SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 55
[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Enrichment of Prevention Trials through Genetic Risk Assessment and APOE Disclosure for Alzheimer’s Disease:  Data from the REVEAL Study ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Financial Disclosures in the Past 5 Years ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
[object Object],[object Object]
Cumulative Risk of Dementia in  First-Degree Relatives of Patients with AD 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Age (years) Cumulative Risk Lautenschlager et al,  Ann Neurol , 1996 Green et al.,  JAMA , 2002
Farrer et al.,  JAMA , 1997 Odds of Alzheimer’s Disease by  APOE and Age
Should APOE Genotyping be used for Risk Assessment in  Asymptomatic Individuals ? ,[object Object],Yes, but it offers only susceptibility information… ,[object Object],WOULD YOU LIKE TO KNOW YOUR OWN RISK OF DEVELOPING AD????
APOE Genotyping for Risk Assessment Conventional Wisdom in 2000 Why we should  NOT  do risk assessment  for Alzheimer’s Disease with APOE… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
APOE Genotyping for Risk Assessment The REVEAL “Rationale” in 2000 Why we should  EXPLORE  risk assessment for Alzheimer’s  Disease using APOE… ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
The REVEAL Study Is risk information beneficial or toxic?  Empirically measure the benefits and risks of genetic susceptibility testing…
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object]
Cupples et al.  Genetics in Medicine , 2004 Gene Risk
Cupples et al.,  Genetics in Medicine , 2004
Cupples et al.,  Genetics in Medicine , 2004 Christensen et al.,  Genetics in Medicine , 2008
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object]
Persons Agreeing to Participate in REVEAL  24% 64% Systematically Ascertained Self Referred Roberts et al.  Genetics in Medicine , 2004
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object]
REVEAL I: Randomized Clinical Trial 301 Participated in  Informational Phone Interview  51 Assigned to Receive Risk Assessment Without Genotype Disclosure 111 Assigned to Receive Risk Assessment With Genotype Disclosure 218 Participated in Education Session 183 Participated in Private Counseling and Blood Draw  Follow Up at: Six Weeks Six Months Twelve Months 162 Randomized Green et al.,  NEJM ,  2009
REVEAL I Study: Mean Anxiety Scale Score Green et al.,  NEJM ,  2009
REVEAL I Study: Adjusted Impact of Event Scores Green et al.,  NEJM , 2010
Post-Disclosure Change to Depression Symptoms:  1 year CES-D Score Green et al.,  NEJM ,  2009 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 -15 and below -14 to -5 -4 to 4 5 to 14 15 and above Percentage  of Cases Change in CES-D from baseline (points) Controls APOE  ε 4- APOE  ε 4+
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object]
Would Do Risk Assessment Again… 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Yes No Controls Intervention Group APOE  ε 4- APOE  ε 4+ Green et al.,  NEJM ,  2009
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object]
0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 6 weeks 1 year Accurate Inaccurate Don't Know Recall of Disclosure Information APOE Status (positive or negative) Eckert et al.,  Genet Med , 2006
Recall of Risk Information: Lifetime Risk Figures within 5 Points Eckert et al.,  Genet Med , 2006 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 6 weeks 1 year 6 weeks 1 year Accurate Inaccurate Don't Know
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object]
Insurance Changes 1 Year After APOE Disclosure Zick et al.,  Health Affairs , 2005 .
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object]
