SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Download to read offline
Cultural differences reflected on the internet:

             a comparison between Belgian and Dutch e-commerce websites




                                    Malaika Brengman




Malaika Brengman

Department of Business Economics and Strategic Management
Faculty of Economic, Social and Political Sciences, and Solvay Business School
Vrije Universiteit Brussel
Pleinlaan 2
1050 Brussel
Tel: +32 (0)2 629 20 65
Fax: +32 (0)2 629 20 60
E-mail: malaika.brengman@vub.ac.be
Cultural differences reflected on the internet:

             a comparison between Belgian and Dutch e-commerce websites



Abstract

The current research investigates whether cultural differences between Belgium and the

Netherlands are actually reflected in their respective commercial websites. With this purpose

e-commerce websites from both countries have been subjected to an elaborate content

analysis. Results indicate that Belgian transaction-oriented websites reflect a higher degree of

‘Power Distance’ (i.e. appreciation for social inequality and hierarchy) in comparison to their

Dutch counterparts. This is manifested in the exceeding amount of information they provide

with regard to company hierarchy, the more frequent depiction of CEO’s and the more

frequent use of proper titles. In comparison with Dutch websites, Belgian websites also appear

to be more ‘Masculine’ (i.e. appreciation of more masculine values, such as the need for

achievement and competition). This is reflected in the fact that they use superlatives more

regularly, distinguish more often between the sexes and use explicit comparisons more often.

Contrary to expectations, Belgian web shops do not seem to reflect a higher degree of

‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ (i.e. the degree to which individuals tend to avoid risks) in

comparison with their Dutch counterparts. Finally, as expected, no difference could be

revealed in the degree of ‘Collectivism’ (i.e. importance attached to group ties) reflected in

Belgian and Dutch websites.



Keywords

Internet communications, cultural differences, e-commerce, website design & localization
1 – Introduction


The growth of the internet as an international communication medium raises the question

whether to standardize or to adapt international marketing communications via the World

Wide Web. On the one hand, the internet is a mass-communication medium with worldwide

accessibility, which may speak in favor of standardization. On the other hand, it is a very

interactive medium, providing the opportunity to gather information on internet user

segments, and making it practically possible to implement a high degree of audience

adaptation.


The current study investigates whether cultural differences between Belgium and the

Netherlands are actually reflected in their respective commercial websites.



2 – Culture and cultural sensitivity of websites


According to a socio-scientific approach, culture can be conceived as a mental predisposition

in attitudes and behaviour, acquired and preserved by education and social relations. It is a

collective phenomenon, with at its core a number of positive and negative values, which can,

according to research by Hofstede (1980, 2001) and Trompenaers (1994), be summarized in 5

to 7 cultural dimensions.


Having studied the convergence and divergence of consumer behaviour across countries for a

long time, Marieke de Mooij (1998, 2000, 2004) argues that cultural differences are becoming

even more pronounced with growing welfare and emphasizes that they should be taken into

account to ensure the efficiency of global marketing strategies.


Some recent academic research investigated more specifically the cultural sensitivity of

websites and the need for localization or standardization.
On the one hand, some researchers are convinced that cultural factors have no influence on

website perceptions and recommend standardization (Hermans and Shanahan, 2002;

Sackmary and Scalia, 1999; Yang and Kang, 2002). Based on content analysis of non-

commercial websites, De Troyer et al. (2006) even assume that the internet has promoted “the

emergence of a cosmopolitan online culture, a hybrid culture overriding traditional cultural

differences”.


On the other hand, do studies by Fink and Laupase (2000), Luna et al. (2002), Fock (2000),

Simon (2001), Kanso and Nelson (2002), Singh and Baack (2004) and Singh et al. (2004)

demonstrate that the internet is not a culturally neutral medium. They confirm that there are

intercultural differences in perception of website content and stress that values, image, themes

and symbols should be adapted to local cultures.


While the internet fosters globalization, the necessity of localized websites seems to have

become more and more obvious (Plumley, 2000; Boston Consulting Group, 2000; Fletcher et

al., 2004). According to Forrester Research, the more a website is transaction-oriented, the

more it should be localized (Torris, 1998). Therefore, especially ‘e-retailers’, eager to enter

foreign markets, should focus on the local customers. A locally adapted language, content and

interface design may be needed to attract the attention of the local user and to win his

confidence. According to Forrester Research localized websites can draw more attention and

lead to more ‘stickyness’ and sales. Therefore they recommend profoundly localized websites

(Fletcher et al., 2004).
3 – Cultural differences between Belgium and the Netherlands


Local (Dutch and Belgian) companies assume that Belgium and the Netherlands (as

neighbours with a common language) are the ideal countries to make their first steps towards

international expansion. Often however in this case cultural differences tend to be ignored

(Kotler et al., 2006). In their studies investigating cross-national cultural differences, Hofstede

(1980, 2001) and Trompenaers (1994) have, nevertheless, discovered large differences in

value-orientations between Belgium and the Netherlands (see table 1).


     “In fact, no two countries (…) with a common border and a common language are so

                   culturally apart (…) as (Dutch) Belgium and the Netherlands”

                                        Geert Hofstede, 1980, p228




                                                       The
                                                    Netherlands   Belgium                         France
                                                                            Flanders   Wallonia
Power Distance
Appreciation of social inequality and hierarchy         38           65       61          67        68

Masculinity
The extent to which masculine values as
assertiveness, competition, urge for achievement
and success prevail in comparison to more               14           54       43          60        43
feminine values such as life quality, nurturing,
helpfulness and solidarity

Uncertainty Avoidance
The degree to which individuals tend to avoid
ambiguous situations and to take risks when             53           94       97          93        86
making decisions

Individualism
The degree to which ties between members of a
community are rather loose (i.e. individualistic)       80           75       78          72        71
or tight (i.e. collectivistic)



      Table 1: Scores for The Netherlands, Belgium (Flanders & Wallonia) and France
                    with respect to Hofstede’s four cultural dimensions (Hofstede, 1980, 2001)
Belgium scores, for instance, much higher than the Netherlands on the dimension ‘Power

Distance’, concerning the relative appreciation of social inequality and hierarchy (B=65

versus Nl=38). Belgium also appears to score considerably higher on the dimension

‘Masculinity’, which reflects the urge for achievement, competition and assertive and

aggressive behaviour, in comparison with the appreciation for modest and obliging behaviour

and solidarity (B=54 versus Nl=14). Finally, Belgium also seems to score significantly higher

on the dimension ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’, which is reflected in a higher number of rules,

formal procedures and rituals (B=94 versus Nl=53).


As a matter of fact, Hofstede (1980, p228) even claims that there are no two neighbouring

countries with the same language that are so culturally different as (Dutch) Belgium and the

Netherlands. With regard to the Belgian sub-regions of (Dutch-speaking) Flanders and

(French-speaking) Wallonia, Hofstede (1980) argues that there are almost no cultural

differences between them and that their cultures resemble in fact the French culture.


Thus, although Belgium and the Netherlands share the same language, they obviously don’t

share the same culture. The remarkable cultural differences between Flanders and the

Netherlands have been confirmed in more recent studies (Claes and Gerritsen, 2006; see table

2 for an overview).


Findings with regard to the cultural differences between Belgium and the Netherlands are also

supported by several other researchers (Schwartz and Ross, 1995; Inglehart, 1997;

Matthyssens and Wursten, 2003).
Hofstede    Hofstede        Orriëns       Claes & Gerritsen   Gerritsen
                          (1980)      (2001)         (1998)              (2004)          (2001)
                           IBM       Managers     Banking-sector        Students       ICT-sector
                         ’60 -‘70      1990           1998                1998            2001
Power Distance
                           +23          +16            +25                 +18            +20
Masculinity
                           +29          +21            +13                 +18            +12
Uncertainty Avoidance
                           +44          +53            +47                 +47            +43
Individualism
                            -2           -4            -26                 -4           no data


       Table 2: Differences between Flanders and the Netherlands with respect to Hofstede’s
                 four cultural dimensions as reported in several more recent studies
                 (based on Gerritsen, 2001 and Claes & Gerritsen, 2004).




These cultural dimensions seem, amongst others, to have an impact on internet adoption and

use. Park (2000), for instance, found strong support for the hypothesis that internet-use is

higher in ‘feminine’ cultures than in ‘masculine’ cultures. Comparing the internet penetration

between Belgium and the Netherlands, our findings reveal that indeed already 65,9% of the

‘more Feminine’ Dutch population uses the internet, in comparison with only 48,7% of the

‘more Masculine’ Belgian population, which has an internet penetration rate which lies close

to the European average of 49,8% (Internet World Stats, 2006).
4 – Research

4.1 – Research question and hypotheses



         Are cultural differences in mentality between Belgium and the Netherlands

                      reflected in their respective commercial websites?



The current study investigates whether the cultural differences in mentality between Belgium

and the Netherlands are being reflected in their respective commercial websites or not. The

aim is thus to reveal whether the websites of online retailers of these respective neighbouring

countries, also reflect the specific cultural values characteristic of these countries.



Based on the review of the literature, we formulate more specifically the following

hypotheses:


    H1 – We propose that Belgian commercial websites will reflect a higher level of

               ‘Power Distance’ in comparison to their Dutch counterparts.


    H2 – We assume that Belgian online retailers in comparison to Dutch ones will

               display a higher level of ‘Masculinity’.


    H3 – We expect Belgian commercial websites to reflect a higher level of ‘Uncertainty

               Avoidance’ in comparison to their Dutch counterparts.


    H4 – We do not expect a significant difference in the level of ‘Collectivism’ reflected

               in Dutch or Belgian transaction-oriented websites, because both countries have

               a rather ‘individualistic’ orientation, in contrast to Eastern countries, for

               example, where more importance is attached to strong group and family ties.
4.2 – Method


To verify these hypotheses, an elaborate content analysis of commercial websites from both

countries was performed (cf. Singh and Baack, 2004). For this purpose, coding schemes

provided by Singh and Matuso (2002) have been used. These schemes make it possible to

register in a quantitative way to what degree Hofstede’s cultural dimensions are being

displayed in the website.


To assess, for example, the level of ‘Masculinity’ reflected in the website, we verified

whether the site contains quizzes or games, whether ‘hard’ sales techniques are being used

(e.g. discounts, coupons,…), whether explicit comparisons are being made, whether the

‘effectiveness’ is emphasized of the products offered for sale, etc… (see tables 4-7).


