Literature Reviews analysis

1. Content analysis and
Developing taxonomies

2. Steps
1
• Identify topic
• Identify keywords and combination of keywords
2
• Identify database
• Identify journals (top tier journals in the area)
3
• Search databases/journals
• Set limit (eg year, language)
4
• Search databases/journals
• Set limit (eg year, language
5
• Download abstract
• Check duplication
Read and Analyse the
content

3. Identify
databases
Identify
keywords
Content analysis
Consolidation of
analysis
Search database
Categories by
themes
Identify themes
for analysis
Classifications of articles process

4. Illustration of article content
analysis

5. Journal Year
Authou
r(s)
Objective(
s)/ RQ
Type
of SM
Constructs/T
heory
SC Dimension
from
Methodology
(Country) Findings
Limitations/ Future
Research
Journal of
Computer
-Mediated
Communi
cation
2009 Sebastia
n
Valenzu
ela
Namsu
Park
Kerk F.
Kee
The
purpose
of this
study was
to explore
whether
college
students’
use of
Facebook
was
related
with their
stock of
social
capital, a
construct
that
includes
intraperso
nal,
interperso
nal, and
behavioral
elements
Facebo
ok
civic
participation,
political
engagement,
life
satisfaction,
and social
trust
Refered much
to Putnam
(2000)
Quantitative.
Using data from
a random web
survey of college
students across
Texas (US) (n = 2,
603).
Respondents’
civic and political
participation was
gauged using a
reduced form
of the Index of
Civic and Political
Engagement
developed by
CIRCLE
(Andolina,
Keeter, Zukin, &
Jenkins, 2003),
an organization
that has
conducted
several national
surveys related
to youth
engagement.
contribution
made
by Facebook
use to these
two
components of
social capital
(life satisfaction
and social trust)
was small but
statistically
significant.
intensity of
Facebook use
was positively
associated with
life satisfaction
and social trust.
Facebook use
had a stronger
relationship
with life
satisfaction
than with social
Future research
could explore the
contribution of
other Facebook
applications, such as
messaging services,
on individuals’
production
of social
capital.other users’
characteristics (e.g.,
personality traits)
that were not
measured here could
discriminate better
for which groups the
association between
social capital by
using the social
network site are
stronger and/or
weaker.

6. Article Information
• Title
• Author
• Journal
• Volume
• Year of publication

7. Decide the themes
• Unit of Analysis
• Area of study (general, individual,
organization, disciplines)
• Theory or Framework used in the Study
• Methodology used
• Data Analysis technique used
• Origin of the Study

8. illustration
• analyse articles in journals related to social media and
subsequently to categorise them based on themes
• six main keywords were identified: Social Media, Social
Network, Social Networking Sites, Web 2.0, Facebook
and Twitter.
• In addition, in order to get a greater analysis of
relevant articles, several combinations of the keywords
(with the help of Boolean operands) were also used.
Twenty combinations were used to search for the
articles.
• 295 articles were choose and downloaded

9. Journal No
Computers in Human Behaviour 40
Public Relations Review 22
J. of Computer-Mediated Communications 10
Business Horizon 7
CAIS, J. of Adolescent Health, Computers & Education, Procedia Social &
Behavioral Sciences,
6
AIS THCI, Internet & Higher Education 5
J. of Interactive Advertising, Government Information Quarterly, Cyber
4
Psychology & Behavior
MISQ, Information & Management, The Learning Organization, I.J of
Hospitality Management, I. J. of Information Management, J. of Consumer
Behaviour, Information, Communication & Society, Cyberpsychology,
Behavior, and soc. networking, IJMM, DSS
3
List of journals where articles were published

10. Category
Frequency
*
Unit of analysis
Students 86
Individuals (Youth, Employees, PR Practitioner,
57
Journalist, Scholars, Entrepreneurs)
SM sites 31
SM users 43
Organization SM pages 12
Organization (Key persons as respondents
17
representing organizations)
Total 246

11. Category
Area of study
No. of
studies
Percentage
Usage 161 55
Social issues 113 38
Security & Privacy 11 4
Others 10 3
Total 295 100%

12. Theories used / adopted
Theory/Framework
No. of
studies
Technology Acceptance Model
(TAM)
15
Uses and Gratification Theory 14
Social Capital Theory 8
Five Factor Model/Big Five
6
Framework
Dialogic Theory 5
Hofstede Framework 4

13. Methodology used
Category Frequency
Mixed method 42
Quantitative
Survey 119
Experiment 17
Action Research 1
Qualitative
Interview/ case study/focus groups 38
Netnography 3
Web Content Analysis 38
Literature Review 29
Conceptual Paper 8
Total 295

14. Dependent variables
Category Frequency
Usage 23
Intention 15
Impact 7
User Behavior 5
Attitude 4
Political participation 3
Self-disclosure 3
Well being 2
Life satisfaction 2
Continuance intention 1
Social capital 1

15. Origin of study
Developing Countries Frequency
Africa (Egypt and South Africa) 12
America (Canada, Chile, Mexico) 10
Western Asia (Saudi Arabia, Israel and Turkey) 11
Southern Asia (India, Iran and Pakistan) 6
South Easthern Asia (Malaysia, Thailand, Singapore) 10
Easthern Asia (China, Hong Kong, Taiwan) 13
Jamaica 1
Total 63
Developed Countries Frequency
America (USA) 156
Europe (France, Germany, Netherlands, Switzerland, Greece, Spain,
13
Romania, Finland, Ireland)
20
Australia 9
New Zealand 3
Japan 4
Total 205
Multiple Countries 26
Total 294

16. Taxonomy is a form of classification
• Taxonomies play an important role in research
and management because the classification of
objects helps researchers and practitioners
understand and analyze complex domains.
• taxonomies provide a structure and an
organization to the knowledge of a field, thus
enabling researchers to study the
relationships among concepts and, therefore,
to hypothesize about these relationships.

