This note is intended to highlight Mexican tax implications when dealing with financing structures involving Bitcoin-backed lending, where a non-resident lender and a resident borrower intervenes.
"APAC Technology Conference" by BM APAC, Panelist for "Key challenges and opportunities facing technology businesses in Asia Pacific - Session: Innovation through M&A and Partnering" (31 July 2018)
"APAC Technology Conference" by BM APAC, Panelist for "Key challenges and opportunities facing technology businesses in Asia Pacific - Session: Innovation through M&A and Partnering" (31 July 2018)
"FinTech and E-Payment" classes for Chulalongkorn University, Master of Law Program in Finance and Tax Laws and Master of Arts Program in Economic Law, (2018)
Deatherage presentation blockchain, cryptocurrency, smart contracts and the l...Scott Deatherage
Blockchain, cryptocurrency, smart contracts and the law provides a general outline of blockchain technology, cryptocurrency, and smart contracts as well as a discussion of legal issues related to these topics.
B11: Central IP & IT Court | FinTech: Legal and Regulatory Challenges (7 Aug ...Kullarat Phongsathaporn
"Special seminar on Memorial Day for Thailand's Father of Law" by Central IP & IT Court, Panelist for "FinTech: Legal and Regulatory Challenges" (7 Aug 2019)
Webinar: Bitcoin, Blockchain, and the LawLogikcull
Erica G. Wilson, of Vuono & Gray, and Stephen T. Middlebrook, of Womble Carlyle, look at the basics of blockchain and bitcoin technology, the legal issues they raise, and the evolving regulatory landscape.
Exploring Blockchain: From Ideas to ApplicationsDavid Bieri
Exploring Blockchain looks at the economic, business and social implications of blockchain technology and cryptocurrencies.
Taught by David Bieri, Associate Professor of Urban Affairs and Associate Professor of Economics at Virginia Tech, the webinar examines the basics of blockchain, along with the potential for blockchain to improve business and government operations. We'll focus on applications such as finance, supply chain management, voting and digital identity
B12: AMLO | FinTech Situation in Thailand and Offshore and Money Laundering R...Kullarat Phongsathaporn
"AMLO Seminar and Workshop regarding new types of financial transactions: FinTech and Financial Inclusion" by AMLO, Panelist for "FinTech Situation in Thailand and Offshore and Money Laundering Risks" (4 Jul 2019)
Bitcoin, ICOs & ITOs: a legal overview | Giorgio Mazzoli | Blockchain ConfCodemotion
This presentation will be on the legal nature of bitcoin. The following aspects will be examined: bitcoin’s fundamental features, what is considered “money” from an economic and legal perspective and the difference, if any, between bitcoin and money. A specific reference shall be made to ECB’s position, to the EU Court of Justice judgment in case C-264/2014 and to EU Parliament’s resolution of April 19th, 2018.
Moreover, I will explain the effects of bitcoin’s definition as a “mean of payment on a voluntary basis” and the differences between bitcoin and fiat money with a legal tender.
From Bitcoin to Central Bank Digital Currencies: The Digitization of Money & ...David Bieri
The digital revolution in money and finance is in the process of fundamentally transforming the traditional model of monetary exchange. Platform-based fintech and digital currencies enable near instantaneous peer-to-peer transfer of funds in ways that were hitherto not possible. The prospect of new digital currencies and other crypto-assets that go beyond national borders promise to redefine the way in which payment and settlement systems operate, reconstituting monetary-financial relations between users. This is likely to lead to changes in the architecture of the international monetary system and the role of government-issued money. In this presentation, I explore the digitization of money and its consequences.
Initial Coin Offerings – legal requirements and types of tokensEspeo Software
Evaluation of the legal nature of projects funded with ICOs is extremely important to define the legal and tax characteristics of tokens. The legal qualification of a token has practical implications for the legal status of its creator, token trading rules and other entities (buyers of tokens or intermediaries in their trade). Presentation will focus on legal types of tokens, specific requirements for ICO’s promoters and attitude of regulatory authorities towards token crowdsales in individual countries.