In the present study, 40 Dutch and 40 Belgian commercial websites have been analysed in a

systematic way. For the Belgian websites, 20 Flemish and 20 Walloon sites were selected.

We focused more specifically on five sectors, namely online sellers of clothing, books, music,

computers and travel. For each of these sectors, 8 websites per country have been analysed

(for Belgium evenly divided between Flemish and Walloon sites). Thus, we tried to overcome

a shortcoming of the study by Singh and Baack (2004), who compared US and Mexican

websites of U.S. Fortune 500 companies, without taking into account the specific sectors

represented in both samples. In the current study the online retailers were identified through

search engines (like Google, Alta Vista and Yahoo).
4.3 - Results


All online retailers studied, are assigned 4 summated scores that indicate to what extent their

website     reflects       Hofstede’s          cultural                   dimensions          (respectively        ‘Power       Distance’,

‘Masculinity’, ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ and ‘Individualism’).


Subsequently, we can calculate per country to what extent these cultural dimensions are

reflected in the respective websites of that country. That way, we can evaluate the differences

between the countries in the degree to which their websites reflect the respective cultural

dimensions.

                                         The Netherlands                  Belgium       Flanders       Wallonia

                       5
                       4
                       3
                       2
                       1
                       0
                                     e                              ity                  e                     m
                                 anc                       l   in                      nc                   vis
                             ist                        cu                         oida                  cti
                           rD                      as                            Av                   lle
                       e                       M                               y                    Co
                   Pow                                                      int
                                                                         rta
                                                                       ce
                                                                     Un


   Figure 1: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimensions reflected in Dutch and
                 Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004)


                                               The
                                                                          Belgium                                                   t-test
                                            Netherlands                                 Flanders      Wallonia        t-test
Power Distance (7 items)
                                               1.50                         2.40             1.90        2.90          n.s.        p = .036
Masculinity (7 items)
                                               2.80                         3.53             2.90        4.15        p = .009      p = .014
Uncertainty Avoidance (9 items)
                                               3.35                         3.73             3.10        4.35        p = .002        n.s.
Collectivism (8 items)
                                               2.13                         2.53             2.10        2.95        p = .050        n.s.


  Table 3: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimensions reflected in Dutch and
                Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004)
4.3.1 – Power Distance


We assumed that Belgian websites would reflect a higher level of ‘Power Distance’ in

comparison to their Dutch counterparts. Our findings (illustrated in figure 1) seem to confirm

this hypothesis. The summated score over all websites on the 7 items reflecting ‘Power

Distance’ (see table 3) amounts to 2.40 for Belgium in comparison with 1.50 for the

Netherlands, a significant difference according to the t-test (p=.036).



                                      The        Belgium                                    χ 2-test
                                                                                   2
                                   Netherlands             Flanders   Wallonia   χ -test

Power Distance                        (%)          (%)       (%)        (%)

Company Hierarchy Information          7.5        32.5       25           40       n.s.     p = .005
Pictures of CEO’s                      2.5         20        25           15       n.s.     p = .014
Quality Information and Awards         20         27.5       25           30       n.s.       n.s.
Vision Statement                       25          40        20           60     p = .011     n.s.
Rank or Prestige of the Company       22.5         30         5           55     p = .001     n.s.
Pride of Ownership appeal              65         47.5       45           50       n.s.       n.s.
Proper Titles                          7.5        42.5       45           40       n.s.     p < .000



     Table 4: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimension “Power Distance”,
                   reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites
                   (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004)



When we take a look at the individual items (see table 4), we notice that significantly more

Belgian than Dutch online retailers give information about their company hierarchy

(respectively 32,5% versus 7,5%; χ2-test, p=.005). Moreover, whereas in 20% of the Belgian

websites CEO’s are depicted, this appears to be the case in only 2,5% of the Dutch websites

(χ2-test, p=.014). Finally, in considerably more Belgian than Dutch websites appropriate

personal titles are being used (42,5% versus 7,5%; χ2-test, p<.000). These findings
demonstrate clearly that a higher level of ‘Power Distance’ is reflected in the Belgian

commercial websites, compared to their Dutch counterparts.


Whereas, within Belgium, the level of ‘Power Distance’ reflected in Flemish commercial

websites seems to be considerably lower than the level reflected in Walloon sites, this

difference between both sub-regions appears in general not to be significant (see table 3).

From the results, conveyed in table 4, we can, however, clearly establish that in more Walloon

than Flemish websites, a company vision statement is provided (respectively 60% compared

to 20%; χ2-test, p=.011) and that in more Walloon than Flemish websites the ranking and

prestige of the company is emphasized (55% versus 5%; χ2-test, p=.001), thus unexpectedly

revealing some higher level of ‘Power Distance’ reflected in Walloon websites.



4.3.2 – Masculinity


We assumed that Belgian commercial websites would be more likely to reflect ‘Masculinity’,

while Dutch sites would appear more ‘Feminine’. Our findings (illustrated in figure 1) seem

to support this hypothesis. The summated score over all websites on the 7 items indicative for

‘Masculinity’ (see table 3), amounts to 3,53 for Belgium, compared to 2,80 for the

Netherlands. A t-test reveals that this difference is in fact significant (p=.014).


When we examine the individual items more carefully (see table 5), we can establish that

significantly more Belgian than Dutch online retailers are using superlatives in their websites

(respectively 65% versus 35%; χ2-test: p=.007). More Belgian websites, in comparison with

Dutch ones, distinguish clearly between the sexes (42,5% versus 20%; χ2-test, p=.026).

Furthermore, it becomes apparent that only Belgian online retailers are using explicit

comparisons in their websites (12,5% versus 0%; χ2-test, p=.027). These results illustrate

clearly that Belgian websites reflect a higher level of ‘Masculinity’ than their Dutch
counterparts. When we examine the individual items that reflect ‘Masculinity’, however, we

notice one exception. More Dutch sites appear to emphasize the effectiveness of their

products than Belgian sites (respectively 85% versus 65%; χ2-test, p=.035).



                                       The        Belgium                                    χ 2-test
                                                                                    2
                                    Netherlands             Flanders   Wallonia   χ -test

Masculinity                            (%)           (%)       (%)       (%)

Quizzes and games                       10           22.5       20       25         n.s.       n.s.
Hard Sell Approach                     57.5          72.5       65       80         n.s.       n.s.
Explicit Comparisons                    0            12.5       0        25       p = .024   p = .027
Realism Theme                          72.5          72.5       75       70         n.s.       n.s.
Product Effectiveness                   85           65         65       65         n.s.     p = .035
Use of Superlatives                     35           65         40       90       p = .001   p = .007
Clear Gender Roles                      20           42.5       25       60       p = .027   p = .026



      Table 5: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimension “Masculinity”,
                        reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites
                        (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004)



When we take a look at the differences within Belgium between Flemish and Walloon sites,

we notice that the earlier reported distinction in reflected ‘Masculinity’ between Belgian and

Dutch websites is almost solely a reflection of the higher level of ‘Masculinity’ displayed in

Walloon sites. In comparison to Flemish e-commerce sites, Walloon e-retailers use

superlatives considerably more often in their websites (90% versus 40%; χ2-test, p=.001).

They also seem to make explicit comparisons more often (25% versus 0%; χ2-test, p=.024)

and they make more often clear distinctions between the sexes (60% versus 25%; χ2-test,

p=.027). Table 3 shows clearly that the summated score, over all the websites of the 7 items

that reflect ‘Masculinity’, amounts to 2,90 for Flanders and differs in this respect hardly from

the Dutch summated score of 2,80. Wallony, on the other hand, attains a significantly higher

score on reflected ‘Masculinity’, namely 4,15 (t-test, p=.009).
4.3.3 – Uncertainty Avoidance


We hypothesized that Belgian transaction-oriented websites would reflect a higher level of

‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ than their Dutch counterparts. Our findings (illustrated in figure 1),

however, do not seem to support this hypothesis. The summated score over all the sites of the

9 items that reflect ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ does not prove to be significantly different

between Belgium and the Netherlands (see table 3). Within Belgium, however, there appears

to be a considerable difference between Flemish and Walloon sites. Walloon sites seem to

reflect significantly more ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ than Flemish ones (respective scores of

4,35 and 3,10; t-test, p=.002).



                                     The         Belgium                                    χ 2-test
                                  Netherlands              Flanders   Wallonia    χ2-test

Uncertainty Avoidance                (%)           (%)        (%)       (%)

Customer Service                      90           95          95       95         n.s.       n.s.
Secure Payment                        70           70          50       90       p = .007     n.s.
Guided Navigation                    82.5         87.5         75       100      p = .024     n.s.
Tradition Theme                       20           25          20       30         n.s.       n.s.
Local Stores                         52.5         57.5         50       65         n.s.       n.s.
Local Terminology                     2.5          5           0        10         n.s.       n.s.
Free Trials and Downloads             2.5         27.5         15       40         n.s.     p = .002
Customer Testimonials                12.5          5           5         5         n.s.       n.s.
Toll Free Numbers                     2.5          0           0         0         n.s.       n.s.



      Table 6: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimension “Uncertainty Avoidance”,
                    reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites
                    (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004)




When we take a look at the individual items (see table 6), we notice that more Belgian sites

offer free downloads and trials than Dutch ones (27,5% versus 2,5%; χ2-test, p=.002). Within

Belgium, especially Walloon sites seem to offer this possibility (40% compared to 15%
Flemish sites), however this difference appears not to be significant. Still, more Walloon than

Flemish online retailers appear to emphasize the security of payments on their sites (90%

versus 50%; χ2-test, p=.007) and the possibility of guided navigation (100% versus 75%; χ2-

test, p=.024), confirming the higher level of reflected ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’.




4.3.4 – Collectivism


We assumed that there would be no significant difference in the level of ‘Collectivism’

reflected in Belgian and Dutch e-commerce websites. Our findings (illustrated in figure 1)

seem to support this hypothesis. The summated score over all websites of the 8 items that

reflect ‘Collectivism’ does not appear to be significantly different between Belgium and the

Netherlands (see table 3). When we consult the individual items (see table 7), we do notice

however that more Belgian sites appear to offer loyalty programs than Dutch sites (40%

versus 20%; χ2-test, p=.043).


