The document discusses how behavioural economics can help financial services firms improve customer outcomes. It explains that behavioural economics studies how people make real-world economic decisions, which often differ from rational choices assumed in traditional economics. The document outlines why behavioural economics is particularly important for financial services due to the complexity of products and long-term impact of decisions. It notes that behavioural economics is gaining attention due to regulatory pressure from organizations like the FCA to protect customers from exploitation and improve trust in the industry.
The FSA TCF initiative has been with the UK financial services world for many years and there are still areas that firms are missing about the whole idea. This guide helps identify the myths and provide sound steps and ideas for any firm to adopt and use in their strategy.
Treating Customers Fairly, specifically
the holistic approach taken by Tesco Bank in integrating TCF into an organisation with tremendously strong customer values already in
place.
The FSA TCF initiative has been with the UK financial services world for many years and there are still areas that firms are missing about the whole idea. This guide helps identify the myths and provide sound steps and ideas for any firm to adopt and use in their strategy.
Treating Customers Fairly, specifically
the holistic approach taken by Tesco Bank in integrating TCF into an organisation with tremendously strong customer values already in
place.
Analytics Retention - Must-Have Analytics For Your Retention Tool Kit via Forrester Research by Srividya Sridharan with Dave Frankland and Allison Smith
This study aims to examine and analyze the influence of Product Quality, Place, Service Quality and
Promotion partially and or together on customer purchase decisions related to choosing regular savings and
business savings at Bank Mandiri, Gading Serpong, Tangerang Selatan. Research data is obtained by
conducting a survey of customers
Retail banks around the world are facing intense margin pressure, slow
balance sheet growth, an uncertain economic outlook and a growing
threat from new entrants, especially in the payments arena. Banks are
also confronted with growing regulatory costs and increasing demands
for greater fairness and clarity in their interactions with customers.
A lot of time and money is being spent by banks in making their organization customer focused and improving the customer experience. According to Gartner’s 2012 CIO Survey, CIOs regard customer experience as the greatest opportunity for IT innovation.
The relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty in the ba...Samaan Al-Msallam
Abstract
A large number of studies on customer satisfaction and customer loyalty have been conducted in marketing over
the years. Customer satisfaction is a crucial factor for bank success and it has the possibility to influence
customer loyalty. From a theoretical perspective it is very important to investigate which factors influence
customer satisfaction. This paper analyzes the basic factors which affects customer satisfaction towards services
of Bank. This study adopted empirical research design on the sample size of 401 respondents who were
customers of different banks in Syria. Data is collected through survey questionnaires related to customer
expectation ,price fairness , customer satisfaction and customer loyalty towards services of banks . Data is
analyzed by using AMOS 18. The research reviews the current academic marketing literature and tries to
identify antecedents of customer satisfaction and customer loyalty. The findings from this study also provide
important managerial implications.
Keywords: bank, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty.
This is the fourth in a series of briefs examining practical considerations in the design and implementation of a strategic purchasing pilot project among private general practitioners (GPs) in Myanmar. This pilot aims to start developing the important functions of, and provide valuable lessons around, contracting of health providers and purchasing that will contribute to the broader health financing agenda. More specifically, it is introducing a blended payment system that mixes capitation payments and performance-based incentives to reduce households’ out-of-pocket spending and incentivize providers to deliver an essential package of primary care services.
Embracing Customer Relationship Management (CRM) to Improve Organisational Vi...IOSRJBM
The study aimed at finding ways of improving organisational viability by small businesses in Chinhoyi through applying Customer Relationship Management (CRM). This study was prompted by lack of growth of the sector. These firms have been facing a business environment characterised by low Gross Domestic Product (GDP), foreign currency challenges, high unemployment, brain drain, liquidity crisis, high competition and low demand for domestic products. The descriptive design was used. Thirty registered small businesses, with approximately 100 subordinates and 25 managers/supervisors formed the target population for the study. The sample size was 40 and comprised of 30 subordinates and 10 managers/supervisors. Simple random sampling was used to select respondents for the study. The research instruments used were questionnaires, observations and interviews. The study found out that many small businesses do not have a comprehensive CRM programme. The study concluded that lack of a comprehensive customer relationship management programmes by small businesses has been hampering performance of the sector. The study recommends the implementation of CRM programmes by small businesses in Zimbabwe through information centres and embracing information technology. Feedback processes are also necessary for CRM. There is need to carry out a national survey on CRM for small businesses for generalisation of findings across the entire Zimbabwean economy.
Analytics Retention - Must-Have Analytics For Your Retention Tool Kit via Forrester Research by Srividya Sridharan with Dave Frankland and Allison Smith
This study aims to examine and analyze the influence of Product Quality, Place, Service Quality and
Promotion partially and or together on customer purchase decisions related to choosing regular savings and
business savings at Bank Mandiri, Gading Serpong, Tangerang Selatan. Research data is obtained by
conducting a survey of customers
Retail banks around the world are facing intense margin pressure, slow
balance sheet growth, an uncertain economic outlook and a growing
threat from new entrants, especially in the payments arena. Banks are
also confronted with growing regulatory costs and increasing demands
for greater fairness and clarity in their interactions with customers.
