SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 21
Download to read offline
Capstone Research Journal Article
(This manuscript fulfills the requirements for the North Carolina Agricultural and
Technical State University Department of Biology Senior Project BIOL 496)
Miquise Carlton
North Carolina Agricultural & Technical State University
Biology 496
Fall 2015
Drs. White & Lang
Signature of Author: Miquise D. Carlton Date: 11-30-2015
CHRONIC PERIODONTITIS
A relationship to the Heart
9/18/2015
1
CHRONIC PERIODONTITIS
A relationship to the Heart
Student Demographic:
Greetings! My name is Miquise D. Carlton and I am a Biology student here at North
Carolina Agriculture and Technical State University. I was born into a single parent
household and raised by my beautiful mother, Mildred N. Johnson, in Hickory, North
Carolina. I am one of three on my mother’s side of the family spectrum and one of nine
on my father’s side of the family spectrum. We roll deep!!!! While living in an area, in
which was highly known for crime, my mother was very determined to introduce myself
and along with my brother and sister to a healthier life style. At the beginning of the
transformation, my brother, sister and I was extremely heartbroken from the new
transformation into a different neighborhood and a better life-style because the change
caused for us to loose old friends. However, from my understanding, in order for a
change to be extremely beneficial for a family, the family will have to disconnect from
other families and/or individuals who they are not equally yoked with and who does not
have the aspiration to enhance their way of living.
With the painful yet awesome change in effect, I was able to enhance my critical thinking
skills, mathematical skills, reading and writing skills, and etcetera. I was able to graduate
within the top 15% of my high school, consisting of approximately 250 graduates. This
was an extremely great accomplishment, considering some, if not all, African American
males from my home town do not necessarily graduate from their local high school but
instead become a high school dropout.
9/18/2015
2
After graduation, I had the opportunity to enroll into North Carolina Agriculture and
Technical State University, in which I am currently attending as I previously stated
before, and from there I decided to major in biology. I decided to become a biology
student because I have always dreamed of becoming a doctor, more specifically a dentist.
In addition of knowing dentistry was the profession I wanted to pursue as a professional
career, I eagerly decided to design a literature research review on the subject matter,
chronic periodontitis and its relationship to the heart.
Furthermore, I would like to personally thank each professor who contributed to
providing me with the necessary tools and information I needed to enhance my education.
In addition, I would also like to thank Dr. White for her dedication and inspiration
towards me because it allowed me to develop endurance and push myself beyond
measure. In addition, I would personally like to thank my friend, Crystal Hill, for being a
phone call away to assist with sentence structure and grammatical errors. Lastly, I would
personally like to thank my family, for keeping me grounded during my last three years
of college. They were always a text message and a phone call away to allow for me to
vent about my college life, when I began to become overwhelmed by my studies.
9/18/2015
3
Table of Contents:
Description: Page Number:
I. Title Page
II. Student Demographics-----------------------------------------------------1-2
III. Table of Contents ------------------------------------------------------3
IV. Abstract ----------------------------------------------------------------------4
V. Body of Paper
a. Introduction --------------------------------------------------------
b. Understanding Chronic Periodontitis----------------------------5-6
c. Understanding Coronary Heart Disease-------------------------6
d. Literature Review--------------------------------------------------6-13
i. Mechanical Linkage of Periodontitis to Cardiovascular/Coronary
Disease------------------------------------------------------6-11
ii. Statistical Linkage of Chronic Periodontitis to Cardiovascular
Disease------------------------------------------------------12-13
e. Conclusion/Discussion---------------------------------------------13-15
f. References------------------------------------------------------------16
VI. Appendix A.-------------------------------------------------------------------17-20
9/18/2015
4
Abstract:
Chronic Periodontitis…….. A relationship to the Heart
Miquise D. Carlton
Coronary heart disease is the leading cause of death amongst men and women. As the
population of victims of CHD increases, it becomes more imperative that causes of CHD
be defined and prevented. The traditional factors of CHD have been outlined by the
American Health Association; yet, the AHA’s prescribed factors only accurate describe
one-third of those who suffer from CHD. The presence oral periodontitis in
atherosclerotic plaque and the chronic periodontitis evident in those who suffer from
acute myocardial infarction, provides substantial evidence that periodontitis is linked to
CHD. In proving that such a linkage is statistically significant and mechanically
plausible, the underlying cause for CHD morbidity will be revealed, for chronic
periodontitis can be a more accurate predictor and descriptor of those at risk for heart
disease. Whereas, the tradition factors prescribed by AHA are merely symptoms of the
symbiosis between chronic periodontitis and CHD.
Representative Article:
http://www.jisponline.com/article.asp?issn=0972124X;year=2012;volume=16;issue=4;sp
age=487;epage=491;aulast=Arigbede#ft12
9/18/2015
5
Introduction:
The purpose of this study is to explore chronic periodontitis as it relates to patients that
suffer from coronary heart disease. More specifically focusing on the question is there a
linkage between chronic periodontitis and coronary heart disease. This study will analyze
a verity of different clinical research linking chronic periodontitis to chronic heart diseases.
If chronic periodontitis is linked to coronary heart disease-statistically and mechanically,
then a significant factor responsible for cardiovascular morbidity will be evinced.
Furthermore, chronic periodontitis may prove to be a more accurate predictor and
descriptor of those at risk for heart disease, when compared to traditional risk factors
prescribed by the American Heart Association.
Understanding Chronic Periodontitis
Chronic periodontitis, a severe case of inflammation around an individuals’ tooth, begins
with a bacterial growth within the oral region of a human. During the process of chronic
periodontitis, the gums begins to loosen and creating spaces, better known as pockets,
between the tooth and the gum that will however become infected. An individuals’ immune
system will begin to attack the invading bacteria as the plaque spreads and develops below
the gum line. The bacterial toxins and an individuals’ natural response to invading bacteria
will begin to break down the bone and connective tissue associated with holding the tooth
in place. Scientist and other physicians across the nation has stated if chronic periodontitis
id not treated in a timely fashion, the bones, gums, and the connective tissue will be
destroyed and could lead to the removal of many teeth due to the destruction. Periodontitis
is primarily caused by plaque, bacteria, but there are serval other factors contributing to
9/18/2015
6
periodontal disease, such as hormonal changes, illnesses, smoking, medications, bad
habits, poor oral hygiene habits, and family history of dental disease.(1) Researchers across
the world have uncovered potential links between chronic periodontitis and other serious
health conditions. It has been stated, in humans with healthy immune systems the bacteria
within the oral region could enter the bloodstream and effect other areas within the body.
Understanding Coronary Heart Disease:
Coronary heart disease (CHD), also known as coronary artery disease, is the leading cause
of death amongst men and women in the United States of America. CHD is a narrowing of
the small blood vessels that supply oxygen-rich blood to the heart. Researchers have stated
and proven that CDH is caused by the buildup of plaque in the arties of the human heart.
The buildup of plaque within the arteries will allow them to become narrow and as a result,
the blood flow, in which is flowing to the heart, could travel at a much slower rate or could
eventually stop (2).
Literature Review:
Mechanical Linkage of Periodontitis to Cardiovascular/Coronary Disease:
Atherosclerotic coronary artery disease, the main underlying disease responsible for
cardiovascular and cerebrovascular morbidity-which includes thrombosis and myocardial
infarction- is a contributing factor in 50% of United States’ deaths. Yet more than one-third
of patients dying from atherosclerotic coronary vascular disease do not possess any of the
traditional risk factors such as: obesity, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, hypertension, and
9/18/2015
7
cigarette smoking (3,4). It has been long since known that there are associations of
atherosclerotic risk with infectious agents and several pathogens. This association is a
rational one, for the process of development of atherosclerosis involves chronic
inflammation (3). To make the involvement of pathogens more concrete, it is also
understood that chlamydia phneumonia, herpes simplex virus, streptococcus sanguis, and
porphyromonas gingivalis have been detected in human atheromas (4). Though
porphyromonas gingivalis is mentioned, it is necessary to further define the role of the oral
