SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 18
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
1
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
AMST 190
3/17/13
Identity Formation and the Cinema
Throughout America’s history, there has come a tendency to create an “us vs.
them” mentality toward each incoming new group of people. The need for
compartmentalizing people based on their identity comes from the initial insecurities
faced by Americans who do not have a core foundational identity. While the issue of the
need for categorizing people based on their national identity reached a peak during the
Ellis Island migrations, the momentum had started years before, and continued
throughout history to modern society, evolving and changing as the social status of the
immigrant changed as well. The focus of this paper is the role that nationality plays in the
creation of identity, and how the cinema portrays the evolution of immigrant identity,
specifically European immigrants, throughout the generations as seen in The Godfather
and Gangs of New York.
In order to understand the importance of identity within spectrum of immigrants,
we first must look at the importance of identity formation in general, along with the
purpose and necessity of identities within society. Throughout the years, identity has
become the key factor in defining a person, which can be problematic when constantly
shifting societies are what dictate the shifts in identity formation; there has been research
that “links identity shifts to historical cultural configurations, arguing that certain
character types are encouraged by cultures through differential socialization practices”1.
1
Howard,Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." Annual Reviewof Scoiology. Vol. 26. N.p.:
Annual Reviews, 200. 367-93. JSTOR. Web. Pg. 373.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
2
As society evolves and expands, so does the spectrum of subcategories that make up the
general components of the meaning of identity, and greatly affect identity formation.
Recently, there have been theorists that have started to argue that with all of the shifting
and changing in societies, especially cross-culturally, the concept of identity has been
assigned with too many different meanings, and it has now “ceased to be meaningful”2.
Although the concept of identity is socially constructed and the meaning has
arguably been stretched thin over the years, there are still psychological reasoning as to
why this construct has been a part of society for so many years, and why it is still
extremely important when understanding society and individuals. Social psychologists
have studied the human psyche, and have developed a theory related to social cognition,
which is the way in which we store and process information3. With the amount of stimuli
in our surrounding world, we as individuals feel as if we must categorize, organize, and
compartmentalize all of these different components in order to make sense of them.
Components of this method to understanding are the self and group schemas we create.
Self-schemas allow us to understand ourselves and our place within society through the
lens of how we are seen in society, based on general group schemas. Group schemas are
essentially stereotypes that we use to understand and compartmentalize different large
groups of people that are connected by an individual commonality, which we then assign
onto all members of said group. With all of the information that we have to intake and
organize, it is easier for us as humans to generalize people and ideas in this manner,
rather than critically assess on an individual basis.
2
Sokefeld, Martin. "Reconsidering Identity." Anthropos (2001): 527-44. Jstor. Web
3
Howard,Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." pg. 368.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
3
The issues surrounding identity have become exceedingly problematic due to the
fact that “when societies were more stable, identity was to a great extent assigned, rather
than selected or adopted. In current times, however, the concept of identity carries the full
weight of the need for a sense of who one is, together with an often overwhelming pace
of change in the surrounding social contexts – changes in the groups and networks in
which people and their identities are embedded”4. Previously in society, such as when
“8.8 million [immigrants] admitted during the 1910’s [were] predominately from
Europe”, identities were assigned to individuals by the populous of society5. At the time,
immigration and the “threat” of national identity towards the Americans influenced the
social norm of identifying people using their nationality as the foundation of their identity
formation. This allowed for the Americans to create a hierarchy in their society based on
these said identities, as well as implement a strict “us vs. them” mentality that
unfortunately continues to exist. The affects of the power of society dictated identity can
be seen clearly in Gangs of New York, which focuses on the divide in New York between
Americans and the incoming swarm of Irish immigrants. Everyone, regardless of age,
sex, or class, will ultimately be identified as either American or Irish, and more
importantly, either American or not American. The process of identity formation
changed over that long period of time, however nationality and ethnicity still are an
extremely significant factor. Studies have shown that ethnic identities are made up of “a
sense of belonging, attitudes toward one’s own ethnic group, social participation, and
cultural practices”, which are determinant on the social climate, and fluctuate throughout
4
Howard,Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." pg. 367
5 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and
Children of Immigrants." Annual Reviewof Sociology 23.1 (1997): 63-95. Print.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
4
the years6. Because identity isn’t assigned in the same manner as it used to be, people are
able to identify themselves by ways other than their nationality. However, since
nationality and ethnicity are still prominent factors, people often feel as if they must over
identify with other aspects of their life and completely dismiss their nationality, as
depicted thoroughly in The Godfather, through Michael’s continuous struggles between
his American and Italian identity.
The subject of identity is a central issue and theme within the films Gangs of New
York and The Godfather. Gangs of New York, directed by Martin Scorsese, places
Leonardo DiCaprio as a young Irish man in 1863, set on avenging his fathers murder
committed by the American, Bill the Butcher. The opening scene depicts a bloody battle
between the Irish and the Americans, who also called themselves the Nativists, in a war
fueled by ethnic and religious identity conflicts. Put this film in contrast with Francis
Ford Coppola’s classic, The Godfather, in which he vividly depicts the hybrid of old-
country culture and assimilated American culture, and the struggles that accompany both.
Vito Corleone, played by Marlon Brando, is an Italian immigrant who came to America,
establishes a name for himself as a mob boss through the 1940s, and attempts to engage
his son Michael, played by Al Pacino, with the rest of the family. Michael initially resists
his Italian identity and family, by attempting to assimilate to the American culture, and
establish himself with an American identity. It is of vital importance to look towards the
cinema when addressing social and cultural issues, such as the one at hand. Historically,
films have been used as a form of social commentary, documenting our society in ways
6 Howard, Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." pg. 374
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
5
in which we can compartmentalize and understand complicated themes and situations7.
The cinema takes these complicated issues and creates a face and a storyline that we can
connect to, as well as identify with on a personal level. While these films address issues
that seemingly happened years ago in America’s past, the popularity and infamy that they
still hold to this day prove that the subject of identity is still one that is continuously
struggled with, and is relevant in our modern society. These films have transcended the
screen and have become a part of our American culture. They have been reappropriated
many times throughout film, television, and other media outlets, which then continue to
press the importance of the subject matter addressed in these story lines. While the
characters and stories may be fictional, the troubles surrounding the themes of identity
are very real, and therefore can be used when academically and critically discussing these
conflicts.
A component of the struggle with identity that can be seen both in the cinema, as
well as in historical context, is the societal assignment of identity that was previously
discussed. When individuals were identified by one particular aspect of themselves,
especially one that did not hold much flexibility in the eyes of society, it became nearly
impossible from them to transcend their dictated placement, and as a result, these
individuals were forced to either adapt to life as a second class citizens, or be forced to
attempt to assimilate as much as they possibly could. Because of the oppressive structure
of identity formation, even assimilation could never make a person truly America in the
eyes of many. Since the beginning of its creation, America has been a country that has
been foundationally based on assimilation, primarily due to the fact that it never had a
7 Harker, Jonathan. ": Film: An Anthology . Daniel Talbot." Film Quarterly 13.3 (1960): n. pag.
Print.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
6
distinct culture to call its own. The lack of a hegemonic American culture lead to the
need of separation of Americans, or the Nativists, from ‘non-Americans’, especially
when immigrants began arriving to America in waves. When Irish immigrants started
rapidly appearing in America, the Americans felt the need to separate themselves from
the immigrants and hold on to their American identity, creating an ‘us vs. them’ mentality
through the land.
While many immigrants were automatically categorized as second-class citizens,
none felt this harsh reality more than the Irish. In the beginning, “’to be called an
‘Irishman’ had come to be nearly as great an insult as to be called a ‘nigger’.’”8 The Irish
were looked down upon, and put on the same plateau as the black slaves in America, to
such an extent that on the census, “it was by no means clear that the Irish were white” for
the Irish were kept as a separate race altogether9. This can clearly be seen in one of the
lesser prominent scenes in Gangs of New York, where a seemingly insignificant
conversation between two of the main characters actually sums up the entire social
commentary of the film itself. Jim Broadbent’s character, William “Boss” Tweed,
converses with Daniel Day-Lewis’ character, known as Bill “The Butcher” Cutting, down
