Best Management Practices For
Reducing Nutrients from Landscaping
          Buzzards Bay Coalition
         Decision Makers Workshop
               March 20, 2013

           Cormac Collier
         Executive Director
     Nantucket Land Council, Inc
Objectives

Nutrient overloading issues on Nantucket

Community Education

Process for creating BOH regulations

Overview of Best Management Practices
Nantucket Land Council, Inc.
Established in 1974, the Nantucket Land Council is the only
environmental watchdog group on Nantucket. The NLC works to
protect Nantucket’s natural resources in three major areas –planning,
protecting, preserving


Planning - The NLC monitors development
proposals, offers educational programs, grants
and scholarships and makes recommendation
to voters on issues which affect the environment

Protecting - The NLC conducts scientific
research to support the protection of our natural
resources such as native species, wildlife habitat,
and water quality

Preserving - The NLC specializes in holding
conservation restrictions.
Plant Communities of Nantucket

  •   Sandplain grasslands
  •   Heathlands
  •   Coastal Shrublands/ scrub oak
  •   Red Maple/tupelo forests

Nantucket Soils

  • Dominated by sands and fine gravels with low
  organic matter content.
  • Soils readily allow water to infiltrate and are prone
     to nutrient leaching.
  • Pockets of clay in the north with impermeable
  layers of clay several feet underground.
Sources of Nutrient Pollution

Atmospheric Deposition
- Direct Rainfall
- Stormwater runfoff

Septic

Fertilizer
Water Quality
Documented increase in nutrients in Nantucket’s
coastal embayments and freshwater bodies

Massachusetts Estuary Report

Remediation efforts have targeted septic
systems, expansion of sewer, stormwater
infrastructure and most recently fertilizer.
45% of the island is protected by
various conservation organizations
How does a community
reduce inappropriate
fertilizer use?

 Education

 Regulation
Indicator Species




Community Symbol
No Eelgrass = No Scallops
Watershed Approach

               1990 Water
               Resources
               Management Plan by
               HWW, delineated all
               the island watersheds

               Regulations and
               education directed at
               watershed land use.
               Similar to Wellhead
               Recharge District
               management
Recent efforts to reduce nutrient
     leaching from fertilizers

Citizen’s Article at 2010 Town Meeting proposed to
   regulate fertilizer use island wide

      - Reintroduced the issue back into the community
      through a direct legislative attempt at control

      - Language of article was flawed

       - Proponents did not gather community wide
  consensus. Lack of input from broad range of
  individuals and practitioners

      - Regulations needed to be science based.
Formation of “Article 68” Workgroup

 Charge:

     Develop a comprehensive plan to reduce the amount
      of nitrogen and phosphorus in our harbors.

  
      Develop an implementation plan, budget, and
      timeframe.
Committee Members
Non-profits
Conservation Commission
Landscape professionals
Golf course managers
Fishermen
Concerned Citizens
Politicians
Committee Recommendations
New Board of Health Regulations & Home Rule
Petition
   Type, quantity, timing
   Island wide

Creation of a Best Management Practices
Manual

Educational initiatives & training for homeowners
and landscape professionals
TOWN OF NANTUCKET BOARD OF HEALTH REGULATIONS
   THE CONTENT AND APPLICATION OF FERTILIZER
         FOR USE ON NANTUCKET REG 75.00

Core standards

    No fertilizer application between Oct.16 – April 14
   No Phosphorus unless a soil test indicates a
    deficiency
   No more than a total of 3lbs of nitrogen per 1000 sq ft
    per year.
   No more than .25lbs of quick release nitrogen per
    1000 sq feet per application and no more than .5lbs
    total per application
   Applications two weeks apart. Inspect and monitor
Standards for Commercial
             Applicators
All Commercial Applicators must receive a
license from Board of Health and follow
the Best Management Practices Manual.

Enforcement ???

    Non-Criminal Disposition
      $300 per day for each day of violation
Objectives of BMP

To provide landscape professionals and homeowners with
information for making environmentally sound landscaping decisions
that take Nantucket’s unique conditions and natural resources into
consideration

To promote the protection of water resources while maintaining
healthy and vibrant ornamental landscapes

To reduce the amount of fertilizer use by promoting cultural
practices that help reduce nutrient inputs

To offer site planning guidelines and suggestions for ecological
restoration that help reduce island-wide fertilizer dependent
landscapes

To provide science based guidance for nutrient management of
lawns and gardens on Nantucket
BMP


    Site Assessment

      Identifying Site Conditions

      Site planning for new construction

      Site planning for existing landscapes

      Choosing a management plan
Soil Nutrients & Soil Test

        Why test your soil?