                                      The         Belgium                                      χ 2-test
                                                                                    2
                                   Netherlands              Flanders   Wallonia    χ -test

Collectivism                           (%)          (%)       (%)        (%)

Community Relations                    7.5          2.5         0         5         n.s.        n.s.
Clubs or Chat room                     15          27.5        30        25         n.s.        n.s.
Newsletter                            57.5         57.5        60        55         n.s.        n.s.
Family Theme                          27.5          45         25        65       p = 0.012     n.s.
Country Specific Information          22.5         12.5        10        15         n.s.        n.s.
Symbols & Pictures of Nation           10          17.5         5        30       p = .046      n.s.
Loyalty Programs                       20           40         45        35         n.s.      p = 0.043
Links to Local Web sites              52.5          50         35        65         n.s.        n.s.



      Table 7: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimension “Collectivism”,
                     reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites
                     (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004)
Within Belgium, we notice that Walloon sites seem to reflect more ‘Collectivism’ than

Flemish ones (respective scores of 2,95 versus 2,10; t-test, p=.050). More Walloon than

Flemish commercial websites appear to make use of family themes (65% versus 25%; χ2-test,

p=.012), and symbols and images of national identity (30% versus 5%; χ2-test, p=.046),

pointing to a higher level of ‘Collectivism’ reflected.



5 – Conclusion


According to the literature, there are major cultural differences between Belgium and the

Netherlands, which should be taken into consideration with respect to marketing

communications (e.g. FEM, 1998; Gerritsen, 2002; Claes & Gerritsen, 2006). The current

study demonstrates that these cultural differences in mentality between Belgium and the

Netherlands are also reflected in their respective commercial websites.


The websites of Belgian online retailers seem, as could be expected, to reflect a higher level

of ‘Power Distance’ in comparison to their Dutch counterparts. This is manifested by the

exceeding frequency to which they provide information with regard to company hierarchy, the

more frequent depiction of CEO’s and the more frequent use of proper titles of address.

Although the level of reflected ‘Power Distance’ does not seem to differ significantly between

Flemish and Walloon sites, more Walloon than Flemish sites appear to provide a company

vision statement and emphasize the ranking and prestige of the company, revealing

unexpectedly some higher level of ‘Power Distance’ reflected in Walloon commercial

websites.


As expected, Belgian e-commerce websites also appear to be more ‘Masculine’ than their

Dutch counterparts, which is reflected in the fact that they use superlatives more regularly,

that they distinguish more often between the sexes and that they use explicit comparisons
more often. Walloon sites, however, seem to be almost exclusively responsible for these

detected differences, as they do also significantly differ from Flemish sites in this regard. On

the other hand, Dutch websites do appear to emphasize the effectiveness of their products

more often than Belgian sites, possibly indicating that the Netherlands are getting more

‘Masculine’ (cfr. Gerritsen, 2001).


Contrary to our expectations, Belgian web shops do not seem to reflect a higher degree of

‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ in comparison to their Dutch counterparts. We notice, nevertheless,

that more Belgian sites offer free downloads and trials than Dutch ones. This is especially

apparent for Walloon sites, which seem to reflect a higher degree of ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’

than the Flemish ones, which is also manifested in the fact that they emphasize the security of

payments on their sites and the possibility of guided navigation more often.


Although, as expected, no difference in ‘Collectivism’ between Belgian and Dutch e-

commerce sites could be revealed, we do notice that more Belgian sites offer loyalty programs

than Dutch ones. Within Belgium, Walloon sites appear to reflect more ‘Collectivism’ than

Flemish websites, which is apparent from the fact that they seem to make more use of family

themes and symbols and images of national identity.



6– Discussion


The present study did not investigate the effectiveness of locally adapted commercial

websites. In a subsequent phase of this research project, an experimental study will be carried

out to investigate this crucial question. At this point, however, we did establish that there are

important cultural differences between Belgium and the Netherlands, but also between

Flanders and Wallonia, which appear to be reflected in their respective e-commerce websites.
If online retailers wish to exploit the possibilities of the internet to attract consumers on the

other side of the border, they may want to take this into consideration.



References

Boston Consulting Group, 2000. The Race for online Riches: e-retailing in Europe, February,
         http://www.dad.be/library/pdf/BCG1.pdf

Claes M-T. & Gerritsen M., 2004. “Nederland en Nederlandstalig België: buren met
         verschillende culturen” (The Netherlands and Dutch speaking Belgium: Neighbours
         with Different Cultures) in Claes & Gerritsen: “Culturele waarden en communicatie in
         internationaal perspectief”(Cultural Values and Communication from an International
         Perspective), Bussum: Uitgeverij Coutinho, chapter 4.

Claes M-T. & Gerritsen M., 2006. “Waarom Vlamingen van Venus komen en Nederlanders van
         Mars” (Why the Flemish come from Venus and the Dutch from Mars), Uitgeverij
         Meulenhoff (in press).

de Mooij M., 1998. “Global marketing and advertising”, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage.

de Mooij M., 2000. The future is predictable for international marketers. International
         Marketing Review, 17 (2), 103-113.

de Mooij M., 2004. "Consumer Behavior and Culture. Consequences for Global Marketing and
         Advertising ", Sage Publications, Inc. USA and UK. (360 p).

De Troyer O., Mushtaha A.N., Stengers H., Baetens M., Boers F., Casteleyn S. & Plessers P.,
         2006. “On Cultural Differences in Local Web Interfaces”, Journal of Web
         Engineering, Vol. 5., No.3., p246-264.

Financiëel Economisch Magazine FEM, 1998. “Cultuurclash tussen Nederland en België”
         (Culture Clash between the Netherlands and Belgium), July 11th.

Fink D. & Laupase R., 2000. “Perceptions of Web Site Design Characteristics”: A
         Malaysian/Australian Comparison”, Internet Research, 10, 1, p44-55.

Fletcher R., Bell J. and R. McNaughton, 2004. International e-Business Marketing, Thomson
         Learning, London.
Fock, H., 2000. Cultural influences on marketing communication on the World Wide Web.
        Paper presented at the Multicultural Marketing Conference, Hong Kong, September.

Gerritsen M., 2001. Cultuur als spelbreker. De communicatieve gevolgen van cultuurverschillen
        tussen Vlaanderen en Nederland (Culture as a Spoilsport. The Communicative
        Consequences of Cultural Differences Between Flanders and the Netherlands),
        publication of Speech at the Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen, Friday September 28th
        2001, Nijmegen.

Gerritsen M., 2002. Cultuur als spelbreker. De communicatieve gevolgen van cultuurverschillen
        tussen Vlaanderen en Nederland. (Culture as a Spoilsport. The Communicative
        Consequences of Cultural Differences Between Flanders and the Netherlands)
        Tijdschrift voor Taalbeheersing (Journal of Applied Linguistics), 24 (1), 50-62.

Hermans M. Ch. & K.J. Shanahan, 2002. “The Reification of Levitt: Advertising preferences
        for Mexican and American online consumers”, Developments in Marketing Science,
        25, p147.

Hofstede G., 1980. “Culture’s consequences. International differences in work related values”,
        Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.

Hofstede G., 2001. "Culture's consequences. Comparing values, behaviours, institutions and
        organizations across nations", 2nd edition, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage.

Internet World Stats, 2006. “Internet Usage in European Union”, Miniwatts Marketing Group,
        available at http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats9.htm.

Inglehart R., 1997. “Modernization and Postmodernization. Cultural, economic and political
        change in 43 societies”, Princeton University Press, Princeton.

Kanso A. & R. Nelson, 2002. “Advertising localization overshadows standardization”, Journal
        of Advertising Research, Jan/Feb, p79-89.

Kotler P., Armstrong G., Saunders J., Wong V., Broere F., 2006. “België en Nederland, dat is
        toch zo’n beetje hetzelfde?” (Belgium and the Netherlands, they appear to be very
        similar, don’t they?), in Principes van Marketing, (Dutch adaptation of Principles of
        Marketing), 4th edition, Pearson Education Benelux, Amsterdam, p189-190.

Luna, D., Peracchio, L. A., & de Juan, M. D., 2002. Cross-cultural and cognitive aspects of
        Web site navigation. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 30 (4), 397-410.
Matthyssens P. & Wursten H., 2003. “Internal Marketing”, in "Cross-cultural Marketing",
        Rugimbana R., Nwankwo S. eds., Thomson Learning, p243-256.

Orriëns D., 1998. “Nederland en Vlaanderen: een wereld van verschil! Een onderzoek naar de
        culturele verschuivingen tussen Nederland en Vlaanderen tussen het einde van de jaren
        ’60 en 1998” (The Netherlands and Flanders, Worlds Apart! Research with regard to
        the Cultural Shifts between the Netherlands and Flanders between the end of the
        Sixties and 1998), Master’s thesis International Business Communication, Katholieke
        Universiteit Nijmegen.

Park H., 2000. “A cross-cultural analysis of internet connectivity”, Journal of Current Research
        in Global Business, fall, p 97-107.

Plumley D.J., 2000. “Global eCommerce: The market, challenges and opportunities”, Bowne
        Global Solutions, January.

Sackmary B. & L. Scalia, 1999. “Cultural patterns of World Wide Web business sites: a
        comparison of Mexican and US companies”, paper presented at the Seventh Cross-
        Cultural Consumer and Business Studies Research Conference, Cancun, Mexico.

Schwartz S.H. & Ros M., 1995. “Values in the West: A theoretical and empirical challenge to
        the Individualism-Collectivism cultural dimension”, World Psychology, 1, 91-122.

Simon, S. J., 2001. The impact of culture and gender on Web sites: An empirical study.
        Database for Advances in Information Systems, 32(1), 18-37.

Singh N., 2002 “Analysing Cultural Sensitivity of Websites. A Normative Framework.”,
        Journal         of       Practical        Global         Business,                April,
        http://www.expandglobal.com/journal/Jour_2/journalv1_p32.pdf

Singh N. and Hisako Matsuo, 2002. “A Framework to Measure Cultural Values on the Web.”
        E-Business Review, Vol. 2, March.

Singh N. & D. W. Baack, 2004. “Website adaptation: a cross-cultural comparison of US and
        Mexican websites”, Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 9 (4), July.

