This course will prepare microfinance practitioners to understand and provide financial and non-financial services to rural and urban youth. The course will introduce participants to best practices for serving youth, help them to understand the differences between rural and urban youth financial service provision, and detail specific products and service delivery models. To ground the information in concrete examples, the training will also involve a live case study component, where participants will be able to engage with representatives of financial institutions in the MENA region that are currently offering financial services to youth.
Vip B Aizawl Call Girls #9907093804 Contact Number Escorts Service Aizawl
Designing and Delivering Youth-inclusive Financial Service
1. 3/29/2016 1
#18MCSummit
Designing and Delivering
Youth Inclusive Financial
Services
with a special focus on rural youth
Timothy H. Nourse:
Making Cents International
Sponsored by the International Fund for Agricultural Development
2. 3/29/2016 2
#18MCSummit
Social Enterprise that increases
economic opportunity and
financial inclusion worldwide
Provides training and capacity
building technical assistance to
international and local institutions
Focuses on youth, women,
farmers, and growing enterprises
BuildsYouth Economic
Opportunity field through
conferences, research, and
hosting of on-line learning
platform.
Making Cents
3. 3/29/2016 33/29/2016 3
#18MCSummit
International Fund for
Agricultural Development
IFAD is dedicated to eradicating rural poverty in developing
countries
IFAD provides loans and grants to governments, and is involved in
project design and direct implementation support
Key areas of IFAD’s investments are rural financial services,
agricultural development, irrigation, livestock, markets and
infrastructure
Since its inception, the Fund has:
Mobilized around USD 21.9 billion in co-financing from domestic sources, in
addition to IFAD’s contribution of about USD 14.7 billion in loans and grants,
with the current total investment reaching USD 13 billion
Supported 924 programmes and projects in 119 countries, including 267
projects in 98 countries in the current portfolio
Empowered over 400 million people to break out of poverty
IFAD funded the RYEE program – whose case studies you’ll be
learning about today
4. 3/29/2016 43/29/2016 4
#18MCSummit
Silatech
Silatech is a regional social initiative that works to create jobs and
expand economic opportunities for young Arabs.
Silatech promotes large-scale job creation, entrepreneurship, access
to capital and markets, and the participation and engagement of
young people in economic and social development.
Since being founded in 2008, Silatech has financed over 100,000
youth-owned businesses, and created or sustained over 180,000
jobs.
Silatech currently has programs in 15 Arab countries, including
Algeria, Egypt, Iraq, Jordan, Lebanon, Libya, Morocco, Palestine,
Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Sudan, Syria,Tunisia andYemen.
For more information, please visit www.silatech.com.
IFAD co-funded the RYEE program – whose case studies you’ll be
learning about today
5. 3/29/2016 53/29/2016 5
#18MCSummit
Agenda
Timing Session
9:00-9:30 Introduction to objectives of course and RYEEP
9:30-10:00 Youth – their financial and non-financial needs,
differentiated by segment and geography (urban/rural)
10:00-10:30 General Principles for servingYouth
10:30-11:00 Product Design Process
11:00-11:30 Break
11:30-12:30 Financial Services Product Development
12:30-1:30 Lunch
1:30-2:30 Non-Financial Services Product Development
2:30-3:00 Special Case –Value Chain Financing
3:00-3:30 Break
3:30-4:15 Case Study
4:15-4:30 The Future ofYFS
6. 3/29/2016 6
#18MCSummit
Bringing out the
Youth in You
First job
How old were you?
What was the job?
How much money did you earn?
First time you visited a financial
institution
How old were you?
What were you there to do?
What was your impression of the FI?
