SlideShare a Scribd company logo
+RZDUG3KLOOLSV/RYHFUDIWDQG+D]HO+HDOG
3XEOLVKHG-XOLQ:HLUG7DOHV1R
,7:$6ODQJXLGFXULRXVLWZKLFKILUVWEURXJKW6WHSKHQ-RQHVWR
0XVHXP6RPHRQHKDGWROGKLPDERXWWKHTXHHUXQGHUJURXQGSO
6RXWKZDUN6WUHHWDFURVVWKHULYHUZKHUHZD[HQWKLQJVVRPXFKP
WKDQWKHZRUVWHIILJLHVDW0DGDPH7XVVDXGߞVZHUHVKRZQDQGKH
RQH$SULOGDWRVHHKRZGLVDSSRLQWLQJKHZRXOGILQGLW2GGO
GLVDSSRLQWHG7KHUHZDVVRPHWKLQJGLIIHUHQWDQGGLVWLQFWLYHKHUH
FRXUVHWKHXVXDOJRUFRPPRQSODFHVZHUHSUHVHQWߚ/DQGUX'R
0DGDPH'HPHUV5L]]LR/DG-DQH*UHHQGOHVVPDLPHGYLFWL
UHYROXWLRQDQGPRQVWHUVOLNH*LOOHVGH5DLVDQG0DUTXLVGH6DG
ZHUHRWKHUWKLQJVZKLFKKDGPDGHKLPEUHDWKHIDVWHUDQGVWDWLO
WKHFORVLQJEHOO7KHPDQZKRKDGIDVKLRQHGWKLVFROOHFWLRQFRXO
PRXQWHEDQN7KHUHZDVLPDJLQDWLRQߚHYHQDNLQGRIGLVHDVHGJ
RIWKLVVWXII
/DWHUKHKDGOHDUQHGDERXW*HRUJH5RJHUV7KHPDQKDGEHHQRQ
VWDIIEXWVRPHWURXEOHKDGGHYHORSHGZKLFKOHGWRKLVGLVFKDUJH
DVSHUVLRQVRQKLVVDQLWDQGWDOHVRIKLVFUD]IRUPVRIVHFUHWZR
ODWWHUOKLVVXFFHVVZLWKKLVRZQEDVHPHQWPXVHXPKDGGXOOHGWK
FULWLFLVPVZKLOHVKDUSHQLQJWKHLQVLGLRXVSRLQWRIRWKHUV7HUDWRO
LFRQRJUDSKRIQLJKWPDUHZHUHKLVKREELHVDQGHYHQKHKDGKDG
VFUHHQRIIVRPHRIKLVZRUVWHIILJLHVLQDVSHFLDODOFROYHIRUDGXO
WKLVDOFROYHZKLFKKDGIDVFLQDWHG-RQHVVRPXFK7KHUHZHUHOXP
WKLQJVZKLFKRQOIDQWDVFRXOGVSDZQPROGHGZLWKGHYLOLVKVN
LQDKRUULEOOLIHOLNHIDVKLRQ
6RPHZHUHWKHILJXUHVRIZHOONQRZQPWKߚJRUJRQVFKLPHUDV
FFORSVDQGDOOWKHLUVKXGGHUVRPHFRQJHQHUV2WKHUVZHUHGUDZ
DQGPRUHIXUWLYHOZKLVSHUHGFFOHVRIVXEWHUUDQHDQOHJHQGߚEO
7VDWKRJJXDPDQWHQWDFOHGWKXOKXSURERVFLGLDQKDXJQDU)D
UXPRUHGEODVSKHPLHVIURPIRUELGGHQERRNVOLNHWKH1HFURQRPLF
(LERQRUWKH8QDXVVSUHFKOLFKHQ.XOWHQRIYRQ-XQ]W%XWWKHZ
RULJLQDOZLWK5RJHUVDQGUHSUHVHQWHGVKDSHVZKLFKQRWDOHRIDQ
GDUHGWRVXJJHVW6HYHUDOZHUHKLGHRXVSDURGLHVRQIRUPVRIRUJ
NQRZZKLOHRWKHUVVHHPHGWREHWDNHQIURPIHYHULVKGUHDPVRIR
JDOD[LHV7KHZLOGHUSDLQWHGRIODUN$VKWRQ6PLWKPLJKWVXJJH
6WHSKHQ-RQHVDVDOHLVXUHOFRQQRLVVHXURIWKHEL]DUUHLQDUWKD
5RJHUVKLPVHOILQWKHGLQJRIILFHDQGZRUNURRPEHKLQGWKHYDX
FKDPEHUߚDQHYLOORRNLQJFUSWOLJKWHGGLPOEGXVWZLQGRZV
KRUL]RQWDOLQWKHEULFNZDOORQDOHYHOZLWKWKHDQFLHQWFREEOHVWR
FRXUWDUG,WZDVKHUHWKDWWKHLPDJHVZHUHUHSDLUHGߚKHUHWRR
WKHPKDGEHHQPDGH:D[HQDUPVOHJVKHDGVDQGWRUVRVODLQ
RQYDULRXVEHQFKHVZKLOHRQKLJKWLHUVRIVKHOYHVPDWWHGZLJVU
ORRNLQJWHHWKDQGJODVVVWDULQJHHVZHUHLQGLVFULPLQDWHOVFDW
RIDOOVRUWVKXQJIURPKRRNVDQGLQRQHDOFRYHZHUHJUHDWSLOHV
ZD[FDNHVDQGVKHOYHVILOOHGZLWKSDLQWFDQVDQGEUXVKHVRIHYHU
WKHFHQWHURIWKHURRPZDVDODUJHPHOWLQJIXUQDFHXVHGWRSUHSD
PROGLQJLWVILUHER[WRSSHGEDKXJHLURQFRQWDLQHURQKLQJHV
ZKLFKSHUPLWWHGWKHSRXULQJRIPHOWHGZD[ZLWKWKHPHUHVWWRXF
2WKHUWKLQJVLQWKHGLVPDOFUSWZHUHOHVVGHVFULEDEOHߚLVRODWHG
SUREOHPDWLFDOHQWLWLHVZKRVHDVVHPEOHGIRUPVZHUHWKHSKDQWRP
$WRQHHQGZDVDGRRURIKHDYSODQNIDVWHQHGEDQXQXVXDOO
DQGZLWKDYHUSHFXOLDUVPEROSDLQWHGRYHULW-RQHZKRKDGR
WRWKHGUHDGHG1HFURQRPLFRQVKLYHUHGLQYROXQWDULODVKHUHFRJ
VPERO7KLVVKRZPDQKHUHIOHFWHGPXVWLQGHHGEHDSHUVRQRI
ZLGHVFKRODUVKLSLQGDUNDQGGXELRXVILHOGV
1RUGLGWKHFRQYHUVDWLRQRI5RJHUVGLVDSSRLQWKLP7KHPDQZD
UDWKHUXQNHPSWZLWKODUJHEODFNHHVZKLFKJD]HGFRPEXVWLYHO
DQGXVXDOOVWXEEOHFRYHUHGIDFH+HGLGQRWUHVHQW-RQHVߞLQWUXV
WRZHOFRPHWKHFKDQFHRIXQEXUGHQLQJKLPVHOIWRDQLQWHUHVWHGS
ZDVRIVLQJXODUGHSWKDQGUHVRQDQFHDQGKDUERUHGDVRUWRIUHSU
ERUGHULQJRQWKHIHYHULVK-RQHVGLGQRWZRQGHUWKDWPDQKDGWK
:LWKHYHUVXFFHVVLYHFDOOߚDQGVXFKFDOOVEHFDPHDKDELWDVWKH
ߚ-RQHVKDGIRXQG5RJHUVPRUHFRPPXQLFDWLYHDQGFRQILGHQWLD
WKHUHKDGEHHQKLQWVRIVWUDQJHIDLWKVDQGSUDFWLFHVRQWKHVKRZP
ODWHURQWKRVHKLQWVH[SDQGHGLQWRWDOHVߚGHVSLWHDIHZRGGFRUUR
SKRWRJUDSKVߚZKRVHH[WUDYDJHQFHZDVDOPRVWFRPLF,WZDVVRP
RQDQLJKWZKHQ-RQHVKDGEURXJKWDERWWOHRIJRRGZKLVNDQGS
LVODQGVRIWKH6RXWK3DFLILFSOXVFODLPVRIKDYLQJUHDGVXFKPRQ
IDEXORXVERRNVDVWKHSUHKLVWRULF3QDNRWLFIUDJPHQWVDQGWKH'K
DWWULEXWHGWRPDOLJQDQGQRQKXPDQ/HQJߚEXWQRWKLQJLQDOOWKL
XQPLVWDNDEOLQVDQHDVZKDWKDGFURSSHGRXWWKDW-XQHHYHQLQJ
RIWKHZKLVN
7REHSODLQ5RJHUVEHJDQPDNLQJYDXJHERDVWVRIKDYLQJIRXQG
QDWXUHWKDWQRRQHKDGIRXQGEHIRUHDQGRIKDYLQJEURXJKWEDFN
HYLGHQFHVRIVXFKGLVFRYHULHV$FFRUGLQJWRKLVELEXORXVKDUDQJ
IDUWKHUWKDQDQRQHHOVHLQLQWHUSUHWLQJWKHREVFXUHDQGSULPDOE
DQGKDGEHHQGLUHFWHGEWKHPWRFHUWDLQUHPRWHSODFHVZKHUHVW
DUHKLGGHQߚVXUYLYDOVRIഊRQVDQGOLIHFFOHVHDUOLHUWKDQPDQN
VRPHFDVHFRQQHFWHGZLWKRWKHUGLPHQVLRQVDQGRWKHUZRUOGVFR
ZLWKZKLFKZDVIUHTXHQWLQWKHIRUJRWWHQSUHKXPDQGDV-RQHV
IDQFZKLFKFRXOGFRQMXUHXSVXFKQRWLRQVDQGZRQGHUHGMXVWZ
PHQWDOKLVWRUKDGEHHQ+DGKLVZRUNDPLGVWWKHPRUELGJURWHV
0DGDPH7XVVDXGߞVEHHQWKHVWDUWRIKLVLPDJLQDWLYHIOLJKWVRUZ
LQQDWHVRWKDWKLVFKRLFHRIRFFXSDWLRQZDVPHUHORQHRILWVPD
DQUDWHWKHPDQߞVZRUNZDVPHUHOYHUFORVHOOLQNHGZLWKKL
QRZWKHUHZDVQRPLVWDNLQJWKHWUHQGRIKLVEODFNHVWKLQWVDERXW
PRQVWURVLWLHVLQWKHVFUHHQHGRIIߡ$GXOWVRQOߢDOFRYH+HHGOHVV
ZDVWULQJWRLPSOWKDWQRWDOORIWKHVHGHPRQLDFDEQRUPDOLWLHV
,WZDV-RQHVߞIUDQNVFHSWLFLVPDQGDPXVHPHQWDWWKHVHLUUHVSRQV
ZKLFKEURNHXSWKHJURZLQJFRUGLDOLW5RJHUVLWZDVFOHDUWRRN
VHULRXVOIRUKHQRZEHFDPHPRURVHDQGUHVHQWIXOFRQWLQXLQJW
RQOWKURXJKDGRJJHGXUJHWREUHDNGRZQKLVZDOORIXUEDQHDQ
LQFUHGXOLW:LOGWDOHVDQGVXJJHVWLRQVRIULWHVDQGVDFULILFHVWRQ
JRGVFRQWLQXHGDQGQRZDQGWKHQ5RJHUVZRXOGOHDGKLVJXHVWW
KLGHRXVEODVKSKHPLHVLQWKHVFUHHQRIIDOFROYHDQGSRLQWRXWIHD
UHFRQFLOHZLWKHYHQWKHILQHVWKXPDQFUDIWVPDQVKLS-RQHVFRQWLQ
WKURXJKVKHHUIDVFLQDWLRQWKRXJKKHNQHZKHKDGIRUIHLWHGKLVK
WLPHVKHZRXOGKXPRU5RJHUVZLWKSUHWHQGHGDVVHQWWRVRPHPD
DVVHUWLRQEXWWKHJDXQWVKRZPDQZDVVHOGRPWREHGHFHLYHGE
7KHWHQVLRQFDPHWRDKHDGODWHULQ6HSWHPEHU-RQHVKDGFDVXDOO
QHUYRXVODVWKHHFKRHVUHYHUEHUDWHGWKURXJKWKHJUHDWYDXOWHGE
WKUHHDWWHQGDQWVH[FKDQJHGRGGJODQFHVDQGRQHRIWKHPDGDUN
IRUHLJQORRNLQJIHOORZZKRDOZDVVHUYHG5RJHUVDVDUHSDLUHUD
GHVLJQHUVPLOHGLQDZDZKLFKVHHPHGWRSX]]OHKLVFROOHDJXHV
JUDWHGYHUKDUVKORQVRPHIDFHWRI-RQHVߞVHQVLELOLWLHV,WZDVW
VFUHDPRIDGRJDQGZDVVXFKDVRXQGDVFRXOGEHPDGHRQOXQ
RIWKHXWPRVWIULJKWDQGDJRQFRPELQHG,WVVWDUNDQJXLVHGIUHQ
DSSDOOLQJWRKHDUDQGLQWKLVVHWWLQJRIJURWHVTXHDEQRUPDOLWLWK
KLGHRXVQHVV-RQHVUHPHPEHUHGWKDWQRGRJVZHUHDOORZHGLQWK
+HZDVDERXWWRJRWRWKHGRRUOHDGLQJLQWRWKHZRUNURRPZKHQ
DWWHQGDQWVWRSSHGKLPZLWKDZRUGDQGDJHVWXUH0U5RJHUVWK
VRIWVRPHZKDWDFFHQWHGYRLFHDWRQFHDSRORJHWLFDQGYDJXHOVD