Health Behavior Changes at 1 Year (Vitamins, Exercise, Medications) * Chao, et al.  Alz Dis Assoc Dis , 2008 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% APOE  ε 4+ APOE  ε 4- Control
Health Behavior Changes at 6 Weeks (Nutrition and Supplements) * * Vernarelli et al., in press *
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object]
120 Assigned to  Extended Protocol 232 Assigned to  Condensed Protocol 112 Completed Pre-education Questionnaire 357 Participated in  Phone Interview   106 Participated in in-person Education Session 198 Participated in Question and Answer Session, Blood Draw 210 Completed Education Brochure Sent by Mail 217 Completed Pre-education Questionnaire & Medical History 93 Received Risk Assessment/APOE disclosure 101 Participated in Individual Counseling Session, Medical History & Blood Draw 187 Received Risk Assessment/APOE disclosure 352 Randomized Follow-up: 6 Weeks 6 Months 12 Months REVEAL II
The REVEAL II Study:  Condensed “Education”
REVEAL II:  Mean Adjusted BAI Scores *Adjusted for age, gender, years of education, baseline CES-D, baseline score (no baseline score for IES)
REVEAL II:  Mean Adjusted IES Scores *Adjusted for age, gender, years of education, baseline CES-D, baseline score (no baseline score for IES)
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object],[object Object]
Among those who accurately recall their risk disclosure (n = 158) 47.5% continue to believe otherwise! Linnenbringer et al.,  Genetics in Medicine , in press
REVEAL Questions ,[object Object],[object Object]
Who did you tell about the results of your test? Ashida et al.,  J Health Communication , in press.
REVEAL III:  The Impact of Pleiotropic Effects AD-only Risk Assessment ( n =138) Randomization ( n =291) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],AD Risk Assessment w. CVD Risk Disclosure  ( n =119) ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],6 Week Follow-Up  ( n =252) 12 Month Follow-Up  ( n =195. In progress)
REVEAL III:  What Were People Told? ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object]
Any Behavior Change No  ε 4 ε 4+ % reporting change 45% 57% 48% 77% 0% 100% AD-Only Risk Info AD & CVD Risk Info
Exercise Change No  ε 4 ε 4+ % reporting change 27% 34% 24% 63% 0% 100% AD-Only Risk Info AD & CVD Risk Info
Diet Change No  ε 4 ε 4+ % reporting change 27% 33% 28% 53% 0% 100% AD-Only Risk Info AD & CVD Risk Info
Mental Exercise Change No  ε 4 ε 4+ % reporting change 16% 25% 34% 37% 0% 100% AD-Only Risk Info AD & CVD Risk Info
REVEAL IV (2010-2013) Can we combine risk elements of  GENOTYPE  and  PHENOTYPE ?  What is the impact of APOE on risk of developing AD in persons with MCI?
Data for Risk Estimates in REVEAL IV Petersen et al.,  NEJM, 2005 .
Data for Risk Estimates in REVEAL IV Estimated from primary data provided by Petersen et al.
[object Object],[object Object]
PARADE Magazine! August 23, 2008 Direct to Consumer Marketing (DTC) Molecular genetic testing
Personal Genome Testing and Disclosure REVEAL
My Navigenics Results
APOE-  4 Genotypes in the  US Caucasian Population 3/3 (67%) 2/3 (8%) 2/2 (1%) 3/4 (20%) 4/4 (2%) 2/4 (3%)
Enriched Research Registry 11,500 (23%) e4/ex 50,000 volunteers 1000 (2%) e4/e4
REVEAL Study Collaborators Consultants George Annas, JD, MPH Barbara Biesecker, MS Deepak Bhatt, MD Deborah Blacker, MD, ScD Gail Geller, PhD Eric Juengst, PhD Jason Karlawish, MD Theresa Marteau, PhD Ronald Petersen, PhD, MD Kimberly Quaid, PhD  Deborah Roter, DrPH Eric Topel, MD ,[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],[object Object],Howard University Thomas Obisesan, MD, MPH  Grace-Ann Fasaye, ScM, CGC  Charmaine Royal, PhD Tiffiney Greer, CGC Case Western Melissa Barber, ScM Peter Whitehouse, MD  Cornell Normal Relkin, MD, PhD Elana Cox, MS Lisa Ravdin, PhD External Advisory Board Robert Cook-Deegan, PhD

