disability over 10 home visits in 4 months. The primary outcome is decreased disability in self-care activities. Secondary outcomes include sustained decreases in disability and improvements in mobility, health-related quality of life, and healthcare utilization. The trial plans to enroll 300 participants and follow them for 52 weeks to assess short and long-term impacts.
Green infrastructure (GI) solutions were investigated as part of a joint-industry program to increase business resilience. GI solutions utilize natural and semi-natural systems to provide benefits like traditional gray infrastructure. The study evaluated case studies where GI increased resilience to stressors through reduced costs, environmental impacts, and socio-political risks compared to gray infrastructure. Both green and gray infrastructure resist shocks in different ways, so hybrid approaches may provide optimal resilience.
C:\Documents And Settings\Prashant1\My Documents\Study Material\Publication\P...Prashant Mehta
Energy and Sustainable Development are dynamically interlinked. This paper highlights industail process and product change can bring requirements of energy to minimum
This document discusses building a green culture at Empire State College's Metro Center campus in New York City. It begins by outlining the team members and their research goals, which are to determine areas where the campus can improve sustainability and energy efficiency by examining other successful green initiatives.
It then discusses defining the current culture at ESC Metro Center through stakeholder analysis and benchmarking other institutions like Berkeley College and Hunter College that have established green programs. The team aims to research industry standards and recommend how ESC Metro can adopt a greener culture by considering its current position and desired future state.
The document discusses the development of an interdisciplinary sustainability program at Fairleigh Dickinson University. It describes how the curriculum draws from various disciplines like geology, meteorology, and economics to provide an integrated learning experience for students. Some challenges in developing the program included territoriality between departments and skepticism about climate change. The first courses for the new sustainability program were offered this semester.
The document is the 2014 annual report of the Purdue Center for the Environment. It provides an overview of the Center's activities in 2014, including renewing its strategic vision with a focus on human health, ecosystems, and environmental decision-making. It summarizes new faculty hires in sustainability-related fields and increased external grant funding. The Director expresses excitement over undergraduate research involvement and soundscape education projects emerging from earlier Center funding.
The report analyzes waste and recycling data reports provided by Speedie Waste, the waste management company for Melbourne University. Key findings include inconsistencies in Speedie Waste's data collection methods and reporting, making accurate analysis difficult. Recommendations include implementing a more systematic tracking method using GPS and weight sensors, editing data for accuracy, reorganizing tables for clarity, and including summaries for quick analysis. The report aims to improve Speedie Waste's reporting to help the university achieve sustainability goals.
This document summarizes presentations from a sustainability conference featuring case studies from universities in Mexico, the US, and Spain. It discusses how the universities have incorporated sustainability into their operations, curriculum, research, and community outreach. For example, the University of Alcala de Henares in Spain created a Council for Sustainability and integrated sustainability programs, majors and research. San Diego State University has a Center for Regional Sustainability that facilitates collaboration and a sustainability-focused undergraduate program. The conclusion calls for universities to promote sustainability awareness, review their own operations and impact, and integrate the concepts into the curriculum.
This document provides guidance for universities on establishing sustainable campus organizations. It discusses the challenges of coordinating sustainability efforts across complex university campuses. Key steps outlined include developing a strategic sustainability plan with buy-in from top leadership, conducting a review of best practices, and creating a dedicated office or department to manage sustainability activities campus-wide. The guide stresses that sustainability goals and initiatives should reflect environmental, social, and financial benefits to engage the university community.
Exploring A New Approach to Instruction in Higher EducationShawn Sweeney
This document outlines a Masters of Education program in Humane Education from the Institute for Humane Education. The program teaches about humane education topics like environmental ethics and human rights. Students complete an independent learning project on a topic like curriculum development. The document proposes an "Inquiry in Systems Change Project" using action research and appreciative inquiry techniques to study and address issues. It provides definitions and examples of these approaches. The project would guide students through developing a small-scale project to address an issue in a system they are part of. Teaching materials like a syllabus, readings, and assessment strategies are suggested.
The document defines ecological literacy as understanding one's place in the ecosystem and discusses its key aspects. Ecological literacy requires shifts in perception, knowledge, and actions. It emphasizes seeing subjects as integrated relationships rather than isolated units, and understanding qualities and processes over quantities and structures. The goal is to develop people who are inquisitive, reflective, self-directed, responsible, and seek to transcend personal interests for the broader environment.
Writing an essay on environmental science can be challenging due to the vast and interconnected nature of environmental issues. It requires a deep understanding of complex scientific concepts as well as the ability to communicate these clearly to diverse audiences. Additionally, essays must address urgent environmental problems and propose solutions while blending scientific evidence with persuasive arguments. However, developing contributions to ongoing discussions of crucial global issues can offer opportunities to raise awareness and influence attitudes towards sustainability. For those facing difficulties, assistance services are available to support research, structure, and articulation of ideas for environmental science essays.
This document discusses the evolution of sustainability paradigms from conventional to contemporary to regenerative sustainability. Regenerative sustainability aims to align human actions with principles of thriving living systems to continually increase whole-system health and wellbeing across scales. It integrates consideration of inner sustainability like worldviews with outer sustainability of social and ecological systems. Regenerative sustainability offers a holistic approach based on how living systems function and addresses root causes of unsustainability.
Environmental Studies Essay. Gadsden State Community CollegeStephanie Wilson
This document discusses the complexity of writing an essay on environmental studies. It notes that the topic encompasses many interconnected issues like climate change, biodiversity loss, pollution, and sustainable development. Staying updated on new research and accurately presenting information is difficult given the dynamic nature of the field. Constructing a persuasive argument requires understanding the interconnections between environmental factors from scientific, social, and economic perspectives. The essay also must advocate for practical solutions while encouraging reflection and stewardship, which demands careful consideration. In summary, an environmental studies essay navigates a vast web of information and issues to present a compelling case for positive change.
This document discusses how academic environmental programs need to evolve to address a new environmental agenda. It outlines the origins of the old environmental agenda in the 1960s-70s based on legislation and issues around pollution. However, a new agenda has emerged considering humanity's growing impact on global systems through climate change, sustainability, and biodiversity loss. The document argues interdisciplinary environmental programs must integrate themes like energy, health, and enterprise to prepare students for careers across many fields and help rebuild economies. Updating programs requires understanding both the old agenda, humanity's now profound role in environmental change, and trends reflecting needs to explore complex new issues.
Poster: Social Learning in support of Climate-‐Smart Agriculture: Ge8ng to Outcomes and Impact
Poster presented at CSA Conference 2015 in Montpellier authored and prepared by Wiebke Förch, Tonya Schuetz, Philip Thornton, Blane Harvey
Read more about the conference: http://ccafs.cgiar.org/3rd-global-science-conference-%E2%80%9Cclimate-smart-agriculture-2015%E2%80%9D#.
Writing an essay on environmental conservation is challenging due to the vast scope and complexity of the topic. It requires integrating scientific data with economic and ethical perspectives to present feasible solutions while conveying urgency and inspiring action. Crafting a balanced essay involves thorough research, critical analysis, and the ability to synthesize information from various sources. Despite difficulties, the process can foster deeper understanding of ecological systems and empower individuals to contribute to sustainability efforts.
1PAGE 5West Chester Private School Case StudyGrand .docxrobert345678
1
PAGE
5
West Chester Private School Case Study
Grand Canyon University
MGT-420: Organizational Behavior and Management
December 11th, 2022
West Chester Private School
Your introduction should be typed here. It should be at least four sentences and include a thesis statement that introduces all the key points of the paper. Please note that you should follow all APA writing rules within your essay. This means avoid first and second person, do not use contractions, and use citations throughout your paper. The final sentence in your introduction must be a strong thesis statement that introduces every key topic that will be introduced in the paper. Remember that a thesis should be one sentence. Here is an example: In the pages to follow, West Chester Private School (WCPS) will be discussed in the context of open systems, organizational culture, the decision to close and the closure process, the impact of technology and innovation on stakeholders, administration closure options, the plans for future direction of WCPS, along with the four functions of management.
