SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
Download to read offline
Review
Forensic pharmacovigilance: Newer dimension of pharmacovigilance
Rakesh K. Sewal, Vikas K. Saini, Bikash Medhi*
Department of Pharmacology, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, 160012, India
a r t i c l e i n f o
Article history:
Received 4 October 2014
Received in revised form
25 March 2015
Accepted 29 May 2015
Available online 6 June 2015
Keywords:
Pharmacovigilance
Forensic science
Medicolegal
Adverse drug reaction
a b s t r a c t
Drug safety for the patients is of paramount importance for a medical professional. Pharmacovigilance
attempts to ensure the safety of patients by keeping a close vigil on the pattern of adverse events sec-
ondary to drug use. Number of medicolegal cases is at rise since last few years. Forensic sciences and
pharmacovigilance need to work hand in hand to unlock the mystery of many criminal and civil pro-
ceedings. Pharmacovigilance offers its wide scope in forensic sciences by putting forward its expertise on
adverse profile of drugs which may be instrumental in solving the cases and bringing the justice forth. It
may range from as simple affairs as defining the adverse drug reaction on one hand to putting expert
advice in critical criminal cases on the other one. Pharmacovigilance experts have to abide by the ethics
of the practice while executing their duties as expert else it may tarnish the justice and loosen its
dependability. As a budding discipline of science, it is confronted with several hurdles and challenges
which include reluctance of medical professionals for being involved in court proceedings, extrapolations
of facts and data and variations in law across the globe etc. These challenges and hurdles call the medical
fraternity come forward to work towards the momentous application of pharmacovigilance in the
forensic sciences. Evidence based practice e.g. testing the biological samples for the presence of drugs
may prove to be pivotal in the success of this collaboration of sciences.
© 2015 Elsevier Ltd and Faculty of Forensic and Legal Medicine. All rights reserved.
1. Introduction
Pharmacovigilance has witnessed an exponential growth in last
few decades owing to the increasing awareness amongst healthcare
professionals. Pharmacovigilance is the science and activities relating
to the detection, assessment, understanding and prevention of
adverse effects or any other drug-related problem.1
The various
components of pharmacovigilance ranging from detection to pre-
vention of adverse drug reactions (ADR's) lay a strong foundation for
the solution of medicolegal cases. A medicolegal case is where a
person is injured or harmed in any way and needs medical attention
for it. Medicolegal cases comprise of detection and collection of ev-
idences in accidents, suicides and homicides. In this contemporary
world of medicine, medicolegal issues are emerging out at an
alarming rate.2
This is worthwhile to mention that law and medical
professionals need to work hand in hand for the sake of betterment
and rehabilitation of the victims of medicolegal cases.3
Forensic sci-
ences and pharmacovigilance offer collaborative services to each
other for the benefit of stakeholders. They can exchange the knowl-
edge with each other to complement the information. This symbiotic
relationship of two vital components of healthcare system gives birth
to a new discipline known as “Forensic Pharmacovigilance”.
2. Scope of pharmacovigilance in forensic medicine
2.1. Illicit drug use
Illicit drug use cases seek the expert opinion on drugs and their
possible adverse events. The illegal drugs use is on rise since few
decades. The number of intentional and unintentional deaths from
prescription drugs overdose is now greater than the deaths from
heroin and cocaine combined. A large part of the problem is the use
of pain-killers without a prescription, or misusing a prescribed drug
to get “high.” Improving the way prescription painkillers are pre-
scribed can reduce the number of people who misuse, abuse or
overdose these drugs, while making sure patients have access to
safe and effective treatment. In 2011, legislation to create a Pre-
scription Drug Monitoring Program was passed in Maryland to
make comprehensive information on prescribed and dispensed
Controlled Dangerous Substances available to doctors, pharmacists
and other healthcare providers.4
* Corresponding author. Department of Pharmacology, Postgraduate Institute of
Medical Education & Research, Chandigarh, India. Tel.: þ91 172 2755250 (O),
þ91 9815409652 (M); fax: þ91 1722744401, þ91 1722745078.
E-mail address: drbikashus@yahoo.com (B. Medhi).
Contents lists available at ScienceDirect
Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine
journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jflm
http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jflm.2015.05.015
1752-928X/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd and Faculty of Forensic and Legal Medicine. All rights reserved.
Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118
2.2. Role in solving civil or criminal cases
During the criminal proceedings, involvement of drugs in a case
may seek the expert advice of pharmacovigilance to solve the case.5
Examples of such cases include death due to overdose toxicity of
drugs like sedatives being used for sleep disorders or opiates used
for pain management. Under few circumstances, apart from the
involvement of toxicological effects of drugs; there are certain
adverse drug reactions which can be attributed responsible for
occurrence of the legal case. The fact that suicidal tendencies sec-
ondary to the use of antidepressants are the known adverse effects
of these drugs may be useful in mining/unleashing the cause of
death of a person treated by these drugs and who commits a suicide
leaving a mystery behind.6
Table 1 enlists the examples of drugs and their forensic signifi-
cance which illustrates the relevance of drugs’ knowledge in
forensic concerns.
2.3. Differentiation between adverse drug reaction and adverse
event
Any untoward medical occurrence that may appear during
treatment with a pharmaceutical product but which does not
necessarily have a causal relationship with the treatment is called
Table 1
Examples of drugs explain their possible ADR's of forensic significance.
S. No. Drug Class/Use ADR Forensic significance Reference
1 Citalopram Selective serotonin
reuptake inhibitors
QTc interval prolongation May cause adverse drug reactions of serious outcomes 7,8
2 Dextropropoxyphene Opioid analgesic QTc interval prolongation May cause adverse drug reactions of serious outcomes 9e11
3 Flunitrazepam Intermediate acting
benzodiazepine
QTc interval prolongation May cause adverse drug reactions of serious outcomes 12
4 Methadone Opioid analgesic QT Prolongation
Respiratory depression
Respiratory arrest 13,14
5 Varenicline Nicotinic acetylcholine
receptor agonist
Manic episodes induced
Suicidal Ideation
Death involving a suspicion of suicide committed
by a person taking varenicline
15,16
6 Digoxin Cardiac glycoside Arrhythmia ST depression,Ventricular fibrillation leading to fatal
or other serious outcome
17
7 Fentanyl Opioid analgesic Respiratory depression Overdose toxicity may result in death. 18
8 Heroin Opiate Mast cell degradation Cardiac failure which may be an explanation of death 19,20
9 Cefuroxime Cephalosporin Disulfiram-like reaction Unexpected death 21
10 Morphine Opioid analgesic Respiratory depression
leading to death in
severe cases
Intentional or accidental overdose results in death.
Medication error or suicidal events should be
differentiated.
22
11 Aldicarb Acetylcholinestearse
inhibitor
CNS depression Death due to an aldicarb acute intoxication. 23,24
12 Trazodone Antidepressant, anxiolytic,
and hypnotic
Suicidal ideation While mining the evidences in death of such cases
suicidal ideation may be considered.
25,26
13 Atracurium Nondepolarizing skeletal
muscle relaxant
Hypertension and tachycardia
and hypotension and bradycardia
Overdose toxicity for Suicidal intention 27
14 Cyclizine Antihistaminic CNS depression, hypertension Overdose toxicity may result in death 28,29
15 Zopiclone Nonbenzodiazepine
hypnotic agent
Amnesia, palpitation,
hallucination
Suicidal attempt results in fatality 30
16 Fluoxetine Selective serotonin
reuptake inhibitor
Development of akathisia
related to the development
of suicidal ideation.
Suicidal ideation information may be instrumental
in solving mysterious death cases
31
17 Imipramine Tricyclic
antidepressant
Depresses automaticity Complete atrio-ventricular heart block resulting in
sudden death
17
18 Mephedrone CNS stimulant Delirium Impaired judgement may cause accidental death 32
19 Quinidine Anti arrhythmic QT prolongation Rapid ventricular arrhythmia results in death. Reason
of death may be explained.
17
20 Clozapine Atypical
antidepressant
Myocarditis Myocarditis induced death due to overdose 33,34
21 Thioridazine Antipsychotic Arrhythmia Arrhythmogenic sudden cardiac death 35
22 Dextromethorphan Antitussive Tachycardia, hypertension,
and respiratory depression
Death from respiratory failure 36
23 Acetamenophen NSAID/Antipyretic Hepatotoxicity Fulminant hepatic failure 37
24 Ceftriaxone Cephalosporin Auto eimmune
hemolytic anemia
Hemolytic anemia induced cardio-respiratory arrest,
Acute renal failure
38,39
25 Tetracycline Antibiotic Jaundice Hepatotoxicity 40
26 Thyroxine Congenital
hypothyroidism
Progressive bradycardia Cardiac Arrest 41
27 Azathioprine Immunosuppresant Bone marrow suppression,
hematological toxicity,
pancreatitis
Serious pancytopenia due to the accumulation
of cytotoxic metabolites
42e44
28 Doxorubicin Cytotoxic Cardiotoxicity Cardiomyopathy or cardiac failure 45,46
29 Rifampicin/Isoniazide/
Ethambutol/Pyrazinamide
Antitubercular FDC Hepatotoxicity Acute liver failure due to hepatic encephalopathy 47
30 Enalapril ACE inhibitor Hepatotoxicity Hepatic failure 41
31 Propofol Anaesthetic Pulmonary oedema and
haemorrhagic pancreatitis,
respiratory depression,
bronchospasm
and chest wall rigidity
Death occurred due to pulmonary oedema as patient
did not receive ventilation
48
R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118114
as adverse event. According to WHO, adverse drug reaction is
defined as “A response to a drug which is noxious and unintended;
and occurs at doses normally used in man for the prophylaxis;
diagnosis or therapy of disease, or for modification of physiological
function.49
Thus, every adverse drug reaction is an adverse event
but not vice versa. Keeping this point in view, it is pertinent to
cautiously identify these two aspects of unintended experiences
after the use of drugs. “Causality assessment” is the tool to put
scientific evidence forth to determine the accurate nature of
adverse experience after a drug use. If there is any stronger or
weaker correlation of administration of drug with the occurrence of
adverse event then it is known as adverse drug reaction. There are
several causality assessment scales adopted by the pharmacovigi-
lance experts to assign the level of correlation. Naranjos's scale,
WHO's causality assessment scale and Bayesian scale are few to
name.50,51
Different degrees of association are described by these