        Tips for obtaining a good
  sample

        Sample soil test
Fertilizer Types and Sources


    Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Potassium NPK
   Nitrogen
     - Slow Release
            Water insoluble
            Coated slow release
     - Water soluble
The Role of Compost

• Provides organic matter
• Food source for beneficial
          bacteria and fungi
• Improves moisture
retention
• Improves nutrient retention
• Is considered a fertilizer for
          the purposes of the
          BMP

    Typical percentages of N and P in compost from various sources

    Compost Type                               %N        %P
    Leaf litter                                0.1       0.05–0.2
    Horse manure                               0.5–1.5   0.5–1.5
    Lawn, garden, and food waste               1.0–1.5   1.0–1.5
    Dairy manure                               1.0–1.5   1.0–1.5
    Feedlot manure                             1.0–1.5   1.0–1.5
    Poultry manure                             1.5–2.0   1.5–2.5
Fertilizer Application
Spoon feeding concept

No fertilizer application between Oct.16 – April 14

No Phosphorus unless a soil test indicates a deficiency

No more than .5lbs of quick release nitrogen per 1000 sq feet per
application and no more than 1lbs total per application. .5lbs total per
application is preferred.
        Business model change

No more than a total of 3lbs of nitrogen per 1000 sq ft per year.

Applications are two weeks apart.

Issues to consider
        Recycling of grass clippings
        Continued compost applications
        Foliar feeding
        Spreader calibration
        Record Keeping
Sample management plans
Guidelines for establishment and renovation of turfgrass
Nutrient Management of gardens, trees and shrubs
Role of irrigation
Native Plants
Turf Care Cultural Practices
   Mowing frequency & height

    Recycling clippings

    Core aeration

    Dethatching

    Top-dressing
Implementation
Education & Outreach
  Landscape Professionals
  Homeowners
  Retail

Licensing

Government Follow Through
Questions?