A lot of time and money is being spent by banks in making their organization customer focused and improving the customer experience. According to Gartner’s 2012 CIO Survey, CIOs regard customer experience as the greatest opportunity for IT innovation.
The relationship between customer satisfaction and customer loyalty in the ba...Samaan Al-Msallam
Abstract
A large number of studies on customer satisfaction and customer loyalty have been conducted in marketing over
the years. Customer satisfaction is a crucial factor for bank success and it has the possibility to influence
customer loyalty. From a theoretical perspective it is very important to investigate which factors influence
customer satisfaction. This paper analyzes the basic factors which affects customer satisfaction towards services
of Bank. This study adopted empirical research design on the sample size of 401 respondents who were
customers of different banks in Syria. Data is collected through survey questionnaires related to customer
expectation ,price fairness , customer satisfaction and customer loyalty towards services of banks . Data is
analyzed by using AMOS 18. The research reviews the current academic marketing literature and tries to
identify antecedents of customer satisfaction and customer loyalty. The findings from this study also provide
important managerial implications.
Keywords: bank, customer satisfaction, customer loyalty.
This is the fourth in a series of briefs examining practical considerations in the design and implementation of a strategic purchasing pilot project among private general practitioners (GPs) in Myanmar. This pilot aims to start developing the important functions of, and provide valuable lessons around, contracting of health providers and purchasing that will contribute to the broader health financing agenda. More specifically, it is introducing a blended payment system that mixes capitation payments and performance-based incentives to reduce households’ out-of-pocket spending and incentivize providers to deliver an essential package of primary care services.
Embracing Customer Relationship Management (CRM) to Improve Organisational Vi...IOSRJBM
The study aimed at finding ways of improving organisational viability by small businesses in Chinhoyi through applying Customer Relationship Management (CRM). This study was prompted by lack of growth of the sector. These firms have been facing a business environment characterised by low Gross Domestic Product (GDP), foreign currency challenges, high unemployment, brain drain, liquidity crisis, high competition and low demand for domestic products. The descriptive design was used. Thirty registered small businesses, with approximately 100 subordinates and 25 managers/supervisors formed the target population for the study. The sample size was 40 and comprised of 30 subordinates and 10 managers/supervisors. Simple random sampling was used to select respondents for the study. The research instruments used were questionnaires, observations and interviews. The study found out that many small businesses do not have a comprehensive CRM programme. The study concluded that lack of a comprehensive customer relationship management programmes by small businesses has been hampering performance of the sector. The study recommends the implementation of CRM programmes by small businesses in Zimbabwe through information centres and embracing information technology. Feedback processes are also necessary for CRM. There is need to carry out a national survey on CRM for small businesses for generalisation of findings across the entire Zimbabwean economy.
Using contract lawyers to scale your law practiceGreg McLawsen
In small law firms there is an inherent pickle when it comes to growth. If you hire employees too soon, there may not be enough work to go around. If you fail to build capacity, you lose profitable business that could have been yours. What to do?
An increasing number of law firms are solving this problem by outsourcing labor either temporarily or permanently. Outsourcing to contractors or specialty businesses instead of hiring employees can allow you to expand – that is, to “scale” – your practice. At the same time, this strategy allows you to mitigate the risk that comes with hiring employees or taking on additional tasks in house. Use of on-demand contractors means that they help is there when you need it, and costs you nothing when you don't.
Join us for a conversation to explore whether outsourcing could help you scale your law practice, increase profitability, and restore some much-needed work/life balance
Our guide to using applied behavioural economics within financial services to help improve customer outcomes.
Under pressure from the FCA, all financial services organisations are now expected to understand the principles of behavioural economics.
Beyond the compliance requirements, we are helping leading organisations to embed behavioural insights throughout the customer journey, supporting customer decision-making and boosting loyalty.
Basic tools of managerial economics for decision makingMilan Padariya
Business decision making is essentially a process of selecting the best out of alternative opportunities open to the firm. Modern business conditions are changing so fast and becoming so competitive and complex that personal business sense, intuition and experience alone are not sufficient to make appropriate business decisions. It is in this area of decision making that economic theories and tools of economic analysis contribute a great deal.
Week 1 Lecture The Nature of Business ResearchBusiness researc.docxkdennis3
Week 1 Lecture
The Nature of Business Research
Business research covers a wide range of phenomena. For managers, the purpose of research is to provide knowledge regarding the organization, the market, the economy, or another area of uncertainty. A financial manager may ask, “Will the environment for long-term financing be better two years from now?†A personnel manager may ask, “What kind of training is necessary for production employees?†or “What is the reason for the company’s high employee turnover?†A marketing manager may ask, “How can I monitor my retail sales and retail trade activities?†Each of these questions requires information about how the environment, employees, customers, or the economy will respond to executives’ decisions. Research is one of the principal tools for answering these practical questions.
Business research is the application of the scientific method in searching for the truth about business phenomena. These activities include defining business opportunities and problems, generating and evaluating alternative courses of action, and monitoring employee and organizational performance. Business research is more than conducting surveys.6 This process includes idea and theory development, problem definition, searching for and collecting information, analyzing data, and communicating the findings and their implications.