7. 3/29/2016 7
#18MCSummit
Financial Services and Youth:
Financial services help youth
to:
Build assets
Contribute to the household
Develop positive habits and
skills
Facilitate education and
employment
Maintain employment
8. 3/29/2016 83/29/2016 8
#18MCSummit
Youth Segments and
Demand for FS
Youth Segment
Demand for Financial Services
Savings Credit Insurance
Early adolescence
(Ages 12-18)
Late adolescence
(Ages 18-24)
Young Adulthood
(Ages 25-30…)
9. 3/29/2016 93/29/2016 9
#18MCSummit
Youth Segments and
Demand for FS
Youth Segment
Demand for Financial Services
Savings Credit Insurance
Early adolescence
(Ages 12-18)
Moderate Low NA
Late adolescence
(Ages 18-24)
High Moderate Low
Young Adulthood
(Ages 25-30…)
High High Moderate
* Age range is contextual
** Parenthood accelerates transition toYoung Adulthood
***Gender also impacts segments
10. 3/29/2016 10
#18MCSummit
Rural Youth
More a question of
underemployment, then
unemployment
Little access to land
More traditional roles
Lower educational levels
Stronger community structures
11. 3/29/2016 113/29/2016 11
#18MCSummit
Current State of
FS Access for youth
• Youth are 33% less likely to have an account at a
formal financial institution
• Youth are 40% less likely to have saved at a formal
financial institution
12. 3/29/2016 123/29/2016 12
#18MCSummit
Activity:
What’s holding us back?
Discuss in small groups the opportunities and challenges of
providing financial services to youth at the:
Client Level
Institutional Level
Enabling Environment and Policy level
How are these opportunities and challenges affected by trying to
serve rural youth?
Ask one person to take notes and be prepared to report out.
Level
Questions
Opportunity? Challenge? Rural implications?
Client
Institutional
Enabling Environment
13. 3/29/2016 13
#18MCSummit
Key Issues – Client Level
Opportunities
Youth demand FS to
manage risks, plan for
the future, and transition
through life phases
Technologically savvy.
Parental/community
support
Challenges
• Perception that FIs are not for
them
• Accessing FIs
• Financial Illiteracy
• Lower volumes demanded
17. 3/29/2016 17
#18MCSummit
Key Issues – Enabling
Environment
Challenges
Age of Majority
Identification and
documentation requirements
Inadequate consumer
protection regimes
Opportunities
Growing interest in serving
youth among central banks
18. 3/29/2016 18
#18MCSummit
Rural Finance Issues
Client:
Seasonality of income and cash
flows
Seasonal migration
Lack of trust in outside institutions
Institutional:
Agricultural activities dependent
on weather and markets
Geographic dispersion of
populations
Poor infrastructure
Enabling Environment:
• Government subsidies/agricultural
policies may help or hinder ag.
19. 3/29/2016 19
#18MCSummit
1. Involve youth In market research and
product development
2. Develop products and services that
reflect diversity of youth
3. Ensure that youth have safe and
supportive spaces
4. Provide or link youth to
complementary non-financial services
5. Focus on core competencies through
partnerships
6. Involve community
7. Establish Institutional Readiness
Principles Developed in concert with:
Emerging Guidelines for
Youth-Inclusive FS
22. 3/29/2016 22
#18MCSummit
Market Research
Recruit a diverse team, including
Youth experts
Use process oriented activities
that help youth process and
depersonalize data
Mix of data gathering techniques
For customers, conduct research
at household level to determine
youth and parent views
Use research to segment market
Young People’s Capacity to Co-
Invest
The use of “money flow” or “asset
mapping” focus group tools are an
effective way of gaining insight into
the kinds of financial and non-financial
assets young people manage. A
microfinance institution in Morocco
that was interested in developing
livelihood programming for youth was
amazed to see the multiple sources of
funds that passed through “poor”
young people’s hands.
