MAXIMIZE ROI BY
                                UNLOCKING THE FULL VALUE
                                OF UNDISCOVERED CONTENT



             Dean Davison, Principal Consultant, Forrester Consulting
                    Joelle Kaufman, Head of Marketing, BloomReach
Erik Small, Senior Manager, Online Advertising & eCommerce, Meijer
Maximize ROI by Unlocking the
 Full Value of Undiscovered
           Content
A big number
The web outpaces stores
20.0%




15.0%




10.0%



                                                                                  Total retail
 5.0%
                                                                                  E-commerce

 0.0%
           Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4
          2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011 2011 2012 2012 2012 2012

 -5.0%




-10.0%

         Source: U.S. Department of Commerce
Customer acquisition through search


               Interactive marketing spend
                     Mobile                   Social
                      2%                       5%

                                         E-mail
                                          4%


                      Search   Display
                       59%      30%




 Source: Forrester Research
But most clicks go to few sites
 Natural search: five sites captured 20% of clicks on
  natural search links in the fourth quarter of 2012
  (Amazon was the top retailer, fifth overall, at 1.4%).
 Natural search: top 500 sites capture nearly 50% of
  all clicks.




Source: Experian Marketing Services
Most paid search clicks, too
 Paid search: top 10 web sites attracted 16% of clicks
  on paid search ads (Amazon was No. 1 at 4.2%).
 Paid search: top 500 captured 56%.




 Source: Experian Marketing Services
Paid search is expensive

                   Monthly paid search spend
                     (in millions of dollars)
$5.00

$4.00

$3.00

$2.00     $3.91
                                                     2.76
$1.00                  $1.70
                                   0.86     0.78
$0.00
         Amazon       Target     Wal-Mart   Sears   Lowe's

Source: ROI Revolution,
Internet Retailer Search Marketing Guide
Maximize ROI by Unlocking the Full
 Value of Undiscovered Content
WHAT ARE YOU DOING NOW ISN’T WORKING


 Social hasn’t converted

 Mobile isn’t a “channel”

 Email is great… but you already knew them




                            You need something else
NEW CUSTOMERS ARE HARD TO FIND
     your data won’t get you customers you don’t already have.


  You understand what your
  customers are doing…
                                        but what about everyone else?
USE THE GREAT CONTENT YOU ALREADY HAVE
THE NEW WAY, BIG DATA MARKETING APPS, WORKS

                                             use the collective
                                           intelligence of your
 Billions                                 site and the web to:
   pages
  per day

                                    capture 60% new customers
  Billions
 interactions         over 25% more natural search traffic
   per day

                2x more conversion than paid search
Thousands
 of hadoop
  jobs/day
BLOOMREACH’S BIG DATA APPLICATIONS
         driving business results with two big data applications



   founded in 2008 by
  Google, Yahoo!, and
             Facebook                         the world’s first big data
 engineers, backed by                         marketing application for natural
          Bain Capital                        search customer
 Ventures, Lightspeed                         acquisition
    Ventures, and NEA




                              increasing advertising ROI using big data to
                              deliver relevance in paid search
BLOOMREACH & MEIJER
ABOUT MEIJER

• Privately-held, 75 years old

• 200+ stores across 6 states

• #298 in Internet Retailer Top 500

• Thousands of products across
 dozens of categories

• Online channel via Meijer.com optimized
 through direct, paid, affiliate, organic, email
MEIJER’S CHALLENGE

          Thousands of products are added
                 every week to Meijer.com
          expanding product categories and
                            sub-categories



                                   The new product pages are
                                indexed and crawled by search
                                 engines, generating site traffic




                               ?
                                                        User experience is limited to
                                                                       internal search
                                                        filtering, navigation, and our
                                                      interpretation of search intent
IMPROVED EXPERIENCE WITH BLOOMREACH

                                        BloomSearch
     New                                  big data
                                                                           large scale web
   Meijer                                marketing
                                                                            crawl – billions
  product                                application
                                                                              of pages per
    pages
                                                                                         day
                                    machine learning and
                                 natural language processing


                                     demand prediction



            “Scratch Resistant                              “Red Home
            Framed Bedroom                                 Accent Décor”
                Furniture”
INCREASE NON-BRANDED SEARCH

                      Thousands of thematic pages have been created and Meijer.com
                      has seen 92%+ increase in non-branded organic search traffic

                                                              BloomReach thematic page




“Rustic Wood Table”
MEIJER’S NON-BRANDED VISITS MAKE A JUMP

              Since the beginning of the partnerships, non-branded visits
                         are up 60%+ year-over-year (Dec ‘11 to Dec ‘12)
BLOOMREACH INFLUENCED REVENUE




          revenue
    influenced by
 BloomReach has
     increased an
 average of 70%+
     month-over-
  month since the
partnership began
THE ECONOMIC IMPACT
WHAT IS A TEI?