Applied business research is conducted to address a specific business decision for a specific firm or organization. The opening vignette describes a situation in which ESPN used applied research to decide how to best create knowledge of its sports fans and their preferences. Basic business research (sometimes referred to as pure research) is conducted without a specific decision in mind, and it usually does not address the needs of a specific organization.
All research, whether basic or applied, involves the scientific method. The scientific method is the way researchers go about using knowledge and evidence to reach objective conclusions about the real world. The scientific method is the same in social sciences, such as business, as in physical sciences, such as physics. In this case, it is the way we come to understand business phenomena.
A firm can be production-oriented. A production-oriented firm prioritizes the efficiency and effectiveness of production processes in making decisions. Here, research providing input from workers, engineers, finance, and accounting becomes important as the firm seeks to drive costs down. Production-oriented firms are usually very large firms manufacturing products in very large quantities. The third orientation is marketing- oriented, which focuses more on how the firm provides value to customers than on the physical product or production process. With a marketing-oriented organization the majority of research focuses on the customer. Research addressing consumer desires, beliefs, and attitudes becomes essential.
Diagnosing Opportunities: After a.
The PGDM Marketing Management course aims to empower students with the expertise and
capabilities needed for proficiently devising, executing, and evaluating marketing plans.
After viewing this project one can understand how a FMCG company operates its finances. The ratio analysis of the firm showing how to calculate the profitability, sustainability, viability of a firm to operate its day to day business in a profitable zone.
Many of my friends from industry have asked for my opinion on the economic crisis and its impact on business. My answer to them is that the real problem is that companies simply do not internalise the proper actions to take in order to respond to such a situation.
And rarely is it more critical than in retail business strategy, and the far-reaching implications surrounding the phenomena often known as ‘wallet share’ or ‘share of wallet’.
‘Share of wallet’ is in essence an holistic term capturing the aspect of a retailer’s desire to understand and manage consumer spending, how much they have, and how frequent and recent this occurs. This clearly introduces the aspects of service, proposition, customer loyalty, and internal & external change as strategy components for serious consideration by the senior management team.
This paper seeks to explore these aspects of a Retail business strategy, giving insight and advice for a stronger business strategy in ‘Changing Times’.
This document reviews best practice in pricing processes to provide a reference against which current practices and proposals can be tested. Our objectives have been: to research the attributes of world-class pricing through publications and academic sources; to investigate how these attributes are applied in practice to products and services; to assess pricing processes in successful businesses.
In recent years a new attitude toward pricing has emerged. Deregulation and international free trade agreements have increased competition. Price promotion has eroded the power of brand loyalty. Pricing has assumed greater importance to most businesses.
As markets increasingly assume a global dimension, customers can more easily compare prices between one region or country and another, using the internet or a fax machine. They can often locate the same product, or an
acceptable substitute, from another source. Customers are more demanding and fickle, and their expectations increasingly difficult to fulfil.
Price inflation in western economies is now at its lowest for decades. Price increases are no longer accepted without protest from customers, if at all.
The Chairman of General Electric has predicted the onset of the ‘Value Decade’. Global price competition will strengthen because of: reduced product differentiation; global over-capacity for production; significantly diminished trade barriers; efficient information and distribution systems; providing customers with easy access to the prices of suppliers; a growing lack of customers’ loyalty to individual suppliers. Choice will be increasingly driven by price.
This is a challenging scenario that reinforces the need for an integrated strategy and concerted managerial action on pricing.
Pricing processes have lagged behind developments in the market place. They are often characterised by internal conflict between accountants wishing to maximise profit per unit and marketing specialists who seek to maximise
throughput. They are also affected by the potential for strained relations with good customers.
Some companies have downsized their operations to a level where diminishing returns cause them to question the benefits of continuing to focus upon reducing costs. As they switch their attention from cost cutting to adding
value, pricing naturally assumes increased weight in the marketing mix.
We have found many companies reluctant to discuss their own processes.
Some may wish to avoid betraying a lack of sophistication.
The events of the last two years constitute more than an economic recession. Rather, they shape a global realignment -- "The New Normal." This position papers describes four fundamental areas where change has occurred in society and provides recommended responses for service brands and service marketers.
1. Behavioural economics:
Driving better customer
outcomes
Financial Services Risk & Regulation: Conduct & Customer/February 2014
Summary p01
/What is behavioural economics p02
/ Why is behavioural economics important
in financial services? p03
/ Behavioural economics in action p06
www.pwc.co.uk/conduct
2. Behavioural economics | Driving better customer outcomes
The study of behavioural economics can provide valuable insights into the
predictable biases and inherent cognitive limitations of how and why
customers make poor financial product decisions. With these behavioural
insights, firms can develop strategies, products and information which
encourage customers to make better financial decisions, improving the
financial outcomes for the customer, building greater customer-centricity
within firms and ultimately taking a significant step in helping rebuild
trust back into financial services.
This paper sets out what behavioural economics is, why it should be at
the forefront of strategy and customer agenda, and provides a number
of potential key impacts to current business.