23. 3/29/2016 23
#18MCSummit
Roll Out and Evaluation
Roll Out:
Adjust product based on pilot
Similar process to pilot plan,
but on scale of full FI
Preparation, training and
marketing critical to success
Evaluation:
On-going analysis of business
case
Direct profit/loss
Cross-selling
Loyalty
Demonstrate CSR
Impact on clients
Financial knowledge
Financial Behavior
Financial Status
24. 3/29/2016 24
#18MCSummit
Some Successful Products
Hatton National Bank
• School banking program
• 503,000 youth savers
Equity Bank – Kenya
• Business loan and youth savings product
• 74,000 loan clients, 140,000 savers
Xac Bank – Mongolia
• Adolescent girl savings account
• 8,000 clients
25. 3/29/2016 253/29/2016 25
#18MCSummit
Rural Youth Economic Empowerment
Project
3Year Learning Project Funding by IFAD and Silatech
5 pilot projects in 4 countries
By project end – over 20,000 youth served with financial services
and almost 15,000 with non-financial services
Country Local Partner
(Institutional Type)
Financial Instrument Non-Financial Instrument
Egypt Plan Egypt
(NGO)
Savings and Credit
Groups
Entrepreneurship and life skills training
offered through Savings Groups
Yemen
Al Amal Bank
(Microfinance Bank)
Enterprise Lending (for
existing businesses)
Financial literacy, entrepreneurship and
technical training offered by NGO partners
Morocco
Al Barid Bank
(Postal Bank)
Individual Savings
Product
Financial literacy training offered through
mass media and face-to-face training
Tunisia
Microcred
(Microfinance Company)
Enterprise Lending (for
start-up businesses)
Entrepreneurship and business
management training offered by NGO
partners
Tunisia
Pro-Invest
(Private Company)
Value Chain Finance
(Trade Credit)
Value Chain Development,
Entrepreneurship and financial literacy
training offered through SMS
26. 3/29/2016 263/29/2016 26
#18MCSummit
The 9 “P”s of Product Design
1. Product:The terms and conditions of the loan or savings product. (the loan
tenor, repayment frequency, application documentation, collateral requirements
etc.)
2. Price:The cost of the product to the end user, set at a level to cover FSP costs
(includes interest rate, fees, penalties, transaction costs, etc.)
3. People:The management and training of the full range of people involved in
delivering the product (human resources; hiring, training, performance
monitoring, etc.)
4. Promotion: How the product is presented to the client (marketing,
advertising, public relations, including formats and delivery channels)
5. Positioning:Competitive advantage or niche in relation to other
products/institutions as perceived by the target customer
6. Place:The product distribution and delivery channels (branches, outreach
workers or field agents,ATMs, mobile units, phones)
7. Physical evidence:The paper or digital requirements for usage (passbook,
promissory note, etc.)
8. Process: How the product is delivered (systems, manuals, operating
procedures, forms, queues, turnaround time)
9. Preparation: Design of non-financial service package to enable the client to
use the product most effectively (e.g. financial literacy, business training; links to
other resources)
27. 3/29/2016 27
#18MCSummit
RYEEP 9”P”s Case Studies
Each RYEEP representative will:
Provide an overview of their
institution
Describe their business case
Describe the market research
and product development
process they followed
Present their product as per the
9P model
Take questions
28. 3/29/2016 28
#18MCSummit
Linking Activity
Each pair receives 4 tiles
Connect your 4 tiles to make a
square
Once connected; find another
pair that has made a square and
combine them into a square or
rectangle (you may need to
rearrange your pieces);
Once connected, find another
pair that has made a square and
connect them and combine
them into a square or rectangle
(you may need to rearrange
your pieces)
If your stuck – you can trade
pieces with the facilitator
29. 3/29/2016 293/29/2016 29
#18MCSummit
The 11 “S”s of Curriculum and
Training Delivery System Design
1. Student: Profile of learners, literacy levels, and learning preferences
2. Setting: Conditions, timing, and pacing of delivery
3. Scale:Content and time to deliver
4. Sequence:Other curricular content before or after this training
5. Scope: Knowledge, Skills, andAttitudes contained in curriculum
6. Style: Learning/teaching methodology
7. Skill-set: Skills needed to deliver, supervise, and coordinate the rollout of training program
8. Sale: How much of the organization, marketing, funding, and delivering can be cost recovered
9. Supplies: Supporting materials (training guides, TOT guides, participant takeaways, facilitation
materials, equipment/ technology, M&E tools)
10. Systems: Delivery system, monitoring, and capacity building
11. Success:Assessment of the reach, depth, and quality of outcomes and impacts
30. 3/29/2016 30
#18MCSummit
RYEEP 11”S” Case Studies
In each group, the RYEEP
representative will:
Describe the findings from their
market research that related to
knowledge, skills or attitudes
Describe the NFS product
development and piloting
process
Present the NFS as per the 11S
model
Take Questions
31. 3/29/2016 313/29/2016 31
#18MCSummit
RYEEP Lessons Learned
Serving rural youth effectively will require both youth
and rural adaptations.
