SlideShare a Scribd company logo
The	
  ‘endless’	
  E-­‐Toll	
  Saga	
  	
  
and	
  other	
  interes4ng	
  facts	
  
Wayne	
  Duvenage	
  
OUTA	
  -­‐	
  Chairperson	
  
Breaking	
  the	
  myths	
  about	
  OUTA	
  &	
  E-­‐Tolls	
  
Dispel	
  SANRAL’s	
  Claims	
  of	
  six	
  court	
  wins	
  
	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  	
  18	
  months	
  of	
  A"ri%on	
  Through	
  Lawfare	
  
Why	
  did	
  OUTA	
  launch?	
  
E-­‐Toll	
  Discussions…	
  
Staying	
  the	
  course	
  and	
  why	
  we	
  had	
  to	
  
What	
  we	
  discovered…	
  
E-­‐Toll	
  Revenue	
  (&	
  “Forecasts”)	
  
!"!!!!
!50.0!!
!100.0!!
!150.0!!
!200.0!!
!250.0!!
!300.0!!
!350.0!!
1! 2! 3! 4! 5! 6! 7! 8! 9! 10! 11! 12! 13! 14! 15! 16! 17! 18! 19! 20! 21! 22! 23! 24! 25! 26! 27! 28! 29! 30!Dec$13 Jan$14 Feb$14 Mar$14 Apr$14 May$14 Jun$14 Jul$14 Aug$14 Sep$14 Oct$14 Nov$14 Dec$14 Jan$15 Feb$15 Mar$15 Apr$15 May$15 Jun$15 Jul$15 Aug$15 Sep$15 Oct$15 Nov$15 Dec$15 Jan$16 Feb$16 Mar$16 Apr$16 May$16
RANDS	
  	
  x	
  Millions	
  
Launched	
  3	
  Dec	
  2013	
  
COURT	
  PROCESS	
  IN	
  2012	
  &	
  2013	
  SANRAL	
  SAID:	
  
1.  COMPLIANCE	
  will	
  be	
  93%.	
  
2.  Average	
  Revenue	
  of	
  R260	
  mil	
  /	
  month	
  achievable	
  
!"!!!!
!50.0!!
!100.0!!
!150.0!!
!200.0!!
!250.0!!
!300.0!!
!350.0!!
1! 2! 3! 4! 5! 6! 7! 8! 9! 10! 11! 12! 13! 14! 15! 16! 17! 18! 19! 20! 21! 22! 23! 24! 25! 26! 27! 28! 29! 30!
E-­‐Toll	
  Revenue	
  (&	
  “Forecasts”)	
  
Projec4on	
  for	
  success	
  (OUTA)	
  
Dec$13 Jan$14 Feb$14 Mar$14 Apr$14 May$14 Jun$14 Jul$14 Aug$14 Sep$14 Oct$14 Nov$14 Dec$14 Jan$15 Feb$15 Mar$15 Apr$15 May$15 Jun$15 Jul$15 Aug$15 Sep$15 Oct$15 Nov$15 Dec$15 Jan$16 Feb$16 Mar$16 Apr$16 May$16
Actual	
  Revenue	
  (SANRAL)	
  
Forecasts	
  Revenue	
  (SANRAL)	
  
!"!!!!
!50.0!!
!100.0!!
!150.0!!
!200.0!!
!250.0!!
!300.0!!
!350.0!!
1! 2! 3! 4! 5! 6! 7! 8! 9! 10! 11! 12! 13! 14! 15! 16! 17! 18! 19! 20! 21! 22! 23! 24! 25! 26! 27! 28! 29! 30!
E-­‐Toll	
  Revenue	
  (&	
  “Forecasts”)	
  
Projec4on	
  for	
  success	
  (OUTA)	
  
Dec$13 Jan$14 Feb$14 Mar$14 Apr$14 May$14 Jun$14 Jul$14 Aug$14 Sep$14 Oct$14 Nov$14 Dec$14 Jan$15 Feb$15 Mar$15 Apr$15 May$15 Jun$15 Jul$15 Aug$15 Sep$15 Oct$15 Nov$15 Dec$15 Jan$16 Feb$16 Mar$16 Apr$16 May$16
Actual	
  Revenue	
  (SANRAL)	
  
Forecasts	
  Revenue	
  (SANRAL)	
  