Behavioural economics
3. 1January 2014
Financial services firms can gain a first-mover,
competitive advantage in the market by using
behavioural economics as the tool to build a
compliant, sustainable, and customer focused
business model. The growing importance of
putting customers at the heart of business and
a comprehensive change in the direction of
regulatory pressure has brought behavioural
economics to the forefront of the financial services
industry. The FCA have stated their intentions to
use behavioural economics as a tool for future
investigations and reviews, and firms which have
significant customer impact are outperforming
the market. If firms act quickly, they can utilise
these changes for a considerable opportunity.
Behavioural economics is the study into the way
humans make economic decisions, challenging
the classical economic view that humans make
Summary
perfectly rational decisions. It is of particular
interest within the financial services industry
where products are complex and require people to
make decisions that will affect them over a long
time period. The tool of behavioural economics
is useful for lots of different functions of the firm.
It can have an impact on strategy, through to
affecting how firms design their products.
Successfully understanding and implementing
behavioural economics across a combination of
the different functions of the firm can lead to
firms creating a customer-centric and sustainable
business model and reach better outcomes for the
firm, and the customer.
4. 2 Behavioural economics | Driving better customer outcomes
What is behavioural
economics and why is it
different from traditional
economic thinking?
The traditional study of economics has
been based on the underlying assumption
that when people make a decision, they
make the right, rational decision. This is
because they are assumed to have perfect
knowledge on all of the options available
to them, what the full outcome of each
option will be, and have the cognitive
capacity to process everything that may
affect the decision. They are assumed to
make the decision completely selfishly,
maximising the amount of utility, or
benefit, they receive from making that
decision, regardless of how it affects
anybody else.
Studies have shown that humans
are not the all-knowing, perfect
creatures traditional economics
assumes.
1 Kahanman, D. Thinking Fast, Thinking Slow, Penguin, 10/05/2012
2 Hodgkinson, G. & Starbuck, W. (Eds) The Oxford Handbook of Organizational Decision Making, OUP, 24/03/2012
Behavioural economics
concentrates on explaining the
economic decisions people make
in practice, especially when these
conflict with what conventional
economic theory predicts they
will do. Behaviourists try to
augment or replace traditional
ideas of economic rationality with
decision making models
borrowed from psychology.
In reality, people do not act in this
manner and behavioural economics is
the study into how people really act,
challenging the underlying rational
consumer assumption.
Research tells us that humans do not
always make logical rational decisions.
By their very nature, humans make
decisions based on non-logical factors
like emotion, past experience or without
having or understanding all the
necessary information.1,2
5. 3January 2014
Why is behavioural
economics important in
financial services?
a. Products offered are inherently
complex for most people
Financial products tend to have multiple
features and complex charging structures
and for many can be abstract and
intangible. This contrasts with most
tangible products where customers can
easily understand what they are
getting and the product has a single,
simple price. Faced with complexity,
customers may simplify decisions in
ways that lead to errors, such as
focusing only on headline rates.
Furthermore, customers may place
reliance on advice which makes issues
of trust and persuasion of key
importance in financial services.
b. Many products involve trade-offs
between the present and the future
People commonly make decisions against
their long term interests because of a
lack of self-control, e.g. borrowing
excessively using payday loans.
c. Decisions may require assessing
risk and uncertainty
People are generally bad intuitive
statisticians and are prone to making
systematic errors in decisions involving
uncertainty.3
Therefore we often
misjudge probabilities and make poor
insurance or investment decisions.
d. Decisions can be emotional
Decisions on which financial products
to buy can have a great and long term
effect. As a result decisions can be
driven by stress, anxiety, fear of losses
and regret, rather than the costs and
benefits of the choices.
e. Some products permit little
learning from past mistakes
Some financial decisions, such as
choosing a retirement plan or mortgage,
are made infrequently, with little learning
from others, and with consequences
revealed only after a long delay.
As financial products usually have
a substantial effect on the long term
wellbeing of customers, a poor decision
made can have a highly significant
effect on the consumer. Therefore,
an understanding of behavioural
economics and how it can affect a
client is crucial to a financial services
firm’s performance – ethically as well
as financially.
The products which people are
offered within financial services
are unique for a number of reasons.
Including:
3 Kahanman, D. Thinking Fast, Thinking Slow, Penguin, 10/05/2012
6. 4 Behavioural economics | Driving better customer outcomes
Why is behavioural economics becoming
increasingly prevalent in financial
services now?
There are two main drivers as to why
behavioural economics has emerged
as such an important tool to the future
of financial services firms – regulation,
and the rise in the importance of
customer focus.
Regulation
The FCA have published two papers
this year on the topic of behavioural
economics and Martin Wheatley (CEO)
has said that ‘the FCA will be using
behavioural economics in the
years ahead’.4
They plan on using
their regulatory authority to change
market practice in areas where
customer behaviour is being used to tie
customers into potentially poor
outcomes. Firms need to make sure
they are not using behavioural
economics in an exploitative way.