cavity/teeth in the pathogenesis of atherosclerotic vascular disease.
It has become increasingly clear that the oral cavity possesses the ability to function as the
site of origin for dissemination of pathogenic organisms to distant body sites, especially in
immunocompromised hosts-including patients suffering from diabetes (a traditional factor
of CHD). This is possible, due to the fact that the teeth are the only non-shedding surfaces
in the body, and bacteria levels can reach more than 1011
microorganisms per milligram of
dental plague (4). Human periodontal infections are associated with complex microfloras
in which approximately 200 species in apical periodontitis and more than 500 species in
marginal periodontitis have been encountered (4). These pathogenic infections are
predominantly anaerobic and gram-negative (4). The mere anatomic proximity of these
complex microfloras to the blood stream can easily facilitate bacteria and the systematic
spread of bacterial products, components, and immunocomplexes (4).
Porphyromonas gingivalis (Pg) is the most common form of adult periodontitis and is
estimated to affect 116 million Americans (5). The consequences of Pg are local
inflammations characterized by gingival ulceration and vascular changes, both of which
increase the incidence and severity of transient oral bacterias (5). Also, various studies have
9/18/2015
8
concluded that Pg can not only adhere but also invade and proliferate in artotic and heart
endothelial cells and coronary artery smooth muscle cells (5,3). In action this translates to
a host having efficient endocytic (endocytosis: form of active transport in which a cell
transports molecules into the cell by engulfing them, includes pinocytosis and
phagocytosis) uptake and Pg persisting within endothelial cells and altering the cells’
integrity (5). Consequently, the transience of such an infection into the systemic circulation
of frequent bacteria would cause chronic inflammatory damage to vasculature and further
the initiation and progression of atherosclerosis and/or atherosclerosis lesions (5).
Furthermore, Li Li and colleagues hypothesized and demonstrated: in vivo long-term
systemic circulatory challenge with Pg can promote and accelerate the development of
atherosclerotic lesions (5). To test such a hypothesis, apoliprotein E-deficient (apoliprotein
E is the official name of the APOE gene/its protein product apo E; it is essential for the
prevention of disorders that affect the heart and blood vessels, i.e-cardiovascular diseases)
heterozygous mice were challenged with Pg (5).
In the study, Pg A7436 was grown on anaerobic blood plates in and anaerobic chamber
with an environment composed of: 85% nitrogen, 5% hydrogen, and 10% carbon dioxide
for 3 to 5 days, and then the grown Pg was inoculated with Shaedler Broth for twenty-four
hours until the culture reached an optical density of 0.8 at 660nm, equivalent to 109
CFU/mL (5). As specified by Neogen Corporation, the manufacturer and distributor of
Schaedler Broth, the utilized broth is specified for the cultivation of anaerobic
microorganisms. Neogen Corporation also mentions that “Shaedler Broth in an atmosphere
of 5% carbon dioxide, 10% hydrogen, and 85% nitrogen exhibited the fastest and highest
growth response” (6). Though the 1%: 2% ratio of hydrogen: carbon in the study is the
9/18/2015
9
reciprocal of that specified by the manufacturer, given the period of time to grow Pg A7436
it is safe to assume that in the experiment the pathogen also exhibited an equally fast and
high growth rate.
Male Apo E homozygotes (ApoE -/-
) and the corresponding female wild-type hybrids were
obtained at eight weeks of age. Both groups were fed regular mouse food. To generate
apoliprotein E-deficient heterozygous (ApoE +/-
), ApoE -/-
mice were crossed with the
female wild type mice (5, Figure 1). At four weeks of age, the Male ApoE heterozygous
mice and wild-type mice were randomly assigned to either a high-fat diet (HFD)- the
experimental diet- or the regular mouse food - the control diet (5, Figure 1). At ten weeks
of age, ApoE +/-
or wild-type mice, HFD-fed or regular food-fed, were divided at random
into two groups: inoculated with live Pg (107
CFU/50 µL/mouse) or diluted medium (50
µL/mouse) (5). The inoculation was performed intravenously once per week for 10, 14, or
24 consecutive weeks (5, Figure 1).
For tissue harvesting, the mice underwent an overnight fast then, were sedated with
isoflurane, and exsanguinated as approved by The Institutional Animal Care and Use
Committee of Boston University (5). The aortic tree and proximal aorta were separated
close to the heat; after which, the aortic tree- including the arch and thoracic and abdominal
aorta- was processed for en face morphometric analysis. This type of analysis refers to the
quantitative analysis of form, which encompasses size and shape, the impact of mutations
on shape, developmental changes in form, etc.
The extent of atherosclerosis in the aortic tree was determined by en face quantification. In
which, the total aortic surface area and the atherosclerosis lesion area were measured with
9/18/2015
10
a stereomiscroscope with computer-assisted image analysis capabilities possessed by the
Image Pro Plus 40 (5). However in the regular mice food fed group, the sensitivity of this
procedure did not allow for the detection of any lesion at any time point. The percentage
of aortic surface area covered by lesions at all time points was greater in the Pg-challenged
mice, than in vehicle control animals, P<0.05 (5, Figure 2A). In the HFD-fed mice groups,
red-stained, lipid-rich lesions were first evident ten weeks after the onset of inoculation
with Pg. Furthermore, at 14- and 24-week time points, red-stained lesions were observed
in both Pg-inoculated and non-inoculated mice but to a greater extend in Pg-challenged
mice (5, Figure 2B).
For histomorphometric and histopathological analysis, the proximal aortic cross-sections
for quantitative and histopthalogical evaluation of atherosclerotic lesions were performed.
In which, the percentage of total aortic lumen occupied by lesions per section were
calculated. Also, the total lesion area and the percentage of total aortic lumen occupied by
lesions were averaged over four sections per animal to develop both the mean lesion area
and percentage of total lumen of the proximal aorta occupied by lesions per section within
each animal (5). In the groups of mice who were fed regular mouse food, lesions were not
evident after 10 weeks of inoculation. In Pg-challenged mice, foam cell lesions were
evident after 14 weeks of inoculation (P<0.01) (5, Figure 3A). After 24 weeks of
inoculation, the average lesion area of the Pg was 9 times greater than in the vehicle
controlled mice; instead, the average lesion area was similar in level to HFD-fed mice
injected with vehicle (5). Also in regards to the HFD groups, the mean lesion area was
greater in Pg- challenged mice than in the unchallenged control mice, as well as attaining
a significance level 2 times greater (P<0.001) after 24 weeks of inoculation, with the same
9/18/2015
11
persistent pattern for percentage of total lumen of the proximal aorta occupied by lesions
per section within each animal (5, Figure 3B).
Furthermore, two stages were observed to characterize the progression of lesions: stage 1
lesions were characterized by sudanophilic (stained by Sudan IV dye, lipid-rich) lesions;
stage 2 lesions were composed of a mixture of sudanophic cells, spindle-shaped cells,
acellular zones, and inflammation (5, Figure 4E, 5C, 5D, 5E, 5F). In relation to location,
lesions primarily occurred in the aortic valve attachments and the free aortic wall, in which
stained cells adhered to the surface of the endothelial lining.
Within 10 weeks, staining of macrophages was evident in HFD mice injected with saline
or Pg and thusly, intensified with the development of lesions until the conclusion of the
24-week period. However, staining was more pronounced in Pg- injected mice than in
saline-injected mice. Mice that were fed regular mouse food exhibited Mac-3 staining
[M3/84 monoclonal antibody reacts with mouse Mac-3. The Mac-3 antigen is upregulated
during macrophage differentiation. Peritoneal and tissue macrophages, dendritic cells, and
endothelial cells express this antigen on their surface (7).] only in Pg-injected mice,
beginning at the 14-week period (5). In wild-type mice that were fed regular mouse food
atherosclerotic lesions were not observed from the 10 to 24-week period, after Pg-
inoculation; while in HFD-fed wild-type mice, early stages of foam cell lesions were
observed at 24 weeks after Pg-inoculation- which is similar to the lesions observed in ApoE
heterozygous, regular food fed mice at 14 weeks after Pg-inoculation (5, Figure 5).
Statistical Linkage of Chronic Periodontitis to Cardiovascular Disease:
9/18/2015
12
In mid-2009, Willershausen et. al. sought to investigate whether a statistically significant
association between periodontal disease and coronary heart disease could be established.
This association was indeed proven in the discovery that dental chronic inflammatory
diseases correlate with the occurrence of acute myocardial infarction (AMI); thusly,
periodontal diseases can be viewed as possible risk factors for CHD (8).
To establish such a correlation, basic statistics-standard deviation, p-value, and the
implications of the normal curve- were combined with standard scientific procedures, i.e.-
control group and an experimental group. The experimental patient group consisted of one
hundred twenty-five of 568 AMI patients (all of which had been previously verified for
having AMI by hospitalization at the Department of Cardiology and Angiology of the