by the docs, where The Butcher has gathered his Nativist men to berate and intimidate the
new shipments of Irish that are streaming in to the city. The individuals getting of the
ship seem broken and frightened, as the women shuffle along with the children and the
men head directly to the politicians who are enlisting them to fight the war of a country in
which they just arrived, in order to prove their loyalty. William, an avid politician
8
Roediger, David R. The Wages of Whiteness: Irish-American Workers and White Racial
Formation in the AntebellumUnited States. NewYork. Print.
9 Roediger, David R. The Wages of Whiteness: Irish-American Workersand White Racial
Formation in the AntebellumUnited States.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
7
himself, approaches Bill and tries to reason with him by telling him that the Irish are
actually important to use in the future for voting numbers. Bill replies that voting is an
American right, and then continues to state, “I don’t see no Americans, I see trespassers.
Irish harps do a job for a nickel a nigger would do for a dime, what a man used to get a
quarter for”10. Bill’s statement not only shows the animosity for immigrants like the
Irish, but it also shows their standing in society in relation to the black slaves. He sees
the immigrants not only as a threat to his fragile American identity, but on his economy
as well, and classifies these people as second-class citizens along with the slaves,
regardless of the fact that he is standing directly next to the Irish men that are signing up
for the war to fight for his beloved country, merely because they were Irish. It was
sentiments such as this that made it impossible for people to transcend their identities and
become someone or something other than their nationality.
However, change did come in time in the form of assimilation. Since the Irish
were placed in the same social classification as Blacks were, they were also often in the
same economical classification as well, and were going after the same jobs that Black
people were, especially since their lack of skill, kept them “at the bottom of white
society”11. Originally, the two communities were civil and sociable, however, when
devastation and war struck America, the Irish immigrants were among the first to demand
“an ‘all-white warfront’, rid of Blacks altogether” as a method of “ensuring their own
survival”12. For the black slaves, “assimilation was believed to be largely unattainable
10
Gangs of New York. Dir. Martin Scorsese. Perf. Leonardo DiCaprio, Daniel Day- Lewis,
Cameron Diaz. 20th Century FOx, 2002. DVD. Time:1:10
11 Roediger, David R. Working Towards Whiteness. Pg 145.
12
Roediger, David R. The Wages of Whiteness: Irish-American Workers and White Racial
Formation in the AntebellumUnited States. NewYork. Print.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
8
and therefore not a source of concern” to the white Irish men who believed that this was
their opportunity to become more white, which was, at the time, synonymous for being
more American13. This was the catalyst for the Irish immigrants; they assimilated and
created their own identity as not only Americans, but also White Americans.
As it can be seen through these examples, there is a clear irony to the formation of
American identity. With each incoming group of immigrants, an American identity can
be established just by being more American than the group before. It is important,
however, to note the fact that while this was a small, although unsettling, success for the
Irish toward forming an American identity, “acculturation did not necessarily lead to
other forms of integration into the host society […] ethnic groups would remain
distinguished from on another depending largely on the degree to which groups gained
the acceptance of the dominant population”14. This essentially means that while the Irish
felt assimilated into their American identities socially, it did not necessarily guaranteed
them the equality and rights of American citizens, and their acceptance was completely
determined by the popular opinion of the current society, which fluctuated and evolved
over the years.
The irony in this is that technically, and theoretically, those that created this
oppressive and subjective system, where once immigrants as well. The white settlers that
deemed themselves Americans, the Nativists, originated from England when their
ancestors came to America, yet they believed that they were able to dictate what is a
socially acceptable American identity to the rest of society. It is type of thinking that
13 Higham, John. Approaches to American Immigration and Ethnic History: The Problem
of Assimilation in the United States. (Cengage Learning, 1998)
14 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and
Children of Immigrants." Pg. 71.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
9
causes a rotational continuation of flawed identity formation, and creates the many
conflictions that people face when creating their own individual identities, as well as their
group schemas surrounding other nationalities.
Despite the historical truths that make up the irony of American identity, many
Americans continued to ostracize and degrade those from other nations, and
compartmentalized them into tiny inflexible identities solely based on their nationalities.
While it seems unjust and repressive, there were some immigrants who remained tied to
their nationalities, and because migrating uprooted them from their original homes and
cultures, they were therefore forced to find new ways to hold onto their culture once
entered in a new land. For the European immigrants, once in America each individual
handled the transition differently; “only those who were capable of adjusting from
peasant ways to the needs of new conditions and new challenges were able to absorb the
successive shocks of migration”, and those who weren’t able to get a grasp on their new
reality, suffered from “loneliness, separation from the community of the village, and
despair at the insignificance of their own human abilities”15. For those who did want to
assimilate, and instead chose to stand by their national identity with pride, adaptation
became the only way to be able to cope with the uprooting for many migrants. An
important factor of the adapting was creating a society that was familiar and made the
new country feel more like home by maintaining their ties to their home countries. Many
learned to achieve this in subtle ways, such as continuing to speak their native language
15
Handlin, Oscar. Major Problems in American Immigration and Ethnic History:Approaches to
American Immigration and Ethnic History. Ed. Jon Gjerde. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1998.
Print.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
10
and combining their language with English, importing books from their homeland, and
continuing their own traditions 16.
This pride and adaption are two themes that are seen strongly in both of the films
this paper is discussing. In Gangs of New York, Five Points, the name of the sector the
main characters live, was a niche for the Irish immigrants, and each different area of New
York was segregated based on the identity of the people that live there. Like many other
immigrants that have come to America over the years, they divided the cities into varying
burros in order to surround themselves with people they identified with. This was also
seen in The Godfather. Through the lens of an organized crime family, the movie depicts
the more embedded issues of assimilation, in relationship to the strong need for
traditional values and customs. Throughout the movie, the importance of loyalty, family,
and traditional Italian manners are displayed as a centerpiece for he rest of the story. It
clearly shows the importance of remaining connected to heritage and culture, no matter
how far from home they are, and the pride they continue to feel when identifying by their
nationality.
While some immigrants held fast to their assigned identities, many struggled with
the concept, and instead decided that they would rather assimilate and identify as an
American. As demonstrated previously, America is a nation that was founded on the
ideals of assimilation, due to the fact that there originally was no distinct American
culture. The process of conformity and assimilation is one that began with the very first
immigrants, and still continues to this day. However, the motivations behind assimilation
have evolved from an idea forced upon by an external oppressor, to a voluntary concept
16
Franklin, Benjamin. Language Loyalties: A Source Book on the Official English
Controversy:The German Language in Pennsylvania. Ed. James Crawford. Chicago:University
of Chicago, 1992. Print.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
11
that has been internalized over the course of many generations. As stated by assimilation
theorists:
Distinctive ethnic traits such as old cultural ways, native
languages, or ethnic enclaves are sources of disadvantages
that negatively affect assimilation […] although complete
acculturation to the dominant American culture may not
ensure all immigrants full social participation in the host
society, immigrants must free themselves from their old
cultures in order to begin rising up from marginal positions
[…] [It was] anticipated, nevertheless, that ethnic
minorities would eventually lose all their distinctive
characteristics and cease to exist as ethnic groups as they
pass through the stages of assimilation.17
While it is clear that the latter argument of total ethnic annihilation did not
happen, nor will happen any time in the immediate future, the attitude behind the
negative affects toward assimilation generated the foundation of the mentality on creating
an American identity. To many of these immigrants, being able to achieve an American
identity meant that they had to completely dismiss their original national identity, and
rather than going to one extreme end of the spectrum with submerging themselves in their
own culture to adapt, they went in the other direction and denounced all parts of their
original heritage. This type of assimilation was most often seen by second generation of
immigrants, or the children of immigrants. In The Godfather, arguably the most
interesting and complex storyline in the movie is that of Vito’s son, Michael Corleone,
who distances himself from his family at a younger age. Wanting to put as much space
between himself and his family’s lifestyle, Michael does everything in his power to
17 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and
Children of Immigrants." Pg. 71.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
12
assimilate, and identify as an American, rather than an Italian. He joins the army,
became an American soldier, and chooses to be involved with an American woman,
rather than an Italian woman, or even Italian American woman. We are first introduced to
Michael at the beginning of the film during a wedding celebration for his sister at his
father’s estate. It is made clear that Vito values Michael because he refuses to take the