The FCA are already conducting
reviews and investigations with a
behavioural economic basis. They
have launched a review into price
comparison sites to look at ‘whether
certain deals are promoted above
others and whether the focus of these
websites on price means customers fail
to get the best deal for their needs.’5
4 Martin Wheatley, FCA Chief Executive, ‘The human face of regulation’, speech at LSE, 10/04/2013
5 Clive Adamson, FCA Director of Supervision, para-phrased in the article ‘FCA probes ‘misleading’ price comparison websites’ by Lucy Warwick-Ching at
www.FT.com, 25/11/2013
FCA outlined signs and indicators of behavioural economic exploitation
Sign Sample indicators
Firms 1. Rip-Offs
Uncompetitively high margins
• Persistent excess profitability
• Price dispersion unrelated to cost
• High penetration rate for high-margin unessential add-ons
2. Suckers
Concentrated profits from
a small group of customers
• Cross-subsidies between customer groups or products
• Very different financial sophistication across targeted customers
Product Features 3. Bargains
Innovative products that
appear very cheap
• ‘Too good to be true’ headline prices or returns
• Some material charges of exclusions are hidden or
under-emphasised
4. Traps
Contract features that often
target behavioural biases
• Teaser rates, especially if with automatic renewals
• Cancellation charges or other hurdles
• ‘Default’ options for some key contract elements
(e.g. opt-out purchase for add-ons)
Customers 5. Regret
Reported or potential regret
• Widespread reports of customer regret not caused
by foreseeable risk
• Product purchased rarely – little scope to learn
6. Folly
Choices out of line with
common sense
• Product inconsistent with other products owned of with stated
goals
• Product clearly provides poor value from some groups
of customers
7. Confusion
Observed or likely confusion
• Customers unable to describe key product features or prices after
purchase
• Product complicated for some or all because of structure
of number of options
7. 5January 2014
Further, there is external pressure on
the FCA to conduct more reviews and
investigations using behavioural
economic grounds. The Financial
Services Consumer Panel (FSCP) has
called for a review into the provision
of annuities, claiming that “They
(insurance firms) can say to them
(customers) it’s very good to shop around
but they are benefitting from people’s
anxiety and a lack of information.”6
However, to help firms prepare for
regulatory scrutiny, the FCA has
outlined the following indicators they
are likely to use to highlight trends or
unexpected indicator values which
could suggest that a firms customer
base is detrimentally impacted through
firm practices/products, and is not in
their current best interest.7
Understanding these signs and
indicators are crucial to the future
business model for all financial services
firms to be regulatory compliant. This
has really brought the attention of
behavioural economics forward.
However, the change in regulation doesn’t
just carry a threat; it also creates an
opportunity for firms to gain a competitive
edge, as it gives an indicator of what the
future landscape of the financial services
industry is going to look like.
Growth in the importance
of customer focus.
A more agile, innovative, risk-conscious
and customer-centric culture is set to be
the primary competitive differentiator in
the new landscape, and the importance
of putting the customer at the heart of a
firm’s business model has been rapidly
growing within the last few years. Since
2008 firms who have mastered the
growth lever of having a high customer
impact have outperformed the market
by a multiple of 2.2.8
This demonstrates
the value that knowing how to address
what your customer wants can add to
performance.
Behavioural economics has been
highlighted as a key tool to applying
the correct solutions to the decision
making problems. Most firms include
customer-centricity in their mission
statement or their vision and values.
Firms need to ask themselves the
extent to which the customer is truly
at the heart of everything they do and
how this translates into everyday
practice. Actively managing behaviours
will result in a culture that aligns
business strategy and leads to
sustainable business outcomes.
These two key drivers – regulation and
the growth in importance of customer
focus have accelerated behavioural
economics to the forefront of the
industry due to factors including
the following:
• The UK market has faced a number
of high profile cases of failure in
terms of meeting customer outcomes,
for example PPI miss-selling. Such
cases provide real-life examples of
how firms have financially benefited
from customer decisions which have
clearly not been in their best interests.
• Trust in financial services is at a
historic low. This has been driven by
organisational failure and lack of
customer-centricity. Behavioural
economics provides a tool to help
understand the inherent human
behaviours and biases within
customers, with predictable results,
which could help firms build
better customer solutions and aide
better customer decisions, helping
rebuild trust.
• Financial services are facing
challenging economic pressures in
terms of margins and competition.
Building better understanding of
real client needs and client decision
making processes will help firms
build strategies which put the
customer needs and values at the
heart of their organisation, coining
the phase “what is good for the
customer, is good for the firm.”
• Macro-economic and structural
changes are impacting financial
services, with significant challenges
in terms of socio-demographic,
geographic, technological,
environmental and political changes.
These long term trends will impact
financial services strategies.
Building customer understanding
will be key to developing long term
sustainable businesses.
• Regulatory developments, such as
Retail Distribution Review (RDR),
have changed the product/service
landscape. Regulatory intervention
in markets to help protect
customers best interests are now
looking at how behavioural
economic analysis can help identify
potential industry issues where
customers have been disadvantaged
through poorly designed products,
insufficient information or insufficient
advice. The FCA has stated that
they intend to use behavioural
economics as a tool in their
supervisory activities.
As financial products usually have a substantial effect on the long term
wellbeing of customers, a wrong decision made can have a highly
significant effect on the customer.