External Environment and Open Systems
There are certain ways in which organizations interact with their external environment (as open systems). These ways rely on the Systems Approach to Management Theory, which perceives an organization as an open system that consists of interdependent and interrelated parts interacting as sub-systems (Jackson, 2017). Generally, organizations rely on the exchange of resources and information with their environments. More so, they cannot hold complete control over their behavior and actions, which are significantly impacted by external forces. For example, an organization may be impacted by various environmental conditions such as government regulations, client demands, and raw material availability. As an open system, an organization can interact with the external environment in the context of inputs, transformations, and outputs. Inputs refer to both human and non-human resources like materials, energy, and information. Transformations refer to the conversion of inputs into outputs. For example, a school can transform a student into an educated individual. Finally, outputs refer to what an organization is giving to the environment.
Internal Environment and Organizational Culture
At the time of the closure, the effectiveness of West Chester Private School (WCPS) as an open system was inadequate. One important factor that impacts the effectiveness of an open system is feedback. Feedback refers to the information that an open system receives from the external environment, which can be used to maintain a system at optimal working conditions or a steady state (Jung & Vakharia, 2019). In the case of WCPS, feedback could be received from parents, teachers, and students. At the time of the closure, none of these stakeholders was consulted. Instead, WCPS made a unilateral decision to close down two campuses without considering the input of parents, te.
Transformative Education: Towards a Relational, Justice-Oriented Approach to ...Zack Walsh
This paper aims to increase related knowledge across personal, social and ecological dimensions of sustainability and how it can be applied to support transformative learning. The paper provides a reflexive case study of the design, content and impact of a course on eco-justice that integrates relational learning with an equity and justice lens. The reflexive case study provides a critical, exploratory self-assessment, including interviews, group discussions and surveys with key stakeholders and course participants. The results show how relational approaches can support transformative learning for sustainability and provide concrete practices, pathways and recommendations for curricula development that other universities/training institutions could follow or learn from. Sustainability research, practice and education generally focuses on structural or systemic factors of transformation (e.g. technology, governance and policy) without due consideration as to how institutions and systems are shaping and shaped by the transformation of personal agency and subjectivity. This presents a vast untapped and under-studied potential for addressing deep leverage points for change by using a relational approach to link personal, societal and ecological transformations for sustainability.
Designing from Place - A Regenerative Framework and Methodology - BR7463 v6Bill Reed
The document describes a regenerative framework and methodology for design. It begins by outlining the need to transition to an ecological worldview to address environmental challenges. A regenerative methodology is proposed as a way for design practitioners to facilitate this transition. The methodology described was developed over 16 years and is rooted in ecological principles. It views humans as part of nature and aims to realign human activities with natural systems through a developmental process. The summary explores the underlying premises and concepts that shape the methodology, including its view of regeneration, human role, and approach of working developmentally.
Designing from place a regenerative framework and methodology - br7463 v6Bill Reed
1. The document describes a regenerative framework and methodology for design that is based on an ecological worldview. It aims to support the transition to more regenerative approaches in the built environment.
2. The methodology was developed and evolved over 16 years of practice. It is explored using a three-tier framework - the underlying premises and principles shape the overall methodology, and specific methods are chosen and applied accordingly.
3. The key premises of the regenerative methodology discussed are that humans should take their place as part of nature and focus on coevolving with natural systems, and that the first step is a change of mindset rather than just adopting new techniques.
External pressures like changing demographics and increasing student debt have created challenges for universities. Effective strategic processes require clear priorities aligned with stakeholders' values. Strategy lies at the leadership core by balancing constituencies' conflicting demands. Strategic planning models include linear, adaptive, and interpretive approaches. The linear method scans environments and pursues objectives. Adaptive strategy continuously adapts through experimentation. Interpretive strategy aligns mission and goals through symbols. Universities that strategically communicated culture changes through symbols were more resilient during financial difficulties.
This document provides an overview of wound healing, its functions, stages, mechanisms, factors affecting it, and complications.
A wound is a break in the integrity of the skin or tissues, which may be associated with disruption of the structure and function.
Healing is the body’s response to injury in an attempt to restore normal structure and functions.
Healing can occur in two ways: Regeneration and Repair
There are 4 phases of wound healing: hemostasis, inflammation, proliferation, and remodeling. This document also describes the mechanism of wound healing. Factors that affect healing include infection, uncontrolled diabetes, poor nutrition, age, anemia, the presence of foreign bodies, etc.
Complications of wound healing like infection, hyperpigmentation of scar, contractures, and keloid formation.
This document discusses building a green culture at Empire State College's Metro Center campus in New York City. It begins by outlining the team members and their research goals, which are to determine areas where the campus can improve sustainability and energy efficiency by examining other successful green initiatives.
It then discusses defining the current culture at ESC Metro Center through stakeholder analysis and benchmarking other institutions like Berkeley College and Hunter College that have established green programs. The team aims to research industry standards and recommend how ESC Metro can adopt a greener culture by considering its current position and desired future state.
The document discusses the development of an interdisciplinary sustainability program at Fairleigh Dickinson University. It describes how the curriculum draws from various disciplines like geology, meteorology, and economics to provide an integrated learning experience for students. Some challenges in developing the program included territoriality between departments and skepticism about climate change. The first courses for the new sustainability program were offered this semester.
The document is the 2014 annual report of the Purdue Center for the Environment. It provides an overview of the Center's activities in 2014, including renewing its strategic vision with a focus on human health, ecosystems, and environmental decision-making. It summarizes new faculty hires in sustainability-related fields and increased external grant funding. The Director expresses excitement over undergraduate research involvement and soundscape education projects emerging from earlier Center funding.
The report analyzes waste and recycling data reports provided by Speedie Waste, the waste management company for Melbourne University. Key findings include inconsistencies in Speedie Waste's data collection methods and reporting, making accurate analysis difficult. Recommendations include implementing a more systematic tracking method using GPS and weight sensors, editing data for accuracy, reorganizing tables for clarity, and including summaries for quick analysis. The report aims to improve Speedie Waste's reporting to help the university achieve sustainability goals.
This document summarizes presentations from a sustainability conference featuring case studies from universities in Mexico, the US, and Spain. It discusses how the universities have incorporated sustainability into their operations, curriculum, research, and community outreach. For example, the University of Alcala de Henares in Spain created a Council for Sustainability and integrated sustainability programs, majors and research. San Diego State University has a Center for Regional Sustainability that facilitates collaboration and a sustainability-focused undergraduate program. The conclusion calls for universities to promote sustainability awareness, review their own operations and impact, and integrate the concepts into the curriculum.
This document provides guidance for universities on establishing sustainable campus organizations. It discusses the challenges of coordinating sustainability efforts across complex university campuses. Key steps outlined include developing a strategic sustainability plan with buy-in from top leadership, conducting a review of best practices, and creating a dedicated office or department to manage sustainability activities campus-wide. The guide stresses that sustainability goals and initiatives should reflect environmental, social, and financial benefits to engage the university community.
Exploring A New Approach to Instruction in Higher EducationShawn Sweeney
This document outlines a Masters of Education program in Humane Education from the Institute for Humane Education. The program teaches about humane education topics like environmental ethics and human rights. Students complete an independent learning project on a topic like curriculum development. The document proposes an "Inquiry in Systems Change Project" using action research and appreciative inquiry techniques to study and address issues. It provides definitions and examples of these approaches. The project would guide students through developing a small-scale project to address an issue in a system they are part of. Teaching materials like a syllabus, readings, and assessment strategies are suggested.
The document defines ecological literacy as understanding one's place in the ecosystem and discusses its key aspects. Ecological literacy requires shifts in perception, knowledge, and actions. It emphasizes seeing subjects as integrated relationships rather than isolated units, and understanding qualities and processes over quantities and structures. The goal is to develop people who are inquisitive, reflective, self-directed, responsible, and seek to transcend personal interests for the broader environment.
Writing an essay on environmental science can be challenging due to the vast and interconnected nature of environmental issues. It requires a deep understanding of complex scientific concepts as well as the ability to communicate these clearly to diverse audiences. Additionally, essays must address urgent environmental problems and propose solutions while blending scientific evidence with persuasive arguments. However, developing contributions to ongoing discussions of crucial global issues can offer opportunities to raise awareness and influence attitudes towards sustainability. For those facing difficulties, assistance services are available to support research, structure, and articulation of ideas for environmental science essays.