University of Mainz). The remaining 443 patients were excluded from the study on basis
of having previous dental examinations (including those whose most recent dental history
was already known would inhibit a random statistical study), lack of teeth, and death (8).
The experimental group possessed a mean age of 61.8 years, with a standard deviation of
10.7 years, and a distribution of 85% male and 15% female (8). The control group was
comprised of 125 of 352 healthy patients, who were selected along the same criteria of
being alive, possessed 5 or more teeth, and had not a recent dental examination. Also, no
statistical difference regarding age and gender was found between the AMI (experimental
group) and healthy control group, for the healthy group had a mean age of 63.4 years, with
a standard deviation of 10.7 years, and a distribution of 82% male and 18% female (8).
Once the groups were characterized by age and gender, the differences of the two groups
were then characterized via physical and clinical oral findings. These differences are listed
9/18/2015
13
as age, body mass index (BMI), diabetes, number of missing teeth, number of treated teeth,
apical lesions, number of crowns, and the increasing severity of periodontitis (PSI).
In comparison to the control patients, the AMI patients had an unfavorable dental status- a
statistically higher number of missing teeth and a higher frequency of dental infection (8).
Furthermore, a significant relationship between increasing severity of periodontitis and
AMI could be observed, for a PSI degree of 4 was found in 42.3% of AMI patients, while
only 17.1% of the control patients (8, Figure 6). A high number of apical lesions was found
in 19.5% of the AMI patients, whereas only 2.3% of the healthy population had less than
the AMI patients; hence, apical lesions do not correlate to CHD (8, Figure 7).
Conclusion/Discussions:
The systematic intravascular challenge with Pg inoculation was shown to accelerate the
progression of atherosclerosis in an ApoE +/-
murine model. However, this acceleration
required genetic susceptibility and/or a dietary risk factor and/or an infectious agent. The
importance of genetic susceptibility was evident in the failure to produce atherosclerotic
lesions in regular food, wild type mice after 24 weeks of Pg- inoculation (5). The
importance of dietary risk factors is emphasized by the earlier, more extensive, and more
advanced progression of atherosclerotic lesions in ApoE +/-
mice that were fed HFD,
when compared to ApoE +/-
mice fed regular mouse food (5). The influence of the
infectious agent is illustrated by the fact that wild-type mice fed HFD had early foam cell
lesions after 24 weeks of Pg-inoculation, compared to those observed in regular food fed
ApoE +/-
mice at 14 weeks of inoculation (5). Also in the context of a genetic
9/18/2015
14
predisposition such as ApoE +/-
or an environmental risk factor, i.e.- HFD, Pg infection
importantly accelerates the progression of atherosclerosis: aortic atherosclerotic lesions in
Pg-inoculated ApoE +/-
mice developed earlier and were larger and more advanced than
in non-inoculated mice with the same genetics and diet (5). In context of short/long term
exposure to the Pg, long-term Pg inoculation contributed to more significantly than in
short-term acceleration of atherosclerosis: at 14 week Pg inoculation, there were mild
effects in mice that were fed regular mice food, whereas at 24 weeks of Pg inoculation
the lesions in regular food fed ApoE +/-
mice were similar to those of the HFD-fed vehicle
control group (5). Thusly showing, the mild effects of Pg could accumulate, resulting in a
remarkable acceleration of atherosclerosis. The murine model employed establishes
periodontal pathogens contribute to the development and progression of atherosclerosis.
Ergo mechanically speaking, periodontitis is a factor in CHD.
Though PSI and lack of teeth correlate dental disease to myocardial infarcation, This
association is more concretely illustrated, using blood glucose levels, C-reactive protein
(CRP) serum levels, and leukocyte numbers. These same factors point to patients with AMI
exhibiting an unfavorable dental state of health (8,9). Thusly, these variables are evidence
that patients with acute myocardial infarction also suffer from chronic dental infection (9)
. Hence one can conclude periodontal disease can be utilized as an established factor for
CHD, as individuals with periodontal disease have an approximately 24% -35% increase
in risk of developing CHD” (8).
The factors of CHD given by the American Heart Association: age, gender, BMI, diabetes,
and ethnicity were directly/in-directly included in each presented study. Willershausen et.
al. includes them directly, and Li et. al. includes them in an indirectly wholistic approach,
9/18/2015
15
for each of the AHA factors can be applied in the categories of genetic susceptibility and/or
dietary risk factor. The inclusion of these factors suggests that the classic AHA factors of
CHD are linked and emphasized, if not merely symptoms, of chronic periodontal pathogens
as they relate to CHD. From this symbiosis of factors, it is understood periodontitis may
be a more accurate descriptor of those at risk for heart disease than classic AHA factors.
9/18/2015
16
Work Cited:
1. "Periodontal (Gum) Disease: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatments." Periodontal
(Gum) Disease: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatments. Web. 9 Oct. 2015.
2. "Dentists: Doctors of Oral Health." Dentists: Doctors of Oral Health. Web. 9
Oct. 2015.
3. Fong, Ignatius W. "Infections and their role in atherosclerotic vascular
disease." The Journal of the American Dental Association 133 (2002): 7S-13S.
4. Li, Xiaojing, et. al. “Systemis Diseases Caused by Oral Infection. Clinical
Microbiology Reviews.13.4 (2000): 547- 558. Web. 28 Oct. 2015.
5. Li, Li et. al. “ Poryphyromonas Gingivalis Infection Accelerates the Progression
of Atherosclerosis in a Hetereozygous Apoliprotein E-Deficient Murine
Model.” American Heart Association Journal 2002; 105:861-867. Web. 28 Oct.
2015.
6. "Schaedler Broth (7154)." Schaedler Broth Product Information Page 06
(2010): n. pag. Neogen.Com. Web. 28 Oct. 2015
7. "Anti-Mouse CD107b (Mac-3) Purified." Mouse CD107b (Mac-3) Antibody
Purified M3/84 RUO. Ebioscience, 2010. Web. 17 Nov. 2015.
8. Willershausen, Brita, et al. "Association between chronic dental infection and
acute myocardial infarction." Journal of endodontics 35.5 (2009): 626-630.
9. Demmer, Ryan T., and Moïse Desvarieux. "Periodontal Infections and
Cardiovascular Disease." The Journal of the American Dental Association.
Print.
10. Cobb, Charles M. "Clinical significance of non‐surgical periodontal therapy: an
evidence‐based perspective of scaling and root planing." Journal of Clinical
Periodontology 29.s2 (2002): 22-32.
11. Arigbede, Abiodun O., B. Osagbemiro Babatope, and M. Kolude Bamidele.
“Periodontitis and Systemic Diseases: A Literature Review.” Journal of Indian
Society of Periodontology 16.4 (2012): 487–491. PMC. Web. 9 Oct. 2015.
12. Chiu, Brian. "Multiple infections in carotid atherosclerotic plaques." American
heart journal 138.5 (1999): S534-S536.
13. Dietrich, Thomas et al. “Age-Dependent Associations between Chronic
Periodontitis/edentulism and Risk of Coronary Heart Disease: Dietrich,
Periodontitis and CHD.” Circulation 117.13 (2008): 1668–1674. PMC. Web. 9
Oct. 2015.
14. Persson, G. Rutger, et al. "Chronic periodontitis, a significant relationship with
acute myocardial infarction." European heart journal 24.23 (2003): 2108-2115.
15. "Coronary Heart Disease: MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia." U.S National
Library of Medicine. U.S. National Library of Medicine. Web. 9 Oct. 2015.
Appendix A:
9/18/2015
17
Figure 1: Time schedule of the experiment (12).
Figure 2: (A) Percentage of aortic surface area covered by lesions. (B)
Representative results of en face analysis in HFD group showing absence of
lessions at 10 weeks of vehicle injection (1) and severity of lesions after 14 weeks
(II) and after 24 weeks (III) of Pg inoculations (12).
9/18/2015
18
Figure 3: (A) Mean lesion area per section per animal. (B) A percentage of total lumen
of proximal aortas occupied by lesions (12).
Figure 4: Cross-sections of aortic lesions in chow-fed ApoE+/ mice challenged
with Pg or vehicle. Normal configuration of proximal aorta from a chow-fed wild-type
mice at 20 weeks of age (A). After 14 weeks of inoculation, no lesion is found in
control mice (B), whereas foam cell lesion (first stage) is present adjacent to valve-
attachment in Pg-inoculated mice (C). After 24-week inoculation, lesions in control
mice remain at foam cell lesion stage (D), whereas most of lesions in Pg-inoculated
mice progress to the second stage (E). *Foam cell. L indicates aortic lumen; I, intima;
M, media; and A, adventitia (12).
9/18/2015
19
Figure 5: Cross-sections of aortic lesions in HFD-fed ApoE/mice challenged with Pg or
vehicle. First-stage lesions (foam cells) adjacent to valve attachments (A and B) and in free
aortic wall (B) are found in 10-week postinoculation mice; secondstage lesions are observed
in 14- and 24-week postinoculation mice (C through F). Lesions in Pg-inoculated ApoE+/-
mice are larger and more advanced than in noninoculated mice at same time point. *Foam
cell. L indicates aortic lumen; M, media; and A, adventitia (12).
Table 1: Basic Group Characteristics (SD or in Percentages) and P values for
Differences between patients with AMI and the Healthy Control Patients (1).
9/18/2015
20
Figure 6: PSI (degree: 0 - 4) distribution in patients after AMI and healthy controls (1).
Figure 7: Frequency of apical lesions in patients after AMI and healthy control patients
(1).