MasterSnacks Cryptocurrency: Legal Issues in Cryptocurrency and BlockchainCitrin Cooperman
If your business is involved in cryptocurrency or Blockchain, it is in your best interest to understand the legal implications that may come along with transacting in digital assets. In this session, Jeff Neuburger, partner at Proskauer Rose and head of its Blockchain Practice, to covered the following topics and more:
- Categorization of cryptocurrencies as securities and resulting implications
- Types of licenses necessary to be involved in a cryptocurrency business
- Non-fungible tokens and associated legal issues
- Smart contracts
"FinTech and E-Payment" classes for Chulalongkorn University, Master of Law Program in Finance and Tax Laws and Master of Arts Program in Economic Law, (2018)
Deatherage presentation blockchain, cryptocurrency, smart contracts and the l...Scott Deatherage
Blockchain, cryptocurrency, smart contracts and the law provides a general outline of blockchain technology, cryptocurrency, and smart contracts as well as a discussion of legal issues related to these topics.
B11: Central IP & IT Court | FinTech: Legal and Regulatory Challenges (7 Aug ...Kullarat Phongsathaporn
"Special seminar on Memorial Day for Thailand's Father of Law" by Central IP & IT Court, Panelist for "FinTech: Legal and Regulatory Challenges" (7 Aug 2019)
Webinar: Bitcoin, Blockchain, and the LawLogikcull
Erica G. Wilson, of Vuono & Gray, and Stephen T. Middlebrook, of Womble Carlyle, look at the basics of blockchain and bitcoin technology, the legal issues they raise, and the evolving regulatory landscape.
Exploring Blockchain: From Ideas to ApplicationsDavid Bieri
Exploring Blockchain looks at the economic, business and social implications of blockchain technology and cryptocurrencies.
Taught by David Bieri, Associate Professor of Urban Affairs and Associate Professor of Economics at Virginia Tech, the webinar examines the basics of blockchain, along with the potential for blockchain to improve business and government operations. We'll focus on applications such as finance, supply chain management, voting and digital identity
B12: AMLO | FinTech Situation in Thailand and Offshore and Money Laundering R...Kullarat Phongsathaporn
"AMLO Seminar and Workshop regarding new types of financial transactions: FinTech and Financial Inclusion" by AMLO, Panelist for "FinTech Situation in Thailand and Offshore and Money Laundering Risks" (4 Jul 2019)
Bitcoin, ICOs & ITOs: a legal overview | Giorgio Mazzoli | Blockchain ConfCodemotion
This presentation will be on the legal nature of bitcoin. The following aspects will be examined: bitcoin’s fundamental features, what is considered “money” from an economic and legal perspective and the difference, if any, between bitcoin and money. A specific reference shall be made to ECB’s position, to the EU Court of Justice judgment in case C-264/2014 and to EU Parliament’s resolution of April 19th, 2018.
Moreover, I will explain the effects of bitcoin’s definition as a “mean of payment on a voluntary basis” and the differences between bitcoin and fiat money with a legal tender.
From Bitcoin to Central Bank Digital Currencies: The Digitization of Money & ...David Bieri
The digital revolution in money and finance is in the process of fundamentally transforming the traditional model of monetary exchange. Platform-based fintech and digital currencies enable near instantaneous peer-to-peer transfer of funds in ways that were hitherto not possible. The prospect of new digital currencies and other crypto-assets that go beyond national borders promise to redefine the way in which payment and settlement systems operate, reconstituting monetary-financial relations between users. This is likely to lead to changes in the architecture of the international monetary system and the role of government-issued money. In this presentation, I explore the digitization of money and its consequences.
Initial Coin Offerings – legal requirements and types of tokensEspeo Software
Evaluation of the legal nature of projects funded with ICOs is extremely important to define the legal and tax characteristics of tokens. The legal qualification of a token has practical implications for the legal status of its creator, token trading rules and other entities (buyers of tokens or intermediaries in their trade). Presentation will focus on legal types of tokens, specific requirements for ICO’s promoters and attitude of regulatory authorities towards token crowdsales in individual countries.