SANRAL’s	
  Discount	
  	
  Dispensa4on…	
  
	
  Moun4ng	
  Public	
  Anxiety	
  
OUTA	
  Refuses	
  to	
  go	
  away…	
  
E-­‐Toll	
  Defense	
  Umbrella	
  
New	
  internal	
  legal	
  capacity	
  
Defend	
  every	
  OUTA	
  member	
  	
  
OUTA	
  Revises	
  strategy	
  –	
  Sep	
  2015…	
  
OUTA	
  REVISES	
  STRATEGY	
  FOR	
  LEGAL	
  DEVELOPMENTS	
  
Threats	
  of	
  Vehicle	
  Lis4ngs	
  (?)	
  &	
  Summonses	
  
Sanral	
  begins	
  to	
  issue	
  6,000	
  summonses	
  
Jan	
  2016	
  –	
  Dispensa4on	
  failing	
  fast	
  
May	
  2016:	
  New	
  Dispensa4on	
  <R150m	
  of	
  R5,9b	
  
OUTA	
  defends	
  all	
  its	
  summonsed	
  members	
  
Current	
  li4ga4on	
  developments	
  	
  
In	
  Feb	
  2016:	
  OUTA	
  expands	
  mandate	
  
OPPOSITION	
  TO	
  URBAN	
  TOLLING	
  ALLIANCE	
  
ORGANISATION	
  UNDOING	
  TAX	
  ABUSE	
  
WHY?	
  
TO	
  
Many	
  ques4ons	
  raised	
  around	
  tax	
  policy	
  
	
  Carbon	
  Tax,	
  Sugar	
  Taxes	
  
	
  Tyre	
  Recycling	
  Taxes	
  
	
  	
  
Many	
  ques4ons	
  around	
  maladministra4on	
  
&	
  /	
  Corrup4on	
  
	
  SAA,	
  	
  Eskom,	
  	
  Prasa,	
  SABC	
  
SOE	
  accoun4ng	
  prac4ces	
  enables	
  more	
  
borrowing…	
  	
  	
  
	
  Increased	
  cost	
  of	
  infrastructure	
  in	
  SA…	
  
2004$ 2005$ 2006$ 2007$ 2008$ 2009$ 2010$ 2011$ 2012$ 2013$ 2014$ 2015$
Debt$Ra2o's$$ 1.234856856$1.178158303$1.185716064$1.219998469$0.516794454$1.026106071$0.232479401$0.246719604$0.260951841$0.250963373$0.252289173$0.288061201$
Total$Assets$ 7780782000$9076108000$8999830000$9826332000$12444495000$30603724000$1.87174E+11$2.2049E+11$2.69265E+11$2.76296E+11$3.10992E+11$3.25469E+11$
Total$Liabili2es$9608152000$10693092000$10671243000$11988110000$14328202000$31402667000$43514132000$54399317000$70265150000$69340215000$78459898000$93754925000$
R0$
R50,000,000,000$
R100,000,000,000$
R150,000,000,000$
R200,000,000,000$
R250,000,000,000$
R300,000,000,000$
R350,000,000,000$
$SANRAL:$Total$Liabili2es$To$Total$Assets$
Rands	
  x	
  Billion	
  
SANRAL’s:	
  	
  Total	
  Assets	
  to	
  Liabili4es	
  
 -­‐	
  	
  	
  	
  
	
  100,000	
  	
  
	
  200,000	
  	
  
	
  300,000	
  	
  
	
  400,000	
  	
  
	
  500,000	
  	
  
	
  600,000	
  	
  
	
  700,000	
  	
  
2005	
   2006	
   2007	
   2008	
   2009	
   2010	
   2011	
   2012	
   2013	
   2014*	
   2015*	
   2016	
  
Eskom	
  Total	
  Assets	
  to	
  Total	
  Liabilites	
  
Total	
  assets	
   Total	
  liabili4es	
  
RANDS	
  x	
  Billions	
  
 -­‐	
  	
  	
  	
  
	
  100,000	
  	
  
	
  200,000	
  	
  
	
  300,000	
  	
  
	
  400,000	
  	
  
	
  500,000	
  	
  
	
  600,000	
  	
  
	
  700,000	
  	
  
2005	
   2006	
   2007	
   2008	
   2009	
   2010	
   2011	
   2012	
   2013	
   2014*	
   2015*	
   2016	
  
Eskom	
  Total	
  Assets	
  to	
  Total	
  Liabilites	
  
Total	
  assets	
   Total	
  liabili4es	
  
RANDS	
  x	
  Billions	
  
Total	
  ProducIon	
  (GwH)	
  
Coal	
  Burn	
  (Mt)	
  
122	
  
119	
  
125	
  
231	
  
237	
  
215	
  
218	
  218	
  
225	
  
0	
  
50	
  
100	
  
150	
  
200	
  
250	
  
Sales	
  (GwH)	
  
39	
  
137	
  
Sales	
  (R’bn)	
  
	
  50	
  
	
  75	
  
100	
  	
  	
  
125	
  	
  	
  
150	
  
	
  25	
  	
  
The	
  QuesIon	
  of	
  Road	
  ConstrucIon	
  Costs	
  in	
  SA	
  	
  
Gauteng	
  Freeway	
  Improvement	
  Project	
  
-­‐  185	
  km	
  =	
  R17,9	
  bn	
  
-­‐  Just	
  under	
  R100m	
  /	
  KM	
  
-­‐  An	
  addi4onal	
  lane	
  each	
  direc4on	
  +	
  3	
  /	
  4	
  lanes	
  resurfaced	
  
OUTA	
  Research	
  in	
  Feb	
  2016	
  –	
  shows	
  serious	
  concerns	
  
Why	
  would	
  this	
  be	
  a	
  concern?	
  	