More Related Content

What's hot

What is brain health? - Gavin Giovannoni
What is brain health? - Gavin GiovannoniWhat is brain health? - Gavin Giovannoni
What is brain health? - Gavin GiovannoniMS Trust
 
2015 05-20 Radboudumc REshape breakfast meeting Alain van Gool
2015 05-20 Radboudumc REshape breakfast meeting Alain van Gool2015 05-20 Radboudumc REshape breakfast meeting Alain van Gool
2015 05-20 Radboudumc REshape breakfast meeting Alain van GoolAlain van Gool
 
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 9 2015
MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 9 2015MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 9 2015
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 9 2015Marie Benz MD FAAD
 
Parkinson's 2015 meeting 2nd July London
Parkinson's 2015 meeting 2nd July LondonParkinson's 2015 meeting 2nd July London
Parkinson's 2015 meeting 2nd July Londonanoyce
 
Non-adherence of CML patients - Results of the global survey of the CML Ad...
Non-adherence of CML patients - Results of the global survey of the CML Ad...Non-adherence of CML patients - Results of the global survey of the CML Ad...
Non-adherence of CML patients - Results of the global survey of the CML Ad...jangeissler
 
Bogota delirium051110
Bogota delirium051110Bogota delirium051110
Bogota delirium051110hospira2010
 
The similarities and differences of the recommendations of azithromycin ther...
The similarities and differences of  the recommendations of azithromycin ther...The similarities and differences of  the recommendations of azithromycin ther...
The similarities and differences of the recommendations of azithromycin ther...WAidid
 
Helen presentation for upload
Helen presentation for uploadHelen presentation for upload
Helen presentation for uploadveronicawain65
 
Deconstructing Modern Illness: Idiopathic or Iatrogenic?
Deconstructing Modern Illness: Idiopathic or Iatrogenic? Deconstructing Modern Illness: Idiopathic or Iatrogenic?
Deconstructing Modern Illness: Idiopathic or Iatrogenic? Lucine Health Sciences
 
Resident Work Hours To AMSA National 2005
Resident Work Hours To AMSA National 2005Resident Work Hours To AMSA National 2005
Resident Work Hours To AMSA National 2005mdmendoz
 
Austin Journal of Genetics and Genomic Research
Austin Journal of Genetics and Genomic ResearchAustin Journal of Genetics and Genomic Research
Austin Journal of Genetics and Genomic ResearchAustin Publishing Group
 
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 6 2015
MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 6 2015MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 6 2015
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 6 2015Marie Benz MD FAAD
 
The Changing Face of Trauma Care
The Changing Face of Trauma Care The Changing Face of Trauma Care
The Changing Face of Trauma Care Camilla Wong
 
Evidence Based Prognostication Peoria 2010 (1)
Evidence Based Prognostication Peoria 2010 (1)Evidence Based Prognostication Peoria 2010 (1)
Evidence Based Prognostication Peoria 2010 (1)Christian Sinclair
 
Family Planning for Persons Living with HIVAIDS_2015 AR and MS
Family Planning for Persons Living with HIVAIDS_2015 AR and MSFamily Planning for Persons Living with HIVAIDS_2015 AR and MS
Family Planning for Persons Living with HIVAIDS_2015 AR and MSNikole Gettings
 

What's hot (20)

What is brain health? - Gavin Giovannoni
What is brain health? - Gavin GiovannoniWhat is brain health? - Gavin Giovannoni
What is brain health? - Gavin Giovannoni
 
Absolute Final PIP poster!!
Absolute Final PIP poster!!Absolute Final PIP poster!!
Absolute Final PIP poster!!
 
2015 05-20 Radboudumc REshape breakfast meeting Alain van Gool
2015 05-20 Radboudumc REshape breakfast meeting Alain van Gool2015 05-20 Radboudumc REshape breakfast meeting Alain van Gool
2015 05-20 Radboudumc REshape breakfast meeting Alain van Gool
 
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 9 2015
MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 9 2015MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 9 2015
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 9 2015
 
Parkinson's 2015 meeting 2nd July London
Parkinson's 2015 meeting 2nd July LondonParkinson's 2015 meeting 2nd July London
Parkinson's 2015 meeting 2nd July London
 
Non-adherence of CML patients - Results of the global survey of the CML Ad...
Non-adherence of CML patients - Results of the global survey of the CML Ad...Non-adherence of CML patients - Results of the global survey of the CML Ad...
Non-adherence of CML patients - Results of the global survey of the CML Ad...
 
BIO International Convention
BIO International ConventionBIO International Convention
BIO International Convention
 
Bogota delirium051110
Bogota delirium051110Bogota delirium051110
Bogota delirium051110
 
The similarities and differences of the recommendations of azithromycin ther...
The similarities and differences of  the recommendations of azithromycin ther...The similarities and differences of  the recommendations of azithromycin ther...
The similarities and differences of the recommendations of azithromycin ther...
 
Helen presentation for upload
Helen presentation for uploadHelen presentation for upload
Helen presentation for upload
 
Barriers to Cure HIV in Women
Barriers to Cure HIV in WomenBarriers to Cure HIV in Women
Barriers to Cure HIV in Women
 
Deconstructing Modern Illness: Idiopathic or Iatrogenic?
Deconstructing Modern Illness: Idiopathic or Iatrogenic? Deconstructing Modern Illness: Idiopathic or Iatrogenic?
Deconstructing Modern Illness: Idiopathic or Iatrogenic?
 
