The document discusses curriculum integration (CI) in middle school education. It provides context on the history of CI, including that the concept first gained popularity in the early 20th century but was later discarded in favor of more traditional methods. The document defines CI according to the National Middle School Association as organizing curriculum around significant problems and issues without regard for subject area lines. It then discusses advocates of CI and research that shows potential benefits for student engagement and achievement when incorporating CI into middle school curriculum.
This document provides an introduction and table of contents for the book "Sociology of Education Today" edited by Jack Demaine. The book contains 11 chapters written by various authors on topics within the sociology of education. The introduction provides background on the editor and acknowledges those who contributed to and supported the work. The table of contents lists the titles of the 11 chapters and their authors.
Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...Andrea Lagalisse
This document summarizes a research paper about supporting motivation for educational change in Ontario public schools. It explores how motivation relates to education and why systemic or "whole-system" change is needed. It discusses theories of social constructivism and sociocultural learning, and examines examples of educational reforms in Finland and Alberta. The document argues that a slow, whole-system approach is needed to change educational philosophy, policy, and practice towards more participatory, relevant, and learner-centered models of teaching and learning.
The document summarizes key aspects of sociological theories of education including functionalism, Marxism, feminism, and interactionism. It also examines research on social class, gender, and ethnicity in relation to differential educational achievement. Some of the studies discussed include Douglas (1964, 1970) on social class differences, Bernstein (1960) on language and social class, and Sharpe (1976, 1994) on changes in expectations for girls over time.
The document summarizes the major debates around curriculum in American education from 1900 to the present. It discusses four major perspectives: the humanists who advocated for a classical curriculum focused on the humanities; the social efficiency educators who wanted schools to produce students ready for the workforce; the developmentalists who believed curriculum should follow child development; and the social meliorists who saw schools as vehicles for social change. Key figures like Dewey attempted to synthesize these perspectives, while advocates for progressive education criticized rigid, subject-focused curriculum.
This document contains a pedagogic creed written by Kylie Bass that outlines their beliefs about education in 5 articles. The key points made are that education develops knowledge and skills to benefit society, the purpose is to enlighten citizens and strengthen government, and the school socializes children into roles to serve the social system. The subject matter should prepare students for the future and develop strengths and weaknesses. Teachers should utilize the hidden curriculum to help the transition to work and citizenship, and the method of teaching should engage the student and develop their powers. Finally, education is the means for social progress and reform by providing knowledge to impact social conditions.
The document summarizes the development of the American curriculum from 1830 to the present. It describes the common school movement from 1830-1890 which aimed to provide universal public education. It then discusses the influence of various interest groups on the curriculum, including humanists, social efficiency educators, developmentalists, and social meliorists. John Dewey is discussed as trying to synthesize these positions and advocating for a pragmatic, problem-solving approach focused on the interests and experiences of students.
Progressive education emerged in the early 20th century based on principles of social reform, children's interests and needs, and opposed autocratic teaching methods. Two main influences were John Dewey who founded a laboratory school emphasizing student choice, and Maria Montessori who believed education activities could influence development. During this era, schools became more diverse but many immigrant and minority students faced punishment for their native languages and disrespect of their cultures. The progressive education movement declined after WWII as its approach was seen as too soft.
Reconstructionism, education and curriculummasoud5912
Reconstructionism aims to use education to reform and improve society. It argues that schools should not claim political neutrality, but rather empower students and teachers to critically examine issues and work towards constructive social change. Reconstructionism wants curriculum to address real-world problems and teach students to be informed citizens who can enhance opportunities for all. It sees the classroom as a place for democratic debate and believes education has a role in strengthening society for the interests of the majority.
This document provides an introduction and table of contents for the book "Sociology of Education Today" edited by Jack Demaine. The book contains 11 chapters written by various authors on topics within the sociology of education. The introduction provides background on the editor and acknowledges those who contributed to and supported the work. The table of contents lists the titles of the 11 chapters and their authors.
Change for Motivation_Support for New Pedagogies of Teaching and Learning in ...Andrea Lagalisse
This document summarizes a research paper about supporting motivation for educational change in Ontario public schools. It explores how motivation relates to education and why systemic or "whole-system" change is needed. It discusses theories of social constructivism and sociocultural learning, and examines examples of educational reforms in Finland and Alberta. The document argues that a slow, whole-system approach is needed to change educational philosophy, policy, and practice towards more participatory, relevant, and learner-centered models of teaching and learning.
The document summarizes key aspects of sociological theories of education including functionalism, Marxism, feminism, and interactionism. It also examines research on social class, gender, and ethnicity in relation to differential educational achievement. Some of the studies discussed include Douglas (1964, 1970) on social class differences, Bernstein (1960) on language and social class, and Sharpe (1976, 1994) on changes in expectations for girls over time.
The document summarizes the major debates around curriculum in American education from 1900 to the present. It discusses four major perspectives: the humanists who advocated for a classical curriculum focused on the humanities; the social efficiency educators who wanted schools to produce students ready for the workforce; the developmentalists who believed curriculum should follow child development; and the social meliorists who saw schools as vehicles for social change. Key figures like Dewey attempted to synthesize these perspectives, while advocates for progressive education criticized rigid, subject-focused curriculum.
This document contains a pedagogic creed written by Kylie Bass that outlines their beliefs about education in 5 articles. The key points made are that education develops knowledge and skills to benefit society, the purpose is to enlighten citizens and strengthen government, and the school socializes children into roles to serve the social system. The subject matter should prepare students for the future and develop strengths and weaknesses. Teachers should utilize the hidden curriculum to help the transition to work and citizenship, and the method of teaching should engage the student and develop their powers. Finally, education is the means for social progress and reform by providing knowledge to impact social conditions.
The document summarizes the development of the American curriculum from 1830 to the present. It describes the common school movement from 1830-1890 which aimed to provide universal public education. It then discusses the influence of various interest groups on the curriculum, including humanists, social efficiency educators, developmentalists, and social meliorists. John Dewey is discussed as trying to synthesize these positions and advocating for a pragmatic, problem-solving approach focused on the interests and experiences of students.
Progressive education emerged in the early 20th century based on principles of social reform, children's interests and needs, and opposed autocratic teaching methods. Two main influences were John Dewey who founded a laboratory school emphasizing student choice, and Maria Montessori who believed education activities could influence development. During this era, schools became more diverse but many immigrant and minority students faced punishment for their native languages and disrespect of their cultures. The progressive education movement declined after WWII as its approach was seen as too soft.
Reconstructionism, education and curriculummasoud5912
Reconstructionism aims to use education to reform and improve society. It argues that schools should not claim political neutrality, but rather empower students and teachers to critically examine issues and work towards constructive social change. Reconstructionism wants curriculum to address real-world problems and teach students to be informed citizens who can enhance opportunities for all. It sees the classroom as a place for democratic debate and believes education has a role in strengthening society for the interests of the majority.
Reconstructionism is an educational philosophy that aims to use education to improve society and address social problems. It was developed in reaction to World War II and focuses on empowering students to envision a better future and prepare for roles in bringing about positive social change. Reconstructionism emphasizes using curricula focused on civic duties, ethics, and real-world issues to develop problem-solving and critical thinking skills. Teachers act as facilitators and social change agents rather than just instructors. Student evaluation is based on their ability to be social activists rather than test scores. However, critics argue that reconstructionism lacks detail on implementation and may be more relevant at advanced education levels.
Theorizing 21st century education reimersLuzuko Maseko
This document summarizes curriculum reforms in 6 countries that have expanded educational goals to include broader competencies beyond cognitive skills. It finds that while countries like Singapore, China, and India have clearly defined new competencies, challenges remain in implementing reforms fully in practice. Countries also took different approaches, from consultations with stakeholders in China to standardized testing pressures influencing changes in the US and Chile. Overall educational aspirations have grown but schools still struggle to meet all new demands.
The document summarizes major events in the history of education reform in the United States from the 1950s to present day, focusing on increased recognition of students' individual rights. It discusses key court cases like Brown v. Board of Education that desegregated schools and Tinker v. Des Moines that established free speech rights for students. Major federal education laws like the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, Education for All Handicapped Children Act, Goals 2000, and No Child Left Behind Act are also summarized along with ongoing debates around standardization and accountability versus flexibility and local control in education policy.