MasterSnacks Cryptocurrency: Legal Issues in Cryptocurrency and BlockchainCitrin Cooperman
If your business is involved in cryptocurrency or Blockchain, it is in your best interest to understand the legal implications that may come along with transacting in digital assets. In this session, Jeff Neuburger, partner at Proskauer Rose and head of its Blockchain Practice, to covered the following topics and more:
- Categorization of cryptocurrencies as securities and resulting implications
- Types of licenses necessary to be involved in a cryptocurrency business
- Non-fungible tokens and associated legal issues
- Smart contracts
Regulation of Bitcoins under Indian Regulatory FrameworksNishtha Sharma
This presentation provides a comprehensive account of meaning of Bitcoins, their intended use, mechanism behind the payment through peer to peer transaction system alonwith an overview on the means or heads under which Bitcoins can be regulated under Indian regulatory regime
Doing Business of Cryptocurrency w.r.t. India Legal PerspectiveEquiCorp Associates
Cryptocurrency has been called as the greatest technological breakthroughs since the Internet. However, a parallel warning from the Reserve Bank of India as a caution against bitcoin and other cryptocurrency, with no guidelines or order to prohibit cryptocurrency may puzzled you to ponder over –Is it legal to do business of cryptocurrency in India? There may be several questions which you may encounter w.r.t. applicable laws of India, as there are no specific guidelines issued by any Government Authority including Reserve Bank of India or Ministry of Finance.
The main stream adoption of cryptocurrency is becoming a reality despite sceptics who compare the boom to the 1636 tulip mania. The issue is not whether cryptocurrency will survive, but rather how it will evolve. The article aims to clarify certain major aspects which may be encountered for- “Doing Business of Cryptocurrency w.r.t. Indian Legal Perspective” under the evolving legal structure.
A Comparative Study of Bitcoin Laws In Canada: Navigating Regulatory LandscapesCrypto in California
Cryptocurrencies, particularly Bitcoin, have emerged as a revolutionary form of digital currency in recent years. With their increasing popularity, governments around the world have been grappling with how to regulate these decentralized virtual currencies. In this blog post, we will explore the regulatory approaches and legal frameworks to Study Bitcoin laws in Canada and the United States.
THE TOP 10 GLOBAL BITCOIN REGULATORY DEVELOPMENTS OF 2015Steven Rhyner
Not a single month passed in 2015 without some groundbreaking new development in the world of digital currency regulation. I’ll count down some of the ones that have been most influential on my own practice.
Japanese new legislation regarding BitLincense explained. Good for bitcoin exchange service providors, legal advisors and consultants who want to know about Japanese new legislation
The first solid explanatory slides about Japan's new BitLicense legislation. Good for foreign VC exchange service providers, legal counsel, consultant, advisors and venture capitalists who are interested in Japanese regulatory environment in virtual currency business.
A cryptocurrency is a digital or virtual currency that is protected by encryption, making counterfeiting and double-spending almost impossible. Many cryptocurrencies are built on blockchain technology, which is a distributed ledger enforced by a global network of computers. Cryptocurrencies are distinguished by the fact that they are not issued by any central authority, making them potentially resistant to government intervention or manipulation.
02-Term-Finance-Certificates and their operations.pdfHaroon742118
It is axiomatic that development of capital markets is sine qua non to the growth and
prosperity of a country’s economy. This paper is an attempt to analyse a potential source of capital
financing which has not heretofore taken in root in Pakistan. It focuses on commercial paper and
debentures, with particular emphasis on term finance certificates (“TFCs”). This paper is organized as
follows:
(A) Concept of Commercial Paper;
(B) Secured Debentures and Bottlenecks;
(C) TFC’s, Stamp Duty and the Structure for Private Placement with Investors;
(D) Capital Issues (Continuance of Control) Act, 1947 (the “Capital Issues Act”) and
Offering/Placement of TFC’s;
(E) Public Offering of TFC’s and Bottlenecks;
(F) Convertible TFC’s
(G) TFC’s and Islam; and
(H) Conclusions.