family picture before he arrives, which enforces his heavy familial values. However
when Michael shows up, he is late, dressed in uniform, and with his white American
girlfriend. While he loves his family, he clearly stands out from the boisterous group of
Italian men and women that fill the celebration. In a particular scene, Michael and Kay
Adams, his girlfriend, are listening to Johnny Fontane, a famous singer who is
performing at the wedding. Kay asks Michael how the family knows Johnny, and this
conversation follows:
Michael: Well, when Johnny was first starting out, he was
signed to a personal services contract with this big-band
leader. And as his career got better and better, he wanted to
get out of it. But the bandleader wouldn’t let him. Now,
Johnny is my father’s godson. SO my father went to see
this bandleader and offered him $10,000 to let Johnny go,
but the bandleader said no. SO the next day, my father went
back, only this time with Luca Brasi. Within an hour, he
had a signed release for a certified check of $1,000.
Kay Adams: How did he do that?
Michael: My father made him an offer he couldn’t refuse
[…] Luca Brasi held a gun to his head, and my father
assured him that either his brains or his signature would be
on the contract.
(Kay is silent and stares at Michael)
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
13
Michael: That’s a true story […] That’s my family Kay,
that’s not me.18
It is clear that Michaels struggle is not just one of heritage, but of morality as
well, however these two issues are largely intertwined throughout the film. As discussed
earlier, society often dictates the way in which different identities, specifically ethnic
ones, are perceived by the general populous by the usage of group schemas. A common
stereotype that derived from this time period during the 1940’s was the correlation of
Italian immigrants and illegal activities. As demonstrated by the previous quote,
Michael’s attempt to assimilate into an American identity is done so by separating
himself not only culturally, but from the other components that make up his family as
well. Because mobster and Italian identity were synonyms at the time, he denounces the
acts of his family and instead takes on a law-abiding job and other American attributes in
order to solidify his identity as American. This way of thinking does change throughout
the movie, however it is interesting to view the initial foundation of what Michael
believed an American identity was conceived of.
These films focus on issues in society that are not just historic, but relevant in our
current society as well. The affects of societies impact on identity formation within the
immigrant community can still be seen to this day in the urban infrastructure and
communities around America. Much like the New York that Five Points inhabited in
Gangs of New York, urban centers such as New York and San Francisco that were major
18 The Godfather. Dir. Francis Ford Coppola. Prod. Francis Ford Coppola. By Francis Ford
Coppola and Mario Puzo. Perf. Al Pacino, Robert Duvall, Diane Keaton, and Niro Robert De.
Paramount Pictures, 1974. DVD.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
14
ports of immigration continue to show the affects of the divided cities of the past19. The
separation mentality and compartmentalization of different national identities in society,
and the massive movements of adaptation, lead to segregation of many urban areas,
which still exist today. The creation of places such as China Town, Japan Town, and
Little Italy not only creates an ethnic and national divide within the urban ecosystem, but
it also continues to perpetuate the “othering” of people based on their identities. While it
is essential that people are able to live in communities with those whom have similar
traditions and values, it also keeps the urban areas of immigration, along with the
mentality of many Americans, stagnant and un-evolved, which in turn continues the cycle
of an ironic and subjective formation of American identities.
Even more important to the issue of modern day impact of historical identity
formation struggles, is the impact on the next generation: the children of the immigrants.
Children of immigrants have often times been overlooked during the study of identity
formation, however it has been found that these individuals often suffer from more
societal conflict in this area than their parents. Even in the 1940’s, children like Michael
felt torn between their family and cultural origins, with the want to assimilate and
identify as America, and that struggle continues to this day.
The focus on children and assimilation comes from the fact that “differing from
their immigrant parents, immigrant children and children of immigrants lack meaningful
connections to their ‘old’ world. They are thus unlikely to consider a foreign country as a
place to return to or as a point of reference. They instead are prone to evaluate themselves
19 Jimenez, Tomas R. Assessing Immigrant Assimilation:New Empirical and Theoretical Challenges.
Annual Review of Scoiology.By Mary C. Waters. Vol. 31. N.p.: AnnualReviews, 2005. 105-25. JSTOR.
Web.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
15
or to be evaluated by others by the standards of their new country”20. Like Michael,
children of immigrants often don’t have the same connection to the homeland that their
parents do. For example, “in the United States, immigrant children often become
Americanized so quickly that their parents cannot keep up with them. There is a fear in
the older generation that their children will leave them, become like other American
youth, and forget about their roots”21. These children assimilate quickly because they
often do not have a strong connection with the homeland like their elder families do,
however their families often times don’t understand this fact, and this gap of
understanding creates even more identity conflict and familial pressure, often times
driving the kids away, such as Michael was in the start of The Godfather.
In addition to the familial pressure that this second generation feels, society as a
whole has a great influence in the conflict faced by these individuals. As it has been seen
time and time again through this analysis of identity formation, it is clear that society
plays a large role in dictating our identities, especially ones based on nationality and
ethnicity. As was seen with the Irish immigrants, attempts to assimilate often failed, and
it was ultimately the American society that determined whether or not the Irish had
successfully been deemed American, and this trend continues to this day. Due to this,
this second generation is caught in a binding conflict of identity; they are identified by
their origin nationality by the dominant populous of society, however they themselves
don’t have any connection with their home countries. This conflict leads to a lot of
confusion and questioning within this group of people, as to who they really are. This
20 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and
Children of Immigrants." Pg. 64.
21 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and
Children of Immigrants." Pg. 83.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
16
question creates conflict within the individuals, and as a result, leads to “a growing
‘oppositional culture’ among young Americans, especially among those who have felt
oppressed and excluded from the American mainstream […] immigrant children have
confronted a reality in their host society where their ascribed physical features may
become a handicap”22. These second generation individuals are feeling the affects of
society dictated identity formation first hand, and it is apparent that while our culture has
evolved in a lot of ways, it has stayed the same in many ways as well. In this instance,
the only thing that has evolved is the way that the individuals react toward the society;
instead of adapting and accepting their assigned identities, the lack of connection to their
homeland makes them confused and aggressive against the dominant views of society.
It is evident that the issues surrounding identity formation are far from historic;
they are happening here and now within our society, with new incoming immigrants from
many different countries more and more each year. These people continue to fight the
dominant society creating inflexible identities for them, just as they used to when it was
only the Irish coming in mass numbers. As it can be seen throughout this analysis, the
importance and relevance of the two movies chosen as references to this social issue is
also still apparent in modern society. These movies have transcended the cinema as a
part of our popular culture, and continue to express stories and underlying themes that
people still identify with to this day. They depict the very real shift of immigrant identity
from adaption to assimilation, and can be used as tools in not only understanding our
history as an immigrant nation, full of insecurity in our own identities, but also
understanding our current society, and how we got to where we are today. The only way
22 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and
Children of Immigrants." Pg. 69&76.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
17
that we will be able to change the oppression and conflict that often accompanies
immigrant identity formation is to understand our past, and learn how to change it and
break the seemingly never ending cycle.
Rebekah Espino-Drobner
18
Bibliography
Franklin, Benjamin. Language Loyalties: A Source Book on the Official English
Controversy:The German Language in Pennsylvania. Ed. James Crawford. Chicago:
University of Chicago, 1992. Print.
Gangs of New York. Dir. Martin Scorsese. Perf. Leonardo DiCaprio, Daniel Day-
Lewis, Cameron Diaz. 20th Century Fox, 2002. DVD. Time:1:10
The Godfather. Dir. Francis Ford Coppola. Prod. Francis Ford Coppola. By
Francis Ford Coppola and Mario Puzo. Perf. Al Pacino, Robert Duvall, Diane Keaton,
and Niro Robert De. Paramount Pictures, 1974. DVD.
Harker, Jonathan. ": Film: An Anthology . Daniel Talbot." Film Quarterly 13.3
(1960): n. pag. Print.
Higham, John. Approaches to American Immigration and Ethnic History: The
Problem of Assimilation in the United States. (Cengage Learning, 1998)
Howard, Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." Annual Review of Scoiology.
Vol. 26. N.p.: Annual Reviews, 200. 367-93. JSTOR. Web. Pg. 373.
Jimenez, Tomas R. Assessing Immigrant Assimilation: New Empirical and
Theoretical Challenges. Annual Review of Scoiology. By Mary C. Waters. Vol. 31. N.p.:
Annual Reviews, 2005. 105-25. JSTOR. Web.
Roediger, David R. The Wages of Whiteness: Irish-American Workers and White
Racial Formation in the Antebellum United States. New York. Print.
Roediger, David R. Working Towards Whiteness. New York: Basic, 2005. Print.
Pg 145.
Sokefeld, Martin. "Reconsidering Identity." Anthropos (2001): 527-44. Jstor.
Web
Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant
Children and Children of Immigrants." Annual Review of Sociology 23.1 (1997): 63-95.
Print.