WHAT: The Total Economic ImpactTM is a standard methodology
developed by Forrester Research Inc., enhancing a company’s
technology decision-making process

WHY: To provide prospects and clients with a framework for
evaluating the potential financial impact of BloomSearch

HOW: Based on interviews with four BloomReach
customers, Forrester constructed a TEI framework, a composite
company, and modeled the associated ROI analysis that
illustrates the economic impact. The composite organizations fall
into two categories: established and emerging.
THE COMPOSITE ORGANIZATION – ESTABLISHED


• Sells $3.5 B annually from a portfolio of 25,000 products (US only).

• Derives 25% of sales from online in year 1; increases to 45% in the third year.

• Converts 6% of direct marketing and 3% of traffic from paid search and SEO.

• Runs remarketing campaigns that have a 5% conversion rate.

• Views search as important and has a full-time individual assigned to manage search.
THE COMPOSITE ORGANIZATION – EMERGING


• Sells $250 million annually from a portfolio of 3,000 products (US only).


• Derives 40% of traffic from paid search, 40% from SEO, and 20% from affiliate sites.


• Converts 3% of its traffic into sales and adds customers to a central customer list.


• Views natural search an interesting experiment as a potential new channel.
WHAT IS THE FORRESTER TOTAL ECONOMIC IMPACT
OF BLOOMSEARCH?
Forrester worked with BloomReach to analyze the total economic impact that
BloomSearch has on a number of its customers, who shared these business
challenges and objectives…

                                                    Natural search is a vast
                                                    unknown opportunity
     We need to        We’re a large brand
                         and looking for     We’re an emerging
      grow TOP
                       alternatives to SEO   brand and want to
    line revenue
                         and paid search       grow in a cost-
                                                effective way
COMPOSITE ANALYSIS

     Through interviews and data aggregation, Forrester concluded the following
                              financial impact BloomSearch had on customers…


       Established Brands                       Emerging Brands

                    ROI                                    ROI
                   196%                                   638%

                  Payback                                Payback
                  2.5 days                             1.2 months

           3-year revenue impact                  3-year revenue impact
                   $464M                                  $75M
WHAT MATTERS MOST TO CUSTOMERS?

                   Established Brands                                Emerging Brands
                         Benefits                                         Benefits
TEI broke down           34%                  31%                                          26%
                    “multichannel      “conversion rate                           “capturing misses from
the specific          marketing            similar to               50%              other channels”
                     efficiency”                           “brand building at a
benefits, costs,                         remarketing”
                                                             fraction of cost”
and metrics                   35%                                                              24%
that mattered        “capturing misses from                                             “conversion rates
                                                                                        better than SEM”
                        other channels”
to customers…
                             Costs                                           Costs
                          99%                                             93%
                         pay for                                  pay for performance
                    performance fee                                        fee
                                                   1%                                              7%
                                                 startup                                         startup
BLOOMSEARCH BY THE NUMBERS


        $3.24:1   Return on ad spend. Based on
                  gross profit for established brands.




                  Return on ad spend. Based on
        $5.85:1   gross profit for emerging brands.




                  BloomSearch traffic from
         60%      noncustomers.
BLOOMSEARCH BY THE NUMBERS


                Of time it takes annually to analyze and optimize
         10%    BloomSearch once it is integrated.




                Of total costs to build an emerging brand by product
         4%     discounting. BloomSearch is 4% of traditional brand
                building costs.




                Conversion rate improvement. BloomSearch
         100%   conversionrate is 2x the paid search conversion rate.
A NEW WAY
YOU CANNOT WIN THE OLD/CURRENT WAY

1,000 head terms              < 25% of pages                 90% search traffic          > 40% of
                                getting natural                     is branded         products change
                                    search                                               each month


                         web and onsite analytics (to the tune of 5 TB everyday)
                        natural language processing (12B phrases and growing)
                        continuous machine learning (1000 Hadoop Jobs per day)
                                           Web Relevance Engine

                                                  Relevant, rich
           Dynamic
                                                     content                       New, targeted
          link graph
                                                     (related                      category pages
                                                    content)


identify and optimize                                          60/40 split
 > 1 M long-tail               75% of pages                        incremental         60% net new
                                  get found                                               customers
     variations                                                    non-branded
DRIVE INCREMENTAL TRAFFIC AND REVENUE