Resident Work Hours To AMSA National 2005
Resident Work Hours To AMSA National 2005Resident Work Hours To AMSA National 2005
Resident Work Hours To AMSA National 2005
 
Austin Journal of Genetics and Genomic Research
Austin Journal of Genetics and Genomic ResearchAustin Journal of Genetics and Genomic Research
Austin Journal of Genetics and Genomic Research
 
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 6 2015
MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 6 2015MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 6 2015
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Exclusive Interviews June 6 2015
 
dspub6
dspub6dspub6
dspub6
 
The Changing Face of Trauma Care
The Changing Face of Trauma Care The Changing Face of Trauma Care
The Changing Face of Trauma Care
 
Evidence Based Prognostication Peoria 2010 (1)
Evidence Based Prognostication Peoria 2010 (1)Evidence Based Prognostication Peoria 2010 (1)
Evidence Based Prognostication Peoria 2010 (1)
 
International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)
International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)
International Journal of Science and Research (IJSR)
 
Family Planning for Persons Living with HIVAIDS_2015 AR and MS
Family Planning for Persons Living with HIVAIDS_2015 AR and MSFamily Planning for Persons Living with HIVAIDS_2015 AR and MS
Family Planning for Persons Living with HIVAIDS_2015 AR and MS
 

Viewers also liked

WACE SoMe presentation
WACE SoMe presentationWACE SoMe presentation
WACE SoMe presentationchristyorgeta
 
"寫代碼 - 一個監獄世界矩陣OUT SPIRITUAL
"寫代碼 - 一個監獄世界矩陣OUT SPIRITUAL "寫代碼 - 一個監獄世界矩陣OUT SPIRITUAL
"寫代碼 - 一個監獄世界矩陣OUT SPIRITUAL cdoecrt
 
Focus Groups, Citizens’ Juries and Open Space method: Innovative tools of pub...
Focus Groups, Citizens’ Juries and Open Space method: Innovative tools of pub...Focus Groups, Citizens’ Juries and Open Space method: Innovative tools of pub...
Focus Groups, Citizens’ Juries and Open Space method: Innovative tools of pub...Iwl Pcu
 
γεωγραφια
γεωγραφιαγεωγραφια
γεωγραφιαxrysa123
 
Traffic Cone Marketing - Marketing for Restaurants PowerPoint
Traffic Cone Marketing - Marketing for Restaurants PowerPointTraffic Cone Marketing - Marketing for Restaurants PowerPoint
Traffic Cone Marketing - Marketing for Restaurants PowerPointDan McMullen
 
Actividad individual Unidad 1 Cesar Augusto Severiche Marquez
Actividad individual Unidad 1 Cesar Augusto Severiche MarquezActividad individual Unidad 1 Cesar Augusto Severiche Marquez
Actividad individual Unidad 1 Cesar Augusto Severiche MarquezCesar Agusto Severiche Marquez
 
Many uses of ICT for Development of Mozambique
Many uses of ICT for Development of MozambiqueMany uses of ICT for Development of Mozambique
Many uses of ICT for Development of MozambiqueL. Neves Cabral Domingos
 
Intro To Virtual Comm Tag 111908
Intro To Virtual Comm Tag 111908Intro To Virtual Comm Tag 111908
Intro To Virtual Comm Tag 111908Erika Bjune
 
Best hospital in uppal
Best hospital in uppalBest hospital in uppal
Best hospital in uppalLavanya Lav
 
SumitomoBlack Ant ID Pestech 2014
SumitomoBlack Ant ID Pestech 2014SumitomoBlack Ant ID Pestech 2014
SumitomoBlack Ant ID Pestech 2014Eris Hess
 
Langkah langkah membuat email dengan gmail
Langkah langkah membuat email dengan gmailLangkah langkah membuat email dengan gmail
Langkah langkah membuat email dengan gmailrizkiadrianpolman
 
http://whatisarsi.carpaltunnelnaturalcures.com
http://whatisarsi.carpaltunnelnaturalcures.comhttp://whatisarsi.carpaltunnelnaturalcures.com
http://whatisarsi.carpaltunnelnaturalcures.comJames Blackstone
 