Similar to Bitcoin backed lending. Mexico tax implications (20)
Matthew Professional CV experienced Government LiaisonMattGardner52
As an experienced Government Liaison, I have demonstrated expertise in Corporate Governance. My skill set includes senior-level management in Contract Management, Legal Support, and Diplomatic Relations. I have also gained proficiency as a Corporate Liaison, utilizing my strong background in accounting, finance, and legal, with a Bachelor's degree (B.A.) from California State University. My Administrative Skills further strengthen my ability to contribute to the growth and success of any organization.
A "File Trademark" is a legal term referring to the registration of a unique symbol, logo, or name used to identify and distinguish products or services. This process provides legal protection, granting exclusive rights to the trademark owner, and helps prevent unauthorized use by competitors.
Visit Now: https://www.tumblr.com/trademark-quick/751620857551634432/ensure-legal-protection-file-your-trademark-with?source=share
Defending Weapons Offence Charges: Role of Mississauga Criminal Defence LawyersHarpreetSaini48
Discover how Mississauga criminal defence lawyers defend clients facing weapon offence charges with expert legal guidance and courtroom representation.
To know more visit: https://www.saini-law.com/
In 2020, the Ministry of Home Affairs established a committee led by Prof. (Dr.) Ranbir Singh, former Vice Chancellor of National Law University (NLU), Delhi. This committee was tasked with reviewing the three codes of criminal law. The primary objective of the committee was to propose comprehensive reforms to the country’s criminal laws in a manner that is both principled and effective.
The committee’s focus was on ensuring the safety and security of individuals, communities, and the nation as a whole. Throughout its deliberations, the committee aimed to uphold constitutional values such as justice, dignity, and the intrinsic value of each individual. Their goal was to recommend amendments to the criminal laws that align with these values and priorities.
Subsequently, in February, the committee successfully submitted its recommendations regarding amendments to the criminal law. These recommendations are intended to serve as a foundation for enhancing the current legal framework, promoting safety and security, and upholding the constitutional principles of justice, dignity, and the inherent worth of every individual.
Synopsis On Annual General Meeting/Extra Ordinary General Meeting With Ordinary And Special Businesses And Ordinary And Special Resolutions with Companies (Postal Ballot) Regulations, 2018
Guide on the use of Artificial Intelligence-based tools by lawyers and law fi...Massimo Talia
This guide aims to provide information on how lawyers will be able to use the opportunities provided by AI tools and how such tools could help the business processes of small firms. Its objective is to provide lawyers with some background to understand what they can and cannot realistically expect from these products. This guide aims to give a reference point for small law practices in the EU
against which they can evaluate those classes of AI applications that are probably the most relevant for them.
Guide on the use of Artificial Intelligence-based tools by lawyers and law fi...
Bitcoin backed lending. Mexico tax implications
1. 1
FINANZAS-FISCAL-LEGAL CORPORATIVO
Bitcoin-backed lending. Some Mexican tax considerations.
Background.
The case under analysis implies a “new” product consisting in offerings of Bitcoin-backed loans by a non-
resident lender (the “Lender”). Such cross-border lender could be assessed as a non-regulated private
lender which is not acting in the area of financial technology institutions (FTIs). The target borrower is a
Mexican resident legal entity, which in turn is also not acting as an FTI (the “Borrower”), and has needs in
order to finance an array of local projects. The type of offered loans might be either retail loans or
corporate loans (depending on the amount of lending required).
The basic structure of these loans requires using Bitcoins as security (primary security but not actually a
collateral security); therefore, the Lender would have a properly registered security (Bitcoins) during the
term of the loan granted.