This document discusses the evolution of sustainability paradigms from conventional to contemporary to regenerative sustainability. Regenerative sustainability aims to align human actions with principles of thriving living systems to continually increase whole-system health and wellbeing across scales. It integrates consideration of inner sustainability like worldviews with outer sustainability of social and ecological systems. Regenerative sustainability offers a holistic approach based on how living systems function and addresses root causes of unsustainability.
Environmental Studies Essay. Gadsden State Community CollegeStephanie Wilson
This document discusses the complexity of writing an essay on environmental studies. It notes that the topic encompasses many interconnected issues like climate change, biodiversity loss, pollution, and sustainable development. Staying updated on new research and accurately presenting information is difficult given the dynamic nature of the field. Constructing a persuasive argument requires understanding the interconnections between environmental factors from scientific, social, and economic perspectives. The essay also must advocate for practical solutions while encouraging reflection and stewardship, which demands careful consideration. In summary, an environmental studies essay navigates a vast web of information and issues to present a compelling case for positive change.
This document discusses how academic environmental programs need to evolve to address a new environmental agenda. It outlines the origins of the old environmental agenda in the 1960s-70s based on legislation and issues around pollution. However, a new agenda has emerged considering humanity's growing impact on global systems through climate change, sustainability, and biodiversity loss. The document argues interdisciplinary environmental programs must integrate themes like energy, health, and enterprise to prepare students for careers across many fields and help rebuild economies. Updating programs requires understanding both the old agenda, humanity's now profound role in environmental change, and trends reflecting needs to explore complex new issues.
Poster: Social Learning in support of Climate-‐Smart Agriculture: Ge8ng to Outcomes and Impact
Poster presented at CSA Conference 2015 in Montpellier authored and prepared by Wiebke Förch, Tonya Schuetz, Philip Thornton, Blane Harvey
Read more about the conference: http://ccafs.cgiar.org/3rd-global-science-conference-%E2%80%9Cclimate-smart-agriculture-2015%E2%80%9D#.
Writing an essay on environmental conservation is challenging due to the vast scope and complexity of the topic. It requires integrating scientific data with economic and ethical perspectives to present feasible solutions while conveying urgency and inspiring action. Crafting a balanced essay involves thorough research, critical analysis, and the ability to synthesize information from various sources. Despite difficulties, the process can foster deeper understanding of ecological systems and empower individuals to contribute to sustainability efforts.
1PAGE 5West Chester Private School Case StudyGrand .docxrobert345678
1
PAGE
5
West Chester Private School Case Study
Grand Canyon University
MGT-420: Organizational Behavior and Management
December 11th, 2022
West Chester Private School
Your introduction should be typed here. It should be at least four sentences and include a thesis statement that introduces all the key points of the paper. Please note that you should follow all APA writing rules within your essay. This means avoid first and second person, do not use contractions, and use citations throughout your paper. The final sentence in your introduction must be a strong thesis statement that introduces every key topic that will be introduced in the paper. Remember that a thesis should be one sentence. Here is an example: In the pages to follow, West Chester Private School (WCPS) will be discussed in the context of open systems, organizational culture, the decision to close and the closure process, the impact of technology and innovation on stakeholders, administration closure options, the plans for future direction of WCPS, along with the four functions of management.
External Environment and Open Systems
There are certain ways in which organizations interact with their external environment (as open systems). These ways rely on the Systems Approach to Management Theory, which perceives an organization as an open system that consists of interdependent and interrelated parts interacting as sub-systems (Jackson, 2017). Generally, organizations rely on the exchange of resources and information with their environments. More so, they cannot hold complete control over their behavior and actions, which are significantly impacted by external forces. For example, an organization may be impacted by various environmental conditions such as government regulations, client demands, and raw material availability. As an open system, an organization can interact with the external environment in the context of inputs, transformations, and outputs. Inputs refer to both human and non-human resources like materials, energy, and information. Transformations refer to the conversion of inputs into outputs. For example, a school can transform a student into an educated individual. Finally, outputs refer to what an organization is giving to the environment.
Internal Environment and Organizational Culture
At the time of the closure, the effectiveness of West Chester Private School (WCPS) as an open system was inadequate. One important factor that impacts the effectiveness of an open system is feedback. Feedback refers to the information that an open system receives from the external environment, which can be used to maintain a system at optimal working conditions or a steady state (Jung & Vakharia, 2019). In the case of WCPS, feedback could be received from parents, teachers, and students. At the time of the closure, none of these stakeholders was consulted. Instead, WCPS made a unilateral decision to close down two campuses without considering the input of parents, te.
Transformative Education: Towards a Relational, Justice-Oriented Approach to ...Zack Walsh
This paper aims to increase related knowledge across personal, social and ecological dimensions of sustainability and how it can be applied to support transformative learning. The paper provides a reflexive case study of the design, content and impact of a course on eco-justice that integrates relational learning with an equity and justice lens. The reflexive case study provides a critical, exploratory self-assessment, including interviews, group discussions and surveys with key stakeholders and course participants. The results show how relational approaches can support transformative learning for sustainability and provide concrete practices, pathways and recommendations for curricula development that other universities/training institutions could follow or learn from. Sustainability research, practice and education generally focuses on structural or systemic factors of transformation (e.g. technology, governance and policy) without due consideration as to how institutions and systems are shaping and shaped by the transformation of personal agency and subjectivity. This presents a vast untapped and under-studied potential for addressing deep leverage points for change by using a relational approach to link personal, societal and ecological transformations for sustainability.
Designing from Place - A Regenerative Framework and Methodology - BR7463 v6Bill Reed
The document describes a regenerative framework and methodology for design. It begins by outlining the need to transition to an ecological worldview to address environmental challenges. A regenerative methodology is proposed as a way for design practitioners to facilitate this transition. The methodology described was developed over 16 years and is rooted in ecological principles. It views humans as part of nature and aims to realign human activities with natural systems through a developmental process. The summary explores the underlying premises and concepts that shape the methodology, including its view of regeneration, human role, and approach of working developmentally.
Designing from place a regenerative framework and methodology - br7463 v6Bill Reed
1. The document describes a regenerative framework and methodology for design that is based on an ecological worldview. It aims to support the transition to more regenerative approaches in the built environment.
2. The methodology was developed and evolved over 16 years of practice. It is explored using a three-tier framework - the underlying premises and principles shape the overall methodology, and specific methods are chosen and applied accordingly.
3. The key premises of the regenerative methodology discussed are that humans should take their place as part of nature and focus on coevolving with natural systems, and that the first step is a change of mindset rather than just adopting new techniques.
External pressures like changing demographics and increasing student debt have created challenges for universities. Effective strategic processes require clear priorities aligned with stakeholders' values. Strategy lies at the leadership core by balancing constituencies' conflicting demands. Strategic planning models include linear, adaptive, and interpretive approaches. The linear method scans environments and pursues objectives. Adaptive strategy continuously adapts through experimentation. Interpretive strategy aligns mission and goals through symbols. Universities that strategically communicated culture changes through symbols were more resilient during financial difficulties.
This document provides an overview of wound healing, its functions, stages, mechanisms, factors affecting it, and complications.
A wound is a break in the integrity of the skin or tissues, which may be associated with disruption of the structure and function.
Healing is the body’s response to injury in an attempt to restore normal structure and functions.
Healing can occur in two ways: Regeneration and Repair
There are 4 phases of wound healing: hemostasis, inflammation, proliferation, and remodeling. This document also describes the mechanism of wound healing. Factors that affect healing include infection, uncontrolled diabetes, poor nutrition, age, anemia, the presence of foreign bodies, etc.
Complications of wound healing like infection, hyperpigmentation of scar, contractures, and keloid formation.