Singh, N., Furrerr O., Ostinelli M., 2004. “To Localize or to Standardize on the Web:
        Empirical Evidence from Italy, India, Netherlands, Spain, and Switzerland.”
        Multinational Business Review

Torris Th., 1998. “JIT Web Localization”, Forrester Research, July.
Trompenaers F., 1994. “Riding the waves of culture. Understanding diversity in global
        business”, New York: Professional Publishing.

Yang C.C.K. & Y. Kang, 2002. “The influence of cultural factors on consumers’ reaction to
        Internet advertisements”, Developments in Marketing Science, Sanibel Island, 25,
        p148-151.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Tim Rotsaert - mediatuin
Tim Rotsaert - mediatuinTim Rotsaert - mediatuin
Tim Rotsaert - mediatuinimec.archive
 
Dirk Beernaert - a European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive Growth
Dirk Beernaert - a European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive GrowthDirk Beernaert - a European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive Growth
Dirk Beernaert - a European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive Growthimec.archive
 
Conversion Conference: Conversion on Mobile Devices
Conversion Conference: Conversion on Mobile DevicesConversion Conference: Conversion on Mobile Devices
Conversion Conference: Conversion on Mobile DevicesSeth Berman
 
2008 Brokerage 02 Test Beds And Living Labs [Compatibility Mode]
2008 Brokerage 02 Test Beds And Living Labs [Compatibility Mode]2008 Brokerage 02 Test Beds And Living Labs [Compatibility Mode]
2008 Brokerage 02 Test Beds And Living Labs [Compatibility Mode]imec.archive
 
I Minds2009 Kpi Ware
I Minds2009 Kpi WareI Minds2009 Kpi Ware
I Minds2009 Kpi Wareimec.archive
 
Brokerage2006 grid computing in de industrie ervaringen uit media productie
Brokerage2006 grid computing in de industrie  ervaringen uit media productieBrokerage2006 grid computing in de industrie  ervaringen uit media productie
Brokerage2006 grid computing in de industrie ervaringen uit media productieimec.archive
 
2008 brokerage 06 multimodal logistics [compatibility mode]
2008 brokerage 06 multimodal logistics [compatibility mode]2008 brokerage 06 multimodal logistics [compatibility mode]
2008 brokerage 06 multimodal logistics [compatibility mode]imec.archive
 
Friday Food 12-07 'Secundary use of persoanl data'
Friday Food 12-07 'Secundary use of persoanl data'Friday Food 12-07 'Secundary use of persoanl data'
Friday Food 12-07 'Secundary use of persoanl data'imec.archive
 
I Minds2009 Michela Pollone Csp–Innovazione Nelle Ict Innovative Paths To I...
I Minds2009 Michela Pollone   Csp–Innovazione Nelle Ict Innovative Paths To I...I Minds2009 Michela Pollone   Csp–Innovazione Nelle Ict Innovative Paths To I...
I Minds2009 Michela Pollone Csp–Innovazione Nelle Ict Innovative Paths To I...imec.archive
 
07 Seniorenmobiliteit Ondersteunen Met In Door Locatiebepaling
07  Seniorenmobiliteit Ondersteunen Met In Door Locatiebepaling07  Seniorenmobiliteit Ondersteunen Met In Door Locatiebepaling
07 Seniorenmobiliteit Ondersteunen Met In Door Locatiebepalingimec.archive
 
The Humanicité workshops
The Humanicité workshopsThe Humanicité workshops
The Humanicité workshopsimec.archive
 
Break out: Project Communication and Dissemination - Karen Boers
Break out: Project Communication and Dissemination - Karen BoersBreak out: Project Communication and Dissemination - Karen Boers
Break out: Project Communication and Dissemination - Karen Boersimec.archive
 
Jan Coppens - Acceleration & Internationalization
Jan Coppens - Acceleration & InternationalizationJan Coppens - Acceleration & Internationalization
Jan Coppens - Acceleration & Internationalizationimec.archive
 
Benoit latré isbo ng wi nets - avoiding interference
Benoit latré   isbo ng wi nets - avoiding interferenceBenoit latré   isbo ng wi nets - avoiding interference
Benoit latré isbo ng wi nets - avoiding interferenceimec.archive
 
Erfgoed2 0 5 Het Tweede Leven Van Erfgoed Marco De Niet
Erfgoed2 0 5 Het Tweede Leven Van Erfgoed   Marco De NietErfgoed2 0 5 Het Tweede Leven Van Erfgoed   Marco De Niet
Erfgoed2 0 5 Het Tweede Leven Van Erfgoed Marco De Nietimec.archive
 
PRoF+ Patient Room of the Future
PRoF+ Patient Room of the FuturePRoF+ Patient Room of the Future
PRoF+ Patient Room of the Futureimec.archive
 

Viewers also liked (18)

Tim Rotsaert - mediatuin
Tim Rotsaert - mediatuinTim Rotsaert - mediatuin
Tim Rotsaert - mediatuin
 
Dirk Beernaert - a European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive Growth
Dirk Beernaert - a European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive GrowthDirk Beernaert - a European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive Growth
Dirk Beernaert - a European Strategy for Smart, Sustainable and Inclusive Growth
 
Direct Eye
Direct EyeDirect Eye
Direct Eye
 
Conversion Conference: Conversion on Mobile Devices
Conversion Conference: Conversion on Mobile DevicesConversion Conference: Conversion on Mobile Devices
Conversion Conference: Conversion on Mobile Devices
 
2008 Brokerage 02 Test Beds And Living Labs [Compatibility Mode]
2008 Brokerage 02 Test Beds And Living Labs [Compatibility Mode]2008 Brokerage 02 Test Beds And Living Labs [Compatibility Mode]
2008 Brokerage 02 Test Beds And Living Labs [Compatibility Mode]
 
I Minds2009 Kpi Ware
I Minds2009 Kpi WareI Minds2009 Kpi Ware
I Minds2009 Kpi Ware
 
Brokerage2006 grid computing in de industrie ervaringen uit media productie
Brokerage2006 grid computing in de industrie  ervaringen uit media productieBrokerage2006 grid computing in de industrie  ervaringen uit media productie
Brokerage2006 grid computing in de industrie ervaringen uit media productie
 
2008 brokerage 06 multimodal logistics [compatibility mode]
2008 brokerage 06 multimodal logistics [compatibility mode]2008 brokerage 06 multimodal logistics [compatibility mode]
2008 brokerage 06 multimodal logistics [compatibility mode]
 
Friday Food 12-07 'Secundary use of persoanl data'
Friday Food 12-07 'Secundary use of persoanl data'Friday Food 12-07 'Secundary use of persoanl data'
Friday Food 12-07 'Secundary use of persoanl data'
 
I Minds2009 Michela Pollone Csp–Innovazione Nelle Ict Innovative Paths To I...
I Minds2009 Michela Pollone   Csp–Innovazione Nelle Ict Innovative Paths To I...I Minds2009 Michela Pollone   Csp–Innovazione Nelle Ict Innovative Paths To I...
I Minds2009 Michela Pollone Csp–Innovazione Nelle Ict Innovative Paths To I...
 
07 Seniorenmobiliteit Ondersteunen Met In Door Locatiebepaling
07  Seniorenmobiliteit Ondersteunen Met In Door Locatiebepaling07  Seniorenmobiliteit Ondersteunen Met In Door Locatiebepaling
07 Seniorenmobiliteit Ondersteunen Met In Door Locatiebepaling
 
The Humanicité workshops
The Humanicité workshopsThe Humanicité workshops
The Humanicité workshops
 
I Lab4 Usecases
I Lab4 UsecasesI Lab4 Usecases
I Lab4 Usecases
 
Break out: Project Communication and Dissemination - Karen Boers
Break out: Project Communication and Dissemination - Karen BoersBreak out: Project Communication and Dissemination - Karen Boers
Break out: Project Communication and Dissemination - Karen Boers
 
Jan Coppens - Acceleration & Internationalization
Jan Coppens - Acceleration & InternationalizationJan Coppens - Acceleration & Internationalization
Jan Coppens - Acceleration & Internationalization
 
Benoit latré isbo ng wi nets - avoiding interference
Benoit latré   isbo ng wi nets - avoiding interferenceBenoit latré   isbo ng wi nets - avoiding interference
Benoit latré isbo ng wi nets - avoiding interference
 
Erfgoed2 0 5 Het Tweede Leven Van Erfgoed Marco De Niet
Erfgoed2 0 5 Het Tweede Leven Van Erfgoed   Marco De NietErfgoed2 0 5 Het Tweede Leven Van Erfgoed   Marco De Niet
Erfgoed2 0 5 Het Tweede Leven Van Erfgoed Marco De Niet
 
PRoF+ Patient Room of the Future
PRoF+ Patient Room of the FuturePRoF+ Patient Room of the Future
PRoF+ Patient Room of the Future
 

Similar to Cultural Differences Reflected Online

071010 cultural differences reflected on the internet brengman malaika ppt
071010 cultural differences reflected on the internet   brengman malaika ppt071010 cultural differences reflected on the internet   brengman malaika ppt
071010 cultural differences reflected on the internet brengman malaika pptguest0f94fe
 
Ecrea3j Brengman Malaika Ppt
Ecrea3j Brengman Malaika PptEcrea3j Brengman Malaika Ppt
Ecrea3j Brengman Malaika Pptimec.archive
 
A Global Perspective on Gifted Education
A Global Perspective on Gifted EducationA Global Perspective on Gifted Education
A Global Perspective on Gifted EducationGiftedkids.ie
 
Fragmented Information Worlds (2014)
Fragmented Information Worlds (2014)Fragmented Information Worlds (2014)
Fragmented Information Worlds (2014)Wolfgang Greller
 
Module 1 examining interface areas
Module 1   examining interface areasModule 1   examining interface areas
Module 1 examining interface areascaniceconsulting
 
Talent Competences In The New E Learning Generation
Talent Competences In The New E Learning GenerationTalent Competences In The New E Learning Generation
Talent Competences In The New E Learning Generationjoao jose saraiva da fonseca
 
Talent competences in the new eLearning generation
Talent competences in the new eLearning generationTalent competences in the new eLearning generation
Talent competences in the new eLearning generationeLearning Papers
 