scales e.g. certain, probable, possible and unlikely are the levels
mentioned by the WHO's scale for causality assessment.52,53
2.4. Discrimination between serious and severe ADR's
There is a thin line of demarcation between serious and severe
drug reactions which are misunderstood many a times. Court
proceedings may be in a need to judge the gravity of problem in
terms of seriousness and severity. Severe reactions should never be
confused with serious reactions. For instance, in any drug related
injury in clinical trials compensation is granted to the victim for
which judiciary needs to ascertain whether the injury was serious
or not.
There is a criterion almost universally accepted for determining
the seriousness of drug reaction. If the ADR falls in to the bracket of
that criterion then it should be designated as serious event. A re-
action is said to be serious if it 1) results in death, 2) is life-
threatening, 3) requires inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of
existing hospitalization, 4) results in persistent or significant
disability/incapacity, 5) results in congenital abnormality, and 6) is
any other medically important condition.
Severity of the ADR's deals with the intensity of the reaction
graded as mild, moderate, severe.49
Severe is never synonymous
with serious e.g. headache may be severe in grade but not of great
medical significance for seriousness.
2.5. Identification of counterfeit and substandard drugs
Pharmacovigilance data can generate the signal for some spe-
cific drug and/or its formulations; under some instances. Forensic
pharmacovigilance is useful when counterfeit or substandard drugs
cause the adverse events. Standard pharmacovigilance methods of
registration, analysis and investigation are able in indentifying the
substandard drugs or formulations which have caused the adverse
events. Thousands of adverse reactions in USA which are secondary
to administration of contaminated heparin in 2009 is an example of
adverse events occurred due to contaminated or counterfeit drugs
which generates the signal for taking corrective action as it
happened in case of the present example. Market authorization
holder had to recall all heparin due to alarming figure of ADR's
including hundreds of fatalities.54
Few areas of scope of forensic pharmacovigilance are depicted
in Fig. 1.
3. Forensic pharmacovigilance as another bud of
pharmacovigilance
Though birth of pharmacovigilance owes back to the occurrence
of a disaster known popularly as thalidomide tragedy but it has
attained a proliferative growth in last few decades.55
Pharmacovi-
gilance has gained a pace to expand its applications in other
streams of science. Ecopharmacovigilance, which is defined as
science and activities concerning detection, assessment, under-
standing, and prevention of adverse effects or other problems
related to the presence of pharmaceuticals in the environment,
which affect human and other animal species is a recent develop-
ment of pharmacovigilance proving its relevance in environmental
sciences.56
Haemovigilance, materiovigilance, biovigilance are few
more examples which are transformed facet of pharmacovigilance.
For example, in Indian context, haemovigilance is covered under
pharmacovigilance program of India as blood or blood products are
governed by drug regulatory authorities in India treating them as
a drug.57
On the same pattern we have recently seen a newer
budding branch of pharmacovigilance i.e Forensic Pharmacovigi-
lance which is instrumental in solving the legal issues raised
on involvement of any drug. Forensic pharmacovigilance i.e
Fig. 1. Scope of forensic pharmacovigilance.
R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118 115
implementation of pharmacovigilance expertise for forensic pur-
pose may be used to answer the following questions:
Could the drug under question (or chemical) have caused the
adverse effect in the victim ?
Did it cause the effect either ‘beyond all reasonable doubt?’
(criminal case) or ‘as a balance of probabilities (civil case)?3
4. Challenges and hurdles in forensic pharmacovigilance
4.1. Reluctance of medical professionals
Reluctance of medical professionals in playing their role as an
expert for forensic purposes is one of the sturdiest challenges to be
met. Causes contributing to the medical professional's reluctance
include fear of litigation, loss of productivity, fear of being twisted
by lawyers etc.58
Despite of these challenges medical professionals
should undertake the civic duties by contributing their expertise in
resolving the forensic issues.
4.2. Extrapolation of a data does not always produce
the real figures
Extrapolation of data generated through previous studies or
experiences cannot always be practised. Competitiveness and
quality of epidemiological studies in medicine always lies under
question mark making it difficult to accept their conclusion for
making decisions in some forensic issues.59
4.3. Uniformity vs non uniformity
Medical Sciences have similar foundation across the globe but
law varies across the borders. Medical profession is not open to
public rather it depends upon the subjective opinion of the pro-
fessionals whereas in contrast law is open at mass levels and has a
strong foundation of defined rules. Though in forensic pharmaco-
vigilance both the disciplines need to work hand in hand but there
are certain conflictions. Medicine discipline is challenged by the
law often during the trials.
4.4. Ethics in forensic pharmacovigilance
Judiciary has to rely more upon the opinion of the expert in a
case involving the drug. They rely more upon the testimony of
forensic experts. Therefore, an ethical obligation always lies upon
expert to put the truth forward and not to mislead the judiciary,
defense, or the state when testifying before the court, or when
preparing their reports relating to their analyses of forensic evi-
dence. We still lack any universally applicable guidelines on ethical
code for the forensic sciences. Though there are few professional
bodies catering to the needs of forensic analysts on ethics in
forensic sciences. American Board of Criminalistics (ABC) and the
American Academy of Forensic Science are two professional bodies
useful for forensic scientists in United States of America.60
In a
study conducted by Brandon L. Garrett and Peter J. Neufeld in 2009
six types of invalid testimony could be identified which are enlisted
as below.61
▪ Evidence that was non-probative presented as probative
▪ Discounting exculpatory evidence
▪ Conclusion of evidence originating from the defendant without
supporting empirical data
▪ Non-statistical statements made without supporting empirical
data
▪ Inaccurate presentation of statistics or frequency
▪ Providing statistics without supporting empirical data
An expert needs to be unbiased and fair enough in his/her
obligations. The prime obligation of an expert must be to
contribute towards the justice. Legal, scientific, and ethical values
can become snarled during the court proceedings. It becomes a
responsibility of an expert to keep his opinion after a competent,
unbiased and probative work. The causes behind practising un-
ethical acts include avarice, zeal of power or over ambitions of
promotion, status or personal welfare. Sometimes even casual
behaviour of experts towards professional duties also makes their
acts unethical. Living with guilt of that a guilty person escapes
and or an impeccant person gets punished based on the advice or
comments submitted by the pharmacovigilance expert may
restrain him or her from unethical acts. Professional bodies and
organizations should put the efforts forward to ensure ethical
practice, veracity of testimony among individuals engaged as
expert for forensic purpose. It is pertinent to devise a code of
conduct for such professionals to keep the benchmark of ethics in
forensic sciences.
5. Key points for an effective forensic pharmacovigilance
5.1. Forensic pharmacokinetics
Forensic pharmacokinetics should be honoured while giving the
opinion or report on medico legal case involving the drugs. If
possible, biological samples should be collected to assess them for
the presence of drugs or their metabolites which further can be
correlated with the adverse events related to the forensic concerns.
Claims of adverse drug reactions may be supported by data of
pharmacokinetics.2
Pharmacokinetics/Pharmacodynamics (PK/PD)
studies are gaining the popularity at various levels of research
which may be a tool for the effective implementation of pharma-
covigilance in forensic sciences.
5.2. Temporal relationship
Temporal relationship of occurrence of adverse event and
administration of drug should be taken into consideration while
preparing the report for forensic purposes. The time lag between
administration of drug and occurrence of ADR defines the time
course of a reaction which is of six types:
 Rapid: toxic reactions
 First-dose: hypersensitivity reactions
 Early: collateral reactions
 Intermediate ecollateral or hyper sensitivity reactions
 Late ecollateral reactions
 Delayed ecollateral reactions62
Temporal relationship lays a strong foundation for the causality
assessment of the case and also plays a vital role for the judgement
purposes e.g. immediate reactions showing a close temporal
relationship-between the adverse event and administration of dose
makes judiciary more convinced. Sometimes, when a far temporal
association lies between the administration of drug and event and
there is any scientific fact explaining that gap, an advice of experts
in pharmacovigilance or pharmacology must be sought because
there are certain drugs which causes the adverse events only after
accumulation of the drug or its metabolite in the body e.g.
morphine. But, there are certain exceptions in classification cited
here e.g. hypersensitivity reaction is usually immediate reactions
but may be delayed in few instances. Stevens Johnson Syndrome
secondary to paracetamol after chronic use may be an example of
such delayed immune mediated reaction.
R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118116
5.3. Causality assessment of the case
Causality assessment determines the degree of probability of
correlation of administration of a drug and occurrence of adverse
event. It must be exercised cautiously and tested rigorously before
putting a report before the bench of a court. Several scales are being
used for causality assessment like Naranjo's scale, WHO's Scale for
causality assessment and Probability algorithm. A pharmacovigi-
lance expert should cautiously use the scale of causality assessment
and it should be specified in the report submitted to the judiciary.52
5.4. Cautious extrapolation of facts to every case
Exaggerated extrapolation of the case to some fact or data may
tarnish the proceedings of the forensic cases. It may entirely
mislead the verdict of the criminal or civil cases. Cautious extrap-
olation is warranted to avoid such misleading judgements based
upon inaccurate data.
5.5. Challenges of pharmacovigilance
Though pharmacovigilance is set to offer its application in
forensic sciences but there are few challenges before the pharma-
covigilance to be met. Increased globalization of drugs, exponential
rise in volume of drugs used and polypharmacy are few elements