Progressive education began in the early 20th century as a reform movement aimed at moral and social transformation through child-centered educational approaches. It grew from the philosophies of thinkers like John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Major early proponents included John Dewey and Maria Montessori. In the 1930s, the Eight-Year Study found that progressive education was as effective at preparing students for college as traditional methods. While progressive education waned in popularity in the 1950s, many of its values and approaches saw a resurgence in the 1960s and continue to influence education today.
Social studies is the integrated study of the social sciences and humanities to promote civic competence. Within K-12 education, social studies provides coordinated lessons drawing on disciplines like history, economics, geography, civics, and others. The primary goal is to help students develop the skills, knowledge, and values to be informed and engaged democratic citizens.
The document discusses the role of culture and socialization in education. It outlines several key agents of socialization, including the family, peer groups, schools, and media. It notes trends like increasing numbers of working mothers, single-parent families, and latchkey children that impact family dynamics. Within schools, it examines student roles, hidden curriculums, and passive forms of learning. Gender roles and differences in achievement between boys and girls are also addressed.
Reconstructionism aims to reconstruct society through education. It believes that education should prepare students to address social, political, and economic problems and reconstruct society. Major reconstructionist educators include Theodore Brameld, George Counts, and Paulo Freire who saw schools as agents of social and political change. Reconstructionism is based on the philosophical perspective of pragmatism and aims to reflect democratic ideals through curriculum focused on civic education, real social problems, and controversial issues to improve quality of life. The role of the teacher is as a social change activist and facilitator.
This document provides a brief history of education reform in America from the 19th century to present day. It discusses how education has changed from an emphasis on memorization and the 3 R's to preparing students for a digital global economy. Key figures like Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Horace Mann, John Dewey, and Maria Montessori influenced education philosophy and approaches. Federal involvement has increased through acts like Brown v. Board, ESEA, and NCLB to address issues like desegregation, funding, and standards. Current trends integrate technology while older approaches come and go. Challenges remain around teacher and funding issues against a backdrop of constant reform debates.
Durkheim argued that education serves two main functions: creating social solidarity and teaching specialist skills. It creates social solidarity by transmitting a society's shared culture from one generation to the next. It teaches individuals specialist skills and knowledge needed to perform their roles in the social division of labor. Parsons viewed education as preparing individuals to move from family to wider society by judging people based on meritocratic principles of equal opportunity and achievement rather than ascription. Davis and Moore argued education "sifts and sorts" individuals by ability, allocating the most able to the most important and highly rewarded social roles.
The document discusses several key issues in education including special education, choice of teachers, school uniforms, discipline, diversity, and the civic mission of schools. It notes that education requires well-defined ethics and values. Some of the major moral and ethical issues faced include resources for special education, disputes over teacher assignments, debates around imposing school uniforms, and how to properly address diversity among students. Overall, the document examines important challenges in education from an ethical standpoint.
Common trends and divergences in the evolution and development of social stud...Alexander Decker
This document discusses the evolution and development of social studies education in Nigeria and South Africa. It provides background on the introduction of social studies in Nigeria in the 1960s to replace traditional history and geography teaching. It then examines the nature of social studies, how it integrates concepts from various social sciences and humanities to address societal problems. The document also outlines the key developments in social studies in Nigeria, including its adoption in the national curriculum in 1969 and efforts by government agencies to develop the Nigerian social studies program. In conclusion, it briefly touches on social studies education in South Africa as well.
- Education both shapes and is shaped by society. It both preserves existing social structures but can also help drive social change, especially when aimed at disadvantaged groups.
- While education typically reflects the existing social order, reformers argue it should aim to transform society by promoting values of equality, cooperation, and social progress.
- Multiple factors influence the relationship between education and social change, including political systems, economic conditions, urbanization, and access to education across all segments of society. Education alone is not sufficient to create social change but is an important tool when combined with other reforms.
Kawthoolei educational system should be ( Presentation by Johnson)JohnsonKawThooLei
This presentation indicates the history of Karen educational background and students ideas towards the journey of future Karen education transformation
This document provides an overview of different sociological perspectives on education including functionalism, Marxism, and the new right view. It also examines how factors like social class, ethnicity, and gender can influence educational achievement. Specific topics covered include the role of material and cultural deprivation in social class differences, the contribution of internal and external factors related to ethnicity and gender, and the impact of policies like marketization. The document is intended as a reference for sociological analyses of education.
This document discusses international development education and inclusive education policies in the country of Lesotho. It provides background on global agreements regarding education for all. As a Peace Corps volunteer in Lesotho, the author worked to implement inclusive education policies for students with disabilities in primary schools. This was attractive due to existing traditions of supporting all community members and lack of resources for special schools. Challenges included beliefs that some disabilities were contagious or cursed. The author overcame challenges by understanding the local history, language and culture. Inclusive education was well-supported by Lesotho's collectivist culture and female teacher workforce. The document advocates for educational approaches that are decided locally while facilitating international idea sharing.
The document discusses key events and developments in education between 1900-1950. Some highlights include:
- In the early 1900s, higher education institutions were established in the US to promote higher standards for universities.
- Mary McLeod Bethune founded a school for African American girls in 1904 that later merged and became Bethune-Cookman University.
- Alfred Binet and Theodore Simon created the Binet-Simon intelligence test in 1905 to identify students with mental retardation.
- John Dewey emerged as a leading progressive education philosopher in the early 1900s, advocating for experiential and problem-based learning approaches.
Critical pedagogy began as an approach to education developed by Paulo Freire that focuses on issues of social justice and empowering oppressed groups. It views traditional education as replicating societal oppression and aims to develop critical thinking in students so they can work to transform society. Key aspects include rejecting discrimination, viewing knowledge as socially constructed rather than objective, and using problem-posing methods where students and teachers jointly analyze problems and their social causes. For teacher education, critical pedagogy emphasizes preparing teachers to address sociocultural issues, promote reflection on social positions, and develop critical consciousness in students to enable social justice work.
This document discusses definitions of education from various scholars and aims of educational institutions. It defines education as the process of passing social heritage from one generation to another and socializing children into the rules of their society. Education is also described as shaping child development with a society's ideals of life. The document outlines different types of educational institutions like schools, colleges, and universities. It lists the basic aims of education as developing power and skills, pursuing virtue and truth, and finding lasting truths.
This document discusses several educational philosophies and their implications for curriculum. It begins by defining philosophy of education and its focus on questions around the purpose and function of education. It then examines the philosophies of perennialism, essentialism, progressivism, and reconstructionism. For each philosophy, it outlines their core beliefs and implications for curriculum, such as their views on subject emphasis, teaching methods, and the role of education in society.
PROGRESSIVISM, THE PROGRESSIVISM CURRICULUM, RECONSTRUCTIONISM THE RECONSTRUC...angeloasuncion0327
Progressivism and reconstructionism are philosophies that aim to make education more relevant to students' real lives and social issues. Progressivism focuses on learning through real-life activities and experiences, with the teacher as facilitator. Reconstructionism believes education should teach students how to reform society and address problems like poverty, racism, and war. Both philosophies emphasize using curriculum centered around students' interests to develop critical thinking skills and prepare students for social participation and change.
The document discusses the philosophy of progressivism in education. It advocates for a student-centered approach where the teacher acts as a facilitator. According to progressivism, students should be problem-solvers and learn through hands-on projects and real-world problem solving rather than standardized tests and facts. The author believes their classroom approach aligns with progressivism by training students in critical thinking and providing resources for exploration.
Progressivism aimed to address problems caused by rapid industrialization through social and political reform. During the Progressive Era, reformers passed laws to regulate working conditions and child labor, though compliance was mixed and conditions were still dangerous for many workers. The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire highlighted ongoing issues, killing 145 garment workers due to locked doors and a lack of safety features. While some laws targeted alcohol and labor issues, working conditions remained a significant problem in many factories during this period of social and economic change.
Reconstructionism is an educational philosophy that aims to use education to improve society and address social problems. It was developed in reaction to World War II and focuses on empowering students to envision a better future and prepare for roles in bringing about positive social change. Reconstructionism emphasizes using curricula focused on civic duties, ethics, and real-world issues to develop problem-solving and critical thinking skills. Teachers act as facilitators and social change agents rather than just instructors. Student evaluation is based on their ability to be social activists rather than test scores. However, critics argue that reconstructionism lacks detail on implementation and may be more relevant at advanced education levels.