हिंदी वर्णमाला पीपीटी, hindi alphabet PPT presentation, hindi varnamala PPT, Hindi Varnamala pdf, हिंदी स्वर, हिंदी व्यंजन, sikhiye hindi varnmala, dr. mulla adam ali, hindi language and literature, hindi alphabet with drawing, hindi alphabet pdf, hindi varnamala for childrens, hindi language, hindi varnamala practice for kids, https://www.drmullaadamali.com
Beyond Degrees - Empowering the Workforce in the Context of Skills-First.pptxEduSkills OECD
Iván Bornacelly, Policy Analyst at the OECD Centre for Skills, OECD, presents at the webinar 'Tackling job market gaps with a skills-first approach' on 12 June 2024
LAND USE LAND COVER AND NDVI OF MIRZAPUR DISTRICT, UPRAHUL
This Dissertation explores the particular circumstances of Mirzapur, a region located in the
core of India. Mirzapur, with its varied terrains and abundant biodiversity, offers an optimal
environment for investigating the changes in vegetation cover dynamics. Our study utilizes
advanced technologies such as GIS (Geographic Information Systems) and Remote sensing to
analyze the transformations that have taken place over the course of a decade.
The complex relationship between human activities and the environment has been the focus
of extensive research and worry. As the global community grapples with swift urbanization,
population expansion, and economic progress, the effects on natural ecosystems are becoming
more evident. A crucial element of this impact is the alteration of vegetation cover, which plays a
significant role in maintaining the ecological equilibrium of our planet.Land serves as the foundation for all human activities and provides the necessary materials for
these activities. As the most crucial natural resource, its utilization by humans results in different
'Land uses,' which are determined by both human activities and the physical characteristics of the
land.
The utilization of land is impacted by human needs and environmental factors. In countries
like India, rapid population growth and the emphasis on extensive resource exploitation can lead
to significant land degradation, adversely affecting the region's land cover.
Therefore, human intervention has significantly influenced land use patterns over many
centuries, evolving its structure over time and space. In the present era, these changes have
accelerated due to factors such as agriculture and urbanization. Information regarding land use and
cover is essential for various planning and management tasks related to the Earth's surface,
providing crucial environmental data for scientific, resource management, policy purposes, and
diverse human activities.
Accurate understanding of land use and cover is imperative for the development planning
of any area. Consequently, a wide range of professionals, including earth system scientists, land
and water managers, and urban planners, are interested in obtaining data on land use and cover
changes, conversion trends, and other related patterns. The spatial dimensions of land use and
cover support policymakers and scientists in making well-informed decisions, as alterations in
these patterns indicate shifts in economic and social conditions. Monitoring such changes with the
help of Advanced technologies like Remote Sensing and Geographic Information Systems is
crucial for coordinated efforts across different administrative levels. Advanced technologies like
Remote Sensing and Geographic Information Systems
9
Changes in vegetation cover refer to variations in the distribution, composition, and overall
structure of plant communities across different temporal and spatial scales. These changes can
occur natural.
Strategies for Effective Upskilling is a presentation by Chinwendu Peace in a Your Skill Boost Masterclass organisation by the Excellence Foundation for South Sudan on 08th and 09th June 2024 from 1 PM to 3 PM on each day.
বাংলাদেশের অর্থনৈতিক সমীক্ষা ২০২৪ [Bangladesh Economic Review 2024 Bangla.pdf] কম্পিউটার , ট্যাব ও স্মার্ট ফোন ভার্সন সহ সম্পূর্ণ বাংলা ই-বুক বা pdf বই " সুচিপত্র ...বুকমার্ক মেনু 🔖 ও হাইপার লিংক মেনু 📝👆 যুক্ত ..
আমাদের সবার জন্য খুব খুব গুরুত্বপূর্ণ একটি বই ..বিসিএস, ব্যাংক, ইউনিভার্সিটি ভর্তি ও যে কোন প্রতিযোগিতা মূলক পরীক্ষার জন্য এর খুব ইম্পরট্যান্ট একটি বিষয় ...তাছাড়া বাংলাদেশের সাম্প্রতিক যে কোন ডাটা বা তথ্য এই বইতে পাবেন ...
তাই একজন নাগরিক হিসাবে এই তথ্য গুলো আপনার জানা প্রয়োজন ...।
বিসিএস ও ব্যাংক এর লিখিত পরীক্ষা ...+এছাড়া মাধ্যমিক ও উচ্চমাধ্যমিকের স্টুডেন্টদের জন্য অনেক কাজে আসবে ...
ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, and GDPR: Best Practices for Implementation and...PECB
Denis is a dynamic and results-driven Chief Information Officer (CIO) with a distinguished career spanning information systems analysis and technical project management. With a proven track record of spearheading the design and delivery of cutting-edge Information Management solutions, he has consistently elevated business operations, streamlined reporting functions, and maximized process efficiency.
Certified as an ISO/IEC 27001: Information Security Management Systems (ISMS) Lead Implementer, Data Protection Officer, and Cyber Risks Analyst, Denis brings a heightened focus on data security, privacy, and cyber resilience to every endeavor.
His expertise extends across a diverse spectrum of reporting, database, and web development applications, underpinned by an exceptional grasp of data storage and virtualization technologies. His proficiency in application testing, database administration, and data cleansing ensures seamless execution of complex projects.
What sets Denis apart is his comprehensive understanding of Business and Systems Analysis technologies, honed through involvement in all phases of the Software Development Lifecycle (SDLC). From meticulous requirements gathering to precise analysis, innovative design, rigorous development, thorough testing, and successful implementation, he has consistently delivered exceptional results.
Throughout his career, he has taken on multifaceted roles, from leading technical project management teams to owning solutions that drive operational excellence. His conscientious and proactive approach is unwavering, whether he is working independently or collaboratively within a team. His ability to connect with colleagues on a personal level underscores his commitment to fostering a harmonious and productive workplace environment.
Date: May 29, 2024
Tags: Information Security, ISO/IEC 27001, ISO/IEC 42001, Artificial Intelligence, GDPR
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Find out more about ISO training and certification services
Training: ISO/IEC 27001 Information Security Management System - EN | PECB
ISO/IEC 42001 Artificial Intelligence Management System - EN | PECB
General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR) - Training Courses - EN | PECB
Webinars: https://pecb.com/webinars
Article: https://pecb.com/article
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For more information about PECB:
Website: https://pecb.com/
LinkedIn: https://www.linkedin.com/company/pecb/
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/PECBInternational/
Slideshare: http://www.slideshare.net/PECBCERTIFICATION
it describes the bony anatomy including the femoral head , acetabulum, labrum . also discusses the capsule , ligaments . muscle that act on the hip joint and the range of motion are outlined. factors affecting hip joint stability and weight transmission through the joint are summarized.
Leveraging Generative AI to Drive Nonprofit InnovationTechSoup
In this webinar, participants learned how to utilize Generative AI to streamline operations and elevate member engagement. Amazon Web Service experts provided a customer specific use cases and dived into low/no-code tools that are quick and easy to deploy through Amazon Web Service (AWS.)
How to Fix the Import Error in the Odoo 17Celine George
An import error occurs when a program fails to import a module or library, disrupting its execution. In languages like Python, this issue arises when the specified module cannot be found or accessed, hindering the program's functionality. Resolving import errors is crucial for maintaining smooth software operation and uninterrupted development processes.
1. Green Campuses: The Road from Little Victories
to Systemic Transformation
Leith Sharp, Harvard University
1
2. Author Contact Details
Leith Sharp, Director, Harvard Green Campus Initiative
Email: Leith_Sharp@harvard.edu
Phone: 1 617 496 0922
Fax: 1 617 495 9409
Address: 38 Oxford St
Cambridge MA 01238
USA
Article Length: 6,900 words
Key words: Systemic Transformation, Environmental Sustainability, University
Operations.
2
3. Green Campuses
The Road from Little Victories to Systemic Transformation
Leith Sharp, Harvard University
Abstract
The purpose of this paper is to contribute to an emerging dialogue about how we can accelerate
progress towards institutionalizing a commitment to campus environmental sustainability throughout
the university sector. This paper seeks to utilize progress made to date, in the field of ‘greening’
universities, looking deeply into these experiences, to learn from them and to start revealing how they
may inform us to move into the realm of wide-spread institutional transformation.
A range of insights, lessons learnt and preferred approaches are presented emerging from seven
years of implementing campus environmental programs in universities both in Australia and the USA.
Many of these ideas have been further informed during a Churchill Fellowship, spent investigating
campus environment initiatives in over 30 universities in Europe and the USA. To assist in giving
further weight to the material presented, this paper draws upon the work of a various authors of
organizational change, leadership and management publications.