which make the pharmacovigilance a complex discipline. Under
the light of these challenges, pharmacovigilance now should be
understood beyond merely reporting the harms; rather it should be
a rigorous risk benefit assessment. Few standards of quality in
pharmacovigilance have been set and good pharmacovigilance
practices (GVP) is a citable example of that.63
It is imperative to
adhere to such standards while implementing pharmacovigilance
in forensic areas.
5.6. Presenting evidence for the court
Proper presentation of the evidences by the medical or phar-
macovigilance expert may illuminate the case. A report for the
forensic purposes should be written clearly and should not include
the comments from the area which is beyond the expertise who is
submitting the report. A clear statement should be made in report if
some additional advice of another expert is needed. Scientifics
evidences, facts and observation should be presented in a manner
that can easily be understood by judges to make them arrive at a
verdict with reasonably fair understanding of the case.58
6. Conclusions
In the light of increasing medicolegal cases, there is a substantial
need of contribution of drug expertise in solving the criminal and
civil cases involving the drugs at one or other stages. Pharmacovi-
gilance is the science of detection, assessment, understanding,
prevention of adverse events associated with the use of drugs.
Pharmacovigilance can cater to the needs of legal framework to
mine the cases involving the drugs by differentiating the serious
and non serious reactions, establishing the causal relationship be-
tween drug and adverse event. Proliferating role of pharmacovi-
gilance has now sprawled over the arena of legal medicine giving
birth to newer branch of science known as forensic pharmacovi-
gilance which offers a wide range of its scope and application and
warrants a cautious execution of this exercise else it may deviate
from the intended use.
Conflict of interest
None declared.
Funding
None declared.
Ethical approval
None declared.
References
1. World Health Organization Collaborating Centre for International Drug Moni-
toring. The importance of pharmacovigilance safety monitoring of medicinal
products. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2002.
2. Medhi B, Singh PK, Bansal YS, Setia P. Forensic pharmacokinetics: a new
dimension for drug related medico legal cases. J Forensic Res 2011;2:128. http://
dx.doi.org/10.4172/2157-7145.1000128.
3. Edwards IR, Body D. Forensic pharmacovigilance. Int J Risk Saf Med 2012;12:
241e2.
4. Drug induced deaths. Maryland: Department of Mental Health and Hygiene;
2012.
5. Aronson JK, Hauben M. Anecdotes that provide definitive evidence. BMJ
2006;333:1267e9.
6. Kielholz P, Battegay R. Behandlung depressiver Zustandsbilder, unter spezieller
Berücksichtigung von Tofranil, einem neuen Antidepressivum. Schweiz Med
Wochenschr 1958;88:763e7.
7. Catalano G, Catalano MC, Epstein MA, Tsambiras PE. QTc interval prolongation
associated with citalopram overdose: a case report and literature review. Clin
Neuropharmacol 2001;24(3):158e62.
8. Jonasson B, Saldeen T. Citalopram in fatal poisoning cases. Forensic Sci Int
2002;126(1):1e6.
9. Carson DJL, Carson ED. Fatal dextropropoxyphene poisoning in Northern
Ireland: review of 30 cases. Lancet 1977;309(8017):894e7.
10. Lawson AAH, Northridge DB. Dextropropoxyphene overdose. Med Toxicol
Adverse Drug Exp 1987;2(6):430e44.
11. Hawton K, Simkin S, Deeks J. Co-proxamol and suicide: a study of national
mortality statistics and local non-fatal self poisonings. BMJ 2003;326(7397):
1006.
12. Barnett JM, Broad RM. Flunitrazepam used in a case of poisoning. J Clin Forensic
Med 2003;10(2):89e91.
13. Modesto-Lowe V, Brooks D, Petry N. Methadone deaths: risk factors in pain and
addicted populations. J Gen Intern Med 2010;25(4):305e9.
14. Andrews CM, Krantz MJ, Wedam EF, Marcuson MJ, Capacchione JF,
Haigney MC. Methadone-induced mortality in the treatment of chronic pain:
role of QT prolongation. Cardiol J 2009;16(3):210e7.
15. Kintz P, Evans J, Villain M, Cirimele V. Smoking cessation with varenicline: a
suicidal fatality. J Anal Toxicol 2009;33(2):118e20.
16. Stove CP, Els A, Piette MH, Lambert WE. Fatality following a suicidal overdose
with varenicline. Int J Leg Med 2013;127(1):85e91.
17. Bigger JT, Weld FM. Drugs and sudden cardiac death. Ann N Y Acad Sci
1982;382(1):229e37.
18. Algren DA, Monteilh CP, Punja M, Schier JG, Belson M, Hepler BR, et al.
Fentanyl-associated fatalities among illicit drug users in Wayne county,
Michigan (July 2005eMay 2006). J Med Toxicol 2013;9(1):106e15.
19. Edston E, Hage-Hamsten MV, Edston E. Anaphylactoid shockea common cause
of death in heroin addicts? Allergy 1997;52(9):950e4.
20. Darke S, Zador D. Fatal heroin ‘overdose’: a review. Addiction 1996;91(12):
1765e72.
21. Dong H, Zhang J, Ren L, Liu Q, Zhu S. Unexpected death due to cefuroxime-
induced disulfiram-like reaction. Indian J Pharmacol 2013;45(4):399.
22. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. CDC grand rounds: prescription
drug overdoses-a US epidemic. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2012;61(1):10.
23. Proença P, Teixeira H, de Mendonca MC, Castanheira F, Marques EP, Corte-
Real F, et al. Aldicarb poisoning: one case report. Forensic Sci Int 2004;146:
S79e81.
24. Ragouc-Sengler C, Tracqui A, Chavonnet A, Daijardin JB, Simonetti M, Kintz P,
et al. Aldicarb poisoning. Hum Exp Toxicol 2000;19(12):657e62.
25. Martínez MA, Ballesteros S, de la Torre CS, Almarza E. Investigation of a fatality
due to trazodone poisoning: case report and literature review. J Anal Toxicol
2005;29(4):262e8.
26. Gamble DE, Peterson LG. Trazodone overdose: four years of experience from
voluntary reports. J Clin Psychiatry 1986;47(11):544e6.
27. Martínez MA, Ballesteros S, Almarza E. Anesthesiologist suicide with atracu-
rium. J Anal Toxicol 2006;30(2):120.
28. Arnestad M, Eldor KBB, Stray-Pedersen A, Bachs L, Karinen R. Suicide due to
cyclizine overdose. J Anal Toxicol 2014;38:110e2.
29. Backer RC, McFeeley P, Wohlenberg N. Fatality resulting from cyclizine over-
dose. J Anal Toxicol 1989;13(5):308e9.
30. Meatherall RC. Zopiclone fatality in a hospitalized patient. J Forensic Sci
1997;42(2):340e3.
31. Creaney W, Murray I, Healy D. Antidepressant induced suicidal ideation.
J Psychopharmacol 1992;6(1):120.
32. Corkery JM, Schifano F, Ghodse AH. Mephedrone-related fatalities in the United
Kingdom: contextual, clinical and practical issues. Pharmacology 2012;17:
355e80.
R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118 117
33. De Berardis D, Serroni N, Campanella D, Olivieri L, Ferri F, Carano A, et al.
Update on the adverse effects of clozapine: focus on myocarditis. Curr Drug Saf
2012;7(1):55e62.
34. Fineschi V, Ner M, Riezzo I, Turillazzi E. Sudden cardiac death due to hyper-
sensitivity myocarditis during clozapine treatment. Int J Leg Med 2004;118(5):
307e9.
35. Killeen DMJ. Antipsychotic-induced sudden cardiac death: examination of an
atypical reaction. Expert Opin Drug Saf 2009;8(3):249e52.
36. Burns JM, Boyer EW. Antitussives and substance abuse. Subst Abuse Rehabili-
tation 2013;4:75e82. http://dx.doi.org/10.2147/SAR.S36761.
37. McCormick PA, Treanor D, McCormack G. Farrell M. Early death from para-
cetamol (acetaminophen) induced fulminant hepatic failure without cerebral
oedema. J Hepatol 2003;39(4):547e51.
38. Garratty G, Postoway N, Schwellenbach J, McMahill PC. A fatal case of ceftri-
axone (Rocephin)-induced hemolytic anaemia associated with intravascular
immune hemolysis. Transfusion 1991;31:176e9.
39. Kapur G, Valentini RP, Mattoo TK, Warrier I, Imam AA. Ceftriaxone induced
hemolysis complicated by acute renal failure. Pediatr Blood Cancer 2008;50(1):
139e42.
40. Hanson GC. A death from tetracycline. Postgrad Med J 1968;44:870e4. http://
dx.doi.org/10.1136/pgmj.44.517.870.
41. Cheng K, Masters S, Stephenson T, Cooke R, Ferner R, Ashworth M, et al.
Identification of suspected fatal adverse drug reactions by paediatricians: a UK
surveillance study. Arch Dis Child 2008;93:609e11.
42. Breen DP, Marinaki AM, Arenas M, Hayes PC. Pharmacogeneticassociation with
adverse drug reactions to azathioprine immunosuppressive therapy following
liver transplantation. Liver Transpl 2005;11(7):826e33.
43. Andersen V, Sonne J, Andersen M. Spontaneous reports on drug-induced pancre-
atitis in Denmark from 1968 to 1999. Eur J ClinPharmacol 2001;57(6e7):517e21.
44. Gastal GR, Moreira S, Noble CF, Ferreira LE, França PH, Pinho M. Toxicity of
azathioprine: why and when: analysis of the prevalence of polymorphism in
Joinville, SC, Brazil. Arq Gastroenterol 2012;49(2):130e4.
45. Clarkson A, Choonara I. Surveillance for fatal suspected adverse drug reactions
in the UK. Arch Dis Child 2002;87:462e7.
46. Ichikawa Y, Ghanefar M, Bayeva1 M, Wu R, Khechaduri A, Sathyamangla V,
et al. Cardiotoxicity of doxorubicin is mediated through mitochondrial iron
accumulation. J Clin Invest 2014;124(2):617e30.
47. Tost JR, Vidal R, Cayla J, Díaz-Cabanela D, Jimenez A, Broquetas JM. Severe
hepatotoxicity due to anti-tuberculosis drugs in Spain. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis
2005;9(5):534e40.
48. Roussin A, Mirepoix M, Lassabe G, Dumestre-Toulet V, Gardette V,
Montastruc JL, et al. Death related to a recreational abuse of propofol at
therapeutic dose range. Br J Anaesth 2006;97(2):268.
49. [Internet] Glossary of terms used in pharmacovigilance. 2011 March [cited 2014
Feb 22]. Available from:, http://who-umc.org/Graphics/24729.pdf.
50. Agbabiaka TB, Savovic J, Ernst E. Methods for causality assessment of adverse
drug reactions a systematic review. Drug Saf 2008;31(1):21e37.
51. Edwards IR. Considerations on causality in pharmacovigilance. Int J Risk Saf Med
2012:2441e54. http://dx.doi.org/10.3233/JRS-2012-0552.
52. Zaki SA. Adverse drug reaction and causality assessment scales. Lung India
2011;28:152e3.
53. [Internet] The use of the WHO-UMC system for standardised case causality
assessment. 2012 April 17 [cited 2014 Mar27]. Available from:, http://who-
umc.org/Graphics/24734.pdf.
54. Labadie J. Forensic pharmacovigilance and substandard or counterfeit drugs. Int
J Risk Saf Med 2012;24:2437e9.
55. Grootheest KV. The dawn of Pharmacovigilance: an historical prospective. Int J
Pharm Med 2003;17:195e200.
56. Medhi B, Sewal RK. Ecopharmacovigilance: an issue urgently to be addressed.
Indian J Pharmacol 2012;44(5):547e9.
57. Bisht A, Singh S, Marwah N. Hemovigilance Programme-India. Asian J Transfus
Sci 2013;7:73e4.
58. Hartigan-Go Kenneth. Presenting evidence for the court. Int J Risk Saf Med
2012;24:59e63.
59. Persaud N, Healy D. Epidemiological evidence in forensic pharmacovigilance.
Int J Risk Saf Med 2012;24:31e5.
60. Dutelle AW. Ethics and forensic science. Mar-Apr Evid Technol Mag 2011;9(2):
24e5.
61. Barnett Peter D. Ethics in forensic science: professional standards for the practice
of criminalistics. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press; 2001.
62. Aronson JK, Ferner RE. Clarification of terminology in drug safety. Drug Saf
2005;28(10):851e70.
63. Jeetu G, Anusha G. Pharmacovigilance: a worldwide master key for drug safety
monitoring. J Young Pharm 2010;2(3):315e20.
R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118118