DQGWKHUHZHUHVWDQGLQJRUGHUVWRDGPLWQRRQHWRWKHZRUNURRP
DEVHQFH$VIRUWKDWHOSLWZDVXQGRXEWHGOVRPHWKLQJRXWLQWK
EHKLQGWKHPXVHXP7KLVQHLJKERUKRRGZDVIXOORIVWUDPRQJUH
ILJKWVZHUHVRPHWLPHVVKRFNLQJOQRLV7KHUHZHUHQRGRJVLQ
PXVHXP%XWLI0U-RQHVZLVKHGWRVHH0U5RJHUVKHPLJKWILQ
EHIRUHFORVLQJWLPH
$IWHUWKLV-RQHVFOLPEHGWKHROGVWRQHVWHSVWRWKHVWUHHWRXWVLGH
WKHVTXDOLGQHLJKERUKRRGFXULRXVO7KHOHDQLQJGHFUHSLWEXLOGL
GZHOOLQJVEXWQRZODUJHOVKRSVDQGZDUHKRXVHVߚZHUHYHUDQ
6RPHRIWKHPZHUHRIDJDEOHGWSHVHHPLQJWRJREDFNWR7XGR
IDLQWPLDVPDWLFVWHQFKKXQJVXEWODERXWWKHZKROHUHJLRQ%HVL
KRXVHZKRVHEDVHPHQWKHOGWKHPXVHXPZDVDORZDUFKZDSLHU
FREEOHGDOOHDQGWKLV-RQHVHQWHUHGLQDYDJXHZLVKWRILQGWKH
WKHZRUNURRPDQGVHWWOHWKHDIIDLURIWKHGRJFRPIRUWDEOLQKLV
FRXUWDUGZDVGLPLQWKHODWHDIWHUQRRQOLJKWKHPPHGLQEUHDU
XJOLHUDQGPRUHLQWDQJLEOPHQDFLQJWKDQWKHFUXPEOLQJIDFDGHV
KRXVHV1RWDGRJZDVLQVLJKWDQG-RQHVZRQGHUHGKRZWKHDIWH
IUDQWLFWXUPRLOFRXOGKDYHFRPSOHWHOYDQLVKHGVRVRRQ
'HVSLWHWKHDVVLVWDQWߞVVWDWHPHQWWKDWQRGRJKDGEHHQLQWKHPXV
JODQFHGQHUYRXVODWWKHWKUHHVPDOOZLQGRZVRIWKHEDVHPHQWZ
QDUURZKRUL]RQWDOUHFWDQJOHVFORVHWRWKHJUDVVJURZQSDYHPHQW
RQWKHFKDQFHWKDWWKHWKLFNJUHHQVKDGHVZRUNHGEORQJFRUGV
WRDUHDFKDEOHOHYHOPLJKWQRWEHGUDZQ7KHRXWHUVXUIDFHVZHU
EXWDVKHUXEEHGWKHPZLWKKLVKDQGNHUFKLHIKHVDZWKHUHZDVQR
FXUWDLQLQWKHZDRIKLVYLVLRQ
6RVKDGRZHGZDVWKHFHOODUIURPWKHLQVLGHWKDWQRWPXFKFRXOG
WKHJURWHVTXHZRUNLQJSDUDSKHUQDOLDQRZDQGWKHQORRPHGXSVS
WULHGHDFKRIWKHZLQGRZVLQWXUQ,WVHHPHGHYLGHQWDWILUVWWKDWQ
ZLWKLQHWZKHQKHSHHUHGWKURXJKWKHH[WUHPHULJKWKDQGZLQG
QHDUHVWWKHHQWUDQFHDOOHߚKHVDZDJORZRIOLJKWDWWKHIDUWKHU
DSDUWPHQWZKLFKPDGHKLPSDXVHLQEHZLOGHUPHQW7KHUHZDVQ
DQOLJKWVKRXOGEHWKHUH,WZDVDQLQQHUVLGHRIWKHURRPDQGK
UHFDOODQJDVRUHOHFWULFIL[WXUHQHDUWKDWSRLQW$QRWKHUORRNGH
DVDODUJHYHUWLFDOUHFWDQJOHDQGDWKRXJKRFFXUUHGWRKLP,WZD
GLUHFWLRQWKDWKHKDGDOZDVQRWLFHGWKHKHDYSODQNGRRUZLWKW
ODUJHSDGORFNߚWKHGRRUZKLFKZDVQHYHURSHQHGDQGDERYHZK
VPHDUHGWKDWKLGHRXVFUSWLFVPEROIURPWKHIUDJPHQWDUUHFRU
HOGHUPDJLF,WPXVWEHRSHQQRZߚDQGWKHUHZDVDOLJKWLQVLGH
VSHFXODWLRQDVWRZKHUHWKDWGRRUOHGDQGDVWRZKDWODEHKLQGL
UHQHZHGZLWKWUHEOGLVTXLHWLQJIRUFH
-RQHVZDQGHUHGDLPOHVVODURXQGWKHGLVPDOORFDOLWWLOOFORVHWR
ZKHQKHUHWXUQHGWRWKHPXVHXPWRPDNHWKHFDOORQ5RJHUV+H
ZKKHZLVKHGVRHVSHFLDOOWRVHHWKHPDQMXVWWKHQEXWWKHUHP
VRPHVXEFRQVFLRXVPLVJLYLQJVDERXWWKDWWHUULEOXQSODFHDEOHFD
WKHDIWHUQQRQDQGDERXWWKHJORZRIOLJKWLQWKDWGLVWXUELQJDQG
XQRSHQHGLQQHUGRRUZDZLWKWKHKHDYSDGORFN7KHDWWHQGDQWV
KHDUULYHGDQGKHWKRXJKWWKDW2UDERQDߚWKHGDUNIRUHLJQORRNL
HHGKLPZLWKVRPHWKLQJOLNHVOUHSUHVVHGDPXVHPHQW+HGLG
ORRNߚHYHQWKRXJKKHKDGVHHQWKHIHOORZWXUQLWRQKLVHPSORH
7KHYDXOWHGH[KLELWLRQURRPZDVJKRXOLVKLQLWVGHVHUWLRQEXWKH
WKURXJKLWDQGUDSSHGDWWKHGRRURIWKHRIILFHDQGZRUNURRP5H
VORZLQFRPLQJWKRXJKWKHUHZHUHIRRWVWHSVLQVLGH)LQDOOLQUH
VHFRQGNQRFNWKHORFNUDWWOHGDQGWKHDQFLHQWVL[SDQHOOHGSRUWD
UHOXFWDQWORSHQWRUHYHDOWKHVORXFKLQJIHYHULVKHHGIRUPRI*
6XUYLYLQJHOGHUJRGVߚQDPHOHVVVDFULILFHVߚWKHRWKHUWKDQDUWLIL
VRPHRIWKHDOFRYHKRUURUVߚDOOWKHXVXDOERDVWVEXWXWWHUHGLQD
SHFXOLDUOLQFUHDVLQJFRQILGHQFH2EYLRXVO-RQHVUHIOHFWHGWKH
PDGQHVVZDVJDLQLQJRQKLP)URPWLPHWRWLPH5RJHUVZRXOGV
JODQFHVWRZDUGWKHKHDYSDGORFNHGLQQHUGRRUDWWKHHQGRIWKH
DSLHFHRIFRDUVHEXUODSRQWKHIORRUQRWIDUIURPLWEHQHDWKZKL
REMHFWDSSHDUHGWREHOLQJ-RQHVJUHZPRUHQHUYRXVDVWKHPRP
DQGEHJDQWRIHHODVKHVLWDQWDERXWPHQWLRQLQJWKHDIWHUQRRQߞVRG
IRUPHUOEHHQDQ[LRXVWRGRVR
5RJHUVߞVHSXOFKUDOOUHVRQDQWEDVVDOPRVWFUDFNHGXQGHUWKHH[F
IHYHUHGUDPEOLQJ
ߡ'RRXUHPHPEHUߢKHVKRXWHGߡZKDW,WROGRXDERXWWKDWUXLQ
KLQDZKHUHWKH7FKR7FKRVOLYHGRXKDGWRDGPLW,ߞGEHHQWK
VDZWKHSKRWRJUDSKVHYHQLIRXGLGWKLQN,PDGHWKDWREORQJVZ
GDUNQHVVRXWRIZD[,IRXߞGVHHQLWZULWKLQJLQWKHXQGHUJURXQG
GLGߨ
ߡ:HOOWKLVLVELJJHUVWLOO,QHYHUWROGRXDERXWWKLVEHFDXVH,Z
RXWWKHODWHUSDUWVEHIRUHPDNLQJDQFODLP:KHQRXVHHWKHVQ
NQRZWKHJHRJUDSKFRXOGQߞWKDYHEHHQIDNHGDQG,IDQF,KDY
SURYLQJ,WLVQߞWDQZD[HGFRQFRFWLRQRIPLQHRXߞYHQHYHUVHH
H[SHULPHQWVZRXOGQߞWOHWPHNHHS,WRQH[KLELWLRQߢ
7KHVKRZPDQJODQFHGTXHHUODWWKHSDGORFNHGGRRU
ߡ,WDOOFRPHVIURPWKDWORQJULWXDOLQWKHHLJKWK3QDNRWLFIUDJPHQ
ILJXUHGRXW,VDZLWFRXOGRQOKDYHRQHPHDQLQJ7KHUHZHUHWK
EHIRUHWKHODQGRI/RPDUߚEHIRUHPDQNLQGH[LVWHGߚDQGWKLVZD
WRRNXVDOOWKHZDWR$ODVNDDQGXSWKH1RRWDNIURP)RUW0RUW
ZDVWKHUHDVZHNQHZLWZRXOGEH*UHDWFFORSHDQUXLQVDFUHVR
ZDVOHVVOHIWWKDQZHKDGKRSHGIRUEXWDIWHUWKUHHPLOOLRQHDUV
H[SHFW$QGZHUHQߞWWKH(VNLPROHJHQGVDOOLQWKHULJKWGLUHFWLRQ
JHWRQHRIWKHEHJJDUVWRJRZLWKXVDQGKDGWRVOHGJHDOOWKHZD
ߡ,ߞOOWHOORXODWHUKRZZHIRXQG,W:KHQZHJRWWKHLFHEODVWHG
SORQVRIWKHFHQWUDOUXLQWKHVWDLUZDZDVMXVWDVZHNQHZLWZR
FDUYLQJVVWLOOWKHUHDQGLWZDVQRWURXEOHNHHSLQJWKHDQNHHVIU
LQ2UDERQDVKLYHUHGOLNHDOHDIߚRXߞGQHYHUWKLQNLWIURPWKHG
ZDKHVWUXWVDURXQGKHUH+HNQHZHQRXJKRIWKH(OGHU/RUHWR
DIUDLG7KHHWHUQDOOLJKWZDVJRQHEXWRXUWRUFKHVVKRZHGHQRXJ
ERQHVRIRWKHUVZKRKDGEHHQEHIRUHXVഊRQVDJRZKHQWKHFOL
6RPHRIWKRVHERQHVZHUHRIWKLQJVRXFRXOGQߞWHYHQLPDJLQH
GRZQZHIRXQGWKHLYRUWKURQHWKHIUDJPHQWVVDLGVRPXFKDER
DVZHOOWHOORXLWZDVQߞWHPSW
ߡ7KHWKLQJRQWKHWKURQHGLGQߞWPRYHߚDQGZHNQHZWKHQWKDW,W
QRXULVKPHQWRIVDFULILFH%XWZHGLGQߞWZDQWWRZDNH,WWKHQ%H
/RQGRQILUVW2UDERQDDQG,ZHQWWRWKHVXUIDFHIRUWKHELJER[
SDFNHGLWZHFRXOGQߞWJHW,WXSWKHWKUHHIOLJKWVRIVWHSV7KHVHVW
PDGHIRUKXPDQEHLQJVDQGWKHLUVL]HERWKHUHGXV$QZDLWZ
KHDY:HKDGWRKDYHWKH$PHULFDQVGRZQWRJHW,WRXW7KHZ
WRJRLQWRWKHSODFHEXWRIFRXUVHWKHZRUVWWKLQJZDVVDIHOLQVL
WROGWKHPLWZDVDEDWFKRILYRUFDUYLQJߚDUFKHRORJLFDOVWXIID
WKHFDUYHGWKURQHWKHSUREDEOEHOLHYHGXV,WߞVDZRQGHUWKHG
KLGGHQWUHDVXUHDQGGHPDQGDVKDUH7KHPXVWKDYHWROGTXHHU
1RPHODWHURQWKRXJK,GRXEWLIWKHHYHUZHQWEDFNWRWKRVHUX
LYRUWKURQHߢ
5RJHUVSDXVHGIHOWDURXQGLQKLVGHVNDQGSURGXFHGDQHQYHORS
SKRWRJUDSKLFSULQWV([WUDFWLQJRQHDQGODLQJLWIDFHGRZQEHIR
KDQGHGWKHUHVWWR-RQHV7KHVHWZDVFHUWDLQODQRGGRQHLFHF
VOHGJHVPHQLQIXUVDQGYDVWWXPEOHGUXLQVDJDLQVWDEDFNJURXQ
UXLQVZKRVHEL]DUUHRXWOLQHVDQGHQRUPRXVVWRQHEORFNVFRXOGKD
DFFRXQWHGIRU2QHIODVKOLJKWYLHZVKRZHGDQLQFUHGLEOHLQWHULRU
ZLOGFDUYLQJVDQGDFXULRXVWKURQHZKRVHSURSRUWLRQVFRXOGQRW
GHVLJQHGIRUDKXPDQRFFXSDQW7KHFDUYLQJVRIWKHJLJDQWLFPD
ZDOOVDQGSHFXOLDUYDXOWLQJRYHUKHDGߚZHUHPDLQOVPEROLFDQ
ZKROOXQNQRZQGHVLJQVDQGFHUWDLQKLHURJOSKVGDUNOFLWHGLQ