This paper is wide ranging in its subject matter as it is intended as a starting point for the reader
to pick and choose ideas that may warrant further investigation in their own university context. Even
though many of the ideas presented need further exploration and development, in their current state
they may prove of some value to the reader as a catalyst for a different level of institutional analysis.
The Environmental Imperative
The force of change now acting upon the university sector, with increasing pressure, is a global
environmental crisis of profound significance to both current and future generations. The nature of this
crisis is complex and wide reaching. Climate disturbance, acid rain, deforestation, species extinction,
fisheries depletion, soil erosion, toxic buildup in ecosystems, water, land and air pollution and ozone
depletion are amongst the menu of environmental problems that are forming a web of destruction
around the world. In short, every natural life support system is in long term systemic decline and every
human contributes directly or indirectly to the escalation of this decline. If universities are going to
survive into the next century, they must not only respond to this new force which, for the duration of
this essay, will be termed the environmental imperative, but they must also provide leadership for
broader society.
There are two key aspects of the environmental imperative that reveal the nature of the
challenge ahead for universities. The first aspect is that an effective solution in addressing the
environmental imperative will change all areas of university campus operations. The second aspect is
that an effective solution will be a moving target, in that new information will continuously become
available that will reveal new environmental requirements and opportunities. Given everything said so
far, the challenge for the university sector is to become skillful at the process of change itself. This
requires the university sector to expand its core mission of teaching and research to include learning.
Universities must become learning organizations, as well as teaching and research institutions.
3
4. The Response of Universities
Many universities have responded to the pressures of students, alumni, government,
administration or faculty, to make some attempt at addressing the environmental imperative in the way
campuses are operated. The common response of universities has been to establish an environment
committee to undertake a series of decision making tasks, employing one individual to implement and
control chosen solution programs. This structural and human resource framework assumes a level of
organizational rationality similar to that discussed by George P. Huber in his publication Managerial
Decision Making. The framework assumes that a committee and staff operating within the university
will be able to effectively:
♦ Define clear organizational goals and objectives
♦ Maintain goal and objective focus
♦ Explore the nature arising problems
♦ Generate alternative solutions to problems
♦ Properly evaluate available information to choose among the alternative solutions
♦ Implement chosen alternative
♦ Control the solution programs
The internal reality of the university does not support this type of organizational practice. The
complexity of the organization itself, compounded with the complexity of the environmental
imperative thwart most attempts to gain organizational agreement on goals, alternatives and solution
programs. As Simon and March identify, organizations are severely limited in their capacity to behave
rationally due to inherent characteristics such as: complexity, limited capacities to calculate all
parameters, the tendency towards ‘satisfycing’, fragmentation of problem and solution elements,
limited organizational repertoires, shifting coalitions, shortages of time and attention, quasi resolutions
to conflict and uncertainty avoidance. (Weiss, 2001).
All of these traits exist within universities. As a result of these rationality-limiting
characteristics of universities, environmental committees and staff are quickly forced to shift their
focus from broad reaching systemic transformation to well-bounded projects with lower levels of
participation, loosing significant momentum and breadth in their organizational impact. Consequently,
in a small percentage of universities across the world we now have many examples of how the
different initiatives such as recycling, energy efficient lighting, water conserving fittings, composting
toilets, passive solar design, green building design, carpooling programs, public transportation
initiatives, environmental procurement programs etc may work. However, we have very few examples
of universities that have actually institutionalized a systemic commitment to environmentally
sustainable campus operations, realizing the enormous efficiencies and opportunities that can be
gained in adopting systems based integrated design of new resource flows and infrastructure
developments.
It is critical to differentiate between project success and institution transformation. The journey
to succeed in building a showcase green building at your university is a very different journey to
successfully in institutionalizing a university-wide commitment to have all future buildings built green,
even though each journey can support the other. The former is a project success, the latter a systemic
4
5. transformation. Once we set our sights upon the goal of systemic transformation we can learn many
lessons from our past efforts to ‘green’ universities. Beyond the many useful project case studies of
new designs, technologies and management strategies that we have created there are at least two other
significant legacies of our efforts at greening universities. The first is an experiential understanding of
what approaches are effective in ensuring the survival and expansion of campus environmental
initiatives. The second is a deepening understanding of the nature of universities. The time is right to
utilize this experiential knowledge in exploring new ways of transcending the organizational
constraints characteristic of universities so that we may enter new potentials of systemic
transformation towards campus environmental sustainability.
Successful Approaches of Leading Green Campus Initiatives
It’s no secret that some green campus initiatives have been more successful in surviving and
expanding their effectiveness than others. In analyzing why this is the case it appears that regardless of
the organizational structure or the political positioning of any green campus initiative there are a
number of approaches that evidently maximize the survival and expansion of pioneering initiatives.
These approaches include:
Management support - secure a commitment in principal that can be gradually substantiated with
action
Effective coordination – dedicated, respectfully persistent, skilled communicator, creative and
personable
Maximize face to face communication – dialogue is the most effective means of progressing with the
change process, learn the language of other people, active listening skills are essential
Build both informal and formal support - ensure there is informal support and general understanding
before formalizing systems
Partnerships – seek a range of partnerships to support projects, optimize synergy’s, maximize broad
relevance and flow on effects
Ideas and the path of least resistance – run with the ideas that attract the most support and utilize these
as a means of generating the foundation for gradually more challenging ideas
Integrated planning and integrated design – utilize systems thinking to understand interrelationships
and to perceive beneficial design solutions
Trial, review, expand – remove risk and generate organizational support by running pilot projects
Continuous improvement, conscious development of a learning organization - where the educational
potential of experience and process is optimized.
The right management framework – the coordinator of environment programs must have freedom to
engage all levels of the university community, access to generate and strategically draw upon the
highest levels of management
Risk tolerant management staff - that are willing to support low risk innovation and mentor staff
working to forward the organizational vision for change
Student partnerships – tapping into talented, committed students and involving them and mentoring
them through paid positions and/or research projects, ensuring that their work is relevant and
integrated into university systems
5
6. Continuity – allow 2-3 years to establish foundation of trust, relationships, organizational familiarity
and skill base to be effective in medium to long term projects
Forums - for broad community involvement, discussion and consideration
Profile – share the learning experience with everyone who has any interest, maintain a profile within
and beyond the University for the efforts being undertaken
Information systems – a means of capturing and presenting information in digestible formats for all
levels of management
Successful application of these approaches requires a high competency in listening, communication,
relationship building, vision development, responsiveness and continuos strategic adaptation.
The Nature of Universities
The second important legacy of our green campus efforts to be discussed in this paper is an expanding
understanding of how universities work and how they respond to change. There are many
characteristics of universities that must be understood and addressed before we can hope to transform
them into environmentally sustainable institutions. What follows it a discussion of some of the more
significant characteristics of universities that are best understood by anyone who seeks to work at
building institutional commitment to environmental sustainability. This discussion does not attempt to
describe every relevant characteristic of universities but rather to begin this journey and hopefully
inspire a type of institutional analysis that can be further developed by the reader in the context of their
own institution.
Complexity
Universities are multi-structured, complex organization that exists without any single
observation point or any single control-center from which university wide changes can be programmed
and implemented. Further to this there are numerous subcultures of decision-making styles, time
constraints, priorities and experiences that exist within the university organization and varying degrees
of differentiation between schools and also between students, administration and faculty within
schools. On top of this, universities are generally ‘plagued with goal ambiguity and conflict, with
poorly understood problems that wander in and out of the system, with a variable environment and
decision-makers with other things on their minds’. (Cohen and March).
The challenge of systemic change in universities is often further compounded by the fact that
many universities are engaged in extensive growth. For example, Harvard University is preparing to
invest almost $1 billion in capital development within the next 5, resulting in a 12% increase in
available square feet for teaching, research and operations. This is an increase of 50% from the
previous five years. Needless to say, this is a significant environmental and organizational challenge
considering that globally, buildings use:
• 25% of the global wood harvest
• 40%of materials entering the global economy
• 35% of the total energy
• 25% of landfill space
• 3 billion tones of raw materials and
6
7. • Generate half the global output of greenhouse gases and agents of acid rain
(Source- Green Building Design workshop at University of Michigan)
Another challenging growth trend in universities is the rapid and unprecedented rise in energy
consumption due to the proliferation of computers and associated technologies. At Harvard University,
electricity consumption, a core source of greenhouse gases, has risen by over 18% during the last 6
years, or at a rate of 3% pa. Universities need to be reducing their greenhouse gas emissions by 3% pa
if they are to take any level of leadership in addressing the enormous problem of climate disturbance.