More Related Content

What's hot

Lesson 9 - Ethnicity
Lesson 9 - EthnicityLesson 9 - Ethnicity
Lesson 9 - EthnicityElle Sullivan
 
Youth collective identity
Youth collective identityYouth collective identity
Youth collective identityJaneen Gatty
 
Terminology quiz
Terminology quizTerminology quiz
Terminology quizAndy Wallis
 
Media and Collective - Young People
Media and Collective - Young PeopleMedia and Collective - Young People
Media and Collective - Young Peoplejphibbert1979
 
Laura Grindstaff: Culture and Popular Culture
Laura Grindstaff: Culture and Popular CultureLaura Grindstaff: Culture and Popular Culture
Laura Grindstaff: Culture and Popular CultureDustin Kidd
 
Individuality, Class
Individuality, ClassIndividuality, Class
Individuality, ClassMr. Benson
 
MEDIA & COLLECTIVE IDENTITY: How do the contemporary media represent collecti...
MEDIA & COLLECTIVE IDENTITY: How do the contemporary media represent collecti...MEDIA & COLLECTIVE IDENTITY: How do the contemporary media represent collecti...
MEDIA & COLLECTIVE IDENTITY: How do the contemporary media represent collecti...Belinda Raji
 
Gender communication and media
Gender communication and mediaGender communication and media
Gender communication and mediaYekaterina Godes
 
Representation of youth theories
Representation of youth theoriesRepresentation of youth theories
Representation of youth theoriesEllieBeazley
 
Representation within media
Representation within mediaRepresentation within media
Representation within mediaConnorevansmedia
 
INT-460 Critical Social Theory
INT-460 Critical Social TheoryINT-460 Critical Social Theory
INT-460 Critical Social TheoryS Meyer
 
Collective identity youth
Collective identity   youthCollective identity   youth
Collective identity youthCat Davies
 
Rhet & Citiz Final Exam
Rhet & Citiz Final ExamRhet & Citiz Final Exam
Rhet & Citiz Final ExamKRISTIKATE
 

What's hot (19)

Lesson 9 - Ethnicity
Lesson 9 - EthnicityLesson 9 - Ethnicity
Lesson 9 - Ethnicity
 
Collectiveidentity youth
Collectiveidentity youthCollectiveidentity youth
Collectiveidentity youth
 
Youth collective identity
Youth collective identityYouth collective identity
Youth collective identity
 
23rd april
23rd april23rd april
23rd april
 
Terminology quiz
Terminology quizTerminology quiz
Terminology quiz
 
Media and Collective - Young People
Media and Collective - Young PeopleMedia and Collective - Young People
Media and Collective - Young People
 
Portrait identity
Portrait identityPortrait identity
Portrait identity
 
Laura Grindstaff: Culture and Popular Culture
Laura Grindstaff: Culture and Popular CultureLaura Grindstaff: Culture and Popular Culture
Laura Grindstaff: Culture and Popular Culture
 
Individuality, Class
Individuality, ClassIndividuality, Class
Individuality, Class
 
MEDIA & COLLECTIVE IDENTITY: How do the contemporary media represent collecti...
MEDIA & COLLECTIVE IDENTITY: How do the contemporary media represent collecti...MEDIA & COLLECTIVE IDENTITY: How do the contemporary media represent collecti...
MEDIA & COLLECTIVE IDENTITY: How do the contemporary media represent collecti...
 
Gender communication and media
Gender communication and mediaGender communication and media
Gender communication and media
 
Theorist cards.docx
Theorist cards.docxTheorist cards.docx
Theorist cards.docx
 
Representation of youth theories
Representation of youth theoriesRepresentation of youth theories
Representation of youth theories
 
Representation within media
Representation within mediaRepresentation within media
Representation within media
 
INT-460 Critical Social Theory
INT-460 Critical Social TheoryINT-460 Critical Social Theory
INT-460 Critical Social Theory
 
Collective identity youth
Collective identity   youthCollective identity   youth
Collective identity youth
 
Theory cads
Theory cadsTheory cads
Theory cads
 
MediaFilmExchange.co.uk Powerpoint
MediaFilmExchange.co.uk PowerpointMediaFilmExchange.co.uk Powerpoint
MediaFilmExchange.co.uk Powerpoint
 
Rhet & Citiz Final Exam
Rhet & Citiz Final ExamRhet & Citiz Final Exam
Rhet & Citiz Final Exam
 

Viewers also liked

Omega European Masters preview
Omega European Masters previewOmega European Masters preview
Omega European Masters previewmahajohn299
 
Dawn Hood New Resume
Dawn Hood New ResumeDawn Hood New Resume
Dawn Hood New ResumeDawn Hood
 
ಎಲ್ಲವೂ ಒಂದೊಂದು ಕಕ್ಸೆಯಲ್ಲಿ (ಫಲಕ್'ನಲ್ಲಿ) ತೇಲುತ್ತಿವೆ
ಎಲ್ಲವೂ ಒಂದೊಂದು ಕಕ್ಸೆಯಲ್ಲಿ (ಫಲಕ್'ನಲ್ಲಿ) ತೇಲುತ್ತಿವೆಎಲ್ಲವೂ ಒಂದೊಂದು ಕಕ್ಸೆಯಲ್ಲಿ (ಫಲಕ್'ನಲ್ಲಿ) ತೇಲುತ್ತಿವೆ
ಎಲ್ಲವೂ ಒಂದೊಂದು ಕಕ್ಸೆಯಲ್ಲಿ (ಫಲಕ್'ನಲ್ಲಿ) ತೇಲುತ್ತಿವೆFAHIM AKTHAR ULLAL
 
Yang mo di upload
Yang mo di uploadYang mo di upload
Yang mo di uploadUkhti EvHa
 
Perkembangan Alat Hitung
Perkembangan Alat HitungPerkembangan Alat Hitung
Perkembangan Alat Hitungtitirosmawati09
 
Revital vision кратко для пациента
Revital vision кратко для пациентаRevital vision кратко для пациента
Revital vision кратко для пациентаOleksii Sologub
 
161002 日本編集者学会セミナー「信州と出版文化」
161002 日本編集者学会セミナー「信州と出版文化」161002 日本編集者学会セミナー「信州と出版文化」
161002 日本編集者学会セミナー「信州と出版文化」Kenya Hiraga
 
Maneesh seminar- infection control
Maneesh seminar- infection controlManeesh seminar- infection control
Maneesh seminar- infection controlManeesh Ahammed Syed
 
14 picasso
14 picasso14 picasso
14 picassogorbea
 
salesforce online training || salesforce training videos || salesforce develo...
salesforce online training || salesforce training videos || salesforce develo...salesforce online training || salesforce training videos || salesforce develo...
salesforce online training || salesforce training videos || salesforce develo...United Trainings
 

