Improving the value of
examination procurement in
         Sussex


      Tim Strickland
       CEO, FE Sussex
FE Sussex
-value for money procurement from
Awarding Bodies
            Set the context of who we are
            and why we have done this

         Talk about the methodology we used

             Discuss what can be gained

 Suggest successful ways of improving value for money

                 Talk about the future
FE Sussex
 -value for money procurement from
 Awarding Bodies

         “Gentlemen:
            we are
     running out of money”

and yet

     “…(the) finance committee’s
     cases of administrative waste
           and inefficiency                 Winston Churchill, History of WWII, Pg 352 Vol IV
I always study (sic) with great interest”
FE Sussex
The consortium company of the 12 post-sixteen
Sussex colleges
The 12 post-sixteen Sussex colleges

           Total turnover
           £228.21M pa

      Total examination board spend
             £5.1M pa
The 12 post-sixteen Sussex colleges

       Five Sixth Form colleges

  Six General Further Education colleges

     One specialist land-based college
Colleges as businesses

  All colleges are businesses in their
  own right and therefore have
         •Suppliers and customers
         •Business philosophy
         •Business ethic
         Awarding bodies are
         suppliers of services to
         colleges
The efficiency programme

 Our aim

  To improve the value for money we
  receive from the suppliers who provide
  services to our member colleges
What are the pros and cons of
collaborative working?




        Group question
     What are the pros and cons
      of collaborative working?
Collaborative working
 The pros
   Strength
   Ideas
   PRD
   Pulling power
   Success
 The cons
    •Trust – is it truly there?
    •Understanding – who wants what
    •Relationships – take time!
    •External politics – difficult!!
    ……
The efficiency programme

 Question?


  Why has the awarding body agenda come
  to the fore?
             •Government
             •Ofqual
             •Customers
             •Fashion
             •Inefficiency
             •Value for money agenda
What we set out to
   put right!
How we’re doing
Our awarding bodies target savings


10% savings by July 2011
Smarter examination procurement

Group question
        How many awarding bodies
        do you use in your college?

     What is the amount of total spend?
        What is the spread of spend?
How we started the process of value for
money improvement


  Undertook a spend analysis on awarding bodies
              within our consortium
                 What it told us
               What it did not tell us
             The result - a plan of action
Conducting a spend analysis


 Group question
       What will the end result look like?
The results of our spend
analysis-

       An enormous spreadsheet –
      12 rows deep, 59 columns wide


     Maximum spend – minimum spend
Our end result - the format of our spend
   analysis:
                                                                                             Universit
                              British                                                        y of
Name of                       Horse     British                                              Cambrid ABC
College AQA       OCN   OCR   Soc       Council   NCFE   ASDAN   EAL   EDI   EMTA   Lantra   ge ESOL AWARDS

Plumpton
Northbrook
Chichester
CCB
Bhasvic
SDC
SCC
Varndean
Collyers
Worthing
CSC
Bexhill

              0
The results of our spend
analysis-

             18%


                         City and Guilds
                         Edexcel
    57%                  Other
                   25%
The results of our spend analysis

        Knowledge of spend with each awarding body

            Strategic targeting of leading boards

          Realisation of the need to target spending
    An ability to talk with confidence to awarding bodies

   The need to get on our bike and talk to awarding bodies

          Concerns by our colleges over effects on
             teaching, success rates and L&M
FE Sussex
What do we do now?
FE Sussex
What do we do now?


Look to achieve our original aim
          of improving
value for money for our colleges
Improve value for money




     HOW?
FE Sussex
What do we do now?

  By consolidating and targeting our
 business and using the advantages this
              could bring
FE Sussex
What do we do now?

 Approach the largest awarding bodies
                  with
  an offer of a strategic partnership
Group question


  What should a partnership arrangement
                  offer
             - on both sides
What a partnership could offer
Some examples

                Financial gain        Improved efficiency



     Enhanced CPD                         Marketing help


                Financial analysis and assistance
What do we want from an awarding
body?
        Service
        Value for money
        Someone who knows the job
        Someone who takes action
        Accurate and concise
        information
        Ease of contact and
        availability
What’s going to get in the way


  Barriers                Problems

     Obstacles      Stumbling blocks


         Challenges
Suggest five examples of barriers and put
them in rank order!




     Group question
Barriers, challenges, obstacles


From our experience:
        From exams…We don’t need to change
       From curriculum teams…doom and gloom
             Cross college…inertia in planning
          Ignorance of the strategic objective
The results of talking –
Success
      Incentive discounts linked to level of turnover

Value added enhancements such as:
                    Key account managers
            Improved quality assurance assistance
      Speedy turnaround of registrations and certification
                  Early alerting to problems
               Free CPD and staff development

              Sponsorship of award ceremonies
Celebrating the
   achievement of
vocational learners in
        Sussex
Who are they and what did
they say?..




              Nobody said there would be days like this…
(and his aunt said “ you’ll never make a living out of playing a guitar”)
                             The times they are a-changing…
         There wil be fewer peopl to m anage. C olaboration is about
                  l                e                l
         saving costs, both front and curricul areas… l
                                             um        ook around at
         your com petitors… we need to be im aginative and take risks …
         (24.6.1 0, Bloom sbury Hotel– Future of Further Ed ucation)
Future ways of working
for colleges

     Tender   exercises for suppliers of
                qualifications

      Having   preferred suppliers of
      qualifications – from tendering

   Forgingmeaningful and commercially
        advantageous partnerships
The future:
      Rationalisation of the number of
      awarding bodies we deal with
  Formation of two-way strategic alliances
Price reduction and value for money increase
The need to incorporate open and fair competition
          under UK procurement rules
The future:
The introduction of tendering –
driving down costs and increasing service levels

Opportunity to become an awarding body
              Regionally or sub-regionally
FE Sussex




Summary
FE Sussex




Thank you and any questions!