Best Management Practices for Reducing Nutrients From Landscaping

  • 1.
    Best Management PracticesFor Reducing Nutrients from Landscaping Buzzards Bay Coalition Decision Makers Workshop March 20, 2013 Cormac Collier Executive Director Nantucket Land Council, Inc
  • 2.
    Objectives Nutrient overloading issueson Nantucket Community Education Process for creating BOH regulations Overview of Best Management Practices
  • 3.
    Nantucket Land Council,Inc. Established in 1974, the Nantucket Land Council is the only environmental watchdog group on Nantucket. The NLC works to protect Nantucket’s natural resources in three major areas –planning, protecting, preserving Planning - The NLC monitors development proposals, offers educational programs, grants and scholarships and makes recommendation to voters on issues which affect the environment Protecting - The NLC conducts scientific research to support the protection of our natural resources such as native species, wildlife habitat, and water quality Preserving - The NLC specializes in holding conservation restrictions.
  • 5.
    Plant Communities ofNantucket • Sandplain grasslands • Heathlands • Coastal Shrublands/ scrub oak • Red Maple/tupelo forests Nantucket Soils • Dominated by sands and fine gravels with low organic matter content. • Soils readily allow water to infiltrate and are prone to nutrient leaching. • Pockets of clay in the north with impermeable layers of clay several feet underground.
  • 6.
    Sources of NutrientPollution Atmospheric Deposition - Direct Rainfall - Stormwater runfoff Septic Fertilizer
  • 7.
    Water Quality Documented increasein nutrients in Nantucket’s coastal embayments and freshwater bodies Massachusetts Estuary Report Remediation efforts have targeted septic systems, expansion of sewer, stormwater infrastructure and most recently fertilizer.
  • 13.
    45% of theisland is protected by various conservation organizations
  • 14.
    How does acommunity reduce inappropriate fertilizer use? Education Regulation
  • 15.
  • 16.
    No Eelgrass =No Scallops
  • 17.
    Watershed Approach 1990 Water Resources Management Plan by HWW, delineated all the island watersheds Regulations and education directed at watershed land use. Similar to Wellhead Recharge District management
  • 22.
    Recent efforts toreduce nutrient leaching from fertilizers Citizen’s Article at 2010 Town Meeting proposed to regulate fertilizer use island wide - Reintroduced the issue back into the community through a direct legislative attempt at control - Language of article was flawed - Proponents did not gather community wide consensus. Lack of input from broad range of individuals and practitioners - Regulations needed to be science based.
  • 23.
    Formation of “Article68” Workgroup Charge:  Develop a comprehensive plan to reduce the amount of nitrogen and phosphorus in our harbors.  Develop an implementation plan, budget, and timeframe.
  • 24.
    Committee Members Non-profits Conservation Commission Landscapeprofessionals Golf course managers Fishermen Concerned Citizens Politicians
  • 25.
    Committee Recommendations New Boardof Health Regulations & Home Rule Petition  Type, quantity, timing  Island wide Creation of a Best Management Practices Manual Educational initiatives & training for homeowners and landscape professionals
  • 26.
    TOWN OF NANTUCKETBOARD OF HEALTH REGULATIONS THE CONTENT AND APPLICATION OF FERTILIZER FOR USE ON NANTUCKET REG 75.00 Core standards  No fertilizer application between Oct.16 – April 14  No Phosphorus unless a soil test indicates a deficiency  No more than a total of 3lbs of nitrogen per 1000 sq ft per year.  No more than .25lbs of quick release nitrogen per 1000 sq feet per application and no more than .5lbs total per application  Applications two weeks apart. Inspect and monitor
  • 27.
    Standards for Commercial Applicators All Commercial Applicators must receive a license from Board of Health and follow the Best Management Practices Manual. Enforcement ???  Non-Criminal Disposition $300 per day for each day of violation
  • 29.
    Objectives of BMP Toprovide landscape professionals and homeowners with information for making environmentally sound landscaping decisions that take Nantucket’s unique conditions and natural resources into consideration To promote the protection of water resources while maintaining healthy and vibrant ornamental landscapes To reduce the amount of fertilizer use by promoting cultural practices that help reduce nutrient inputs To offer site planning guidelines and suggestions for ecological restoration that help reduce island-wide fertilizer dependent landscapes To provide science based guidance for nutrient management of lawns and gardens on Nantucket
  • 30.
    BMP  Site Assessment Identifying Site Conditions Site planning for new construction Site planning for existing landscapes Choosing a management plan
  • 31.
    Soil Nutrients &Soil Test Why test your soil? Tips for obtaining a good sample Sample soil test
  • 33.
    Fertilizer Types andSources  Nitrogen, Phosphorus, Potassium NPK  Nitrogen - Slow Release Water insoluble Coated slow release - Water soluble
  • 34.
    The Role ofCompost • Provides organic matter • Food source for beneficial bacteria and fungi • Improves moisture retention • Improves nutrient retention • Is considered a fertilizer for the purposes of the BMP Typical percentages of N and P in compost from various sources Compost Type %N %P Leaf litter 0.1 0.05–0.2 Horse manure 0.5–1.5 0.5–1.5 Lawn, garden, and food waste 1.0–1.5 1.0–1.5 Dairy manure 1.0–1.5 1.0–1.5 Feedlot manure 1.0–1.5 1.0–1.5 Poultry manure 1.5–2.0 1.5–2.5
  • 35.
    Fertilizer Application Spoon feedingconcept No fertilizer application between Oct.16 – April 14 No Phosphorus unless a soil test indicates a deficiency No more than .5lbs of quick release nitrogen per 1000 sq feet per application and no more than 1lbs total per application. .5lbs total per application is preferred. Business model change No more than a total of 3lbs of nitrogen per 1000 sq ft per year. Applications are two weeks apart. Issues to consider Recycling of grass clippings Continued compost applications Foliar feeding Spreader calibration Record Keeping
  • 36.
    Sample management plans Guidelinesfor establishment and renovation of turfgrass Nutrient Management of gardens, trees and shrubs Role of irrigation Native Plants Turf Care Cultural Practices  Mowing frequency & height  Recycling clippings  Core aeration  Dethatching  Top-dressing
  • 37.
    Implementation Education & Outreach Landscape Professionals Homeowners Retail Licensing Government Follow Through
  • 38.