  	
  
-­‐ 	
  E-­‐Tolls	
  more	
  irra4onal	
  
GFIP	
  
Addis-­‐Ababa	
  –	
  Adama	
  (85km)	
  
AWer	
  Before	
  
Before	
  
AWer	
  
GFIP	
  
Nairobi-­‐Thika	
  SuperHighway	
  (50km)	
  
AWer	
  Before	
  
Before	
  
AWer	
  
GFIP	
  
Grand	
  Parkway	
  to	
  SH6	
  –	
  Texas	
  (11km)	
  
AWer	
  Before	
  
AWer	
  Before	
  
The	
  Cost	
  of	
  Road	
  Construc4on	
  in	
  SA	
  
Cost	
  comparison	
  for	
  GFIP	
  and	
  Other	
  
0	
  
1000	
  
2000	
  
3000	
  
4000	
  
5000	
  
6000	
  
GFIP	
   Addis	
  Ababa-­‐Adama	
  
Expressway	
  
Nairobi-­‐Thika	
  
Expressway	
  
Grand	
  Parkway	
  to	
  
SH6	
  Texas	
  
N3	
  Future	
  Upgrades	
  
Cost	
  /	
  m²	
  
GFIP	
   Addis	
  Ababa-­‐Adama	
  Expressway	
   Nairobi-­‐Thika	
  Expressway	
  
Grand	
  Parkway	
  to	
  SH6	
  Texas	
   N3	
  Future	
  Upgrades	
  
N3	
  Upgrade	
  –	
  Durban	
  to	
  Cedara	
  /	
  Pmb	
  (84km)	
  
PMB	
  
DURBAN	
  
N3	
  Upgrade	
  –	
  Durban	
  to	
  Cedara	
  /	
  Pmb	
  (84km)	
  
The	
  Cost	
  of	
  Road	
  Construc4on	
  in	
  SA	
  
Cost	
  comparison	
  for	
  GFIP	
  and	
  Other	
  
0	
  
1000	
  
2000	
  
3000	
  
4000	
  
5000	
  
6000	
  
GFIP	
   Addis	
  Ababa-­‐Adama	
  
Expressway	
  
Nairobi-­‐Thika	
  
Expressway	
  
Grand	
  Parkway	
  to	
  
SH6	
  Texas	
  
N3	
  Future	
  Upgrades	
  
Cost	
  /	
  m²	
  
GFIP	
   Addis	
  Ababa-­‐Adama	
  Expressway	
   Nairobi-­‐Thika	
  Expressway	
  
Grand	
  Parkway	
  to	
  SH6	
  Texas	
   N3	
  Future	
  Upgrades	
  
?	
  
Harrismith	
  will	
  loose	
  Est.	
  
R1bn	
  /	
  annum	
  pa	
  (1,5m	
  cars)	
  
98	
  Km	
  New	
  4	
  Lane	
  Freeway	
  	
  
to	
  save	
  14km	
  ???	
  	
  
Road	
  will	
  cost	
  est	
  R10bn	
  
Toll	
  costs	
  will	
  negate	
  the	
  
14km	
  Saving	
  
Alterna4ve	
  shortening	
  and	
  
safer	
  alignments	
  best	
  
op4on	
  
Swinburne	
  &	
  Van	
  Reenen	
  
Pass	
  nodes	
  die	
  
THANK	
  	
  
YOU	
  

More Related Content

Similar to E toll presentation Wayne Duvenage TruckX

Esta Colombia en num3r05 crisis o cambio de entorno - febrero de 2015
Esta Colombia en num3r05   crisis o cambio de entorno - febrero de 2015Esta Colombia en num3r05   crisis o cambio de entorno - febrero de 2015
Esta Colombia en num3r05 crisis o cambio de entorno - febrero de 2015
Camilo Herrera
 
CSCMP 2014 - Capacity Crunch: Utilizing Technology to Overcome Capacity Const...
CSCMP 2014 - Capacity Crunch: Utilizing Technology to Overcome Capacity Const...CSCMP 2014 - Capacity Crunch: Utilizing Technology to Overcome Capacity Const...
CSCMP 2014 - Capacity Crunch: Utilizing Technology to Overcome Capacity Const...
Peter Vomocil
 
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
LTC @ CSUSB
 
Jordina Vidal, Oriol Vidal Enginyeria, Barcelona, Spain.
Jordina Vidal, Oriol Vidal Enginyeria, Barcelona, Spain.Jordina Vidal, Oriol Vidal Enginyeria, Barcelona, Spain.
Jordina Vidal, Oriol Vidal Enginyeria, Barcelona, Spain.
ARC research group
 
Stock Portfolio Analysis
Stock Portfolio AnalysisStock Portfolio Analysis
Stock Portfolio AnalysisDaniel Lei
 
