SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
The Collapse of the Cod Fishery in
Newfoundland and Labrador
Written by: Kate Hewitt
10053174
For: Andrew McDonough
Resource and Environment Economics
Friday, November 25th
, 2011
2
Table of Contents
Table of Figures……………..…………………………………………………………………………………………….……………………………………Page 3
Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..………..………………Page 4
Introduction…………………………………..………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 5
The History of NewfoundlandandLabrador’s Cod Fishery…………………………………………….……………………………..….Page 5
WhyCod? - An Economic Standpoint…………………………………………………………………………………..……………………………Page 7
The Cod FisheryCollapse – What Happened..……………………………………………………………………………….………………….Page 8
Environmental Implications………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..…..Page 11
Where the FisheryStands Today…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 13
Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 15
References……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 16
3
Table of Figures
Figure 1: A detailedmapof NewfoundlandandLabrador.……………………………………………………….………………………..Page 6
Figure 2: Biomassandtotal cod catch inNewfoundlandandLabrador………………………………………………………………Page 9
Figure 3: A mapof 200-mile exclusionzone……………………………………………………………………………………………………..Page 11
Figure 4: PopulationtrendsinNewfoundlandandLabrador…………………………………………………..……………………….Page 13
Figure 5: The Committee onthe Statusof EndangeredWildlife inCanada’scoddesignation…………………………..Page 14
4
Abstract
The collapse of the cod fisheryinNewfoundlandandLabradorinthe late 20th
centuryis consideredone of the
worsteconomicandecological disastersinCanadianhistory.The codfishis a veryimportantfoodstaple andthe
province helpedprovidethe resource bothnationallyandinternationallyforover500 years.Large-scale
industrializationafterWorldWarII, however,isoftenblamedasthe initial cause of the collapse.More sophisticated
machinerynearlydecimatedthe oceanflooraffectingnotonlycod,butothersignificantmarine organisms.The
degradationof the cod stockput over30,000 people outof workand alteredland-useandhumanmigration
patternsacross NewfoundlandandLabrador.Federal governmentfundinghasgiventhe province several billionsof
dollarsincompensationforthe lossof the resource,yetitseemsmostof the damage has beendone.Thispaperwill
explore the variouswaysinwhichthe codfisheryhasaffectedthe economy,the environment,andthe residentsof
NewfoundlandandLabradorandCanada.
5
Introduction
The Atlanticcod, Gadusmorhua,isone of the world’smostpopularfoodfishesandhasbeenharvestedoff the
continental shelvesof Europe andNorth Americaforcenturies(HutchingsandMyers,1995). In the westernNorth
Atlantic,the geographicdistributionof the fishrangesfromGreenlandandBaffinIsland,andmayextendasfar
southas NorthCarolina(Ibid,1995) The NewfoundlandandLabradorcod fisherywasonce the largest(McGrath,
1911) andmost productive (Thompson,1943) cod fisheryinthe world,whenthe ‘Northern’codcomponent
constitutedupwardsof 70 per centof all Newfoundlandcatchesafter1954 (HutchingsandMyers,1995). ‘Northern’
cod had beenfishedinthe areasince the late 15th
century,inwhichthe plentifulstockswere expectedtoremain
continuallyplentiful(Quinn,1979).Due to manyfactors suchas international,factory-basedtrawlersandlackof
catch quotas,the resultantover-fishingof Newfoundland’scodstockinevitablyledtoacomplete collapseof the cod
fisheryinthe province.The followingpaperwill examinewhythe codfishwaschoseninaneconomicstandpoint,a
thoroughdescriptionof the collapse of the fishery,andthe environmental implicationsof thisaquaculture business.
Thispaperwill conclude withanoverviewof the fishery’ssuccesstoday,andhow the aforementionedfactors
impactedthe once prosperousfisheryinNewfoundlandandLabrador.
The Historyof NewfoundlandandLabrador’sCodFishery
Since the voyagesof JohnCabotin 1497 and 1498 there hasbeenmajorinternational interestinfishingalong
the coast of Newfoundland(Quinn,1979).Portugal,France,England,andthe SpanishBasquesfishedalongthe east
coast of the province betweenCape Race andCape Bonavista(where JohnCabotfirstlandedinNewfoundland)
(HutchingsandMyers,1995). Spanishand Portuguese fisheriesinNewfoundlandwere short-livedasEnglish
participationincreased(Innis,1931).In the 17th
century,wars betweenthe English,Spanish,andthe Dutchresulted
infewerfishingvessels(Lounsbury,1934).Thisresultedinthe rise of year-roundcodfishers(planters) ascatches
rose from zeroto 37 percent between1610 and 1675 (Ibid,1934). The 1917 Treatyof Utrechtwas signedforthe
War of SpanishSuccession,whichalsoendedthe Frenchfisheryalongthe southcoastof Newfoundland(Hutchings
and Myers,1995). France removeditssettlersfromthe islandinreturn forthe rightto fishwithoutrestrictionson
6
the westand northeastshore betweenPointRiche andCape Bonavista(de LaVillemarqué,1991). See Figure 1 fora
detailedmapof NewfoundlandandLabrador.
In the second-half of the 18th
century,catcheswere splitequallybetweenthe shore andthe bankfisheries
alongthe southcoast of Labrador on the Straitof Belle Isle,whichlaterdiminisheddue tothe SevenYearsWar and
the cedingof Labrador to the BritishCrown(Black,1960). Duringthistime,the inshore fisherybecame more popular
despite offshore expansionintothe GrandBanks(HutchingsandMyers,1995). From 1736 to 1739, an annual
average of 380,000 quintals(1quintal = 112 lbs) of cod were caught byBritishfishersinshore,asopposedto45,000
quintalscaughtoffshore (Lounsbury,1934).Decliningcatchratesoffshore promptedmuchof Newfoundland’s
Figure 1: A detailed map of Newfoundland and Labrador
Encyclopedia Brittanica, 1999
7
populationtomove westwardandnorthwardintothe province (HutchingsandMyers,1995). Schoonerswere
eventuallyoutfitted inshore by1798, but the NewfoundlandandLabrador-basedfisherydidnotfirmlybecome
establisheduntil the 1820’s(Gosling,1910, Black,1960, Ryan,1986).
The residentsof Newfoundlandwhowere occupiedwiththe fisherygenerallyfounditmore prosperoustofish
withinthe province thanseasonallytravel toBritain(HutchingsandMyers,1995). Duringthe NapoleonicWarsfrom
1793-1812, FrenchactivityinNewfoundlandwassuspended,andthisgave local residentsmore of anopportunityto
take advantage of the fishstocks(Ibid,1995). The signingof the Treatyof Parisin1814, however,restoredFrench
occupationinNewfoundlandandcatchesexpanded27per cent(Gosling,1910). Between1900 and 1950,
Newfoundland(whichwasasyetnot a part of Canada) andFrance were dominantamongthe six fishingnations,
accountingformore than90 percentof the total cod catch inNewfoundland(ICNAF,1952).The otherparticipating
countrieswere Canada,the U.S.,Portugal,andSpain(Ibid,1952). At thispoint,cod stockswere depletingsorapidly
fromthe combinationof over-fishingandlackof catch quotasthat between1900 and 1935, the Newfoundlandbank
fisherydeclinedinquintal catchby22 per cent(Ibid,1952). However,Newfoundland’sinshorecatchstill exce eded
offshore catchinall countriesuntil the mid-1950s(HutchingsandMyers, 1995).
Why Cod?– AnEconomicStandpoint
WhenJohnCabot firstarrivedinBonavista,Newfoundlandover500 yearsago, it wassaidthat fishers simply
had to diptheirbucketsoverthe sidesof theirschoonersandtheywould come back burstingwithcod(Canadian
Geographic,2011). Inthe year1620, SirRichard Whitbourne,aNewfoundlandexplorerandsettler,stated“…Butthe
chiefe commodityof New-found-land...isthe Cod-fishinguponthatCoast,bywhichour Nationandmany other
Countriesare enricht.”(Ibid,2011).Newfoundland’scodwasa lucrative oceanicfishnotonlyforproviding
sustenance forthe residentsof the province,butalsointrade betweenNorthAmericanandEuropeancountries
(Ibid,2011). The fishisvaluedfor food,liveroil andotherproducts. Codcanbe soldfresh,frozen,salted orsmoked
while some are turnedintosticks,blocksandfilletsandothersare usedinfishmeal andglue production.Codcheeks
and cod tonguesare considereddelicacies insome regions(Ibid,2011).Atlanticcod alsobecame the protein-source
of choice inEurope as populationsrose.Itsfirm, flakyflesh,andlow-fatcontentallowedthe fishtoreadilydry
8
outdoorsandstoredoverthe wintermonthsforthe 40 daysof fastingat Lent(Pringler,2011).Lightly-salted,dried
cod was able toresistrot foryears,eveninthe most temperate conditions,makingitideal forlightweight,naval
rations(Ibid,2011).
The Cod FisheryCollapse–What Happened
The industrializationof NewfoundlandandLabradorinthe 20th
centuryhada profoundeffectonthe way
residentsof the province livedandworked.More sophisticatedgearsuchas large trawlersandlonglinersreplaced
less-powerful schooners,dories,andpunts(Higgins,2008).These improvementsallowedfisherstoharvest
unprecedentednumbersof codfishandothermarine resources,andallowedboatstoremainatseafor longer
periodsof time.These changesaffectedsettlementpatternsandalteredthe demographicsof manyfishing
communities.Settlementsclosetocod-processingsitesoftenflourishedwhileothercommunitiesmovedtolarger
urban centres(Ibid,2008).This out-migrationfromrural areasbecame alarge probleminthe 1990’s whenmost
youngpeople movedinordertofindemploymentelsewhere.