Aoc exam presentation Manchester

  • 1.
    Improving the valueof examination procurement in Sussex Tim Strickland CEO, FE Sussex
  • 2.
    FE Sussex -value formoney procurement from Awarding Bodies Set the context of who we are and why we have done this Talk about the methodology we used Discuss what can be gained Suggest successful ways of improving value for money Talk about the future
  • 3.
    FE Sussex -valuefor money procurement from Awarding Bodies “Gentlemen: we are running out of money” and yet “…(the) finance committee’s cases of administrative waste and inefficiency Winston Churchill, History of WWII, Pg 352 Vol IV I always study (sic) with great interest”
  • 4.
    FE Sussex The consortiumcompany of the 12 post-sixteen Sussex colleges
  • 5.
    The 12 post-sixteenSussex colleges Total turnover £228.21M pa Total examination board spend £5.1M pa
  • 6.
    The 12 post-sixteenSussex colleges Five Sixth Form colleges Six General Further Education colleges One specialist land-based college
  • 7.
    Colleges as businesses All colleges are businesses in their own right and therefore have •Suppliers and customers •Business philosophy •Business ethic Awarding bodies are suppliers of services to colleges
  • 8.
    The efficiency programme Our aim To improve the value for money we receive from the suppliers who provide services to our member colleges
  • 9.
    What are thepros and cons of collaborative working? Group question What are the pros and cons of collaborative working?
  • 10.
    Collaborative working Thepros Strength Ideas PRD Pulling power Success The cons •Trust – is it truly there? •Understanding – who wants what •Relationships – take time! •External politics – difficult!! ……
  • 11.
    The efficiency programme Question? Why has the awarding body agenda come to the fore? •Government •Ofqual •Customers •Fashion •Inefficiency •Value for money agenda
  • 12.
    What we setout to put right!
  • 13.
  • 14.
    Our awarding bodiestarget savings 10% savings by July 2011
  • 15.
    Smarter examination procurement Groupquestion How many awarding bodies do you use in your college? What is the amount of total spend? What is the spread of spend?
  • 16.
    How we startedthe process of value for money improvement Undertook a spend analysis on awarding bodies within our consortium What it told us What it did not tell us The result - a plan of action
  • 17.
    Conducting a spendanalysis Group question What will the end result look like?
  • 18.
    The results ofour spend analysis- An enormous spreadsheet – 12 rows deep, 59 columns wide Maximum spend – minimum spend
  • 19.
    Our end result- the format of our spend analysis: Universit British y of Name of Horse British Cambrid ABC College AQA OCN OCR Soc Council NCFE ASDAN EAL EDI EMTA Lantra ge ESOL AWARDS Plumpton Northbrook Chichester CCB Bhasvic SDC SCC Varndean Collyers Worthing CSC Bexhill 0
  • 20.
    The results ofour spend analysis- 18% City and Guilds Edexcel 57% Other 25%
  • 21.
    The results ofour spend analysis Knowledge of spend with each awarding body Strategic targeting of leading boards Realisation of the need to target spending An ability to talk with confidence to awarding bodies The need to get on our bike and talk to awarding bodies Concerns by our colleges over effects on teaching, success rates and L&M
  • 22.
  • 23.
    FE Sussex What dowe do now? Look to achieve our original aim of improving value for money for our colleges
  • 24.
  • 25.
    FE Sussex What dowe do now? By consolidating and targeting our business and using the advantages this could bring
  • 26.
    FE Sussex What dowe do now? Approach the largest awarding bodies with an offer of a strategic partnership
  • 27.
    Group question What should a partnership arrangement offer - on both sides
  • 28.
    What a partnershipcould offer Some examples Financial gain Improved efficiency Enhanced CPD Marketing help Financial analysis and assistance
  • 29.
    What do wewant from an awarding body? Service Value for money Someone who knows the job Someone who takes action Accurate and concise information Ease of contact and availability
  • 30.
    What’s going toget in the way Barriers Problems Obstacles Stumbling blocks Challenges
  • 31.
    Suggest five examplesof barriers and put them in rank order! Group question
  • 32.
    Barriers, challenges, obstacles Fromour experience: From exams…We don’t need to change From curriculum teams…doom and gloom Cross college…inertia in planning Ignorance of the strategic objective
  • 33.
    The results oftalking – Success Incentive discounts linked to level of turnover Value added enhancements such as: Key account managers Improved quality assurance assistance Speedy turnaround of registrations and certification Early alerting to problems Free CPD and staff development Sponsorship of award ceremonies
  • 34.
    Celebrating the achievement of vocational learners in Sussex
  • 35.
    Who are theyand what did they say?.. Nobody said there would be days like this… (and his aunt said “ you’ll never make a living out of playing a guitar”) The times they are a-changing… There wil be fewer peopl to m anage. C olaboration is about l e l saving costs, both front and curricul areas… l um ook around at your com petitors… we need to be im aginative and take risks … (24.6.1 0, Bloom sbury Hotel– Future of Further Ed ucation)
  • 36.
    Future ways ofworking for colleges Tender exercises for suppliers of qualifications Having preferred suppliers of qualifications – from tendering Forgingmeaningful and commercially advantageous partnerships
  • 37.
    The future: Rationalisation of the number of awarding bodies we deal with Formation of two-way strategic alliances Price reduction and value for money increase The need to incorporate open and fair competition under UK procurement rules
  • 38.
    The future: The introductionof tendering – driving down costs and increasing service levels Opportunity to become an awarding body Regionally or sub-regionally
  • 39.
  • 40.
    FE Sussex Thank youand any questions!