Multi-Party Computation in 2029: Boom, Bust, or Bonanza?
Multi-Party Computation in 2029: Boom, Bust, or Bonanza?Multi-Party Computation in 2029: Boom, Bust, or Bonanza?
Multi-Party Computation in 2029: Boom, Bust, or Bonanza?
David Evans
 
Artificial+Lift+Market+by+Spears+Q1+15.pptx
Artificial+Lift+Market+by+Spears+Q1+15.pptxArtificial+Lift+Market+by+Spears+Q1+15.pptx
Artificial+Lift+Market+by+Spears+Q1+15.pptx
ger80
 
28.05.2012, Staggering costs of inefficient regulation in Mongolia, Olin McGill
28.05.2012, Staggering costs of inefficient regulation in Mongolia, Olin McGill 28.05.2012, Staggering costs of inefficient regulation in Mongolia, Olin McGill
28.05.2012, Staggering costs of inefficient regulation in Mongolia, Olin McGill
The Business Council of Mongolia
 
SearchLove San Diego 2018 | Rob Bucci | Featured Snippets: From Then to Now, ...
SearchLove San Diego 2018 | Rob Bucci | Featured Snippets: From Then to Now, ...SearchLove San Diego 2018 | Rob Bucci | Featured Snippets: From Then to Now, ...
SearchLove San Diego 2018 | Rob Bucci | Featured Snippets: From Then to Now, ...
Distilled
 
Presentation to O'Connor and Associates Land Forecast 051414
Presentation to O'Connor and Associates Land Forecast 051414Presentation to O'Connor and Associates Land Forecast 051414
Presentation to O'Connor and Associates Land Forecast 051414
Scott Davis
 
Oil and Gas Industry Day 2014
Oil and Gas Industry Day 2014Oil and Gas Industry Day 2014
Oil and Gas Industry Day 2014
State of Utah, Salt Lake City
 
The Power 2Connect
The Power 2ConnectThe Power 2Connect
CSB Eece Presentation
CSB Eece PresentationCSB Eece Presentation
CSB Eece Presentation391445
 
QCon2015 NoSQLWithCachingSearchAndRealTimeAnalytics
QCon2015 NoSQLWithCachingSearchAndRealTimeAnalyticsQCon2015 NoSQLWithCachingSearchAndRealTimeAnalytics
QCon2015 NoSQLWithCachingSearchAndRealTimeAnalytics
James Gorlick
 
HSMAI Dialogue Evening - STR Global: Dublin Hotel Pricing and International T...
HSMAI Dialogue Evening - STR Global: Dublin Hotel Pricing and International T...HSMAI Dialogue Evening - STR Global: Dublin Hotel Pricing and International T...
HSMAI Dialogue Evening - STR Global: Dublin Hotel Pricing and International T...
HSMAI_Ireland
 
Prosperity Scorecard For The Sault
Prosperity Scorecard For The SaultProsperity Scorecard For The Sault
Prosperity Scorecard For The Saultmpian
 
SIMIDoneDeal Quarter4 Motor Industry Review for 2014 2nd feb 2015
SIMIDoneDeal Quarter4 Motor Industry Review for 2014 2nd feb 2015SIMIDoneDeal Quarter4 Motor Industry Review for 2014 2nd feb 2015
SIMIDoneDeal Quarter4 Motor Industry Review for 2014 2nd feb 2015
Teresa Noone
 
Roadway Impact Fees
Roadway Impact FeesRoadway Impact Fees
Roadway Impact Fees
City of College Station
 

Similar to E toll presentation Wayne Duvenage TruckX (20)

Esta Colombia en num3r05 crisis o cambio de entorno - febrero de 2015
Esta Colombia en num3r05   crisis o cambio de entorno - febrero de 2015Esta Colombia en num3r05   crisis o cambio de entorno - febrero de 2015
Esta Colombia en num3r05 crisis o cambio de entorno - febrero de 2015
 
CSCMP 2014 - Capacity Crunch: Utilizing Technology to Overcome Capacity Const...
CSCMP 2014 - Capacity Crunch: Utilizing Technology to Overcome Capacity Const...CSCMP 2014 - Capacity Crunch: Utilizing Technology to Overcome Capacity Const...
CSCMP 2014 - Capacity Crunch: Utilizing Technology to Overcome Capacity Const...
 
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
LTC, Annual Forum, For Whom the Road Should Toll: The Future of Toll Roads an...
 
Project
ProjectProject
Project
 
Jordina Vidal, Oriol Vidal Enginyeria, Barcelona, Spain.
Jordina Vidal, Oriol Vidal Enginyeria, Barcelona, Spain.Jordina Vidal, Oriol Vidal Enginyeria, Barcelona, Spain.
Jordina Vidal, Oriol Vidal Enginyeria, Barcelona, Spain.
 