Trevor Arnold's ECA Conference Presentation
Trevor Arnold's ECA Conference PresentationTrevor Arnold's ECA Conference Presentation
Trevor Arnold's ECA Conference PresentationTrevor Arnold
 
icalendar nguyen duc thang
icalendar nguyen duc thangicalendar nguyen duc thang
icalendar nguyen duc thangkillertanya
 

Viewers also liked (20)

WACE SoMe presentation
WACE SoMe presentationWACE SoMe presentation
WACE SoMe presentation
 
"寫代碼 - 一個監獄世界矩陣OUT SPIRITUAL
"寫代碼 - 一個監獄世界矩陣OUT SPIRITUAL "寫代碼 - 一個監獄世界矩陣OUT SPIRITUAL
"寫代碼 - 一個監獄世界矩陣OUT SPIRITUAL
 
Focus Groups, Citizens’ Juries and Open Space method: Innovative tools of pub...
Focus Groups, Citizens’ Juries and Open Space method: Innovative tools of pub...Focus Groups, Citizens’ Juries and Open Space method: Innovative tools of pub...
Focus Groups, Citizens’ Juries and Open Space method: Innovative tools of pub...
 
γεωγραφια
γεωγραφιαγεωγραφια
γεωγραφια
 
ScottDowdenCV
ScottDowdenCVScottDowdenCV
ScottDowdenCV
 
Kristian
KristianKristian
Kristian
 
Traffic Cone Marketing - Marketing for Restaurants PowerPoint
Traffic Cone Marketing - Marketing for Restaurants PowerPointTraffic Cone Marketing - Marketing for Restaurants PowerPoint
Traffic Cone Marketing - Marketing for Restaurants PowerPoint
 
Actividad individual Unidad 1 Cesar Augusto Severiche Marquez
Actividad individual Unidad 1 Cesar Augusto Severiche MarquezActividad individual Unidad 1 Cesar Augusto Severiche Marquez
Actividad individual Unidad 1 Cesar Augusto Severiche Marquez
 
Many uses of ICT for Development of Mozambique
Many uses of ICT for Development of MozambiqueMany uses of ICT for Development of Mozambique
Many uses of ICT for Development of Mozambique
 
Intro To Virtual Comm Tag 111908
Intro To Virtual Comm Tag 111908Intro To Virtual Comm Tag 111908
Intro To Virtual Comm Tag 111908
 
Pocket Guide: Pharmacokinetics Made Easy - sample
Pocket Guide: Pharmacokinetics Made Easy - sample Pocket Guide: Pharmacokinetics Made Easy - sample
Pocket Guide: Pharmacokinetics Made Easy - sample
 
Mockup
MockupMockup
Mockup
 
Best hospital in uppal
Best hospital in uppalBest hospital in uppal
Best hospital in uppal
 
SumitomoBlack Ant ID Pestech 2014
SumitomoBlack Ant ID Pestech 2014SumitomoBlack Ant ID Pestech 2014
SumitomoBlack Ant ID Pestech 2014
 
Langkah langkah membuat email dengan gmail
Langkah langkah membuat email dengan gmailLangkah langkah membuat email dengan gmail
Langkah langkah membuat email dengan gmail
 
http://whatisarsi.carpaltunnelnaturalcures.com
http://whatisarsi.carpaltunnelnaturalcures.comhttp://whatisarsi.carpaltunnelnaturalcures.com
http://whatisarsi.carpaltunnelnaturalcures.com
 
Marc0s
Marc0sMarc0s
Marc0s
 
Trevor Arnold's ECA Conference Presentation
Trevor Arnold's ECA Conference PresentationTrevor Arnold's ECA Conference Presentation
Trevor Arnold's ECA Conference Presentation
 
Cultura ciudadana grupo 34
Cultura ciudadana grupo 34Cultura ciudadana grupo 34
Cultura ciudadana grupo 34
 
icalendar nguyen duc thang
icalendar nguyen duc thangicalendar nguyen duc thang
icalendar nguyen duc thang
 

Similar to APOE Genotyping and Risk Disclosure Impacts in the REVEAL Studies

11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo tBenitoSumpter862
 
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo tSantosConleyha
 
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Interviews Month in Review
MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Interviews Month in ReviewMedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Interviews Month in Review
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Interviews Month in ReviewMarie Benz MD FAAD
 
Ethical dilemas of clinical genetics
Ethical dilemas of clinical geneticsEthical dilemas of clinical genetics
Ethical dilemas of clinical geneticstariko49
 
