The OCR resolution process has a tendency to induce panic in educators nationwide. This presentation will give you the perspective you need to not only get through a resolution, but to build a scalable process for your unique needs.
Building a Plan to Help Educators Through the OCR Resolution Process
1. Building a Plan to Help Educators Through
the OCR Resolution Process
1
2. An OCR complaint has a tendency to
cause panic in educators nationwide.
The “New” American Horror Story
2
3. What is OCR?
OCR is the
US Department of Education’s
Office of Civil Rights
OCR’s mission is to ensure equal access to education and to
promote educational excellence through vigorous enforcement
of civil rights in our nation's schools.
3
4. A Brief History
The Office for Civil Rights (OCR) enforces federal civil rights
laws that prohibit discrimination in programs or activities that
receive federal financial assistance from the Department of
Education.
Discrimination against persons with disabilities is prohibited by
Section 504 and Title II of the ADA. Title II affects public entities
whether or not they receive federal funding.
4
5. Who is affected by these complaints?
We see complaints across all industries, but education has
been one of the hardest hit areas for accessibility.
•K-12 Districts
•Charter Schools
•Private Schools
•State Education Departments
•Education Cooperatives
•Community Colleges
•Colleges and Universities
5
6. • This is not a lawsuit
• Section 504 and Title II of the ADA
• How do I know if OCR is investigating me?
• What kinds of pages are affected?
• Communicating with OCR
• Whose fault is this?
Breaking Down an OCR Complaint
6
7. • Timely
• Rely on your legal counsel
• List of items for response
• List of pages (4-12 is typical)
• Current policies and procedures related to your website
• Vendors used, and if they provided VPAT documents or other assurances
• Contact info of person responsible for Web accessibility
• Documents regarding efforts to make the site accessible
• Any monitoring or reports used to evaluate website accessibility
• Any complaints received
• Any other documents you feel OCR needs for consideration in this complaint
Responding to OCR
7
8. Resolution Agreement
Remedies and Reporting
• Policies and Procedures for New Online Content and
Functionality (Plan for New Content)
• Undue Burden
• Designate Auditor
• Audit of Content and Functionality
• Proposed Corrective Action Plan
• Policy/Accessibility Notice
• Training
• Provide accessibility training to appropriate staff quarterly or annually
8
10. 3. Audit of Existing Content
Auditor with bona fides (qualifications) i.e. the person who will
review the internal audit and assist the school with the testing
and resolution process.
Internal Auditor?
External Auditor?
Resolution Agreement
10
16. • Sitewide
• Automated Testing
• Manual Testing
• Sampling of pages for manual testing
• Template pages
• Popular pages
• Pages in complaint
• Functional elements
• User paths/journeys
Auditing/Testing Begins
16
17. • Site templates
• Representational content pages
• Dynamic content pages
• Dialog modals and alerts
• Key entry and exit pages
(including account login and recovery pages)
• Help and assistance pages
• Interactive forms
Automated
17
18. • Page zoom
• Form elements and form validation
• Visible focus
• Multimedia and media control
• Dynamic elements
• Modals and dialog boxes
• Modal receives focus
• No keyboard trap
• Close modal
Manual
18
20. • Combine automated, manual, and AT test results into a
comprehensive report for OCR
Audit Results
20
21. Corrective Action Plan
• Staff Responsibilities
• Funding
• Communication
• Training
• Vendor Relationships
• Ongoing Plans
21
22. • Fix or start over?
• Addressing old site issues
• Resources
• Vendors
• Documents
• Multimedia
• Third Party Pages/Plug ins
Remediation
22
23. • OCR requirement
• Accessibility awareness
• Basic Web skills
• Documents
• Assistive tech
• User task-based testing
• PwD testers
Training
23
24. Next Steps
So your received a complaint from the OCR. Now what?
• Work with your legal counsel and draft a response to OCR
1.Submit an auditor and a Plan for New Content
• Audit approved
2.Audit/testing begins
3.Auditor creates audit report
4.Auditor assists with Corrective Action Plan
5.Submit report and CAP
• Remediation begins
• Training
• Ongoing monitoring
• Sign-off by OCR
24
25. We are changing a culture
• Buy-in
• Awareness education
• Organizational policies
• Budgetary considerations
25
26. • Identify (realistic) goals
• Timelines
(marathon not a sprint)
• Action plans
• Define milestones
• Budgetary considerations
• Identify existing resources
• Address legal/regulatory issues
Start your accessibility program
26
27. • How do we portray the level of importance?
• Security compliance training?
• Sexual harassment training?