More Related Content

What's hot

Adr reporting ppt
Adr reporting pptAdr reporting ppt
Adr reporting pptRimaSingh14
 
INTERNATIONAL NON PROPRIETARY NAMES FOR DRUGS1.pptx
INTERNATIONAL NON PROPRIETARY NAMES FOR DRUGS1.pptxINTERNATIONAL NON PROPRIETARY NAMES FOR DRUGS1.pptx
INTERNATIONAL NON PROPRIETARY NAMES FOR DRUGS1.pptxE Poovarasan
 
Detection and monitoring of ADRs
Detection and monitoring of ADRsDetection and monitoring of ADRs
Detection and monitoring of ADRsDr. Ramesh Bhandari
 
Establish Pharmacovigilance Centres in hospital and National Programmes.pptx
Establish Pharmacovigilance Centres in hospital and National Programmes.pptxEstablish Pharmacovigilance Centres in hospital and National Programmes.pptx
Establish Pharmacovigilance Centres in hospital and National Programmes.pptxPiyushZala5
 
Good Clinical Practice and Pharmacovigilance
Good Clinical Practice and PharmacovigilanceGood Clinical Practice and Pharmacovigilance
Good Clinical Practice and PharmacovigilanceMd. Zakaria Faruki
 
D&C Act 1940 Schedule Y - A Presentation by Akshay Anand
D&C Act 1940 Schedule Y - A Presentation by Akshay AnandD&C Act 1940 Schedule Y - A Presentation by Akshay Anand
D&C Act 1940 Schedule Y - A Presentation by Akshay AnandAkshay Anand
 
Oecd guidelines for toxicology studies
Oecd guidelines for toxicology studiesOecd guidelines for toxicology studies
Oecd guidelines for toxicology studiesJasdeep singh brar
 
Management of adverse drug reactions
Management of adverse drug reactionsManagement of adverse drug reactions
Management of adverse drug reactionsReshmaManeDeshmukh
 
7.Safety Monitoring in Clinical Trails.pptx
7.Safety Monitoring in Clinical Trails.pptx7.Safety Monitoring in Clinical Trails.pptx
7.Safety Monitoring in Clinical Trails.pptxbrahmaiahmph
 
Pharmacological Approach to Drug Discovery
Pharmacological Approach to Drug DiscoveryPharmacological Approach to Drug Discovery
Pharmacological Approach to Drug DiscoverySuhas Reddy C
 
3..Post marketing surveillance.pptx
3..Post marketing surveillance.pptx3..Post marketing surveillance.pptx
3..Post marketing surveillance.pptxKrishnapriyaVH1
 
post marketing –surveillance methods
post marketing –surveillance  methodspost marketing –surveillance  methods
post marketing –surveillance methodsAMRUTHA JOSE
 
METHODS OF POST MARKETING SURVEILLANCE
METHODS OF POST MARKETING SURVEILLANCEMETHODS OF POST MARKETING SURVEILLANCE
METHODS OF POST MARKETING SURVEILLANCEDr Arathy R Nath
 
Toxicology & Toxicovigilance
Toxicology & ToxicovigilanceToxicology & Toxicovigilance
Toxicology & Toxicovigilancekaran1803
 

What's hot (20)

Med-DRA
Med-DRAMed-DRA
Med-DRA
 
Schedule Y
Schedule Y Schedule Y
Schedule Y
 
Adr reporting ppt
Adr reporting pptAdr reporting ppt
Adr reporting ppt
 
INTERNATIONAL NON PROPRIETARY NAMES FOR DRUGS1.pptx
INTERNATIONAL NON PROPRIETARY NAMES FOR DRUGS1.pptxINTERNATIONAL NON PROPRIETARY NAMES FOR DRUGS1.pptx
INTERNATIONAL NON PROPRIETARY NAMES FOR DRUGS1.pptx
 
ADR REPORTING
ADR REPORTINGADR REPORTING
ADR REPORTING
 
Detection and monitoring of ADRs
Detection and monitoring of ADRsDetection and monitoring of ADRs
Detection and monitoring of ADRs
 
Establish Pharmacovigilance Centres in hospital and National Programmes.pptx
Establish Pharmacovigilance Centres in hospital and National Programmes.pptxEstablish Pharmacovigilance Centres in hospital and National Programmes.pptx
Establish Pharmacovigilance Centres in hospital and National Programmes.pptx
 
Good Clinical Practice and Pharmacovigilance
Good Clinical Practice and PharmacovigilanceGood Clinical Practice and Pharmacovigilance
Good Clinical Practice and Pharmacovigilance
 
D&C Act 1940 Schedule Y - A Presentation by Akshay Anand
D&C Act 1940 Schedule Y - A Presentation by Akshay AnandD&C Act 1940 Schedule Y - A Presentation by Akshay Anand
D&C Act 1940 Schedule Y - A Presentation by Akshay Anand
 
Oecd guidelines for toxicology studies
Oecd guidelines for toxicology studiesOecd guidelines for toxicology studies
Oecd guidelines for toxicology studies
 
Management of adverse drug reactions
Management of adverse drug reactionsManagement of adverse drug reactions
Management of adverse drug reactions
 
Safety Data Generation
Safety Data GenerationSafety Data Generation
Safety Data Generation
 
7.Safety Monitoring in Clinical Trails.pptx
7.Safety Monitoring in Clinical Trails.pptx7.Safety Monitoring in Clinical Trails.pptx
7.Safety Monitoring in Clinical Trails.pptx
 
Pharmacological Approach to Drug Discovery
Pharmacological Approach to Drug DiscoveryPharmacological Approach to Drug Discovery
Pharmacological Approach to Drug Discovery
 
3..Post marketing surveillance.pptx
3..Post marketing surveillance.pptx3..Post marketing surveillance.pptx
3..Post marketing surveillance.pptx
 
post marketing –surveillance methods
post marketing –surveillance  methodspost marketing –surveillance  methods
post marketing –surveillance methods
 
METHODS OF POST MARKETING SURVEILLANCE
METHODS OF POST MARKETING SURVEILLANCEMETHODS OF POST MARKETING SURVEILLANCE
METHODS OF POST MARKETING SURVEILLANCE
 
Toxicity Studies
Toxicity StudiesToxicity Studies
Toxicity Studies
 
Copyright
CopyrightCopyright
Copyright
 
Toxicology & Toxicovigilance
Toxicology & ToxicovigilanceToxicology & Toxicovigilance
Toxicology & Toxicovigilance
 

Similar to Forensic Pharmacovigilance: New Dimension of Drug Safety

profile of adverse drug reactions in a rural tertiary care hospital
profile of adverse drug reactions in a rural tertiary care hospital profile of adverse drug reactions in a rural tertiary care hospital
profile of adverse drug reactions in a rural tertiary care hospital Naser Tadvi
 
ADVERSE DRUG REACTION | PHARMACY PRACTICE | PDF | SHIVAM DUBEY B PHARMA | PHA...
ADVERSE DRUG REACTION | PHARMACY PRACTICE | PDF | SHIVAM DUBEY B PHARMA | PHA...ADVERSE DRUG REACTION | PHARMACY PRACTICE | PDF | SHIVAM DUBEY B PHARMA | PHA...
ADVERSE DRUG REACTION | PHARMACY PRACTICE | PDF | SHIVAM DUBEY B PHARMA | PHA...MrHotmaster1
 
Introduction to clinical pharmacy & toxicology
Introduction to clinical pharmacy & toxicologyIntroduction to clinical pharmacy & toxicology
Introduction to clinical pharmacy & toxicologyAsraful Islam Rayhan
 
introductiontopharmacoepidemiology-230613144442-c713d639.pdf
introductiontopharmacoepidemiology-230613144442-c713d639.pdfintroductiontopharmacoepidemiology-230613144442-c713d639.pdf
introductiontopharmacoepidemiology-230613144442-c713d639.pdfOgunsina1
 
INTRODUCTION TO PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGY.pptx
INTRODUCTION TO PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGY.pptxINTRODUCTION TO PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGY.pptx
INTRODUCTION TO PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGY.pptxAmeena Kadar
 
Understanding pharmacovigilance
Understanding pharmacovigilanceUnderstanding pharmacovigilance
Understanding pharmacovigilancefinenessinstitute
 
Adverse Drug Reactions - Basics and Classification
Adverse Drug Reactions - Basics and ClassificationAdverse Drug Reactions - Basics and Classification
Adverse Drug Reactions - Basics and ClassificationVenkateswaramurthy N
 
Pharmacovigilance: The conscientious today for safe tomorrow
Pharmacovigilance: The conscientious today for safe tomorrowPharmacovigilance: The conscientious today for safe tomorrow
Pharmacovigilance: The conscientious today for safe tomorrowpharmaindexing
 
Spontaneous Reporting and Prescription Event Monitoring.pptx
Spontaneous Reporting and Prescription Event Monitoring.pptxSpontaneous Reporting and Prescription Event Monitoring.pptx
Spontaneous Reporting and Prescription Event Monitoring.pptxDrRajeshHadia
 

Similar to Forensic Pharmacovigilance: New Dimension of Drug Safety (20)

profile of adverse drug reactions in a rural tertiary care hospital
profile of adverse drug reactions in a rural tertiary care hospital profile of adverse drug reactions in a rural tertiary care hospital
profile of adverse drug reactions in a rural tertiary care hospital
 
ADVERSE DRUG REACTION | PHARMACY PRACTICE | PDF | SHIVAM DUBEY B PHARMA | PHA...
ADVERSE DRUG REACTION | PHARMACY PRACTICE | PDF | SHIVAM DUBEY B PHARMA | PHA...ADVERSE DRUG REACTION | PHARMACY PRACTICE | PDF | SHIVAM DUBEY B PHARMA | PHA...
ADVERSE DRUG REACTION | PHARMACY PRACTICE | PDF | SHIVAM DUBEY B PHARMA | PHA...
 