Viewers also liked (16)

Omega European Masters preview
Omega European Masters previewOmega European Masters preview
Omega European Masters preview
 
Deontologia del abogado trabajo
Deontologia del abogado trabajoDeontologia del abogado trabajo
Deontologia del abogado trabajo
 
Dawn Hood New Resume
Dawn Hood New ResumeDawn Hood New Resume
Dawn Hood New Resume
 
ಎಲ್ಲವೂ ಒಂದೊಂದು ಕಕ್ಸೆಯಲ್ಲಿ (ಫಲಕ್'ನಲ್ಲಿ) ತೇಲುತ್ತಿವೆ
ಎಲ್ಲವೂ ಒಂದೊಂದು ಕಕ್ಸೆಯಲ್ಲಿ (ಫಲಕ್'ನಲ್ಲಿ) ತೇಲುತ್ತಿವೆಎಲ್ಲವೂ ಒಂದೊಂದು ಕಕ್ಸೆಯಲ್ಲಿ (ಫಲಕ್'ನಲ್ಲಿ) ತೇಲುತ್ತಿವೆ
ಎಲ್ಲವೂ ಒಂದೊಂದು ಕಕ್ಸೆಯಲ್ಲಿ (ಫಲಕ್'ನಲ್ಲಿ) ತೇಲುತ್ತಿವೆ
 
Yang mo di upload
Yang mo di uploadYang mo di upload
Yang mo di upload
 
презентация1
презентация1презентация1
презентация1
 
C after correction
C after correctionC after correction
C after correction
 
Environmental catalyst, Methanol Synthesizer Catalyst, IDM8
Environmental catalyst, Methanol Synthesizer Catalyst, IDM8Environmental catalyst, Methanol Synthesizer Catalyst, IDM8
Environmental catalyst, Methanol Synthesizer Catalyst, IDM8
 
Perkembangan Alat Hitung
Perkembangan Alat HitungPerkembangan Alat Hitung
Perkembangan Alat Hitung
 
Revital vision кратко для пациента
Revital vision кратко для пациентаRevital vision кратко для пациента
Revital vision кратко для пациента
 
Control structure
Control structureControl structure
Control structure
 
161002 日本編集者学会セミナー「信州と出版文化」
161002 日本編集者学会セミナー「信州と出版文化」161002 日本編集者学会セミナー「信州と出版文化」
161002 日本編集者学会セミナー「信州と出版文化」
 
Maneesh seminar- infection control
Maneesh seminar- infection controlManeesh seminar- infection control
Maneesh seminar- infection control
 
14 picasso
14 picasso14 picasso
14 picasso
 
Arte Paleocristiano
Arte PaleocristianoArte Paleocristiano
Arte Paleocristiano
 
salesforce online training || salesforce training videos || salesforce develo...
salesforce online training || salesforce training videos || salesforce develo...salesforce online training || salesforce training videos || salesforce develo...
salesforce online training || salesforce training videos || salesforce develo...
 

Similar to AMST paper

Essay On Fences By August Wilson
Essay On Fences By August WilsonEssay On Fences By August Wilson
Essay On Fences By August WilsonSarah Peterson
 
G325 - Collective identity:youth
G325 - Collective identity:youthG325 - Collective identity:youth
G325 - Collective identity:youthCat Davies
 
Collective identity youth
Collective identity   youthCollective identity   youth
Collective identity youthCat Davies
 
College Essay Writers
College Essay WritersCollege Essay Writers
College Essay WritersAmy Moore
 
2.3. Empowerment (Quiz)
2.3. Empowerment (Quiz)2.3. Empowerment (Quiz)
2.3. Empowerment (Quiz)Øyvind Kalnes
 
Examples Of Poetry Analysis Essays
Examples Of Poetry Analysis EssaysExamples Of Poetry Analysis Essays
Examples Of Poetry Analysis EssaysStephanie Hill
 
Collective ID quotes and key words
Collective ID quotes and key wordsCollective ID quotes and key words
Collective ID quotes and key wordsBelinda Raji
 
With regards to this article, I agree and disagree on certain leve.docx
With regards to this article, I agree and disagree on certain leve.docxWith regards to this article, I agree and disagree on certain leve.docx
With regards to this article, I agree and disagree on certain leve.docxalanfhall8953
 
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES - Bahia 2005
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES - Bahia 2005MULTIPLE IDENTITIES - Bahia 2005
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES - Bahia 2005Olu Alake
 
CHARLES W. CHESNUTT LIBRARY ELECTRONIC RESERVE COLLECTI.docx
CHARLES W. CHESNUTT LIBRARY  ELECTRONIC RESERVE COLLECTI.docxCHARLES W. CHESNUTT LIBRARY  ELECTRONIC RESERVE COLLECTI.docx
CHARLES W. CHESNUTT LIBRARY ELECTRONIC RESERVE COLLECTI.docxbissacr
 
Collective ID Thursday 28th April
Collective ID Thursday 28th AprilCollective ID Thursday 28th April
Collective ID Thursday 28th AprilBelinda Raji
 

Similar to AMST paper (12)

Anne percy social representation presentation
Anne percy social representation presentationAnne percy social representation presentation
Anne percy social representation presentation
 
Essay On Fences By August Wilson
Essay On Fences By August WilsonEssay On Fences By August Wilson
Essay On Fences By August Wilson
 
G325 - Collective identity:youth
G325 - Collective identity:youthG325 - Collective identity:youth
G325 - Collective identity:youth
 
Collective identity youth
Collective identity   youthCollective identity   youth
Collective identity youth
 
College Essay Writers
College Essay WritersCollege Essay Writers
College Essay Writers
 
2.3. Empowerment (Quiz)
2.3. Empowerment (Quiz)2.3. Empowerment (Quiz)
2.3. Empowerment (Quiz)
 
Examples Of Poetry Analysis Essays
Examples Of Poetry Analysis EssaysExamples Of Poetry Analysis Essays
Examples Of Poetry Analysis Essays
 
Collective ID quotes and key words
Collective ID quotes and key wordsCollective ID quotes and key words
Collective ID quotes and key words
 
With regards to this article, I agree and disagree on certain leve.docx
With regards to this article, I agree and disagree on certain leve.docxWith regards to this article, I agree and disagree on certain leve.docx
With regards to this article, I agree and disagree on certain leve.docx
 
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES - Bahia 2005
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES - Bahia 2005MULTIPLE IDENTITIES - Bahia 2005
MULTIPLE IDENTITIES - Bahia 2005
 
CHARLES W. CHESNUTT LIBRARY ELECTRONIC RESERVE COLLECTI.docx
CHARLES W. CHESNUTT LIBRARY  ELECTRONIC RESERVE COLLECTI.docxCHARLES W. CHESNUTT LIBRARY  ELECTRONIC RESERVE COLLECTI.docx
CHARLES W. CHESNUTT LIBRARY ELECTRONIC RESERVE COLLECTI.docx
 
Collective ID Thursday 28th April
Collective ID Thursday 28th AprilCollective ID Thursday 28th April
Collective ID Thursday 28th April
 