OHJHQGV2YHUWKHWKURQHORRPHGWKHVDPHGUHDGIXOVPEROZKLF
SDLQWHGRQWKHZRUNURRPZDOODERYHWKHSDGORFNHGSODQNGRRU-
5RJHUVZDVFRQWLQXLQJ
ߡ:HOOZHVKLSSHGWKHER[IURP1RPHDQGJRWWR/RQGRQZLWKRX
7KDWZDVWKHILUVWWLPHZHߞGHYHUEURXJKWEDFNDQWKLQJWKDWKDG
FRPLQJDOLYH,GLGQߞWSXW,WRQGLVSODEHFDXVHWKHUHZHUHPRUH
WKLQJVWRGRIRU,W,WQHHGHGWKHQRXULVKPHQWRIVDFULILFHIRU,WZ
FRXUVH,FRXOGQߞWJHW,WWKHVRUWRIVDFULILFHVZKLFK,WXVHGWRKDY
VXFKWKLQJVGRQߞWH[LVWQRZ%XWWKHUHZHUHRWKHUWKLQJVZKLFKP
EORRGLVWKHOLIHRXNQRZ(YHQWKHOHPXUHVDQGHOHPHQWDOVWKD
WKHHDUWKZLOOFRPHZKHQWKHEORRGRIPHQRUEHDVWVLVRIIHUHGX
FRQGLWLRQVߢ
7KHH[SUHVVLRQRQWKHQDUUDWRUߞVIDFHZDVJURZLQJYHUDODUPLQJ
VRWKDW-RQHVILGJHWHGLQYROXQWDULOLQKLVFKDLU5RJHUVVHHPHGW
JXHVWߞVQHUYRXVQHVVDQGFRQWLQXHGZLWKDGLVWLQFWOHYLOVPLOH
ߡ,WZDVODVWHDUWKDW,JRW,WDQGHYHUVLQFHWKHQ,ߞYHEHHQWULQJ
VDFULILFHV2UDERQDKDVQߞWEHHQPXFKKHOSIRUKHZDVDOZDVDJ
ZDNLQJ,W+HKDWHV,WߚSUREDEOEHFDXVHKHߞVDIUDLGRIZKDW,WZ
PHDQ+HFDUULHVDSLVWRODOOWKHWLPHWRSURWHFWKLPVHOIߚIRRODV
KXPDQSURWHFWLRQDJDLQVW,W,I,HYHUVHHKLPGUDZWKDWSLVWRO,ߞ
+HZDQWHGPHWRNLOO,WDQGPDNHDQHIILJRI,W%XW,ߞYHVWXFNE
,ߞPFRPLQJRXWRQWRSLQVSLWHRIDOOWKHFRZDUGVOLNH2UDERQDD
VQLJJHULQJVNHSWLFVOLNHRX-RQHV,ߞYHFKDQWHGWKHULWHVDQGP
VDFULILFHVDQGODVWZHHNWKHWUDQVLWLRQFDPH7KHVDFULILFHZDVߚ
HQMRHGߢ
5RJHUVDFWXDOOOLFNHGKLVOLSVZKLOH-RQHVKHOGKLPVHIXQHDVLO
VKRZPDQSDXVHGDQGURVHFURVVLQJWKHURRPWRWKHSLHFHRIEXU
KDGJODQFHGVRRIWHQ%HQGLQJGRZQKHWRRNKROGRIRQHFRUQHU
DJDLQ
ߡRXߞYHODXJKHGHQRXJKDWPZRUNߚQRZLWߞVWLPHIRURXWRJ
2UDERQDWHOOVPHRXKHDUGDGRJVFUHDPLQJDURXQGKHUHWKLVDIW
NQRZZKDWWKDWPHDQWߢ
PDVVZKLFK-RQHVZDVVORZWRFODVVLI:DVLWDRQFHOLYLQJWKLQ
DJHQFKDGIODWWHQHGVXFNHGGURIEORRGSXQFWXUHGLQDWKRXVD
ZUXQJLQWRDOLPSEURNHQERQHGKHDSRIJURWHVTHQHVV$IWHUDP
UHDOL]HGZKDWLWPXVWEH,WZDVZKDWZDVOHIWRIDGRJߚDGRJS
FRQVLGHUDEOHVL]HDQGZKLWLVKFRORU,WVEUHHGZDVSDVWUHFRJQLWLR
KDGFRPHLQQDPHOHVVDQGKLGHRXVZDV0RVWRIWKHKDLUZDVE
VRPHSXQJHQWDFLGDQGWKHH[SRVHGEORRGOHVVVNLQZDVULGGOHG
FLUFXODUZRXQGVRULQFLVLRQV7KHIRUPRIWRUWXUHQHFHVVDUWRFD
ZDVSDVWLPDJLQLQJ
(OHFWULILHGZLWKDSXUHORDWKLQJZKLFKFRQTXHUHGKLVPRXQWLQJG
VSUDQJZLWKDFU
ߡRXGDPQHGVDGLVWߚRXPDGPDQߚRXGRDWKLQJOLNHWKLVDQG
WRDGHFHQWPDQߢ
5RJHUVGURSSHGWKHEXUODSZLWKDPDOLJQDQWVQHHUDQGIDFHGKLV
+LVZRUGVKHOGDQXQQDWXUDOFDOP
ߡ:KRXIRROGRRXWKLQN,GLGWKLV:KDWRILW,WLVQRWKXP
SUHWHQGWREH7RVDFULILFHLVPHUHOWRRIIHU,JDYHWKHGRJWR,W
LV,WߞVZRUNQRWPLQH,WQHHGHGWKHQRXULVKPHQWRIWKHRIIHULQJ
RZQZD%XWOHWPHVKRZRXZKDW,WORRNVOLNHߢ
$V-RQHVVWRRGKHVLWDWLQJWKHVSHDNHUKDGUHWXUQHGWRKLVGHVND
SKRWRJUDSKKHKDGODLGIDFHGRZQZLWKRXWVKRZLQJ1RZKHH[W
FXULRXVORRN-RQHVWRRNLWDQGJODQFHGDWLQLQDQDOPRVWPHFKDQ
DPRPHQWWKHYLVLWRUߞVJODQFHEHFDPHVKDUSHUDQGPRUHDEVRUEH
VDWDQLFIRUFHRIWKHREMHFWGHSLFWHGKDGDQDOPRVWKSQRWLFHIIHF
5RJHUVKDGRXWGRQHKLPVHOILQPRGHOLQJWKHHOGULWFKQLJKWPDUHZ
FDPHUDKDGFDXJKW7KHWKLQJZDVDZRUNRIVKHHULQIHUQDOJHQL
ZRQGHUHGKRZWKHSXEOLFZRXOGUHDFWZKHQLWZDVSODFHGRQH[K
KLGHRXVDWKLQJKDGQRULJKWWRH[LVWߚSUREDEOWKHPHUHFRQWHP
DIWHULWZDVGRQHKDGFRPSOHWHGWKHXQKLQJLQJRILWVPDNHUߞVPL
WRZRUVKLSLWZLWKEUXWDOVDFULILFHV2QODVWRXWVDQLWFRXOGUHVL
VXJJHVWLRQWKDWWKHEODVSKHPZDVߚRUKDGRQFHEHHQߚVRPHP
FOHYHUUHSURGXFWLRQRIWKHPRQVWURXVOFDUYHGWKURQHLQWKHRWKH
SKRWRJUDSK7RGHVFULEHLWZLWKDQRUGLQDUYRFDEXODUZRXOGE
IRUQRWKLQJHYHQURXJKOFRUUHVSRQGLQJWRLWKDVHYHUFRPHZLWK
LPDJLQDWLRQRIVDQHPDQNLQG,WUHSUHVHQWHGVRPHWKLQJPHDQWSH
URXJKOFRQQHFWHGZLWKWKHYHUWHEUDWHVRIWKLVSODQHWߚWKRXJKRQ
WRRVXUHRIWKDW,WVEXONZDVFFORSHDQIRUHYHQVTXDWWHGLWWRZ
WZLFHWKHKHLJKWRI2UDERQDZKRZDVVKRZQEHVLGHLW/RRNLQJ
PLJKWWUDFHLWVDSSUR[LPDWLRQVWRZDUGWKHERGLOIHDWXUHVRIWKH
YHUWHEUDWHV
7KHUHZDVDQDOPRVWJOREXODUWRUVRZLWKVL[ORQJVLQXRXVOLPEV
FUDEOLNHFODZV)URPWKHXSSHUHQGDVXEVLGLDUJOREHEXOJHGIR
LWVWULDQJOHRIWKUHHVWDULQJILVKHHVLWVIRRWORQJDQGHYLGHQWO
SURERVFLVDQGDGLVWHQGHGODWHUDOVVWHPDQDORJRXVWRJLOOVVXJJ
ZDVDKHDG0RVWRIWKHERGZDVFRYHUHGZLWKZKDWDWILUVWDSS
EXWZKLFKRQFORVHUH[DPLQDWLRQSURYHGWREHDGHQVHJURZWKRI
WHQWDFOHVRUVXFNLQJILODPHQWVHDFKWLSSHGZLWKDPRXWKVXJJHVW
DQDVS2QWKHKHDGDQGEHORZWKHSURERVFLVWKHWHQWDFOHVWHQGHG
DQGWKLFNHUPDUNHGZLWKVSLUDOVWULSHVߚVXJJHVWLQJWKHWUDGLWLRQ
RI0HGXVD7RVXJJHVWWKDWVXFKDWKLQJFRXOGKDYHDQH[SUHVVLR
SDUDGR[LFDOHW-RQHVIHOWWKDWWKDWWULDQJOHRIEXOJLQJILVKHHV
REOLTXHOSRLVHGSURERVFLVDOOEHVSRNHDEOHQGRIKDWHJUHHGDQG
LQFRPSUHKHQVLEOHWRPDQNLQGEHFDXVHLWZDVPL[HGZLWKRWKHUH
WKHZRUOGRUWKLVVRODUVVWHP,QWRWKLVEHVWLDODEQRUPDOLWKHUH
PXVWKDYHSRXUHGDWRQFHDOOKLVPDOLJQDQWLQVDQLWDQGDOOKLVX
VFXOSWXUDOJHQLXV7KHWKLQJZDVLQFUHGLEOHߚDQGHWWKHSKRWRJ
LWH[LVWHG
5RJHUVLQWHUUXSWHGKLVUHYHULHV
ߡ:HOOߚZKDWGRRXWKLQNRI,W1RZGRRXZRQGHUZKDWFUXVK
VXFNHGLWGUZLWKDPLOOLRQPRXWKV,WQHHGHGQRXULVKPHQWߚDQ
PRUH,WLVDJRGDQG,DPWKHILUVWSULHVWRI,WVODWWHUGDKLHUDUF
1LJJXUDWK7KH*RDWZLWKD7KRXVDQGRXQJߢ
-RQHVORZHUHGWKHSKRWRJUDSKLQGLVJXVWDQGSLW
SLFWXUHXSWRRߢ
:LWKDVQDUO5RJHUVVQDWFKHGWKHSKRWRJUDSKDQGUHWXUQHGLWWRW
ߡ,GLRWߚRXߚDQGRXVWLOOWKLQN,WߞVDIUDXGRXVWLOOWKLQN,PD
VWLOOWKLQNPILJXUHVDUHQRWKLQJEXWOLIHOHVVZD[:KGDPQR
WRNQRZ1RWMXVWQRZIRU,WLVUHVWLQJDIWHUWKHVDFULILFHߚEXWOD
RXZLOOQRWGRXEWWKHSRZHURI,WWKHQߢ
$V5RJHUVJODQFHGWRZDUGWKHSDGORFNHGLQQHUGRRU-RQHVUHWULHY
VWLFNIURPDQHDUEEHQFK
ߡ9HUZHOO5RJHUVOHWLWEHODWHU,PXVWEHJRLQJQRZEXW,ߞOOF
WRPRUURZDIWHUQRRQ7KLQNPDGYLFHRYHUDQGVHHLILWGRHVQߞW
$VN2UDERQDZKDWKHWKLQNVWRRߢ
5RJHUVEDUHGKLVWHHWKLQZLOGEHDVWIDVKLRQ
ߡ0XVWEHJRLQJQRZHK$IUDLGDIWHUDOO$IUDLGIRUDOORXUER
WKHHIILJLHVDUHRQOZD[DQGHWRXUXQDZDZKHQ,EHJLQWR
DUHQߞWRXߞUHOLNHWKHIHOORZVZKRWDNHPVWDQGLQJEHWWKDWWKH
WKHQLJKWLQWKHPXVHXPߚWKHFRPHEROGOHQRXJKEXWDIWHUDQ
VKULHNDQGKDPPHUWRJHWRXW:DQWPHWRDVN2UDERQDHKRX
DJDLQVWPHRXZDQWWREUHDNGRZQWKHFRPLQJHDUWKOUHLJQRI
-RQHVSUHVHUYHGKLVFDOP
ߡ1R5RJHUVߚWKHUHߞVQRERGDJDLQVWRX$QG,ߞPQRWDIUDLGRI
HLWKHUPXFKDV,DGPLUHRXUVNLOO%XWZHߞUHERWKDELWQHUYRXV
IDQFVRPHUHVWZLOOGRXVJRRGߢ
$JDLQ5RJHUVFKHFNHGKLVJXHVWߞVGHSDUWXUH
ߡ1RWDIUDLGHKߚWKHQZKDUHRXVRDQ[LRXVWRJR/RRNKHUH
GRQߞWRXGDUHWRVWDDORQHKHUHLQWKHGDUN:KDWߞVRXUKXUU
EHOLHYHLQ,Wߢ
DORQH:KDWZRXOGLWSURYH0RQOREMHFWLRQLVWKDWLWLVQߞWYH
IRUVOHHSLQJ:KDWJRRGZRXOGLWGRHLWKHURIXVߢ
7KLVWLPHLWZDV-RQHVZKRZDVVWUXFNZLWKDQLGHD+HFRQWLQXH
FRQFLOLDWLRQ
ߡ6HHKHUH5RJHUVߚ,ߞYHMXVWDVNHGRXZKDWLWZRXOGSURYHLI,