                                                                                       thematic pages
                                                                                        aggregate desired products reducing click
                          related content                                               to discovery and relevance
    add relevant content to drive traffic to
   undiscovered pages while flattening site
                                                                                                          new category (thematic) page

                                                                                          filtering             relevant products
          existing category or product page                                               SHOP FOR CHIC
                                                                                          BLACK DRESSES

                                                                                          COLOR
                                                                                           Red
                                                                                           Blue
                                                                                           Striped

                                                                                          TYPE
                                                                                           Lace
                                                                                           A line
                                                                                           Open back
           related searches     related products

           street chic dress
           red shift dress
           dakota black dress
                                 open back short   sleeveless with   black polka dot
           black sheer dress     sleeve dress      cinched bodice    belted dress
                                 with lace         and sheer         with sleeves
                                 > more            > more            > more
WHAT DOES THIS MEAN FOR THE CONSUMER?
    better experiences, more discovery
WHAT CAN THIS MEAN FOR YOU?
           more revenue
natural search uplift
       125%


        100
                                                                                    90%

         75
                                                                                   equal or
         50
                                                                                   higher
                                                                                   conversion
                                                                                   rates
         25


          0
              1    2    3   4   5   6   7    8    9    10    11   12    13    14

                                            months since bloomsearch launch
THANK YOU.



 Dean Davison, ddavison@forrester.com
Joelle Kaufman, joelle@bloomreach.com
      Erik Small, erik.small@meijer.com