FollowingConfederationin1949, the cod fisheryindustrybecame more popularinthe frozenfishsectorthan
infamily-basedsaltfisheries(Higgins,2008).Fishersbegansellingfishdirectlytoprocessingcentresratherthan
tradingwithlocal merchants,andmany fishersbeganworkingincompany-ownedfacilities(Ibid,2008).Long-term
and severe over-fishingledtothe collapse of the codfisheryinthe 1990’s andput over30,000 people outof workin
Newfoundland(Ibid,2008).In 1992, a moratoriumwasdeclaredoninshore andoffshore fishinginthe province
(Myerset al,1997). Cod biomassduringthe collapse haddeclinedto99 percent of previousnumbersoff north-
easternNewfoundlandandLabrador(McGrath, 1911 and Thompson,1943). Referto Figure 2 where the dottedlines
representtotal catchand the solidlinesare the biomassof codfishinnorth-easternNewfoundlandandLabrador.
9
Myers, et al, 1997
Figure 2: Biomassandtotal cod catch inNewfoundlandandLabrador
10
The primarycause of the collapse isattributedtothe inabilitytocontrol fishingmortalityasthe targetwasto
maintainsustainable levels(HutchingsandMyers, 1994). Asthe new fishingtechnologybecame more sophisticated,
catch rates grewsteadilyuntil theysurpassedthe cod’sabilitytorebuild(Ibid,2009).Atthe same time,regulations
safeguardingcodstockswere insufficient,andgovernmentsandinternational bodiessometimesassignedquotas
basedon economicfactorsratherthan ecological ones(Higgins,2009).In1968, trawlingbyforeignfleetsmade up
to 80 per centof the total catch for that year(Ibid,2009). Althoughmarine conservationbecame anincreasing
concernafterthe 1960’s, oceanofficialsoftenoverestimatedthe size of codstocksand,therefore,the amountcod
fisherscouldharvestatsustainable levels.Thisresultedinanoverexploitationof northerncod,whichforcedOttawa
to impose amoratorium(Ibid,2009). In the year1970, the International Commissionforthe NorthwestAtlantic
Fisheries(ICNAF) establishedcatchquotas,knownasTotal Allowable Catches(TAC’s) (Ibid,2009).It was believed
that TAC’swouldequal the maximumnumber of fishthatfisherswere permittedtocatch withoutdepletingthe
resource.Unfortunately,the ICNAFoverestimatedthe abundance of codaswell asits stockrate, andTAC’s were too
highto be sustainable (Ibid,2009).Between1962 and 1977, the harvestable biomassof northerncoddropped82
percent, resultinginanearcollapse of the stockand the industry(Ibid,2009). Inthe 1970’s, cod stockdepletionwas
officiallyrecognizedasaconcern.In 1976, Canadadeclareda 200-mile economicexclusionzone (EEZ) torestrict
fishingbyforeigncountries,butsoonafter,Canada’sdomesticcapacitycompensatedforthe codbiomass
international fleetswouldhave caught(HamiltonandButler,2001).In 1977, Canadaextendedits200-mile EEZI in
hopestoregainsome of the lostcod stock(Higgins,2009). Most of the international fishingvesselscame from
NorthAmericaand Europe – primarilythe SovietUnion,Spain,France,andPortugal –althoughsmallernumbers
alsoarrivedfromAsiaand the Caribbean(Ibid,2009).See Figure 3 for a clear understandingof the 200-mile EEZ
aroundNewfoundlandandLabrador. At the same time,state-sponsoredresettlementprogramsencouragedthe
centralizationof NewfoundlandandLabrador’sresidentsindesignatedgrowthcentres(Higgins,2008).Between
1954 and 1975, about24,000 people leftmore than315 rural villagestolive inlarge centralizedcommunities(Ibid,
2008). The province thenhadfewerthan1,000 settlements,eachwithanaverage populationof about500 people.
The federal andprovincial governmenthopedthe programswouldreduce the costsof providingelectricity,roads,
schools,andotherservicestohundredsof remote communities(Ibid,2008).
11
Environmental Implications
The over-fishingof Atlanticcodenabledacomplete ecological shiftincludingchangesintrophicsystemsand
foodchains,andland use withinthe province.The oceanecosystemaroundthe GrandBankswas once dominated
by cod fishandotherpredatorygroundfish,butsince the eradicationof mostcod,there isan insurgence of lower-
trophic-level invertebrates(HamiltonandButler,2001).Thischange inthe area’sfoodchain alsoimpactsmarine
animalsandlocal mammals.The populationof smallerfishmaydecrease aslargerpiscivoresbecome more
dominant.Largermammalssuchas sealsand whalesare directlyimpactedbythe lackof foodavailability.Sealsin
the regionhave a dietthat largely consistsof cod,while some whalesfeedonsmallermammalslike seals,which
may be decreasinginpopulation.AsRichardHaedrich,afisheriesscientistatMemorial UniversityinSt.John’s
Newfoundlandhasnoted,“Theymightnevercome back,at leastnot intheirformerabundance.Once youstart
Rose, 2003
Figure 3: A map of 200-mile exclusion zone
12
changingthe whole ecosystem,the communitystructuresandsizes,you’ve gotawhole new ball game.”(E
Magazine,2001).
Historically,codandothergroundfishspecieswere consideredthe mostvaluable inthe economicmarket.
However,asthese populationsdeclinedothermarine speciesbecame more popular.The snow crab(Chionoecetes
opilio) and northernshrimp(Pandalusborealis) became muchmore prized,butthese are speciesthatcannot
supportextensive exploitation(HamiltonandButler,2001). The Greenlandhalibut(Reinhardtiushippoglossoides)
was consideredanalternative tocodfora time,butitis a slow-growing,long-livedspeciesthatisalsoonthe verge
of collapse (Ibid,2001).
There isdirectevidence thatthe large trawlersusedforthe masscollectionof codhave decimatedthe entire
seafloorthata plethoraof organismsuse tosurvive (EMagazine,2001). Modernbottomtrawlershave destroyed
the fragile continentalshelf,disturbingsensitive habitatandfoodavailabilityformanyspecies(Ibid,2001). Thisarea
may take centuriestore-establishitself,andthiswouldonlyoccurwithzerotrawling.Trawling’seffectwasonce
likenedtothe effectsof clear-cuttingforests,exceptinanarea150 timesgreater(Ibid,2001).The Grand Banksmay
no longerbe capable of supportinglarge populationsof marine species,whichhasenabledsome opportunistic
speciestoflourish.Insome areas,skatesanddogfishhave takenoverthe cod’splace withinthe ecosystem(Ibid,
2001).
Many of Newfoundland’sresidentsalsochangedthe province’slanduse throughmigrationtoandfrom fishing
ports.As cod stocklevelsstartingdepleting,more residentsmovedawayfromfisheries-dependentregionsand
more towardswesternandnorthernNewfoundlandtofindemploymentelsewhere.RefertoFigure 4 fora visual
representationof populationdecreasesinsome of the largestfishinglocationsinNewfoundland.Thishasplaced
extreme stressonthe environmentaslanduseschange andmore area needstoconvertedtoa liveableand
profitable state tosupportthe outmigrationof residents.
13
Where the FisheryStandsToday
In April 1997, the federal governmentallowedatemporaryandlimitedcodcatch off the southerncoastof
Newfoundlandinhonourof JohnCabot’sAtlanticcrossing500 yearsprior(CanadianGeographic,2011). Thisirked
some environmentalists,asthe Committee onthe Statusof EndangeredWildlife inCanada(COSEWIC) hassuggested
that cod be placedon the endangeredspecieslist(Comeau,2011). RefertoFigure 5 to see the determinationof cod
stockson the COSEWIC listineasternCanada.
On April 17th
, Departmentof FisheriesandOcean’sministerFredMifflinannouncedthat6,000 tonnesof cod
couldbe takenfrom the northernGulf of St. Lawrence andoff the westcoastof Newfoundland,and10,000 tonnes
fromthe southerncoast,butthisledto much debate asitappearedthat some scientistsdidnotrealize the extentof
the cod loss(Ibid,2011). Finally,inApril 2003, Federal FisheriesMinisterRobertThibaultannouncedthe complete
closure of the cod fisheryinNewfoundland,the Maritime provinces,andQuebec(CBCNews,2004).In the summer
of 2010, Federal FisheriesMinisterGail Sheaopenedthe recreational groundfishfisheryforthree weeksin
NewfoundlandandLabrador(The Telegram,2010).It insistedadailybaglimitof onlyfive fishandaboat limitof 15
fishwhenthree ormore people are fishing(Ibid,2010).
Figure 4: Population trends in Newfoundland and Labrador
HamiltonandButler, 2001
14
Followingthe 2003 moratoriumonfishing,the federalandprovincial governmentsbegandevelopinglong-
termstrategiesforrebuildingcodstocks(FisheriesandOceansCanada,2008). Theydevelopedthe federal based
Canada-NewfoundlandandLabradorActionTeamforCod Rebuilding,ledbythe Departmentof Fisheriesand
Oceans(DFO) andprovinciallybythe NewfoundlandandLabradorDepartmentof FisheriesandAquaculture (DFA)
(Ibid,2008). In September2003, the Canada-QuebecActionTeamwasestablished,followedbyaCanada-Maritimes
Cod ActionTeaminOctoberthat involvedthe governmentsof Canada,New Brunswick,NovaScotia,andPrince
Edward Island(Ibid,2008).Theircommonprinciplesforcodrestockingwere generalpurpose,asharedstewardship,
precautionarymanagementdecision-makingframeworks,andindicators,all designedforlong-termsuccess(Ibid,
2008). These strategiesare continuallymonitoredandresultsare reportedbacktogovernmentofficialsinorderto
ensure success(Ibid,2008).
Some residentsof NewfoundlandandLabradorwhowere previouslyemployed inthe codfisheriessector
qualifiedforfinancial assistance followingthe collapseof the fishery.In1992, Federal FisheriesMinisterJohn
Crosbie announcedthat19,000 Newfoundlandfishermenandplantworkerswouldreceivedupto$406 a weekin
compensation,andtheycouldgetinvolvedwithskillsdevelopmentprogramstoqualifyformaximumbenefitsup