The magnitude of these trends provides us with the most concentrated and challenging opportunity to
change the current patterns of development towards environmental sustainability.
Growth trends at many universities have resulted in many university administrators, faculty and
perhaps even students experiencing the greatest workloads they ever have. This increase in the “energy
load on the system” is resulting in greater inefficiency in dealing with current problems as well as
inhibiting the capacity to address new problems – such as the environmental imperative. If we do
manage to get the environmental imperative on the agenda of university decision-makers it is often
seen as a late arriving competing priority that will have to wait its turn to be addressed - and who
knows when this will be.
Due to the inherent nature of universities, it is not appropriate to conceive of organizational
change as the outcome of a comprehensive and rationally executed strategy, even though such an
approach may play some part. It is evident that transformation will only come about when a large
number of people set up different priorities in both the large and the small arenas of the university,
establishing new routines and structures despite local conflicts and set-backs. This is a critical
understanding to have when launching into the challenge of catalyzing systemic change to support in
pursuit of campus environmental sustainability. The following sections of this paper will address why
we don’t yet have this wide-scale involvement and how we may achieve it in the near future.
Mental Models
As Peter Senge states, in his publication the Fifth Discipline:
‘The Unhealthiness of the world today is in direct proportion to our inability to see
it as a whole.’
Clearly, the university sector has failed to perceive itself as part of the whole planetary life support
system. Developing this understanding of place within the whole is a critical mental shift that must be
undertaken by a critical mass of individuals throughout every university on two levels:
♦ seeing their place in the whole of the planets life support systems and
♦ seeing their place in the whole of the campus system.
♦ seeing the campus systems place within society
People within universities, like people everywhere in society, have a number of mental models
that inform their behavior towards our natural life support systems. In general, these mental models
include subconscious and unspoken assumptions that:
7
8. ♦ the Earth is infinite,
♦ that there is an ‘away’ where you can throw things and
♦ materials from the Earth’s crust can be removed and re emitted almost anywhere without a problem
(e.g. metals, burnt fossil fuels, arsenic, asbestos etc).
♦ the individual is powerless to effect change within large and complex systems
In order to engage the university sector in the process of addressing the environmental
imperative, we must replace these unspoken mental models with new understandings that reflect
greater truths like:
♦ the Earth is finite and we are already living beyond its carrying capacity,
♦ there is no ‘away’ because everything in interconnected and
♦ nature locked away a range of materials in the Earth’s crust because they are poisonous to life
♦ the individual is the source of significant systemic change within large and complex environments
The Absurd Consensus
One of the other challenges we face in generating wide scale participation across the university is
the susceptibility of people to allow ourselves to be manipulated or controlled in order to achieve
security in the short term. Consider the work of Somoan Asch in the 1940’s and 1950’s, when he
conducted a range of tests to assess people’s capacity for independent judgment.
“Asch bought an unsuspecting subject into a room containing a group of people instructed to
falsify their answers in response to a simple perceptual test. In the test, the group was asked to
assert which of three lines in varying lengths on one graph most closely corresponded to a single
line on an adjacent graph. Unknown to the subjects of the experiments, Asch was pitting them
against a pre-arranged unanimous, yet entirely irrational consensus. Initially the group matched
lines that were reasonably similar. Gradually, however, Asch introduced widening discrepancies so
that eventually, the group consensus matched the lines of extremely different lengths, also mixing
in a few disagreements amongst the group for the sake of realism. The results were extraordinary:
only 20 percent of Asch’s subjects proved capable of independent judgement in the face of an
absurd consensus. Of these, many found the experiment highly stressful.” (Edwards p202)
This research indicates that people are conditioned to conform to group perceptions and to
doubt and withhold their individual perceptions if they are in conflict with the shared reality of those
around them. This has enormous significance when considering how people are currently responding
to the demise of the planetary systems that support human life. The degree of inaction around this
profoundly life threatening situation can perhaps best be explained by viewing our state as a massive
‘absurd consensus’ that is the product of our social conditioning which has enforced our subservience
to, and blind confidence in, shared societal constructs of reality.
The university sector is certainly engaged in this absurd consensus (or perhaps it is a
convenient consensus) and it is likely that until a critical mass of individuals actively change their
mental models, we will be unable to break through the group denial agreement that appears to be in
action. Given this susceptibility to conformity, the pursuit of systemic transformation fundamentally
requires an unerring and open exploration of truth, beyond any socialized framework.
8
9. System Archetypes - The Myth of the Rational University
According to Senge, systems archetypes are the simple stories that get told over and over again
within an organization. They are the system patterns that underscore many organizational responses
and activities. Failure to understand the system archetypes will often lead to fixing the problem but not
the thinking that produced the problem in the first place. It is possible that the inaction of the university
sector is largely connected to some powerful system archetypes. One such archetype to be explored
here is what will be termed the myth of rationality.
Fundamentally, the survival of the university sector depends upon holding the prized place
within the market, as the premier provider and regulator of higher education and research. To maintain
this position within society, a position secured by a deep and assumed trust in the nature of the
institution, the university sector must appear to be institutions of supreme rationality. After all, who
would agree to pay tuition for a degree or fund research from anything less than a rational institution?
Universities have developed a deep cultural assumption that it is necessary to preserve the
image of rationality, at all costs, as a means of ensuring organizational survival. It’s worth noting that
Universities are one of the oldest types of institutions in the world. During hundreds of years of
organizational evolution the image of rationality has been such a successful strategy that it was taken
for granted until it has even ‘dropped out of awareness’. This makes it extremely difficult and
potentially dangerous to address.
As a result of this cultural assumption, universities in general, persist in designing processes
and structures that are based on assumptions of rationality, despite the inevitable disfunction of such
approaches, because it supports the greater goal of appearing rational. From personal experience, it
appears that one of the most significant and prevalent forms of stress experienced by staff within
universities is the stress of having to sustain the myth of organizational rationality while facing the
reality of organizational irrationality.
Regardless of the damage it does, the need to protect the myth of rationality is a cultural
assumption within universities. It is one of the core ‘ basic assumptions and beliefs that are shared by
members of an organization, that operate unconsciously, and that define in a basic “taken for granted”
fashion, an organizations view of itself and its environment’. (Schein, 1987).
The myth of rationality greatly inhibits systemic transformation in a number of ways. It is one
of the greatest barriers to the development of a learning organization since it propagates the
assumption that universities have attained the highest possible levels of functionality and that whatever
is lacking must be accepted as an inevitable limitation of the system. The myth prevents institutional
analysis and reform as a response to disfunction since the political payoff for accepting disfunction is
much greater than the payoff for dealing with root causes.
It is possible that our approach to greening universities has suffered the containment of abiding
to the myth of organizational rationality. If we could approach greening universities with an
understanding of the true nature of the university, rather than the perceived nature of the organization,
then we may achieve a breakthrough in the depth and breadth of institutional transformation within the
university sector. Such a breakthrough would involve accessing new levels of institutional openness,
9
10. learning and collaboration that is intrinsic to organizational transformation. At the very least,
considering the nature of organizational culture within universities can deepen understanding and
inform strategy for achieving new levels of institutional engagement in environmental sustainability.
It is no accident that the most successful green campus initiatives are the ones that have been
able to adapt to the low levels of rationality that exist within the university organization. Instead of
operating only to a strategic plan these initiatives stand ever ready to embrace emerging opportunities,
shifting priorities and resources constantly. Instead of depending only on business models and
structured growth, these initiatives are highly organic in their growth patterns, with growth rates
reflecting opportunities of the day. Instead of relying upon operational structures and fixed staffing
levels, these initiatives remain adaptive in their structure and staffing. Rather than relying upon formal
links to decision-makers and formal decision-making forums these initiatives are extremely adept at
building networks of trusting and diverse relationships with a wide range of individuals. In essence, the
most successful green campus initiatives are able to thrive in the dynamic complexity of the university
because they strike a pragmatic balance between appearing rational (strategic plans, business models,
operational structures, and formal decision-making forums) and operating irrationally (organic,
adaptive, chaotic growth, networks of trust).
