The document challenges the traditional Paid, Owned, Earned (POE) model of digital marketing. It argues that the POE model has become Paid, Paid, Paid (PPP) as content distribution is now dominated by a few large platforms like Google and Facebook, requiring marketers to pay to reach audiences. It also notes that people's attention spans are shrinking and they are less likely to organically share content. The document proposes a new POE framework that focuses on paying for emotional content, earning word-of-mouth from talkable content, and owning rational explanations. It provides brand examples to illustrate this approach.

1. Challenging
digital’s Paid,
Owned and
Earned model
Presented at Content 360 Conference,
Singapore
April, 2015
http://www.marketing-interactive.com/content360/sg/

2. Digital Marketing, a bedfellow of technology, has been through its own Hype Cycle: huge expectations from
Clicks, Social, Apps … followed by plummeting towards the reality that tech toys need to work harder to
deliver business objectives. And then, a gentle ascent towards digital efficiency through repeatable models.
Gartner Hype Cycle: http://www.gartner.com/technology/research/methodologies/hype-cycle.jsp

3. Paid
Owned
The most popular model of Paid Owned and Earned says – Pay for some content, get huge amounts of free
Earned content, and drive traffic to your Owned assets. This is a framework was relevant a year ago, but
even today, is being offered up like a magic pill to marketers.

4. That model of POE in 2015, is as much a reality as a Hoverboard is in 2015.
The movie ‘Back To The Future’ promised fantastic Hoverboards as a way of life – in 2015 – but the real
ones we have today are pretty grounded, literally! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=HSheVhmcYLA

5. Paid
Earned
& Paid
Owned &
Paid
90
9
1
I believe the POE model is actually Paid, Paid & Paid (PPP) model. You pay to reach content to the 90, if the
content is good enough (this is often serendipity), 9 will create earned media, and 1 will find their way to
your owned assets. And at every step of the way, there is a component of Paid that filters through.

6. PUBLISHING
PEOPLE
Allow me to explain: this image is at once exciting to us marketers, & frightening to the human in us. It
reveals both the attractiveness of digital content, and the behavioural changes it causes. In the recent 8-12
months, seismic shifts have taken place in the world of content Publishing, and to People as consumers of
content. Understanding these changes will explain why we now have to do business with a PPP model.

7. The magnitude of content online is escaping quantification. We’re creating new words – Petabytes, Exabytes & eventually
Zettabytes – to define the data-size of text, videos, the billions of selfies & memes published online. In the open web, this
content is splayed across the internet – each website with its own domain, to be browsed at one’s own pace. The open
web is wide and allows for whattevabytes of content to exist comfortably – much like spread out American suburbia.
PUBLISHING

8. But in the past 2 years, ‘The Four Horsemen’* have gained incredible control over the open web. Just think about it:
Google defines how you find answers to questions, Facebook defines what you discover socially, the size of your
iPhone screen defines how you view your content and Amazon, in the developed world, defines what you buy.
These four admirable behemoths have constricted the sprawling open web into a narrow pipe through which massive
amounts of content must flow. In real-estate terms, American suburbia has become high-density Hong Kong.
*Credit Scott Galloway https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XCvwCcEP74Q

9. Exabytes of content, with the potential to reach billions of people – but – within limited inventory! This is the classic story of high-
demand & low-supply reconciling themselves into a seller’s market. Sellers who need to patiently explain to us marketers why we
need to pay for the magic pill that was once free.
Making us wish that the rent, was heaven sent…(just stretching that real estate analogy!).

10. The influence of the Digital 1%, will continue to dominate the Digital 99%, being as they are, the most
efficient conduits to our consumers. We can see this happening already as News publishers begin to
redefine their ecosystems and their very business model. If they’re so deeply integrated into Facebook,
would BBC need it’s own .com? Should you buy ad space in bbc.com if no one’s going there?

11. Meanwhile, in an effort to be discovered by people, advertising has gone more native than ever, embedding itself
as Branded Content within the ‘news’. Native Advertising or Branded Content have worked very well in the most
part – but there are indications we may need to work towards more authentic models of content discovery.
Last Week Tonight with John Oliver https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=E_F5GxCwizc

12. And absolutely none of this branded content is Earned or Owned or free… it will take a respectable chunk
of the overall Paid digital media budget.
And so it is, that Paid content behind Google and Facebook, Paid content behind native advertising (which
in turn is discovered on Google & Facebook), transform POE into PPP!

13. Meanwhile, what’s happening to People? They’re hungry for content, alright! So hungry that they would
sign away their first-born* for free Wi-Fi to access content.
*social experiment with fake Wi-Fi T&Cs that no one reads! https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=plT5989P1v4
PEOPLE

14. Mirroring the narrow inventory available online, peoples’ attention spans are narrowing too. There’s just
too much content and too little mind space. We’ve all heard about it: we are the Twitter generation with
patience for no more than 140 characters.