More Related Content

What's hot

Vascular repair after firearm injury is associated with increased morbidity a...
Vascular repair after firearm injury is associated with increased morbidity a...Vascular repair after firearm injury is associated with increased morbidity a...
Vascular repair after firearm injury is associated with increased morbidity a...anomwiradana
 
Crimson Publishers-Considerations for Elderly People Facing Colorectal Surgery
Crimson Publishers-Considerations for Elderly People Facing Colorectal SurgeryCrimson Publishers-Considerations for Elderly People Facing Colorectal Surgery
Crimson Publishers-Considerations for Elderly People Facing Colorectal SurgeryCrimsonPublishersGGS
 
Recovered file 1
Recovered file 1Recovered file 1
Recovered file 1tldegros
 
health inequalities water & sanitation
health inequalities water & sanitationhealth inequalities water & sanitation
health inequalities water & sanitationMahimaGirase
 
2018 ACC AHA guideline for the management of adults with congenital heart dis...
2018 ACC AHA guideline for the management of adults with congenital heart dis...2018 ACC AHA guideline for the management of adults with congenital heart dis...
2018 ACC AHA guideline for the management of adults with congenital heart dis...Vinh Pham Nguyen
 
Seizure in Alzheimer Disease
Seizure in Alzheimer Disease Seizure in Alzheimer Disease
Seizure in Alzheimer Disease Ade Wijaya
 
Sarnak2019
Sarnak2019Sarnak2019
Sarnak2019nazmi287
 
Care of Sickle Cell Disease Patients: Process Improvement & Change with Nurses
Care of Sickle Cell Disease Patients: Process Improvement & Change with NursesCare of Sickle Cell Disease Patients: Process Improvement & Change with Nurses
Care of Sickle Cell Disease Patients: Process Improvement & Change with NursesTosin Ola-Weissmann
 
Study on the Health Related Quality of Life of Patients with Ischemic stroke
Study on the Health Related Quality of Life of Patients with Ischemic strokeStudy on the Health Related Quality of Life of Patients with Ischemic stroke
Study on the Health Related Quality of Life of Patients with Ischemic strokeiosrjce
 
2018 guidelines on the management of blood cholesterol
2018 guidelines on the management of blood cholesterol2018 guidelines on the management of blood cholesterol
2018 guidelines on the management of blood cholesterolVinh Pham Nguyen
 
Epidemiology of Pediatric Heart Failure in the US - PCICS 2018
Epidemiology of Pediatric Heart Failure in the US - PCICS 2018Epidemiology of Pediatric Heart Failure in the US - PCICS 2018
Epidemiology of Pediatric Heart Failure in the US - PCICS 2018Texas Children's Hospital
 

What's hot (14)

Vascular repair after firearm injury is associated with increased morbidity a...
Vascular repair after firearm injury is associated with increased morbidity a...Vascular repair after firearm injury is associated with increased morbidity a...
Vascular repair after firearm injury is associated with increased morbidity a...
 
Crimson Publishers-Considerations for Elderly People Facing Colorectal Surgery
Crimson Publishers-Considerations for Elderly People Facing Colorectal SurgeryCrimson Publishers-Considerations for Elderly People Facing Colorectal Surgery
Crimson Publishers-Considerations for Elderly People Facing Colorectal Surgery
 
Recovered file 1
Recovered file 1Recovered file 1
Recovered file 1
 
health inequalities water & sanitation
health inequalities water & sanitationhealth inequalities water & sanitation
health inequalities water & sanitation
 
2018 ACC AHA guideline for the management of adults with congenital heart dis...
2018 ACC AHA guideline for the management of adults with congenital heart dis...2018 ACC AHA guideline for the management of adults with congenital heart dis...
2018 ACC AHA guideline for the management of adults with congenital heart dis...
 
Seizure in Alzheimer Disease
Seizure in Alzheimer Disease Seizure in Alzheimer Disease
Seizure in Alzheimer Disease
 
Nosrati E et al
Nosrati E et alNosrati E et al
Nosrati E et al
 
Sarnak2019
Sarnak2019Sarnak2019
Sarnak2019
 
Care of Sickle Cell Disease Patients: Process Improvement & Change with Nurses
Care of Sickle Cell Disease Patients: Process Improvement & Change with NursesCare of Sickle Cell Disease Patients: Process Improvement & Change with Nurses
Care of Sickle Cell Disease Patients: Process Improvement & Change with Nurses
 
Study on the Health Related Quality of Life of Patients with Ischemic stroke
Study on the Health Related Quality of Life of Patients with Ischemic strokeStudy on the Health Related Quality of Life of Patients with Ischemic stroke
Study on the Health Related Quality of Life of Patients with Ischemic stroke
 
2018 guidelines on the management of blood cholesterol
2018 guidelines on the management of blood cholesterol2018 guidelines on the management of blood cholesterol
2018 guidelines on the management of blood cholesterol
 
Epidemiology of Pediatric Heart Failure in the US - PCICS 2018
Epidemiology of Pediatric Heart Failure in the US - PCICS 2018Epidemiology of Pediatric Heart Failure in the US - PCICS 2018
Epidemiology of Pediatric Heart Failure in the US - PCICS 2018
 
2016 CV Sara M Handy PDF
2016 CV Sara M Handy PDF2016 CV Sara M Handy PDF
2016 CV Sara M Handy PDF
 
2016 CV Sara M Handy Word Doc
2016 CV Sara M Handy Word Doc2016 CV Sara M Handy Word Doc
2016 CV Sara M Handy Word Doc
 

Viewers also liked

Report by the Task Force for the Establishment of a pan-European Retirement S...
Report by the Task Force for the Establishment of a pan-European Retirement S...Report by the Task Force for the Establishment of a pan-European Retirement S...
Report by the Task Force for the Establishment of a pan-European Retirement S...Théodore Economou
 
MPA GLobal Diversity Governance - Digital
MPA GLobal Diversity Governance - DigitalMPA GLobal Diversity Governance - Digital
MPA GLobal Diversity Governance - DigitalTom Fisher
 
Autonomie dans l apprentissage de langue etrangère
Autonomie dans l apprentissage de langue etrangèreAutonomie dans l apprentissage de langue etrangère
Autonomie dans l apprentissage de langue etrangèrehala youness
 
Xpression 2015_FINAL_print 7-01-2015 reduced
Xpression 2015_FINAL_print 7-01-2015 reducedXpression 2015_FINAL_print 7-01-2015 reduced
Xpression 2015_FINAL_print 7-01-2015 reducedAurette Bowes
 
แนะนำแผนการตลาด มิตรแท้
แนะนำแผนการตลาด มิตรแท้แนะนำแผนการตลาด มิตรแท้
แนะนำแผนการตลาด มิตรแท้tao2009
 
A Digital marketing Solution - Skybound Digital
A Digital marketing Solution - Skybound DigitalA Digital marketing Solution - Skybound Digital
A Digital marketing Solution - Skybound Digitalskybound
 
590X15 European Export Controls S
590X15 European Export Controls S590X15 European Export Controls S
590X15 European Export Controls SSTEPHANIE C HART
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Reference.pdf
Reference.pdfReference.pdf
Reference.pdf
 
The split fake
The split fakeThe split fake
The split fake
 
ASP.NET vNext
ASP.NET vNextASP.NET vNext
ASP.NET vNext
 
Report by the Task Force for the Establishment of a pan-European Retirement S...
Report by the Task Force for the Establishment of a pan-European Retirement S...Report by the Task Force for the Establishment of a pan-European Retirement S...
Report by the Task Force for the Establishment of a pan-European Retirement S...
 
MPA GLobal Diversity Governance - Digital
MPA GLobal Diversity Governance - DigitalMPA GLobal Diversity Governance - Digital
MPA GLobal Diversity Governance - Digital
 
Autonomie dans l apprentissage de langue etrangère
Autonomie dans l apprentissage de langue etrangèreAutonomie dans l apprentissage de langue etrangère
Autonomie dans l apprentissage de langue etrangère
 
Tipos de herramientas
Tipos de herramientasTipos de herramientas
Tipos de herramientas
 
MARINE ANIMALS NNTT
MARINE ANIMALS NNTTMARINE ANIMALS NNTT
MARINE ANIMALS NNTT
 
Currículo...tema final
Currículo...tema finalCurrículo...tema final
Currículo...tema final
 
Xpression 2015_FINAL_print 7-01-2015 reduced
Xpression 2015_FINAL_print 7-01-2015 reducedXpression 2015_FINAL_print 7-01-2015 reduced
Xpression 2015_FINAL_print 7-01-2015 reduced
 
แนะนำแผนการตลาด มิตรแท้
แนะนำแผนการตลาด มิตรแท้แนะนำแผนการตลาด มิตรแท้
แนะนำแผนการตลาด มิตรแท้
 
A Digital marketing Solution - Skybound Digital
A Digital marketing Solution - Skybound DigitalA Digital marketing Solution - Skybound Digital
A Digital marketing Solution - Skybound Digital
 
DCI : Sistemas Tecnológicos
DCI : Sistemas Tecnológicos DCI : Sistemas Tecnológicos
DCI : Sistemas Tecnológicos
 
DCI de Investigación e innovación tecnológica
DCI de Investigación e innovación tecnológicaDCI de Investigación e innovación tecnológica
DCI de Investigación e innovación tecnológica
 