Adverse drug reactions
Adverse drug reactionsAdverse drug reactions
Adverse drug reactions
 
Hospital pharmacy
Hospital pharmacyHospital pharmacy
Hospital pharmacy
 
Introduction to clinical pharmacy & toxicology
Introduction to clinical pharmacy & toxicologyIntroduction to clinical pharmacy & toxicology
Introduction to clinical pharmacy & toxicology
 
Pharmacovigilance
PharmacovigilancePharmacovigilance
Pharmacovigilance
 
JPDS
JPDSJPDS
JPDS
 
Pharmacoepidemiology
Pharmacoepidemiology Pharmacoepidemiology
Pharmacoepidemiology
 
Pharmacovigilance
PharmacovigilancePharmacovigilance
Pharmacovigilance
 
Outlining pharmacovigilance
Outlining pharmacovigilanceOutlining pharmacovigilance
Outlining pharmacovigilance
 
introductiontopharmacoepidemiology-230613144442-c713d639.pdf
introductiontopharmacoepidemiology-230613144442-c713d639.pdfintroductiontopharmacoepidemiology-230613144442-c713d639.pdf
introductiontopharmacoepidemiology-230613144442-c713d639.pdf
 
INTRODUCTION TO PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGY.pptx
INTRODUCTION TO PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGY.pptxINTRODUCTION TO PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGY.pptx
INTRODUCTION TO PHARMACOEPIDEMIOLOGY.pptx
 
Understanding pharmacovigilance
Understanding pharmacovigilanceUnderstanding pharmacovigilance
Understanding pharmacovigilance
 
Pharmacovigilance: A review
Pharmacovigilance: A reviewPharmacovigilance: A review
Pharmacovigilance: A review
 
Drug induced diseases
Drug induced diseasesDrug induced diseases
Drug induced diseases
 
Pharmacovigilance
PharmacovigilancePharmacovigilance
Pharmacovigilance
 
Adverse Drug Reactions - Basics and Classification
Adverse Drug Reactions - Basics and ClassificationAdverse Drug Reactions - Basics and Classification
Adverse Drug Reactions - Basics and Classification
 
Farmakoepidemiologi3
Farmakoepidemiologi3Farmakoepidemiologi3
Farmakoepidemiologi3
 
Pharmacovigilance: The conscientious today for safe tomorrow
Pharmacovigilance: The conscientious today for safe tomorrowPharmacovigilance: The conscientious today for safe tomorrow
Pharmacovigilance: The conscientious today for safe tomorrow
 
Spontaneous Reporting and Prescription Event Monitoring.pptx
Spontaneous Reporting and Prescription Event Monitoring.pptxSpontaneous Reporting and Prescription Event Monitoring.pptx
Spontaneous Reporting and Prescription Event Monitoring.pptx
 

More from Rosmirella Cano Rojas

Can chlorine dioxide prevent the spreading of coronavirus or other viral infe...
Can chlorine dioxide prevent the spreading of coronavirus or other viral infe...Can chlorine dioxide prevent the spreading of coronavirus or other viral infe...
Can chlorine dioxide prevent the spreading of coronavirus or other viral infe...Rosmirella Cano Rojas
 
Characteristics of pediatric SARS CoV-2 infection and potential evidence for ...
Characteristics of pediatric SARS CoV-2 infection and potential evidence for ...Characteristics of pediatric SARS CoV-2 infection and potential evidence for ...
Characteristics of pediatric SARS CoV-2 infection and potential evidence for ...Rosmirella Cano Rojas
 
Buenas Prácticas de Farmacovigilancia para las Américas
Buenas Prácticas de Farmacovigilancia para las AméricasBuenas Prácticas de Farmacovigilancia para las Américas
Buenas Prácticas de Farmacovigilancia para las AméricasRosmirella Cano Rojas
 
Experiencia da implementação da Tecnovigilância no Brasil
Experiencia da implementação da Tecnovigilância no BrasilExperiencia da implementação da Tecnovigilância no Brasil
Experiencia da implementação da Tecnovigilância no BrasilRosmirella Cano Rojas
 
Biosimilaridad e intercambiabilidad: principios y evidencia: una revisión sis...
Biosimilaridad e intercambiabilidad: principios y evidencia: una revisión sis...Biosimilaridad e intercambiabilidad: principios y evidencia: una revisión sis...
Biosimilaridad e intercambiabilidad: principios y evidencia: una revisión sis...Rosmirella Cano Rojas
 
Risk Management In Pharmacovigilance
Risk Management In PharmacovigilanceRisk Management In Pharmacovigilance
Risk Management In PharmacovigilanceRosmirella Cano Rojas
 
A Comparison Between French and Mexican Technovigilance Process
A Comparison Between French and Mexican Technovigilance ProcessA Comparison Between French and Mexican Technovigilance Process
A Comparison Between French and Mexican Technovigilance ProcessRosmirella Cano Rojas
 
Cosmetovigilance definition, regulation and use in practice.
Cosmetovigilance definition, regulation and use in practice.Cosmetovigilance definition, regulation and use in practice.
Cosmetovigilance definition, regulation and use in practice.Rosmirella Cano Rojas
 
Regulación en Dispositivos Médicos
Regulación en Dispositivos MédicosRegulación en Dispositivos Médicos
Regulación en Dispositivos MédicosRosmirella Cano Rojas
 
"Pharmacovigilance in Crisis: Drug Safety at a Crossroads, 2018".
"Pharmacovigilance in Crisis: Drug Safety at a Crossroads, 2018"."Pharmacovigilance in Crisis: Drug Safety at a Crossroads, 2018".
"Pharmacovigilance in Crisis: Drug Safety at a Crossroads, 2018".Rosmirella Cano Rojas
 

More from Rosmirella Cano Rojas (11)

Can chlorine dioxide prevent the spreading of coronavirus or other viral infe...
Can chlorine dioxide prevent the spreading of coronavirus or other viral infe...Can chlorine dioxide prevent the spreading of coronavirus or other viral infe...
Can chlorine dioxide prevent the spreading of coronavirus or other viral infe...
 
Characteristics of pediatric SARS CoV-2 infection and potential evidence for ...
Characteristics of pediatric SARS CoV-2 infection and potential evidence for ...Characteristics of pediatric SARS CoV-2 infection and potential evidence for ...
Characteristics of pediatric SARS CoV-2 infection and potential evidence for ...
 
Buenas Prácticas de Farmacovigilancia para las Américas
Buenas Prácticas de Farmacovigilancia para las AméricasBuenas Prácticas de Farmacovigilancia para las Américas
Buenas Prácticas de Farmacovigilancia para las Américas
 
Experiencia da implementação da Tecnovigilância no Brasil
Experiencia da implementação da Tecnovigilância no BrasilExperiencia da implementação da Tecnovigilância no Brasil
Experiencia da implementação da Tecnovigilância no Brasil
 
Pharmacovigilance in pediatrics
Pharmacovigilance in pediatricsPharmacovigilance in pediatrics
Pharmacovigilance in pediatrics
 
Biosimilaridad e intercambiabilidad: principios y evidencia: una revisión sis...
Biosimilaridad e intercambiabilidad: principios y evidencia: una revisión sis...Biosimilaridad e intercambiabilidad: principios y evidencia: una revisión sis...
Biosimilaridad e intercambiabilidad: principios y evidencia: una revisión sis...
 
Risk Management In Pharmacovigilance
Risk Management In PharmacovigilanceRisk Management In Pharmacovigilance
Risk Management In Pharmacovigilance
 
A Comparison Between French and Mexican Technovigilance Process
A Comparison Between French and Mexican Technovigilance ProcessA Comparison Between French and Mexican Technovigilance Process
A Comparison Between French and Mexican Technovigilance Process
 
Cosmetovigilance definition, regulation and use in practice.
Cosmetovigilance definition, regulation and use in practice.Cosmetovigilance definition, regulation and use in practice.
Cosmetovigilance definition, regulation and use in practice.
 
Regulación en Dispositivos Médicos
Regulación en Dispositivos MédicosRegulación en Dispositivos Médicos
Regulación en Dispositivos Médicos
 
"Pharmacovigilance in Crisis: Drug Safety at a Crossroads, 2018".
"Pharmacovigilance in Crisis: Drug Safety at a Crossroads, 2018"."Pharmacovigilance in Crisis: Drug Safety at a Crossroads, 2018".
"Pharmacovigilance in Crisis: Drug Safety at a Crossroads, 2018".
 

Recently uploaded

Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...Taniya Sharma
 
Call Girls Tirupati Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Tirupati Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Tirupati Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Tirupati Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...Taniya Sharma
 
♛VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls Chintalkunta🖕7001035870🖕Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
♛VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls Chintalkunta🖕7001035870🖕Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...♛VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls Chintalkunta🖕7001035870🖕Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
♛VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls Chintalkunta🖕7001035870🖕Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...astropune
 
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 6297143586 𖠋 Will You Mis...
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 6297143586 𖠋 Will You Mis...The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 6297143586 𖠋 Will You Mis...
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 6297143586 𖠋 Will You Mis...chandars293
 
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore EscortsCall Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escortsvidya singh
 
Call Girls Jabalpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Jabalpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Jabalpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Jabalpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...
Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...
Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...Call Girls in Nagpur High Profile
 
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD availableChandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD availableDipal Arora
 
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...perfect solution
 
Call Girls Cuttack Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Cuttack Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Cuttack Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Cuttack Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableDipal Arora
 
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...Arohi Goyal
 
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any TimeTop Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any TimeCall Girls Delhi
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Gen...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Gen...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Gen...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Gen...narwatsonia7
 
Bangalore Call Girl Whatsapp Number 100% Complete Your Sexual Needs
Bangalore Call Girl Whatsapp Number 100% Complete Your Sexual NeedsBangalore Call Girl Whatsapp Number 100% Complete Your Sexual Needs
Bangalore Call Girl Whatsapp Number 100% Complete Your Sexual NeedsGfnyt
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls JaipurCall Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipurparulsinha
 
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ❤️🍑 8250192130 👄 Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ❤️🍑 8250192130 👄 Independent Escort Service ...Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ❤️🍑 8250192130 👄 Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ❤️🍑 8250192130 👄 Independent Escort Service ...CALL GIRLS
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...narwatsonia7
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Faridabad Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
💎VVIP Kolkata Call Girls Parganas🩱7001035870🩱Independent Girl ( Ac Rooms Avai...
 
Call Girls Tirupati Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Tirupati Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Tirupati Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Tirupati Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
(👑VVIP ISHAAN ) Russian Call Girls Service Navi Mumbai🖕9920874524🖕Independent...
 
♛VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls Chintalkunta🖕7001035870🖕Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
♛VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls Chintalkunta🖕7001035870🖕Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...♛VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls Chintalkunta🖕7001035870🖕Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
♛VVIP Hyderabad Call Girls Chintalkunta🖕7001035870🖕Riya Kappor Top Call Girl ...
 
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 6297143586 𖠋 Will You Mis...
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 6297143586 𖠋 Will You Mis...The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 6297143586 𖠋 Will You Mis...
The Most Attractive Hyderabad Call Girls Kothapet 𖠋 6297143586 𖠋 Will You Mis...
 
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore EscortsCall Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
Call Girls Horamavu WhatsApp Number 7001035870 Meeting With Bangalore Escorts
 
Call Girls Jabalpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Jabalpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Jabalpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Jabalpur Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Gwalior Just Call 8617370543 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...
Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...
Book Paid Powai Call Girls Mumbai 𖠋 9930245274 𖠋Low Budget Full Independent H...
 
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD availableChandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
Chandrapur Call girls 8617370543 Provides all area service COD available
 
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
College Call Girls in Haridwar 9667172968 Short 4000 Night 10000 Best call gi...
 
Call Girls Cuttack Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Cuttack Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service AvailableCall Girls Cuttack Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
Call Girls Cuttack Just Call 9907093804 Top Class Call Girl Service Available
 
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
All Time Service Available Call Girls Marine Drive 📳 9820252231 For 18+ VIP C...
 
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any TimeTop Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
Top Quality Call Girl Service Kalyanpur 6378878445 Available Call Girls Any Time
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Gen...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Gen...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Gen...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Richmond Circle ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Gen...
 
