Uploaded byProf.Dr.Christoph Behrens
Complexity Governance
The document presents a model for complexity governance in Indonesia. It acknowledges that Indonesian society is complex with a variety of conflicting traditional and modern values. The model shows that good governance requires decisions through discourse and selection, with collective assessment, openness to change, equality, rule of law, safety, consideration of individuals and collective realities. It poses questions about how to bridge old and new values, govern complexity in practice, and provide leadership in a complex democratic society.
Complexity Governance
- 1. Better Governance forIndonesia THE CONCEPT OF COMPLEXITY GOVERNANCE DECISIONS DISCOURSE (S)ELECTION COLLECTIVE ASSESSMENT INDIVIDUAL OPEN MIND FOR CHANGE TRUST EQUALITY RULE OF LAW SAFETY Prof. Dr. Christoph Behrens INDIVIDUAL REALITIES COLLECTIVE UIN Jakarta 10 Dec 2012 UMY Yogyakarta 15 Dec 2012
- 2. Better Governance forIndonesia COMPLEXITY: System/Environment – Balance Globalization/Localization, Risk Society Urgent Problems Available Information (Knowledge?) Global Society of multiple presents → Integrative Pluralism (S.Mitchell) Democracy / Good Governance DECISIONS DISCOURSE (S)ELECTION COLLECTIVE ASSESSMENT INDIVIDUAL OPEN MIND FOR CHANGE TRUST EQUALITY RULE OF LAW SAFETY INDIVIDUAL REALITIES COLLECTIVE
- 3. Better Governance forIndonesia rational-legal authority ABORTION MOTIVATION FOR VARIATIONS PERFORMANCE PASIMONY ACCEPTED DIVORCE RESOLUTENESS ACCEPTED POLITICAL OF VALUES PARTICIPATION CIVIL SERVANT MGMT INTEREST IN RESPONSIBILITY POLITICS CHANGE INDEPENDENCE TRUST ACCEPTANCE OF HOMOSEXUALITY UNHAPPINESS POLITICS IS PHANTASY IN COMPLEX WOMEN EXPECTED TO HAVE CHILDREN IMPORTANT TOLERANCE POSTMATERIAL VALUES FRIENDS ARE IMPORTANT well being HARD WORK ECOLOGY survival SOCIETIES MONEY WOMEN’S MOVEMENT CHILDREN NEED MUM & DAD LEISURE TIME IMPORTANT EXCLUSION OF MINORITIES FREE CHOICE TRUST IN SCIENCE GOVERNMENT GOOD LEISURE IS RESPONSIBLE Traditional vs. JOBS FOR LOCALS TIME HEALTH SATISFACTION GOOD AND EVIL ARE DISTINCT Rational-legal authority RESPECT TOW. WITH LIFE MANY CHILDREN WANTED and PARENTS RESPECT TOW. FAMILY IS IMPORTANT Mangelwerte vs. AUTHORITY WORK IS IMORTANT SUBMISSIVENESS Postmodern values NATIONAL PRIDE GOD IS IMPORTANT RELIGION IS IMPORTANT traditional authority DECISIONS DISCOURSE (S)ELECTION COLLECTIVE ASSESSMENT INDIVIDUAL OPEN MIND FOR CHANGE TRUST Source: World Values Survey EQUALITY RULE OF LAW SAFETY INDIVIDUAL REALITIES COLLECTIVE
- 4. Better Governance forIndonesia FROM EMPIRIC RESEARCH TO A MODEL FOR COMPLEXITY GOVERNANCE DECISIONS DISCOURSE (S)ELECTION COLLECTIVE ASSESSMENT OPEN MIND INDIVIDUAL TRUST FOR CHANGE EQUALITY RULE OF LAW SAFETY INDIVIDUAL REALITIES COLLECTIVE © Christoph Behrens 2012
- 5. Better Governance forIndonesia QUESTIONS TO ANSWER How to bridge the gap between old values and new values in a complex society? How to govern complexity in practice? What means leadership in a complex democratic society? DECISIONS DISCOURSE (S)ELECTION COLLECTIVE ASSESSMENT INDIVIDUAL OPEN MIND FOR CHANGE TRUST EQUALITY RULE OF LAW SAFETY INDIVIDUAL REALITIES COLLECTIVE
- 6. Better Governance forIndonesia SOME ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Christoph Behrens Complexity Governance: Change Management under challenges of Glocalization Christoph Behrens / Anwar Kholid / Pradnya Paramitha Governance Reform in Yogyakarta. A case study on Indonesia’s way towards Modernity Dina Agustus Administrative Reform: Tension between Legal- Rational Authority and Traditional Authority. The Case of “Career Pattern” of the Provincial Government of the Special Region of Yogyakarta, Indonesia Enggar Ferry Wibowo Sugiharto Performance-Related Pay (PRP) in Jakarta: A critical review DECISIONS DISCOURSE (S)ELECTION COLLECTIVE ASSESSMENT INDIVIDUAL OPEN MIND FOR CHANGE TRUST EQUALITY RULE OF LAW SAFETY INDIVIDUAL REALITIES COLLECTIVE
- 7. Better Governance forIndonesia SOME ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS Reza Fathurrahman Education and Training for Civil Servants: A Comparative Perspective Margareth Gfrerer Towards a University of Quality Christoph Behrens Green Economy – A key area of Complexity Governance Yacinta Esti Policy Formulation for Food Security after Merapi Eruption - A Case Study in the Special Region of Yogyakarta (DIY) Catherine Lefevre Green Economy – A key policy sector for Governance Reform DECISIONS To be published in early 2013 OPEN MIND DISCOURSE COLLECTIVE ASSESSMENT INDIVIDUAL (S)ELECTION FOR CHANGE TRUST EQUALITY RULE OF LAW SAFETY INDIVIDUAL REALITIES COLLECTIVE
- 8. Better Governance forIndonesia THE CONCEPT OF COMPLEXITY GOVERNANCE THANK YOU FOR YOUR KIND ATTENTION! Prof. Dr. Christoph Behrens DISCOURSE DECISIONS (S)ELECTION COLLECTIVE ASSESSMENT INDIVIDUAL OPEN MIND FOR CHANGE TRUST EQUALITY RULE OF LAW SAFETY INDIVIDUAL REALITIES COLLECTIVE