until 1994 (Maclean’s1992). As of 2003, Canadiantax-payershadspentabout$4.2 billionin11 yearsto bailoutthe
Atlanticcodfisheryandhelpcompensate the formeremployeesandprovide skills-trainingprograms(Harris,2003).
Tax-payermoneywasprovidedtothe fishersthroughthe AtlanticGroundfishStrategy(TAGS),butunfortunatelythe
federal governmentactuallylicensedmore fisherswhogotinvolvedwithcrab,shrimp,andalternate speciesfishing,
Figure 5: The Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada’s cod designation
Fisheries andOceans Canada, 2008
15
anotherenvironmental probleminitself (Ibid,2003).About38,000 people qualifiedforthe federal compensation
fundwhichincludedrelicensing,butonly476 licenceswere reissued(Ibid,2003).
Conclusion
The Atlanticcod fisherycollapse,particularlyinNewfoundlandandLabrador,isone of the worsteconomic
and ecological disastersinCanadianhistory.Itwasonce the largestandmost productive aquaculturebusinessinthe
world,withinternational marketsvyingforsharesof the resource.Unfortunately,however,thisbusinessproved
unsustainableandover30,000 people became unemployed.The codfishisanimportantfoodsource formanybut
withoutpropereconomicandecological grounding,it,like manyotherspecies,hasbecome endangered.The
Canadiangovernmentandthe country’sresidentsmaycontinue tofundfishingprojectsineasternCanadaformany
decades,buthopefullythe collapse of the NewfoundlandandLabradorcod fisherywill become apoignantexample
of the importance of sustainablebusinesspractices.
16
References
Black,W.A. 1960. The Labrador FloaterFishery. AnnualsAssoc.Amer.Geogr. 50: 267-295 inHutchings,JeffreyA.and
RansomA. Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Explorationof
Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online].
Available from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22
Nov2011.
CanadianGeographic.2011. The Rise and Fall of AtlanticCod – A Special Feature. [online].Availablefrom:
http://www.canadiangeographic.ca/specialfeatures/atlanticcod/codhome.asp.Accessed:22Nov 2011.
CBC News.2004. “Newfoundland’scodfishery.”May9th
. [online].Availablefrom:
http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/fishing/cod.html.Accessed:24 Nov2011.
Comeau,Pauline.“A confidential reportconcludesthatAtlanticcodisendangered.” Canadian Geographic.[online].
Available from :http://www.canadiangeographic.ca/specialfeatures/atlanticcod/cod.asp.Accessed:24Nov2011.
de La Villamarqué,J.H.1991. La pêche françaisedela moruedu XVIeau XVIIIesiècle dansl’Atlantiquedu nord ouest.
Counseil International pourl’Explorationde laMer.C.M. 1991/G:67. 21 pp.in Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.
Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof AtlanticCod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Exploration of Historical
Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online].Available
from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22Nov2011.
E Magazine.2001. “A Run onthe Banks- HowFactory FishingDecimated NewfoundlandCod.”February28th
.
[online].Available from: http://www.emagazine.com/archive/507.Accessed:23Nov 2011.
EncyclopediaBritannica.1999. [online].Available from:
http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?t=125040. Accessed24 Nov2011.
FisheriesandOceansCanada.2008. “A Federal-Provincial Strategyforthe Rebuildingof AtlanticCodStocks.”
[online].Available from: http://www.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/fm-gp/initiatives/cod-morue/strategy_overview-eng.htm.
Accessed:24 Nov2011.
Gosling,W.G.1910. Labrador:ItsDiscovery,Exploration,and Development.London:A.RiversinHutchings,JeffreyA.
and RansomA.Myers. 1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundlandand Labrador:An Exploration
of Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.
[online].Available from: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.
Accessed:22 Nov2011.
Hamilton,Lawrence C.andMelissaJ.Butler.“OutportAdaptations:Social IndicatorsthroughNewfoundland’sCod
Crisis.”Human Ecology Review.Vol 8. No.2. 2001. SocietyforHuman Ecology.
Harris,Michael.2003. “The graveyardof the sea.” The Ottawa Sun. May 9th
. [online].Availablefrom:
http://www.rudemacedon.ca/0305/030511-harris.html.Accessed:24 Nov2011.
Higgins,Jenny.2008. “FisheriesTechnologySince Confederation.” Society,Economy,and Culture.[online].Available
from:http://www.heritage.nf.ca/society/pc_fisheries.html.Accessed22 Nov2011.
Higgins,Jenny.2009. “Cod Moratorium:NewfoundlandandLabradorHeritage.” Society,Economy,and Culture.
[online].Available from: http://www.heritage.nf.ca/society/moratorium.html.Accessed23Nov2011.
17
Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and
Labrador:An Exploration of HistoricalChangesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The North
AtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-
1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011.
ICNAF.1952. Statisticsof Landingsof Groundfishfromthe ConventionArea. Second annualreportfortheyear1951-
52. St. Andrews,New Brunswick: International Commissiononthe NorthwestAtlanticFisheriesinHutchings,Jeffrey
A. andRansomA. Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof AtlanticCod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An
Exploration of Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlantic
Fisheries.[online].Availablefrom: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-
1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011.
Innis,H.A.1931. The Rise and Fall of the Spanish Fishery in Newfoundland. Trans.Roy.Soc.Canada 1931, (sec:2) 51-
70 in Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers. 1995. The Biological Collapse of AtlanticCod Off Newfoundland
and Labrador:An Exploration of HistoricalChangesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology, and Management. The
NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-
1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011.
Lounsbury,R.G.1934. The British Fishery at Newfoundland 1634-1763. New Haven:Yale UniversityPress.398 p.in
Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and
Labrador:An Exploration of HistoricalChangesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The North
AtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-
1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011.
Maclean’s.1992. “Improvedrelief.”July27th
,Vol.105 Issue 30, p.15. [online].Available from:
http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/9208101534/improved-relief.Accessed:24Nov2011.
McGrath, P.T.1911. Newfoundland in 1911. London:Whitehead,Morris&Co. 271 pp. inHutchings,JeffreyA.and
RansomA. Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Explorationof
Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online].
Available from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22
Nov2011.
Myers,Ransom A.,JeffreyA.Hutchings,andNicholasJ. Barrowman.1997. “Why do FishStocksCollapse?The
Example of CodinCanada.” Ecological Applications. Vol.7,No.1 (Feb.1997), pp. 91-106.
Pringler,Heather.2011. “Cabot,cod, andthe colonists –A Special Feature.”Canadian Geographic. [online].
Available from:http://www.canadiangeographic.ca/specialfeatures/atlanticcod/cabot.asp.Accessed:22 Nov2011.
Quinn,D.B.[ed].1979a. NewAmerican World. Vol.1. America FromConceptto Discovery:Early Exploration of North
America. NewYork: ArnoPressand HectorBye inHutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers.1995. The Biological
Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Explorationof HistoricalChangesin Exploitation,
Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from:
http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011.
Rose,G.A. 2003. “FisheriesResourcesandScience inNewfoundlandandLabrador:AnIndependentAssessment.”
RoyalCommission on Strengthening and Renewing OurPlacein Canada. March. [online].Availablefrom:
http://www.gov.nl.ca/publicat/royalcomm/research/Rose.pdf.Accessed:24 Nov2011.
18
Ryan,S. 1986. Fish Outof Water: The Newfoundland Saltfish Trade1814-1914. St. John’s:Breakwater.320 pp. in
Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and
Labrador:An Exploration of HistoricalChangesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The North
AtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-
1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011.
The Telegram.2010. “Recreational codfisheryannouncedforNewfoundlandandLabrador.”June 24th
. [online].
Available from:http://www.thetelegram.com/Business/Natural-resources/2010-06-24/article-
1442478/Recreational-cod-fishery-announced-for-Newfoundland-and-Labrador/1.Accessed:24Nov2011.
Thompson,H.1943. A Biological andEconomicStudyof Cod Gaduscallarias, L.) Res Bull. No.14. St. John’s:
Departmentof Natural Resources,Governmentof NewfoundlandandLabrador.160 pp.in Hutchings,JeffreyA. and
RansomA. Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Explorationof
Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online].
Available from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22
Nov2011.