ERWKNQHZ,WZRXOGSURYHWKDWRXUHIILJLHVDUHMXVWHIILJLHVDQG
RXJKWQߞWWROHWRXULPDJLQDWLRQJRWKHZDLWߞVEHHQJRLQJODWHO
VWD,I,VWLFNLWRXWWLOOPRUQLQJZLOORXDJUHHWRWDNHDQHZYLH
RQDYDFDWLRQIRUWKUHHPRQWKVRUVRDQGOHW2UDERQDGHVWURWKD
RXUVRPHQRZߚLVQߞWWKDWIDLUߢ
7KHH[SUHVVLRQRQWKHVKRZPDQߞVIDFHZDVKDUGWRUHDG,WZDVR
ZDVWKLQNLQJTXLFNODQGWKDWRIVXQGUFRQIOLFWLQJHPRWLRQVP
ZDVJHWWLQJWKHXSSHUKDQG+LVYRLFHKHOGDFKRNLQJTXDOLWDVK
ߡ)DLUHQRXJK,IRXGRVWLFNLWRXW,ߞOOWDNHRXUDGYLFH:HߞOOJ
DQGFRPHEDFN,ߞOOORFNRXLQWKHGLVSODURRPDQGJRKRPH,
,ߞOOFRPHGRZQDKHDGRI2UDERQDߚKHFRPHVKDOIDQKRXUEHIRU
VHHKRZRXDUH%XWGRQߞWWULWXQOHVVRXDUHYHUVXUHRIRX
2WKHUVKDYHEDFNHGRXWߚRXKDYHWKDWFKDQFH$QG,VXSSRVHD
WKHRXWHUGRRUZRXOGDOZDVEULQJDFRQVWDEOHRXPDQRWOLNH
DZKLOHߚRXߞOOEHLQWKHVDPHEXLOGLQJWKRXJKQRWLQWKHVDPH
$VWKHOHIWWKHUHDUGRRULQWRWKHGLQJFRXUWDUG5RJHUVWRRNZ
SLHFHRIEXUODSߚZHLJKWHGZLWKDJUXHVRPHEXUGHQ1HDUWKHFHQ
ZDVDPDQKROHZKRVHFRYHUWKHVKRZPDQOLIWHGTXLHWODQGZLW
VKXGGHUVRPHVXJJHVWLRQRIIDPLOLDULW%XUODSDQGDOOWKHEXUGH
WKHREOLYLRQRIDFORDFDOODEULQWK-RQHVVKXGGHUHGDQGDOPRVW
JDXQWILJXUHDWKLVVLGHDVWKHHPHUJHGLQWRWKHVWUHHW
%XQVSRNHQPXWXDOFRQVHQWWKHGLGQRWGLQHWRJHWKHUEXWDJU
IURQWRIWKHPXVHXPDWHOHYHQ
-RQHVKDLOHGDFDEDQGEUHDWKHGPRUHIUHHOZKHQKHKDGFURVVH
%ULGJHDQGZDVDSSURDFKLQJWKHEULOOLDQWOOLJKWHG6WUDQG+HGL
ERRNVRFFXOWSDUDSKHUQDOLDDQGZD[LPDJHVZKLFKKHGLGQRWFK
RQH[KLELWLRQ2UDERQDKHXQGHUVWRRGOLYHGLQVHSDUDWHTXDUWHUV
KRXVH
$WHOHYHQ-RQHVIRXQG5RJHUVZDLWLQJEWKHEDVHPHQWGRRULQ6
6WUHHW7KHLUZRUGVZHUHIHZEXWHDFKVHHPHGWDXWZLWKDPHQDF
7KHDJUHHGWKDWWKHYDXOWHGH[KLELWLRQURRPDORQHVKRXOGIRUP
YLJLODQG5RJHUVGLGQRWLQVLVWWKDWWKHZDWFKHUVLWLQWKHVSHFLDO
VXSUHPHKRUURUV7KHVKRZPDQKDYLQJH[WLQJXLVKHGDOOWKHOLJK
LQWKHZRUNURRPORFNHGWKHGRRURIWKDWFUSWZLWKRQHRIWKHNH
FURZGHGULQJ:LWKRXWVKDNLQJKDQGVKHSDVVHGRXWWKHVWUHHWGR
DIWHUKLPDQGSDVVHGXSWKHZRUQVWHSVWRWKHVLGHZDONRXWVLGH
UHFHGHG-RQHVUHDOL]HGWKDWWKHORQJWHGLRXVYLJLOKDGFRPPHQF
/DWHULQWKHXWWHUEODFNQHVVRIWKHJUHDWDUFKHGFHOODU-RQHVFXUV
QDഊYHWഊZKLFKKDGEURXJKWKLPWKHUH)RUWKHILUVWKDOIKRXUK
IODVKLQJKLVSRFNHWOLJKWDWLQWHUYDOVEXWQRZMXVWVLWWLQJLQWKHG
WKHYLVLWRUߞVEHQFKHVKDGEHFRPHDPRUHQHUYHZUDFNLQJWKLQJ(
EHDPVKRWRXWLWOLJKWHGXSVRPHPRUELGJURWHVTXHREMHFWߚDJX
QDPHOHVVKEULGPRQVWHUDSDVWEHDUGHGIDFHFUDIWZLWKHYLOD
WRUUHQWVVWUHDPLQJIURPDVHYHUHGWKURDW-RQHVNQHZWKDWQRVLQL
DWWDFKHGWRWKHVHWKLQJVEXWDIWHUWKDWILUVWKDOIKRXUKHSUHIHUUHG
:KKHKDGERWKHUHGWRKXPRUWKDWPDGPDQKHFRXOGVFDUFHOL
KDYHEHHQPXFKVLPSOHUPHUHOWRKDYHOHWKLPDORQHRUWRKDYH
PHQWDOVSHFLDOLVW3UREDEOKHUHIOHFWHGLWZDVWKHIHOORZIHHOLQ
IRUDQRWKHU7KHUHZDVVRPXFKJHQLXVLQ5RJHUVWKDWKHGHVHUYH
FKDQFHWREHKHOSHGTXLHWORXWRIKLVJURZLQJPDQLD$QPDQ
LPDJLQHDQGFRQVWUXFWWKHLQFUHGLEOOLIHOLNHWKLQJVWKDWKHKDGS
QRWIDUIURPDFWXDOJUHDWQHVV+HKDGWKHIDQFRID6LPHRUD'R
WKHPLQXWHVFLHQWLILFFUDIWVPDQVKLSRID%ODWVFKND,QGHHGKHK
ZRUOGRIQLJKWPDUHZKDWWKH%ODWVFKNDVZLWKWKHLUPDUYHORXVOD
PRGHOVRIILQHOZURXJKWDQGFRORXUHGJODVVKDGGRQHIRUWKHZR
$WPLGQLJKWWKHVWURNHVRIDGLVWDQWFORFNILOWHUHGWKURXJKWKHGD
-RQHVIHOWFKHHUHGEWKHPHVVDJHIURPDVWLOOVXUYLYLQJRXWVLGH
YDXOWHGPXVHXPFKDPEHUZDVOLNHDWRPEߚJKDVWOLQLWVXWWHUV
PRXVHZRXOGEHFKHHULQJFRPSDQHW5RJHUVKDGRQFHERDVWH
ߡFHUWDLQUHDVRQVߢDVKHVDLGߚQRPLFHRUHYHQLQVHFWVHYHUFDPH
7KDWZDVYHUFXULRXVHWLWVHHPHGWREHWUXH7KHGHDGQHVVDQ
YLUWXDOOFRPSOHWH,IRQOVRPHWKLQJZRXOGPDNHDVRXQG+HV
DQGWKHHFKRHVFDPHVSHFWUDOORXWRIWKHDEVROXWHVWLOOQHVV+HF
WKHUHZDVVRPHWKLQJPRFNLQJLQWKHVWDFFDWRUHYHUEHUDWLRQV+H
YRZHGEHJLQWDONLQJWRKLPVHOI7KDWPHDQWQHUYRXVGLVLQWHUJUD
VHHPHGWRSDVVZLWKDEQRUPDODQGGLVFRQFHUWLQJVORZQHVV+HF
WKDWKRXUVKDGHODSVHGVLQFHKHODVWIODVKHGWKHOLJKWRQKLVZDWFK
RQOWKHVWURNHRIPLGQLJKW
+HZLVKHGWKDWKLVVHQVHVZHUHQRWVRSUHWHUQDWXUDOONHHQ6RP
GDUNQHVVDQGVWLOOQHVVVHHPHGWRKDYHVKDUSHQHGWKHPVRWKDWWK
RIYDJXHLUUHOHYDQWWKLQJVOLNHWKHPXVLFRIWKHVSKHUHVDQGWKHX
LQDFFHVVLEOHOLIHRIDOLHQGLPHQVLRQVSUHVVLQJRQRXURZQ5RJHU
VSHFXODWHGDERXWVXFKWKLQJV
7KHIORDWLQJVSHFNVRIOLJKWLQKLVEODFNQHVVGURZQHGHHVVHHP
WDNHRQFXULRXVVPPHWULHVRISDWWHUQDQGPRWLRQ+HKDGRIWHQ
WKRVHVWUDQJHUDVIURPWKHXQSOXPEHGDEVVZKLFKVFLQWLOODWHE
DEVHQFHRIDOOHDUWKOLOOXPLQDWLRQEXWKHKDGQHYHUNQRZQDQ
DVWKHVHZHUHEHKDYLQJ7KHODFNHGWKHUHVWIXODLPOHVVQHVVRIR
VSHFNVߚVXJJHVWLQJVRPHZLOODQGSXUSRVHUHPRWHIURPDQWHUU
FRQFHSWLRQ
7KHQWKHUHZDVWKDWVXJJHVWLRQRIRGGVWLUULQJV1RWKLQJZDVRSH
WKHJHQHUDOGUDIWOHVVQHVV-RQHVIHOWWKDWWKHDLUZDVQRWXQLIRUPO
ZHUHLQWDQJLEOHYDULDWLRQVLQSUHVVXUHߚQRWTXLWHGHFLGHGHQRXJK
ORDWKVRPHSDZLQJVRIXQVHHQHOHPHQWDOV,WZDVDEQRUPDOOFKLO
QRWOLNHDQRIWKLV7KHDLUWHVWHGVDOWDVLILWZHUHPL[HGZLWK
VXEWHUUHQHZDWHUVDQGWKHUHZDVDEDUHKLQWRIVRPHRGRURILQHI
,QWKHGDWLPHKHKDGQHYHUQRWLFHGWKDWWKHZD[HQILJXUHVKDGD
QRZWKDWKDOIUHFHLYHGKLQWZDVQRWWKHZDZD[ILJXUHVRXJKWWR
PRUHOLNHWKHIDLQWVPHOORIVSHFLPHQVLQDQDWXUDOKLVWRUPXVHX
YLHZRI5RJHUVߞFODLPVWKDWKLVILJXUHVZHUHQRWDOODUWLILFLDOߚLQ
SUREDEOWKDWFODLPZKLFKPDGHRQHߞVLPDJLQDWLRQFRQMXUHXSWK
VXVSLFLRQ2QHPXVWJXDUGDJDLQVWH[FHVVHVRILPDJLQDWLRQߚKDG
GULYHQSRRU5RJHUVPDG
%XWWKHXWWHUORQHOLQHVVRIWKLVSODFHZDVIULJKWIXO(YHQWKHGLVWD
VHHPHGWRFRPHIURPDFURVVFRVPLFJXOIV,WPDGH-RQHVWKLQNR
SLFWXUHZKLFK5RJHUVKDGVKRZHGKLPWKHZLOGOFDUYHGFKDPEH
FUSWLFWKURQHZKLFKWKHIHOORZKDGFODLPHGZDVSDUWRIDWKUHH
UXLQLQWKHVKXQQHGDQGLQDFFHVVLEOHVROLWXGHVRIWKH$UFWLF3HUK
EHHQWR$ODVNDEXWWKDWSLFWXUHZDVFHUWDLQOQRWKLQJEXWVWDJHV
FRXOGQߞWQRUPDOOEHRWKHUZLVHZLWKDOOWKDWFDUYLQJDQGWKRVHW
$QGWKDWPRQVWURXVVKDSHVXSSRVHGWRKDYHEHHQIRXQGRQWKDWW
IOLJKWRIGLVHDVHGIDQF-RQHVZRQGHUHGMXVWKRZIDUKHDFWXDOO
LQVDQHPDVWHUSLHFHLQZD[ߚSUREDEOLWZDVNHSWEHKLQGWKDWKHD
VFUHHQRQWKHOHIWZDVWKHߡ$GXOWVRQOߢDOFRYHZLWKLWVQDPHOHVV
GHOHULXP
7KHSUR[LPLWRIWKHQXPEHUOHVVZD[HQVKDSHVEHJDQWRJHWRQ-
PRUHDQGPRUHDVWKHTXDUWHUKRXUVZRUHRQ+HNQHZWKHPXVH
KHFRXOGQRWJHWULGRIWKHLUXVXDOLPDJHVHYHQLQWKHWRWDOGDUNQH
GDUNQHVVKDGWKHHIIHFWRIDGGLQJWRWKHUHPHPEHUHGLPDJHVFHUW
GLVWXUELQJLPJLQDWLYHRYHUWRQHV7KHJXLOORWLQHVHHPHGWRFUHDN
IDFHRI/DQGUXߚVODHURIKLVILIWZLYHVߚWZLVWHGLWVHOILQWRH[S
PRQVWURXVPHQDFH)URPWKHVHYHUHGWKURDWRI0DGDPH'HPHUV
EXEEOLQJVRXQGVHHPHGWRHPDQDWHZKLOHWKHKHDGOHVVOHJOHVVY
PXUGHUWULHGWRHGJHFORVHUDQGFORVHURQLWVJRUVWXPSV-RQHV
KLVHHVWRVHHLIWKDWZRXOGGLPWKHLPDJHVEXWIRXQGLWZDVXVH