6 Debbie Harrisson, member of the FSCP, quoted in the article ‘Pensioners are being ‘burgled’ by insurers on annuities’ by Steve Hawkes, and Dan Hyde at
www.telegraph.co.uk, 09/12/2013
7 Kristine Erta, Stefan Hunt, Zanna Iscenko, Will Brambley, ‘Occasional Paper No.1 – Applying behavioural economics at the Financial Conduct Authority’,
10/04/2013
8 Based on PwC analysis on publicly available data
8. 6 Behavioural economics | Driving better customer outcomes
The impact of behavioural economics on customer decisions can be
illustrated through a number of examples. The following are just a few of
the many examples which show the breadth and depth of the ways cognitive
inhibitors and biases are present in firms and the industry, preventing
customers making good decisions.
Behavioural economics in action
Investment choices in pension plans
When having to choose investment plans, the rational economic view is that
people will evaluate options well and the more choices available, the more
healthy competition drives out bad options and the better the decision. Having
greater breadth and flexibility of plans on offer ensures that participants are able
to meet their individual needs. However, whilst giving individuals more choices
can increase people’s welfare and participation, more choice means a more
complex decision, and this can have an adverse effect on participation and
investment allocation. Research has shown that there is sometimes a drop in
participation as plan options increase.
Within pension schemes, reducing the number of options can potentially increase
participation. When presented with too many options, people find it harder to
make a decision due to being unable to evaluate and compare all the choices.
There is also higher probability of regretting the decision, as having more choice
also increases peoples’ expectations on the outcome, and consequently the
likelihood of the outcome not meeting their expectations. People are then likely
to feel they made the wrong decision – and regret the decision they have made. To
avoid this regret, people are less likely to opt into the plan at all.
In practice, there was a study on an asset management company who employ over
1 million staff’s voluntary retirement pension plans. The study showed that with
every 10 funds added to choose from, the participation rate fell by 2% – showing
that more choice isn’t always in the interest of either party.
A study on an asset
management company’s
voluntary retirement pension
plans showed that with every
10 funds added to choose
from, the participation rate
fell by 2%.
10 2%
Identifying insurance needs
Rationality assumes that when deciding to buy insurance, people will figure
out the probability of the outcome occurring, and then weight the potential loss
with this probability. They would then insure if the cost of insurance is less than
this amount.
One of the reasons people don’t act rationally in this way is that they are likely to
underestimate uncertainty; people often make predictions on the basis of
observations, believing that these form patterns. As a result, people believe that
when things happen very regularly, they will happen all the time. Therefore, they
overestimate the probability of common events occurring. Within insurance, this
means that people are less likely to insure against some things which they rationally
would as they assume it would never happen. Research indicates that in many
countries, homeowners and individuals are not sufficiently insured against
disaster risk. In addition, people tend to underestimate what the damage caused
from the potential disaster would be, and therefore what their coverage needs to be.
9. 7January 2014
Present bias: Auto-enrolment
Rational economic behaviour suggests that people will make decisions based
on how much it benefits them over their entire life. However, people commonly
respond to urges for immediate gratification – people value satisfaction in the
present more than satisfaction in the future – and as such will make decisions
which benefits them greater in the present.
When it comes to saving, we find that the optimal behaviour for both customers
and firms is for the individual to save more. The individual has the propensity to
under save, preferring consumption in the short term to long term. To help correct
this, there is regulatory or state intervention to increase savings through auto-
enrolment schemes to align desired optimal behaviour with market incentives.
Information asymmetries: Provider loyalty for annuities
A lack of information and sticking to the status quo are two factors which highly
influence people to act irrationally. The annuities market is a good example of
how providers are able to generate huge profits due to these factors.
When an individual wants to buy an annuity with their pension fund, they have
two choices. One option is buying an annuity from the company with whom they
have accumulated their pension fund, and the alternative is to shop around and
choose the best annuity from the range of annuity providers. Research shows that
two-thirds of customers buy their annuity from their current pension provider
despite higher annuity rates being available in the market in which an engaged,
well informed rational customer would choose. This is driven by people being
adverse to change – sticking to the status quo – as well as not being informed of
the other rates available to them.
Loss aversion: Over insuring small risk
Loss aversion can have important implications on insurance. Customers who
are loss averse may over-insure small risks, where the expected value of the
loss is small relative to the cost of the insurance e.g. mobile phone, bundling
cancellation insurance with ticket purchases. Premiums paid for such insurance
schemes are hard to justify in the context of rational economics but can be
explained by loss aversion and overweighting of loss probability. Travel insurance
with small incremental decreases in excess or baggage allowance is often
disproportionally matched with a significant increase in premium.
Information and limited attention to process complex
information; inability to compute: Limited awareness of
financial product fees and expenses
The average consumer of financial services reports tends to be unfamiliar fees
and expenses, even with respect to their own portfolio or products. However, over
the long term, even small fees can significantly erode long term value. Research
has found that fund purchases are sensitive to salient fees, such as front-end loads
but are insensitive to less salient charges such as expense ratios.
Borrowers may pick the lowest, most salient cost, such as the lowest monthly cost
for a credit card rather than focusing on their cost of credit over the expected life
of the card. Firms have introduced options to cater to these behaviours with
attractive low introduction fees.