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

ಸಾಮಾಜಿಕ ಹಕ್ಕು ಬಾಧ್ಯತೆಗಳ ಕುರಿತು ಇಸ್ಲಾಮ್ ಏನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತದೆ 1 (32)
ಸಾಮಾಜಿಕ ಹಕ್ಕು ಬಾಧ್ಯತೆಗಳ ಕುರಿತು ಇಸ್ಲಾಮ್ ಏನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತದೆ 1 (32)ಸಾಮಾಜಿಕ ಹಕ್ಕು ಬಾಧ್ಯತೆಗಳ ಕುರಿತು ಇಸ್ಲಾಮ್ ಏನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತದೆ 1 (32)
ಸಾಮಾಜಿಕ ಹಕ್ಕು ಬಾಧ್ಯತೆಗಳ ಕುರಿತು ಇಸ್ಲಾಮ್ ಏನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತದೆ 1 (32)FAHIM AKTHAR ULLAL
 
Guia de trabajo 1 4 dispositivos e s y e-s
Guia de trabajo 1 4 dispositivos e s y e-sGuia de trabajo 1 4 dispositivos e s y e-s
Guia de trabajo 1 4 dispositivos e s y e-sing_ebeltran
 
Trabajo completo alejo 650
Trabajo completo alejo 650Trabajo completo alejo 650
Trabajo completo alejo 650alejitogoloso69
 
Job specification
Job specificationJob specification
Job specificationPonta Nath
 
Manual emociones def
Manual emociones defManual emociones def
Manual emociones defTrinotrinito
 
Cognitive Task Analysis Of Teams Team Cta 25648
Cognitive Task Analysis Of Teams Team Cta 25648Cognitive Task Analysis Of Teams Team Cta 25648
Cognitive Task Analysis Of Teams Team Cta 25648ESS
 
Indusmedia 2014 - Talleres mendizabal - Apretando las tuercas a Google
Indusmedia 2014 - Talleres mendizabal - Apretando las tuercas a GoogleIndusmedia 2014 - Talleres mendizabal - Apretando las tuercas a Google
Indusmedia 2014 - Talleres mendizabal - Apretando las tuercas a GoogleIndusmedia
 

Viewers also liked (11)

La contaminacion
La contaminacionLa contaminacion
La contaminacion
 
ಸಾಮಾಜಿಕ ಹಕ್ಕು ಬಾಧ್ಯತೆಗಳ ಕುರಿತು ಇಸ್ಲಾಮ್ ಏನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತದೆ 1 (32)
ಸಾಮಾಜಿಕ ಹಕ್ಕು ಬಾಧ್ಯತೆಗಳ ಕುರಿತು ಇಸ್ಲಾಮ್ ಏನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತದೆ 1 (32)ಸಾಮಾಜಿಕ ಹಕ್ಕು ಬಾಧ್ಯತೆಗಳ ಕುರಿತು ಇಸ್ಲಾಮ್ ಏನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತದೆ 1 (32)
ಸಾಮಾಜಿಕ ಹಕ್ಕು ಬಾಧ್ಯತೆಗಳ ಕುರಿತು ಇಸ್ಲಾಮ್ ಏನು ಹೇಳುತ್ತದೆ 1 (32)
 
Suicidio infantil - Iniciativa
Suicidio infantil - IniciativaSuicidio infantil - Iniciativa
Suicidio infantil - Iniciativa
 
Guia de trabajo 1 4 dispositivos e s y e-s
Guia de trabajo 1 4 dispositivos e s y e-sGuia de trabajo 1 4 dispositivos e s y e-s
Guia de trabajo 1 4 dispositivos e s y e-s
 
Trabajo completo alejo 650
Trabajo completo alejo 650Trabajo completo alejo 650
Trabajo completo alejo 650
 
Job specification
Job specificationJob specification
Job specification
 
Perifericos grupo 1
Perifericos grupo 1Perifericos grupo 1
Perifericos grupo 1
 
Manual emociones def
Manual emociones defManual emociones def
Manual emociones def
 
Cognitive Task Analysis Of Teams Team Cta 25648
Cognitive Task Analysis Of Teams Team Cta 25648Cognitive Task Analysis Of Teams Team Cta 25648
Cognitive Task Analysis Of Teams Team Cta 25648
 
Africa
AfricaAfrica
Africa
 
Indusmedia 2014 - Talleres mendizabal - Apretando las tuercas a Google
Indusmedia 2014 - Talleres mendizabal - Apretando las tuercas a GoogleIndusmedia 2014 - Talleres mendizabal - Apretando las tuercas a Google
Indusmedia 2014 - Talleres mendizabal - Apretando las tuercas a Google
 

Similar to Cod Paper

7.1.4. lesson plan
7.1.4. lesson plan7.1.4. lesson plan
7.1.4. lesson planddonahuereid
 
What WAS the fishing like in Doubtless Bay, New Zealand. A marine conservat...
What WAS the fishing like in Doubtless Bay, New Zealand.   A marine conservat...What WAS the fishing like in Doubtless Bay, New Zealand.   A marine conservat...
What WAS the fishing like in Doubtless Bay, New Zealand. A marine conservat...Mary Ralph
 
The New England Colonies
The New England ColoniesThe New England Colonies
The New England Coloniesezlee2
 
Struggle to Control the Atlantic
Struggle to Control the AtlanticStruggle to Control the Atlantic
Struggle to Control the AtlanticRenata Niemiec
 