Who and how am I online
Who and how am I onlineWho and how am I online
Who and how am I onlineJISC SSBR
 
Bob Fryer's Keynote Presentation - EDEN 2012 Annual Conference
Bob Fryer's Keynote Presentation - EDEN 2012 Annual ConferenceBob Fryer's Keynote Presentation - EDEN 2012 Annual Conference
Bob Fryer's Keynote Presentation - EDEN 2012 Annual ConferenceEDEN Digital Learning Europe
 
The impact of global values at an individual level on creativity : evidence f...
The impact of global values at an individual level on creativity : evidence f...The impact of global values at an individual level on creativity : evidence f...
The impact of global values at an individual level on creativity : evidence f...Tarig Bouazzati
 
Bridging The Digital Divide For Latina Girls Analysis (Doc)
Bridging The Digital Divide For Latina Girls    Analysis (Doc)Bridging The Digital Divide For Latina Girls    Analysis (Doc)
Bridging The Digital Divide For Latina Girls Analysis (Doc)Marisa Tapia
 
Italian companies and internationalisation
Italian companies and internationalisationItalian companies and internationalisation
Italian companies and internationalisationHofstede Insights
 
Global Campaign Strategy and Development
Global Campaign Strategy and DevelopmentGlobal Campaign Strategy and Development
Global Campaign Strategy and DevelopmentSimon Hjorth
 
Cross cultural website optimization
Cross cultural website optimizationCross cultural website optimization
Cross cultural website optimizationGuido X Jansen
 
Naime.docx
Naime.docxNaime.docx
Naime.docxJakir26
 
Global Marketing Campaign Strategy and Development
Global Marketing Campaign Strategy and DevelopmentGlobal Marketing Campaign Strategy and Development
Global Marketing Campaign Strategy and DevelopmentSimon Hjorth
 

Similar to Cultural Differences Reflected Online (20)

071010 cultural differences reflected on the internet brengman malaika ppt
071010 cultural differences reflected on the internet   brengman malaika ppt071010 cultural differences reflected on the internet   brengman malaika ppt
071010 cultural differences reflected on the internet brengman malaika ppt
 
Ecrea3j Brengman Malaika Ppt
Ecrea3j Brengman Malaika PptEcrea3j Brengman Malaika Ppt
Ecrea3j Brengman Malaika Ppt
 
A Global Perspective on Gifted Education
A Global Perspective on Gifted EducationA Global Perspective on Gifted Education
A Global Perspective on Gifted Education
 
Fragmented Information Worlds (2014)
Fragmented Information Worlds (2014)Fragmented Information Worlds (2014)
Fragmented Information Worlds (2014)
 
Module 1 examining interface areas
Module 1   examining interface areasModule 1   examining interface areas
Module 1 examining interface areas
 
Talent Competences In The New E Learning Generation
Talent Competences In The New E Learning GenerationTalent Competences In The New E Learning Generation
Talent Competences In The New E Learning Generation
 
Talent competences in the new eLearning generation
Talent competences in the new eLearning generationTalent competences in the new eLearning generation
Talent competences in the new eLearning generation
 
Who and how am I online
Who and how am I onlineWho and how am I online
Who and how am I online
 
Bob Fryer's Keynote Presentation - EDEN 2012 Annual Conference
Bob Fryer's Keynote Presentation - EDEN 2012 Annual ConferenceBob Fryer's Keynote Presentation - EDEN 2012 Annual Conference
Bob Fryer's Keynote Presentation - EDEN 2012 Annual Conference
 
Ponte et al IAMCR 2011
Ponte et al IAMCR 2011Ponte et al IAMCR 2011
Ponte et al IAMCR 2011
 
Enter module 1
Enter  module 1Enter  module 1
Enter module 1
 
The impact of global values at an individual level on creativity : evidence f...
The impact of global values at an individual level on creativity : evidence f...The impact of global values at an individual level on creativity : evidence f...
The impact of global values at an individual level on creativity : evidence f...
 
Bridging The Digital Divide For Latina Girls Analysis (Doc)
Bridging The Digital Divide For Latina Girls    Analysis (Doc)Bridging The Digital Divide For Latina Girls    Analysis (Doc)
Bridging The Digital Divide For Latina Girls Analysis (Doc)
 
Italian companies and internationalisation
Italian companies and internationalisationItalian companies and internationalisation
Italian companies and internationalisation
 
Global Campaign Strategy and Development
Global Campaign Strategy and DevelopmentGlobal Campaign Strategy and Development
Global Campaign Strategy and Development
 
Cross cultural website optimization
Cross cultural website optimizationCross cultural website optimization
Cross cultural website optimization
 
Leonardo Corporate Learning Award
Leonardo Corporate Learning AwardLeonardo Corporate Learning Award
Leonardo Corporate Learning Award
 
Naime.docx
Naime.docxNaime.docx
Naime.docx
 
Global Marketing Campaign Strategy and Development
Global Marketing Campaign Strategy and DevelopmentGlobal Marketing Campaign Strategy and Development
Global Marketing Campaign Strategy and Development
 
Welfare Reform Essay
Welfare Reform EssayWelfare Reform Essay
Welfare Reform Essay
 

More from imec.archive

iMinds-iLab.o, Open Innovation in ICT
iMinds-iLab.o, Open Innovation in ICTiMinds-iLab.o, Open Innovation in ICT
iMinds-iLab.o, Open Innovation in ICTimec.archive
 
Accio presentation closing event
Accio presentation closing eventAccio presentation closing event
Accio presentation closing eventimec.archive
 
A Real-World Experimentation Platform
A Real-World Experimentation PlatformA Real-World Experimentation Platform
A Real-World Experimentation Platformimec.archive
 
ENoLL @ AAL Forum 2012
ENoLL @ AAL Forum 2012ENoLL @ AAL Forum 2012
ENoLL @ AAL Forum 2012imec.archive
 
ENoLL 6th Wave Results Ceremony (Jesse Marsh)
ENoLL 6th Wave Results Ceremony (Jesse Marsh)ENoLL 6th Wave Results Ceremony (Jesse Marsh)
ENoLL 6th Wave Results Ceremony (Jesse Marsh)imec.archive
 
The Connected Smart Cities Network and Living Labs - Towards Horizon 2020 - K...
The Connected Smart Cities Network and Living Labs - Towards Horizon 2020 - K...The Connected Smart Cities Network and Living Labs - Towards Horizon 2020 - K...
The Connected Smart Cities Network and Living Labs - Towards Horizon 2020 - K...imec.archive
 
Apollon-23/05/2012-9u30- Parallell session: Living Labs added value
Apollon-23/05/2012-9u30- Parallell session: Living Labs added value  Apollon-23/05/2012-9u30- Parallell session: Living Labs added value
Apollon-23/05/2012-9u30- Parallell session: Living Labs added value imec.archive
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across bordersApollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across bordersimec.archive
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future InternetApollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internetimec.archive
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future InternetApollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internetimec.archive
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future InternetApollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internetimec.archive
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future InternetApollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internetimec.archive
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across bordersApollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across bordersimec.archive
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation EcosystemsApollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystemsimec.archive
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation EcosystemsApollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystemsimec.archive
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation EcosystemsApollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystemsimec.archive
 
Zorg en technologie_Peter_Degadt
Zorg en technologie_Peter_DegadtZorg en technologie_Peter_Degadt
Zorg en technologie_Peter_Degadtimec.archive
 
Zorg en technologie_IBBT_Brokerage_HS_Peter_Degadt0120416_
Zorg en technologie_IBBT_Brokerage_HS_Peter_Degadt0120416_Zorg en technologie_IBBT_Brokerage_HS_Peter_Degadt0120416_
Zorg en technologie_IBBT_Brokerage_HS_Peter_Degadt0120416_imec.archive
 
Brokerage healthy society_16042012_Birgit_Morlion
Brokerage healthy society_16042012_Birgit_MorlionBrokerage healthy society_16042012_Birgit_Morlion
Brokerage healthy society_16042012_Birgit_Morlionimec.archive
 
Analyse Gent M #11 & Launch Startup Garage
Analyse Gent M #11 & Launch Startup GarageAnalyse Gent M #11 & Launch Startup Garage
Analyse Gent M #11 & Launch Startup Garageimec.archive
 

More from imec.archive (20)

iMinds-iLab.o, Open Innovation in ICT
iMinds-iLab.o, Open Innovation in ICTiMinds-iLab.o, Open Innovation in ICT
iMinds-iLab.o, Open Innovation in ICT
 
Accio presentation closing event
Accio presentation closing eventAccio presentation closing event
Accio presentation closing event
 
A Real-World Experimentation Platform
A Real-World Experimentation PlatformA Real-World Experimentation Platform
A Real-World Experimentation Platform
 
ENoLL @ AAL Forum 2012
ENoLL @ AAL Forum 2012ENoLL @ AAL Forum 2012
ENoLL @ AAL Forum 2012
 
ENoLL 6th Wave Results Ceremony (Jesse Marsh)
ENoLL 6th Wave Results Ceremony (Jesse Marsh)ENoLL 6th Wave Results Ceremony (Jesse Marsh)
ENoLL 6th Wave Results Ceremony (Jesse Marsh)
 
The Connected Smart Cities Network and Living Labs - Towards Horizon 2020 - K...
The Connected Smart Cities Network and Living Labs - Towards Horizon 2020 - K...The Connected Smart Cities Network and Living Labs - Towards Horizon 2020 - K...
The Connected Smart Cities Network and Living Labs - Towards Horizon 2020 - K...
 