IntegrateYFS into rural strategies..
Use different approaches for different age groups.
Target NFS carefully and engage partners to meet
remaining needs.
Subsidize start-ups.
Engage new partners and innovative technologies.
33. 3/29/2016 33
#18MCSummit
YFS–RemainingChallenges
andPotentialSolutions
Challenges
The Business Case
Financing Programs that Build
Financial Capability
Developing regulations that
balance access with protection
Developing a suite of products
that “grow” as youth do
Scaling up products
Solutions
Behavioral economic models
providing promising
approaches
Technology may be enabler,
though how to use it effectively
for youth remains a question
Mainstreaming youth into
financial service provision
strategies for households
provides promising strategy
Describe Making Cents
Making Cents is an international development consulting firm. We consider ourselves a social enterprise because we do some of our work on a for-profit basis and some on a not-for-profit basis, depending on the donor and the type of work.
At our core, we are a training and capacity building company – we build the capacity of local institutions – whether banks, microfinance institutions, ministries, or NGOs to use experiential and applied learning models to better serve youth, women, farmers and growing businesses with training programs or financial products.
On our not-for profit side, we are known as knowledge management experts in the area of youth economic opportunity. Our global Youth Economic Opportunity Summit attracts over 400 participants and our learning platform over 30,000 practitioners and funders; it serves as a hub for stakeholders to share information on youth inclusive financial services approaches, entrepreneurship initiatives and workforce development programs.
It was this combination of expertise on youth, financial services and knowledge management that led us to work with IFAD on this initiative.
So how are we doing? Not well.
The Findex information gathering exercise has begun to scratch the surface and since it just started, can’t tell us changes since a focus on YFS began. However, in general, we know that most institutions are serving youth, however only a minority have youth specific financial services that reach a substantial number of youth, and that there is substantial unmet demand.
Through market research and through the experiences of pioneering organizations, we have seen several general trends for how young people behave and what they want with respect to engaging in financial services.
We know that youth are in fact economically active and that youth are looking for the kinds of financial services that can help them manage shocks, plan for the future, and transition through life phases such as moving into the workforce or seeking higher education. Research indicates that savings, more so than other products, can help youth manage their consumption, emergency, educational, and basic family needs, and can also help them cover the costs of such important life events as marriages and funerals
Young people have different aspirations and needs and they often talk about activities that will require further learning whether through formal institutions like universities and technical schools or through apprenticeships. This has implications for how a product may be designed to suit those aspirations. For example in Kenya and Bangladesh, girls want to pursue secondary or higher level as well as technical education. Although trends show that there is a preference for savings products to help young people do this, in some cases they may need access to adapted credit products to achieve these goals. Young people also show interest in credit products to start a business, build a home, or pay for school fees.
Examples: Camfed, a Zambian NGO, promotes the development of young women through mentoring, loans and grants so that they are able to build houses, engage in farming, or run small businesses. Twenty percent of their youth clients use profits made from their businesses to further their own education. In Uganda, Equity Bank and Banyan Global provide youth with access to credit to help students pay term fees, which are one of the key barriers to enrolment for potential nursing students ages 17-24. (ANECDOTE: In Palestine, we are conducting market research, but have not yet determined if loans or savings are preferred. We do know that saving whether through asset accumulation (land and gold) or decreasing ones expenditures, Palestinian youth already sight various ways in which they practice savings.
2. Youth are also looking for friendly, convenient, secure and low-cost services. In a recent USAID MicroReport, it was reported that youth demand for savings services is fairly similar to what low-income adults want – convenient access, relative security, liquidity in case of emergencies, and a secure place to accumulate larger sums. This means that they are looking for services that can meet their need to deposit very small amounts, without having to pay transaction fees and/or a small minimum opening requirement. After conducting market research with their target market segment, XacBank in Mongolia realized that they needed to “go to where the girls were” in order to engage them, and they were in schools. Xac Bank in Mongolia has since partnered with schools to provide financial education and savings accounts with no fees or minimum deposits to young girls in Mongolia.
In terms of convenience, young people are often time also located far from branches, or have limited mobility to reach branch and so financial service providers may have to find innovative ways to make access as easy and as convenient as possible. Financial service providers like BRAC, have implemented doorstep collection, where in order to continue engaging girls in savings even with limited mobility.
