This document summarizes a research project on how NYPD surveillance has impacted how American Muslim individuals and communities in New York City express their identity. The research was conducted through interviews and workshops with participants including community activists and recent Brooklyn College graduates. Emerging themes from the research included fear of surveillance suppressing religious and political expression, intergenerational divides, impacts on Muslim student organizations, and changes to community gender dynamics and levels of religious expression. The document concludes by acknowledging shortcomings but potential for the research to inform future interventions and applications.