Apollon-23/05/2012-9u30- Parallell session: Living Labs added value
Apollon-23/05/2012-9u30- Parallell session: Living Labs added value  Apollon-23/05/2012-9u30- Parallell session: Living Labs added value
Apollon-23/05/2012-9u30- Parallell session: Living Labs added value
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across bordersApollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future InternetApollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future InternetApollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future InternetApollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future InternetApollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 16:00 - Smart Open Cities and the Future Internet
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across bordersApollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 11:30 - Local SME's - Innovating Across borders
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation EcosystemsApollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation EcosystemsApollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
 
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation EcosystemsApollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
Apollon - 22/5/12 - 09:00 - User-driven Open Innovation Ecosystems
 
Zorg en technologie_Peter_Degadt
Zorg en technologie_Peter_DegadtZorg en technologie_Peter_Degadt
Zorg en technologie_Peter_Degadt
 
Zorg en technologie_IBBT_Brokerage_HS_Peter_Degadt0120416_
Zorg en technologie_IBBT_Brokerage_HS_Peter_Degadt0120416_Zorg en technologie_IBBT_Brokerage_HS_Peter_Degadt0120416_
Zorg en technologie_IBBT_Brokerage_HS_Peter_Degadt0120416_
 
Brokerage healthy society_16042012_Birgit_Morlion
Brokerage healthy society_16042012_Birgit_MorlionBrokerage healthy society_16042012_Birgit_Morlion
Brokerage healthy society_16042012_Birgit_Morlion
 
Analyse Gent M #11 & Launch Startup Garage
Analyse Gent M #11 & Launch Startup GarageAnalyse Gent M #11 & Launch Startup Garage
Analyse Gent M #11 & Launch Startup Garage
 