Bangalore Call Girl Whatsapp Number 100% Complete Your Sexual Needs
Bangalore Call Girl Whatsapp Number 100% Complete Your Sexual NeedsBangalore Call Girl Whatsapp Number 100% Complete Your Sexual Needs
Bangalore Call Girl Whatsapp Number 100% Complete Your Sexual Needs
 
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls JaipurCall Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
Call Girls Service Jaipur Grishma WhatsApp ❤8445551418 VIP Call Girls Jaipur
 
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ❤️🍑 8250192130 👄 Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ❤️🍑 8250192130 👄 Independent Escort Service ...Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ❤️🍑 8250192130 👄 Independent Escort Service ...
Call Girls Service Surat Samaira ❤️🍑 8250192130 👄 Independent Escort Service ...
 
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
Top Rated Bangalore Call Girls Mg Road ⟟ 8250192130 ⟟ Call Me For Genuine Sex...
 

Forensic Pharmacovigilance: New Dimension of Drug Safety

  • 1. Review Forensic pharmacovigilance: Newer dimension of pharmacovigilance Rakesh K. Sewal, Vikas K. Saini, Bikash Medhi* Department of Pharmacology, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, 160012, India a r t i c l e i n f o Article history: Received 4 October 2014 Received in revised form 25 March 2015 Accepted 29 May 2015 Available online 6 June 2015 Keywords: Pharmacovigilance Forensic science Medicolegal Adverse drug reaction a b s t r a c t Drug safety for the patients is of paramount importance for a medical professional. Pharmacovigilance attempts to ensure the safety of patients by keeping a close vigil on the pattern of adverse events sec- ondary to drug use. Number of medicolegal cases is at rise since last few years. Forensic sciences and pharmacovigilance need to work hand in hand to unlock the mystery of many criminal and civil pro- ceedings. Pharmacovigilance offers its wide scope in forensic sciences by putting forward its expertise on adverse profile of drugs which may be instrumental in solving the cases and bringing the justice forth. It may range from as simple affairs as defining the adverse drug reaction on one hand to putting expert advice in critical criminal cases on the other one. Pharmacovigilance experts have to abide by the ethics of the practice while executing their duties as expert else it may tarnish the justice and loosen its dependability. As a budding discipline of science, it is confronted with several hurdles and challenges which include reluctance of medical professionals for being involved in court proceedings, extrapolations of facts and data and variations in law across the globe etc. These challenges and hurdles call the medical fraternity come forward to work towards the momentous application of pharmacovigilance in the forensic sciences. Evidence based practice e.g. testing the biological samples for the presence of drugs may prove to be pivotal in the success of this collaboration of sciences. © 2015 Elsevier Ltd and Faculty of Forensic and Legal Medicine. All rights reserved. 1. Introduction Pharmacovigilance has witnessed an exponential growth in last few decades owing to the increasing awareness amongst healthcare professionals. Pharmacovigilance is the science and activities relating to the detection, assessment, understanding and prevention of adverse effects or any other drug-related problem.1 The various components of pharmacovigilance ranging from detection to pre- vention of adverse drug reactions (ADR's) lay a strong foundation for the solution of medicolegal cases. A medicolegal case is where a person is injured or harmed in any way and needs medical attention for it. Medicolegal cases comprise of detection and collection of ev- idences in accidents, suicides and homicides. In this contemporary world of medicine, medicolegal issues are emerging out at an alarming rate.2 This is worthwhile to mention that law and medical professionals need to work hand in hand for the sake of betterment and rehabilitation of the victims of medicolegal cases.3 Forensic sci- ences and pharmacovigilance offer collaborative services to each other for the benefit of stakeholders. They can exchange the knowl- edge with each other to complement the information. This symbiotic relationship of two vital components of healthcare system gives birth to a new discipline known as “Forensic Pharmacovigilance”. 2. Scope of pharmacovigilance in forensic medicine 2.1. Illicit drug use Illicit drug use cases seek the expert opinion on drugs and their possible adverse events. The illegal drugs use is on rise since few decades. The number of intentional and unintentional deaths from prescription drugs overdose is now greater than the deaths from heroin and cocaine combined. A large part of the problem is the use of pain-killers without a prescription, or misusing a prescribed drug to get “high.” Improving the way prescription painkillers are pre- scribed can reduce the number of people who misuse, abuse or overdose these drugs, while making sure patients have access to safe and effective treatment. In 2011, legislation to create a Pre- scription Drug Monitoring Program was passed in Maryland to make comprehensive information on prescribed and dispensed Controlled Dangerous Substances available to doctors, pharmacists and other healthcare providers.4 * Corresponding author. Department of Pharmacology, Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education & Research, Chandigarh, India. Tel.: þ91 172 2755250 (O), þ91 9815409652 (M); fax: þ91 1722744401, þ91 1722745078. E-mail address: drbikashus@yahoo.com (B. Medhi). Contents lists available at ScienceDirect Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jflm http://dx.doi.org/10.1016/j.jflm.2015.05.015 1752-928X/© 2015 Elsevier Ltd and Faculty of Forensic and Legal Medicine. All rights reserved. Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118
  • 2. 2.2. Role in solving civil or criminal cases During the criminal proceedings, involvement of drugs in a case may seek the expert advice of pharmacovigilance to solve the case.5 Examples of such cases include death due to overdose toxicity of drugs like sedatives being used for sleep disorders or opiates used for pain management. Under few circumstances, apart from the involvement of toxicological effects of drugs; there are certain adverse drug reactions which can be attributed responsible for occurrence of the legal case. The fact that suicidal tendencies sec- ondary to the use of antidepressants are the known adverse effects of these drugs may be useful in mining/unleashing the cause of death of a person treated by these drugs and who commits a suicide leaving a mystery behind.6 Table 1 enlists the examples of drugs and their forensic signifi- cance which illustrates the relevance of drugs’ knowledge in forensic concerns. 2.3. Differentiation between adverse drug reaction and adverse event Any untoward medical occurrence that may appear during treatment with a pharmaceutical product but which does not necessarily have a causal relationship with the treatment is called Table 1 Examples of drugs explain their possible ADR's of forensic significance. S. No. Drug Class/Use ADR Forensic significance Reference 1 Citalopram Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors QTc interval prolongation May cause adverse drug reactions of serious outcomes 7,8 2 Dextropropoxyphene Opioid analgesic QTc interval prolongation May cause adverse drug reactions of serious outcomes 9e11 3 Flunitrazepam Intermediate acting benzodiazepine QTc interval prolongation May cause adverse drug reactions of serious outcomes 12 4 Methadone Opioid analgesic QT Prolongation Respiratory depression Respiratory arrest 13,14 5 Varenicline Nicotinic acetylcholine receptor agonist Manic episodes induced Suicidal Ideation Death involving a suspicion of suicide committed by a person taking varenicline 15,16 6 Digoxin Cardiac glycoside Arrhythmia ST depression,Ventricular fibrillation leading to fatal or other serious outcome 17 7 Fentanyl Opioid analgesic Respiratory depression Overdose toxicity may result in death. 18 8 Heroin Opiate Mast cell degradation Cardiac failure which may be an explanation of death 19,20 9 Cefuroxime Cephalosporin Disulfiram-like reaction Unexpected death 21 10 Morphine Opioid analgesic Respiratory depression leading to death in severe cases Intentional or accidental overdose results in death. Medication error or suicidal events should be differentiated. 22 11 Aldicarb Acetylcholinestearse inhibitor CNS depression Death due to an aldicarb acute intoxication. 23,24 12 Trazodone Antidepressant, anxiolytic, and hypnotic Suicidal ideation While mining the evidences in death of such cases suicidal ideation may be considered. 25,26 13 Atracurium Nondepolarizing skeletal muscle relaxant Hypertension and tachycardia and hypotension and bradycardia Overdose toxicity for Suicidal intention 27 14 Cyclizine Antihistaminic CNS depression, hypertension Overdose toxicity may result in death 28,29 15 Zopiclone Nonbenzodiazepine hypnotic agent Amnesia, palpitation, hallucination Suicidal attempt results in fatality 30 16 Fluoxetine Selective serotonin reuptake inhibitor Development of akathisia related to the development of suicidal ideation. Suicidal ideation information may be instrumental in solving mysterious death cases 31 17 Imipramine Tricyclic antidepressant Depresses automaticity Complete atrio-ventricular heart block resulting in sudden death 17 18 Mephedrone CNS stimulant Delirium Impaired judgement may cause accidental death 32 19 Quinidine Anti arrhythmic QT prolongation Rapid ventricular arrhythmia results in death. Reason of death may be explained. 17 20 Clozapine Atypical antidepressant Myocarditis Myocarditis induced death due to overdose 33,34 21 Thioridazine Antipsychotic Arrhythmia Arrhythmogenic sudden cardiac death 35 22 Dextromethorphan Antitussive Tachycardia, hypertension, and respiratory depression Death from respiratory failure 36 23 Acetamenophen NSAID/Antipyretic Hepatotoxicity Fulminant hepatic failure 37 24 Ceftriaxone Cephalosporin Auto eimmune hemolytic anemia Hemolytic anemia induced cardio-respiratory arrest, Acute renal failure 38,39 25 Tetracycline Antibiotic Jaundice Hepatotoxicity 40 26 Thyroxine Congenital hypothyroidism Progressive bradycardia Cardiac Arrest 41 27 Azathioprine Immunosuppresant Bone marrow suppression, hematological toxicity, pancreatitis Serious pancytopenia due to the accumulation of cytotoxic metabolites 42e44 28 Doxorubicin Cytotoxic Cardiotoxicity Cardiomyopathy or cardiac failure 45,46 29 Rifampicin/Isoniazide/ Ethambutol/Pyrazinamide Antitubercular FDC Hepatotoxicity Acute liver failure due to hepatic encephalopathy 47 30 Enalapril ACE inhibitor Hepatotoxicity Hepatic failure 41 31 Propofol Anaesthetic Pulmonary oedema and haemorrhagic pancreatitis, respiratory depression, bronchospasm and chest wall rigidity Death occurred due to pulmonary oedema as patient did not receive ventilation 48 R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118114