ZKHQKHVKXWKLVHHVWKHVWUDQJHSXUSRVHIXOSDWWHUQVRIOLJKWVS
PRUHGLVWXUELQJOSURQRXQFHG
7KHQVXGGHQOKHEHJDQWULQJWRNHHSWKHKLGHRXVLPDJHVKHKD
WULQJWREDQLVK+HWULHGWRNHHSWKHPEHFDXVHWKHZHUHJLYLQJ
PRUHKLGHRXVRQHV,QVSLWHRIKLPVHOIKLVPHPRUEHJDQUHFRQV
XWWHUOQRQKXPDQEODVSKHPLHVWKDWOXUNHGLQWKHREVFXUHUFRUQH
OXPSLVKKEULGJURZWKVRR]HGDQGZULJJOHGWRZDUGKLPDVWKRX
GRZQLQDFLUFOH%ODFN7VDWKRJJXDPROGHGLWVHOIIURPDWRDGOLN
ORQJVLQXRXVOLQHZLWKKXQGUHGVRIUXGLPHQWDUIHHWDQGDOHDQ
JDXQWVSUHDGLWVZLQJVDVLIWRDGYDQFHDQGVPRWKHUWKHZDWFKHU
KLPVHOIWRNHHSIURPVFUHDPLQJ+HNQHZKHZDVUHYHUWLQJWRWK
WHUURUVRIKLVFKLOGKRRGDQGUHVROYHGWRXVHKLVDGXOWUHDVRQWRN
SKDQWRPVDWED,WKHOSHGDELWKHIRXQGWRIODVKWKHOLJKWDJDLQ
ZHUHWKHLPDJHVLWVKRZHGWKHVHZHUHQRWDVEDGDVZKDWKLVIDQ
WKHXWWHUEODFNQHVV
%XWWKHUHZHUHGUDZEDFNV(YHQLQWKHOLJKWRIKLVWRUFKKHFRXOG
VXVSHFWLQJDVOLJKWIXUWLYHWUHPEOLQJRQWKHSDUWRIWKHFDQYDVSD
RIIWKHWHUULEOHߡ$GXOWVRQOߢDOFRYH+HNQHZZKDWODEHRQG
,PDJLQDWLRQFDOOHGXSWKHVKRFNLQJIRUPVRIIDEXORXVRJ6RWKR
FRQJHULHVRILULGHVFHQWJOREHVHWVWXSHQGRXVLQLWVPDOLJQVXJJ
ZDVWKLVDFFXUVHGPDVVVORZOIORDWLQJWRZDUGKLPDQGEXPSLQJ
VWXIIRXWRIKLVKHDG-RQHVZDONHGEROGOWRZDUGWKHKHOOLVKDOFR
EXUQLQJVWHDGLO2IFRXUVHQRQHRIKLVIHDUVZDVWUXHHWZHUH
IDFLDOWHQWDOFHVRIJUHDWWKXOKXDFWXDOOVZDLQJVORZODQGLQ
NQHZWKHZHUHIOH[LEOHEXWKHKDGQRWUHDOLVHGWKDWWKHGUDIWFD
DGYDQFHZDVHQRXJKWRVHWWKHPLQPRWLRQ
5HWXUQLQJWRKLVIRUPHUVHDWRXWVLGHWKHDOFRYHKHVKXWKLVHHV
VPPHWULFDOOLJKWVSHFNVGRWKHLUZRUVW7KHGLVWDQWFORFNERRP
VWURNHRXOGLWEHRQORQH+HIODVKHGWKHOLJKWRQKLVZDWFKD
ZDVSUHFLVHOWKDWKRXU,WZRXOGEHKDUGLQGHHGZDLWLQJIRUWKHP
ZRXOGEHGRZQDWDERXWHLJKWRߞFORFNDKHDGRIHYHQ2UDERQD,
RXWVLGHLQWKHPDLQEDVHPHQWORQJEHIRUHWKDWEXWQRQHRILWFRX
KHUH$OOWKHZLQGRZVLQWKLVEDVHPHQWKDGEHHQEULFNHGXSEXW
RQHVIDFLQJWKHFRXUW$SUHWWEDGZDLWDOOWROG
+LVHDUVZHUHJHWWLQJPRVWRIWKHKDOOXFLQDWLRQVQRZߚIRUKHFRX
KHDUGVWHDOWKSORGGLQJIRRWVWHSVLQWKHZRUNURRPEHRQGWKHF
GRRU+HKDGQREXVLQHVVWKLQNLQJRIWKDWXQH[KLELWHGKRUURUZK
FDOOHGߡ,Wߢ7KHWKLQJZDVDFRQWDPLQDWLRQLWKDGGULYHQLWVPDNH
HYHQLWVSLFWXUHZDVFDOOLQJXSLPDJLQDWLYHWHUURUV,WZDVYHUR
WKDWSDGORFNHGGRRURIKHDYSODQNLQJ7KRVHVWHSVZHUHFHUWDLQ
LPDJLQDWLRQ
7KHQKHWKRXJKWKHKHDUGWKHNHWXUQLQWKHZRUNURRPGRRU)OD
WRUFKKHVDZQRWKLQJEXWWKHDQFLHQWVL[SDQHOHGSRUWODLQLWVSUR
$JDLQKHWULHGGDUNQHVVDQGFORVHGKLVHHVEXWWKHUHIROORZHGD
LOOXVLRQRIFUHDNLQJߚQRWWKHJXLOORWLQHWKLVWLPHEXWWKHVORZIX
WKHZRUNURRPGRRU+HZRXOGQRWVFUHDP2QFHKHVFUHDPHGKH
7KHUHZDVDVRUWRISDGGLQJRUVKXIIOLQJDXGLEOHQRZDQGLWZDV
DGYDQFLQJWRZDUGKLP+HPXVWUHWDLQFRPPDQGRIKLPVHOI+DG
ZKHQWKHQDPHOHVVEUDLQVKDSHGWULHGWRFORVHLQRQKLP7KHVK
QHDUHUDQGKLVUHVROXWLRQIDLOHG+HGLGQRWVFUHDPEXWPHUHOJ
FKDOOHQJH
ߡ:KRJRHVWKHUH:KRDUHRX:KDWGRRXZDQWߢ
WKHHYHQLQJ+LVILQJHUVDQGWKURDWZRUNHGVSDVPRGLFDOO6LOHQF
LPSRVVLEOHDQGWKHVXVSHQVHRIXWWHUEODFNQHVVZDVEHJLQQLQJWR
LQWROHUDEOHRIDOOFRQGLWLRQV$JDLQKHFULHGRXWKVWHULFDOOߚߡ+
WKHUHߢߚDVKHVZLWFKHGRQWKHUHYHDOLQJEHDPRIKLVWRUFK7KH
ZKDWKHVDZKHGURSSHGWKHIODVKOLJKWDQGVFUHDPHGߚQRWRQFH
6KXIIOLQJWRZDUGKLPLQWKHGDUNQHVVZDVWKHJLJDQWLFEODVSKHP
EODFNWKLQJQRWZKROODSHDQGQRWZKROOLQVHFW,WVKLGHKXQJO
IUDPHDQGLWVUXJRVHGHDGHHGUXGLPHQWRIDKHDGVZDHGGUXQ
WRVLGH,WVIRUHSDZVZHUHH[WHQGHGZLWKWDORQVVSUHDGZLGHDQG
ZDVWDXWZLWKPXUGHURXVPDOLJQLWGHVSLWHLWVXWWHUODFNRIIDFLDO
$IWHUWKHVFUHDPVDQGWKHILQDOFRPLQJRIGDUNQHVVLWOHDSHGDQG
KDG-RQHVSLQQHGWRWKHIORRU7KHUHZDVQRVWUXJJOHIRUWKHZDWF
-RQHVߞIDLQWLQJVSHOOFRXOGQRWKDYHODVWHGPRUHWKDQDPRPHQW
WKLQJZDVDSLVKOGUDJJLQJKLPWKURXJKWKHGDUNQHVVZKHQKHEH
FRQVFLRXVQHVV:KDWVWDUWHGKLPIXOODZDNHZHUHWKHVRXQGVZ
ZDVPDNLQJߚRUUDWKHUWKHYRLFHZLWKZKLFKLWZDVPDNLQJWKHP
ZDVKXPDQDQGLWZDVIDPLOLDU2QORQHOLYLQJEHLQJFRXOGEHE
KRDUVHIHYHULVKDFFHQWVZKLFKZHUHFKDQWLQJWRDQXQNQRZQKRU
ߡ,ഊ,ഊߢLWZDVKRZOLQJߡ,DPFRPLQJ25KDQ7HJRWKFRPL
QRXULVKPHQWRXKDYHZDLWHGORQJDQGIHGLOOEXWQRZRXVKDO
SURPLVHG7KDWDQGPRUHIRULQVWHDGRI2UDERQDLWZLOOEHRQHR
ZKRKDVGRXEWHGRXRXVKDOOFUXVKDQGGUDLQKLPZLWKDOOKLV
JURZVWURQJWKHUHE$QGHYHUDIWHUDPRQJPHQKHVKDOOEHVKRZ
PRQXPHQWWRRXUJORU5KDQ7HJRWKLQILQLWHDQGLQYLQFLEOH,
DQGKLJKSULHVWRXDUHKXQJUDQG,VKDOOSURYLGH,UHDGWKHVL
RXIRUWK,VKDOOIHHGRXZLWKEORRGDQGRXVKDOOIHHGPHZLW
6KXE1LJJXUDWK7KH*RDWZLWKD7KRXVDQGRXQJߢ
,QDQLQVWDQWDOOWKHWHUURUVRIWKHQLJKWGURSSHGIURP-RQHVOLNHD
FORDN+HZDVDJDLQPDVWHURIKLVPLQGIRUKHNQHZWKHYHUHD
PDWHULDOSHULOKHKDGWRGHDOZLWK7KLVZDVQRPRQVWHURIIDEOH
PDGPDQ,WZDV5RJHUVGUHVVHGLQVRPHQLJKWPDUHFRYHULQJRI
GHVLJQLQJDQGDERXWWRPDNHDIULJKWIXOVDFULILFHWRWKHGHYLOJR
RQHPXVWDFWTXLFNORXQWLQJRQWKHPDGPDQߞVFRQILGHQFHLQK
XQFRQVFLRXVQHVVKHGHWHUPLQHGWRWDNHKLPEVXUSULVHZKLOHKL
UHODWLYHOOD[7KHIHHORIDWKUHVKROGWROGKLPKHZDVFURVVLQJLQ
EODFNZRUNURRP
:LWKWKHVWUHQJWKRIPRUWDOIHDU-RQHVPDGHDVXGGHQVSULQJIURP
UHFXPEHQWSRVWXUHLQZKLFKKHZDVEHLQJGUDJJHG)RUDQLQVWDQ
WKHDVWRQLVKHGPDQLDFߞVKDQGVDQGLQDQRWKHULQVWDQWDOXFNOXQ
KDGSXWKLVRZQKDQGVDWKLVFDSWRUߞVZHLUGOFRQFHDOHGWKURDW6
5RJHUVJULSSHGKLPDJDLQDQGZLWKRXWIXUWKHUSUHOLPLQDULHVWKH
LQDGHVSHUDWHVWUXJJOHRIOLIHDQGGHDWK-RQHVߞDWKOHWLFWUDLQLQJ
ZDVKLVVROHVDOYDWLRQIRUKLVPDGDVVDLODQWIUHHGIURPHYHULQ
SODGHFHQFRUHYHQVHOISUHVHUYDWLRQZDVDQHQJLQHRIVDYDJH
IRUPLGDEOHDVDZROIRUSDQWKHU
*XWWXUDOFULHVVRPHWLPHVSXQFWXUHGWKHKLGHRXVWXVVOHLQWKHGDU
VSXUWHGFORWKLQJULSSHGDQG-RQHVDWODVWIHOWWKHDFWXDOWKURDWRI
VKRUQRILWVVSHFWUDOPDVN+HVSRNHQRWDZRUGEXWSXWHYHURX
LQWRWKHGHIHQFHRIKLVOLIH5RJHUVNLFNHGJRXJHGEXWWHGELWF
ߚHWIRXQGVWUHQJWKWRHOSRXWDFWXDOVHQWHQFHVDWWLPHV0RVW
ZDVLQDULWXDOLVWLFMDUJRQIXOORIUHIHUHQFHVWRߡ,WߢRUߡ5KDQ7HJ
-RQHVߞRYHUZURXJKWQHUYHVLWVHHPHGDVLIWKHFULHVHFKRHGIURP
GLVWDQFHRIGHPRQLDFVQRUWLFVDQGEDLQJV7RZDUGWKHODVWWKH
WKHIORRURYHUWXUQLQJEHQFKHVRUVWULNLQJDJDLQVWWKHZDOOVDQGWK
IRXQGDWLRQVRIWKHFHQWUDOPHOWLQJIXUQDFH8SWRWKHYHUHQG-R
FHUWDLQRIVDYLQJKLPVHOIEXWFKDQFHILQDOOLQWHUYHQHGLQKLVIDY
NQHHDJDLQVW5RJHUVߞFKHVWSURGXFHGDJHQHUDOUHOD[DWLRQDQGDP
NQHZKHKDGZRQ
7KRXJKKDUGODEOHWRKROGKLPVHOIXS-RQHVURVHDQGVWXPEOHG
VHHNLQJWKHOLJKWVZLWFKߚIRUKLVIODVKOLJKWZDVJRQHWRJHWKHUZ
FORWKLQJ$VKHOXUFKHGDORQJKHGUDJJHGKLVOLPSRSSRQHQWZLWK
VXGGHQDWWDFNZKHQWKHPDGPDQFDPHWR)LQGLQJWKHVZLWFKER
WLOOKHKDGWKHULJKWKDQGOH7KHQDVWKHZLOGOGLVRUGHUHGZRUNU
VXGGHQUDGLDQFHKHVHWDERXWELQGLQJ5RJHUVZLWKVXFKFRUGVDQ