The analysis would require some assumptions, for example that the Lender and Borrower are not related
parties for tax purposes (i.e. neither direct nor indirect cross-participations or administrative influence or
control between themselves); the “new” product does not involve the performance of neither financial
lease nor factoring transactions; the income derived by the non-resident Lender is not subject to a
preferential tax regime; there is currently in force and effect a tax treaty (including ample exchange of
information provisions) by and between the residency countries of the Lender and Borrower.
As a matter of fact, it is not intended (at least not at this stage) the aforementioned loan structure to be
assessed as a swap contract transaction using Bitcoins, or Bitcoin mining, or any initial coin offerings
(ICOs)/crowdfunding denominated in cryptocurrencies. It is needed to keep in mind that the Mexican
resident Borrower might be performing investments in Bitcoins prior to or at the moment of entering into
the Bitcoin-backed lending structure with the non-resident Lender.
Regulatory framework.
It is generally accepted that Bitcoinsare cryptocurrenciesor virtual assets. Those assets may also be known
as tokens. It appears that currently, the use of virtual assets in Mexico (e.g. Bitcoins) is merely that of a
speculative investment (and, in general, the performance of transactions denominated in virtual assets)1.
As of today, it can be claimed that the general regulatory framework in Mexico trying to settle the
definition of virtual assets, and transactions with virtual assets, is essentially represented by the Act for
the Regulation of Financial Technology Institutions (FINTECH Act, Ley para Regular las Instituciones de
Tecnología Financiera), which was enacted in March, 2018. Additionally, there were also published general
provisions (Disposiciones de Carácter General) to such Act in September, 2018, as well as certain guidelines
1
See Becerra Cantu, Juan Angel. Veritas Online, Taxation in Mexico of transactions carried out in “virtual assets”, August 29, 2018, and,
Veritas Online, Regulating Transactions with Virtual Assets in Mexico, September 24, 2018.
2. 2
FINANZAS-FISCAL-LEGAL CORPORATIVO
on authorisations issued by the National Banking and Securities Commission (CNBV, Comisión Nacional
Bancaria y de Valores) in November, 2018.
Nevertheless, the Mexican Central Bank (Banco de México, BANXICO) still needs to publish general rules
for purposes of regulating cryptocurrencies – virtual assets, including characteristics of virtual assets,
operative conditions, rules for their modification, transactions with virtual assets which might be allowed,
and those cryptocurrencies relevant for operational purposes for BANXICO, i.e. general rules related to
the treatment of virtual assets as well as allowed transactions denominated in virtual assets. Additionally,
there are also general rules to be published on measures to custody and control virtual assets, reporting
on transactions performed by participants in virtual markets, and define specific criteria for eligible
projects aiming at obtaining authorisation to operate as a novel/innovative model. It is expected that
BANXICO would initiate a public consultation on these items shortly, and finally approve and publish
relevant general rules on virtual assets no later than March, 2019.
Needless to say, the “new” product at play (i.e. Bitcoin-backed lending), where a target borrower is a
Mexican resident legal entity, shall be tested in the light of the current regulatory legal framework, and
when appropriate, also in the light of any general rules to be published by BANXICO. It is of paramount
importance to determine if using Bitcoins as primary security in relation to a non-resident lender may fall
or not within the provisions of the FINTECH Act, or otherwise the transaction would be assessed as “taking
place outside of Mexico”.
Repayment of the loan itself.
One shall take into account basic tax implications regarding the repayment of the loan (principal and
accessories). It is not intended to include an exhaustive list of items which may derive from this
“transaction”, and which should be carefully addressed, but, among others, a minimum threshold would
include:
(i) Beneficial ownership of interest income at the level of the Lender.
(ii) WHT at source on interest income derived by Lender (see interaction of domestic law, and if
the case, tax treaty provisions, together with compliance of applicability requirements).
(iii) Definition of WHT “agent” (Retenedor), and fulfillment of reporting obligations (e.g. WHT
documentation, information returns for payments abroad, etc.).
(iv) Issuance of tax receipts (CFDIs, Comprobante Fiscal Digital por Internet).