AMST paper

  • 1. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 1 Rebekah Espino-Drobner AMST 190 3/17/13 Identity Formation and the Cinema Throughout America’s history, there has come a tendency to create an “us vs. them” mentality toward each incoming new group of people. The need for compartmentalizing people based on their identity comes from the initial insecurities faced by Americans who do not have a core foundational identity. While the issue of the need for categorizing people based on their national identity reached a peak during the Ellis Island migrations, the momentum had started years before, and continued throughout history to modern society, evolving and changing as the social status of the immigrant changed as well. The focus of this paper is the role that nationality plays in the creation of identity, and how the cinema portrays the evolution of immigrant identity, specifically European immigrants, throughout the generations as seen in The Godfather and Gangs of New York. In order to understand the importance of identity within spectrum of immigrants, we first must look at the importance of identity formation in general, along with the purpose and necessity of identities within society. Throughout the years, identity has become the key factor in defining a person, which can be problematic when constantly shifting societies are what dictate the shifts in identity formation; there has been research that “links identity shifts to historical cultural configurations, arguing that certain character types are encouraged by cultures through differential socialization practices”1. 1 Howard,Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." Annual Reviewof Scoiology. Vol. 26. N.p.: Annual Reviews, 200. 367-93. JSTOR. Web. Pg. 373.
  • 2. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 2 As society evolves and expands, so does the spectrum of subcategories that make up the general components of the meaning of identity, and greatly affect identity formation. Recently, there have been theorists that have started to argue that with all of the shifting and changing in societies, especially cross-culturally, the concept of identity has been assigned with too many different meanings, and it has now “ceased to be meaningful”2. Although the concept of identity is socially constructed and the meaning has arguably been stretched thin over the years, there are still psychological reasoning as to why this construct has been a part of society for so many years, and why it is still extremely important when understanding society and individuals. Social psychologists have studied the human psyche, and have developed a theory related to social cognition, which is the way in which we store and process information3. With the amount of stimuli in our surrounding world, we as individuals feel as if we must categorize, organize, and compartmentalize all of these different components in order to make sense of them. Components of this method to understanding are the self and group schemas we create. Self-schemas allow us to understand ourselves and our place within society through the lens of how we are seen in society, based on general group schemas. Group schemas are essentially stereotypes that we use to understand and compartmentalize different large groups of people that are connected by an individual commonality, which we then assign onto all members of said group. With all of the information that we have to intake and organize, it is easier for us as humans to generalize people and ideas in this manner, rather than critically assess on an individual basis. 2 Sokefeld, Martin. "Reconsidering Identity." Anthropos (2001): 527-44. Jstor. Web 3 Howard,Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." pg. 368.
  • 3. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 3 The issues surrounding identity have become exceedingly problematic due to the fact that “when societies were more stable, identity was to a great extent assigned, rather than selected or adopted. In current times, however, the concept of identity carries the full weight of the need for a sense of who one is, together with an often overwhelming pace of change in the surrounding social contexts – changes in the groups and networks in which people and their identities are embedded”4. Previously in society, such as when “8.8 million [immigrants] admitted during the 1910’s [were] predominately from Europe”, identities were assigned to individuals by the populous of society5. At the time, immigration and the “threat” of national identity towards the Americans influenced the social norm of identifying people using their nationality as the foundation of their identity formation. This allowed for the Americans to create a hierarchy in their society based on these said identities, as well as implement a strict “us vs. them” mentality that unfortunately continues to exist. The affects of the power of society dictated identity can be seen clearly in Gangs of New York, which focuses on the divide in New York between Americans and the incoming swarm of Irish immigrants. Everyone, regardless of age, sex, or class, will ultimately be identified as either American or Irish, and more importantly, either American or not American. The process of identity formation changed over that long period of time, however nationality and ethnicity still are an extremely significant factor. Studies have shown that ethnic identities are made up of “a sense of belonging, attitudes toward one’s own ethnic group, social participation, and cultural practices”, which are determinant on the social climate, and fluctuate throughout 4 Howard,Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." pg. 367 5 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and Children of Immigrants." Annual Reviewof Sociology 23.1 (1997): 63-95. Print.
  • 4. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 4 the years6. Because identity isn’t assigned in the same manner as it used to be, people are able to identify themselves by ways other than their nationality. However, since nationality and ethnicity are still prominent factors, people often feel as if they must over identify with other aspects of their life and completely dismiss their nationality, as depicted thoroughly in The Godfather, through Michael’s continuous struggles between his American and Italian identity. The subject of identity is a central issue and theme within the films Gangs of New York and The Godfather. Gangs of New York, directed by Martin Scorsese, places Leonardo DiCaprio as a young Irish man in 1863, set on avenging his fathers murder committed by the American, Bill the Butcher. The opening scene depicts a bloody battle between the Irish and the Americans, who also called themselves the Nativists, in a war fueled by ethnic and religious identity conflicts. Put this film in contrast with Francis Ford Coppola’s classic, The Godfather, in which he vividly depicts the hybrid of old- country culture and assimilated American culture, and the struggles that accompany both. Vito Corleone, played by Marlon Brando, is an Italian immigrant who came to America, establishes a name for himself as a mob boss through the 1940s, and attempts to engage his son Michael, played by Al Pacino, with the rest of the family. Michael initially resists his Italian identity and family, by attempting to assimilate to the American culture, and establish himself with an American identity. It is of vital importance to look towards the cinema when addressing social and cultural issues, such as the one at hand. Historically, films have been used as a form of social commentary, documenting our society in ways 6 Howard, Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." pg. 374
  • 5. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 5 in which we can compartmentalize and understand complicated themes and situations7. The cinema takes these complicated issues and creates a face and a storyline that we can connect to, as well as identify with on a personal level. While these films address issues that seemingly happened years ago in America’s past, the popularity and infamy that they still hold to this day prove that the subject of identity is still one that is continuously struggled with, and is relevant in our modern society. These films have transcended the screen and have become a part of our American culture. They have been reappropriated many times throughout film, television, and other media outlets, which then continue to press the importance of the subject matter addressed in these story lines. While the characters and stories may be fictional, the troubles surrounding the themes of identity are very real, and therefore can be used when academically and critically discussing these conflicts. A component of the struggle with identity that can be seen both in the cinema, as well as in historical context, is the societal assignment of identity that was previously discussed. When individuals were identified by one particular aspect of themselves, especially one that did not hold much flexibility in the eyes of society, it became nearly impossible from them to transcend their dictated placement, and as a result, these individuals were forced to either adapt to life as a second class citizens, or be forced to attempt to assimilate as much as they possibly could. Because of the oppressive structure of identity formation, even assimilation could never make a person truly America in the eyes of many. Since the beginning of its creation, America has been a country that has been foundationally based on assimilation, primarily due to the fact that it never had a 7 Harker, Jonathan. ": Film: An Anthology . Daniel Talbot." Film Quarterly 13.3 (1960): n. pag. Print.
  • 6. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 6 distinct culture to call its own. The lack of a hegemonic American culture lead to the need of separation of Americans, or the Nativists, from ‘non-Americans’, especially when immigrants began arriving to America in waves. When Irish immigrants started rapidly appearing in America, the Americans felt the need to separate themselves from the immigrants and hold on to their American identity, creating an ‘us vs. them’ mentality through the land. While many immigrants were automatically categorized as second-class citizens, none felt this harsh reality more than the Irish. In the beginning, “’to be called an ‘Irishman’ had come to be nearly as great an insult as to be called a ‘nigger’.’”8 The Irish were looked down upon, and put on the same plateau as the black slaves in America, to such an extent that on the census, “it was by no means clear that the Irish were white” for the Irish were kept as a separate race altogether9. This can clearly be seen in one of the lesser prominent scenes in Gangs of New York, where a seemingly insignificant conversation between two of the main characters actually sums up the entire social commentary of the film itself. Jim Broadbent’s character, William “Boss” Tweed, converses with Daniel Day-Lewis’ character, known as Bill “The Butcher” Cutting, down by the docs, where The Butcher has gathered his Nativist men to berate and intimidate the new shipments of Irish that are streaming in to the city. The individuals getting of the ship seem broken and frightened, as the women shuffle along with the children and the men head directly to the politicians who are enlisting them to fight the war of a country in which they just arrived, in order to prove their loyalty. William, an avid politician 8 Roediger, David R. The Wages of Whiteness: Irish-American Workers and White Racial Formation in the AntebellumUnited States. NewYork. Print. 9 Roediger, David R. The Wages of Whiteness: Irish-American Workersand White Racial Formation in the AntebellumUnited States.