  • 3. as adverse event. According to WHO, adverse drug reaction is defined as “A response to a drug which is noxious and unintended; and occurs at doses normally used in man for the prophylaxis; diagnosis or therapy of disease, or for modification of physiological function.49 Thus, every adverse drug reaction is an adverse event but not vice versa. Keeping this point in view, it is pertinent to cautiously identify these two aspects of unintended experiences after the use of drugs. “Causality assessment” is the tool to put scientific evidence forth to determine the accurate nature of adverse experience after a drug use. If there is any stronger or weaker correlation of administration of drug with the occurrence of adverse event then it is known as adverse drug reaction. There are several causality assessment scales adopted by the pharmacovigi- lance experts to assign the level of correlation. Naranjos's scale, WHO's causality assessment scale and Bayesian scale are few to name.50,51 Different degrees of association are described by these scales e.g. certain, probable, possible and unlikely are the levels mentioned by the WHO's scale for causality assessment.52,53 2.4. Discrimination between serious and severe ADR's There is a thin line of demarcation between serious and severe drug reactions which are misunderstood many a times. Court proceedings may be in a need to judge the gravity of problem in terms of seriousness and severity. Severe reactions should never be confused with serious reactions. For instance, in any drug related injury in clinical trials compensation is granted to the victim for which judiciary needs to ascertain whether the injury was serious or not. There is a criterion almost universally accepted for determining the seriousness of drug reaction. If the ADR falls in to the bracket of that criterion then it should be designated as serious event. A re- action is said to be serious if it 1) results in death, 2) is life- threatening, 3) requires inpatient hospitalization or prolongation of existing hospitalization, 4) results in persistent or significant disability/incapacity, 5) results in congenital abnormality, and 6) is any other medically important condition. Severity of the ADR's deals with the intensity of the reaction graded as mild, moderate, severe.49 Severe is never synonymous with serious e.g. headache may be severe in grade but not of great medical significance for seriousness. 2.5. Identification of counterfeit and substandard drugs Pharmacovigilance data can generate the signal for some spe- cific drug and/or its formulations; under some instances. Forensic pharmacovigilance is useful when counterfeit or substandard drugs cause the adverse events. Standard pharmacovigilance methods of registration, analysis and investigation are able in indentifying the substandard drugs or formulations which have caused the adverse events. Thousands of adverse reactions in USA which are secondary to administration of contaminated heparin in 2009 is an example of adverse events occurred due to contaminated or counterfeit drugs which generates the signal for taking corrective action as it happened in case of the present example. Market authorization holder had to recall all heparin due to alarming figure of ADR's including hundreds of fatalities.54 Few areas of scope of forensic pharmacovigilance are depicted in Fig. 1. 3. Forensic pharmacovigilance as another bud of pharmacovigilance Though birth of pharmacovigilance owes back to the occurrence of a disaster known popularly as thalidomide tragedy but it has attained a proliferative growth in last few decades.55 Pharmacovi- gilance has gained a pace to expand its applications in other streams of science. Ecopharmacovigilance, which is defined as science and activities concerning detection, assessment, under- standing, and prevention of adverse effects or other problems related to the presence of pharmaceuticals in the environment, which affect human and other animal species is a recent develop- ment of pharmacovigilance proving its relevance in environmental sciences.56 Haemovigilance, materiovigilance, biovigilance are few more examples which are transformed facet of pharmacovigilance. For example, in Indian context, haemovigilance is covered under pharmacovigilance program of India as blood or blood products are governed by drug regulatory authorities in India treating them as a drug.57 On the same pattern we have recently seen a newer budding branch of pharmacovigilance i.e Forensic Pharmacovigi- lance which is instrumental in solving the legal issues raised on involvement of any drug. Forensic pharmacovigilance i.e Fig. 1. Scope of forensic pharmacovigilance. R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118 115
  • 4. implementation of pharmacovigilance expertise for forensic pur- pose may be used to answer the following questions: Could the drug under question (or chemical) have caused the adverse effect in the victim ? Did it cause the effect either ‘beyond all reasonable doubt?’ (criminal case) or ‘as a balance of probabilities (civil case)?3 4. Challenges and hurdles in forensic pharmacovigilance 4.1. Reluctance of medical professionals Reluctance of medical professionals in playing their role as an expert for forensic purposes is one of the sturdiest challenges to be met. Causes contributing to the medical professional's reluctance include fear of litigation, loss of productivity, fear of being twisted by lawyers etc.58 Despite of these challenges medical professionals should undertake the civic duties by contributing their expertise in resolving the forensic issues. 4.2. Extrapolation of a data does not always produce the real figures Extrapolation of data generated through previous studies or experiences cannot always be practised. Competitiveness and quality of epidemiological studies in medicine always lies under question mark making it difficult to accept their conclusion for making decisions in some forensic issues.59 4.3. Uniformity vs non uniformity Medical Sciences have similar foundation across the globe but law varies across the borders. Medical profession is not open to public rather it depends upon the subjective opinion of the pro- fessionals whereas in contrast law is open at mass levels and has a strong foundation of defined rules. Though in forensic pharmaco- vigilance both the disciplines need to work hand in hand but there are certain conflictions. Medicine discipline is challenged by the law often during the trials. 4.4. Ethics in forensic pharmacovigilance Judiciary has to rely more upon the opinion of the expert in a case involving the drug. They rely more upon the testimony of forensic experts. Therefore, an ethical obligation always lies upon expert to put the truth forward and not to mislead the judiciary, defense, or the state when testifying before the court, or when preparing their reports relating to their analyses of forensic evi- dence. We still lack any universally applicable guidelines on ethical code for the forensic sciences. Though there are few professional bodies catering to the needs of forensic analysts on ethics in forensic sciences. American Board of Criminalistics (ABC) and the American Academy of Forensic Science are two professional bodies useful for forensic scientists in United States of America.60 In a study conducted by Brandon L. Garrett and Peter J. Neufeld in 2009 six types of invalid testimony could be identified which are enlisted as below.61 ▪ Evidence that was non-probative presented as probative ▪ Discounting exculpatory evidence ▪ Conclusion of evidence originating from the defendant without supporting empirical data ▪ Non-statistical statements made without supporting empirical data ▪ Inaccurate presentation of statistics or frequency ▪ Providing statistics without supporting empirical data An expert needs to be unbiased and fair enough in his/her obligations. The prime obligation of an expert must be to contribute towards the justice. Legal, scientific, and ethical values can become snarled during the court proceedings. It becomes a responsibility of an expert to keep his opinion after a competent, unbiased and probative work. The causes behind practising un- ethical acts include avarice, zeal of power or over ambitions of promotion, status or personal welfare. Sometimes even casual behaviour of experts towards professional duties also makes their acts unethical. Living with guilt of that a guilty person escapes and or an impeccant person gets punished based on the advice or comments submitted by the pharmacovigilance expert may restrain him or her from unethical acts. Professional bodies and organizations should put the efforts forward to ensure ethical practice, veracity of testimony among individuals engaged as expert for forensic purpose. It is pertinent to devise a code of conduct for such professionals to keep the benchmark of ethics in forensic sciences. 5. Key points for an effective forensic pharmacovigilance 5.1. Forensic pharmacokinetics Forensic pharmacokinetics should be honoured while giving the opinion or report on medico legal case involving the drugs. If possible, biological samples should be collected to assess them for the presence of drugs or their metabolites which further can be correlated with the adverse events related to the forensic concerns. Claims of adverse drug reactions may be supported by data of pharmacokinetics.2 Pharmacokinetics/Pharmacodynamics (PK/PD) studies are gaining the popularity at various levels of research which may be a tool for the effective implementation of pharma- covigilance in forensic sciences. 5.2. Temporal relationship Temporal relationship of occurrence of adverse event and administration of drug should be taken into consideration while preparing the report for forensic purposes. The time lag between administration of drug and occurrence of ADR defines the time course of a reaction which is of six types: Rapid: toxic reactions First-dose: hypersensitivity reactions Early: collateral reactions Intermediate ecollateral or hyper sensitivity reactions Late ecollateral reactions Delayed ecollateral reactions62 Temporal relationship lays a strong foundation for the causality assessment of the case and also plays a vital role for the judgement purposes e.g. immediate reactions showing a close temporal relationship-between the adverse event and administration of dose makes judiciary more convinced. Sometimes, when a far temporal association lies between the administration of drug and event and there is any scientific fact explaining that gap, an advice of experts in pharmacovigilance or pharmacology must be sought because there are certain drugs which causes the adverse events only after accumulation of the drug or its metabolite in the body e.g. morphine. But, there are certain exceptions in classification cited here e.g. hypersensitivity reaction is usually immediate reactions but may be delayed in few instances. Stevens Johnson Syndrome secondary to paracetamol after chronic use may be an example of such delayed immune mediated reaction. R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118116