Elecyr pitch deck
Elecyr pitch deckElecyr pitch deck
Elecyr pitch deck
 
Stock Portfolio Analysis
Stock Portfolio AnalysisStock Portfolio Analysis
Stock Portfolio Analysis
 
Multi-Party Computation in 2029: Boom, Bust, or Bonanza?
Multi-Party Computation in 2029: Boom, Bust, or Bonanza?Multi-Party Computation in 2029: Boom, Bust, or Bonanza?
Multi-Party Computation in 2029: Boom, Bust, or Bonanza?
 
Artificial+Lift+Market+by+Spears+Q1+15.pptx
Artificial+Lift+Market+by+Spears+Q1+15.pptxArtificial+Lift+Market+by+Spears+Q1+15.pptx
Artificial+Lift+Market+by+Spears+Q1+15.pptx
 
28.05.2012, Staggering costs of inefficient regulation in Mongolia, Olin McGill
28.05.2012, Staggering costs of inefficient regulation in Mongolia, Olin McGill 28.05.2012, Staggering costs of inefficient regulation in Mongolia, Olin McGill
28.05.2012, Staggering costs of inefficient regulation in Mongolia, Olin McGill
 
SearchLove San Diego 2018 | Rob Bucci | Featured Snippets: From Then to Now, ...
SearchLove San Diego 2018 | Rob Bucci | Featured Snippets: From Then to Now, ...SearchLove San Diego 2018 | Rob Bucci | Featured Snippets: From Then to Now, ...
SearchLove San Diego 2018 | Rob Bucci | Featured Snippets: From Then to Now, ...
 
Presentation to O'Connor and Associates Land Forecast 051414
Presentation to O'Connor and Associates Land Forecast 051414Presentation to O'Connor and Associates Land Forecast 051414
Presentation to O'Connor and Associates Land Forecast 051414
 
Oil and Gas Industry Day 2014
Oil and Gas Industry Day 2014Oil and Gas Industry Day 2014
Oil and Gas Industry Day 2014
 
The Power 2Connect
The Power 2ConnectThe Power 2Connect
The Power 2Connect
 
CSB Eece Presentation
CSB Eece PresentationCSB Eece Presentation
CSB Eece Presentation
 
QCon2015 NoSQLWithCachingSearchAndRealTimeAnalytics
QCon2015 NoSQLWithCachingSearchAndRealTimeAnalyticsQCon2015 NoSQLWithCachingSearchAndRealTimeAnalytics
QCon2015 NoSQLWithCachingSearchAndRealTimeAnalytics
 
HSMAI Dialogue Evening - STR Global: Dublin Hotel Pricing and International T...
HSMAI Dialogue Evening - STR Global: Dublin Hotel Pricing and International T...HSMAI Dialogue Evening - STR Global: Dublin Hotel Pricing and International T...
HSMAI Dialogue Evening - STR Global: Dublin Hotel Pricing and International T...
 
Prosperity Scorecard For The Sault
Prosperity Scorecard For The SaultProsperity Scorecard For The Sault
Prosperity Scorecard For The Sault
 
SIMIDoneDeal Quarter4 Motor Industry Review for 2014 2nd feb 2015
SIMIDoneDeal Quarter4 Motor Industry Review for 2014 2nd feb 2015SIMIDoneDeal Quarter4 Motor Industry Review for 2014 2nd feb 2015
SIMIDoneDeal Quarter4 Motor Industry Review for 2014 2nd feb 2015
 
Roadway Impact Fees
Roadway Impact FeesRoadway Impact Fees
Roadway Impact Fees
 

Recently uploaded

5 Warning Signs Your BMW's Intelligent Battery Sensor Needs Attention
5 Warning Signs Your BMW's Intelligent Battery Sensor Needs Attention5 Warning Signs Your BMW's Intelligent Battery Sensor Needs Attention
5 Warning Signs Your BMW's Intelligent Battery Sensor Needs Attention
Bertini's German Motors
 
What Does the Active Steering Malfunction Warning Mean for Your BMW
What Does the Active Steering Malfunction Warning Mean for Your BMWWhat Does the Active Steering Malfunction Warning Mean for Your BMW
What Does the Active Steering Malfunction Warning Mean for Your BMW
Tanner Motors
 
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release CommandsWhy Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Dart Auto
 
Things to remember while upgrading the brakes of your car
Things to remember while upgrading the brakes of your carThings to remember while upgrading the brakes of your car
Things to remember while upgrading the brakes of your car
jennifermiller8137
 
Core technology of Hyundai Motor Group's EV platform 'E-GMP'
Core technology of Hyundai Motor Group's EV platform 'E-GMP'Core technology of Hyundai Motor Group's EV platform 'E-GMP'
Core technology of Hyundai Motor Group's EV platform 'E-GMP'
Hyundai Motor Group
 
What Exactly Is The Common Rail Direct Injection System & How Does It Work
What Exactly Is The Common Rail Direct Injection System & How Does It WorkWhat Exactly Is The Common Rail Direct Injection System & How Does It Work
What Exactly Is The Common Rail Direct Injection System & How Does It Work
Motor Cars International
 