0%
10. 8 Behavioural economics | Driving better customer outcomes
The potential impact and value of using
behavioural economic analysis across
your business
Business area Impact/value
Compliance and risk Using behavioural economic metrics, such as those identified by the FCA (see table on page 4),
to help firms identify early instances of potential customer detriment, enabling proactive
management of product and services suitability for customers
FCA supervisory approach is anticipated to incorporate a focus on behavioural economics.
Developing an understanding and being able to provide evidence of behavioural economics in
action across a firms’ products and services, supporting better customer outcomes, will become
increasingly important
Strategy Building an understanding of the behaviours which drive customer decisions aides the
development of product and service strategies focusing on better customer outcomes. Such
strategies will help rebuild trust with customers at a firm and industry level
Developing behavioural economic led strategies will help evidence customer-centricity in strategic
approach and leadership culture
Becoming an early adopter of behavioural economic led strategies, developing products and
services which help deliver better customer outcomes will strengthen competitor positioning
through product/service offering and pricing
Human Resources Using behavioural economic testing to help assess potential candidates customer-centricity in the
selection and promotion processes
Using behavioural economic metrics to build performance management and compensation
systems, reinforcing and rewarding customer focused behaviour
Providing ongoing training on behavioural economic concepts and the associated understanding
of customer behaviours in their decision making processes as a major component of customer-
centricity training and development at all levels
Customer team Building understanding of what customers actually value and how decisions are made in terms of
product, service and attributes
Developing greater customer understanding through client segmentation based on behavioural
economic concepts
Product Using behavioural economic metrics and conceptual understanding of decision making to develop
product and servicing offering to counter poor customer decisions
Building pricing strategies which are transparent and reflect customer value, helping customers
determine true value of products and services
Marketing Understanding how people will react to different types of campaigns will have a substantial
impact on how firms develop strategies and materials
By focusing on what and how information is received and interpreted by customers, improving
transparency and clarity of information in marketing and product information, overcoming
information asymmetries and aiding decision making processes
Positive use of behavioural economics as a tool to build trust and reputation into brand
Distribution channels Improving face to face interactions with greater understanding of the customer and customer
decision making
Developing advice and service models, reflecting the impact of behavioural economics
With this wide spectrum of interest in behavioural economics as a tool to aide firms and help customers make
better decisions, we believe behavioural economics should be of interest across a wide audience within your firm.
There are opportunities and instances where the use of behavioural economics should be central to your daily and
strategic operations and activities.
11. 9January 2014
To help firms develop their strategy,
customer agenda and to prepare for
regulatory expectations, there are a
number of practical activities they
could consider undertaking; including
in the design and pricing of products,
the information they provide, and in
the advice they give to customers.
Product and pricing
• Undertaking detailed client
segmentation to understand
different client needs.
• Undertaking client ‘value’ research
to understand what customers
value in terms of product/service
attributes and developing products
which reflect these outcomes.
• Developing fair and transparent
pricing structures, for example
fair-value pricing.
• Providing ‘portfolio’ of services to
help clients understand how a new
product/service/feature will fit
(compliment/conflict) with existing
portfolio of products/services/
features already held.
• Defining an optimal number of
product/service options to
overcome decision paralysis.
• Developing detailed metrics, for
example around product/service
revenues and client distribution,
evidencing actual behavioural
patterns with customers are as
intended to help customer make
better decisions.
Information
• Clearly presenting and articulating
variations in product/service
offerings, identifying costs, risks
and benefits. For example providing
illustrative examples of product/
service value verses cost.
• Providing information and analysis
to help customers understand long
term cost/benefit analysis, including
for example tax implications, and
the potential impact of variables to
these long term costs/benefits.
• Providing customers with enhanced
information to help inform
customers of potential probability
and loss factors to increase customers’
evaluation capability, helping them
to make better informed decisions.
• Providing information which is
easily comparable across different
providers, with clear articulates of
the ‘value of attributes’ a product/
service/feature may hold.
Advice
• Assisting customers in their ability
to appropriately identify the ‘best’
choices and decisions to meet their
‘true’ needs and requirements,
through for example, various filtering
options and client segmentation.
• Enhancing the flexibility and ease
of switching between products
and providers.
• Encouraging the use of advice
services such as ‘MoneyAdvice’ –
the government sponsored
advice service.
How can firms use
behavioural economics?
The implications and practical uses of behavioural economics analysis are wide ranging.
It can be used solely from a compliance perspective, however the greater the extent firms use
it to build a customer-centric culture, the greater the opportunity.
To evidence customer-centricity
through behavioural economic
metrics
To understand the customers’
behavioural traits in existing
products and services,
helping to identify potential
products or services which
may not be in the customers’
best interests
To proactively help customers
make decisions which
support their best interests
To actively understand
customer needs by developing
a deep understanding of
customer behavioural traits
and developing tailored
products and services to aide
better customer outcomes
12. 10 Behavioural economics | Driving better customer outcomes
What can PwC do to help?
The time to act is now
Firms are already beginning to realise
the importance of using behavioural
economics to sustainably keep the
interests of the customer at the centre
of their strategy, and in doing so build
more sustainable organisational
success. The chance remains there for
other firms to take advantage too.