  • 7. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 7 himself, approaches Bill and tries to reason with him by telling him that the Irish are actually important to use in the future for voting numbers. Bill replies that voting is an American right, and then continues to state, “I don’t see no Americans, I see trespassers. Irish harps do a job for a nickel a nigger would do for a dime, what a man used to get a quarter for”10. Bill’s statement not only shows the animosity for immigrants like the Irish, but it also shows their standing in society in relation to the black slaves. He sees the immigrants not only as a threat to his fragile American identity, but on his economy as well, and classifies these people as second-class citizens along with the slaves, regardless of the fact that he is standing directly next to the Irish men that are signing up for the war to fight for his beloved country, merely because they were Irish. It was sentiments such as this that made it impossible for people to transcend their identities and become someone or something other than their nationality. However, change did come in time in the form of assimilation. Since the Irish were placed in the same social classification as Blacks were, they were also often in the same economical classification as well, and were going after the same jobs that Black people were, especially since their lack of skill, kept them “at the bottom of white society”11. Originally, the two communities were civil and sociable, however, when devastation and war struck America, the Irish immigrants were among the first to demand “an ‘all-white warfront’, rid of Blacks altogether” as a method of “ensuring their own survival”12. For the black slaves, “assimilation was believed to be largely unattainable 10 Gangs of New York. Dir. Martin Scorsese. Perf. Leonardo DiCaprio, Daniel Day- Lewis, Cameron Diaz. 20th Century FOx, 2002. DVD. Time:1:10 11 Roediger, David R. Working Towards Whiteness. Pg 145. 12 Roediger, David R. The Wages of Whiteness: Irish-American Workers and White Racial Formation in the AntebellumUnited States. NewYork. Print.
  • 8. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 8 and therefore not a source of concern” to the white Irish men who believed that this was their opportunity to become more white, which was, at the time, synonymous for being more American13. This was the catalyst for the Irish immigrants; they assimilated and created their own identity as not only Americans, but also White Americans. As it can be seen through these examples, there is a clear irony to the formation of American identity. With each incoming group of immigrants, an American identity can be established just by being more American than the group before. It is important, however, to note the fact that while this was a small, although unsettling, success for the Irish toward forming an American identity, “acculturation did not necessarily lead to other forms of integration into the host society […] ethnic groups would remain distinguished from on another depending largely on the degree to which groups gained the acceptance of the dominant population”14. This essentially means that while the Irish felt assimilated into their American identities socially, it did not necessarily guaranteed them the equality and rights of American citizens, and their acceptance was completely determined by the popular opinion of the current society, which fluctuated and evolved over the years. The irony in this is that technically, and theoretically, those that created this oppressive and subjective system, where once immigrants as well. The white settlers that deemed themselves Americans, the Nativists, originated from England when their ancestors came to America, yet they believed that they were able to dictate what is a socially acceptable American identity to the rest of society. It is type of thinking that 13 Higham, John. Approaches to American Immigration and Ethnic History: The Problem of Assimilation in the United States. (Cengage Learning, 1998) 14 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and Children of Immigrants." Pg. 71.
  • 9. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 9 causes a rotational continuation of flawed identity formation, and creates the many conflictions that people face when creating their own individual identities, as well as their group schemas surrounding other nationalities. Despite the historical truths that make up the irony of American identity, many Americans continued to ostracize and degrade those from other nations, and compartmentalized them into tiny inflexible identities solely based on their nationalities. While it seems unjust and repressive, there were some immigrants who remained tied to their nationalities, and because migrating uprooted them from their original homes and cultures, they were therefore forced to find new ways to hold onto their culture once entered in a new land. For the European immigrants, once in America each individual handled the transition differently; “only those who were capable of adjusting from peasant ways to the needs of new conditions and new challenges were able to absorb the successive shocks of migration”, and those who weren’t able to get a grasp on their new reality, suffered from “loneliness, separation from the community of the village, and despair at the insignificance of their own human abilities”15. For those who did want to assimilate, and instead chose to stand by their national identity with pride, adaptation became the only way to be able to cope with the uprooting for many migrants. An important factor of the adapting was creating a society that was familiar and made the new country feel more like home by maintaining their ties to their home countries. Many learned to achieve this in subtle ways, such as continuing to speak their native language 15 Handlin, Oscar. Major Problems in American Immigration and Ethnic History:Approaches to American Immigration and Ethnic History. Ed. Jon Gjerde. Boston: Houghton Mifflin, 1998. Print.
  • 10. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 10 and combining their language with English, importing books from their homeland, and continuing their own traditions 16. This pride and adaption are two themes that are seen strongly in both of the films this paper is discussing. In Gangs of New York, Five Points, the name of the sector the main characters live, was a niche for the Irish immigrants, and each different area of New York was segregated based on the identity of the people that live there. Like many other immigrants that have come to America over the years, they divided the cities into varying burros in order to surround themselves with people they identified with. This was also seen in The Godfather. Through the lens of an organized crime family, the movie depicts the more embedded issues of assimilation, in relationship to the strong need for traditional values and customs. Throughout the movie, the importance of loyalty, family, and traditional Italian manners are displayed as a centerpiece for he rest of the story. It clearly shows the importance of remaining connected to heritage and culture, no matter how far from home they are, and the pride they continue to feel when identifying by their nationality. While some immigrants held fast to their assigned identities, many struggled with the concept, and instead decided that they would rather assimilate and identify as an American. As demonstrated previously, America is a nation that was founded on the ideals of assimilation, due to the fact that there originally was no distinct American culture. The process of conformity and assimilation is one that began with the very first immigrants, and still continues to this day. However, the motivations behind assimilation have evolved from an idea forced upon by an external oppressor, to a voluntary concept 16 Franklin, Benjamin. Language Loyalties: A Source Book on the Official English Controversy:The German Language in Pennsylvania. Ed. James Crawford. Chicago:University of Chicago, 1992. Print.
  • 11. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 11 that has been internalized over the course of many generations. As stated by assimilation theorists: Distinctive ethnic traits such as old cultural ways, native languages, or ethnic enclaves are sources of disadvantages that negatively affect assimilation […] although complete acculturation to the dominant American culture may not ensure all immigrants full social participation in the host society, immigrants must free themselves from their old cultures in order to begin rising up from marginal positions […] [It was] anticipated, nevertheless, that ethnic minorities would eventually lose all their distinctive characteristics and cease to exist as ethnic groups as they pass through the stages of assimilation.17 While it is clear that the latter argument of total ethnic annihilation did not happen, nor will happen any time in the immediate future, the attitude behind the negative affects toward assimilation generated the foundation of the mentality on creating an American identity. To many of these immigrants, being able to achieve an American identity meant that they had to completely dismiss their original national identity, and rather than going to one extreme end of the spectrum with submerging themselves in their own culture to adapt, they went in the other direction and denounced all parts of their original heritage. This type of assimilation was most often seen by second generation of immigrants, or the children of immigrants. In The Godfather, arguably the most interesting and complex storyline in the movie is that of Vito’s son, Michael Corleone, who distances himself from his family at a younger age. Wanting to put as much space between himself and his family’s lifestyle, Michael does everything in his power to 17 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and Children of Immigrants." Pg. 71.