Maximize ROI by Unlocking the Full Value of Undiscovered Content

  • 1.
    MAXIMIZE ROI BY UNLOCKING THE FULL VALUE OF UNDISCOVERED CONTENT Dean Davison, Principal Consultant, Forrester Consulting Joelle Kaufman, Head of Marketing, BloomReach Erik Small, Senior Manager, Online Advertising & eCommerce, Meijer
  • 2.
    Maximize ROI byUnlocking the Full Value of Undiscovered Content
  • 3.
  • 4.
    The web outpacesstores 20.0% 15.0% 10.0% Total retail 5.0% E-commerce 0.0% Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 Q1 Q2 Q3 Q4 2009 2009 2010 2010 2010 2010 2011 2011 2011 2011 2012 2012 2012 2012 -5.0% -10.0% Source: U.S. Department of Commerce
  • 5.
    Customer acquisition throughsearch Interactive marketing spend Mobile Social 2% 5% E-mail 4% Search Display 59% 30% Source: Forrester Research
  • 6.
    But most clicksgo to few sites  Natural search: five sites captured 20% of clicks on natural search links in the fourth quarter of 2012 (Amazon was the top retailer, fifth overall, at 1.4%).  Natural search: top 500 sites capture nearly 50% of all clicks. Source: Experian Marketing Services
  • 7.
    Most paid searchclicks, too  Paid search: top 10 web sites attracted 16% of clicks on paid search ads (Amazon was No. 1 at 4.2%).  Paid search: top 500 captured 56%. Source: Experian Marketing Services
  • 8.
    Paid search isexpensive Monthly paid search spend (in millions of dollars) $5.00 $4.00 $3.00 $2.00 $3.91 2.76 $1.00 $1.70 0.86 0.78 $0.00 Amazon Target Wal-Mart Sears Lowe's Source: ROI Revolution, Internet Retailer Search Marketing Guide
  • 9.
    Maximize ROI byUnlocking the Full Value of Undiscovered Content
  • 10.
    WHAT ARE YOUDOING NOW ISN’T WORKING Social hasn’t converted Mobile isn’t a “channel” Email is great… but you already knew them You need something else
  • 11.
    NEW CUSTOMERS AREHARD TO FIND your data won’t get you customers you don’t already have. You understand what your customers are doing… but what about everyone else?
  • 12.
    USE THE GREATCONTENT YOU ALREADY HAVE
  • 13.
    THE NEW WAY,BIG DATA MARKETING APPS, WORKS use the collective intelligence of your Billions site and the web to: pages per day capture 60% new customers Billions interactions over 25% more natural search traffic per day 2x more conversion than paid search Thousands of hadoop jobs/day
  • 14.
    BLOOMREACH’S BIG DATAAPPLICATIONS driving business results with two big data applications founded in 2008 by Google, Yahoo!, and Facebook the world’s first big data engineers, backed by marketing application for natural Bain Capital search customer Ventures, Lightspeed acquisition Ventures, and NEA increasing advertising ROI using big data to deliver relevance in paid search
  • 15.
  • 16.
    ABOUT MEIJER • Privately-held,75 years old • 200+ stores across 6 states • #298 in Internet Retailer Top 500 • Thousands of products across dozens of categories • Online channel via Meijer.com optimized through direct, paid, affiliate, organic, email
  • 17.
    MEIJER’S CHALLENGE Thousands of products are added every week to Meijer.com expanding product categories and sub-categories The new product pages are indexed and crawled by search engines, generating site traffic ? User experience is limited to internal search filtering, navigation, and our interpretation of search intent
  • 18.
    IMPROVED EXPERIENCE WITHBLOOMREACH BloomSearch New big data large scale web Meijer marketing crawl – billions product application of pages per pages day machine learning and natural language processing demand prediction “Scratch Resistant “Red Home Framed Bedroom Accent Décor” Furniture”
  • 19.
    INCREASE NON-BRANDED SEARCH Thousands of thematic pages have been created and Meijer.com has seen 92%+ increase in non-branded organic search traffic BloomReach thematic page “Rustic Wood Table”
  • 20.
    MEIJER’S NON-BRANDED VISITSMAKE A JUMP Since the beginning of the partnerships, non-branded visits are up 60%+ year-over-year (Dec ‘11 to Dec ‘12)
  • 21.
    BLOOMREACH INFLUENCED REVENUE revenue influenced by BloomReach has increased an average of 70%+ month-over- month since the partnership began
  • 22.
  • 23.
    WHAT IS ATEI? WHAT: The Total Economic ImpactTM is a standard methodology developed by Forrester Research Inc., enhancing a company’s technology decision-making process WHY: To provide prospects and clients with a framework for evaluating the potential financial impact of BloomSearch HOW: Based on interviews with four BloomReach customers, Forrester constructed a TEI framework, a composite company, and modeled the associated ROI analysis that illustrates the economic impact. The composite organizations fall into two categories: established and emerging.
  • 24.
    THE COMPOSITE ORGANIZATION– ESTABLISHED • Sells $3.5 B annually from a portfolio of 25,000 products (US only). • Derives 25% of sales from online in year 1; increases to 45% in the third year. • Converts 6% of direct marketing and 3% of traffic from paid search and SEO. • Runs remarketing campaigns that have a 5% conversion rate. • Views search as important and has a full-time individual assigned to manage search.
  • 25.
    THE COMPOSITE ORGANIZATION– EMERGING • Sells $250 million annually from a portfolio of 3,000 products (US only). • Derives 40% of traffic from paid search, 40% from SEO, and 20% from affiliate sites. • Converts 3% of its traffic into sales and adds customers to a central customer list. • Views natural search an interesting experiment as a potential new channel.
  • 26.
    WHAT IS THEFORRESTER TOTAL ECONOMIC IMPACT OF BLOOMSEARCH? Forrester worked with BloomReach to analyze the total economic impact that BloomSearch has on a number of its customers, who shared these business challenges and objectives… Natural search is a vast unknown opportunity We need to We’re a large brand and looking for We’re an emerging grow TOP alternatives to SEO brand and want to line revenue and paid search grow in a cost- effective way
  • 27.
    COMPOSITE ANALYSIS Through interviews and data aggregation, Forrester concluded the following financial impact BloomSearch had on customers… Established Brands Emerging Brands ROI ROI 196% 638% Payback Payback 2.5 days 1.2 months 3-year revenue impact 3-year revenue impact $464M $75M
  • 28.
    WHAT MATTERS MOSTTO CUSTOMERS? Established Brands Emerging Brands Benefits Benefits TEI broke down 34% 31% 26% “multichannel “conversion rate “capturing misses from the specific marketing similar to 50% other channels” efficiency” “brand building at a benefits, costs, remarketing” fraction of cost” and metrics 35% 24% that mattered “capturing misses from “conversion rates better than SEM” other channels” to customers… Costs Costs 99% 93% pay for pay for performance performance fee fee 1% 7% startup startup
  • 29.
    BLOOMSEARCH BY THENUMBERS $3.24:1 Return on ad spend. Based on gross profit for established brands. Return on ad spend. Based on $5.85:1 gross profit for emerging brands. BloomSearch traffic from 60% noncustomers.
  • 30.
    BLOOMSEARCH BY THENUMBERS Of time it takes annually to analyze and optimize 10% BloomSearch once it is integrated. Of total costs to build an emerging brand by product 4% discounting. BloomSearch is 4% of traditional brand building costs. Conversion rate improvement. BloomSearch 100% conversionrate is 2x the paid search conversion rate.
  • 31.
  • 32.
    YOU CANNOT WINTHE OLD/CURRENT WAY 1,000 head terms < 25% of pages 90% search traffic > 40% of getting natural is branded products change search each month web and onsite analytics (to the tune of 5 TB everyday) natural language processing (12B phrases and growing) continuous machine learning (1000 Hadoop Jobs per day) Web Relevance Engine Relevant, rich Dynamic content New, targeted link graph (related category pages content) identify and optimize 60/40 split > 1 M long-tail 75% of pages incremental 60% net new get found customers variations non-branded
  • 33.
    DRIVE INCREMENTAL TRAFFICAND REVENUE thematic pages aggregate desired products reducing click related content to discovery and relevance add relevant content to drive traffic to undiscovered pages while flattening site new category (thematic) page filtering relevant products existing category or product page SHOP FOR CHIC BLACK DRESSES COLOR Red Blue Striped TYPE Lace A line Open back related searches related products street chic dress red shift dress dakota black dress open back short sleeveless with black polka dot black sheer dress sleeve dress cinched bodice belted dress with lace and sheer with sleeves > more > more > more
  • 34.
    WHAT DOES THISMEAN FOR THE CONSUMER? better experiences, more discovery
  • 35.
    WHAT CAN THISMEAN FOR YOU? more revenue natural search uplift 125% 100 90% 75 equal or 50 higher conversion rates 25 0 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 months since bloomsearch launch
  • 36.
    THANK YOU. DeanDavison, ddavison@forrester.com Joelle Kaufman, joelle@bloomreach.com Erik Small, erik.small@meijer.com