17. Theories/
Model/
Guidelines
Authour
/Year
Unit of
Analysi
s
I/O
Place
Anne Marie Warren (CHA110011)
Constructs
Tec
h
Gov
/
Reg
/
Pol.
Info.
Seek.
Social
Int.
Sharin
g
Info/
Intend
Shar
ed
value
s/
cultu
re
Trust Entertai-nment Status Others
Marketing
Strategies : 5
Axioms
Berthon
et al.
2012
- X X X
U&G theory
Social cognitive
theories
Lee& Ma
2012
I
(uni
stud.)
Sing.
X X X X X Prior social media
sharing experience
Social
information
processing
theory
Wester
man et
al. 2012
I
(users)
US
X Followers
Follows
Creditability (Trust)
U.S. federal
government
regulatory
framework
Bertot et
al.
2012
O (gov)
US
X Access and
social inclusion;
privacy, security,
accuracy, and
archiving; governing
and
governance
Supporting Theories/Models/Guidelines for Social Media Usage & Factors

18. S. Ramnath et al. / International Journal of Forecasting 24 (2008) 34–75
Selected Papers Addressing Questions Related to Analysts' Decision Processes
Reference Method Key result
Chung and Jo (1996) Archival, I/B/E/S, 1984-1987. Analyst following has a positive
impact on firm value, and
analysts tend to follow stocks
of high quality firms.
Block (1999) Questionnaire survey of
members of AIMR.
46% of respondents said that
present value analysis is not part
of their normal procedures.
Analysts considered earnings and
cash flow to be far more
important than dividends and
book value in security valuation.
However, analysts rely more
heavily on earnings multiples
versus DCF in valuation, and
growth potential and earnings
quality are the crucial factors in
evaluating P/E ratios.

19. A method for taxonomy development and its application in information systems
Robert C Nickerson, Upkar Varshney and Jan Muntermann
Table 8. Taxonomy of mobile applications
Applications Temporal Communication Transaction Access
S AS INF RP INT T NT PU PR
Mobile voice
communication
s
X X X X
Mobile
messaging
X X X X
Mobile TV X X X X
Purchasing
location-based
contents
X X X X
Mobile
inventory
management
X X X X
Product
location and
tracking
X X X X
Mobile
advertisement
X X X X

20. Problem Context Theory Model Method Time Unit (quaN. / quaL/ Mixed)
Citation
Old
New/Novel/
Community Interest
Single
Multiple
Single
Multiple
New
Incremental Innovation
Modular Innovation
Architectural Innovation
Radical Innovation
Single
Multiple
Integrated / New
One
Intervals
Series
Individual
Group
Organization
Enterprise
Industry
Nation
Region
World
Steinfiel
d, et al.
[1]
X X X X X X N
Young
[2]
X X
X X
X
X
M
Angelle
&Rose[3
]
X X X X L
Anne Marie Warren (CHA110011)

21. Summary On Major Literature On End-User Information Systems Satisfaction
Reference IS Application Usage Theory Population
Direct antecedents to user
satisfaction
Result
(R.-D. Chang, Chang,
& Paper, 2003)
Accounting
information
systems N/S
Contingency
Theory
125
Manager
from cross-industry
in
Taiwan
System characteristic:
scope
timeliness
aggregation
Sig.+
Sig.+
Sig.+
(Negash, Ryan, &
Igbaria, 2003)
Web-based
customer
support
systems
N/S
IS Success
model
726
university
students in
USA
Information quality
System quality
service quality
Sig.+
Sig.+
Sig.+
(Calisir & Calisir,
2004)
Enterprise
Resource
Planning
System
N/S
IS Success
model
20 ERP
system end-users
in
Turkey
Perceived usefulness
Learnability
Sig.+
Sig.+
(Chu, Hsiao, Lee, &
Chen, 2004)
Government
Electronic
Tendering
System
N/S
Theory of
Planned
Behavior
158 Syatem
users in
Taiwan
Perceived Ease of Use
Perceived Usefulness
Accuracy
N/Sig..
Sig.+
Sig.+
(Avlonitis &
Panagopoulos, 2005)
Customer
Relationship
Management
N/S
Technology
Acceptance
Model
IS Success
model
240 sales
managers in
Greek
Perceived Ease-of-use
Perceived Usefulness
Sig.+
Sig.+
Manal Sharabati

22. Social Capital Definitions Anne Marie Warren (CHA110011)
Bourdieu and Wacquant (cited in Resnick,
2001; Williams, 2006)
“the sum of the resouces, acutal or virtual,
that accrue to an individual or a gorup by
cirtue of possessing a durable network of
more or less institutionalized relationships of
mutual acquaintance in recognition.”
Shailendra C Jain Palvia; Rudy Pancaro
(2010)
“Social capital broadly refers to the resouces
accumilated through the relationships among
people.”
Zuniga (2012)
antecedent of behavior that is oriented
toward the public good, either at the
community or the political
level.