MD Consult 改版說明會 - 實證醫學 – 資料庫使用與臨床實作
MD Consult 改版說明會 - 實證醫學 – 資料庫使用與臨床實作MD Consult 改版說明會 - 實證醫學 – 資料庫使用與臨床實作
MD Consult 改版說明會 - 實證醫學 – 資料庫使用與臨床實作Chung-Han Yang
 
Current Topics in CareA Case of Inappropriate Apolipoprote
Current Topics in CareA Case of Inappropriate ApolipoproteCurrent Topics in CareA Case of Inappropriate Apolipoprote
Current Topics in CareA Case of Inappropriate ApolipoproteOllieShoresna
 
HAART Making ART Possible 2015 Fall P2P
HAART Making ART Possible 2015 Fall P2PHAART Making ART Possible 2015 Fall P2P
HAART Making ART Possible 2015 Fall P2PNikole Gettings
 
"How Scientific Wellness will Drive The Future of Health" - Nathan Price (Pro...
"How Scientific Wellness will Drive The Future of Health" - Nathan Price (Pro..."How Scientific Wellness will Drive The Future of Health" - Nathan Price (Pro...
"How Scientific Wellness will Drive The Future of Health" - Nathan Price (Pro...Hyper Wellbeing
 
Meg Ehm: Fueling a Genetics-Driven Drug Discovery Organization
Meg Ehm: Fueling a Genetics-Driven Drug Discovery OrganizationMeg Ehm: Fueling a Genetics-Driven Drug Discovery Organization
Meg Ehm: Fueling a Genetics-Driven Drug Discovery OrganizationTHL
 
Evidence Based Practice_lecture 5_slides
Evidence Based Practice_lecture 5_slidesEvidence Based Practice_lecture 5_slides
Evidence Based Practice_lecture 5_slidesZakCooper1
 
Fo gm vi-cinnamonbloss_idiom_7march2013_fina_lpost
Fo gm vi-cinnamonbloss_idiom_7march2013_fina_lpostFo gm vi-cinnamonbloss_idiom_7march2013_fina_lpost
Fo gm vi-cinnamonbloss_idiom_7march2013_fina_lpostCinnamonBloss
 
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.pptKEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.pptPriyankaGawai6
 
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.pptKEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.pptPriyankaSharma89719
 
Evidence to Decision tables – 11th CE&B's research day presentation
Evidence to Decision tables – 11th CE&B's research day presentationEvidence to Decision tables – 11th CE&B's research day presentation
Evidence to Decision tables – 11th CE&B's research day presentationCarlos Cuello
 
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical ApprPUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical ApprTakishaPeck109
 
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr.docx
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr.docxPUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr.docx
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr.docxwoodruffeloisa
 
EnvChemExposure_Presentation
EnvChemExposure_PresentationEnvChemExposure_Presentation
EnvChemExposure_PresentationLila Rubenstein
 

Similar to APOE Genotyping and Risk Disclosure Impacts in the REVEAL Studies (20)

11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
 
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
11. Identifying the Elements of the Limitations & ImplicationsGo t
 
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Interviews Month in Review
MedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Interviews Month in ReviewMedicalResearch.com:  Medical Research Interviews Month in Review
MedicalResearch.com: Medical Research Interviews Month in Review
 
Ethical dilemas of clinical genetics
Ethical dilemas of clinical geneticsEthical dilemas of clinical genetics
Ethical dilemas of clinical genetics
 
MD Consult 改版說明會 - 實證醫學 – 資料庫使用與臨床實作
MD Consult 改版說明會 - 實證醫學 – 資料庫使用與臨床實作MD Consult 改版說明會 - 實證醫學 – 資料庫使用與臨床實作
MD Consult 改版說明會 - 實證醫學 – 資料庫使用與臨床實作
 
Dancing: Alternative Therapies
Dancing: Alternative TherapiesDancing: Alternative Therapies
Dancing: Alternative Therapies
 
Current Topics in CareA Case of Inappropriate Apolipoprote
Current Topics in CareA Case of Inappropriate ApolipoproteCurrent Topics in CareA Case of Inappropriate Apolipoprote
Current Topics in CareA Case of Inappropriate Apolipoprote
 
HAART Making ART Possible 2015 Fall P2P
HAART Making ART Possible 2015 Fall P2PHAART Making ART Possible 2015 Fall P2P
HAART Making ART Possible 2015 Fall P2P
 
HINZ Education Workshop: Evidence Based Practice
HINZ Education Workshop: Evidence Based PracticeHINZ Education Workshop: Evidence Based Practice
HINZ Education Workshop: Evidence Based Practice
 
"How Scientific Wellness will Drive The Future of Health" - Nathan Price (Pro...
"How Scientific Wellness will Drive The Future of Health" - Nathan Price (Pro..."How Scientific Wellness will Drive The Future of Health" - Nathan Price (Pro...
"How Scientific Wellness will Drive The Future of Health" - Nathan Price (Pro...
 