Theorizing 21st century education reimersLuzuko Maseko
This document summarizes curriculum reforms in 6 countries that have expanded educational goals to include broader competencies beyond cognitive skills. It finds that while countries like Singapore, China, and India have clearly defined new competencies, challenges remain in implementing reforms fully in practice. Countries also took different approaches, from consultations with stakeholders in China to standardized testing pressures influencing changes in the US and Chile. Overall educational aspirations have grown but schools still struggle to meet all new demands.
The document summarizes major events in the history of education reform in the United States from the 1950s to present day, focusing on increased recognition of students' individual rights. It discusses key court cases like Brown v. Board of Education that desegregated schools and Tinker v. Des Moines that established free speech rights for students. Major federal education laws like the Elementary and Secondary Education Act, Education for All Handicapped Children Act, Goals 2000, and No Child Left Behind Act are also summarized along with ongoing debates around standardization and accountability versus flexibility and local control in education policy.
Progressive education began in the early 20th century as a reform movement aimed at moral and social transformation through child-centered educational approaches. It grew from the philosophies of thinkers like John Locke and Jean-Jacques Rousseau. Major early proponents included John Dewey and Maria Montessori. In the 1930s, the Eight-Year Study found that progressive education was as effective at preparing students for college as traditional methods. While progressive education waned in popularity in the 1950s, many of its values and approaches saw a resurgence in the 1960s and continue to influence education today.
Social studies is the integrated study of the social sciences and humanities to promote civic competence. Within K-12 education, social studies provides coordinated lessons drawing on disciplines like history, economics, geography, civics, and others. The primary goal is to help students develop the skills, knowledge, and values to be informed and engaged democratic citizens.
The document discusses the role of culture and socialization in education. It outlines several key agents of socialization, including the family, peer groups, schools, and media. It notes trends like increasing numbers of working mothers, single-parent families, and latchkey children that impact family dynamics. Within schools, it examines student roles, hidden curriculums, and passive forms of learning. Gender roles and differences in achievement between boys and girls are also addressed.
Reconstructionism aims to reconstruct society through education. It believes that education should prepare students to address social, political, and economic problems and reconstruct society. Major reconstructionist educators include Theodore Brameld, George Counts, and Paulo Freire who saw schools as agents of social and political change. Reconstructionism is based on the philosophical perspective of pragmatism and aims to reflect democratic ideals through curriculum focused on civic education, real social problems, and controversial issues to improve quality of life. The role of the teacher is as a social change activist and facilitator.
This document provides a brief history of education reform in America from the 19th century to present day. It discusses how education has changed from an emphasis on memorization and the 3 R's to preparing students for a digital global economy. Key figures like Jean-Jacques Rousseau, Horace Mann, John Dewey, and Maria Montessori influenced education philosophy and approaches. Federal involvement has increased through acts like Brown v. Board, ESEA, and NCLB to address issues like desegregation, funding, and standards. Current trends integrate technology while older approaches come and go. Challenges remain around teacher and funding issues against a backdrop of constant reform debates.
Durkheim argued that education serves two main functions: creating social solidarity and teaching specialist skills. It creates social solidarity by transmitting a society's shared culture from one generation to the next. It teaches individuals specialist skills and knowledge needed to perform their roles in the social division of labor. Parsons viewed education as preparing individuals to move from family to wider society by judging people based on meritocratic principles of equal opportunity and achievement rather than ascription. Davis and Moore argued education "sifts and sorts" individuals by ability, allocating the most able to the most important and highly rewarded social roles.
The document discusses several key issues in education including special education, choice of teachers, school uniforms, discipline, diversity, and the civic mission of schools. It notes that education requires well-defined ethics and values. Some of the major moral and ethical issues faced include resources for special education, disputes over teacher assignments, debates around imposing school uniforms, and how to properly address diversity among students. Overall, the document examines important challenges in education from an ethical standpoint.
Common trends and divergences in the evolution and development of social stud...Alexander Decker
This document discusses the evolution and development of social studies education in Nigeria and South Africa. It provides background on the introduction of social studies in Nigeria in the 1960s to replace traditional history and geography teaching. It then examines the nature of social studies, how it integrates concepts from various social sciences and humanities to address societal problems. The document also outlines the key developments in social studies in Nigeria, including its adoption in the national curriculum in 1969 and efforts by government agencies to develop the Nigerian social studies program. In conclusion, it briefly touches on social studies education in South Africa as well.
- Education both shapes and is shaped by society. It both preserves existing social structures but can also help drive social change, especially when aimed at disadvantaged groups.
- While education typically reflects the existing social order, reformers argue it should aim to transform society by promoting values of equality, cooperation, and social progress.
- Multiple factors influence the relationship between education and social change, including political systems, economic conditions, urbanization, and access to education across all segments of society. Education alone is not sufficient to create social change but is an important tool when combined with other reforms.
Kawthoolei educational system should be ( Presentation by Johnson)JohnsonKawThooLei
This presentation indicates the history of Karen educational background and students ideas towards the journey of future Karen education transformation
This document provides an overview of different sociological perspectives on education including functionalism, Marxism, and the new right view. It also examines how factors like social class, ethnicity, and gender can influence educational achievement. Specific topics covered include the role of material and cultural deprivation in social class differences, the contribution of internal and external factors related to ethnicity and gender, and the impact of policies like marketization. The document is intended as a reference for sociological analyses of education.
This document discusses international development education and inclusive education policies in the country of Lesotho. It provides background on global agreements regarding education for all. As a Peace Corps volunteer in Lesotho, the author worked to implement inclusive education policies for students with disabilities in primary schools. This was attractive due to existing traditions of supporting all community members and lack of resources for special schools. Challenges included beliefs that some disabilities were contagious or cursed. The author overcame challenges by understanding the local history, language and culture. Inclusive education was well-supported by Lesotho's collectivist culture and female teacher workforce. The document advocates for educational approaches that are decided locally while facilitating international idea sharing.
The document discusses key events and developments in education between 1900-1950. Some highlights include:
- In the early 1900s, higher education institutions were established in the US to promote higher standards for universities.
- Mary McLeod Bethune founded a school for African American girls in 1904 that later merged and became Bethune-Cookman University.
- Alfred Binet and Theodore Simon created the Binet-Simon intelligence test in 1905 to identify students with mental retardation.
- John Dewey emerged as a leading progressive education philosopher in the early 1900s, advocating for experiential and problem-based learning approaches.
Critical pedagogy began as an approach to education developed by Paulo Freire that focuses on issues of social justice and empowering oppressed groups. It views traditional education as replicating societal oppression and aims to develop critical thinking in students so they can work to transform society. Key aspects include rejecting discrimination, viewing knowledge as socially constructed rather than objective, and using problem-posing methods where students and teachers jointly analyze problems and their social causes. For teacher education, critical pedagogy emphasizes preparing teachers to address sociocultural issues, promote reflection on social positions, and develop critical consciousness in students to enable social justice work.
This document discusses definitions of education from various scholars and aims of educational institutions. It defines education as the process of passing social heritage from one generation to another and socializing children into the rules of their society. Education is also described as shaping child development with a society's ideals of life. The document outlines different types of educational institutions like schools, colleges, and universities. It lists the basic aims of education as developing power and skills, pursuing virtue and truth, and finding lasting truths.
This document discusses several educational philosophies and their implications for curriculum. It begins by defining philosophy of education and its focus on questions around the purpose and function of education. It then examines the philosophies of perennialism, essentialism, progressivism, and reconstructionism. For each philosophy, it outlines their core beliefs and implications for curriculum, such as their views on subject emphasis, teaching methods, and the role of education in society.
PROGRESSIVISM, THE PROGRESSIVISM CURRICULUM, RECONSTRUCTIONISM THE RECONSTRUC...angeloasuncion0327
Progressivism and reconstructionism are philosophies that aim to make education more relevant to students' real lives and social issues. Progressivism focuses on learning through real-life activities and experiences, with the teacher as facilitator. Reconstructionism believes education should teach students how to reform society and address problems like poverty, racism, and war. Both philosophies emphasize using curriculum centered around students' interests to develop critical thinking skills and prepare students for social participation and change.