Cultural Differences Reflected Online

  • 1. Cultural differences reflected on the internet: a comparison between Belgian and Dutch e-commerce websites Malaika Brengman Malaika Brengman Department of Business Economics and Strategic Management Faculty of Economic, Social and Political Sciences, and Solvay Business School Vrije Universiteit Brussel Pleinlaan 2 1050 Brussel Tel: +32 (0)2 629 20 65 Fax: +32 (0)2 629 20 60 E-mail: malaika.brengman@vub.ac.be
  • 2. Cultural differences reflected on the internet: a comparison between Belgian and Dutch e-commerce websites Abstract The current research investigates whether cultural differences between Belgium and the Netherlands are actually reflected in their respective commercial websites. With this purpose e-commerce websites from both countries have been subjected to an elaborate content analysis. Results indicate that Belgian transaction-oriented websites reflect a higher degree of ‘Power Distance’ (i.e. appreciation for social inequality and hierarchy) in comparison to their Dutch counterparts. This is manifested in the exceeding amount of information they provide with regard to company hierarchy, the more frequent depiction of CEO’s and the more frequent use of proper titles. In comparison with Dutch websites, Belgian websites also appear to be more ‘Masculine’ (i.e. appreciation of more masculine values, such as the need for achievement and competition). This is reflected in the fact that they use superlatives more regularly, distinguish more often between the sexes and use explicit comparisons more often. Contrary to expectations, Belgian web shops do not seem to reflect a higher degree of ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ (i.e. the degree to which individuals tend to avoid risks) in comparison with their Dutch counterparts. Finally, as expected, no difference could be revealed in the degree of ‘Collectivism’ (i.e. importance attached to group ties) reflected in Belgian and Dutch websites. Keywords Internet communications, cultural differences, e-commerce, website design & localization
  • 3. 1 – Introduction The growth of the internet as an international communication medium raises the question whether to standardize or to adapt international marketing communications via the World Wide Web. On the one hand, the internet is a mass-communication medium with worldwide accessibility, which may speak in favor of standardization. On the other hand, it is a very interactive medium, providing the opportunity to gather information on internet user segments, and making it practically possible to implement a high degree of audience adaptation. The current study investigates whether cultural differences between Belgium and the Netherlands are actually reflected in their respective commercial websites. 2 – Culture and cultural sensitivity of websites According to a socio-scientific approach, culture can be conceived as a mental predisposition in attitudes and behaviour, acquired and preserved by education and social relations. It is a collective phenomenon, with at its core a number of positive and negative values, which can, according to research by Hofstede (1980, 2001) and Trompenaers (1994), be summarized in 5 to 7 cultural dimensions. Having studied the convergence and divergence of consumer behaviour across countries for a long time, Marieke de Mooij (1998, 2000, 2004) argues that cultural differences are becoming even more pronounced with growing welfare and emphasizes that they should be taken into account to ensure the efficiency of global marketing strategies. Some recent academic research investigated more specifically the cultural sensitivity of websites and the need for localization or standardization.
  • 4. On the one hand, some researchers are convinced that cultural factors have no influence on website perceptions and recommend standardization (Hermans and Shanahan, 2002; Sackmary and Scalia, 1999; Yang and Kang, 2002). Based on content analysis of non- commercial websites, De Troyer et al. (2006) even assume that the internet has promoted “the emergence of a cosmopolitan online culture, a hybrid culture overriding traditional cultural differences”. On the other hand, do studies by Fink and Laupase (2000), Luna et al. (2002), Fock (2000), Simon (2001), Kanso and Nelson (2002), Singh and Baack (2004) and Singh et al. (2004) demonstrate that the internet is not a culturally neutral medium. They confirm that there are intercultural differences in perception of website content and stress that values, image, themes and symbols should be adapted to local cultures. While the internet fosters globalization, the necessity of localized websites seems to have become more and more obvious (Plumley, 2000; Boston Consulting Group, 2000; Fletcher et al., 2004). According to Forrester Research, the more a website is transaction-oriented, the more it should be localized (Torris, 1998). Therefore, especially ‘e-retailers’, eager to enter foreign markets, should focus on the local customers. A locally adapted language, content and interface design may be needed to attract the attention of the local user and to win his confidence. According to Forrester Research localized websites can draw more attention and lead to more ‘stickyness’ and sales. Therefore they recommend profoundly localized websites (Fletcher et al., 2004).
  • 5. 3 – Cultural differences between Belgium and the Netherlands Local (Dutch and Belgian) companies assume that Belgium and the Netherlands (as neighbours with a common language) are the ideal countries to make their first steps towards international expansion. Often however in this case cultural differences tend to be ignored (Kotler et al., 2006). In their studies investigating cross-national cultural differences, Hofstede (1980, 2001) and Trompenaers (1994) have, nevertheless, discovered large differences in value-orientations between Belgium and the Netherlands (see table 1). “In fact, no two countries (…) with a common border and a common language are so culturally apart (…) as (Dutch) Belgium and the Netherlands” Geert Hofstede, 1980, p228 The Netherlands Belgium France Flanders Wallonia Power Distance Appreciation of social inequality and hierarchy 38 65 61 67 68 Masculinity The extent to which masculine values as assertiveness, competition, urge for achievement and success prevail in comparison to more 14 54 43 60 43 feminine values such as life quality, nurturing, helpfulness and solidarity Uncertainty Avoidance The degree to which individuals tend to avoid ambiguous situations and to take risks when 53 94 97 93 86 making decisions Individualism The degree to which ties between members of a community are rather loose (i.e. individualistic) 80 75 78 72 71 or tight (i.e. collectivistic) Table 1: Scores for The Netherlands, Belgium (Flanders & Wallonia) and France with respect to Hofstede’s four cultural dimensions (Hofstede, 1980, 2001)
  • 6. Belgium scores, for instance, much higher than the Netherlands on the dimension ‘Power Distance’, concerning the relative appreciation of social inequality and hierarchy (B=65 versus Nl=38). Belgium also appears to score considerably higher on the dimension ‘Masculinity’, which reflects the urge for achievement, competition and assertive and aggressive behaviour, in comparison with the appreciation for modest and obliging behaviour and solidarity (B=54 versus Nl=14). Finally, Belgium also seems to score significantly higher on the dimension ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’, which is reflected in a higher number of rules, formal procedures and rituals (B=94 versus Nl=53). As a matter of fact, Hofstede (1980, p228) even claims that there are no two neighbouring countries with the same language that are so culturally different as (Dutch) Belgium and the Netherlands. With regard to the Belgian sub-regions of (Dutch-speaking) Flanders and (French-speaking) Wallonia, Hofstede (1980) argues that there are almost no cultural differences between them and that their cultures resemble in fact the French culture. Thus, although Belgium and the Netherlands share the same language, they obviously don’t share the same culture. The remarkable cultural differences between Flanders and the Netherlands have been confirmed in more recent studies (Claes and Gerritsen, 2006; see table 2 for an overview). Findings with regard to the cultural differences between Belgium and the Netherlands are also supported by several other researchers (Schwartz and Ross, 1995; Inglehart, 1997; Matthyssens and Wursten, 2003).
  • 7. Hofstede Hofstede Orriëns Claes & Gerritsen Gerritsen (1980) (2001) (1998) (2004) (2001) IBM Managers Banking-sector Students ICT-sector ’60 -‘70 1990 1998 1998 2001 Power Distance +23 +16 +25 +18 +20 Masculinity +29 +21 +13 +18 +12 Uncertainty Avoidance +44 +53 +47 +47 +43 Individualism -2 -4 -26 -4 no data Table 2: Differences between Flanders and the Netherlands with respect to Hofstede’s four cultural dimensions as reported in several more recent studies (based on Gerritsen, 2001 and Claes & Gerritsen, 2004). These cultural dimensions seem, amongst others, to have an impact on internet adoption and use. Park (2000), for instance, found strong support for the hypothesis that internet-use is higher in ‘feminine’ cultures than in ‘masculine’ cultures. Comparing the internet penetration between Belgium and the Netherlands, our findings reveal that indeed already 65,9% of the ‘more Feminine’ Dutch population uses the internet, in comparison with only 48,7% of the ‘more Masculine’ Belgian population, which has an internet penetration rate which lies close to the European average of 49,8% (Internet World Stats, 2006).
  • 8. 4 – Research 4.1 – Research question and hypotheses Are cultural differences in mentality between Belgium and the Netherlands reflected in their respective commercial websites? The current study investigates whether the cultural differences in mentality between Belgium and the Netherlands are being reflected in their respective commercial websites or not. The aim is thus to reveal whether the websites of online retailers of these respective neighbouring countries, also reflect the specific cultural values characteristic of these countries. Based on the review of the literature, we formulate more specifically the following hypotheses:  H1 – We propose that Belgian commercial websites will reflect a higher level of ‘Power Distance’ in comparison to their Dutch counterparts.  H2 – We assume that Belgian online retailers in comparison to Dutch ones will display a higher level of ‘Masculinity’.  H3 – We expect Belgian commercial websites to reflect a higher level of ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ in comparison to their Dutch counterparts.  H4 – We do not expect a significant difference in the level of ‘Collectivism’ reflected in Dutch or Belgian transaction-oriented websites, because both countries have a rather ‘individualistic’ orientation, in contrast to Eastern countries, for example, where more importance is attached to strong group and family ties.
  • 9. 4.2 – Method To verify these hypotheses, an elaborate content analysis of commercial websites from both countries was performed (cf. Singh and Baack, 2004). For this purpose, coding schemes provided by Singh and Matuso (2002) have been used. These schemes make it possible to register in a quantitative way to what degree Hofstede’s cultural dimensions are being displayed in the website. To assess, for example, the level of ‘Masculinity’ reflected in the website, we verified whether the site contains quizzes or games, whether ‘hard’ sales techniques are being used (e.g. discounts, coupons,…), whether explicit comparisons are being made, whether the ‘effectiveness’ is emphasized of the products offered for sale, etc… (see tables 4-7). In the present study, 40 Dutch and 40 Belgian commercial websites have been analysed in a systematic way. For the Belgian websites, 20 Flemish and 20 Walloon sites were selected. We focused more specifically on five sectors, namely online sellers of clothing, books, music, computers and travel. For each of these sectors, 8 websites per country have been analysed (for Belgium evenly divided between Flemish and Walloon sites). Thus, we tried to overcome a shortcoming of the study by Singh and Baack (2004), who compared US and Mexican websites of U.S. Fortune 500 companies, without taking into account the specific sectors represented in both samples. In the current study the online retailers were identified through search engines (like Google, Alta Vista and Yahoo).
  • 10. 4.3 - Results All online retailers studied, are assigned 4 summated scores that indicate to what extent their website reflects Hofstede’s cultural dimensions (respectively ‘Power Distance’, ‘Masculinity’, ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ and ‘Individualism’). Subsequently, we can calculate per country to what extent these cultural dimensions are reflected in the respective websites of that country. That way, we can evaluate the differences between the countries in the degree to which their websites reflect the respective cultural dimensions. The Netherlands Belgium Flanders Wallonia 5 4 3 2 1 0 e ity e m anc l in nc vis ist cu oida cti rD as Av lle e M y Co Pow int rta ce Un Figure 1: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimensions reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004) The Belgium t-test Netherlands Flanders Wallonia t-test Power Distance (7 items) 1.50 2.40 1.90 2.90 n.s. p = .036 Masculinity (7 items) 2.80 3.53 2.90 4.15 p = .009 p = .014 Uncertainty Avoidance (9 items) 3.35 3.73 3.10 4.35 p = .002 n.s. Collectivism (8 items) 2.13 2.53 2.10 2.95 p = .050 n.s. Table 3: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimensions reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004)
  • 11. 4.3.1 – Power Distance We assumed that Belgian websites would reflect a higher level of ‘Power Distance’ in comparison to their Dutch counterparts. Our findings (illustrated in figure 1) seem to confirm this hypothesis. The summated score over all websites on the 7 items reflecting ‘Power Distance’ (see table 3) amounts to 2.40 for Belgium in comparison with 1.50 for the Netherlands, a significant difference according to the t-test (p=.036). The Belgium χ 2-test 2 Netherlands Flanders Wallonia χ -test Power Distance (%) (%) (%) (%) Company Hierarchy Information 7.5 32.5 25 40 n.s. p = .005 Pictures of CEO’s 2.5 20 25 15 n.s. p = .014 Quality Information and Awards 20 27.5 25 30 n.s. n.s. Vision Statement 25 40 20 60 p = .011 n.s. Rank or Prestige of the Company 22.5 30 5 55 p = .001 n.s. Pride of Ownership appeal 65 47.5 45 50 n.s. n.s. Proper Titles 7.5 42.5 45 40 n.s. p < .000 Table 4: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimension “Power Distance”, reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004) When we take a look at the individual items (see table 4), we notice that significantly more Belgian than Dutch online retailers give information about their company hierarchy (respectively 32,5% versus 7,5%; χ2-test, p=.005). Moreover, whereas in 20% of the Belgian websites CEO’s are depicted, this appears to be the case in only 2,5% of the Dutch websites (χ2-test, p=.014). Finally, in considerably more Belgian than Dutch websites appropriate personal titles are being used (42,5% versus 7,5%; χ2-test, p<.000). These findings