Economic History AssociationDutch Herring, Technology, and.docx
Economic History AssociationDutch Herring, Technology, and.docxEconomic History AssociationDutch Herring, Technology, and.docx
Economic History AssociationDutch Herring, Technology, and.docxSALU18
 
The origin of introduced rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) - in the Santa C...
The origin of introduced rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) - in the Santa C...The origin of introduced rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) - in the Santa C...
The origin of introduced rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) - in the Santa C...International Aquafeed
 
Sea power 2-session 2-meanwhile
Sea power 2-session 2-meanwhileSea power 2-session 2-meanwhile
Sea power 2-session 2-meanwhileJim Powers
 
CXC History School Based Assesment
CXC History School Based AssesmentCXC History School Based Assesment
CXC History School Based AssesmentKareem Jacobs
 
8.2 Decline of Atlantic Cod.A Case Study
8.2 Decline of Atlantic Cod.A Case Study8.2 Decline of Atlantic Cod.A Case Study
8.2 Decline of Atlantic Cod.A Case StudyEvanChristopherMurph
 
Caso Mcdonald´S
Caso Mcdonald´SCaso Mcdonald´S
Caso Mcdonald´SLiz Sims
 
Ferry boats and Fossil Fish - Featherbed Nature Reserve Knysna
Ferry boats and Fossil Fish - Featherbed Nature Reserve KnysnaFerry boats and Fossil Fish - Featherbed Nature Reserve Knysna
Ferry boats and Fossil Fish - Featherbed Nature Reserve KnysnaMartin Hatchuel
 
Should Antarctica Be Developed?
Should Antarctica Be Developed?Should Antarctica Be Developed?
Should Antarctica Be Developed?jacksonthree
 
Nation Dates (fifth edition) preview
Nation Dates (fifth edition) previewNation Dates (fifth edition) preview
Nation Dates (fifth edition) previewMcGuinness Institute
 
GvD_vol102_issue07_0124 1
GvD_vol102_issue07_0124 1GvD_vol102_issue07_0124 1
GvD_vol102_issue07_0124 1Tram B. Nham
 
Ush canada2 '11
Ush canada2 '11Ush canada2 '11
Ush canada2 '11MyDucky10
 

Similar to Cod Paper (20)

7.1.4. lesson plan
7.1.4. lesson plan7.1.4. lesson plan
7.1.4. lesson plan
 
Cod
CodCod
Cod
 
What WAS the fishing like in Doubtless Bay, New Zealand. A marine conservat...
What WAS the fishing like in Doubtless Bay, New Zealand.   A marine conservat...What WAS the fishing like in Doubtless Bay, New Zealand.   A marine conservat...
What WAS the fishing like in Doubtless Bay, New Zealand. A marine conservat...
 
The New England Colonies
The New England ColoniesThe New England Colonies
The New England Colonies
 
International marketing
International marketingInternational marketing
International marketing
 
Struggle to Control the Atlantic
Struggle to Control the AtlanticStruggle to Control the Atlantic
Struggle to Control the Atlantic
 
Economic History AssociationDutch Herring, Technology, and.docx
Economic History AssociationDutch Herring, Technology, and.docxEconomic History AssociationDutch Herring, Technology, and.docx
Economic History AssociationDutch Herring, Technology, and.docx
 
The origin of introduced rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) - in the Santa C...
The origin of introduced rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) - in the Santa C...The origin of introduced rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) - in the Santa C...
The origin of introduced rainbow trout (Oncorhynchus mykiss) - in the Santa C...
 
Sea power 2-session 2-meanwhile
Sea power 2-session 2-meanwhileSea power 2-session 2-meanwhile
Sea power 2-session 2-meanwhile
 
New zealand history
New zealand historyNew zealand history
New zealand history
 
HIST 600 Final_Dunham
HIST 600 Final_DunhamHIST 600 Final_Dunham
HIST 600 Final_Dunham
 
CXC History School Based Assesment
CXC History School Based AssesmentCXC History School Based Assesment
CXC History School Based Assesment
 
8.2 Decline of Atlantic Cod.A Case Study
8.2 Decline of Atlantic Cod.A Case Study8.2 Decline of Atlantic Cod.A Case Study
8.2 Decline of Atlantic Cod.A Case Study
 
Caso Mcdonald´S
Caso Mcdonald´SCaso Mcdonald´S
Caso Mcdonald´S
 
Ferry boats and Fossil Fish - Featherbed Nature Reserve Knysna
Ferry boats and Fossil Fish - Featherbed Nature Reserve KnysnaFerry boats and Fossil Fish - Featherbed Nature Reserve Knysna
Ferry boats and Fossil Fish - Featherbed Nature Reserve Knysna
 
Should Antarctica Be Developed?
Should Antarctica Be Developed?Should Antarctica Be Developed?
Should Antarctica Be Developed?
 
Nation Dates (fifth edition) preview
Nation Dates (fifth edition) previewNation Dates (fifth edition) preview
Nation Dates (fifth edition) preview
 
GvD_vol102_issue07_0124 1
GvD_vol102_issue07_0124 1GvD_vol102_issue07_0124 1
GvD_vol102_issue07_0124 1
 