Tyre Industrymarket overview with examples of CEAT
Tyre Industrymarket overview with examples of CEATTyre Industrymarket overview with examples of CEAT
Tyre Industrymarket overview with examples of CEAT
kshamashah95
 
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptxStatistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
coc7987515756
 
Ec330B Lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Ec330B Lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdfEc330B Lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Ec330B Lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Excavator
 
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to TellWondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Vic Auto Collision & Repair
 
一比一原版SDSU毕业证圣地亚哥州立大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版SDSU毕业证圣地亚哥州立大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版SDSU毕业证圣地亚哥州立大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版SDSU毕业证圣地亚哥州立大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
psavhef
 
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
Autohaus Service and Sales
 
Why Isn't Your BMW X5's Comfort Access Functioning Properly Find Out Here
Why Isn't Your BMW X5's Comfort Access Functioning Properly Find Out HereWhy Isn't Your BMW X5's Comfort Access Functioning Properly Find Out Here
Why Isn't Your BMW X5's Comfort Access Functioning Properly Find Out Here
Masters European & Gapanese Auto Repair
 
gtyccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
gtycccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccgtyccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
gtyccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
4thzenzstar
 
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs Consulting SMEs.pptx
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs  Consulting SMEs.pptxEmpowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs  Consulting SMEs.pptx
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs Consulting SMEs.pptx
Precious Mvulane CA (SA),RA
 
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
European Service Center
 
Ec460b lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Ec460b lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdfEc460b lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Ec460b lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Excavator
 
Antique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders Company ProfileAntique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders
 
一比一原版BC毕业证波士顿学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版BC毕业证波士顿学院毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版BC毕业证波士顿学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版BC毕业证波士顿学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
amvovau
 

Recently uploaded (19)

5 Warning Signs Your BMW's Intelligent Battery Sensor Needs Attention
5 Warning Signs Your BMW's Intelligent Battery Sensor Needs Attention5 Warning Signs Your BMW's Intelligent Battery Sensor Needs Attention
5 Warning Signs Your BMW's Intelligent Battery Sensor Needs Attention
 
What Does the Active Steering Malfunction Warning Mean for Your BMW
What Does the Active Steering Malfunction Warning Mean for Your BMWWhat Does the Active Steering Malfunction Warning Mean for Your BMW
What Does the Active Steering Malfunction Warning Mean for Your BMW
 
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release CommandsWhy Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
Why Is Your BMW X3 Hood Not Responding To Release Commands
 
Things to remember while upgrading the brakes of your car
Things to remember while upgrading the brakes of your carThings to remember while upgrading the brakes of your car
Things to remember while upgrading the brakes of your car
 
Core technology of Hyundai Motor Group's EV platform 'E-GMP'
Core technology of Hyundai Motor Group's EV platform 'E-GMP'Core technology of Hyundai Motor Group's EV platform 'E-GMP'
Core technology of Hyundai Motor Group's EV platform 'E-GMP'
 
What Exactly Is The Common Rail Direct Injection System & How Does It Work
What Exactly Is The Common Rail Direct Injection System & How Does It WorkWhat Exactly Is The Common Rail Direct Injection System & How Does It Work
What Exactly Is The Common Rail Direct Injection System & How Does It Work
 
Tyre Industrymarket overview with examples of CEAT
Tyre Industrymarket overview with examples of CEATTyre Industrymarket overview with examples of CEAT
Tyre Industrymarket overview with examples of CEAT
 
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptxStatistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
Statistics5,c.xz,c.;c.;d.c;d;ssssss.pptx
 
Ec330B Lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Ec330B Lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdfEc330B Lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Ec330B Lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
 
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to TellWondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
Wondering if Your Mercedes EIS is at Fault Here’s How to Tell
 
一比一原版SDSU毕业证圣地亚哥州立大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版SDSU毕业证圣地亚哥州立大学毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版SDSU毕业证圣地亚哥州立大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版SDSU毕业证圣地亚哥州立大学毕业证成绩单如何办理
 
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
What Does the PARKTRONIC Inoperative, See Owner's Manual Message Mean for You...
 
Why Isn't Your BMW X5's Comfort Access Functioning Properly Find Out Here
Why Isn't Your BMW X5's Comfort Access Functioning Properly Find Out HereWhy Isn't Your BMW X5's Comfort Access Functioning Properly Find Out Here
Why Isn't Your BMW X5's Comfort Access Functioning Properly Find Out Here
 
gtyccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
gtycccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccgtyccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
gtyccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccccc
 
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs Consulting SMEs.pptx
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs  Consulting SMEs.pptxEmpowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs  Consulting SMEs.pptx
Empowering Limpopo Entrepreneurs Consulting SMEs.pptx
 
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
What Causes 'Trans Failsafe Prog' to Trigger in BMW X5
 
Ec460b lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Ec460b lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdfEc460b lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
Ec460b lc Excavator Volvo Service Repair.pdf
 
Antique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders Company ProfileAntique Plastic Traders Company Profile
Antique Plastic Traders Company Profile
 