3. Young people need information that is presented in a way that appeals to them in order to help them better understand their available options and make choices that are right for them. There are a variety of decisions that young people can make regarding their livelihoods, and they must be well informed about services available. This includes understanding the risks as well as the benefits. It also means having fair expectations around the service and knowing when and where they can access it. In a market research study done in the West Bank, of the individuals who did not bank due to lack of banking information, 65% of them were between the ages of 15-17 years of age. When it comes to financial services, youth want to be informed in order to manage and keep their finances safe.
ADDITIONAL NOTES TO CONSIDER FOR A DIFFERENT PRESENTATION
Like financial institutions, girls also face particular challenges. One of those is mobility and learning about services. Rules around girls’ movements are more stringent than rules governing where boys go and when they girl. As such, girls may not find out about opportunities because they are not outside their homes. Plus girls may have less an opportunity to interact directly with the financial institution. Flexible hours and providing a reputable place for girls to spend time will help girls reach financial institutions. Messaging that can reach into homes through radio, TV, or text messaging will help ensure that girls are accessing information about the availability of services. Finally, making bank branches places that inspire confidence among parents and community members are important investments in making services accessible for girls. Expectations around girls’ behavior are very high, and as such girls must often seek permission to go places. Proving to parents that the bank is a place where girls will learn and grow rather than be exposed to activities deemed inappropriate will also help girls negotiate with their family and seek permission to access services.
2009 – Making Cents did a survey with 150 institutions globally.
So what are the challenges that are facing these suppliers?
According to these institutions, there is no lack of demand by youth for financial services!
The top challenge identified, is interestingly enough, attitudinal, and an attitude that is held by providers’ own staff! Staff training, support, and motivation are all crucial to attracting youth to financial products and retaining them as clients. Also, getting buy-in from leadership and middle management is also essential. Another barrier that appears not so easily addressed or within control of management of providers, and that is legal and regulatory barriers to serving youth—which may be to offering savings at all or minors not being able to sign legal contracts. Even in these cases, many institutions have found ways to provide financial services to youth through creative solutions. Finally, 42% of financial service providers surveyed still perceive youth as a high risk market. (Note to presenter: Go to next slide to address perception of youth as a high risk market)
23% of young adults reported lack of necessary documentation vs.
16% of adults ages 25-64
What’s the competition for the youth market
Will regulations make it easy/hard to serve youth
What are the opportunity costs of serving youth as compared to other markets
Do you have the capacity and infarstructure to serve youth? Is it part of your mission?
What is your time horizon for profitability – it should be longer if you intend to serve youth
Who do you want to target (18-25 easier than 12-18)
Cost of marketing, cost of product development, cost of delivery
Effective youth workers can teach us a lot about approaching young people as “actors” and “decision makers” in their own lives – and not simply as passive beneficiaries. They can model for us how to facilitate young people through a step by step process of (i) surfacing their knowledge and experiences; (ii) organizing and structuring it; and then (iii) analyzing, prioritizing and/or making systematic sense of what they have shared. They can show us how to avoid common pitfalls such as prompting youth to give us the answers they think we wan to hear, or of not understanding the complex group dynamics among youth as they slowly build trust with each other and with us, their facilitator.
Business case – providing financial services to youth is expensive due to low savings balances and demand for borrowing – how can we drive down costs that will improve the business case?
Financial Capability – to use finance effectively, young people need to develop knowledge and behaviors. What’s effective, who should deliver it and how will we pay for services?
Regulations – for youth, especially below the age of majority (often 18), regulations designed to protect often restrict access to services. How can the two be balanced
“Growing Products” – youth need for financial services evolves over time, but the product mix in many developing countries doesn’t – perhaps offering a kiddie account at a young age, but nothing afterwards until adulthood. Youth start-ups are particularly poorly served, with few credit or equity products available to the next generation of entrepreneurs
Scale – Most YFS programs are limited to a single institution and with limited scale – what innovations will enable more scaleable programs?
Many YFS resources available on youtheconomicopportunities.org . Major discussions at youth economic opportunity conference