A 44-year-old female with stage IV rectal cancer, bilateral nephrostomy tubes, and a history of DVTs on Eliquis presented with shortness of breath. A CTA showed new large bilateral pleural effusions and ascites, likely malignant. The patient would benefit from a therapeutic thoracentesis to drain the pleural fluid. Thoracentesis is generally safe in patients taking novel oral anticoagulants like Eliquis, with a low risk of major bleeding complications. Individualized management of anticoagulation is important to minimize risks. Validated bleeding risk scores can help guide anticoagulation management for percutaneous procedures.