Ush canada2 '11
Ush canada2 '11Ush canada2 '11
Ush canada2 '11
 
Presentation1
Presentation1Presentation1
Presentation1
 

Cod Paper

  • 1. The Collapse of the Cod Fishery in Newfoundland and Labrador Written by: Kate Hewitt 10053174 For: Andrew McDonough Resource and Environment Economics Friday, November 25th , 2011
  • 2. 2 Table of Contents Table of Figures……………..…………………………………………………………………………………………….……………………………………Page 3 Abstract…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..………..………………Page 4 Introduction…………………………………..………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 5 The History of NewfoundlandandLabrador’s Cod Fishery…………………………………………….……………………………..….Page 5 WhyCod? - An Economic Standpoint…………………………………………………………………………………..……………………………Page 7 The Cod FisheryCollapse – What Happened..……………………………………………………………………………….………………….Page 8 Environmental Implications………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………..…..Page 11 Where the FisheryStands Today…………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 13 Conclusion……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 15 References……………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………………….Page 16
  • 3. 3 Table of Figures Figure 1: A detailedmapof NewfoundlandandLabrador.……………………………………………………….………………………..Page 6 Figure 2: Biomassandtotal cod catch inNewfoundlandandLabrador………………………………………………………………Page 9 Figure 3: A mapof 200-mile exclusionzone……………………………………………………………………………………………………..Page 11 Figure 4: PopulationtrendsinNewfoundlandandLabrador…………………………………………………..……………………….Page 13 Figure 5: The Committee onthe Statusof EndangeredWildlife inCanada’scoddesignation…………………………..Page 14
  • 4. 4 Abstract The collapse of the cod fisheryinNewfoundlandandLabradorinthe late 20th centuryis consideredone of the worsteconomicandecological disastersinCanadianhistory.The codfishis a veryimportantfoodstaple andthe province helpedprovidethe resource bothnationallyandinternationallyforover500 years.Large-scale industrializationafterWorldWarII, however,isoftenblamedasthe initial cause of the collapse.More sophisticated machinerynearlydecimatedthe oceanflooraffectingnotonlycod,butothersignificantmarine organisms.The degradationof the cod stockput over30,000 people outof workand alteredland-useandhumanmigration patternsacross NewfoundlandandLabrador.Federal governmentfundinghasgiventhe province several billionsof dollarsincompensationforthe lossof the resource,yetitseemsmostof the damage has beendone.Thispaperwill explore the variouswaysinwhichthe codfisheryhasaffectedthe economy,the environment,andthe residentsof NewfoundlandandLabradorandCanada.
  • 5. 5 Introduction The Atlanticcod, Gadusmorhua,isone of the world’smostpopularfoodfishesandhasbeenharvestedoff the continental shelvesof Europe andNorth Americaforcenturies(HutchingsandMyers,1995). In the westernNorth Atlantic,the geographicdistributionof the fishrangesfromGreenlandandBaffinIsland,andmayextendasfar southas NorthCarolina(Ibid,1995) The NewfoundlandandLabradorcod fisherywasonce the largest(McGrath, 1911) andmost productive (Thompson,1943) cod fisheryinthe world,whenthe ‘Northern’codcomponent constitutedupwardsof 70 per centof all Newfoundlandcatchesafter1954 (HutchingsandMyers,1995). ‘Northern’ cod had beenfishedinthe areasince the late 15th century,inwhichthe plentifulstockswere expectedtoremain continuallyplentiful(Quinn,1979).Due to manyfactors suchas international,factory-basedtrawlersandlackof catch quotas,the resultantover-fishingof Newfoundland’scodstockinevitablyledtoacomplete collapseof the cod fisheryinthe province.The followingpaperwill examinewhythe codfishwaschoseninaneconomicstandpoint,a thoroughdescriptionof the collapse of the fishery,andthe environmental implicationsof thisaquaculture business. Thispaperwill conclude withanoverviewof the fishery’ssuccesstoday,andhow the aforementionedfactors impactedthe once prosperousfisheryinNewfoundlandandLabrador. The Historyof NewfoundlandandLabrador’sCodFishery Since the voyagesof JohnCabotin 1497 and 1498 there hasbeenmajorinternational interestinfishingalong the coast of Newfoundland(Quinn,1979).Portugal,France,England,andthe SpanishBasquesfishedalongthe east coast of the province betweenCape Race andCape Bonavista(where JohnCabotfirstlandedinNewfoundland) (HutchingsandMyers,1995). Spanishand Portuguese fisheriesinNewfoundlandwere short-livedasEnglish participationincreased(Innis,1931).In the 17th century,wars betweenthe English,Spanish,andthe Dutchresulted infewerfishingvessels(Lounsbury,1934).Thisresultedinthe rise of year-roundcodfishers(planters) ascatches rose from zeroto 37 percent between1610 and 1675 (Ibid,1934). The 1917 Treatyof Utrechtwas signedforthe War of SpanishSuccession,whichalsoendedthe Frenchfisheryalongthe southcoastof Newfoundland(Hutchings and Myers,1995). France removeditssettlersfromthe islandinreturn forthe rightto fishwithoutrestrictionson
  • 6. 6 the westand northeastshore betweenPointRiche andCape Bonavista(de LaVillemarqué,1991). See Figure 1 fora detailedmapof NewfoundlandandLabrador. In the second-half of the 18th century,catcheswere splitequallybetweenthe shore andthe bankfisheries alongthe southcoast of Labrador on the Straitof Belle Isle,whichlaterdiminisheddue tothe SevenYearsWar and the cedingof Labrador to the BritishCrown(Black,1960). Duringthistime,the inshore fisherybecame more popular despite offshore expansionintothe GrandBanks(HutchingsandMyers,1995). From 1736 to 1739, an annual average of 380,000 quintals(1quintal = 112 lbs) of cod were caught byBritishfishersinshore,asopposedto45,000 quintalscaughtoffshore (Lounsbury,1934).Decliningcatchratesoffshore promptedmuchof Newfoundland’s Figure 1: A detailed map of Newfoundland and Labrador Encyclopedia Brittanica, 1999
  • 7. 7 populationtomove westwardandnorthwardintothe province (HutchingsandMyers,1995). Schoonerswere eventuallyoutfitted inshore by1798, but the NewfoundlandandLabrador-basedfisherydidnotfirmlybecome establisheduntil the 1820’s(Gosling,1910, Black,1960, Ryan,1986). The residentsof Newfoundlandwhowere occupiedwiththe fisherygenerallyfounditmore prosperoustofish withinthe province thanseasonallytravel toBritain(HutchingsandMyers,1995). Duringthe NapoleonicWarsfrom 1793-1812, FrenchactivityinNewfoundlandwassuspended,andthisgave local residentsmore of anopportunityto take advantage of the fishstocks(Ibid,1995). The signingof the Treatyof Parisin1814, however,restoredFrench occupationinNewfoundlandandcatchesexpanded27per cent(Gosling,1910). Between1900 and 1950, Newfoundland(whichwasasyetnot a part of Canada) andFrance were dominantamongthe six fishingnations, accountingformore than90 percentof the total cod catch inNewfoundland(ICNAF,1952).The otherparticipating countrieswere Canada,the U.S.,Portugal,andSpain(Ibid,1952). At thispoint,cod stockswere depletingsorapidly fromthe combinationof over-fishingandlackof catch quotasthat between1900 and 1935, the Newfoundlandbank fisherydeclinedinquintal catchby22 per cent(Ibid,1952). However,Newfoundland’sinshorecatchstill exce eded offshore catchinall countriesuntil the mid-1950s(HutchingsandMyers, 1995). Why Cod?– AnEconomicStandpoint WhenJohnCabot firstarrivedinBonavista,Newfoundlandover500 yearsago, it wassaidthat fishers simply had to diptheirbucketsoverthe sidesof theirschoonersandtheywould come back burstingwithcod(Canadian Geographic,2011). Inthe year1620, SirRichard Whitbourne,aNewfoundlandexplorerandsettler,stated“…Butthe chiefe commodityof New-found-land...isthe Cod-fishinguponthatCoast,bywhichour Nationandmany other Countriesare enricht.”(Ibid,2011).Newfoundland’scodwasa lucrative oceanicfishnotonlyforproviding sustenance forthe residentsof the province,butalsointrade betweenNorthAmericanandEuropeancountries (Ibid,2011). The fishisvaluedfor food,liveroil andotherproducts. Codcanbe soldfresh,frozen,salted orsmoked while some are turnedintosticks,blocksandfilletsandothersare usedinfishmeal andglue production.Codcheeks and cod tonguesare considereddelicacies insome regions(Ibid,2011).Atlanticcod alsobecame the protein-source of choice inEurope as populationsrose.Itsfirm, flakyflesh,andlow-fatcontentallowedthe fishtoreadilydry