The document discusses the philosophy of progressivism in education. It advocates for a student-centered approach where the teacher acts as a facilitator. According to progressivism, students should be problem-solvers and learn through hands-on projects and real-world problem solving rather than standardized tests and facts. The author believes their classroom approach aligns with progressivism by training students in critical thinking and providing resources for exploration.
Progressivism aimed to address problems caused by rapid industrialization through social and political reform. During the Progressive Era, reformers passed laws to regulate working conditions and child labor, though compliance was mixed and conditions were still dangerous for many workers. The Triangle Shirtwaist Factory fire highlighted ongoing issues, killing 145 garment workers due to locked doors and a lack of safety features. While some laws targeted alcohol and labor issues, working conditions remained a significant problem in many factories during this period of social and economic change.
This document provides an overview and analysis of adult education programs through a study of the Literacy Coalition of Central Texas (LCCT). It discusses how LCCT aims to provide job training and basic education courses, but does so within a larger political and economic context that can potentially reinforce inequality. The document advocates examining nonprofit structures, hidden curriculums that promote dominant values, and alternative models of adult education that promote liberation rather than just workforce training. A critical analysis of assumptions and systems of power is needed to ensure education truly addresses poverty and lack of access.
This document provides an overview of structuralist perspectives on the role and purpose of education in contemporary society. It discusses functionalism, Marxism, and feminism. Functionalism views education as preparing students for social roles and maintaining social stability. Marxism sees education as reproducing social class through cultural reproduction and a hidden curriculum. Feminism examines how gender socialization influences subject choices and career opportunities for males and females. The document explores key concepts from each perspective, such as meritocracy, correspondence theory, and differential socialization.
The document discusses whether nurses should study sociology. It argues that sociology should be studied in nursing and many other careers. A study found that nursing students who learned sociology recognized its importance for understanding patients' social contexts and its relevance to other aspects of life. Sociology is present in everyday life and helps understand oneself and one's circumstances.
EXPERIENCE & EDUCATION John Dewey The .docxgitagrimston
EXPERIENCE & EDUCATION
John Dewey
The great educational theorist's most concise statement of his ideas about the needs,
the problems, and the possibilities of education--written after his experience with the
progressive schools and in the light of the criticisms his theories received.
"No one has done more to keep alive the fundamental ideals of liberal civilization." -
Morris R. Cohen
Experience and Education is the best concise statement on education ever published
by John Dewey, the man acknowledged to be the pre-eminent educational theorist of the
twentieth century. Written more than two decades after Democracy and Education
(Dewey's most comprehensive statement of his position in educational philosophy), this
book demonstrates how Dewey reformulated his ideas as a result of his intervening
experience with the progressive schools and in the light of the criticisms his theories had
received .
Analyzing both "traditional" and "progressive" education, Dr. Dewey here insists that
neither the old nor the new education is adequate and that each is miseducative because
neither of them applies the principles of a carefully developed philosophy of experience.
Many pages of this volume illustrate Dr. Dewey's ideas for a philosophy of experience
and its relation to education. He particularly urges that all teachers and educators looking
for a new movement in education should think in terms of the deeped and larger issues of
education rather than in terms of some divisive "ism" about education, even such an
"ism" as "progressivism." His philosophy, here expressed in its most essential, most
readable form, predicates an American educational system that respects all sources of
experience, on that offers a true learning situation that is both historical and social, both
orderly and dynamic.
"John Dewey is to be classed among those who have made philosophic thought
relevant to the needs of their own day. In the performance of this function he is to be
classed with the ancient stoics, with Augustine, with Aquinas, with Francis Bacon, with
Descartes, with Locke, with Auguste Comte."
--Alfred North Whitehead
"No one who is informed in the educational held can doubt for a moment the profound
influence of John Dewey on both the theory and the practice of American education."
--William Heard Kilpatrick
"John Dewey is unquestionably the preeminent figure in American philosophy; no one
has done more to keep alive the fundamental ideals of liberal civilization; and if there
could be such an office as that of national philosopher, no one else could be properly
mentioned for it."
--"Morris R. Cohen
Preface
ALL SOCIAL movements involve conflicts, which are reflected intellectually in
controversies. It would not be a sign of health if such an important social interest as
education were not also an aren ...
Dr. Rosa Maria Abreo and Dr. Kimberly S. Barker, NATIONAL FORUM OF EDUCATIONA...William Kritsonis
Dr. Rosa Maria Abreo and Dr. Kimberly S. Barker, NATIONAL FORUM OF EDUCATIONAL ADMINISTRATION AND SUPERVISION JOURNAL, 30(3) 2013.
Dr. David E. Herrington, Invited Guest Editor, NFEAS JOURNAL, 30(3) 2013
Dr. William Allan Kritsonis, Editor-in-Chief (Since 1982)
Progressive education aims to bring democratic ideals into the classroom by respecting diversity and developing critical thinking skills. It began in the late 19th century as Americans questioned education's role in creating uniform citizens. Progressive educators like John Dewey wanted schools to teach community and participation. Dewey tested his ideas in a laboratory school and others later founded the Progressive Education Association to promote child-centered, socially focused learning through projects and collaboration rather than separate academic and vocational training. While progressive schools still exist, their ideals became less accepted in the 1950s amid Cold War fears and conservatism, though modern public education seeks a balance with traditional methods.
This document discusses several sociological theories that are relevant to understanding education:
1) Functionalism views society as a system of interrelated parts that work together to maintain stability. Emile Durkheim argued that education perpetuates social homogeneity needed for society's survival.
2) Structural functionalism focuses on how social structures like the family and education system fulfill necessary functions.
3) Conflict theory emphasizes social inequality and power struggles within education systems.
4) Symbolic interactionism examines how individuals interact and make meaning through symbols like language.
5) Open systems theory analyzes how education systems adapt in response to inputs from the external environment.
The document provides information about progressivism and the Progressive Era in the United States. It discusses that progressivism welcomed political, economic, and social reforms. While the Progressive movement from 1901-1917 aimed to be liberal reforms, it ultimately preserved capitalist social and economic relations. The Progressive Era addressed problems caused by rapid industrialization through social activism and political reform. New laws were passed to regulate industries like mining and railroads, as well as issues like child labor and alcohol. However, working conditions were still poor in many industries due to lack of enforcement and safety regulations.
The document discusses the origins and development of social studies as a subject. It states that social studies first emerged as a subject in the United States in 1916 when a committee defined it as topics related to human society and individuals within social groups. This definition then formed the basis for subsequent definitions. The document also outlines how social studies later developed as a subject in other regions such as Africa, Nigeria, Britain and others. It traces the introduction and growth of social studies as a subject in Nigeria from the 1960s onwards.
Definition and purpose of comparative education.mogana arumungam
1. The document provides an overview of comparative education, defining it as the analytical study of education systems across national borders to identify similarities and differences.
2. It discusses various definitions of comparative education provided by different scholars and the objectives and scope of comparative education, including description, understanding education systems, evaluation, and aiding education planning.
3. The rationale for comparative education includes using other countries' experiences to evaluate and improve one's own education system, and satisfying intellectual curiosity about other education systems.
Definition and purpose of comparative education.Iffat rafiq
Comparative education examines education systems across national borders to identify similarities and differences. It aims to describe educational practices, assist development, highlight relationships between education and society, and make generalized statements about education. Comparative education has been defined in various ways by scholars, but generally focuses on analyzing factors that influence different countries' education systems and how societal forces shape these systems over time. The field provides insights to improve one's own education system by studying variations in other societies.
This document provides an overview of curriculum development and the forces that impact curriculum. It discusses how curriculum has been defined over time and includes multiple levels from societal to instructional. Social forces like changes in society, technology, and political movements influence curriculum development. Reform movements and changes to education policy also impact curriculum design. The document uses examples from the US and Ecuadorian education systems to illustrate how external initiatives and local factors shape curriculum.
The document discusses conflicting aims in education in a liberal democracy. It mentions logistics for a parent night, a blog response about not giving enough homework, and a dismal view of American education presented by Charles Sykes. It also asks what individual teachers can do to inspire learning in students given they cannot change the values that dominate education.