Achieving Broad Participation by Engaging Subcultures within Universities
It is possible that any effort to bring about wide scale participation must be responsive to the
existence of three predominant subcultures that exist within universities – faculty, administration and
students organizational cultures. These subcultures are the product of different group histories
associated with decision-making practices, time constraints, priorities, opportunities, threats and
experiences that each group has had within the university organization. There exists an inherent
tension within the power structure of the university organization as a result of the delegation of and
struggle for power between these three subcultures. Evidence suggests that the greatest leverage in
achieving institutional change occurs when all three subcultures or groups have a shared vision and a
sense of organizational alignment in their respective actions. What follows is a brief summary of some
of the key group characteristics of students, faculty and administrative staff and some ideas for how
these groups can effectively increase their impact in generating an institutional commitment to
environmental sustainability. This includes some direction for how they can be moved closer towards a
shared vision and organizational alignment.
Students
The first subculture to consider is the students. Students, for many years have been organizing
to address the issue of environmental sustainability. Now, almost every school has its own student
environment group. These groups depend on the emergence of passionate, committed students who
come together with other students, who they have often not previously met, to decide upon which
activities they can undertake with the precious time they have available. The students usually have no
resources, limited understanding of how the university itself is managed and no immediate access to
decision-making processes that they could directly influence. Despite these obstacles, an increasing
number of students are turning their attention to getting the university to become environmentally
responsible in campus operations, curriculum and research. The tendency is for students to engage in
short term activities that aim to raise the profile of certain issues and sometimes to embarrass the
university into responding to popular demand.
10
11. Some common experiences of students that have shaped the student culture includes:
♦ A shared sense that older generations and powerful institutions are failing to take action to address
environmental and social issues that are of significant concern to their generation
♦ a lack of access to timely information about the way the organization works,
♦ little guidance on how students can most effectively influence organizational decisions
♦ no effective means ensuring a continuum of organizational learning between multiple student
generations
This collective experience has resulted in a student culture that limits itself to focusing on
short-term project victories rather than longer-term systemic transformation. In reality, students have
much more potential power to catalyze and drive organizational transformation than they believe is
possible. Given the cultural characteristics of students, the greatest leverage in working with students is
to engage them in developing the five disciplines outlined by Peter Senge in the context of a chosen
project. Primary activities include:
♦ a shift of mind to understand their actual capacity to influence systemic change
♦ introducing systems thinking concepts to deepen understandings of organizational irrationality and
how the university actually functions,
♦ developing a shared vision by providing enough information and training and facilitating dialogue
♦ building team learning capabilities by organizing and facilitating regular meetings, building
personal mastery by establishing a context for personal learning and openness,
Working with students to develop these skills has been extremely fruitful at Harvard
University. In the last 12 months the Harvard Green Campus Initiative (HGCI) has undertaken this
type of work with students from a number of schools. This work lead to one student group to
successfully deliver a set of highly informed, strategic recommendations for greenhouse gas reductions
to the Deans of the largest school at Harvard University. The recommendations have already catalyzed
some significant action. Another student partnership of this nature resulted in a student run forum that
has been highly successful in engaging faculty, administration staff and students from three schools to
consider campus environmental sustainability. The political power of students, when combined with
the skill set listed above, forms an extremely effective catalyst for institutional transformation. Without
these skills, students are like the match that can’t find the fuel.
Faculty
Many faculty are actively expanding the environmental content in teaching and research
however it appears that far fewer faculty are attempting to influence decisions made around campus
operations. At Harvard University we have been able to identify only six faculty who are willing to
invest time in this issues at Harvard University. The involvement of even these committed individuals
is highly sporadic, lacking the necessary continuity and development to be successful.
Some of the common experiences of faculty include:
♦ Intense and ongoing pressures to compete for research funding, space and recognition
♦ Association, partnership and rivalry with a global community of research peers
♦ Rigorous and long term requirements to secure tenure
♦ Concern with success and quality of students
11
12. Perhaps the most significant organizational trait that limits faculty engagement in pursuing
campus environmental sustainability is the fact that historically, the demands of academic life resulted
in the structural removal of faculty from managing the operation of the campus. Instead, the faculty
employ and control administration staff to manage the campus freeing the faculty to pursue the real
mission of the organization - teaching and research. Throughout the university sector this structure has
served to imbed the assumption, amongst the faculty, that focusing on the campus is a distraction from
the core mission of teaching and research. Consequently, the few faculty who do attempt to take action
on campus environmental concerns tend to do it out of a commitment to voluntary public service.
While this is commendable, it is not a sustainable approach to the problem of securing faculty
engagement.
One of the more evident problems with this structure now is that administration staff who wish
to address the environmental imperative often find themselves blocked by faculty who wish to
maintain control, but have little understanding of the campus operations and associated environmental
implications. Throughout the university sector this structure has served to alienate the faculty from a
practice of self-study within the campus, while also inhibiting the capacity of administrative staff to
innovate.
The type of fundamental cultural shift that is necessary within the faculty is to value placing
themselves within the system of study. They must, as Senge states, perceive themselves ‘as part of the
feedback process, not standing apart from it.’ In this case the campus system could be viewed as the
feedback process for the activities of teaching and research. This shift would allow faculty to perceive
opportunities for alignment of their teaching and research efforts through practical experimentation and
application within the campus system. In this way the organization could achieve mission alignment
between teaching, research and campus operations, harnessing the vast collective learning process that
is currently underway within its walls, to benefit its own systems. At the very least this shift would
cause faculty to deal with the inherent irrationality of the organization to a new and challenging
degree.
Senge believes that ‘the bottom line of systems thinking is leverage – seeing where actions and
changes in structures can lead to significant, enduring improvements.’ It is possible that working with
faculty to remove perceived mission conflicts between teaching, research and campus operations will
provide the greatest leverage in freeing universities to become learning organizations of the highest
caliber.
One approach currently under development in the HGCI is to establish a visionary, visible and
project that articulates the environmental, social and political future for Harvard University in the
context of the Cambridge-Boston community, considering organizational and individual behavior,
materials and energy, infrastructure and transportation. This project would bring together faculty from
many different schools to engage in a rigorous academic research project that would effectively raise
the profile and legitimacy of the campus as a living laboratory for teaching and research.
Administration
In general, administrative staff are expected to service the operational needs of faculty and
students, freeing these groups up to go about the core mission of the organization – teaching and
research. Administrative staff are considered to have no direct role in the core mission of the
12
13. organization and as such they tend to be viewed as a relatively expendable resource. Politically and
structurally, administrative staff have much less in the way of formal organizational power. However,
due to their consistency, relationship building and access to organizational information, they are able to
significantly influence decisions, through the establishment of informal channels of influence and the
provision of information.
Administrative staff sit closest to the pressure point between the myth of rationality and the
reality of organizational irrationality. As a result, the leadership and engagement of administration staff
is profoundly tempered by the uncertainty and risk they feel in associated with getting caught in
between organizational irrationality and the sacred myth of rationality. Administrative staff are also
very wary of the power of faculty and students to not only block initiatives but to embarrass and isolate
administration staff.
Some effective ways to engage administrative staff include:
♦ The provision of centrally administered, interest free loan money to fund conservation projects
with reasonable payback periods
♦ Partnership with students - such as student internship programs or part-time student employees
dedicated to campus environmental projects
♦ Partnerships with faculty to support campus environmental research opportunities
♦ High profile signals from the highest levels of the university affirming the importance of campus
environmental efforts
The HGCI has established a number of projects, listed in Table 1, targeted at engaging administration
staff in the above listed activities.
Table 1:Harvard Green Campus Initiative Projects
Projects Description
Environmental Loan Fund University-wide financial incentive for cost effective conservation projects.
Best Practice Exchange A forum for university staff and students to present and share their innovative
projects that exemplify environmental best practice in Harvard University
operations
High Performance Building An initiative to develop Harvard University’s capabilities in the area of high
Initiative performance building design. High Performance building design achieves
optimal financial, human health, environment, aesthetic and building function
performance.
Harvard Alternative Fuel A program to research, evaluate and introduce environmentally preferred
Vehicle Program vehicles into Harvard fleet.