15. People do engage actively with brands online, enough to create that magic pill of free, earned content. More often than not, it is a trivial
meme or a clever spoof of the brand that gets the most laughs, or traction. A few weeks ago, heavy floods in Bangkok affected Tops
supermarket (pic far left). That picture was transformed into amusing memes by consumers, and went viral on Line Messenger. It takes a
bold brand to turn this free, no-control content into an advantage as Tops did, by offering discount coupons to it’s Line Messenger group!
http://bangkok.coconuts.co/2015/03/25/internet-overflows-flood-memes

16. When it comes to sharing brand
content organically, Unruly
metrics show we must expect it to
be below 10%. Even Super Bowl
quality content is shared at
approx. 5% (i.e. 5 shares from
every 100 views)
https://unruly.co/insight/#whitepapers

17. When people do share content, the Earned media effect typically has a short shelf life. People are hungry for content – if they like it,
they talk about it, but very quickly move on to the next interesting story. Warhol’s comment on fame is true for digital content too!
https://unruly.co/insight/#whitepapers

18. Growth in market share comes by increasing
popularity… by gaining many more buyers (of all
types), most of whom are light consumers buying
the brand only occasionally.
Eventually, the people who grow our brands are the 90 we reach with paid media and good content, so
we convert them into more 9s and 1s.

19. Paid
Earned
& Paid
Owned
& Paid
90
9
1
In a largely Paid, Paid & Paid world, how should we plan for Content? How do we decide what kind of
content sits under which silo?

20. Begin with people at the center
We have to begin with the people brands serve.
People who have feelings, who like to talk and who want to know more.

21. PAY for the heart
EARN talkability
(pay for some of it)
OWN rational stories
(pay for all of it)
I propose a POE content framework that begins at the heart. Pay heavily for content that appeals to the seat of human
emotion, Earn talkability when people begin to talk about the things you made them feel, and Own the rational
stories & explanations that people will come looking for, when they want to know more about you.

22. This is a simple model that follows typical human behavior. When exposed to compelling video content, the
first thing viewers did was to talk to someone about it. The second thing they did was to seek more
information. So follow the trail of the emotional heart, the talkative mouth and finally, the rational brain.
https://unruly.co/insight/#whitepapers

23. $$$
Pay for the Heart: Content – blockbuster, epic type storytelling that appeals to emotions | Asset type – Video | Paid
Media – heavy investment | Timing – ideally 1-3 campaigns per year
CONTENT ASSET INVESTMENT TIMING

24. $$$
$
Earn Talkability & Pay for some PR: Content – consumer generated conversations, memes, that get shared | Asset
type – Hashtag to anchor all conversations | Paid Media – small, to promote positive conversations| Timing –
campaign #tag & always on #tag
CONTENT ASSET INVESTMENT TIMING

25. $$$
$$
$
Own rational stories & Pay for Search: Content – search strategy, search ad units | Asset type – destination page e.g.
website or YT channel| Paid Media – moderate towards Search | Timing – always on
CONTENT ASSET INVESTMENT TIMING

26. #epicsplit
Volvo Trucks example:
Van Damme video appeals to the heart (or funny
bone, if you may).
People love it, talk about it, few create inspired
content anchored around #epicsplit.
End game? Get those in the market for a Volvo, to
learn more about the engineering behind every
Volvo truck – by watching very rational & technical
videos on the dual-clutch technology.
https://www.youtube.com/user/VolvoTrucks?hl=en-GB&gl=SG

27. #ayoindonesiabisa
Clear Indonesia example:
Pay for the soccer- passion of Indonesian men.
Earn their talkability through conversations around
encouraging Indonesian soccer players anchored
on the #tag.
End game? Get young Indonesian men to consider
Clear men’s range of shampoos by Owning brand
salience & rational stories of the shampoo.
http://www.clear.co.id/

28. Knorr example:
Pay for the emotional story of the Flavour of Home.
Earn talkability when women have conversations
about how they love their mum’s cooking.
End game? Inspire women to cook delicious Knorr-
based recipes http://www.knorr.com.ph/
#lutongnanay

29. And just as the dust settles on that, Digital Marketing has entered the next phase of the hype cycle, what
with wearables and messaging driving massive expectations on what they can do for brands.

30. But we’re approaching these new technologies with maturity now. We know it’s a mostly PPP world and
programmatic buying platforms are already preparing the battlefield for inventory on a 2-inch screen.

31. 10M Private Messages
Line Pay
And Messaging looks promising, given the paths WeChat and Line have carved out, and
Facebook’s act of unbundling FB Messenger. Sir Paul McCartney recently sampled his latest track
on multiple platforms, only to get the largest reach on Line Messenger!

32. In summary: a lot has changed since Apple’s 1984 Macintosh ad, but much has remained just the same.
Stunning creative and efficient paid media, still create maximum impact. 1984 was an ‘insanely great’ piece
of content, backed with clever paid media at the Super Bowl (and contrary to myth, further airings). This is
also one of those rare, serendipitous examples of the magic pill of free earned media. For here we are,
some 30 years later, still talking about it.

33. Thank you for your time! I hope you’ve found this point of
point of view as interesting as I found it enjoyable to present.
It is an incredibly exciting time for digital marketing, and we’re
at the brink of the next explosion in innovation. Here’s to the
exchange of more ideas and opinions on how digital is
changing the world!
Triveni Rajagopal.