FRXOGHDVLOILQG7KHIHOORZߞVGLVJXLVHߚRUZKDWZDVOHIWRILWߚ
VHL]HGDVKLVILQDOSDVVSRUWWRIUHHGRP7KHVKDGHVDWWKHVPDOO
ZLQGRZVZHUHDOOVHFXUHOGUDZQDQGKHOHWWKHPUHPDLQVR
:DVKLQJRIIWKHEORRGRIEDWWOHDWDFRQYHQLHQWVLQN-RQHVGRQQ
RUGLQDUORRNLQJDQGOHDVWLOOILWWLQJFORWKHVKHFRXOGILQGRQWKH
7HVWLQJWKHGRRUWRWKHFRXUWDUGKHIRXQGLWIDVWHQHGZLWKDVSU
GLGQRWUHTXLUHDNHIURPWKHLQVLGH+HNHSWWKHNHULQJKRZH
KLPRQKLVUHWXUQZLWKDLGߚIRUSODLQOWKHWKLQJWRGRZDVWRFD
7KHUHZDVQRWHOHSKRQHLQWKHPXVHXPEXWLWZRXOGQRWWDNHORQ
QLJKWUHVWDXUDQWRUFKHPLVWߞVVKRSZKHUHRQHFRXOGEHKDG+HK
RSHQHGWKHGRRUZKHQDWRUUHQWRIKLGHRXVDEXVHIURPDFURVVWKH
WKDW5RJHUVߚZKRVHYLVLEOHLQMXULHVZHUHFRQILQHGWRDORQJGHH
WKHOHIWFKHHNߚKDGUHJDLQHGFRQVFLRXVQHVV
ߡ)RRO6SDZQRI1RWKLGLNDQGHIIOXYLXPRI.ߞWKXQ6RQRIWK
LQWKHPDHOVWURPRI$]DWKRWKRXZRXOGKDYHEHHQVDFUHGDQG
QRZRXDUHEHWUDLQJ,WDQG,WVSULHVW%HZDUHߚIRU,WLVKXQJU
EHHQ2UDERQDߚWKDWGDPQHGWUHDFKHURXVGRJUHDGWRWXUQDJDLQ
EXW,JLYHRXWKHKRQRULQVWHDG1RZRXPXVWERWKEHZDUHIRU
ZLWKRXW,WVSULHVW
ߡ,ഊ,ഊ9HQJHDQFHLVDWKDQG'RRXNQRZRXZRXOGKDYH
/RRNDWWKHIXUQDFH7KHUHLVDILUHUHDGWROLJKWDQGWKHUHLVZ
ZRXOGKDYHGRQHZLWKRXDV,KDYHGRQHZLWKRWKHURQFHOLYLQJ
RXZKRKDYHYRZHGDOOPHIILJLHVDUHZD[HQZRXOGKDYHEHF
HIILJRXUVHOI7KHIXUQDFHZDVDOUHDG:KHQ,WKDGKDGLWVILO
OLNHWKDWGRJ,VKRZHGRX,ZRXOGKDYHPDGHRXUIODWWHQHGSX
IUDJPHQWVLPPRUWDO:D[ZRXOGKDYHGRQHLW+DYHQߞWRXVDLG
DUWLVW:D[LQHYHUSRUHߚZD[RYHUHYHUVTXDUHLQFKRIRXߚ
HYHUDIWHUWKHZRUOGZRXOGKDYHORRNHGDWRXUPDQJOHGFDUFDVV
KRZ,HYHULPDJLQHGDQGPDGHVXFKDWKLQJ+HLDQG2UDERQDZ
QH[WDQGRWKHUVDIWHUKLPDQGWKXVZRXOGPZD[HQIDPLOKDY
ߡ'RJߚGRRXVWLOOWKLQJ,PDGHDOOPHIILJLHV:KQRWVDSU
NQRZEWKLVWLPHWKHVWUDQJHSODFHV,ߞYHEHHQWRDQGWKHVWUDQJ
EURXJKWEDFNRZDUGߚRXFRXOGQHYHUIDFHWKHGLPHQVLRQDOVK
5RJHUVSURSSHGDJDLQVWWKHZDOOVZDHGWRDQGIURLQKLVERQGV
ߡ6HHKHUH-RQHVߚLI,OHWRXJRZLOORXOHWPHJR,WPXVWEHW
,WVKLJKSULHVW2UDERQDZLOOEHHQRXJKWRNHHS,WDOLYHߚDQGZK
,ZLOOPDNHKLVIUDJPHQWVLPPRUWDOLQZD[IRUWKHZRUOGWRVHH
EHHQRXEXWRXKDYHUHMHFWHGWKHKRQRU,ZRQߞWERWKHURXDJ
DQG,ZLOOVKDUHZLWKRXWKHSRZHUWKDW,WZLOOEULQJPH,ഊ,ഊ
5KDQ7HJRWK/HWPHJR/HWPHJR,WLVVWDUYLQJGRZQWKHUHEH
DQGLI,WGLHVWKH2OG2QHVFDQQHYHUFRPHEDFN+HL+HL/HWP
-RQHVPHUHOVKRRNKLVKHDGWKRXJKWKHKLGHRXVQHVVRIWKHVKRZ
LPDJLQLQJVUHYROWHGKLP5RJHUVQRZVWDULQJZLOGODWWKHSDGOR
GRRUWKXPSHGKLVKHDGDJDLQDQGDJDLQDJDLQVWWKHEULFNZDOODQ
KLVWLJKWOERXQGDQNOHV-RQHVZDVDIUDLGKHZRXOGLQMXUHKLPVH
WRELQGKLPPRUHILUPOWRVRPHVWDWLRQDUREMHFW:ULWKLQJ5R
IURPKLPDQGVHWXSDVHULHVRIIUHQHWLFXOXODWLRQVZKRVHXWWHUP
XQKXPDQQHVVZDVDSSDOOLQJDQGZKRVHVKHHUYROXPHZDVDOPR
VHHPHGLPSRVVLEOHWKDWDQKXPDQWKURDWFRXOGSURGXFHQRLVHVV
SLHUFLQJDQG-RQHVIHOWWKDWLIWKLVFRQWLXQHGWKHUHZRXOGEHQRQ
WHOHSKRQHIRUDLG,WFRXOGQRWEHORQJEHIRUHDFRQVWDEOHZRXOG
JUDQWLQJWKDWWKHUHZHUHQROLVWHQLQJQHLJKERUVLQWKLVGHVHUWHGZ
GLVWULFW
ߡ:]DߞHL:]DߞHLߢKRZOHGWKHPDGPDQߡߞNDDKDDKRLL5
WKXOKXIWKDJQ(L(L(L(L5KDQ7HRJWK5KDQ7HJRWK5KDQ
7KHWDXWOWUXVVHGFUHDWXUHZKRKDGVWDUWHGVTXLUPLQJKLVZDD
IORRUQRZUHDFKHGWKHSDGORFNHGSODQNGRRUDQGFRPPHQFHGNQ
WKXQGHURXVODJDLQVWLW-RQHVGUHDGHGWKHWDVNRIELQGLQJKLPIX
ZLVKHGKHZHUHQRWVRH[KDXVWHGIURPKLVSUHYLRXVVWUXJJOH7KL
DIWHUPDWKZDVJHWWLQJKLGHRXVORQKLVQHUYHVDQGKHEHJDQWRI
WKHQDPHOHVVTXDOPVKHKDGIHOWLQWKHGDUN(YHUWKLQJDERXW5
PXVHXPZDVVRKHOOLVKOPRUELGDQGVXJJHVWLYHRIEODFNYLVWDVE
ZDVORDWKVRPHWRWKLQNRIWKHZD[HQPDVWHUSLHFHRIDEQRUPDOJH
PXVWDWWKLVYHUPRPHQWEHOXUNLQJFORVHDWKDQGLQWKHEODFNQH
FDXVHGHYHUKDLUߚHYHQWKHWLQJURZWKRQWKHEDFNVRIKLVKDQ
ZLWKDYDJXHIULJKWEHRQGFODVVLILFDWLRQ5RJHUVKDGVXGGHQOV
VFUHDPLQJDQGEHDWLQJKLVKHDGDJDLQVWWKHVWRXWSODQNGRRUDQG
XSWRDVLWWLQJSRVLWLRQKHDGFRFNHGRQRQHVLGHDVLIOLVWHQLQJLQ
VRPHWKLQJ$OODWRQFHDVPLOHRIGHYLOLVKWULXPSKRYHUVSUHDGKL
EHJDQVSHDNLQJLQWHOOLJLEODJDLQߚWKLVWLPHLQDKRDUVHZKLVSHU
RGGOZLWKKLVIRUPHUVWHQWRULDQKRZOLQJ
ߡ/LVWHQIRRO/LVWHQKDUG,WKDVKHDUGPHDQGLVFRPLQJDQߞW
VSODVKLQJRXWRI,WVWDQNGRZQWKHUHDWWKHHQGRIWKHUXQZD,G
EHFDXVHWKHUHZDVQRWKLQJWRRJRRGIRU,W,WLVDPSKLELRXVRX
WKHJLOOVLQWKHSLFWXUH,WFDPHWRWKHHDUWKIURPOHDGJUDXJJR
FLWLHVDUHXQGHUWKHZDUPGHHSVHD,WFDQߞWVWDQGXSLQWKHUHߚWR
GRZQRUFURXFK/HWPHJHWPNHVߚZHPXVWOHW,WRXWDQGNQ
LW7KHQZHZLOOJRRXWDQGILQGDGRJRUFDWߚRUSHUKDSVDGUXQN
JLYH,WWKHQRXULVKPHQW,WQHHGVߢ
,WZDVQRWZKDWWKHPDGPDQVDLGEXWWKHZDKHVDLGLWWKDWGLV
VREDGO7KHXWWHULQVDQHFRQILGHQFHDQGVLQFHULWLQWKDWFUD]H
GDPQDEOFRQWDJLRXV,PDJLQDWLRQVXFKDVWLPXOXVFRXOGILQGD
LQWKHGHYLOLVKZD[ILJXUHWKDWOXUNHGXQVHHQMXVWEHRQGWKHKHD
(HLQJWKHGRRULQXQKROIDVFLQDWLRQ-RQHVQRWLFHVWKDWLWERUH
FUDFNVWKRXJKQRPDUNVRIYLROHQWWUHDWPHQWZHUHYLVLEOHRQWKLV
ZRQGHUHGKRZODUJHDURRPRUFORVHWODEHKLQGLWDQGKRZWKH
ZDVDUUDQJHG7KHPDQLDFߞVLGHDRIDWDQNDQGUXQZDZDVDVFO
RWKHULPDJLQLQJV
7KHQLQRQHWHUULEOHLQVWDQW-RQHVFRPSOHWHOORVWWKHSRZHUWR
7KHOHDWKHUEHOWKHKDGVHL]HGIRU5RJHUVߞIXUWKHUVWUDSSLQJIHOOI
KDQGVDQGDVSDVPRIVKLYHULQJFRQYXOVHGKLPIURPKHDGWRIRR
NQRZQWKHSODFHZRXOGGULYHKLPPDGDVLWKDGGULYHQ5RJHUVD
PDG+HZDVPDGIRUKHQRZKDUERUHGKDOOXFLQDWLRQVPRUHZHL
ZKLFKKDGDVVDLOHGKLPHDUOLHUWKDWQLJKW7KHPDGPDQZDVELGG
VSODVKLQJRIDPWKLFDOPRQVWHULQDWDQNEHRQGWKHGRRUߚDQG
KLPKHGLGKHDULW
ߡ$WODVWIRRORXEHOLHYH$WODVWRXNQRZRXKHDU,WDQG,W
PNHVIRROߚZHPXVWGRKRPDJHDQGVHUYH,Wߢ
%XW-RQHVZDVSDVWSDLQJDWWHQWLRQWRDQKXPDQZRUGVPDGR
SDUDOVLVKHOGKLPLPPRELOHDQGKDOIFRQVFLRXVZLWKZLOGLPDJ
IDQWDVPDJRULFDOOWKRXJKKLVKHOSOHVVLPDJLQDWLRQ7KHUHZDVD
ZDVSDGGLQJRUVKXIIOLQJDVRIJUHDWZHWSDZVRQDVROLGVXUIDFH
ZDVDSSURDFKLQJ,QWRKLVQRVWULOVIURPWKHFUDFNVLQWKDWQLJKWP
SRXUHGDQRLVRPHDQLPDOVWHQFKOLNHDQGHWXQOLNHWKDWRIWKHP
WKH]RRORJLFDOJDUGHQVLQ5HJHQWߞV3DUN
+HGLGQRWNQRZQZKHUH5RJHUVZDVWDONLQJRUQRW(YHUWKLQJU
DZDDQGKHZDVDVWDWXHREVHVVHGZLWKGUHDPVDQGKDOOXFLQDWLR
WKDWWKHEHFDPHDOPRVWREMHFWLYHDQGUHPRWHIURPKLP+HWKRX
VQLIILQJRUVQRUWLQJIURPWKHXQNQRZQJXOIEHRQGWKHGRRUDQG
EDLQJWUXPSHWLQJQRLVHDVVDLOHGKLVHDUVKHFRXOGQRWIHHOVXUH
IURPWKHWLJKWOERXQGPDQLDFZKRVHLPDJHVZDPXQFHUWDLQOLQ
YLVLRQ7KHSKRWRJUDSKRIWKDWDFFXUVHGXQVHHQZD[WKLQJSHUVLV
WKURXJKKLVFRQVFLRXVQHVV6XFKDWKLQJKDGQRULJKWWRH[LVW+D
KLPPDG
(YHQDVKHUHIOHFWHGDIUHVKHYLGHQFHRIPDGQHVVEHVHWKLP6RP
WKRXJKWZDVIXPEOLQJZLWKWKHODWFKRIWKHKHDYSDGORFNHGGRR
DQGSDZLQJDQGSXVKLQJDWWKHSODQNV7KHUHZDVDWKXGGLQJRQ
ZKLFKJUHZORXGHUDQGORXGHU7KHVWHQFKZDVKRUULEOH$QGQRZ