(v) Special treatment for specific types of lenders (e.g. non-resident/foreign pension funds).
(vi) Non-existence of a permanent establishment in Mexico of the Lender.
(vii) Deductibility of interest expenses at the level of the Borrower (payer) for income taxpurposes
(including tests corresponding to thin-cap rules, and tax deductibility requisites under
domestic fiscal law).
On a separate note, the Borrower should also carefully assess its position towards Bitcoins to be used as
primary security in relation to the loan. Assuming that the Borrower is performing speculative investments
in Bitcoins prior to or at the time of formalization of the loan, such Borrower might be interested in
determining the acquisition cost of Bitcoins, their accounting treatment when acquired (e.g. are Bitcoins
3. 3
FINANZAS-FISCAL-LEGAL CORPORATIVO
treated as merchandise/inventories? as financial or intangible assets?) as well as their actual valuation
(real/market value? nominal value?).
Tax treatment of a security interest in Bitcoins.
The non-resident Lender would require to confirm the accounting and tax treatment of any properly
registered security during the term of the loan. It is assumed that Bitcoins “owned” by the Borrower will
serve as primary security (not really as a collateral security) for purposes of the loan. As previously
mentioned, it will be a matter for the Borrower to properly assess and treat its investments in Bitcoins,
and also value such investments.
In a situation in which the relevant loan may fall into the category of a non-performing loan, and the Lender
may opt to exercise and make effective the primary security granted according to the terms and conditions
of the loan (it is assumed that all activities related to the loan, including granting, repayment, security,
etc., are agreed and executed through virtual/internet means), then it appears that Bitcoins would be
“transferred” from the Borrower to the Lender (i.e. cross-border transfer).
Therefore, under these circumstances, one may suggest that the following tax implications or fiscal items
would need to be addressed on a non-exhaustive basis:
(i) Transfer of Bitcoins from Borrower to Lender as a “tax transfer”.
(ii) VAT treatment of the transfer (e.g. potential qualification as an export of property/services?),
and issuance of tax receipts (CFDIs).
(iii) Specific implications:
a. The transfer of Bitcoins would imply the acquisition of credit claims/rights of any type
(present, future, contingent) at the level of the Lender? If so, any income in credit would
be assessed as interest, and potentially subject to WHT at source (Mexico). For these
purposes, it will be highly relevant to determine the nominal value of the credit
claims/rights as well as the consideration corresponding to the transfer.
b. The transfer of Bitcoins would imply an in-kind payment of the loan by the Borrower? If
so, under domestic tax law, items of taxable income for resident legal entities would
include, among others, those gains derived from the transfer of property by in-kind
payments. In this case, it will be also relevant to determine the value of the transferred
property (Bitcoins).
c. If the case, any further gains derived from the disposal of credits (e.g. credits stemming
from the Bitcoin-backed lending) owed by the Borrower, and disposed by the Lender,
shall be carefully assessed on a case-by-case basis.
(iv) Accounting treatment by the Lender and Borrower towards the ownership transfer of
Bitcoins, and in the light of a non-performing loan.
4. 4
FINANZAS-FISCAL-LEGAL CORPORATIVO
(v) WHT implications of any “originally sourced” interest income deriving from the loan, and
falling into the in-kind payment of the loan.
Other comments.
There is still the need for a comprehensive legal regulatory framework in Mexico for purposes of
structuring and operating transactions using cryptocurrencies or virtual assets. It is expected that general
rules to be issued by BANXICO (as described above) may shed some light on the use of virtual assets
domestically, and be regulated together with provisions of the FINTECH Act.
This may also facilitate the definition of financial, accounting, and tax implications inherent to transactions
such as the one described in this note (e.g. Bitcoin-backed lending).
Notably, any further guidance on the treatment and classification of virtual assets, and to be included
through additions and/or amendments to the current tax law, or Omnibus Tax Bill (Resolución Miscelánea
Fiscal), will be also highly useful and very welcome.
***