• Awareness
• Technical training
• Role-based training
•Faculty
•Staff
•Documents
Staff Training
27
28. • Ownership of digital properties
• Role-based team members
• Inventory
•Web pages
•Documents
•Multimedia
Identify Existing Resources
28
29. • Management
• Human Resources
• Marketing
• IT Office
• Compliance/Legal
• Purchasing
• Other Community Stakeholders
• External Agencies
Buy-in from Stakeholders
29
30. Community Stakeholders
• Department Lead
• Faculty/Staff
• Blended classroom environments
• Use of multimedia
• Documents
• Disability Services Office
• Students with disabilities that go unreported
• Development/IT Teams
30
31. Concrete Policy and Plan
• Communications/Transparency
• Visible Policy and Contact Info
• Implementation plan
• Remediation plan
31
34. • Resources, training, and technologies can affect
your approach to an OCR resolution
• Creating a scalable process
• Accessibility is a cultural issue
• Takeaways:
• Firmer understanding of how to approach an OCR resolution
• Tools needed to build a plan to achieve ongoing accessibility
compliance
Remember
34
35. Digital Accessibility is a Process Not a Project
The Project Management Institute defines a project as
a “temporary endeavor undertaken to create a project,
service, or result.”
A process can be defined as a series of actions or
steps taken in order to achieve a particular end.
35
36. Staff Responsibilities
• Who is directly involved with our website and what
are their responsibilities?
• Developers
• Content creators
• Decision makers
• Who is ultimately responsible for making sure
compliance is achieved?
• How do we track progress?
36
37. Funding
Is this initiative being funded at an institutional level or
is a specific department responsible?
37
38. Communication
How do we communicate to employees that this is an
organization-wide issue and everyone plays a part?
How do we communicate this externally?
A website policy?
An accessibility section on the website?
38
39. Vendor Relationships
Do our third-party vendors support accessible content
creation?
Are their products themselves accessible if our
employees require accessible technology?
Do we write accessibility
(requirements/expectations/etc.?) into our contracts,
RFPs, etc.?
39
40. • Complaint
• Resolution Agreement
• Remediation
• Training
Be Sure the Process for is Scalable
40
41. …and finally
• Accessibility has to be on your radar.
• There is no silver bullet when it comes to accessibility.
• Understanding accessibility and accessibility issues has to
be an ongoing conversation.
• Accessibility is an issue that touches everyone in an
organization.
41
This presentation will give you the perspective you need to not only get through a resolution, but to build a scalable process for your unique needs.
This presentation will give you the perspective you need to not only get through a resolution, but to build a scalable process for your unique needs.
This presentation will give you the perspective you need to not only get through a resolution, but to build a scalable process for your unique needs.
This presentation will give you the perspective you need to not only get through a resolution, but to build a scalable process for your unique needs.
i) Policies and Procedures for New Online Content and Functionality (Plan for New Content)
(1) Submit for approval
(2) Adopt and implement after receiving approval
ii) Undue Burden
iii) Designate Auditor
(1) Submit for Bona Fides for Approval
(2) Proof that Auditor is retained after receiving Approval
iv) Audit of Content and Functionality
(1) Submit Audit
v) Proposed Corrective Action Plan
(1) Submit Corrective Action Plan
(2 )Adopt and implement CAP after receiving approval
vi) Policy/Accessibility Notice
(1) Submit for Approval
(2) Post approved notice/policy
vii) Training
viii) Provide accessibility training to appropriate staff quarterly or annually
Staff Responsibilities
Who is directly involved with our website and what are their responsibilities?
Developers
Content creators
Decision makers
Who is ultimately responsible for making sure compliance is achieved?
How do we track progress?
Keeping accessibility within the testing phase traps it as a project problem. The Project Management Institute defines a project as a “temporary endeavor undertaken to create a project, service, or result.” Since projects are unique by their definition, it stands to reason that the same flaws and risks are bound to be repeated because testing for accessibility is the only place flaws and risks are going to be identified. When it remains at the project level, nothing changes to prevent it from becoming a problem in the first place.
In my opinion, the question Designers and Developers should be asking is, “What’s the best method to employ so my users will react to it the way I expect them to?” To be able to arrive at that answer, accessibility needs to be taken out of the context of making it work for a specific implementation and more about doing things according to the theories of development best practices.
Developers and Designers should begin to understand that accessibility is not a project problem, but a process problem. A process can be defined as a series of actions or steps taken in order to achieve a particular end. When considered as a process, the conversation becomes addressing the behavior that’s employed to perform an activity.