Meg Ehm: Fueling a Genetics-Driven Drug Discovery Organization
Meg Ehm: Fueling a Genetics-Driven Drug Discovery OrganizationMeg Ehm: Fueling a Genetics-Driven Drug Discovery Organization
Meg Ehm: Fueling a Genetics-Driven Drug Discovery Organization
 
Evidence Based Practice_lecture 5_slides
Evidence Based Practice_lecture 5_slidesEvidence Based Practice_lecture 5_slides
Evidence Based Practice_lecture 5_slides
 
Fo gm vi-cinnamonbloss_idiom_7march2013_fina_lpost
Fo gm vi-cinnamonbloss_idiom_7march2013_fina_lpostFo gm vi-cinnamonbloss_idiom_7march2013_fina_lpost
Fo gm vi-cinnamonbloss_idiom_7march2013_fina_lpost
 
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.pptKEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
 
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.pptKEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
KEECH AND PIZZI-- Geriatric_Syndromes3-11.ppt
 
Evidence to Decision tables – 11th CE&B's research day presentation
Evidence to Decision tables – 11th CE&B's research day presentationEvidence to Decision tables – 11th CE&B's research day presentation
Evidence to Decision tables – 11th CE&B's research day presentation
 
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical ApprPUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr
 
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr.docx
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr.docxPUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr.docx
PUBH6005 Epidemiology Assignment- 3 Critical Appr.docx
 
MyRISQ
MyRISQMyRISQ
MyRISQ
 
EnvChemExposure_Presentation
EnvChemExposure_PresentationEnvChemExposure_Presentation
EnvChemExposure_Presentation
 