一比一原版BC毕业证波士顿学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版BC毕业证波士顿学院毕业证成绩单如何办理一比一原版BC毕业证波士顿学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
一比一原版BC毕业证波士顿学院毕业证成绩单如何办理
 

E toll presentation Wayne Duvenage TruckX

  • 1. The  ‘endless’  E-­‐Toll  Saga     and  other  interes4ng  facts   Wayne  Duvenage   OUTA  -­‐  Chairperson  
  • 2. Breaking  the  myths  about  OUTA  &  E-­‐Tolls   Dispel  SANRAL’s  Claims  of  six  court  wins                  18  months  of  A"ri%on  Through  Lawfare   Why  did  OUTA  launch?   E-­‐Toll  Discussions…   Staying  the  course  and  why  we  had  to   What  we  discovered…  
  • 3. E-­‐Toll  Revenue  (&  “Forecasts”)   !"!!!! !50.0!! !100.0!! !150.0!! !200.0!! !250.0!! !300.0!! !350.0!! 1! 2! 3! 4! 5! 6! 7! 8! 9! 10! 11! 12! 13! 14! 15! 16! 17! 18! 19! 20! 21! 22! 23! 24! 25! 26! 27! 28! 29! 30!Dec$13 Jan$14 Feb$14 Mar$14 Apr$14 May$14 Jun$14 Jul$14 Aug$14 Sep$14 Oct$14 Nov$14 Dec$14 Jan$15 Feb$15 Mar$15 Apr$15 May$15 Jun$15 Jul$15 Aug$15 Sep$15 Oct$15 Nov$15 Dec$15 Jan$16 Feb$16 Mar$16 Apr$16 May$16 RANDS    x  Millions   Launched  3  Dec  2013   COURT  PROCESS  IN  2012  &  2013  SANRAL  SAID:   1.  COMPLIANCE  will  be  93%.   2.  Average  Revenue  of  R260  mil  /  month  achievable  
  • 4. !"!!!! !50.0!! !100.0!! !150.0!! !200.0!! !250.0!! !300.0!! !350.0!! 1! 2! 3! 4! 5! 6! 7! 8! 9! 10! 11! 12! 13! 14! 15! 16! 17! 18! 19! 20! 21! 22! 23! 24! 25! 26! 27! 28! 29! 30! E-­‐Toll  Revenue  (&  “Forecasts”)   Projec4on  for  success  (OUTA)   Dec$13 Jan$14 Feb$14 Mar$14 Apr$14 May$14 Jun$14 Jul$14 Aug$14 Sep$14 Oct$14 Nov$14 Dec$14 Jan$15 Feb$15 Mar$15 Apr$15 May$15 Jun$15 Jul$15 Aug$15 Sep$15 Oct$15 Nov$15 Dec$15 Jan$16 Feb$16 Mar$16 Apr$16 May$16 Actual  Revenue  (SANRAL)   Forecasts  Revenue  (SANRAL)  
  • 5. !"!!!! !50.0!! !100.0!! !150.0!! !200.0!! !250.0!! !300.0!! !350.0!! 1! 2! 3! 4! 5! 6! 7! 8! 9! 10! 11! 12! 13! 14! 15! 16! 17! 18! 19! 20! 21! 22! 23! 24! 25! 26! 27! 28! 29! 30! E-­‐Toll  Revenue  (&  “Forecasts”)   Projec4on  for  success  (OUTA)   Dec$13 Jan$14 Feb$14 Mar$14 Apr$14 May$14 Jun$14 Jul$14 Aug$14 Sep$14 Oct$14 Nov$14 Dec$14 Jan$15 Feb$15 Mar$15 Apr$15 May$15 Jun$15 Jul$15 Aug$15 Sep$15 Oct$15 Nov$15 Dec$15 Jan$16 Feb$16 Mar$16 Apr$16 May$16 Actual  Revenue  (SANRAL)   Forecasts  Revenue  (SANRAL)  
  • 6. SANRAL’s  Discount    Dispensa4on…    Moun4ng  Public  Anxiety   OUTA  Refuses  to  go  away…   E-­‐Toll  Defense  Umbrella   New  internal  legal  capacity   Defend  every  OUTA  member     OUTA  Revises  strategy  –  Sep  2015…   OUTA  REVISES  STRATEGY  FOR  LEGAL  DEVELOPMENTS  
  • 7. Threats  of  Vehicle  Lis4ngs  (?)  &  Summonses   Sanral  begins  to  issue  6,000  summonses   Jan  2016  –  Dispensa4on  failing  fast   May  2016:  New  Dispensa4on  <R150m  of  R5,9b   OUTA  defends  all  its  summonsed  members   Current  li4ga4on  developments    
  • 8. In  Feb  2016:  OUTA  expands  mandate   OPPOSITION  TO  URBAN  TOLLING  ALLIANCE   ORGANISATION  UNDOING  TAX  ABUSE   WHY?   TO  
  • 9. Many  ques4ons  raised  around  tax  policy    Carbon  Tax,  Sugar  Taxes    Tyre  Recycling  Taxes       Many  ques4ons  around  maladministra4on   &  /  Corrup4on    SAA,    Eskom,    Prasa,  SABC   SOE  accoun4ng  prac4ces  enables  more   borrowing…        Increased  cost  of  infrastructure  in  SA…  