The document discusses conflicting aims in education in a liberal democracy. It mentions problems with homework completion by students and giving too much homework. It also discusses the need to inspire a desire to learn in students but that individual teachers have limited ability to change broader societal values around education.
Redefining Education in America Cultivating Ethical & Moral LeadershipAnne Hamilton
This document discusses the need to redefine American public education by integrating moral and ethical teachings from Eastern philosophies like Buddhism and Confucianism. It argues that the current education system focuses too much on training students for jobs and the economy, rather than cultivating qualities like compassion and wisdom. Incorporating mindfulness practices and principles from great historical teachers could help address issues facing today's students and society. The document provides numerous examples and studies supporting the benefits of teaching mindfulness and moral philosophy in schools. It asserts that reorienting education in this way would better prepare students for the complex problems of the modern world.
journal3#The art of creative teaching implications for higher educationThirah Dehearty
This document discusses fostering creativity in higher education. It argues that universities should nurture creativity in students to produce leaders for the 21st century, as creativity is linked to economic prosperity. However, many aspects of higher education can dampen creativity. The document proposes strategies for creative teaching and learning, such as curriculum negotiation, flexible assessment, and collaborative/project-based learning. It concludes universities must focus on creativity to develop students who can succeed in today's changing world.
Similar to Curriculum Integration in Middle School (20)
The document discusses guidelines for cataloging children's materials, including a history of children's cataloging standards and practices. It describes how children search differently than adults, preferring graphical interfaces and natural language. It recommends catalogers consider how a child would search and provide multiple access points to improve search success. The document also provides details on using appropriate MARC fields and Dewey or Library of Congress classification numbers.
This document provides a lesson plan for teaching kindergarten students about the author Tedd Arnold. The purpose is to reinforce poetry elements they have been learning during National Poetry Month and to introduce another of Arnold's books in preparation for his upcoming visit to the school. During the lesson, the teacher will read Arnold's book "Catalina Magdalena Hoopensteiner" and check for student understanding. Afterwards, the students will listen to a song version of the book. The goal is for students to become familiar with Arnold's work and make connections between rhyme and meter in different media.
This document provides details of a lesson plan for a 4th grade class on research skills. The purpose is to review key parts of information books like the table of contents, index, glossary, and taking notes using a graphic organizer. During the 30 minute lesson, students will use books about planets to identify these parts and their functions. The teacher will guide a discussion reviewing each part and have students locate examples. By the end, students should recall how to use various parts of books to find information on topics.
This lesson plan summarizes a 30-minute library lesson for kindergarten and cross-grade 1st/2nd and 3rd grade classes about the theme of the sun. The purpose is to provide an enjoyable read aloud while teaching basic information and concepts about the sun. Students will gain an understanding of what the sun is and why it is important through reading fiction and nonfiction books, singing songs, and a sun-themed craft. The librarian will check for comprehension through questions during and after the read aloud and activities.
The document outlines the collection development policy for the Leal Elementary School Library Media Center. It describes the mission and student population of the school. The policy provides guidelines for selecting materials to support the curriculum and meet student needs. Materials must be aligned with educational objectives, age-appropriate, and meet standards of quality. The collection includes print, digital, and audiovisual resources. Community input and review tools are used in selection. Donations are accepted but not automatically added. The policy also addresses weeding outdated materials and responding to reconsideration requests.
1) The America the Beautiful (ATB) series seemed to be the best option of the three geography series reviewed for a public library to purchase, due to its more recent publication date, higher quality writing and more in-depth information.
2) However, the selector noted the ATB series has a higher reading level, so it may not be suitable for all 4th grade students depending on their abilities.
3) To ensure all students could access the materials, the selector proposed putting volumes from the series purchased and the library's existing series on reserve for in-library use only during the period when students would be researching their reports.
This document summarizes several studies on teenagers' use of the internet and social media. It finds that while online risks exist, internet and social media use can also provide developmental benefits to teens such as facilitating friendships and interests. The document advocates for parents and educators to take a balanced approach by having open discussions with teens and guiding their safe and productive online activities rather than restricting access. It also discusses research showing that while video games are often blamed for negative effects, characteristics of game play can relate to improved mood, attention, and civic engagement for teens when played in moderation.
This document discusses two main topics: 1) Adolescents' use of social networking sites and 2) Teens' use of video games.
For social networking, research found that while "horror stories" exist, most teen online activity aids development. Studies show teens restrict photos and communicate offline more. Time online benefits development by extending friendships and interests.
For video games, most teens play but genres vary widely. Games are often social and half of online gamers play with real-life friends. Certain game qualities relate to increased civic engagement. Contrary to stereotypes, gaming does not withdraw teens but can engage them in society and teach moral decision making.
The lesson plan introduces students to the International Children's Digital Library (ICDL) to select a children's book that represents their selected immigrant population for a portfolio project. Students will learn how to navigate the ICDL interface and search for books, either through simple searches or more advanced searches. They will read and select a book to include in their immigration portfolio. The teacher and librarian will provide guidance on using the ICDL and help students complete their searches.
This folktale from Sweden tells the story of a woodcutter who is granted three wishes by a tree spirit. The woodcutter and his wife argue about what to wish for, wasting their first two wishes on a sausage that appears and then attaching the sausage to the man's nose when the wife wishes for it. They use their final wish to remove the sausage from his nose, having missed an opportunity to wish for something more valuable like a large house or riches. The moral of the story is the importance of thinking carefully about wishes.
The document summarizes a 20-minute lesson plan for 7th grade social studies students on using the citation generator EasyBib to create a works cited page. The lesson will have students identify source information for a book and website, use EasyBib to generate citations, review the citations for accuracy, and export citations into a Word document. The teacher will demonstrate the process using examples and guide student practice in evaluating websites for a future research assignment on world leaders. Student learning will be evaluated through discussion, reviewing their website evaluations, and listing important criteria for evaluating sources.
This document discusses how to use EasyBib to create a Works Cited page in MLA format. It provides examples of proper citations for a book and website using MLA style. It then walks through the steps to cite those same sources using EasyBib, including entering ISBN and URL information. It explains that EasyBib can generate a full Works Cited page once sources are cited. The document emphasizes that EasyBib makes creating citations and a Works Cited page easy.
The document summarizes the author's monitoring and evaluation of the ISLMANET-L electronic discussion list over three weeks in September and October 2009. Some key findings include:
1) The listserv is open to anyone interested in school libraries and allows subscribers to easily post, view archives, and manage subscriptions.
2) During the monitoring period, the list averaged 4-6 discussion threads per day on topics like announcements, job postings, and requests for advice.
3) Two popular threads involved sharing activities for teaching the Dewey Decimal System and expressing outrage over cuts to an Illinois public library.
4) The author believes the listserv is a valuable local resource for Illinois school libr
This lesson plan introduces 4th grade students to author Jim Aylesworth and his book Country Crossing. The students will listen to an audio recording of the book while following along with slides. They will then discuss the use of onomatopoeia, or words that imitate sounds, in the story. Each student will then create their own onomatopoeic word and illustration to display for Aylesworth's upcoming visit. In subsequent lessons, the class will further explore figurative language devices like simile and metaphor.
This document provides background on Fiona Griswold's proposal to create a mobile computer lab for DH Elementary School. The school currently lacks a dedicated computer lab, which would benefit students and teachers. Griswold outlines a plan with four stages: research, formal planning, implementation, and follow-up/evaluation. The goals are to obtain funding, equip the lab, train staff/students, and increase technology integration and student achievement over time. Potential support and obstacles are also discussed.
The document proposes creating a mobile computer lab at DH Elementary School to help improve test scores of disadvantaged students and allow teachers to incorporate technology into lessons. It would include 25 laptops, a cart, and training led by the Library Media Specialist. Research shows technology can boost achievement, but DH currently lacks sufficient computer access. The $22,000-28,000 proposal outlines purchasing needs, staff responsibilities, and a timeline to set up the lab by August 2010 to provide equal technology access and meet standards.
The document provides information about the 2010-11 Bluestem Award, which recognizes the top book selected by Illinois students in grades 3 through 5. It lists 20 nominated books and encourages students to read at least 4 books to be eligible to vote for their favorite title. It also explains the meaning behind the award's name and provides summaries for 5 of the nominated books: Sky Boys, Kenny and the Dragon, How to Steal a Dog, The BFG, and No Talking.