  • 5. 5.3. Causality assessment of the case Causality assessment determines the degree of probability of correlation of administration of a drug and occurrence of adverse event. It must be exercised cautiously and tested rigorously before putting a report before the bench of a court. Several scales are being used for causality assessment like Naranjo's scale, WHO's Scale for causality assessment and Probability algorithm. A pharmacovigi- lance expert should cautiously use the scale of causality assessment and it should be specified in the report submitted to the judiciary.52 5.4. Cautious extrapolation of facts to every case Exaggerated extrapolation of the case to some fact or data may tarnish the proceedings of the forensic cases. It may entirely mislead the verdict of the criminal or civil cases. Cautious extrap- olation is warranted to avoid such misleading judgements based upon inaccurate data. 5.5. Challenges of pharmacovigilance Though pharmacovigilance is set to offer its application in forensic sciences but there are few challenges before the pharma- covigilance to be met. Increased globalization of drugs, exponential rise in volume of drugs used and polypharmacy are few elements which make the pharmacovigilance a complex discipline. Under the light of these challenges, pharmacovigilance now should be understood beyond merely reporting the harms; rather it should be a rigorous risk benefit assessment. Few standards of quality in pharmacovigilance have been set and good pharmacovigilance practices (GVP) is a citable example of that.63 It is imperative to adhere to such standards while implementing pharmacovigilance in forensic areas. 5.6. Presenting evidence for the court Proper presentation of the evidences by the medical or phar- macovigilance expert may illuminate the case. A report for the forensic purposes should be written clearly and should not include the comments from the area which is beyond the expertise who is submitting the report. A clear statement should be made in report if some additional advice of another expert is needed. Scientifics evidences, facts and observation should be presented in a manner that can easily be understood by judges to make them arrive at a verdict with reasonably fair understanding of the case.58 6. Conclusions In the light of increasing medicolegal cases, there is a substantial need of contribution of drug expertise in solving the criminal and civil cases involving the drugs at one or other stages. Pharmacovi- gilance is the science of detection, assessment, understanding, prevention of adverse events associated with the use of drugs. Pharmacovigilance can cater to the needs of legal framework to mine the cases involving the drugs by differentiating the serious and non serious reactions, establishing the causal relationship be- tween drug and adverse event. Proliferating role of pharmacovi- gilance has now sprawled over the arena of legal medicine giving birth to newer branch of science known as forensic pharmacovi- gilance which offers a wide range of its scope and application and warrants a cautious execution of this exercise else it may deviate from the intended use. Conflict of interest None declared. Funding None declared. Ethical approval None declared. References 1. World Health Organization Collaborating Centre for International Drug Moni- toring. The importance of pharmacovigilance safety monitoring of medicinal products. Geneva: World Health Organization; 2002. 2. Medhi B, Singh PK, Bansal YS, Setia P. Forensic pharmacokinetics: a new dimension for drug related medico legal cases. J Forensic Res 2011;2:128. http:// dx.doi.org/10.4172/2157-7145.1000128. 3. Edwards IR, Body D. Forensic pharmacovigilance. Int J Risk Saf Med 2012;12: 241e2. 4. Drug induced deaths. Maryland: Department of Mental Health and Hygiene; 2012. 5. Aronson JK, Hauben M. Anecdotes that provide definitive evidence. BMJ 2006;333:1267e9. 6. Kielholz P, Battegay R. Behandlung depressiver Zustandsbilder, unter spezieller Berücksichtigung von Tofranil, einem neuen Antidepressivum. Schweiz Med Wochenschr 1958;88:763e7. 7. Catalano G, Catalano MC, Epstein MA, Tsambiras PE. QTc interval prolongation associated with citalopram overdose: a case report and literature review. Clin Neuropharmacol 2001;24(3):158e62. 8. Jonasson B, Saldeen T. Citalopram in fatal poisoning cases. Forensic Sci Int 2002;126(1):1e6. 9. Carson DJL, Carson ED. Fatal dextropropoxyphene poisoning in Northern Ireland: review of 30 cases. Lancet 1977;309(8017):894e7. 10. Lawson AAH, Northridge DB. Dextropropoxyphene overdose. Med Toxicol Adverse Drug Exp 1987;2(6):430e44. 11. Hawton K, Simkin S, Deeks J. Co-proxamol and suicide: a study of national mortality statistics and local non-fatal self poisonings. BMJ 2003;326(7397): 1006. 12. Barnett JM, Broad RM. Flunitrazepam used in a case of poisoning. J Clin Forensic Med 2003;10(2):89e91. 13. Modesto-Lowe V, Brooks D, Petry N. Methadone deaths: risk factors in pain and addicted populations. J Gen Intern Med 2010;25(4):305e9. 14. Andrews CM, Krantz MJ, Wedam EF, Marcuson MJ, Capacchione JF, Haigney MC. Methadone-induced mortality in the treatment of chronic pain: role of QT prolongation. Cardiol J 2009;16(3):210e7. 15. Kintz P, Evans J, Villain M, Cirimele V. Smoking cessation with varenicline: a suicidal fatality. J Anal Toxicol 2009;33(2):118e20. 16. Stove CP, Els A, Piette MH, Lambert WE. Fatality following a suicidal overdose with varenicline. Int J Leg Med 2013;127(1):85e91. 17. Bigger JT, Weld FM. Drugs and sudden cardiac death. Ann N Y Acad Sci 1982;382(1):229e37. 18. Algren DA, Monteilh CP, Punja M, Schier JG, Belson M, Hepler BR, et al. Fentanyl-associated fatalities among illicit drug users in Wayne county, Michigan (July 2005eMay 2006). J Med Toxicol 2013;9(1):106e15. 19. Edston E, Hage-Hamsten MV, Edston E. Anaphylactoid shockea common cause of death in heroin addicts? Allergy 1997;52(9):950e4. 20. Darke S, Zador D. Fatal heroin ‘overdose’: a review. Addiction 1996;91(12): 1765e72. 21. Dong H, Zhang J, Ren L, Liu Q, Zhu S. Unexpected death due to cefuroxime- induced disulfiram-like reaction. Indian J Pharmacol 2013;45(4):399. 22. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. CDC grand rounds: prescription drug overdoses-a US epidemic. Morb Mortal Wkly Rep 2012;61(1):10. 23. Proença P, Teixeira H, de Mendonca MC, Castanheira F, Marques EP, Corte- Real F, et al. Aldicarb poisoning: one case report. Forensic Sci Int 2004;146: S79e81. 24. Ragouc-Sengler C, Tracqui A, Chavonnet A, Daijardin JB, Simonetti M, Kintz P, et al. Aldicarb poisoning. Hum Exp Toxicol 2000;19(12):657e62. 25. Martínez MA, Ballesteros S, de la Torre CS, Almarza E. Investigation of a fatality due to trazodone poisoning: case report and literature review. J Anal Toxicol 2005;29(4):262e8. 26. Gamble DE, Peterson LG. Trazodone overdose: four years of experience from voluntary reports. J Clin Psychiatry 1986;47(11):544e6. 27. Martínez MA, Ballesteros S, Almarza E. Anesthesiologist suicide with atracu- rium. J Anal Toxicol 2006;30(2):120. 28. Arnestad M, Eldor KBB, Stray-Pedersen A, Bachs L, Karinen R. Suicide due to cyclizine overdose. J Anal Toxicol 2014;38:110e2. 29. Backer RC, McFeeley P, Wohlenberg N. Fatality resulting from cyclizine over- dose. J Anal Toxicol 1989;13(5):308e9. 30. Meatherall RC. Zopiclone fatality in a hospitalized patient. J Forensic Sci 1997;42(2):340e3. 31. Creaney W, Murray I, Healy D. Antidepressant induced suicidal ideation. J Psychopharmacol 1992;6(1):120. 32. Corkery JM, Schifano F, Ghodse AH. Mephedrone-related fatalities in the United Kingdom: contextual, clinical and practical issues. Pharmacology 2012;17: 355e80. R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118 117
  • 6. 33. De Berardis D, Serroni N, Campanella D, Olivieri L, Ferri F, Carano A, et al. Update on the adverse effects of clozapine: focus on myocarditis. Curr Drug Saf 2012;7(1):55e62. 34. Fineschi V, Ner M, Riezzo I, Turillazzi E. Sudden cardiac death due to hyper- sensitivity myocarditis during clozapine treatment. Int J Leg Med 2004;118(5): 307e9. 35. Killeen DMJ. Antipsychotic-induced sudden cardiac death: examination of an atypical reaction. Expert Opin Drug Saf 2009;8(3):249e52. 36. Burns JM, Boyer EW. Antitussives and substance abuse. Subst Abuse Rehabili- tation 2013;4:75e82. http://dx.doi.org/10.2147/SAR.S36761. 37. McCormick PA, Treanor D, McCormack G. Farrell M. Early death from para- cetamol (acetaminophen) induced fulminant hepatic failure without cerebral oedema. J Hepatol 2003;39(4):547e51. 38. Garratty G, Postoway N, Schwellenbach J, McMahill PC. A fatal case of ceftri- axone (Rocephin)-induced hemolytic anaemia associated with intravascular immune hemolysis. Transfusion 1991;31:176e9. 39. Kapur G, Valentini RP, Mattoo TK, Warrier I, Imam AA. Ceftriaxone induced hemolysis complicated by acute renal failure. Pediatr Blood Cancer 2008;50(1): 139e42. 40. Hanson GC. A death from tetracycline. Postgrad Med J 1968;44:870e4. http:// dx.doi.org/10.1136/pgmj.44.517.870. 41. Cheng K, Masters S, Stephenson T, Cooke R, Ferner R, Ashworth M, et al. Identification of suspected fatal adverse drug reactions by paediatricians: a UK surveillance study. Arch Dis Child 2008;93:609e11. 42. Breen DP, Marinaki AM, Arenas M, Hayes PC. Pharmacogeneticassociation with adverse drug reactions to azathioprine immunosuppressive therapy following liver transplantation. Liver Transpl 2005;11(7):826e33. 43. Andersen V, Sonne J, Andersen M. Spontaneous reports on drug-induced pancre- atitis in Denmark from 1968 to 1999. Eur J ClinPharmacol 2001;57(6e7):517e21. 44. Gastal GR, Moreira S, Noble CF, Ferreira LE, França PH, Pinho M. Toxicity of azathioprine: why and when: analysis of the prevalence of polymorphism in Joinville, SC, Brazil. Arq Gastroenterol 2012;49(2):130e4. 45. Clarkson A, Choonara I. Surveillance for fatal suspected adverse drug reactions in the UK. Arch Dis Child 2002;87:462e7. 46. Ichikawa Y, Ghanefar M, Bayeva1 M, Wu R, Khechaduri A, Sathyamangla V, et al. Cardiotoxicity of doxorubicin is mediated through mitochondrial iron accumulation. J Clin Invest 2014;124(2):617e30. 47. Tost JR, Vidal R, Cayla J, Díaz-Cabanela D, Jimenez A, Broquetas JM. Severe hepatotoxicity due to anti-tuberculosis drugs in Spain. Int J Tuberc Lung Dis 2005;9(5):534e40. 48. Roussin A, Mirepoix M, Lassabe G, Dumestre-Toulet V, Gardette V, Montastruc JL, et al. Death related to a recreational abuse of propofol at therapeutic dose range. Br J Anaesth 2006;97(2):268. 49. [Internet] Glossary of terms used in pharmacovigilance. 2011 March [cited 2014 Feb 22]. Available from:, http://who-umc.org/Graphics/24729.pdf. 50. Agbabiaka TB, Savovic J, Ernst E. Methods for causality assessment of adverse drug reactions a systematic review. Drug Saf 2008;31(1):21e37. 51. Edwards IR. Considerations on causality in pharmacovigilance. Int J Risk Saf Med 2012:2441e54. http://dx.doi.org/10.3233/JRS-2012-0552. 52. Zaki SA. Adverse drug reaction and causality assessment scales. Lung India 2011;28:152e3. 53. [Internet] The use of the WHO-UMC system for standardised case causality assessment. 2012 April 17 [cited 2014 Mar27]. Available from:, http://who- umc.org/Graphics/24734.pdf. 54. Labadie J. Forensic pharmacovigilance and substandard or counterfeit drugs. Int J Risk Saf Med 2012;24:2437e9. 55. Grootheest KV. The dawn of Pharmacovigilance: an historical prospective. Int J Pharm Med 2003;17:195e200. 56. Medhi B, Sewal RK. Ecopharmacovigilance: an issue urgently to be addressed. Indian J Pharmacol 2012;44(5):547e9. 57. Bisht A, Singh S, Marwah N. Hemovigilance Programme-India. Asian J Transfus Sci 2013;7:73e4. 58. Hartigan-Go Kenneth. Presenting evidence for the court. Int J Risk Saf Med 2012;24:59e63. 59. Persaud N, Healy D. Epidemiological evidence in forensic pharmacovigilance. Int J Risk Saf Med 2012;24:31e5. 60. Dutelle AW. Ethics and forensic science. Mar-Apr Evid Technol Mag 2011;9(2): 24e5. 61. Barnett Peter D. Ethics in forensic science: professional standards for the practice of criminalistics. Boca Raton, FL: CRC Press; 2001. 62. Aronson JK, Ferner RE. Clarification of terminology in drug safety. Drug Saf 2005;28(10):851e70. 63. Jeetu G, Anusha G. Pharmacovigilance: a worldwide master key for drug safety monitoring. J Young Pharm 2010;2(3):315e20. R.K. Sewal et al. / Journal of Forensic and Legal Medicine 34 (2015) 113e118118