590X15 European Export Controls S
590X15 European Export Controls S590X15 European Export Controls S
590X15 European Export Controls S
 
Presentación Plataforma ILIAS
Presentación Plataforma ILIASPresentación Plataforma ILIAS
Presentación Plataforma ILIAS
 

Similar to ChronicPeriodontitisfinal1-CarltonM

Ideal Job Essay. Describe your ideal job essay writing
Ideal Job Essay. Describe your ideal job essay writingIdeal Job Essay. Describe your ideal job essay writing
Ideal Job Essay. Describe your ideal job essay writingJennifer Johnson
 
Essay On Economic Growth. Economic Growth Analysis | Economics - Year 12 HSC ...
Essay On Economic Growth. Economic Growth Analysis | Economics - Year 12 HSC ...Essay On Economic Growth. Economic Growth Analysis | Economics - Year 12 HSC ...
Essay On Economic Growth. Economic Growth Analysis | Economics - Year 12 HSC ...Susan Belcher
 
Definition Of Descriptive Essay.pdfDefinition Of Descriptive Essay. Descripti...
Definition Of Descriptive Essay.pdfDefinition Of Descriptive Essay. Descripti...Definition Of Descriptive Essay.pdfDefinition Of Descriptive Essay. Descripti...
Definition Of Descriptive Essay.pdfDefinition Of Descriptive Essay. Descripti...Toni Craven
 
Extended Essay Example
Extended Essay ExampleExtended Essay Example
Extended Essay ExampleShannon Green
 
Taking A Stand Essay Topics.pdf
Taking A Stand Essay Topics.pdfTaking A Stand Essay Topics.pdf
Taking A Stand Essay Topics.pdfNikki Wheeler
 
Persuasive Essay On Death Penalty. The death Penalty - persuasive essay. - GC...
Persuasive Essay On Death Penalty. The death Penalty - persuasive essay. - GC...Persuasive Essay On Death Penalty. The death Penalty - persuasive essay. - GC...
Persuasive Essay On Death Penalty. The death Penalty - persuasive essay. - GC...Amanda Brown
 
Paraphrasing, Summarizing, and Quoting Information
Paraphrasing, Summarizing, and Quoting InformationParaphrasing, Summarizing, and Quoting Information
Paraphrasing, Summarizing, and Quoting InformationMGC1987
 
Worst Essay Ever Written
Worst Essay Ever WrittenWorst Essay Ever Written
Worst Essay Ever WrittenRosa Williams
 
Classification Essay Thesis Statement.pdf
Classification Essay Thesis Statement.pdfClassification Essay Thesis Statement.pdf
Classification Essay Thesis Statement.pdfKathleen Harvey
 
Research Argument Essay
Research Argument EssayResearch Argument Essay
Research Argument EssayRebecca Harris
 
Essays On Baseball. Baseball essays. . Negro Baseball Leagues - Free Essay Ex...
Essays On Baseball. Baseball essays. . Negro Baseball Leagues - Free Essay Ex...Essays On Baseball. Baseball essays. . Negro Baseball Leagues - Free Essay Ex...
Essays On Baseball. Baseball essays. . Negro Baseball Leagues - Free Essay Ex...Jennifer Castro
 
World War 1 Essay Topics. World War 1 amp; 2 Essay Example Topics and Well W...
World War 1 Essay Topics. World War 1 amp; 2 Essay Example  Topics and Well W...World War 1 Essay Topics. World War 1 amp; 2 Essay Example  Topics and Well W...
World War 1 Essay Topics. World War 1 amp; 2 Essay Example Topics and Well W...Dawn Tucker
 
Essay Structure Writing - Academic Writing - Libra
Essay Structure  Writing - Academic Writing - LibraEssay Structure  Writing - Academic Writing - Libra
Essay Structure Writing - Academic Writing - LibraCaitlin Wilson
 
Smith, olivia antoinette mary mind maps for medical students clinical speci...
Smith, olivia antoinette mary mind maps for medical students   clinical speci...Smith, olivia antoinette mary mind maps for medical students   clinical speci...
Smith, olivia antoinette mary mind maps for medical students clinical speci...sarfaraz ahmed
 
Essays To Buy. 015 Essay Example Buy College Essays Online 1858891829 Thatsn...
Essays To Buy. 015 Essay Example Buy College Essays Online 1858891829  Thatsn...Essays To Buy. 015 Essay Example Buy College Essays Online 1858891829  Thatsn...
Essays To Buy. 015 Essay Example Buy College Essays Online 1858891829 Thatsn...Carolyn Wagner
 
Geriatric Oncology_ Treatment, Assessment and Management ( PDFDrive ).pdf
Geriatric Oncology_ Treatment, Assessment and Management ( PDFDrive ).pdfGeriatric Oncology_ Treatment, Assessment and Management ( PDFDrive ).pdf
Geriatric Oncology_ Treatment, Assessment and Management ( PDFDrive ).pdfbalaji jegannathan
 

Similar to ChronicPeriodontitisfinal1-CarltonM (20)

Ideal Job Essay. Describe your ideal job essay writing
Ideal Job Essay. Describe your ideal job essay writingIdeal Job Essay. Describe your ideal job essay writing
Ideal Job Essay. Describe your ideal job essay writing
 
Research Essays.pdf
Research Essays.pdfResearch Essays.pdf
Research Essays.pdf
 
Essay On Economic Growth. Economic Growth Analysis | Economics - Year 12 HSC ...
Essay On Economic Growth. Economic Growth Analysis | Economics - Year 12 HSC ...Essay On Economic Growth. Economic Growth Analysis | Economics - Year 12 HSC ...
Essay On Economic Growth. Economic Growth Analysis | Economics - Year 12 HSC ...
 
Definition Of Descriptive Essay.pdfDefinition Of Descriptive Essay. Descripti...
Definition Of Descriptive Essay.pdfDefinition Of Descriptive Essay. Descripti...Definition Of Descriptive Essay.pdfDefinition Of Descriptive Essay. Descripti...
Definition Of Descriptive Essay.pdfDefinition Of Descriptive Essay. Descripti...
 
Extended Essay Example
Extended Essay ExampleExtended Essay Example
Extended Essay Example
 
Taking A Stand Essay Topics.pdf
Taking A Stand Essay Topics.pdfTaking A Stand Essay Topics.pdf
Taking A Stand Essay Topics.pdf
 
Persuasive Essay On Death Penalty. The death Penalty - persuasive essay. - GC...
Persuasive Essay On Death Penalty. The death Penalty - persuasive essay. - GC...Persuasive Essay On Death Penalty. The death Penalty - persuasive essay. - GC...
Persuasive Essay On Death Penalty. The death Penalty - persuasive essay. - GC...
 
Inform Essay
Inform EssayInform Essay
Inform Essay
 
Paraphrasing, Summarizing, and Quoting Information
Paraphrasing, Summarizing, and Quoting InformationParaphrasing, Summarizing, and Quoting Information
Paraphrasing, Summarizing, and Quoting Information
 
Worst Essay Ever Written
Worst Essay Ever WrittenWorst Essay Ever Written
Worst Essay Ever Written
 
Classification Essay Thesis Statement.pdf
Classification Essay Thesis Statement.pdfClassification Essay Thesis Statement.pdf
Classification Essay Thesis Statement.pdf
 
Research Argument Essay
Research Argument EssayResearch Argument Essay
Research Argument Essay
 
Essays On Baseball. Baseball essays. . Negro Baseball Leagues - Free Essay Ex...
Essays On Baseball. Baseball essays. . Negro Baseball Leagues - Free Essay Ex...Essays On Baseball. Baseball essays. . Negro Baseball Leagues - Free Essay Ex...
Essays On Baseball. Baseball essays. . Negro Baseball Leagues - Free Essay Ex...
 
World War 1 Essay Topics. World War 1 amp; 2 Essay Example Topics and Well W...
World War 1 Essay Topics. World War 1 amp; 2 Essay Example  Topics and Well W...World War 1 Essay Topics. World War 1 amp; 2 Essay Example  Topics and Well W...
World War 1 Essay Topics. World War 1 amp; 2 Essay Example Topics and Well W...
 
Essay Structure Writing - Academic Writing - Libra
Essay Structure  Writing - Academic Writing - LibraEssay Structure  Writing - Academic Writing - Libra
Essay Structure Writing - Academic Writing - Libra
 
Essay On Economics
Essay On EconomicsEssay On Economics
Essay On Economics
 
Smith, olivia antoinette mary mind maps for medical students clinical speci...
Smith, olivia antoinette mary mind maps for medical students   clinical speci...Smith, olivia antoinette mary mind maps for medical students   clinical speci...
Smith, olivia antoinette mary mind maps for medical students clinical speci...
 