APOE Genotyping and Risk Disclosure Impacts in the REVEAL Studies

  • 1.
  • 2.
  • 3.
  • 4. Cumulative Risk of Dementia in First-Degree Relatives of Patients with AD 40 50 60 70 80 90 100 0 .1 .2 .3 .4 .5 .6 .7 Age (years) Cumulative Risk Lautenschlager et al, Ann Neurol , 1996 Green et al., JAMA , 2002
  • 5. Farrer et al., JAMA , 1997 Odds of Alzheimer’s Disease by APOE and Age
  • 6.
  • 7.
  • 8.
  • 9. The REVEAL Study Is risk information beneficial or toxic? Empirically measure the benefits and risks of genetic susceptibility testing…
  • 10.
  • 11. Cupples et al. Genetics in Medicine , 2004 Gene Risk
  • 12. Cupples et al., Genetics in Medicine , 2004
  • 13. Cupples et al., Genetics in Medicine , 2004 Christensen et al., Genetics in Medicine , 2008
  • 14.
  • 15. Persons Agreeing to Participate in REVEAL 24% 64% Systematically Ascertained Self Referred Roberts et al. Genetics in Medicine , 2004
  • 16.
  • 17. REVEAL I: Randomized Clinical Trial 301 Participated in Informational Phone Interview 51 Assigned to Receive Risk Assessment Without Genotype Disclosure 111 Assigned to Receive Risk Assessment With Genotype Disclosure 218 Participated in Education Session 183 Participated in Private Counseling and Blood Draw Follow Up at: Six Weeks Six Months Twelve Months 162 Randomized Green et al., NEJM , 2009
  • 18. REVEAL I Study: Mean Anxiety Scale Score Green et al., NEJM , 2009
  • 19. REVEAL I Study: Adjusted Impact of Event Scores Green et al., NEJM , 2010
  • 20. Post-Disclosure Change to Depression Symptoms: 1 year CES-D Score Green et al., NEJM , 2009 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 -15 and below -14 to -5 -4 to 4 5 to 14 15 and above Percentage of Cases Change in CES-D from baseline (points) Controls APOE ε 4- APOE ε 4+
  • 21.
  • 22. Would Do Risk Assessment Again… 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% Yes No Controls Intervention Group APOE ε 4- APOE ε 4+ Green et al., NEJM , 2009
  • 23.
  • 24. 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% 6 weeks 1 year Accurate Inaccurate Don't Know Recall of Disclosure Information APOE Status (positive or negative) Eckert et al., Genet Med , 2006
  • 25. Recall of Risk Information: Lifetime Risk Figures within 5 Points Eckert et al., Genet Med , 2006 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 6 weeks 1 year 6 weeks 1 year Accurate Inaccurate Don't Know
  • 26.
  • 27. Insurance Changes 1 Year After APOE Disclosure Zick et al., Health Affairs , 2005 .
  • 28.
  • 29. Health Behavior Changes at 1 Year (Vitamins, Exercise, Medications) * Chao, et al. Alz Dis Assoc Dis , 2008 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% APOE ε 4+ APOE ε 4- Control
  • 30. Health Behavior Changes at 6 Weeks (Nutrition and Supplements) * * Vernarelli et al., in press *
  • 31.
  • 32. 120 Assigned to Extended Protocol 232 Assigned to Condensed Protocol 112 Completed Pre-education Questionnaire 357 Participated in Phone Interview 106 Participated in in-person Education Session 198 Participated in Question and Answer Session, Blood Draw 210 Completed Education Brochure Sent by Mail 217 Completed Pre-education Questionnaire & Medical History 93 Received Risk Assessment/APOE disclosure 101 Participated in Individual Counseling Session, Medical History & Blood Draw 187 Received Risk Assessment/APOE disclosure 352 Randomized Follow-up: 6 Weeks 6 Months 12 Months REVEAL II
  • 33. The REVEAL II Study: Condensed “Education”
  • 34. REVEAL II: Mean Adjusted BAI Scores *Adjusted for age, gender, years of education, baseline CES-D, baseline score (no baseline score for IES)
  • 35. REVEAL II: Mean Adjusted IES Scores *Adjusted for age, gender, years of education, baseline CES-D, baseline score (no baseline score for IES)
  • 36.
  • 37. Among those who accurately recall their risk disclosure (n = 158) 47.5% continue to believe otherwise! Linnenbringer et al., Genetics in Medicine , in press
  • 38.
  • 39. Who did you tell about the results of your test? Ashida et al., J Health Communication , in press.
  • 40.
  • 41.
  • 42. Any Behavior Change No ε 4 ε 4+ % reporting change 45% 57% 48% 77% 0% 100% AD-Only Risk Info AD & CVD Risk Info
  • 43. Exercise Change No ε 4 ε 4+ % reporting change 27% 34% 24% 63% 0% 100% AD-Only Risk Info AD & CVD Risk Info
  • 44. Diet Change No ε 4 ε 4+ % reporting change 27% 33% 28% 53% 0% 100% AD-Only Risk Info AD & CVD Risk Info
  • 45. Mental Exercise Change No ε 4 ε 4+ % reporting change 16% 25% 34% 37% 0% 100% AD-Only Risk Info AD & CVD Risk Info
  • 46. REVEAL IV (2010-2013) Can we combine risk elements of GENOTYPE and PHENOTYPE ? What is the impact of APOE on risk of developing AD in persons with MCI?
  • 47. Data for Risk Estimates in REVEAL IV Petersen et al., NEJM, 2005 .
  • 48. Data for Risk Estimates in REVEAL IV Estimated from primary data provided by Petersen et al.
  • 49.
  • 50. PARADE Magazine! August 23, 2008 Direct to Consumer Marketing (DTC) Molecular genetic testing
  • 51. Personal Genome Testing and Disclosure REVEAL
  • 53. APOE-  4 Genotypes in the US Caucasian Population 3/3 (67%) 2/3 (8%) 2/2 (1%) 3/4 (20%) 4/4 (2%) 2/4 (3%)
  • 54. Enriched Research Registry 11,500 (23%) e4/ex 50,000 volunteers 1000 (2%) e4/e4
  • 55.

Editor's Notes

  1. All compared to 3/3 odds of particular genotypes vary with age the greqtest effect of apoe 4 is between 60-75
  2. Lin et al. 05/12/10 Lesser-form CL in BOFS
  3. Numbers are ok
  4. ok