This document summarizes a project to set up computer labs at two sites - Second Chance Shelter in East St. Louis and Restoration Urban Ministries in Champaign-Urbana. Both sites provide transitional housing and services for families. The project team set up computer labs with 6 computers each running Linux or Edubuntu. They encountered issues like inappropriate web content, computer crashing, and saving documents. Solutions included installing content filters, cleaning up systems daily, and using Google Docs. Sustainability of the labs and consistent administrative support remained problems.
This document discusses classroom management strategies and theories that are relevant for school librarians. It profiles several school librarians and their approaches, which generally focus on establishing positive relationships with students, maintaining consistency in enforcing rules, having an inviting library space, and circulating to monitor behavior rather than taking an authoritarian approach. The document also reviews classroom management theories like Positive Behavioral Interventions and Supports (PBIS), Choice Theory, and the Nurtured Heart Approach that inform best practices for librarians.
This document presents criteria that students identified as important to evaluate websites, including whether sources are cited, the topic is clearly stated, graphics are useful or distracting, there are spelling errors, when the site was last updated, information about the author is provided, navigation is easy, links work, information is clear, whether it is a personal site, types of ads, author/sponsor is named, and contact information is available. The most commonly identified criteria were whether sources are cited, the topic is clear, graphics are useful, and errors are present.
1. Fiona B. Griswold
CI 410
August 1, 2010
Curriculum Integration in Middle School Education
Curriculum integration (CI) is not a new idea. In fact, the concept first came into
popularity and practice in the first half of the 20th century, but was soon discarded in favor of
more “traditional” methods of instruction and curriculum development. The curriculum
development model, though, is being explored once again as a better curriculum model for U.S.
schools, particularly middle schools. While it is unlikely that the curriculum integration model
will become the predominant model for curriculum development and instruction in the U.S., the
core ideas of this model, in whatever way they might be incorporated into middle school
teaching, hold the promise of improved student engagement and achievement in the future. This
paper seeks to provide one option of how CI might be incorporated into the future middle school
curriculum.
What is Curriculum Integration?
Giving a definition of CI is not as simple as it might appear on the surface. One reason
for this is that the terms “curriculum integration” or “integrated curriculum” tend to be used by a
number of different individuals and groups to mean a range of approaches to curriculum
development and teaching at various levels, including higher education. Despite these varying
definitions, there are a few common elements that can be found in most of them. In the most
basic description of the curriculum integration model, curriculum is conceptualized as being
organized around a specific topic, theme or problem, the investigation or exploration of which is
guided by a number of “essential questions” drawing from a number of subject or discipline
areas. However, it might be argued that if the definition stops there, the CI model doesn‟t look
that different from an interdisciplinary approach to curriculum development. Since the focus of
this paper is the CI model in the middle school, the appropriate definition of CI would be that
which is promoted by CI advocates and reflected in the September 2002 National Middle School
Association (NMSA) Position Statement on Curriculum Integration:
Curriculum integration is a curriculum design that promotes personal and social
integration through the organization of curriculum around significant problems and
issues, collaboratively identified by educators and young people, without regard for
subject area lines. (Brown & Knowles, 2007 p. 131)
2. The key areas in which this definition differs from and extends beyond the basic one is that there
is a specific focus on the transformative possibilities of CI. The form of CI which is embraced by
the NMSA and other middle school reformers (and is probably most true to that proposed in the
1920s and 30s) emphasizes the social outcomes of CI. By promoting “personal and social
integration” and focusing on “significant problems and issues, collaboratively identified by
educators and young people” [my emphasis] this CI model makes teaching and learning a
democratic process where the decision-making is shared equally by both teacher and student.
Further, the curriculum is intended to focus on what matters to students and to go beyond
academic learning to personal and social growth and integration at a time when students are
beginning the transition to adulthood and acquiring the values and knowledge that will help them
find their place in society.
Brief (and Simplified) History of Curriculum Integration
In Chapter 2 of his book on CI, James Beane (1997), provides a summary of from where
(and from whom) the present-day notion of CI is derived, or as he eloquently puts it “[we] stand
on the shoulders of giants” (p. 20). The following very simplified and somewhat brief look at the
ideas and movements that gave us our current notions about CI have been largely derived and
restated from pages 19-37 of this work.
As stated in the previous section, the idea of CI extends back to the early part of the 20th
century. With the start of the industrial revolution in the U.S., people also began to question the
common mode of education, which, until around 1890 had been largely “a combination of the
high-culture subjects associated with classical humanism and… mental discipline” (Beane, 1997,
p. 20). The industrial revolution caused a questioning of whether this sort of education would
meet the modern needs of the age and led to a number of reform movements. The first of these
was geared towards preparing individuals for their future role in society and differentiated
instruction so that young men were prepared for a life of manual labor, management tasks or a
profession (such as medicine or the law) while young women were provided instruction in
domestic matters as well as a basic education that would include literacy, basic math and so on.
Not surprisingly, this type of curriculum not only met labor needs but also helped to reinforce the
class and race distinctions of the day. Another movement developed out of a new interest by
Griswold 2 Curriculum Integration
3. notables like Rousseau and G. Stanley Hall in children as individual beings, separate and
different from adults who required a special curriculum geared toward their interests, a “child-
centered” curriculum. A third reform movement was concerned about education as a social force
that could be used to promote democracy and remedy some of the inequalities in wealth and
class that were becoming more pronounced with the second wave of immigration in the last half
of the 19th century and U.S. transformation from a more agrarian society to an industrial one. In
this reform, curriculum was designed to use social problems as learning opportunities and to
encourage more involvement between school and community. Though all three of these
movements came to see CI as a means to their ends, it is largely these last two movements, as
well as the work of John Dewey and, later, the contributions of William Kilpatrick, Meredith
Smith and L. Thomas Hopkins that came to form what we view as CI today.
The educational writings of John Dewey published between 1900 and 1930, and his work
at the University of Chicago Laboratory School, are fundamental to much current educational
thought, particularly its social aspects and effects. Dewey‟s contributions toward the model of CI
being promoted for use in the middle school came from both his ideas of education as key to a
fully-formed democracy and in his idea that classroom instruction is most effective when it is
experiential and interactive and when students play an active role in shaping their own learning.
Many models of teaching that are related to CI, such as inquiry-based learning, hands-on
learning or project-based learning, owe much of their theories to Dewey‟s work.
Another important figure in the creation of the CI model is a teacher named Meredith
Smith. Informed by Dewey‟s theories about the importance of children‟s interactions with their
environment (i.e., their school, the larger community and society as a whole) in the learning
process, Smith decided to test these ideas. In her experiment, she had a group of first-grade
students begin a community project in which they built themselves small houses which were
grouped together and small dolls were given to the children to represent the residents of their
“pretend community.” What Smith observed was that the children, without prompting from
teachers or other adults, proceeded to create all the other structures, roles and responsibilities that
would be required of a real-life, functional community. In addition, their interactions, over the 5-
year span of the experiment, became more sophisticated and they began to tackle complex social
and economic issues. Smith concluded from this experiment that the children had, on their own,
had more effectively learned about the needs of a community and the concept of democracy and
Griswold 3 Curriculum Integration
4. that the children were not only willing participants in their learning, but that they were actively
seeking more information and knowledge. Smith‟s ultimate conclusion about education based on
her observations was that the traditional form of instruction, in which students were largely
passive recipients of knowledge, was inadequate. Instead, children should be given the
opportunity to engage with an act upon their environments, developing skills (such as math and
literacy) and gaining knowledge as they became increasingly informed about their roles in and
relationships with others in their society.
Following on the publication of Smith‟s doctoral dissertation, Education and the
Integration of Behavior in 1927, the term “integration” came into common usage when referring
to the ways that education was meant to serve both the needs of the individual as well as those of
the individual in society. In the 1930s, one of the most important theorists of the integration
movement was L. Thomas Hopkins from Teachers College, Columbia University. In his
writings, Hopkins consistently promoted integration as involving both the personal and social
and insisted that curriculum must be problem- and experience-centered created through a
collaboration between teachers and students. Hopkins also criticized others in the education field
for misusing the term “integration” when their projects were really multi-disciplinary in nature
and more concerned with acquisition of subject-matter knowledge.