Essays To Buy. 015 Essay Example Buy College Essays Online 1858891829 Thatsn...
Essays To Buy. 015 Essay Example Buy College Essays Online 1858891829  Thatsn...Essays To Buy. 015 Essay Example Buy College Essays Online 1858891829  Thatsn...
Essays To Buy. 015 Essay Example Buy College Essays Online 1858891829 Thatsn...
 
Geriatric Oncology_ Treatment, Assessment and Management ( PDFDrive ).pdf
Geriatric Oncology_ Treatment, Assessment and Management ( PDFDrive ).pdfGeriatric Oncology_ Treatment, Assessment and Management ( PDFDrive ).pdf
Geriatric Oncology_ Treatment, Assessment and Management ( PDFDrive ).pdf
 
Logical Fallacy Research Paper
Logical Fallacy Research PaperLogical Fallacy Research Paper
Logical Fallacy Research Paper
 

ChronicPeriodontitisfinal1-CarltonM

  • 1. Capstone Research Journal Article (This manuscript fulfills the requirements for the North Carolina Agricultural and Technical State University Department of Biology Senior Project BIOL 496) Miquise Carlton North Carolina Agricultural & Technical State University Biology 496 Fall 2015 Drs. White & Lang Signature of Author: Miquise D. Carlton Date: 11-30-2015 CHRONIC PERIODONTITIS A relationship to the Heart
  • 2. 9/18/2015 1 CHRONIC PERIODONTITIS A relationship to the Heart Student Demographic: Greetings! My name is Miquise D. Carlton and I am a Biology student here at North Carolina Agriculture and Technical State University. I was born into a single parent household and raised by my beautiful mother, Mildred N. Johnson, in Hickory, North Carolina. I am one of three on my mother’s side of the family spectrum and one of nine on my father’s side of the family spectrum. We roll deep!!!! While living in an area, in which was highly known for crime, my mother was very determined to introduce myself and along with my brother and sister to a healthier life style. At the beginning of the transformation, my brother, sister and I was extremely heartbroken from the new transformation into a different neighborhood and a better life-style because the change caused for us to loose old friends. However, from my understanding, in order for a change to be extremely beneficial for a family, the family will have to disconnect from other families and/or individuals who they are not equally yoked with and who does not have the aspiration to enhance their way of living. With the painful yet awesome change in effect, I was able to enhance my critical thinking skills, mathematical skills, reading and writing skills, and etcetera. I was able to graduate within the top 15% of my high school, consisting of approximately 250 graduates. This was an extremely great accomplishment, considering some, if not all, African American males from my home town do not necessarily graduate from their local high school but instead become a high school dropout.
  • 3. 9/18/2015 2 After graduation, I had the opportunity to enroll into North Carolina Agriculture and Technical State University, in which I am currently attending as I previously stated before, and from there I decided to major in biology. I decided to become a biology student because I have always dreamed of becoming a doctor, more specifically a dentist. In addition of knowing dentistry was the profession I wanted to pursue as a professional career, I eagerly decided to design a literature research review on the subject matter, chronic periodontitis and its relationship to the heart. Furthermore, I would like to personally thank each professor who contributed to providing me with the necessary tools and information I needed to enhance my education. In addition, I would also like to thank Dr. White for her dedication and inspiration towards me because it allowed me to develop endurance and push myself beyond measure. In addition, I would personally like to thank my friend, Crystal Hill, for being a phone call away to assist with sentence structure and grammatical errors. Lastly, I would personally like to thank my family, for keeping me grounded during my last three years of college. They were always a text message and a phone call away to allow for me to vent about my college life, when I began to become overwhelmed by my studies.
  • 4. 9/18/2015 3 Table of Contents: Description: Page Number: I. Title Page II. Student Demographics-----------------------------------------------------1-2 III. Table of Contents ------------------------------------------------------3 IV. Abstract ----------------------------------------------------------------------4 V. Body of Paper a. Introduction -------------------------------------------------------- b. Understanding Chronic Periodontitis----------------------------5-6 c. Understanding Coronary Heart Disease-------------------------6 d. Literature Review--------------------------------------------------6-13 i. Mechanical Linkage of Periodontitis to Cardiovascular/Coronary Disease------------------------------------------------------6-11 ii. Statistical Linkage of Chronic Periodontitis to Cardiovascular Disease------------------------------------------------------12-13 e. Conclusion/Discussion---------------------------------------------13-15 f. References------------------------------------------------------------16 VI. Appendix A.-------------------------------------------------------------------17-20
  • 5. 9/18/2015 4 Abstract: Chronic Periodontitis…….. A relationship to the Heart Miquise D. Carlton Coronary heart disease is the leading cause of death amongst men and women. As the population of victims of CHD increases, it becomes more imperative that causes of CHD be defined and prevented. The traditional factors of CHD have been outlined by the American Health Association; yet, the AHA’s prescribed factors only accurate describe one-third of those who suffer from CHD. The presence oral periodontitis in atherosclerotic plaque and the chronic periodontitis evident in those who suffer from acute myocardial infarction, provides substantial evidence that periodontitis is linked to CHD. In proving that such a linkage is statistically significant and mechanically plausible, the underlying cause for CHD morbidity will be revealed, for chronic periodontitis can be a more accurate predictor and descriptor of those at risk for heart disease. Whereas, the tradition factors prescribed by AHA are merely symptoms of the symbiosis between chronic periodontitis and CHD. Representative Article: http://www.jisponline.com/article.asp?issn=0972124X;year=2012;volume=16;issue=4;sp age=487;epage=491;aulast=Arigbede#ft12
  • 6. 9/18/2015 5 Introduction: The purpose of this study is to explore chronic periodontitis as it relates to patients that suffer from coronary heart disease. More specifically focusing on the question is there a linkage between chronic periodontitis and coronary heart disease. This study will analyze a verity of different clinical research linking chronic periodontitis to chronic heart diseases. If chronic periodontitis is linked to coronary heart disease-statistically and mechanically, then a significant factor responsible for cardiovascular morbidity will be evinced. Furthermore, chronic periodontitis may prove to be a more accurate predictor and descriptor of those at risk for heart disease, when compared to traditional risk factors prescribed by the American Heart Association. Understanding Chronic Periodontitis Chronic periodontitis, a severe case of inflammation around an individuals’ tooth, begins with a bacterial growth within the oral region of a human. During the process of chronic periodontitis, the gums begins to loosen and creating spaces, better known as pockets, between the tooth and the gum that will however become infected. An individuals’ immune system will begin to attack the invading bacteria as the plaque spreads and develops below the gum line. The bacterial toxins and an individuals’ natural response to invading bacteria will begin to break down the bone and connective tissue associated with holding the tooth in place. Scientist and other physicians across the nation has stated if chronic periodontitis id not treated in a timely fashion, the bones, gums, and the connective tissue will be destroyed and could lead to the removal of many teeth due to the destruction. Periodontitis is primarily caused by plaque, bacteria, but there are serval other factors contributing to
  • 7. 9/18/2015 6 periodontal disease, such as hormonal changes, illnesses, smoking, medications, bad habits, poor oral hygiene habits, and family history of dental disease.(1) Researchers across the world have uncovered potential links between chronic periodontitis and other serious health conditions. It has been stated, in humans with healthy immune systems the bacteria within the oral region could enter the bloodstream and effect other areas within the body. Understanding Coronary Heart Disease: Coronary heart disease (CHD), also known as coronary artery disease, is the leading cause of death amongst men and women in the United States of America. CHD is a narrowing of the small blood vessels that supply oxygen-rich blood to the heart. Researchers have stated and proven that CDH is caused by the buildup of plaque in the arties of the human heart. The buildup of plaque within the arteries will allow them to become narrow and as a result, the blood flow, in which is flowing to the heart, could travel at a much slower rate or could eventually stop (2). Literature Review: Mechanical Linkage of Periodontitis to Cardiovascular/Coronary Disease: Atherosclerotic coronary artery disease, the main underlying disease responsible for cardiovascular and cerebrovascular morbidity-which includes thrombosis and myocardial infarction- is a contributing factor in 50% of United States’ deaths. Yet more than one-third of patients dying from atherosclerotic coronary vascular disease do not possess any of the traditional risk factors such as: obesity, hyperlipidemia, diabetes, hypertension, and