  • 10. 2004$ 2005$ 2006$ 2007$ 2008$ 2009$ 2010$ 2011$ 2012$ 2013$ 2014$ 2015$ Debt$Ra2o's$$ 1.234856856$1.178158303$1.185716064$1.219998469$0.516794454$1.026106071$0.232479401$0.246719604$0.260951841$0.250963373$0.252289173$0.288061201$ Total$Assets$ 7780782000$9076108000$8999830000$9826332000$12444495000$30603724000$1.87174E+11$2.2049E+11$2.69265E+11$2.76296E+11$3.10992E+11$3.25469E+11$ Total$Liabili2es$9608152000$10693092000$10671243000$11988110000$14328202000$31402667000$43514132000$54399317000$70265150000$69340215000$78459898000$93754925000$ R0$ R50,000,000,000$ R100,000,000,000$ R150,000,000,000$ R200,000,000,000$ R250,000,000,000$ R300,000,000,000$ R350,000,000,000$ $SANRAL:$Total$Liabili2es$To$Total$Assets$ Rands  x  Billion   SANRAL’s:    Total  Assets  to  Liabili4es  
  • 11.  -­‐          100,000      200,000      300,000      400,000      500,000      600,000      700,000     2005   2006   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   2014*   2015*   2016   Eskom  Total  Assets  to  Total  Liabilites   Total  assets   Total  liabili4es   RANDS  x  Billions  
  • 12.  -­‐          100,000      200,000      300,000      400,000      500,000      600,000      700,000     2005   2006   2007   2008   2009   2010   2011   2012   2013   2014*   2015*   2016   Eskom  Total  Assets  to  Total  Liabilites   Total  assets   Total  liabili4es   RANDS  x  Billions   Total  ProducIon  (GwH)   Coal  Burn  (Mt)   122   119   125   231   237   215   218  218   225   0   50   100   150   200   250   Sales  (GwH)   39   137   Sales  (R’bn)    50    75   100       125       150    25    
  • 13. The  QuesIon  of  Road  ConstrucIon  Costs  in  SA     Gauteng  Freeway  Improvement  Project   -­‐  185  km  =  R17,9  bn   -­‐  Just  under  R100m  /  KM   -­‐  An  addi4onal  lane  each  direc4on  +  3  /  4  lanes  resurfaced   OUTA  Research  in  Feb  2016  –  shows  serious  concerns   Why  would  this  be  a  concern?       -­‐  E-­‐Tolls  more  irra4onal  
  • 14. GFIP   Addis-­‐Ababa  –  Adama  (85km)   AWer  Before   Before   AWer  
  • 15. GFIP   Nairobi-­‐Thika  SuperHighway  (50km)   AWer  Before   Before   AWer  
  • 16. GFIP   Grand  Parkway  to  SH6  –  Texas  (11km)   AWer  Before   AWer  Before  
  • 17. The  Cost  of  Road  Construc4on  in  SA   Cost  comparison  for  GFIP  and  Other   0   1000   2000   3000   4000   5000   6000   GFIP   Addis  Ababa-­‐Adama   Expressway   Nairobi-­‐Thika   Expressway   Grand  Parkway  to   SH6  Texas   N3  Future  Upgrades   Cost  /  m²   GFIP   Addis  Ababa-­‐Adama  Expressway   Nairobi-­‐Thika  Expressway   Grand  Parkway  to  SH6  Texas   N3  Future  Upgrades  
  • 18. N3  Upgrade  –  Durban  to  Cedara  /  Pmb  (84km)   PMB   DURBAN  
  • 19. N3  Upgrade  –  Durban  to  Cedara  /  Pmb  (84km)  
  • 20. The  Cost  of  Road  Construc4on  in  SA   Cost  comparison  for  GFIP  and  Other   0   1000   2000   3000   4000   5000   6000   GFIP   Addis  Ababa-­‐Adama   Expressway   Nairobi-­‐Thika   Expressway   Grand  Parkway  to   SH6  Texas   N3  Future  Upgrades   Cost  /  m²   GFIP   Addis  Ababa-­‐Adama  Expressway   Nairobi-­‐Thika  Expressway   Grand  Parkway  to  SH6  Texas   N3  Future  Upgrades   ?  
  • 21. Harrismith  will  loose  Est.   R1bn  /  annum  pa  (1,5m  cars)   98  Km  New  4  Lane  Freeway     to  save  14km  ???     Road  will  cost  est  R10bn   Toll  costs  will  negate  the   14km  Saving   Alterna4ve  shortening  and   safer  alignments  best   op4on   Swinburne  &  Van  Reenen   Pass  nodes  die