WKDWGRRUIURPWKHLQVLGHZDVDPDOLJQGHWHUPLQHGSRXQGLQJOLN
DEDWWHULQJUDP7KHUHZDVDQRPLQRXVFUDFNLQJߚDVSOLQWHULQJߚ
ߚDIDOOLQJSODQNߚDEODFNSDZHQGLQJLQDFUDEOLNHFODZߨ
ߡ+HOS+HOS*RGKHOSPHߨ$DDDDDDߨߢ
:LWKLQWHQVHHIIRUW-RQHVLVWRGDDEOHWRUHFDOODVXGGHQEXUVWLQJ
SDUDOVLVLQWRWKHOLEHUDWLRQRIIUHQ]LHGDXWRPDWLFIOLJKW:KDWKH
PXVWKDYHSDUDOOHOHGFXULRXVOWKHZLOGSOXQJLQJIOLJKWVRIPDG
IRUKHVHHPVWRKDYHOHDSHGDFURVVWKHGLVRUGHUHGFUSWDWDOPRV
DQNHGRSHQWKHRXWVLGHGRRUZKLFKFORVHGDQGORFNHGLWVHOIDIW
+HUHWKHPHPRUHQGV-RQHVGRHVQRWNQRZKRZKHJRWKRPHD
HYLGHQFHRIKLVKDYLQJKLUHGDFDE3UREDEOKHUDFHGDOOWKHZD
LQVWLQFWߚRYHU:DWHUORR%ULGJHDORQJWKH6WUDQGDQGKDULQJ
+DPDUNHWDQG5HJHQW6WUHHWWRKLVRZQQHLJKERUKRRG+HVWLOO
PHODQJHRIPXVHXPFRVWXPHVZKHQKHJUHZFRQVFLRXVHQRXJKW
GRFWRU
$ZHHNODWHUWKHQHUYHVSHFLDOLVWVDOORZHGKLPWROHDYHKLVEHGD
RSHQDLU
%XWKHKDGQRWWROGWKHVSHFLDOLVWVPXFK2YHUKLVZKROHH[SHULH
RIPDGQHVVDQGQLJKWPDUHDQGKHIHOWWKDWVLOHQFHZDVWKHRQOF
ZDVXSKHVFDQQHGLQWHQWODOOWKHSDSHUVZKLFKKDGDFFXPXODWH
KLGHRXVQLJKWEXWIRXQGQRUHIHUHQFHWRDQWKLQJTXHHUDWWKHP
PXFKDIWHUDOOKDGEHHQUHDOLW:KHUHGLGUHDOLWHQGDQGPRUE
EHJLQ+DGKLVPLQGJRQHZKROOWRSLHFHVLQWKDWGDUNH[KLELWLR
KDGWKHZKROHILJKWZLWK5RJHUVEHHQDIDQWDVPRIIHYHU,WZRX
KLPRQKLVIHHWLIKHFRXOGVHWWOHVRPHRIWKHVHPDGGHQLQJSRLQW
VHHQWKDWGDPQDEOHSKRWRJUDSKRIWKHZD[LPDJHFDOOHGߡ,WߢIRU
5RJHUVߞFRXOGHYHUKDYHFRQFHLYHGVXFKDEODVSKHP
,WZDVDIRUWQLJKWEHIRUHKHGDUHGWRHQWHU6RXWKZDUN6WUHHWDJDL
WKHPLGGOHRIWKHPRUQLQJZKHQWKHUHZDVWKHJUHDWHVWDPRXQWR
ZKROHVRPHDFWLYLWDURXQGWKHDQFLHQWFUXPEOLQJVKRSVDQGZD
PXVHXPߞVVLJQZDVVWLOOWKHUHDQGDVKHDSSURDFKHGKHVDZWKDW
VWLOORSHQ7KHJDWHPDQQRGGHGLQSOHDVDQWUHFRJQLWLRQDVKHVXP
FRXUDJHWRHQWHUDQGLQWKHYDXOWHGFKDPEHUEHORZDQDWWHQGDQW
FKHHUIXOO3HUKDSVHYHUWKLQJKDGEHHQDGUHDP:RXOGKHGDUH
GRRURIWKHZRUNURRPDQGORRNIRU5RJHUV
7KHQ2UDERQDDGYDQFHGWRJUHHWKLP+LVGDUNVOHHNIDFHZDVD
EXW-RQHVIHOWWKDWKHZDVQRWXQIULHQGO+HVSRNHZLWKDWUDFHR
ߡ*RRGPRUQLQJ0U-RQHV,WLVVRPHWLPHVLQFHZHKDYHVHHQ
ZLVK0U5RJHUV,ߞPVRUUEXWKHLVDZD+HKDGZRUGRIEXVL
7KHIRUHLJQHUVPLOHGߚSHUKDSVIURPDIIDELOLWDORQH-RQHVVFDUF
WRUHSOEXWPDQDJHGWRPXPEOHRXWDIHZLQTXLULHVDERXWWKHG
YLVLW2UDERQDVHHPHGJUHDWODPXVHGEWKHTXHVWLRQVDQGWRRN
FDUHLQIUDPLQJKLVUHSOLHV
ߡ2KHV0U-RQHVߚWKHWKRIODVWPRQWK,UHPHPEHULWIRUP
WKHPRUQLQJߚEHIRUH0U5RJHUVJRWKHUHRXXQGHUVWDQGߚ,IR
ZRUNURRPLQTXLWHDPHVV7KHUHZDVDJUHDWGHDORIߚFOHDQLQJX
KDGEHHQߚODWHZRUNRXVHH,PSRUWDQWQHZVSHFLPHQJLYHQLWV
EDNLQJSURFHVV,WRRNFRPSOHWHFKDUJHZKHQ,FDPH
ߡ,WZDVDKDUGVSHFLPHQWRSUHSDUHߚEXWRIFRXUVH0U5RJHUVK
JUHDWGHDO+HLVDVRXNQRZDYHUJUHDWDUWLVW:KHQKHFDPH
FRPSOHWHWKHVSHFLPHQߚKHOSHGYHUPDWHULDOO,DVVXUHRXߚE
ZLWKRXWHYHQJUHHWLQJWKHPHQ$V,WHOORXKHZDVFDOOHGDZD
ZHUHLPSRUWDQWFKHPLFDOUHDFWLRQVLQYROYHG7KHPDGHORXGQR
VRPHWHDPVWHUVLQWKHFRXUWRXWVLGHIDQFWKHKHDUGVHYHUDOSLVW
DPXVLQJLGHD
ߡ$VIRUWKHQHZVSHFLPHQߚWKDWPDWWHULVYHUXQIRUXWQDWH,WLV
PDVWHUSLHFHߚGHVLJQHGDQGPDGHRXXQGHUVWDQGE0U5RJHU
DERXWLWZKHQKHJHWVEDFNߢ
$JDLQ2UDERQDVPLOHG
ߡ7KHSROLFHRXNQRZ:HSXWLWRQGLVSODDZHHNDJRDQGWKH
WKUHHIDLQWLQJV2QHSRRUIHOORZKDGDQHSLOHSWLFILWLQIURQWRILW
WULIOHߚVWURQJHUߚWKDQWKHUHVW/DUJHUIRURQHWKLQJ2IFRXUVH
DGXOWDOFRYH7KHQH[WGDDFRXSOHRIPHQIURP6FRWODQGDUGO
DQGVDLGLWZDVWRRPRUELGWREHVKRZQ6DLGZHߞGKDYHWRUHPR
WUHPHQGRXVVKDPHߚVXFKDPDVWHUSLHFHRIDUWߚEXW,GLGQߞWGHHO
DSSHDOLQJWRWKHFRXUWVLQ0U5RJHUVߞDEVHQFH+HZRXOGQRWOLN
SXEOLFLWZLWKWKHSROLFHQRZߚEXWZKHQKHJHWVEDFNߚZKHQKH
)RUVRPHUHDVRQRURWKHU-RQHVIHOWDPRXQWLQJWLGHRIXQHDVLQHV
%XW2UDERQDZDVFRQWLQXLQJ
-RQHVKDGDSRZHUIXOLPSXOVHWRUHIXVHWKHVLJKWDQGIOHHSUHFLSL
2UDERQDZDVOHDGLQJKLPIRUZDUGEWKHDUPZLWKDQDUWLVWߞVHQW
DGXOWDOFRYHFURZGHGZLWKQDPHOHVVKRUURUVKHOGQRYLVLWRUV,Q
FRUQHUDODUJHQLFKHKDGEHHQFXUWDLQHGRIIDQGWRWKLVWKHVPLOLQ
DGYDQFHG
ߡRXPXVWNQRZ0U-RQHVWKDWWKHWLWOHRIWKLVVSHFLPHQLVߝ7K
5KDQ7HJRWKߞߡ
-RQHVVWDUWHGYLROHQWOEXW2UDERQDDSSHDUHGQRWWRQRWLFH
ߡ7KHVKDSHOHVVFRORVVDOJRGLVDIHDWXUHLQFHUWDLQREVFXUHOHJHQ
5RJHUVKDGVWXGLHG$OOQRQVHQVHRIFRXUVHDVRXߞYHVRRIWHQ
5RJHUV,WLVVXSSRVHGWRKDYHFRPHIURPRXWHUVSDFHDQGWRKDY
$UFWLFWKUHHPLOOLRQHDUVDJR,WWUHDWHGLWVVDFULILFHVUDWKHUSHFX
KRUULEODVRXVKDOOVHH0U5RJHUVKDGPDGHLWILHQGLVKOOLIH
WKHIDFHRIWKHYLFWLPߢ
1RZWUHPEOLQJYLROHQWO-RQHVFOXQGWRWKHEUDVVUDLOLQJLQIURQW
QLFKH+HDOPRVWUHDFKHGRXWWRVWRS2UDERQDZKHQKHVDZWKHF
WRVZLQJDVLGHEXWVRPHFRQIOLFWLQJLPSXOVHKHOGKLPEDFN7KH
VPLOHGWULXPSKDQWO
ߡ%HKROGߢ
-RQHVUHHOHGLQVSLWHRIKLVJULSRQWKHUDLOLQJ
ߡ*RGߚJUHDWJRGߢ
)XOOWHQIHHWKLJKGHVSLWHDVKDPEOLQJFURXFKLQJDWWLWXGHH[SUH
FRVPLFPDOLJQDQFDPRQVWURVLWRIXQEHOLHYDEOHKRUURUZDVVK
IRUZDUGIURPDFFORSHDQLYRUWKURQHFRYHUHGZLWKJURWHVTXHF
FHQWUDOSDLURILWVVL[OHJVLWERUHDFUXVKHGIODWWHQHGGLVWRUWHGE
ULGGOHGZLWKDPLOOLRQSXQFWXUHVDQGLQSODFHVVHDUHGDVZLWKVRP
2QOWKHPDQJOHGKHDGRIWKHYLFWLPOROOLQJXSVLGHGRZQDWRQH
WKDWLWUHSUHVHQWHGVRPHWKLQJRQFHKXPDQ
EXEEOHOLNHVXJJHVWLRQRIDKHDGߚWKHWKUHHILVKHHVߚWKHIRRW
ߚWKHEXOJLQJJLOOVߚWKHPRQVWURXVFDSLOODWLRQRIDVSOLNHVXFNH
VLQXRXVOLPEVZLWKWKHLUEODFNSDZVDQGFUDEOLNHFODZVߚ*RG
WKHEODFNSDZHQGLQJLQDFUDEOLNHFODZߨ
2UDERQDߞVVPLOHZDVXWWHUOGDPQDEOH-RQHVFKRNHGDQGVWDUHG
H[KLELWZLWKDPRXQWLQJIDVFLQDWLRQZKLFKSHUSOH[HGDQGGLVWXUE
KDOIUHYHDOHGKRUURUZDVKROGLQJDQGIRUFLQJKLPWRORRNORQJHU
GHWDLOV7KLVKDGGULYHQ5RJHUVPDGߨ5RJHUVVXSUHPHDUWLVWߨ
ZHUHQߞWDUWLILFLDOߨ
7KHQKHORFDOL]HGWKHWKLQJWKDWKHOGKLP,WZDVWKHFUXVKHGZD[
OROOLQJKHDGDQGVRPHWKLQJWKDWLWLPSOLHG7KLVKHDGZDVQRWHQ
DIDFHDQGWKDWIDFHZDVIDPLOLDU,WZDVOLNHWKHPDGIDFHRISRR
SHHUHGFORVHUKDUGONQRZLQJZKKHZDVGULYHQWRGRVR:DVQ
PDGHJRWLVWWRPROGKLVRZQIHDWXUHVLQWRKLVPDVWHUSLHFH:DV
PRUHWKDWVXEFRQVFLRXVYLVLRQKDGVHL]HGRQDQGVXSSUHVVHGLQV
7KHZD[RIWKHPDQJOHGIDFHKDGEHHQKDQGOHGZLWKERXQGOHVVG
SXQFWXUHVߚKRZSHUIHFWOWKHUHSURGXFHGWKHPULDGZRXQGVV
LQIOLFWHGRQWKDWSRRUGRJ%XWWKHUHZDVVRPHWKLQJPRUH2QWK
FRXOGWUDFHDQLUUHJXODULWZKLFKVHHPHGRXWVLGHWKHJHQHUDOVFK
VFXOSWRUKDGVRXJKWWRFRYHUXSDGHIHFWRIKLVILUVWPRGHOOLQJ7
ORRNHGDWLWWKHPRUHPVWHULRXVOLWKRUULILHGKLPߚDQGWKHQVX
UHPHPEHUHGDFLUFXPVWDQFHZKLFKEURXJKWKLVKRUURUWRDKHDG
KLGHRXVQHVVߚWKHWXVVOHߚWKHERXQGPDGPDQߚDQGWKHORQJGH
WKHOHIWFKHHNRIWKHDFWXDOOLYLQJ5RJHUVߨ
-RQHVUHOHDVLQJKLVGHVSHUDWHFOXWFKRQWKHUDLOLQJVDQNLQDWRWD
2UDERQDFRQWLQXHGWRVPLOH
Proof