The 1940s saw the publication of the results of the Eight Year Study which had been
conducted by the Progressive Education Association. This study compared the social and
academic success of graduates of non-traditional high schools that followed some sort of
integrative curriculum model (in that they shied away from the traditional separate-subject means
of instruction) with graduates from traditional subject-focused high schools. The graduates of
non-traditional high schools did better than the traditional students in all measures, and graduates
of the six schools that were most like the integrated curriculum model performed best on all the
measures. The results of the Eight Year Study had an impact in the curricula used at both
elementary and secondary schools in the 1940s, but the most obvious influence of the study can
be seen in the development of “core” programs for teaching general education requirements in
middle and high schools. In its most progressive form, the “core” curriculum was to be
collaboratively planned, problem-based and free from subject matter distinctions, and “core”
scheduling consisted of large blocks of time and, sometimes, multiple years of teachers and
Griswold 4 Curriculum Integration
5. students working within the same group (as opposed to the traditional annual move from one
classroom and teacher to another).
Unfortunately, the fairly widespread adoption of the “core” curriculum along with other
progressive education movements were not destined to last. With the launch of the Sputnik
rocket by the USSR in 1954 and the fear of Communism and the Cold War, progressive
education movements were linked to communism and a threat against the U.S. by conservatives
trying to preserve the status quo and protect traditional institutions and systems within U.S.
society. For much of the 1950s through the early 1980s there was the occasional publication
discussing CI, but very little implementation of the practice in schools. Then, most recently,
beginning in the late 1980s and early 90s, the term “curriculum integration” once again appeared
in writings about early childhood education, whole-language elementary instruction, gifted
programs and outcomes-based instruction. Also, research from the 1980s and 90s on how the
brain organizes information leant support to organizing curriculum around central themes and
learning theorists reported that knowledge is more likely to be retained if it is presented in the
context of previous experience and as whole ideas rather than isolated pieces of information.
The resurgence of interest in CI is subject to some of the same problems that were faced
in the past. In particular, Hopkins complaint about the mislabeling of any sort of
multidisciplinary curriculum model as “integrative” continues to be an issue today, as evidenced
by the range of definitions and models that can be found in current literature on curriculum. One
interesting difference, identified by Beane (1997), between discussions of CI from 75 years ago
and current (as of the late 1990s) discussions is the link between CI and a bigger social agenda.
Most often, articles about CI are focused on the individual and not on the true integration of
individual learning with that of society. In some ways, the lack of the social (or some may say,
“progressive”) aspect of CI has likely made the appeal of the model more palatable to
conservative interests. However, a quick review of some of the more recent publications about
CI shows that the social, progressive benefits of CI are again receiving attention, resulting in
criticisms from conservatives that are nervous about the “social agenda” of CI proponents (see
1996 opinion piece in Education Digest by Paul George).
Griswold 5 Curriculum Integration
6. Why Curriculum Integration?
Implementing the CI model in the nation‟s middle schools would require an enormous
reorganization of the way these schools currently function as well a major shift in thinking about
the way curriculum is developed and implemented, instructional methods, classroom
organization and the role of students in determining their own curriculum. Given the extreme
change that would need to happen before CI could be implemented, then why do some
individuals or organizations advocate so strongly for this model? A simplistic answer would be,
“because it works” or “because the interactions and learning observed in students immersed in
this sort of curriculum model are so compelling and inspiring,” These responses would be true,
but are not sufficient to convert the skeptic or to explain to a veteran teacher why you would like
them to completely retool their curriculum and way of teaching. In fact, this sort of simplistic
answer may be one of the reason why CI frequently comes under scrutiny or criticism. While it is
true that there are studies (which we will examine later) that show that students from schools that
use the CI model frequently do better on standard measures of academic and social achievement,
much of the most compelling evidence of the advantages of CI comes from first-person
narratives by teachers and students that have experienced this curriculum model or from outside
observers who have had the opportunity to witness the benefits of such a program. In addition,
some of the research that is offered to support the assertion that CI is the best model for the
middle school is not able to show that CI is the sole or major causal factor in the high levels of
achievement.
The major reason put forth by CI advocates as to why the CI model is the most
appropriate one for middle school is that it meets all the essential attributes of an effective
middle school as detailed by NMSA. The CI model is developmentally appropriate in meeting
the young adolescent‟s desire to explore and learn about themselves and the world around them.
It‟s challenging because it meets students‟ instructional needs on every level--students who are
ahead of grade level have the ability to take their inquiry and learning to the next level while
students who may be struggling are able to contribute their particular strengths and to be
challenged by the higher achieving students with whom they are collaborating. The CI model is
empowering because it includes students in all aspects of the decision-making process and is
designed to focus on their interests and questions about their world. Finally, it‟s equitable
because everyone participates, every student has access to the same instruction and the same
Griswold 6 Curriculum Integration
7. products of learning and nobody is tracked or labeled as “high” or “low” achievers. Those who
have participated in CI as teachers or learners report greater motivation and engagement (by
teachers and students), a better understanding of the ideals of democracy, the ability to think
critically, increased intellectual curiosity and, the gold standard in the era of No Child Left
Behind (NCLB), improved scores on achievement tests.
What the Research Says
Despite some deficiencies in the supportive research about CI implementation, there
exists some compelling research to bolster its use in the middle school environment. Though it
was difficult to find current, original studies, one of the more interesting and useful resources
was a meta-analysis found in the unpublished doctoral dissertation of Deborah Hartzler (2000) of
thirty studies on the effects of integrated curriculum programs on student achievement. This
dissertation is useful for several reasons. First, it confirms the difficulty that a researcher faces in
determining a suitable definition for CI on which to base research. For her meta-analysis,
Hartzler (2000) first had to arrive at a definition for integrated curriculum, then identify studies
of programs that conformed to this definition. After an examination of a number of historical
definitions of CI and a presentation of the various models for CI (many of which would not
satisfy Beane‟s definition as they did not include student collaboration or emphasize both
personal and social integration), Hartzler was left with the following, “In general, all the
definitions involve a curriculum design that combines the skills and/or content from the
disciplines that have traditionally been taught separately.” (p. 40) Using this definition of CI and
several other factors, such as the use of a control group, thirty studies were included in the final
analysis. After a statistical analysis of the results of the included studies, Hartzler (2000) reached
the following conclusions: 1) programs using a CI model were effective in raising academic
achievement, 2) they were most effective when science and language arts were combined with
other subject areas, 3) students from the “middle class” and those who were achieving below
grade level at the start of the integration showed the greatest gains, and 4) students participating
in integrated programs showed significant gains in standardized test scores (p. 153). In addition,
the analysis showed that “none of the categories assessed resulted in negative effect sizes… the
overall outcomes were positive. Regardless of the type of program, the grade levels involved, the
Griswold 7 Curriculum Integration
8. training and support provided, or the assessment instruments used, integrated programs have
consistently demonstrated that these programs work” (p. 156).
The “classic” study that supported the effectiveness of CI is, of course, the Eight-Year
Study, the results of which were published in 1942 in a five-volume collection titled, Adventure
in American Education. The first volume of this publication, The Story of the Eight-Year Study,
has recently been republished online by staff and students from the University of Maine,
Farmington, with support from the Maine Association for Middle-Level Learning. According to
the introduction to the Web project, the Eight-Year Study (1942), which followed the graduates
of thirty experimental high schools during the 1930s is “considered by many educational
researchers to be one of the best program evaluation studies ever conducted.” (Project
Introduction section, para. 1) As mentioned earlier in this paper, this study is of particular
importance to the CI movement because the results showed that “the traditional separate-subject
approach appeared to be the least effective for preparing students, even for things that we‟d
always assumed it was best for” (Eight Year Study, Project Introduction section, para. 1).
Furthermore, the schools that were most effective employed a CI model for organizing
curriculum, which, at that time, was called “Core Curriculum.” Though researchers found only
modest increases in academic achievement in the experimental high school graduates, they found
that these students made much greater gains in other areas and did as well as or better at college
than there traditional high school counterparts. From the thirty participating schools themselves
came the conclusions that current, lifeless subject matter should be replaced by content that is
“alive and pertinent to the problems of youth and modern civilization.” In fact, much of what
was concluded by the authors of the Eight-Year Study about the role of the school vis-à-vis the
academic, social and wellness needs of the student has found its way into the current NMSA
vision for the middle school, This We Believe.