  • 8. 8 outdoorsandstoredoverthe wintermonthsforthe 40 daysof fastingat Lent(Pringler,2011).Lightly-salted,dried cod was able toresistrot foryears,eveninthe most temperate conditions,makingitideal forlightweight,naval rations(Ibid,2011). The Cod FisheryCollapse–What Happened The industrializationof NewfoundlandandLabradorinthe 20th centuryhada profoundeffectonthe way residentsof the province livedandworked.More sophisticatedgearsuchas large trawlersandlonglinersreplaced less-powerful schooners,dories,andpunts(Higgins,2008).These improvementsallowedfisherstoharvest unprecedentednumbersof codfishandothermarine resources,andallowedboatstoremainatseafor longer periodsof time.These changesaffectedsettlementpatternsandalteredthe demographicsof manyfishing communities.Settlementsclosetocod-processingsitesoftenflourishedwhileothercommunitiesmovedtolarger urban centres(Ibid,2008).This out-migrationfromrural areasbecame alarge probleminthe 1990’s whenmost youngpeople movedinordertofindemploymentelsewhere. FollowingConfederationin1949, the cod fisheryindustrybecame more popularinthe frozenfishsectorthan infamily-basedsaltfisheries(Higgins,2008).Fishersbegansellingfishdirectlytoprocessingcentresratherthan tradingwithlocal merchants,andmany fishersbeganworkingincompany-ownedfacilities(Ibid,2008).Long-term and severe over-fishingledtothe collapse of the codfisheryinthe 1990’s andput over30,000 people outof workin Newfoundland(Ibid,2008).In 1992, a moratoriumwasdeclaredoninshore andoffshore fishinginthe province (Myerset al,1997). Cod biomassduringthe collapse haddeclinedto99 percent of previousnumbersoff north- easternNewfoundlandandLabrador(McGrath, 1911 and Thompson,1943). Referto Figure 2 where the dottedlines representtotal catchand the solidlinesare the biomassof codfishinnorth-easternNewfoundlandandLabrador.
  • 9. 9 Myers, et al, 1997 Figure 2: Biomassandtotal cod catch inNewfoundlandandLabrador
  • 10. 10 The primarycause of the collapse isattributedtothe inabilitytocontrol fishingmortalityasthe targetwasto maintainsustainable levels(HutchingsandMyers, 1994). Asthe new fishingtechnologybecame more sophisticated, catch rates grewsteadilyuntil theysurpassedthe cod’sabilitytorebuild(Ibid,2009).Atthe same time,regulations safeguardingcodstockswere insufficient,andgovernmentsandinternational bodiessometimesassignedquotas basedon economicfactorsratherthan ecological ones(Higgins,2009).In1968, trawlingbyforeignfleetsmade up to 80 per centof the total catch for that year(Ibid,2009). Althoughmarine conservationbecame anincreasing concernafterthe 1960’s, oceanofficialsoftenoverestimatedthe size of codstocksand,therefore,the amountcod fisherscouldharvestatsustainable levels.Thisresultedinanoverexploitationof northerncod,whichforcedOttawa to impose amoratorium(Ibid,2009). In the year1970, the International Commissionforthe NorthwestAtlantic Fisheries(ICNAF) establishedcatchquotas,knownasTotal Allowable Catches(TAC’s) (Ibid,2009).It was believed that TAC’swouldequal the maximumnumber of fishthatfisherswere permittedtocatch withoutdepletingthe resource.Unfortunately,the ICNAFoverestimatedthe abundance of codaswell asits stockrate, andTAC’s were too highto be sustainable (Ibid,2009).Between1962 and 1977, the harvestable biomassof northerncoddropped82 percent, resultinginanearcollapse of the stockand the industry(Ibid,2009). Inthe 1970’s, cod stockdepletionwas officiallyrecognizedasaconcern.In 1976, Canadadeclareda 200-mile economicexclusionzone (EEZ) torestrict fishingbyforeigncountries,butsoonafter,Canada’sdomesticcapacitycompensatedforthe codbiomass international fleetswouldhave caught(HamiltonandButler,2001).In 1977, Canadaextendedits200-mile EEZI in hopestoregainsome of the lostcod stock(Higgins,2009). Most of the international fishingvesselscame from NorthAmericaand Europe – primarilythe SovietUnion,Spain,France,andPortugal –althoughsmallernumbers alsoarrivedfromAsiaand the Caribbean(Ibid,2009).See Figure 3 for a clear understandingof the 200-mile EEZ aroundNewfoundlandandLabrador. At the same time,state-sponsoredresettlementprogramsencouragedthe centralizationof NewfoundlandandLabrador’sresidentsindesignatedgrowthcentres(Higgins,2008).Between 1954 and 1975, about24,000 people leftmore than315 rural villagestolive inlarge centralizedcommunities(Ibid, 2008). The province thenhadfewerthan1,000 settlements,eachwithanaverage populationof about500 people. The federal andprovincial governmenthopedthe programswouldreduce the costsof providingelectricity,roads, schools,andotherservicestohundredsof remote communities(Ibid,2008).
  • 11. 11 Environmental Implications The over-fishingof Atlanticcodenabledacomplete ecological shiftincludingchangesintrophicsystemsand foodchains,andland use withinthe province.The oceanecosystemaroundthe GrandBankswas once dominated by cod fishandotherpredatorygroundfish,butsince the eradicationof mostcod,there isan insurgence of lower- trophic-level invertebrates(HamiltonandButler,2001).Thischange inthe area’sfoodchain alsoimpactsmarine animalsandlocal mammals.The populationof smallerfishmaydecrease aslargerpiscivoresbecome more dominant.Largermammalssuchas sealsand whalesare directlyimpactedbythe lackof foodavailability.Sealsin the regionhave a dietthat largely consistsof cod,while some whalesfeedonsmallermammalslike seals,which may be decreasinginpopulation.AsRichardHaedrich,afisheriesscientistatMemorial UniversityinSt.John’s Newfoundlandhasnoted,“Theymightnevercome back,at leastnot intheirformerabundance.Once youstart Rose, 2003 Figure 3: A map of 200-mile exclusion zone
  • 12. 12 changingthe whole ecosystem,the communitystructuresandsizes,you’ve gotawhole new ball game.”(E Magazine,2001). Historically,codandothergroundfishspecieswere consideredthe mostvaluable inthe economicmarket. However,asthese populationsdeclinedothermarine speciesbecame more popular.The snow crab(Chionoecetes opilio) and northernshrimp(Pandalusborealis) became muchmore prized,butthese are speciesthatcannot supportextensive exploitation(HamiltonandButler,2001). The Greenlandhalibut(Reinhardtiushippoglossoides) was consideredanalternative tocodfora time,butitis a slow-growing,long-livedspeciesthatisalsoonthe verge of collapse (Ibid,2001). There isdirectevidence thatthe large trawlersusedforthe masscollectionof codhave decimatedthe entire seafloorthata plethoraof organismsuse tosurvive (EMagazine,2001). Modernbottomtrawlershave destroyed the fragile continentalshelf,disturbingsensitive habitatandfoodavailabilityformanyspecies(Ibid,2001). Thisarea may take centuriestore-establishitself,andthiswouldonlyoccurwithzerotrawling.Trawling’seffectwasonce likenedtothe effectsof clear-cuttingforests,exceptinanarea150 timesgreater(Ibid,2001).The Grand Banksmay no longerbe capable of supportinglarge populationsof marine species,whichhasenabledsome opportunistic speciestoflourish.Insome areas,skatesanddogfishhave takenoverthe cod’splace withinthe ecosystem(Ibid, 2001). Many of Newfoundland’sresidentsalsochangedthe province’slanduse throughmigrationtoandfrom fishing ports.As cod stocklevelsstartingdepleting,more residentsmovedawayfromfisheries-dependentregionsand more towardswesternandnorthernNewfoundlandtofindemploymentelsewhere.RefertoFigure 4 fora visual representationof populationdecreasesinsome of the largestfishinglocationsinNewfoundland.Thishasplaced extreme stressonthe environmentaslanduseschange andmore area needstoconvertedtoa liveableand profitable state tosupportthe outmigrationof residents.
  • 13. 13 Where the FisheryStandsToday In April 1997, the federal governmentallowedatemporaryandlimitedcodcatch off the southerncoastof Newfoundlandinhonourof JohnCabot’sAtlanticcrossing500 yearsprior(CanadianGeographic,2011). Thisirked some environmentalists,asthe Committee onthe Statusof EndangeredWildlife inCanada(COSEWIC) hassuggested that cod be placedon the endangeredspecieslist(Comeau,2011). RefertoFigure 5 to see the determinationof cod stockson the COSEWIC listineasternCanada. On April 17th , Departmentof FisheriesandOcean’sministerFredMifflinannouncedthat6,000 tonnesof cod couldbe takenfrom the northernGulf of St. Lawrence andoff the westcoastof Newfoundland,and10,000 tonnes fromthe southerncoast,butthisledto much debate asitappearedthat some scientistsdidnotrealize the extentof the cod loss(Ibid,2011). Finally,inApril 2003, Federal FisheriesMinisterRobertThibaultannouncedthe complete closure of the cod fisheryinNewfoundland,the Maritime provinces,andQuebec(CBCNews,2004).In the summer of 2010, Federal FisheriesMinisterGail Sheaopenedthe recreational groundfishfisheryforthree weeksin NewfoundlandandLabrador(The Telegram,2010).It insistedadailybaglimitof onlyfive fishandaboat limitof 15 fishwhenthree ormore people are fishing(Ibid,2010). Figure 4: Population trends in Newfoundland and Labrador HamiltonandButler, 2001
  • 14. 14 Followingthe 2003 moratoriumonfishing,the federalandprovincial governmentsbegandevelopinglong- termstrategiesforrebuildingcodstocks(FisheriesandOceansCanada,2008). Theydevelopedthe federal based Canada-NewfoundlandandLabradorActionTeamforCod Rebuilding,ledbythe Departmentof Fisheriesand Oceans(DFO) andprovinciallybythe NewfoundlandandLabradorDepartmentof FisheriesandAquaculture (DFA) (Ibid,2008). In September2003, the Canada-QuebecActionTeamwasestablished,followedbyaCanada-Maritimes Cod ActionTeaminOctoberthat involvedthe governmentsof Canada,New Brunswick,NovaScotia,andPrince Edward Island(Ibid,2008).Theircommonprinciplesforcodrestockingwere generalpurpose,asharedstewardship, precautionarymanagementdecision-makingframeworks,andindicators,all designedforlong-termsuccess(Ibid, 2008). These strategiesare continuallymonitoredandresultsare reportedbacktogovernmentofficialsinorderto ensure success(Ibid,2008). Some residentsof NewfoundlandandLabradorwhowere previouslyemployed inthe codfisheriessector qualifiedforfinancial assistance followingthe collapseof the fishery.In1992, Federal FisheriesMinisterJohn Crosbie announcedthat19,000 Newfoundlandfishermenandplantworkerswouldreceivedupto$406 a weekin compensation,andtheycouldgetinvolvedwithskillsdevelopmentprogramstoqualifyformaximumbenefitsup until 1994 (Maclean’s1992). As of 2003, Canadiantax-payershadspentabout$4.2 billionin11 yearsto bailoutthe Atlanticcodfisheryandhelpcompensate the formeremployeesandprovide skills-trainingprograms(Harris,2003). Tax-payermoneywasprovidedtothe fishersthroughthe AtlanticGroundfishStrategy(TAGS),butunfortunatelythe federal governmentactuallylicensedmore fisherswhogotinvolvedwithcrab,shrimp,andalternate speciesfishing, Figure 5: The Committee on the Status of Endangered Wildlife in Canada’s cod designation Fisheries andOceans Canada, 2008