  • 12. demonstrate clearly that a higher level of ‘Power Distance’ is reflected in the Belgian commercial websites, compared to their Dutch counterparts. Whereas, within Belgium, the level of ‘Power Distance’ reflected in Flemish commercial websites seems to be considerably lower than the level reflected in Walloon sites, this difference between both sub-regions appears in general not to be significant (see table 3). From the results, conveyed in table 4, we can, however, clearly establish that in more Walloon than Flemish websites, a company vision statement is provided (respectively 60% compared to 20%; χ2-test, p=.011) and that in more Walloon than Flemish websites the ranking and prestige of the company is emphasized (55% versus 5%; χ2-test, p=.001), thus unexpectedly revealing some higher level of ‘Power Distance’ reflected in Walloon websites. 4.3.2 – Masculinity We assumed that Belgian commercial websites would be more likely to reflect ‘Masculinity’, while Dutch sites would appear more ‘Feminine’. Our findings (illustrated in figure 1) seem to support this hypothesis. The summated score over all websites on the 7 items indicative for ‘Masculinity’ (see table 3), amounts to 3,53 for Belgium, compared to 2,80 for the Netherlands. A t-test reveals that this difference is in fact significant (p=.014). When we examine the individual items more carefully (see table 5), we can establish that significantly more Belgian than Dutch online retailers are using superlatives in their websites (respectively 65% versus 35%; χ2-test: p=.007). More Belgian websites, in comparison with Dutch ones, distinguish clearly between the sexes (42,5% versus 20%; χ2-test, p=.026). Furthermore, it becomes apparent that only Belgian online retailers are using explicit comparisons in their websites (12,5% versus 0%; χ2-test, p=.027). These results illustrate clearly that Belgian websites reflect a higher level of ‘Masculinity’ than their Dutch
  • 13. counterparts. When we examine the individual items that reflect ‘Masculinity’, however, we notice one exception. More Dutch sites appear to emphasize the effectiveness of their products than Belgian sites (respectively 85% versus 65%; χ2-test, p=.035). The Belgium χ 2-test 2 Netherlands Flanders Wallonia χ -test Masculinity (%) (%) (%) (%) Quizzes and games 10 22.5 20 25 n.s. n.s. Hard Sell Approach 57.5 72.5 65 80 n.s. n.s. Explicit Comparisons 0 12.5 0 25 p = .024 p = .027 Realism Theme 72.5 72.5 75 70 n.s. n.s. Product Effectiveness 85 65 65 65 n.s. p = .035 Use of Superlatives 35 65 40 90 p = .001 p = .007 Clear Gender Roles 20 42.5 25 60 p = .027 p = .026 Table 5: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimension “Masculinity”, reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004) When we take a look at the differences within Belgium between Flemish and Walloon sites, we notice that the earlier reported distinction in reflected ‘Masculinity’ between Belgian and Dutch websites is almost solely a reflection of the higher level of ‘Masculinity’ displayed in Walloon sites. In comparison to Flemish e-commerce sites, Walloon e-retailers use superlatives considerably more often in their websites (90% versus 40%; χ2-test, p=.001). They also seem to make explicit comparisons more often (25% versus 0%; χ2-test, p=.024) and they make more often clear distinctions between the sexes (60% versus 25%; χ2-test, p=.027). Table 3 shows clearly that the summated score, over all the websites of the 7 items that reflect ‘Masculinity’, amounts to 2,90 for Flanders and differs in this respect hardly from the Dutch summated score of 2,80. Wallony, on the other hand, attains a significantly higher score on reflected ‘Masculinity’, namely 4,15 (t-test, p=.009).
  • 14. 4.3.3 – Uncertainty Avoidance We hypothesized that Belgian transaction-oriented websites would reflect a higher level of ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ than their Dutch counterparts. Our findings (illustrated in figure 1), however, do not seem to support this hypothesis. The summated score over all the sites of the 9 items that reflect ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ does not prove to be significantly different between Belgium and the Netherlands (see table 3). Within Belgium, however, there appears to be a considerable difference between Flemish and Walloon sites. Walloon sites seem to reflect significantly more ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ than Flemish ones (respective scores of 4,35 and 3,10; t-test, p=.002). The Belgium χ 2-test Netherlands Flanders Wallonia χ2-test Uncertainty Avoidance (%) (%) (%) (%) Customer Service 90 95 95 95 n.s. n.s. Secure Payment 70 70 50 90 p = .007 n.s. Guided Navigation 82.5 87.5 75 100 p = .024 n.s. Tradition Theme 20 25 20 30 n.s. n.s. Local Stores 52.5 57.5 50 65 n.s. n.s. Local Terminology 2.5 5 0 10 n.s. n.s. Free Trials and Downloads 2.5 27.5 15 40 n.s. p = .002 Customer Testimonials 12.5 5 5 5 n.s. n.s. Toll Free Numbers 2.5 0 0 0 n.s. n.s. Table 6: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimension “Uncertainty Avoidance”, reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004) When we take a look at the individual items (see table 6), we notice that more Belgian sites offer free downloads and trials than Dutch ones (27,5% versus 2,5%; χ2-test, p=.002). Within Belgium, especially Walloon sites seem to offer this possibility (40% compared to 15%
  • 15. Flemish sites), however this difference appears not to be significant. Still, more Walloon than Flemish online retailers appear to emphasize the security of payments on their sites (90% versus 50%; χ2-test, p=.007) and the possibility of guided navigation (100% versus 75%; χ2- test, p=.024), confirming the higher level of reflected ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’. 4.3.4 – Collectivism We assumed that there would be no significant difference in the level of ‘Collectivism’ reflected in Belgian and Dutch e-commerce websites. Our findings (illustrated in figure 1) seem to support this hypothesis. The summated score over all websites of the 8 items that reflect ‘Collectivism’ does not appear to be significantly different between Belgium and the Netherlands (see table 3). When we consult the individual items (see table 7), we do notice however that more Belgian sites appear to offer loyalty programs than Dutch sites (40% versus 20%; χ2-test, p=.043). The Belgium χ 2-test 2 Netherlands Flanders Wallonia χ -test Collectivism (%) (%) (%) (%) Community Relations 7.5 2.5 0 5 n.s. n.s. Clubs or Chat room 15 27.5 30 25 n.s. n.s. Newsletter 57.5 57.5 60 55 n.s. n.s. Family Theme 27.5 45 25 65 p = 0.012 n.s. Country Specific Information 22.5 12.5 10 15 n.s. n.s. Symbols & Pictures of Nation 10 17.5 5 30 p = .046 n.s. Loyalty Programs 20 40 45 35 n.s. p = 0.043 Links to Local Web sites 52.5 50 35 65 n.s. n.s. Table 7: Scores with regard to Hofstede’s cultural dimension “Collectivism”, reflected in Dutch and Belgian (Flemish & Walloon) commercial websites (cfr. Singh & Baack, 2004)
  • 16. Within Belgium, we notice that Walloon sites seem to reflect more ‘Collectivism’ than Flemish ones (respective scores of 2,95 versus 2,10; t-test, p=.050). More Walloon than Flemish commercial websites appear to make use of family themes (65% versus 25%; χ2-test, p=.012), and symbols and images of national identity (30% versus 5%; χ2-test, p=.046), pointing to a higher level of ‘Collectivism’ reflected. 5 – Conclusion According to the literature, there are major cultural differences between Belgium and the Netherlands, which should be taken into consideration with respect to marketing communications (e.g. FEM, 1998; Gerritsen, 2002; Claes & Gerritsen, 2006). The current study demonstrates that these cultural differences in mentality between Belgium and the Netherlands are also reflected in their respective commercial websites. The websites of Belgian online retailers seem, as could be expected, to reflect a higher level of ‘Power Distance’ in comparison to their Dutch counterparts. This is manifested by the exceeding frequency to which they provide information with regard to company hierarchy, the more frequent depiction of CEO’s and the more frequent use of proper titles of address. Although the level of reflected ‘Power Distance’ does not seem to differ significantly between Flemish and Walloon sites, more Walloon than Flemish sites appear to provide a company vision statement and emphasize the ranking and prestige of the company, revealing unexpectedly some higher level of ‘Power Distance’ reflected in Walloon commercial websites. As expected, Belgian e-commerce websites also appear to be more ‘Masculine’ than their Dutch counterparts, which is reflected in the fact that they use superlatives more regularly, that they distinguish more often between the sexes and that they use explicit comparisons
  • 17. more often. Walloon sites, however, seem to be almost exclusively responsible for these detected differences, as they do also significantly differ from Flemish sites in this regard. On the other hand, Dutch websites do appear to emphasize the effectiveness of their products more often than Belgian sites, possibly indicating that the Netherlands are getting more ‘Masculine’ (cfr. Gerritsen, 2001). Contrary to our expectations, Belgian web shops do not seem to reflect a higher degree of ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ in comparison to their Dutch counterparts. We notice, nevertheless, that more Belgian sites offer free downloads and trials than Dutch ones. This is especially apparent for Walloon sites, which seem to reflect a higher degree of ‘Uncertainty Avoidance’ than the Flemish ones, which is also manifested in the fact that they emphasize the security of payments on their sites and the possibility of guided navigation more often. Although, as expected, no difference in ‘Collectivism’ between Belgian and Dutch e- commerce sites could be revealed, we do notice that more Belgian sites offer loyalty programs than Dutch ones. Within Belgium, Walloon sites appear to reflect more ‘Collectivism’ than Flemish websites, which is apparent from the fact that they seem to make more use of family themes and symbols and images of national identity. 6– Discussion The present study did not investigate the effectiveness of locally adapted commercial websites. In a subsequent phase of this research project, an experimental study will be carried out to investigate this crucial question. At this point, however, we did establish that there are important cultural differences between Belgium and the Netherlands, but also between Flanders and Wallonia, which appear to be reflected in their respective e-commerce websites.
  • 18. If online retailers wish to exploit the possibilities of the internet to attract consumers on the other side of the border, they may want to take this into consideration. References Boston Consulting Group, 2000. The Race for online Riches: e-retailing in Europe, February, http://www.dad.be/library/pdf/BCG1.pdf Claes M-T. & Gerritsen M., 2004. “Nederland en Nederlandstalig België: buren met verschillende culturen” (The Netherlands and Dutch speaking Belgium: Neighbours with Different Cultures) in Claes & Gerritsen: “Culturele waarden en communicatie in internationaal perspectief”(Cultural Values and Communication from an International Perspective), Bussum: Uitgeverij Coutinho, chapter 4. Claes M-T. & Gerritsen M., 2006. “Waarom Vlamingen van Venus komen en Nederlanders van Mars” (Why the Flemish come from Venus and the Dutch from Mars), Uitgeverij Meulenhoff (in press). de Mooij M., 1998. “Global marketing and advertising”, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage. de Mooij M., 2000. The future is predictable for international marketers. International Marketing Review, 17 (2), 103-113. de Mooij M., 2004. "Consumer Behavior and Culture. Consequences for Global Marketing and Advertising ", Sage Publications, Inc. USA and UK. (360 p). De Troyer O., Mushtaha A.N., Stengers H., Baetens M., Boers F., Casteleyn S. & Plessers P., 2006. “On Cultural Differences in Local Web Interfaces”, Journal of Web Engineering, Vol. 5., No.3., p246-264. Financiëel Economisch Magazine FEM, 1998. “Cultuurclash tussen Nederland en België” (Culture Clash between the Netherlands and Belgium), July 11th. Fink D. & Laupase R., 2000. “Perceptions of Web Site Design Characteristics”: A Malaysian/Australian Comparison”, Internet Research, 10, 1, p44-55. Fletcher R., Bell J. and R. McNaughton, 2004. International e-Business Marketing, Thomson Learning, London.
  • 19. Fock, H., 2000. Cultural influences on marketing communication on the World Wide Web. Paper presented at the Multicultural Marketing Conference, Hong Kong, September. Gerritsen M., 2001. Cultuur als spelbreker. De communicatieve gevolgen van cultuurverschillen tussen Vlaanderen en Nederland (Culture as a Spoilsport. The Communicative Consequences of Cultural Differences Between Flanders and the Netherlands), publication of Speech at the Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen, Friday September 28th 2001, Nijmegen. Gerritsen M., 2002. Cultuur als spelbreker. De communicatieve gevolgen van cultuurverschillen tussen Vlaanderen en Nederland. (Culture as a Spoilsport. The Communicative Consequences of Cultural Differences Between Flanders and the Netherlands) Tijdschrift voor Taalbeheersing (Journal of Applied Linguistics), 24 (1), 50-62. Hermans M. Ch. & K.J. Shanahan, 2002. “The Reification of Levitt: Advertising preferences for Mexican and American online consumers”, Developments in Marketing Science, 25, p147. Hofstede G., 1980. “Culture’s consequences. International differences in work related values”, Beverly Hills, CA: Sage. Hofstede G., 2001. "Culture's consequences. Comparing values, behaviours, institutions and organizations across nations", 2nd edition, Thousand Oaks, CA, Sage. Internet World Stats, 2006. “Internet Usage in European Union”, Miniwatts Marketing Group, available at http://www.internetworldstats.com/stats9.htm. Inglehart R., 1997. “Modernization and Postmodernization. Cultural, economic and political change in 43 societies”, Princeton University Press, Princeton. Kanso A. & R. Nelson, 2002. “Advertising localization overshadows standardization”, Journal of Advertising Research, Jan/Feb, p79-89. Kotler P., Armstrong G., Saunders J., Wong V., Broere F., 2006. “België en Nederland, dat is toch zo’n beetje hetzelfde?” (Belgium and the Netherlands, they appear to be very similar, don’t they?), in Principes van Marketing, (Dutch adaptation of Principles of Marketing), 4th edition, Pearson Education Benelux, Amsterdam, p189-190. Luna, D., Peracchio, L. A., & de Juan, M. D., 2002. Cross-cultural and cognitive aspects of Web site navigation. Journal of the Academy of Marketing Science, 30 (4), 397-410.
  • 20. Matthyssens P. & Wursten H., 2003. “Internal Marketing”, in "Cross-cultural Marketing", Rugimbana R., Nwankwo S. eds., Thomson Learning, p243-256. Orriëns D., 1998. “Nederland en Vlaanderen: een wereld van verschil! Een onderzoek naar de culturele verschuivingen tussen Nederland en Vlaanderen tussen het einde van de jaren ’60 en 1998” (The Netherlands and Flanders, Worlds Apart! Research with regard to the Cultural Shifts between the Netherlands and Flanders between the end of the Sixties and 1998), Master’s thesis International Business Communication, Katholieke Universiteit Nijmegen. Park H., 2000. “A cross-cultural analysis of internet connectivity”, Journal of Current Research in Global Business, fall, p 97-107. Plumley D.J., 2000. “Global eCommerce: The market, challenges and opportunities”, Bowne Global Solutions, January. Sackmary B. & L. Scalia, 1999. “Cultural patterns of World Wide Web business sites: a comparison of Mexican and US companies”, paper presented at the Seventh Cross- Cultural Consumer and Business Studies Research Conference, Cancun, Mexico. Schwartz S.H. & Ros M., 1995. “Values in the West: A theoretical and empirical challenge to the Individualism-Collectivism cultural dimension”, World Psychology, 1, 91-122. Simon, S. J., 2001. The impact of culture and gender on Web sites: An empirical study. Database for Advances in Information Systems, 32(1), 18-37. Singh N., 2002 “Analysing Cultural Sensitivity of Websites. A Normative Framework.”, Journal of Practical Global Business, April, http://www.expandglobal.com/journal/Jour_2/journalv1_p32.pdf Singh N. and Hisako Matsuo, 2002. “A Framework to Measure Cultural Values on the Web.” E-Business Review, Vol. 2, March. Singh N. & D. W. Baack, 2004. “Website adaptation: a cross-cultural comparison of US and Mexican websites”, Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication, 9 (4), July. Singh, N., Furrerr O., Ostinelli M., 2004. “To Localize or to Standardize on the Web: Empirical Evidence from Italy, India, Netherlands, Spain, and Switzerland.” Multinational Business Review Torris Th., 1998. “JIT Web Localization”, Forrester Research, July.
  • 21. Trompenaers F., 1994. “Riding the waves of culture. Understanding diversity in global business”, New York: Professional Publishing. Yang C.C.K. & Y. Kang, 2002. “The influence of cultural factors on consumers’ reaction to Internet advertisements”, Developments in Marketing Science, Sanibel Island, 25, p148-151.