HGCI Website A tool for building communities of participation throughout Harvard University
and for providing relevant resources to further best practice in campus
environmental sustainability.
Greenhouse Gas Inventory An inventory of greenhouse gas emissions resulting from Harvard University
fossil fuel dependent utilities.
UOS EnergyStar and A program to position UOS as an EnergyStar and environmental procurement
Environmental Procurement service provider.
Program
FAS Computer Energy An initiative to allow the Faculty of Arts and Sciences to achieve considerable
Conservation Initiative and cost effective energy savings associated with a shift in computer purchasing
13
14. & operations.
Student Internship Program A program to involve students in project specific research and innovation.
Students are co-supervised by the HGCI and various university departments.
The core approach of the HGCI is to establish an engine for expanding participation and
learning throughout the university. This engine has two key elements as identified in Diagram 1 below.
The first of these elements is the interest free environmental loan fund. This is a revolving loan fund, in
the order of $3-5 million, made available to any university member who has identified a conservation
project with a payback period of not more than 5 years. This mechanism was first trialed in 1993-98
and proved itself to be highly successful. During this trial period, some $2.4 million was invested in 32
conservation projects, through the interest free, revolving loan fund structure. The average rate of
return on this investment was 34%, resulting in annual savings of over $880,000. The environmental
benefits were significant, including an annual reduction in greenhouse gases of 8.8 million pounds. (A
review of this trial was published in the International Journal of Sustainability in Higher Education, Volume 1,
Number 3, 2000, entitled Economic Incentives for Sustainable Resource Consumption at a Large University)
The second key element of the HGCI is to do the missionary work of building school
partnerships, undertaking strategic communications, education, training and promotional activities,
implementing a wide range of research, auditing, trial and evaluations, environmental information
system development, strategic planning for program expansion and fund raising. To date, this approach
has been highly successful, achieving a rapid expansion of participation within less than 18 months. In
essence, this success has been due to sustaining a pragmatic balance between appearing rational
(strategic plans, business models, operational structures, and formal decision-making forums) and
operating irrationally (organic, adaptive, chaotic growth, networks of trust).
14
15. Diagram 1: The Harvard Green Campus Initiative - Engine for Expansion
% Savings absorbed into
Communications,
related Schools budgets
Education, Training &
Promotions
Building School &
Resources invested to develop Department
and expand Faculty Engagement Commitment & Research,
and capabilities for innovation Participation Harvard Auditing,
Green Information
Campus Systems,
Evaluation
Initiative & Trial
Loan
Repaid Fund Raising
Savings Generated from Strategic Planning,
Reduced Operating Costs Program
Harvard Green Development and
Campus Expansion
Building Design & Renovation
Initiative
Environmental
Transport Purchasing
Loan Fund
Operations & Maintenance
Conservation
Projects Funded
Build School Based Management Support, Local Participation, Expertise & Information
The Challenge of Being the Change Agent
So far this paper has presented a number of ideas, insights and experiences associated with the
nature of universities, the challenge of systemic transformation and the types of approaches that can be
utilized in this effort. The final area of discussion to be addressed is a foundation piece to all of this -
the challenge of being the change agent.
For anyone who is actively engaged in catalyzing and managing change, it is critical to develop
a level of what Senge describes as personal mastery. Senge defines this as:
‘the discipline of continually clarifying and deepening our personal vision, of focusing
our energies, of developing patience, and of seeing reality objectively’
Working within any university to generate a change in the way decisions are currently made
15
16. requires a combination of all of these qualities, especially a high competency in experiential learning.
The immense dynamic complexity within universities requires a skillful approach to learning through
experience and reflection, when inside decision making arenas, outside them or in transition. The
learning must involve a deep and bold self-honesty, where one is prepared to acknowledge and work
with one’s experiences – especially the most difficult ones. This is a critical requirement for
undertaking the task of institutionalizing environmental sustainability within universities, since no
amount of experience can protect one from the inherent complex, diverse and dynamic nature of this
organization. Further to this, the practice of reflection, humility and reciprocity are essential in
maintaining positive relationships with the numerous participants.
One key aspect of personal mastery, explored by Senge, is the process of developing a person
vision and sustaining the creative tension that results from the difference between reality and the
vision. Senge suggests that a common process for individuals who confront this difference between
their personal vision and their daily reality, is that they experience a negative emotional response. This
in turn causes them to down grade the vision to the point at which the tension between reality and their
vision is not emotionally demanding.
This insight is particularly relevant in the situation of the university sector. It is hard to imagine
a larger gap between a reality and a vision than the gap that exists between universities today and a
personal vision of an environmentally sustainable university sector. To sustain this vision requires the
individual to engage in action towards meeting their vision in order to feed a sense of hope and
engagement. It also requires a practice of deep and personal reflection to help the individual process
the effects of dealing with the inertia, resistance, occasional political backlashing, or territorialism that
may be provoked along the way.
On a more personal note, at times the complexity and urgency of the environmental imperative
coupled with the complexity and inertia of the organizations we seek to change can overwhelm us. We
must all deal with the heartbreaking role of bearing witness to the spreading destruction of our world
and the ominous denial of our organizations and broader society. We are left alone to process what this
means for our own life journey as best we can. In these times it is important to be conscious that
despite the enormity of the situation, the fundamental power to create positive and wide reaching
change is within reach of all of us. Take any environmental challenge or organizational barrier and it is
possible to trace its fundamental creation and relief back to a change inside the human heart. As Ram
Daas states in his book ‘How Can I Help’:
“The basic social institution is the individual human heart. It is the source of the energy from
which all social action derives its power and purpose. The more we honor the integrity of that
source, the more chance our actions have of reaching and stirring others. But we must first be
whole hearted, fully integrated as we set out.”
The work of institutional transformation is a calling to undertake a parallel journey within
ourselves. As we seek to change what is around us we must seek to change what is within us also. If
we seek a world that is aware, kind, fair and sustainable then, as Mohandas K. Gandhi said, ‘We must
be the change we seek’. This truth can be taken into the deepest realms of spiritual practice where our
own human potential may be unfolded and exercised beyond our current conditioning to effectively
expand our energy, resilience, connection, vision and influence. Expanding our awareness of our inner
being and the way our inner world connects to the world around us is an essential requirement to
16
17. creating an environmental sustainable institution and society. While this may never be written into our
position descriptions, it is a truth that offers us salvation in so many ways that we can’t afford to put it
aside. We need to make the time for the journey within.
Conclusion
The environmental imperative requires a rapid and wide reaching response from the university
sector far beyond the kind of response we have seen to date. The ultimate vision of the
environmentally sustainable campus is a vision of a learning organization and a living laboratory for
the practice and development of environmental sustainability. The breadth and longevity of
organizational change that is needed for this to occur can only be achieved if the true nature of the
university organization is revealed and transformed. Mental models must be revealed, questioned and
expanded, and the absurd group consensus that is at play must be undone. The fundamental cultures of
separation that exist between faculty, administration staff and students must be transcended and
perceived mission conflicts between teaching, research and campus operations must be overcome.
Ideally, campus environmental initiatives must be protected and respected for the success of their
irrationality, freeing them from the onerous and self-defeating task of investing precious resources into
appearing rational. This would free all precious energy for the real and organic work of building wide-
ranging participation in the large and small arena’s throughout the university. And finally, change
agents must expand their understanding of the university organization and of themselves so that they
can expand and sustain their positive energy, vision and creativity in the face of all obstacles.
17
18. Bibliography
Cohen, M., and March, J., Leadership and Ambiguity – The American College President. 2nd Edition,
Harvard Business School Press, Boston.
Daas, R. (1987), How Can I Help, Rider, Random House, London.
Edwards, D. (1995), Free To Be Human – Intellectual Self-Defense in an Age of Illusions, Green
Books Ltd.
Huber, G. (1980), Managerial Decision Making, Glenview IL:Scott, Foreman & Co, Out of print.
Schein, E. (1987), Organizational Culture and Leadership, Jossey-Bass Publishers, San Francisco.
Senge, P. (1990), The Fifth Discipline – The Art and Practice of the Learning Organization, Currency
Doubleday, New York.
Weiss, C. (2001) A665 Organizational Decision-Making class notes, Harvard Graduate School of
Education, Boston.
18