To achieve the greatest benefits from
the use of behavioural economics,
firms should act now to incorporate
behavioural economics across all
functions of the firms. This will give
them advantage in the future
landscape of the financial services. The
regulation change is likely to impact
the industry significantly, and the real
winners will be the firms who didn’t
wait, and took the opportunity whilst it
was there. PwC can help firms make
the most of the opportunity by helping
with the following:
13. 11January 2014
Customer
• Review of sales, marketing, advice
approach and advertising
approaches against behavioural
economic triggers.
• Product review process to identify
whether triggers have been missed
intentionally or unintentionally.
• Detailed customer segmentation
research using conjoint analysis
(customer willingness vs need) to
inform strategy and product/
service offering.
• Developing proposition and pricing
strategies.
• Analysing desired customer
behaviours per product/service.
• Designing ‘smart’ information
disclosures (timely, relevant, simple
and easy to understand).
• Measurement of customer
outcomes.
• Provide tools to educate your
customers on how behavioural
economics influences their
decisions.
Regulation
• Undertaking a behavioural
economic diagnostic across the firm
for regulatory preparation.
• Support in building evidence if
investigated by the regulator.
• Help you to become an exemplar of
best practice in the industry.
Behaviour change
• Facilitate a review of the business
strategy to build customer-centricity
into the heart of organisation
success.
• Identification of the key moments
that matter for driving customer-
centricity.
• Leadership development to
understand and role model
customer-centric behaviours.
• Review and redesign of HR levers
to set expectations, develop and
reward customer-centric
behaviours.
• Training to help relationship teams
get to know your customer, your
products and identify potential
‘exploiting’ scenarios.
• Build on/design regular
organisation wide assessments of
customer-centric culture to drive
continuous improvement.
14. 12 Behavioural economics | Driving better customer outcomes
Julie Coates
UK leader – Financial Services
Risk Regulation Practice
T +44 (0) 20 721 23211
E julie.x.coates@uk.pwc.com
Matthew King
Partner – Financial Services
Risk Regulation Practice –
Conduct Risk Culture
T +44 (0) 20 721 22801
E matthew.king@uk.pwc.com
David Kenmir
Partner – Financial Services
Risk Regulation Practice
Conduct Risk
T +44 (0) 20 780 44794
E david.kenmir@uk.pwc.com
Rachel Collins
Consultant – People and Change
T +44 (0) 20 780 42122
E Rachel.C.Collins@uk.pwc.com
Contacts
15. About us
UK financial services continue to face
significant shifts in the regulatory
environment. These include new FCA
PRA structures; a focus on retail and
wholesale conduct risk as well as
greater supervision and more intensive
and enforced remediation work.
Further afield, new EU regulations and
global agreements enforced in UK are
driving yet more reform of recovery
plans, derivatives, capital liquidity,
regulatory reporting, remuneration
and incentives.
In order to build a resilient position
from which to return value to
stakeholders, organisations must
adjust their approach and attitude
to risk management – the mechanism
by which they can best evaluate the
opportunities and risks of today
and tomorrow.
Our expertise is brought together
in our Financial Services Risk and
Regulation team made up of over
50 partners and 800 professional
staff covering the following areas
of expertise:
Risk Analytics and Prudential
Regulation and Reporting
We help our clients plan for and
implement the changes required to
meet new regulatory requirements. We
offer assistance through the regulatory
lifecycle - assessment of the business
impact of regulatory change, creating
a change portfolio and the associated
implementation. We also provide
guidance on capital, liquidity and
leverage requirements and their
required levels of implementation
support. Throughout this process we
help our clients to evaluate current
risks and their associated business
impact. Where required we assist in
the design and implementation of an
optimised, value driven risk strategy
and framework. We offer assessment
and remediation around risk
architecture and risk-related system
infrastructure and Management
Information, analytics including: credit
risk analytics, risk capital analytics,
data analytics, and business analytics.
Conduct and Culture
We help our clients understand and
implement the changes required by
conduct-related regulation, offering
assistance through the regulatory
lifecycle. This includes assessing the
business impact of regulatory change;
planning and creating a change
portfolio. We perform conduct risk
assessments and existing policy review
(e.g. AML/financial crime/consumer
protection), providing advice and
operational and implementation
support. We also assist with culture
reviews, improvement programmes
and advise on the impact of regulatory
changes on reward and remuneration.
Operational Resilience
To help our clients maximise value
within the parameters of their risk
profile and situation, we offer guidance
and solutions in regards to ‘too big to
fail initiatives’ (including RRP
drafting); regulatory dialogue and
follow up actions and implementation,
including structural and legal changes.
We also provide support on resilience
of control functions (e.g. transaction
processing, payments), internal audit,
structure and efficiency and
governance optimisation.
Redress and Remediation
We support our clients in their efforts
to treat customers fairly, helping them
to ensure compliance with internal and
regulatory requirements. Evolving
regulatory expectation and
requirements means that existing
remediation and redress programmes
often require review or re-calibration,
while new issues continue to emerge.
We help clients across the full lifecycle
of redress and remediation programmes,
helping advise on policy, process and
program design, providing resource to
support the execution of existing and
new programmes, including fully
outsourced solutions, and in addition
provide quality assurance and
monitoring support.