There have been some other, more recent studies that touch on the effectiveness of the
CI model in middle or other schools, but the difficulty with interpreting these results is that,
usually, CI is just one aspect being examine in a larger context that may include other middle
school curricular reforms such as teaming, small-group instruction and authentic instruction and
assessment. In addition the form of CI being examined in many of these studies often does not
meet the standard of the definition put forth by Beane (1997), and repeated by Brown and
Knowles (2007) and the NMSA. One such article, “Middle School Practices Improve Student
Griswold 8 Curriculum Integration
9. Achievement in High Poverty Schools,” authored by Steven B. Mertens and Nancy Flowers
(2003) looked at data from the School Improvement Self-Study collected from 121 middle
schools in Arkansas, Louisiana and Mississippi during the 1998-99 and 2000-01 academic years.
In analyzing the data, the authors looked at practices related to CI, such as “curriculum
coordination and integration,” which was defined as “team members work together to coordinate
learning activities and integrate curriculum” (p. 35); but this was just one of many team and
classroom practices included in this study. Some of the authors‟ conclusions about CI as a result
of their analysis are 1) “schools with 60% or more students from low-income families also have
the highest levels of curriculum coordination and integration practices [author‟s emphasis] as
compared to schools serving more affluent populations” (p. 39); 2) the highest level of
association between team and classroom practice was found to be that of team “curriculum
coordination & integration” and classroom “integration and interdisciplinary practices,” (p. 37).
In other words, as the amount of time or frequency the teaching team meets to plan and
coordinate curriculum, the more integrated or interdisciplinary content is delivered in the
classroom. However, when the authors performed an analysis of how the study factors affect
achievement, particularly in low-income schools, the results were not so positive. Achievement
scores from low-poverty schools far exceeded those of high-poverty ones, though, schools in the
high-poverty group that had the most time spent in teaming practices, such as curriculum
coordination and integration, had the highest reading scores (Mertens & Flowers, 2003, p. 41).
However, a weakness of this study, at least in terms of its relation to implementation of the CI
model put forth by the NMSA, is that the author‟s definition of integration does not meet the
collaborative planning condition and there is no way of knowing what sort of integration,
specifically, was occurring at any of the study‟s schools.
Barriers and Opposition to Curriculum Integration
Thus far, this paper has focused primarily on the positive aspects and benefits of the CI
model and the support it has received from various associations, research bodies and educators.
Despite a good amount of support and documented benefits, however, the CI model is not a
“simple fix” and has its share of critics.
Even for those who might feel the CI model is, in essence, the best choice for middle
schools, the changes required to implement this model may feel overwhelming. James Beane
Griswold 9 Curriculum Integration
10. (1997) reports what must be a fairly common feeling about CI. A journal editor, after reviewing
an article about CI written by Beane, commented, “I know you‟re right about this idea, but it
terrifies me. So much would have to change” (p. 95). Most of the barriers to CI lie in the ways in
which it represents a complete shift in curricular thinking from what has always been the
traditional way of teaching in middle schools. Teachers may feel uncomfortable with their new
role as collaborator rather than authority and may struggle with the lack of certainty in course
direction inherent in the CI planning process. School and district administrators may feel at a loss
about all the changes, from how the day is scheduled to how state standards are considered or
met, that CI implementation would require. Parents may be worried about a departure from the
traditional curriculum that they likely experienced as middle school students and worry as to
whether their children will be sufficiently prepared for high school and for university or other
endeavors that lie beyond. Finally, the use of the CI model in U.S. middle schools would require
a radical reimaging of the curriculum of our system of public education, which hasn‟t changed
much in the last century, despite the enormous changes that have occurred in U.S. society during
this same period.
Also, while the CI model has some very vocal supporters, it also has attracted equally
vocal detractors. One highly-visible critic of CI is Paul George, an education professor at the
University of Florida and well-known scholar of middle school education. In a 1996 opinion
piece published in Education Digest, George listed 36 reasons why he believes that “many
current claims for integrated curriculum are unfounded, unsubstantiated, or both” (p. 16). In
particular, George argues that, while there are some studies and testimonies that support the
effectiveness of CI, proponents have failed to make their case for broad implementation of CI
and have not shown evidence that it holds any advantage over a well-developed traditional
curriculum delivered by experienced, dedicated teachers.
While George‟s 1996 piece might be a bit overdramatic, he does make some valid
arguments. While it is clear that many U.S. middle schools are struggling and that achievement
scores for their students have generally fallen or remained flat in recent years, these problems
cannot be generalized to every traditional middle school. In fact, there are likely any number of
examples of highly successful middle schools which by combining a traditional, subject-centered
approach with excellent enthusiastic teachers and a supportive and nurturing school environment,
are showing great gains in achievement even in student populations that have historically been at
Griswold 10 Curriculum Integration
11. risk for academic failure. On the other hand, there are some great examples or case studies of
highly effective middle schools that have moved to the CI model, and the personal stories and
accounts from teachers and students in these schools are frequently quite compelling. Yet, can
this relatively small number of case studies be generalized to the entire population of U.S.
middle schools to the extent that it is time to throw away the traditional models and adopt the CI
model?
Conclusion
After reviewing all of the sources mentioned in this article and some additional general
reading, one thing has become clear in the debate over curriculum integration in the middle
school--it is unlikely that this debate will ever be resolved in favor of one model or another and
probable that, far into the future, U.S. middle schools will continue to draw from a number of
curricular models in developing and delivering instruction. While both extremes of this debate,
those who believe CI is the only means of curriculum development for the middle school and
those who are unreservedly opposed to it, are likely to be dissatisfied with this outcome, for the
rest of us, what is right and what is comfortable lies somewhere in the middle, along the
spectrum of integration that is disliked by Beane but probably more realistic for the majority of
stakeholders in middle grades education. There is no doubt, based on countless studies of all
levels of education, that some level of integration in curriculum and instruction generally
improves both academic outcomes (as measured by typical means of assessment such as
standardized tests) and student outcomes such as improved motivation and engagement in the
classroom. Therefore, integration of curriculum and collaboration, both among teachers and
between teachers and students, should be encouraged to the extent that any school is able to
accomplish with the hope that integration might continue to develop and deepen over time as
more teachers and students experience this model of curriculum.
To adopt an “all or none” approach to integration is not only unrealistic but also
undermines any real hope for middle school improvement along these lines. Despite the strong
rhetoric used by the proponents of the CI model in some of their writings, I believe that, in the
end, the majority of them have accepted this reality. James Beane, in the final chapter of
Curriculum Integration, admits that while he will continue to take a unwavering stand on what
he feels to be the meaning of CI, goes on to say “curriculum integration does not involve a recipe
Griswold 11 Curriculum Integration
12. or packaged program. In the end it is not an „ideal state‟ to be achieved but rather an idea that is
constantly struggled over by those who work with it” (p. 101). Therefore, the CI model is, for
me, something to work toward and should continue to be the subject of research, development
and refinement to be implemented as one is able in whatever way will best meet the needs of the
students for which the curriculum is intended.
Griswold 12 Curriculum Integration
13. References
Beane, J. A. (1997). Curriculum integration: Designing the core of democratic education. New
York: Teachers College Press. Retrieved from:
www.netlibrary.com.proxy2.library.uiuc.edu/Details.aspx.
Eight Year Study. (1942). Adventures in American Education, vol. I. Retrieved from
www.8yearstudy.org.
George, P. (1996). Arguing integrated curriculum. Education Digest, 62(3), 16.
Hartzler, D. S. (2000). A meta-analysis of studies conducted on integrated curriculum programs
and their effects on student achievement. Retrieved from ProQuest Digital Dissertations.
(AAT 9967119)
Knowles, T., & Brown, D. F. (2007). What every middle school teacher should know.
Portsmouth, NH: Heinemann.
Mertens, S. B., & Flowers, N. (2003). Middle school practices improve student achievement in
high poverty schools. Middle School Journal, 35, 33-43.
NMSA (2002) Position statement on curriculum integration. Retrieved from:
www.nmsa.org/AboutNMSA/PositionStatements/CurriculumIntegration/tabid/282/Defau
lt.aspx.
Griswold 13 Curriculum Integration