Bertie McClellan is participating in a polyamory challenge where he must court and fall in love with multiple sims. He moves his boyfriend Corey and girlfriend Vanessa into his home. Corey is unhappy about sharing Bertie with Vanessa, causing arguments. Bertie apologizes profusely to Corey and Vanessa to try to smooth things over. The relationships remain complicated as Bertie balances caring for multiple partners.