More Related Content

What's hot

Terms of contract
Terms of contractTerms of contract
Terms of contractFAROUQ
 
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2FAROUQ
 
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & casesPrivity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & casesFAROUQ
 
Quotes & gems of wisdom
Quotes & gems of wisdomQuotes & gems of wisdom
Quotes & gems of wisdomRaj Luitel
 
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lectureVoid and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lectureFAROUQ
 
Discharge lecture
Discharge lectureDischarge lecture
Discharge lectureFAROUQ
 
Remax single family home market reports for team Paris911 focused cities
Remax single family home market reports for team Paris911 focused citiesRemax single family home market reports for team Paris911 focused cities
Remax single family home market reports for team Paris911 focused cities
Connor T. MacIVOR
 
Sfantul Nectarie, Sfantul Iubirii, Iosif D Agapitos
Sfantul Nectarie, Sfantul Iubirii, Iosif D  AgapitosSfantul Nectarie, Sfantul Iubirii, Iosif D  Agapitos
Sfantul Nectarie, Sfantul Iubirii, Iosif D Agapitossokoban
 
Razonamientomatematico
RazonamientomatematicoRazonamientomatematico
Razonamientomatematico
marco gamonal suarez
 
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Abdulsalam Taha
 
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday WorshipFiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Caller To Islam / الداعية الإسلامي
 
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_aliHoly quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_alimfahmy2010
 
Maria montessori
Maria montessori Maria montessori
Maria montessori
elmackay
 
Conditions and System of Government/Official Information in some NATO Countries
Conditions and System of Government/Official Information in some NATO Countries Conditions and System of Government/Official Information in some NATO Countries
Conditions and System of Government/Official Information in some NATO Countries
Ivan Zary
 
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal MuslimThe Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslimzakir2012
 

What's hot (15)

Terms of contract
Terms of contractTerms of contract
Terms of contract
 
Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2Remedies lecture 2
Remedies lecture 2
 
Privity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & casesPrivity lecture & cases
Privity lecture & cases
 
Quotes & gems of wisdom
Quotes & gems of wisdomQuotes & gems of wisdom
Quotes & gems of wisdom
 
Void and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lectureVoid and illegality lecture
Void and illegality lecture
 
Discharge lecture
Discharge lectureDischarge lecture
Discharge lecture
 
Remax single family home market reports for team Paris911 focused cities
Remax single family home market reports for team Paris911 focused citiesRemax single family home market reports for team Paris911 focused cities
Remax single family home market reports for team Paris911 focused cities
 
Sfantul Nectarie, Sfantul Iubirii, Iosif D Agapitos
Sfantul Nectarie, Sfantul Iubirii, Iosif D  AgapitosSfantul Nectarie, Sfantul Iubirii, Iosif D  Agapitos
Sfantul Nectarie, Sfantul Iubirii, Iosif D Agapitos
 
Razonamientomatematico
RazonamientomatematicoRazonamientomatematico
Razonamientomatematico
 
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
Emergency thoracotomy for cardiac or great vessel injuries: a report of 5 cases.
 
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday WorshipFiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
Fiqh-us-Sunnah: Essentials of Everyday Worship
 
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_aliHoly quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
 
Maria montessori
Maria montessori Maria montessori
Maria montessori
 
Conditions and System of Government/Official Information in some NATO Countries
Conditions and System of Government/Official Information in some NATO Countries Conditions and System of Government/Official Information in some NATO Countries
Conditions and System of Government/Official Information in some NATO Countries
 
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal MuslimThe Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
 

Similar to Devansu rathva life_ Biography friend's girlfriend

marcela_paz_Los_pecosos.pdf
marcela_paz_Los_pecosos.pdfmarcela_paz_Los_pecosos.pdf
marcela_paz_Los_pecosos.pdf
andrea771906
 
Module 1.pdf
Module 1.pdfModule 1.pdf
Module 1.pdf
Mohamedshabana38
 
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
ayshaayyoob2003
 
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly 100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
P6P
 
Fiqh us-sunnah
Fiqh us-sunnahFiqh us-sunnah
Fiqh us-sunnah
Noor Al Islam
 
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Connor T. MacIVOR
 
40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi
Ari Khozin
 
Sfantul nectarie sfintul iubirii, minuni necunoscute
Sfantul nectarie   sfintul iubirii, minuni necunoscuteSfantul nectarie   sfintul iubirii, minuni necunoscute
Sfantul nectarie sfintul iubirii, minuni necunoscute
gedeona19
 
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_aliHoly quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_aliF El Mohdar
 
Holy qur'an translation by yusuf ali
Holy qur'an translation by yusuf aliHoly qur'an translation by yusuf ali
Holy qur'an translation by yusuf ali
FAHIM AKTHAR ULLAL
 
The holy quran translation by yusuf ali
The holy quran translation by yusuf aliThe holy quran translation by yusuf ali
The holy quran translation by yusuf aliTengku Puteh Tippi
 

Similar to Devansu rathva life_ Biography friend's girlfriend (18)

marcela_paz_Los_pecosos.pdf
marcela_paz_Los_pecosos.pdfmarcela_paz_Los_pecosos.pdf
marcela_paz_Los_pecosos.pdf
 
Module 1.pdf
Module 1.pdfModule 1.pdf
Module 1.pdf
 
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal MuslimThe Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
 
The Ideal Muslim
The Ideal MuslimThe Ideal Muslim
The Ideal Muslim
 
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fastingFiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
Fiqh us sunnah_zakat_fasting
 
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
A Note On Phillips Curve (The Phillips Curve Was Simply A Set of Observations...
 
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly 100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
100 Ways of Greening your Life - Walk Cheerfully, Step Lightly
 
RESUME
RESUMERESUME
RESUME
 
Fiqh us-sunnah
Fiqh us-sunnahFiqh us-sunnah
Fiqh us-sunnah
 
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
Santa Clarita real estate update by remax of Valencia paris911 team week 2 Se...
 
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
Die kunst der gehirnwascheDie kunst der gehirnwasche
Die kunst der gehirnwasche
 
40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi
 
40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi40 hadeeth qudsi
40 hadeeth qudsi
 
40 hadeeth
40 hadeeth40 hadeeth
40 hadeeth
 
Sfantul nectarie sfintul iubirii, minuni necunoscute
Sfantul nectarie   sfintul iubirii, minuni necunoscuteSfantul nectarie   sfintul iubirii, minuni necunoscute
Sfantul nectarie sfintul iubirii, minuni necunoscute
 
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_aliHoly quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
Holy quran english_translation_by_yusuf_ali
 
Holy qur'an translation by yusuf ali
Holy qur'an translation by yusuf aliHoly qur'an translation by yusuf ali
Holy qur'an translation by yusuf ali
 
The holy quran translation by yusuf ali
The holy quran translation by yusuf aliThe holy quran translation by yusuf ali
The holy quran translation by yusuf ali
 

Devansu rathva life_ Biography friend's girlfriend