  • 12. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 12 assimilate, and identify as an American, rather than an Italian. He joins the army, became an American soldier, and chooses to be involved with an American woman, rather than an Italian woman, or even Italian American woman. We are first introduced to Michael at the beginning of the film during a wedding celebration for his sister at his father’s estate. It is made clear that Vito values Michael because he refuses to take the family picture before he arrives, which enforces his heavy familial values. However when Michael shows up, he is late, dressed in uniform, and with his white American girlfriend. While he loves his family, he clearly stands out from the boisterous group of Italian men and women that fill the celebration. In a particular scene, Michael and Kay Adams, his girlfriend, are listening to Johnny Fontane, a famous singer who is performing at the wedding. Kay asks Michael how the family knows Johnny, and this conversation follows: Michael: Well, when Johnny was first starting out, he was signed to a personal services contract with this big-band leader. And as his career got better and better, he wanted to get out of it. But the bandleader wouldn’t let him. Now, Johnny is my father’s godson. SO my father went to see this bandleader and offered him $10,000 to let Johnny go, but the bandleader said no. SO the next day, my father went back, only this time with Luca Brasi. Within an hour, he had a signed release for a certified check of $1,000. Kay Adams: How did he do that? Michael: My father made him an offer he couldn’t refuse […] Luca Brasi held a gun to his head, and my father assured him that either his brains or his signature would be on the contract. (Kay is silent and stares at Michael)
  • 13. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 13 Michael: That’s a true story […] That’s my family Kay, that’s not me.18 It is clear that Michaels struggle is not just one of heritage, but of morality as well, however these two issues are largely intertwined throughout the film. As discussed earlier, society often dictates the way in which different identities, specifically ethnic ones, are perceived by the general populous by the usage of group schemas. A common stereotype that derived from this time period during the 1940’s was the correlation of Italian immigrants and illegal activities. As demonstrated by the previous quote, Michael’s attempt to assimilate into an American identity is done so by separating himself not only culturally, but from the other components that make up his family as well. Because mobster and Italian identity were synonyms at the time, he denounces the acts of his family and instead takes on a law-abiding job and other American attributes in order to solidify his identity as American. This way of thinking does change throughout the movie, however it is interesting to view the initial foundation of what Michael believed an American identity was conceived of. These films focus on issues in society that are not just historic, but relevant in our current society as well. The affects of societies impact on identity formation within the immigrant community can still be seen to this day in the urban infrastructure and communities around America. Much like the New York that Five Points inhabited in Gangs of New York, urban centers such as New York and San Francisco that were major 18 The Godfather. Dir. Francis Ford Coppola. Prod. Francis Ford Coppola. By Francis Ford Coppola and Mario Puzo. Perf. Al Pacino, Robert Duvall, Diane Keaton, and Niro Robert De. Paramount Pictures, 1974. DVD.
  • 14. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 14 ports of immigration continue to show the affects of the divided cities of the past19. The separation mentality and compartmentalization of different national identities in society, and the massive movements of adaptation, lead to segregation of many urban areas, which still exist today. The creation of places such as China Town, Japan Town, and Little Italy not only creates an ethnic and national divide within the urban ecosystem, but it also continues to perpetuate the “othering” of people based on their identities. While it is essential that people are able to live in communities with those whom have similar traditions and values, it also keeps the urban areas of immigration, along with the mentality of many Americans, stagnant and un-evolved, which in turn continues the cycle of an ironic and subjective formation of American identities. Even more important to the issue of modern day impact of historical identity formation struggles, is the impact on the next generation: the children of the immigrants. Children of immigrants have often times been overlooked during the study of identity formation, however it has been found that these individuals often suffer from more societal conflict in this area than their parents. Even in the 1940’s, children like Michael felt torn between their family and cultural origins, with the want to assimilate and identify as America, and that struggle continues to this day. The focus on children and assimilation comes from the fact that “differing from their immigrant parents, immigrant children and children of immigrants lack meaningful connections to their ‘old’ world. They are thus unlikely to consider a foreign country as a place to return to or as a point of reference. They instead are prone to evaluate themselves 19 Jimenez, Tomas R. Assessing Immigrant Assimilation:New Empirical and Theoretical Challenges. Annual Review of Scoiology.By Mary C. Waters. Vol. 31. N.p.: AnnualReviews, 2005. 105-25. JSTOR. Web.
  • 15. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 15 or to be evaluated by others by the standards of their new country”20. Like Michael, children of immigrants often don’t have the same connection to the homeland that their parents do. For example, “in the United States, immigrant children often become Americanized so quickly that their parents cannot keep up with them. There is a fear in the older generation that their children will leave them, become like other American youth, and forget about their roots”21. These children assimilate quickly because they often do not have a strong connection with the homeland like their elder families do, however their families often times don’t understand this fact, and this gap of understanding creates even more identity conflict and familial pressure, often times driving the kids away, such as Michael was in the start of The Godfather. In addition to the familial pressure that this second generation feels, society as a whole has a great influence in the conflict faced by these individuals. As it has been seen time and time again through this analysis of identity formation, it is clear that society plays a large role in dictating our identities, especially ones based on nationality and ethnicity. As was seen with the Irish immigrants, attempts to assimilate often failed, and it was ultimately the American society that determined whether or not the Irish had successfully been deemed American, and this trend continues to this day. Due to this, this second generation is caught in a binding conflict of identity; they are identified by their origin nationality by the dominant populous of society, however they themselves don’t have any connection with their home countries. This conflict leads to a lot of confusion and questioning within this group of people, as to who they really are. This 20 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and Children of Immigrants." Pg. 64. 21 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and Children of Immigrants." Pg. 83.
  • 16. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 16 question creates conflict within the individuals, and as a result, leads to “a growing ‘oppositional culture’ among young Americans, especially among those who have felt oppressed and excluded from the American mainstream […] immigrant children have confronted a reality in their host society where their ascribed physical features may become a handicap”22. These second generation individuals are feeling the affects of society dictated identity formation first hand, and it is apparent that while our culture has evolved in a lot of ways, it has stayed the same in many ways as well. In this instance, the only thing that has evolved is the way that the individuals react toward the society; instead of adapting and accepting their assigned identities, the lack of connection to their homeland makes them confused and aggressive against the dominant views of society. It is evident that the issues surrounding identity formation are far from historic; they are happening here and now within our society, with new incoming immigrants from many different countries more and more each year. These people continue to fight the dominant society creating inflexible identities for them, just as they used to when it was only the Irish coming in mass numbers. As it can be seen throughout this analysis, the importance and relevance of the two movies chosen as references to this social issue is also still apparent in modern society. These movies have transcended the cinema as a part of our popular culture, and continue to express stories and underlying themes that people still identify with to this day. They depict the very real shift of immigrant identity from adaption to assimilation, and can be used as tools in not only understanding our history as an immigrant nation, full of insecurity in our own identities, but also understanding our current society, and how we got to where we are today. The only way 22 Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and Children of Immigrants." Pg. 69&76.
  • 17. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 17 that we will be able to change the oppression and conflict that often accompanies immigrant identity formation is to understand our past, and learn how to change it and break the seemingly never ending cycle.
  • 18. Rebekah Espino-Drobner 18 Bibliography Franklin, Benjamin. Language Loyalties: A Source Book on the Official English Controversy:The German Language in Pennsylvania. Ed. James Crawford. Chicago: University of Chicago, 1992. Print. Gangs of New York. Dir. Martin Scorsese. Perf. Leonardo DiCaprio, Daniel Day- Lewis, Cameron Diaz. 20th Century Fox, 2002. DVD. Time:1:10 The Godfather. Dir. Francis Ford Coppola. Prod. Francis Ford Coppola. By Francis Ford Coppola and Mario Puzo. Perf. Al Pacino, Robert Duvall, Diane Keaton, and Niro Robert De. Paramount Pictures, 1974. DVD. Harker, Jonathan. ": Film: An Anthology . Daniel Talbot." Film Quarterly 13.3 (1960): n. pag. Print. Higham, John. Approaches to American Immigration and Ethnic History: The Problem of Assimilation in the United States. (Cengage Learning, 1998) Howard, Judith A. "Social Psychology of Identities." Annual Review of Scoiology. Vol. 26. N.p.: Annual Reviews, 200. 367-93. JSTOR. Web. Pg. 373. Jimenez, Tomas R. Assessing Immigrant Assimilation: New Empirical and Theoretical Challenges. Annual Review of Scoiology. By Mary C. Waters. Vol. 31. N.p.: Annual Reviews, 2005. 105-25. JSTOR. Web. Roediger, David R. The Wages of Whiteness: Irish-American Workers and White Racial Formation in the Antebellum United States. New York. Print. Roediger, David R. Working Towards Whiteness. New York: Basic, 2005. Print. Pg 145. Sokefeld, Martin. "Reconsidering Identity." Anthropos (2001): 527-44. Jstor. Web Zhou, Min. "Growing Up American: The Challenge Confronting Immigrant Children and Children of Immigrants." Annual Review of Sociology 23.1 (1997): 63-95. Print.