  • 8. 9/18/2015 7 cigarette smoking (3,4). It has been long since known that there are associations of atherosclerotic risk with infectious agents and several pathogens. This association is a rational one, for the process of development of atherosclerosis involves chronic inflammation (3). To make the involvement of pathogens more concrete, it is also understood that chlamydia phneumonia, herpes simplex virus, streptococcus sanguis, and porphyromonas gingivalis have been detected in human atheromas (4). Though porphyromonas gingivalis is mentioned, it is necessary to further define the role of the oral cavity/teeth in the pathogenesis of atherosclerotic vascular disease. It has become increasingly clear that the oral cavity possesses the ability to function as the site of origin for dissemination of pathogenic organisms to distant body sites, especially in immunocompromised hosts-including patients suffering from diabetes (a traditional factor of CHD). This is possible, due to the fact that the teeth are the only non-shedding surfaces in the body, and bacteria levels can reach more than 1011 microorganisms per milligram of dental plague (4). Human periodontal infections are associated with complex microfloras in which approximately 200 species in apical periodontitis and more than 500 species in marginal periodontitis have been encountered (4). These pathogenic infections are predominantly anaerobic and gram-negative (4). The mere anatomic proximity of these complex microfloras to the blood stream can easily facilitate bacteria and the systematic spread of bacterial products, components, and immunocomplexes (4). Porphyromonas gingivalis (Pg) is the most common form of adult periodontitis and is estimated to affect 116 million Americans (5). The consequences of Pg are local inflammations characterized by gingival ulceration and vascular changes, both of which increase the incidence and severity of transient oral bacterias (5). Also, various studies have
  • 9. 9/18/2015 8 concluded that Pg can not only adhere but also invade and proliferate in artotic and heart endothelial cells and coronary artery smooth muscle cells (5,3). In action this translates to a host having efficient endocytic (endocytosis: form of active transport in which a cell transports molecules into the cell by engulfing them, includes pinocytosis and phagocytosis) uptake and Pg persisting within endothelial cells and altering the cells’ integrity (5). Consequently, the transience of such an infection into the systemic circulation of frequent bacteria would cause chronic inflammatory damage to vasculature and further the initiation and progression of atherosclerosis and/or atherosclerosis lesions (5). Furthermore, Li Li and colleagues hypothesized and demonstrated: in vivo long-term systemic circulatory challenge with Pg can promote and accelerate the development of atherosclerotic lesions (5). To test such a hypothesis, apoliprotein E-deficient (apoliprotein E is the official name of the APOE gene/its protein product apo E; it is essential for the prevention of disorders that affect the heart and blood vessels, i.e-cardiovascular diseases) heterozygous mice were challenged with Pg (5). In the study, Pg A7436 was grown on anaerobic blood plates in and anaerobic chamber with an environment composed of: 85% nitrogen, 5% hydrogen, and 10% carbon dioxide for 3 to 5 days, and then the grown Pg was inoculated with Shaedler Broth for twenty-four hours until the culture reached an optical density of 0.8 at 660nm, equivalent to 109 CFU/mL (5). As specified by Neogen Corporation, the manufacturer and distributor of Schaedler Broth, the utilized broth is specified for the cultivation of anaerobic microorganisms. Neogen Corporation also mentions that “Shaedler Broth in an atmosphere of 5% carbon dioxide, 10% hydrogen, and 85% nitrogen exhibited the fastest and highest growth response” (6). Though the 1%: 2% ratio of hydrogen: carbon in the study is the
  • 10. 9/18/2015 9 reciprocal of that specified by the manufacturer, given the period of time to grow Pg A7436 it is safe to assume that in the experiment the pathogen also exhibited an equally fast and high growth rate. Male Apo E homozygotes (ApoE -/- ) and the corresponding female wild-type hybrids were obtained at eight weeks of age. Both groups were fed regular mouse food. To generate apoliprotein E-deficient heterozygous (ApoE +/- ), ApoE -/- mice were crossed with the female wild type mice (5, Figure 1). At four weeks of age, the Male ApoE heterozygous mice and wild-type mice were randomly assigned to either a high-fat diet (HFD)- the experimental diet- or the regular mouse food - the control diet (5, Figure 1). At ten weeks of age, ApoE +/- or wild-type mice, HFD-fed or regular food-fed, were divided at random into two groups: inoculated with live Pg (107 CFU/50 µL/mouse) or diluted medium (50 µL/mouse) (5). The inoculation was performed intravenously once per week for 10, 14, or 24 consecutive weeks (5, Figure 1). For tissue harvesting, the mice underwent an overnight fast then, were sedated with isoflurane, and exsanguinated as approved by The Institutional Animal Care and Use Committee of Boston University (5). The aortic tree and proximal aorta were separated close to the heat; after which, the aortic tree- including the arch and thoracic and abdominal aorta- was processed for en face morphometric analysis. This type of analysis refers to the quantitative analysis of form, which encompasses size and shape, the impact of mutations on shape, developmental changes in form, etc. The extent of atherosclerosis in the aortic tree was determined by en face quantification. In which, the total aortic surface area and the atherosclerosis lesion area were measured with
  • 11. 9/18/2015 10 a stereomiscroscope with computer-assisted image analysis capabilities possessed by the Image Pro Plus 40 (5). However in the regular mice food fed group, the sensitivity of this procedure did not allow for the detection of any lesion at any time point. The percentage of aortic surface area covered by lesions at all time points was greater in the Pg-challenged mice, than in vehicle control animals, P<0.05 (5, Figure 2A). In the HFD-fed mice groups, red-stained, lipid-rich lesions were first evident ten weeks after the onset of inoculation with Pg. Furthermore, at 14- and 24-week time points, red-stained lesions were observed in both Pg-inoculated and non-inoculated mice but to a greater extend in Pg-challenged mice (5, Figure 2B). For histomorphometric and histopathological analysis, the proximal aortic cross-sections for quantitative and histopthalogical evaluation of atherosclerotic lesions were performed. In which, the percentage of total aortic lumen occupied by lesions per section were calculated. Also, the total lesion area and the percentage of total aortic lumen occupied by lesions were averaged over four sections per animal to develop both the mean lesion area and percentage of total lumen of the proximal aorta occupied by lesions per section within each animal (5). In the groups of mice who were fed regular mouse food, lesions were not evident after 10 weeks of inoculation. In Pg-challenged mice, foam cell lesions were evident after 14 weeks of inoculation (P<0.01) (5, Figure 3A). After 24 weeks of inoculation, the average lesion area of the Pg was 9 times greater than in the vehicle controlled mice; instead, the average lesion area was similar in level to HFD-fed mice injected with vehicle (5). Also in regards to the HFD groups, the mean lesion area was greater in Pg- challenged mice than in the unchallenged control mice, as well as attaining a significance level 2 times greater (P<0.001) after 24 weeks of inoculation, with the same
  • 12. 9/18/2015 11 persistent pattern for percentage of total lumen of the proximal aorta occupied by lesions per section within each animal (5, Figure 3B). Furthermore, two stages were observed to characterize the progression of lesions: stage 1 lesions were characterized by sudanophilic (stained by Sudan IV dye, lipid-rich) lesions; stage 2 lesions were composed of a mixture of sudanophic cells, spindle-shaped cells, acellular zones, and inflammation (5, Figure 4E, 5C, 5D, 5E, 5F). In relation to location, lesions primarily occurred in the aortic valve attachments and the free aortic wall, in which stained cells adhered to the surface of the endothelial lining. Within 10 weeks, staining of macrophages was evident in HFD mice injected with saline or Pg and thusly, intensified with the development of lesions until the conclusion of the 24-week period. However, staining was more pronounced in Pg- injected mice than in saline-injected mice. Mice that were fed regular mouse food exhibited Mac-3 staining [M3/84 monoclonal antibody reacts with mouse Mac-3. The Mac-3 antigen is upregulated during macrophage differentiation. Peritoneal and tissue macrophages, dendritic cells, and endothelial cells express this antigen on their surface (7).] only in Pg-injected mice, beginning at the 14-week period (5). In wild-type mice that were fed regular mouse food atherosclerotic lesions were not observed from the 10 to 24-week period, after Pg- inoculation; while in HFD-fed wild-type mice, early stages of foam cell lesions were observed at 24 weeks after Pg-inoculation- which is similar to the lesions observed in ApoE heterozygous, regular food fed mice at 14 weeks after Pg-inoculation (5, Figure 5). Statistical Linkage of Chronic Periodontitis to Cardiovascular Disease:
  • 13. 9/18/2015 12 In mid-2009, Willershausen et. al. sought to investigate whether a statistically significant association between periodontal disease and coronary heart disease could be established. This association was indeed proven in the discovery that dental chronic inflammatory diseases correlate with the occurrence of acute myocardial infarction (AMI); thusly, periodontal diseases can be viewed as possible risk factors for CHD (8). To establish such a correlation, basic statistics-standard deviation, p-value, and the implications of the normal curve- were combined with standard scientific procedures, i.e.- control group and an experimental group. The experimental patient group consisted of one hundred twenty-five of 568 AMI patients (all of which had been previously verified for having AMI by hospitalization at the Department of Cardiology and Angiology of the University of Mainz). The remaining 443 patients were excluded from the study on basis of having previous dental examinations (including those whose most recent dental history was already known would inhibit a random statistical study), lack of teeth, and death (8). The experimental group possessed a mean age of 61.8 years, with a standard deviation of 10.7 years, and a distribution of 85% male and 15% female (8). The control group was comprised of 125 of 352 healthy patients, who were selected along the same criteria of being alive, possessed 5 or more teeth, and had not a recent dental examination. Also, no statistical difference regarding age and gender was found between the AMI (experimental group) and healthy control group, for the healthy group had a mean age of 63.4 years, with a standard deviation of 10.7 years, and a distribution of 82% male and 18% female (8). Once the groups were characterized by age and gender, the differences of the two groups were then characterized via physical and clinical oral findings. These differences are listed
  • 14. 9/18/2015 13 as age, body mass index (BMI), diabetes, number of missing teeth, number of treated teeth, apical lesions, number of crowns, and the increasing severity of periodontitis (PSI). In comparison to the control patients, the AMI patients had an unfavorable dental status- a statistically higher number of missing teeth and a higher frequency of dental infection (8). Furthermore, a significant relationship between increasing severity of periodontitis and AMI could be observed, for a PSI degree of 4 was found in 42.3% of AMI patients, while only 17.1% of the control patients (8, Figure 6). A high number of apical lesions was found in 19.5% of the AMI patients, whereas only 2.3% of the healthy population had less than the AMI patients; hence, apical lesions do not correlate to CHD (8, Figure 7). Conclusion/Discussions: The systematic intravascular challenge with Pg inoculation was shown to accelerate the progression of atherosclerosis in an ApoE +/- murine model. However, this acceleration required genetic susceptibility and/or a dietary risk factor and/or an infectious agent. The importance of genetic susceptibility was evident in the failure to produce atherosclerotic lesions in regular food, wild type mice after 24 weeks of Pg- inoculation (5). The importance of dietary risk factors is emphasized by the earlier, more extensive, and more advanced progression of atherosclerotic lesions in ApoE +/- mice that were fed HFD, when compared to ApoE +/- mice fed regular mouse food (5). The influence of the infectious agent is illustrated by the fact that wild-type mice fed HFD had early foam cell lesions after 24 weeks of Pg-inoculation, compared to those observed in regular food fed ApoE +/- mice at 14 weeks of inoculation (5). Also in the context of a genetic
  • 15. 9/18/2015 14 predisposition such as ApoE +/- or an environmental risk factor, i.e.- HFD, Pg infection importantly accelerates the progression of atherosclerosis: aortic atherosclerotic lesions in Pg-inoculated ApoE +/- mice developed earlier and were larger and more advanced than in non-inoculated mice with the same genetics and diet (5). In context of short/long term exposure to the Pg, long-term Pg inoculation contributed to more significantly than in short-term acceleration of atherosclerosis: at 14 week Pg inoculation, there were mild effects in mice that were fed regular mice food, whereas at 24 weeks of Pg inoculation the lesions in regular food fed ApoE +/- mice were similar to those of the HFD-fed vehicle control group (5). Thusly showing, the mild effects of Pg could accumulate, resulting in a remarkable acceleration of atherosclerosis. The murine model employed establishes periodontal pathogens contribute to the development and progression of atherosclerosis. Ergo mechanically speaking, periodontitis is a factor in CHD. Though PSI and lack of teeth correlate dental disease to myocardial infarcation, This association is more concretely illustrated, using blood glucose levels, C-reactive protein (CRP) serum levels, and leukocyte numbers. These same factors point to patients with AMI exhibiting an unfavorable dental state of health (8,9). Thusly, these variables are evidence that patients with acute myocardial infarction also suffer from chronic dental infection (9) . Hence one can conclude periodontal disease can be utilized as an established factor for CHD, as individuals with periodontal disease have an approximately 24% -35% increase in risk of developing CHD” (8). The factors of CHD given by the American Heart Association: age, gender, BMI, diabetes, and ethnicity were directly/in-directly included in each presented study. Willershausen et. al. includes them directly, and Li et. al. includes them in an indirectly wholistic approach,
  • 16. 9/18/2015 15 for each of the AHA factors can be applied in the categories of genetic susceptibility and/or dietary risk factor. The inclusion of these factors suggests that the classic AHA factors of CHD are linked and emphasized, if not merely symptoms, of chronic periodontal pathogens as they relate to CHD. From this symbiosis of factors, it is understood periodontitis may be a more accurate descriptor of those at risk for heart disease than classic AHA factors.
  • 17. 9/18/2015 16 Work Cited: 1. "Periodontal (Gum) Disease: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatments." Periodontal (Gum) Disease: Causes, Symptoms, and Treatments. Web. 9 Oct. 2015. 2. "Dentists: Doctors of Oral Health." Dentists: Doctors of Oral Health. Web. 9 Oct. 2015. 3. Fong, Ignatius W. "Infections and their role in atherosclerotic vascular disease." The Journal of the American Dental Association 133 (2002): 7S-13S. 4. Li, Xiaojing, et. al. “Systemis Diseases Caused by Oral Infection. Clinical Microbiology Reviews.13.4 (2000): 547- 558. Web. 28 Oct. 2015. 5. Li, Li et. al. “ Poryphyromonas Gingivalis Infection Accelerates the Progression of Atherosclerosis in a Hetereozygous Apoliprotein E-Deficient Murine Model.” American Heart Association Journal 2002; 105:861-867. Web. 28 Oct. 2015. 6. "Schaedler Broth (7154)." Schaedler Broth Product Information Page 06 (2010): n. pag. Neogen.Com. Web. 28 Oct. 2015 7. "Anti-Mouse CD107b (Mac-3) Purified." Mouse CD107b (Mac-3) Antibody Purified M3/84 RUO. Ebioscience, 2010. Web. 17 Nov. 2015. 8. Willershausen, Brita, et al. "Association between chronic dental infection and acute myocardial infarction." Journal of endodontics 35.5 (2009): 626-630. 9. Demmer, Ryan T., and Moïse Desvarieux. "Periodontal Infections and Cardiovascular Disease." The Journal of the American Dental Association. Print. 10. Cobb, Charles M. "Clinical significance of non‐surgical periodontal therapy: an evidence‐based perspective of scaling and root planing." Journal of Clinical Periodontology 29.s2 (2002): 22-32. 11. Arigbede, Abiodun O., B. Osagbemiro Babatope, and M. Kolude Bamidele. “Periodontitis and Systemic Diseases: A Literature Review.” Journal of Indian Society of Periodontology 16.4 (2012): 487–491. PMC. Web. 9 Oct. 2015. 12. Chiu, Brian. "Multiple infections in carotid atherosclerotic plaques." American heart journal 138.5 (1999): S534-S536. 13. Dietrich, Thomas et al. “Age-Dependent Associations between Chronic Periodontitis/edentulism and Risk of Coronary Heart Disease: Dietrich, Periodontitis and CHD.” Circulation 117.13 (2008): 1668–1674. PMC. Web. 9 Oct. 2015. 14. Persson, G. Rutger, et al. "Chronic periodontitis, a significant relationship with acute myocardial infarction." European heart journal 24.23 (2003): 2108-2115. 15. "Coronary Heart Disease: MedlinePlus Medical Encyclopedia." U.S National Library of Medicine. U.S. National Library of Medicine. Web. 9 Oct. 2015. Appendix A:
  • 18. 9/18/2015 17 Figure 1: Time schedule of the experiment (12). Figure 2: (A) Percentage of aortic surface area covered by lesions. (B) Representative results of en face analysis in HFD group showing absence of lessions at 10 weeks of vehicle injection (1) and severity of lesions after 14 weeks (II) and after 24 weeks (III) of Pg inoculations (12).
  • 19. 9/18/2015 18 Figure 3: (A) Mean lesion area per section per animal. (B) A percentage of total lumen of proximal aortas occupied by lesions (12). Figure 4: Cross-sections of aortic lesions in chow-fed ApoE+/ mice challenged with Pg or vehicle. Normal configuration of proximal aorta from a chow-fed wild-type mice at 20 weeks of age (A). After 14 weeks of inoculation, no lesion is found in control mice (B), whereas foam cell lesion (first stage) is present adjacent to valve- attachment in Pg-inoculated mice (C). After 24-week inoculation, lesions in control mice remain at foam cell lesion stage (D), whereas most of lesions in Pg-inoculated mice progress to the second stage (E). *Foam cell. L indicates aortic lumen; I, intima; M, media; and A, adventitia (12).
  • 20. 9/18/2015 19 Figure 5: Cross-sections of aortic lesions in HFD-fed ApoE/mice challenged with Pg or vehicle. First-stage lesions (foam cells) adjacent to valve attachments (A and B) and in free aortic wall (B) are found in 10-week postinoculation mice; secondstage lesions are observed in 14- and 24-week postinoculation mice (C through F). Lesions in Pg-inoculated ApoE+/- mice are larger and more advanced than in noninoculated mice at same time point. *Foam cell. L indicates aortic lumen; M, media; and A, adventitia (12). Table 1: Basic Group Characteristics (SD or in Percentages) and P values for Differences between patients with AMI and the Healthy Control Patients (1).
  • 21. 9/18/2015 20 Figure 6: PSI (degree: 0 - 4) distribution in patients after AMI and healthy controls (1). Figure 7: Frequency of apical lesions in patients after AMI and healthy control patients (1).