Editor's Notes

  • #3 Welcome. My name is Don Davis. I’m the editor in chief of Internet Retailer magazine and I’ll be moderating today’s discussion.We’ll be talking about how retailers can acquire new online customers in a cost effective way through natural search—and how you can make a convincing case that this can be done to your top management.We’ll be hearing from: INSERT DETAILS HEREAfter their presentations we’ll take questions. You can ask questions at any time using the box provided. And you will all get an e-mail after today’s discussion explaining how you can get a copy of the presentation.So let’s begin, and what better place to begin than by sizing the opportunity in selling online today.
  • #4 That’s the size of the online retail market worldwide in 2012, according to market research firm eMarketer. The global market is growing at better than 15% a year and will reach nearly $2 trillion by 2016, eMarketer says.Even in the U.S., the most mature of e-commerce markets, growth has been running consistently over 15% since the recession ended a few years ago.
  • #5 This chart shows the growth in online retail sales in the U.S., the dark blue bar, versus total retail, the light blue. As we all know, the web is steadily taking sales from stores.I thought it was interesting that a couple of weeks ago Macy’s reported that its same-store sales grew 3.9% in the fourth quarter, but 85% of that growth was online. They count Macy’s.com and Bloomingdales.com in their same-store sales, and that’s where the growth is coming from.Overall,the web grew 15.8% in the fourth quarter of 2012, versus 4.0% for all of retail.For the full year, e-commerce growth was also 15.8%, while total retail grew 4.8%.So there’s big opportunity online, but you have to attract new customers to grow. And search marketing is the main way retailers do that.
  • #6 This chart shows the breakdown of spending on online marketing channels by companies of all kinds, according to Forrester Research. Search takes well over half that spend, and retailers especially rely on search marketing for new customer acquisition.
  • #7 But it’s not so easy, especially if you’re not a well-known brand. In the fourth quarter of last year, 20% of all clicks on natural search links went to just five sites—Amazon was the leading retailer, and fifth overall among all sites. 500 sites captured nearly half the clicks.
  • #8 It wasn’t much different in terms of paid search clicks. Again, the big players dominate.
  • #9 The difference is that to be a big player in paid search you have to be willing to spend a lot. This chart shows the monthly spending in millions of dollars by the five retailers that ranked highest in paid search traffic in a study by ROI Revolution.Amazon can afford to spend nearly $4 million dollars a month on paid search ads, but not many other retailers can. That’s what makes it so valuable for a retailer if it can show up high in natural search results on Google and Bing, and get those free clicks. How to do that better is what we’re going to be talking about today.
  • #10 Our speakers will be: Joelle Kaufman, Head of Marketing for Bloomreach, a Big Data marketing platform-- Erik Small, Senior Manager Online advertising and eCommerce for the grocery chain Meijer-- as well as Dean Davison Principal Consultant for Forrester Consulting.Remember, you can ask questions at any time and we’ll take your questions after the presentations. And you’ll all receive an e-mail about how to access these presentations.With that, I’ll turn it over to…
  • #11 Mobile is a personal bridge to the internet
  • #33 I like this version