  • 15. 15 anotherenvironmental probleminitself (Ibid,2003).About38,000 people qualifiedforthe federal compensation fundwhichincludedrelicensing,butonly476 licenceswere reissued(Ibid,2003). Conclusion The Atlanticcod fisherycollapse,particularlyinNewfoundlandandLabrador,isone of the worsteconomic and ecological disastersinCanadianhistory.Itwasonce the largestandmost productive aquaculturebusinessinthe world,withinternational marketsvyingforsharesof the resource.Unfortunately,however,thisbusinessproved unsustainableandover30,000 people became unemployed.The codfishisanimportantfoodsource formanybut withoutpropereconomicandecological grounding,it,like manyotherspecies,hasbecome endangered.The Canadiangovernmentandthe country’sresidentsmaycontinue tofundfishingprojectsineasternCanadaformany decades,buthopefullythe collapse of the NewfoundlandandLabradorcod fisherywill become apoignantexample of the importance of sustainablebusinesspractices.
  • 16. 16 References Black,W.A. 1960. The Labrador FloaterFishery. AnnualsAssoc.Amer.Geogr. 50: 267-295 inHutchings,JeffreyA.and RansomA. Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Explorationof Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online]. Available from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011. CanadianGeographic.2011. The Rise and Fall of AtlanticCod – A Special Feature. [online].Availablefrom: http://www.canadiangeographic.ca/specialfeatures/atlanticcod/codhome.asp.Accessed:22Nov 2011. CBC News.2004. “Newfoundland’scodfishery.”May9th . [online].Availablefrom: http://www.cbc.ca/news/background/fishing/cod.html.Accessed:24 Nov2011. Comeau,Pauline.“A confidential reportconcludesthatAtlanticcodisendangered.” Canadian Geographic.[online]. Available from :http://www.canadiangeographic.ca/specialfeatures/atlanticcod/cod.asp.Accessed:24Nov2011. de La Villamarqué,J.H.1991. La pêche françaisedela moruedu XVIeau XVIIIesiècle dansl’Atlantiquedu nord ouest. Counseil International pourl’Explorationde laMer.C.M. 1991/G:67. 21 pp.in Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA. Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof AtlanticCod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Exploration of Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22Nov2011. E Magazine.2001. “A Run onthe Banks- HowFactory FishingDecimated NewfoundlandCod.”February28th . [online].Available from: http://www.emagazine.com/archive/507.Accessed:23Nov 2011. EncyclopediaBritannica.1999. [online].Available from: http://forums.superherohype.com/showthread.php?t=125040. Accessed24 Nov2011. FisheriesandOceansCanada.2008. “A Federal-Provincial Strategyforthe Rebuildingof AtlanticCodStocks.” [online].Available from: http://www.dfo-mpo.gc.ca/fm-gp/initiatives/cod-morue/strategy_overview-eng.htm. Accessed:24 Nov2011. Gosling,W.G.1910. Labrador:ItsDiscovery,Exploration,and Development.London:A.RiversinHutchings,JeffreyA. and RansomA.Myers. 1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundlandand Labrador:An Exploration of Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries. [online].Available from: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf. Accessed:22 Nov2011. Hamilton,Lawrence C.andMelissaJ.Butler.“OutportAdaptations:Social IndicatorsthroughNewfoundland’sCod Crisis.”Human Ecology Review.Vol 8. No.2. 2001. SocietyforHuman Ecology. Harris,Michael.2003. “The graveyardof the sea.” The Ottawa Sun. May 9th . [online].Availablefrom: http://www.rudemacedon.ca/0305/030511-harris.html.Accessed:24 Nov2011. Higgins,Jenny.2008. “FisheriesTechnologySince Confederation.” Society,Economy,and Culture.[online].Available from:http://www.heritage.nf.ca/society/pc_fisheries.html.Accessed22 Nov2011. Higgins,Jenny.2009. “Cod Moratorium:NewfoundlandandLabradorHeritage.” Society,Economy,and Culture. [online].Available from: http://www.heritage.nf.ca/society/moratorium.html.Accessed23Nov2011.
  • 17. 17 Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Exploration of HistoricalChangesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The North AtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991- 1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011. ICNAF.1952. Statisticsof Landingsof Groundfishfromthe ConventionArea. Second annualreportfortheyear1951- 52. St. Andrews,New Brunswick: International Commissiononthe NorthwestAtlanticFisheriesinHutchings,Jeffrey A. andRansomA. Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof AtlanticCod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Exploration of Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlantic Fisheries.[online].Availablefrom: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991- 1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011. Innis,H.A.1931. The Rise and Fall of the Spanish Fishery in Newfoundland. Trans.Roy.Soc.Canada 1931, (sec:2) 51- 70 in Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers. 1995. The Biological Collapse of AtlanticCod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Exploration of HistoricalChangesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology, and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991- 1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011. Lounsbury,R.G.1934. The British Fishery at Newfoundland 1634-1763. New Haven:Yale UniversityPress.398 p.in Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Exploration of HistoricalChangesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The North AtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991- 1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011. Maclean’s.1992. “Improvedrelief.”July27th ,Vol.105 Issue 30, p.15. [online].Available from: http://connection.ebscohost.com/c/articles/9208101534/improved-relief.Accessed:24Nov2011. McGrath, P.T.1911. Newfoundland in 1911. London:Whitehead,Morris&Co. 271 pp. inHutchings,JeffreyA.and RansomA. Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Explorationof Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online]. Available from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011. Myers,Ransom A.,JeffreyA.Hutchings,andNicholasJ. Barrowman.1997. “Why do FishStocksCollapse?The Example of CodinCanada.” Ecological Applications. Vol.7,No.1 (Feb.1997), pp. 91-106. Pringler,Heather.2011. “Cabot,cod, andthe colonists –A Special Feature.”Canadian Geographic. [online]. Available from:http://www.canadiangeographic.ca/specialfeatures/atlanticcod/cabot.asp.Accessed:22 Nov2011. Quinn,D.B.[ed].1979a. NewAmerican World. Vol.1. America FromConceptto Discovery:Early Exploration of North America. NewYork: ArnoPressand HectorBye inHutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Explorationof HistoricalChangesin Exploitation, Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011. Rose,G.A. 2003. “FisheriesResourcesandScience inNewfoundlandandLabrador:AnIndependentAssessment.” RoyalCommission on Strengthening and Renewing OurPlacein Canada. March. [online].Availablefrom: http://www.gov.nl.ca/publicat/royalcomm/research/Rose.pdf.Accessed:24 Nov2011.
  • 18. 18 Ryan,S. 1986. Fish Outof Water: The Newfoundland Saltfish Trade1814-1914. St. John’s:Breakwater.320 pp. in Hutchings,JeffreyA.andRansomA.Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Exploration of HistoricalChangesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The North AtlanticFisheries.[online].Available from: http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991- 1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011. The Telegram.2010. “Recreational codfisheryannouncedforNewfoundlandandLabrador.”June 24th . [online]. Available from:http://www.thetelegram.com/Business/Natural-resources/2010-06-24/article- 1442478/Recreational-cod-fishery-announced-for-Newfoundland-and-Labrador/1.Accessed:24Nov2011. Thompson,H.1943. A Biological andEconomicStudyof Cod Gaduscallarias, L.) Res Bull. No.14. St. John’s: Departmentof Natural Resources,Governmentof NewfoundlandandLabrador.160 pp.in Hutchings,JeffreyA. and RansomA. Myers.1995. The Biological Collapseof Atlantic Cod Off Newfoundland and Labrador:An Explorationof Historical Changesin Exploitation,Harvesting Technology,and Management. The NorthAtlanticFisheries.[online]. Available from:http://ram.biology.dal.ca/~myers/papers/Papers-1991-1995/biological_collapse.pdf.Accessed:22 Nov2011.